From 4a372a8fae053b42f8a8da0631288a6e1c9f5b90 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 10:21:05 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 001/110] docs(product-gap): refresh protected-main baseline Refresh the buyer-facing inventory against the current protected main and live GitHub queue. Remove the unsupported valuation appendix and keep shipped, active, and blocked evidence distinct. Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 402 +++---------------------- 1 file changed, 36 insertions(+), 366 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index e025d854e..dcc4c0e03 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-25T05:20:00Z**
-Protected-main basis: **`9c12eab15fb8a187b135f9be1961f0693a431c23`**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T01:14:34Z**
+Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** ## 1. Purpose and authority @@ -66,7 +66,7 @@ transportability, fairness, and decision utility are separate claims. The observed protected main declares: -- package version **`0.9.0`**; +- package version **`0.9.1`**; - Python **`>=3.12`**; - Maturin/PyO3 bindings to the Rust workspace; - PyPI classifier **`Development Status :: 3 - Alpha`**; and @@ -244,43 +244,49 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-25T05:20:00Z against protected -`main@9c12eab15fb8a187b135f9be1961f0693a431c23`. Every row is +2026-08-28T01:14:34Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1363](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1363) | `d232423d…` | seals nested subscore response/group evidence traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1362](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1362)) | draft at observation; checks queued; re-fetch draft/ready, checks and reviews before acting | -| [#1345](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1345) | `2bc7ba2a…` | bounds CAT administration evidence before deduplication/dense marshalling (issues [#1344](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1344)/[#1347](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1347)/[#1354](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1354)) | merge-forward onto `main@9c12eab1` pushed (`2bc7ba2a`) after resolving the package-surface conflict; fresh current-head CI required | -| [#1279](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1279) | `7ddfa2c1…` | exposes Rust polytomous predictions with admission safety (issues [#1280](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1280), [#1281](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1291)) | merge-forward onto `main@9c12eab1` pushed (`7ddfa2c1`); predecessor-head reviews are historical after the head change | -| [#1029](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1029) | `2f4a4e03…` | rejects lossy extended-precision S-X² scalar controls before Rust dispatch (issue [#1028](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1028)) | open, non-draft; first strix attempt failed on provider availability and was rerun; current-head checks/reviews still required | -| [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | `9bde9837…` | Rust continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch estimator replayed on the current review workflow (issue [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565)) | up to date with main; preserve exact recovery evidence through integration; predecessor-head REQUEST_CHANGES was bound to a stale head SHA | -| [#998](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/998) | `3177525d…` | release/changelog resync plus logistic-DIF control hardening (issue [#958](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/958)) | mergeable; first strix attempt failed on provider availability and was rerun; formal approval still required | - -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **6 open pull requests**: `#1363, -#1345, #1279, #1029, #1005, #998`. Open issues numbered 42, led by the -admission-boundary family (`#1365`, `#1364`, `#1362`, `#1354`, `#1347`, -`#1344`), the polytomous-prediction family (`#1307`, `#1308`, `#1291`, -`#1292`, `#1280`, `#1281`, `#1296`, `#1297`, `#1300`, `#1303`, `#1301`), -the governance/provenance family (`#1146`, `#1144`, `#1111`, `#1150`, -`#1131`), and the validation/conformance family (`#1096`, `#1094`, `#1092`, -`#1078`, `#1152`). The long-lived structural gaps remain `#621` (bounded 1.0 -capability/support matrix), `#626` (Rust-owned ordinary production boundary), -and `#565` (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). +| [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `1342862e…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | draft; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; review and protected merge are absent | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, and security checks passed, but required Strix failed during non-code report mapping; independent approval still required | +| [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1501](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1501) | `34338763…` | bounds EBDIF item evidence before allocation (issue [#1500](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1500)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1494](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1494) | `fb3f7e24…` | seals LLTM scientific evidence admission before NumPy protocols (issues [#1493](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1493)–[#1499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1499)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1492](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1492) | `9feae4de…` | preserves integer safety across essay contracts reload (issue [#1491](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1491)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1481](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1481) | `7946f4b8…` | bounds parallel-analysis observed data before dense marshalling (issues [#1480](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1480)–[#1489](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1489)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1479](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1479) | `057a4082…` | replays factor-retention result invariants (issue [#1478](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1478)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1471](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1471) | `8ce2ae2e…` | cuts the 0.9.2 release | ready; current checks passed, but the release parent remains review-blocked; stack children must be synchronized after any parent change | +| [#1476](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1476) | `f3c66f0e…` | replays item-bank evidence-reference identity (issue [#1475](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1475)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | +| [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | +| [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; current checks passed, but review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | +| [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | +| [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | + +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **16 open pull requests** and GitHub +search enumerated **48 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is +dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack +is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The +long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and +#565 (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). The Rust-owned +ordinary-production boundary has materially advanced through the integrated +backend/runtime work; issue #626 is closed, but the remaining public capability +and release evidence still prevents a universal technical-GA claim. This list is a reproducible snapshot, not a merge instruction. A completion or merge decision must begin with a fresh repository-wide PR and writer sweep, including exact head/base, dependency stack, reviews, unresolved threads, required Checks, and active path ownership. -Since the previous observation (2026-08-21), the open-PR queue collapsed from -74 to 6 through normal review/merge activity. Notably integrated since then: -[#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951) (automatic -Rust backend + configuration hardening), [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014) -(crossed multiple-membership estimator), [#1130](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1130) -(Figma design-boundary ADR), the v0.9.0 release cut, and the polytomous -GRM/GPCM/CAT/FIPC parameter-recovery suite (#1313). +The previous six-row snapshot is obsolete: those listed PRs are no longer open, +and the current queue above was re-fetched from the live repository. Their +integrated capability evidence remains part of protected main where the merge +was completed; the active rows above remain candidates until their exact heads +pass current reviews and protected merge gates. ### 7.1 Superseded lineage record @@ -312,7 +318,7 @@ enforces exact-type admission and replays `__post_init__` invariants | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | GAP-01 | P0 | Freeze a bounded 1.0 capability, support and maturity matrix; do not equate planned research with GA | [#621](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/621), [#636](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/636), [#648](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/648) | every public capability is classified, supported versions match metadata, and the release gate makes no valuation/certification claim | | GAP-02 | P0 | One ordinary Rust/PyO3 numerical owner; NumPy only on explicit reference/parity surfaces | [#626](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/626), [#627](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/627); the automatic-backend and reference-isolation slices landed on protected main via merged [#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951)/[#1070](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1070) | production config/API cannot silently select Python numerics; missing/incompatible Rust fails before result-affecting work | -| GAP-03 | P0 | Complete non-atomistic multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership and longitudinal estimation with identification and recovery | [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565); crossed multiple-membership estimator landed via merged [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014) plus the crossed multiple-membership replay (#0827dfa lineage); continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch remains on active PR [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | realistic aligned bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence and temporal leakage tests pass; both stacked scientific deltas survive | +| GAP-03 | P0 | Complete non-atomistic multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership and longitudinal estimation with identification and recovery | [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565); crossed multiple-membership estimator landed via merged [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014), and continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch landed via merged [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | realistic aligned bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence and temporal leakage tests pass; the remaining profile must preserve its declared estimand and recovery evidence | | GAP-04 | P0 | Relation-safe factor retention, structural model selection and identified exploratory multidimensional estimation | [#608](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/608), [#633](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/633), [#551](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/551), PR [#1008](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1008) | no winner is forced without relation-appropriate tests, held-out evidence, scoreability and true-structure recovery | | GAP-05 | P1 | Close rubric, generated-item, scoring, RAG, essay, enterprise-issue and item-bank lifecycles without parallel contracts | [#397](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/397), [#404](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/404), [#607](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/607), [#609](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/609), PR [#1003](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1003) | one immutable assessment/rubric/scoring lineage reaches pilot, calibration, validation, lifecycle and report evidence without provider coupling or silent state promotion | | GAP-06 | P0 | Independently test equations and fitted estimands against explicitly matched mature engines | [#1077](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1077) closed as COMPLETED after the reusable conformance provenance manifest landed ([#1082](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1082)); residual validation-family execution evidence tracks under [#1092](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1092)/[#1094](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1094)/[#1096](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1096)/[#1152](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1152) | versioned capability×engine matrix, fixed-parameter equation conformance first, aligned fitted-result comparisons, visible disagreement register | @@ -698,339 +704,3 @@ The document is complete when reviewers can determine: - which evidence blocks domain/high-stakes claims; - what repository owns each remaining concern; and - the next root-cause-changing action without relying on chat history. - ---- - -## 17. Executive Summary & $20B Commercial Valuation Vision - -`fast-mlsirm` is the foundational, domain-neutral psychometric measurement and statistical computation engine of the **ContextualWisdomLab** ecosystem. It provides mathematically rigorous, content-addressed, Rust-backed measurement models, item response theory (IRT), multidimensional latent space item response modeling (MLSIRM / MLS2PLM), many-facet rater calibration, generalizability theory (G-theory), automated scoring verification, and longitudinal state tracking. - -### 1.1 Commercial Valuation Position ($20B Enterprise Standard) -To satisfy the standard of a multi-billion dollar enterprise-grade foundational software layer, `fast-mlsirm` adheres to zero-compromise architectural invariants: -1. **Mathematical Truth over Heuristics**: No arbitrary weights, heuristics, or ungrounded rules of thumb. Every parameter is estimated via formal psychometric and statistical methods with published asymptotic properties and standard error estimates. -2. **Rust-First Computational Sovereignty**: Production likelihoods, gradients, Hessians, Oakes information matrices, EM/ECM optimizers, MHRM routines, and WLE estimators execute in compiled Rust with SIMD and low-context-switching multithreading (and GPU device kernels where applicable). Python acts strictly as a type-safe orchestrator, boundary validator, and reporting layer. -3. **Atomistic Fallacy Prevention**: Modeling human, rater, or AI behavior requires explicit support for multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership, testlet, and longitudinal/temporal structures. -4. **Legally Sound Enterprise Privacy & Security**: Full alignment with CSAP and SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria. PII masking that damages psychometric tracking is replaced with non-destructive, purpose-limited pseudonymization, field-level tokenization, and deterministic cryptographic lineage. -5. **Ecosystem Modularity (MSA)**: Completely decoupled from hosted application concerns (persistence, web UI, auth). Seamlessly consumed by `ContextualWisdomLab/psychometrics-commons`, `TEPP`, `contextual-orchestrator`, `RankWeave`, `LineageWeave`, `keyverse`, `ThreadWeave`, `disksage`, and `wardnet`. - ---- - -## 18. Authoritative Research & Standards Literature (APA 7th) - -### 18.1 Multidimensional Latent Space & Item Response Models -- **Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021).** Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika*, 86(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 -- **Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025).** Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika*, 90(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 -- **Molenaar, D., & Jeon, M. (2026).** Regularized joint maximum likelihood estimation of latent space item response models. *Psychometrika*, 91, 335–359. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.10068 -- **Roberts, J. S., Donoghue, J. R., & Laughlin, J. E. (1998).** The Generalized Graded Unfolding Model: A general parametric item response model for unfolding graded responses. *ETS Research Report Series*, 1998(1). https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2333-8504.1998.tb01781.x -- **Tay, L., Ali, U. S., Drasgow, F., & Williams, B. (2011).** Fitting IRT models to dichotomous and polytomous data: Assessing the relative model-data fit of ideal point and dominance models. *Applied Psychological Measurement*, 35(4), 280–295. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146621610390674 -- **Chalmers, R. P. (2012).** mirt: A multidimensional item response theory package for the R environment. *Journal of Statistical Software*, 48(6), 1–29. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v048.i06 - -### 18.2 Model Fit, Diagnostic Statistics & Asymptotic Uncertainty -- **Orlando, M., & Thissen, D. (2000).** Likelihood-based item-fit indices for dichotomous item response theory models. *Applied Psychological Measurement*, 24(1), 50–64. https://doi.org/10.1177/01466210022031558 -- **Maydeu-Olivares, A., & Joe, H. (2005).** Limited- and full-information estimation and goodness-of-fit testing in $2^n$ contingency tables. *Journal of the American Statistical Association*, 100(471), 1009–1020. https://doi.org/10.1198/016214504000002069 -- **Oakes, D. (1999).** Direct calculation of the information matrix via the EM algorithm. *Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Statistical Methodology)*, 61(2), 479–482. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9868.00188 -- **Benjamini, Y., & Hochberg, Y. (1995).** Controlling the false discovery rate: A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. *Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Methodological)*, 57(1), 289–300. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2517-6161.1995.tb02031.x -- **Warm, T. A. (1989).** Weighted likelihood estimation of ability in item response theory. *Psychometrika*, 54(3), 427–450. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02294627 - -### 18.3 Multilevel, Longitudinal & Multiple-Membership Modeling -- **Fox, J.-P., & Glas, C. A. W. (2001).** Bayesian estimation of a multilevel IRT model. *Psychometrika*, 66(2), 271–288. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02294839 -- **Bock, R. D., & Zimowski, M. F. (1997).** Multiple group IRT. In W. J. van der Linden & R. K. Hambleton (Eds.), *Handbook of Modern Item Response Theory* (pp. 433–448). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-2691-6_25 -- **Browne, W. J., Goldstein, H., & Rasbash, J. (2001).** Multiple membership and cross-classified models for education and social research. *Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics*, 26(2), 87–114. https://doi.org/10.3102/10769986026002087 - -### 18.4 Measurement Standards, Generalizability Theory & LLM-as-a-Judge -- **American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014).** *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. -- **Brennan, R. L. (2001).** *Generalizability theory*. Springer Science & Business Media. -- **Lin, C., Chen, S., & Thorne, J. (2024).** TRINITY: Test-time compute routing and multi-agent synergy for complex reasoning. *arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.xxxxx*. -- **Zhou, D., et al. (2024).** Fugu & Conductor: Dynamic compute allocation and reasoning depth orchestration. *Contextual Intelligence Review*, 12, 101–124. - ---- - -## 19. Product & Technical Requirements Specification (PRD & TRD) - -### 19.1 Functional Requirements Matrix -| ID | Requirement Area | Specification Description | Primary Beneficiary | -|---|---|---|---| -| **PRD-FR-001** | Measurement Contracts | Canonical versioned `AssessmentSpec` and `RubricSpecification` with immutable SHA-256 fingerprinting. | Assessment Engineers | -| **PRD-FR-002** | IRT & MLSIRM Models | High-throughput estimation for 1PL, 2PL, 3PL, GRM, GPCM, RSM, MLSRM, MLS2PLM, ULSRM, and ULS2PLM. | Psychometricians | -| **PRD-FR-003** | Rust Computation | All M-step, E-step, Oakes SE, MHRM, WLE, and gradient arithmetic owned by `crates/mlsirm-core`. | Core Performance | -| **PRD-FR-004** | Fit & Diagnostics | S-$X^2$, $M_2$, $M_2^*$, Orlando-Thissen, and Benjamini-Hochberg FDR-adjusted significance matrices. | Research Validation | -| **PRD-FR-005** | Judge & Rater Facets | Many-Facet Rasch/IRT rater severity calibration, judge drift detection, and rubric category mapping. | AI Evaluation Teams | -| **PRD-FR-006** | Finite-Population Sampling | Stratified probabilistic sampling designs, bounded allocation, and exact inclusion-ratio tracking. | Survey & Assessment | -| **PRD-FR-007** | Multilevel & Temporal | Cross-classified multiple-membership structures and continuous/discrete longitudinal state engines. | Behavioral Research | -| **PRD-FR-008** | Item Banking & Lifecycle | Governed item transition states (Draft $\to$ Provisional $\to$ Calibrated $\to$ Anchored $\to$ Retired). | Enterprise Operations | -| **PRD-FR-009** | Diagnostic Reporting | Standalone, accessible (WCAG 2.1 AA) HTML audit reports with CSP nonces and tabular numerals. | Enterprise Reviewers | - -### 19.2 Technical Requirements Matrix -| ID | Architecture Area | Implementation Contract | Invariant & Boundary | -|---|---|---|---| -| **TRD-TECH-001** | Memory & Bounds | 20M logical cells, 40M structural nodes ceiling on all ingress arrays before NumPy/Rust allocation. | DoS / OOM Immunity | -| **TRD-TECH-002** | Type & Scalar Admission | Exact numeric NumPy / Python scalar universe; callback-bearing subclasses rejected fail-closed. | Safety / Predictability | -| **TRD-TECH-003** | Database Persistence | Third Normal Form (3NF), snake_case naming ($\ge 2$ words), UPSERT idempotent contracts. | DB Integrity / Hot-Partition | -| **TRD-TECH-004** | SIMD / Multithreading | Rayon-backed CPU coarse parallelism, GPU device kernel parity with strict f64 reference bounds. | Low Context Switching | -| **TRD-TECH-005** | Enterprise Compliance | CSAP / SOC 2 Type II controls; PII tokenization preserving longitudinal linkage without data loss. | Enterprise Audit | -| **TRD-TECH-006** | Test & Doc Coverage | 100% test coverage, 100% docstring coverage, true-parameter RMSE recovery tests against ground truth. | Release Quality Gate | - ---- - -## 20. Architecture Blueprints & UML System Design - -### 20.1 Ecosystem Topology & Microservices System Context - -```mermaid -graph TB - subgraph Client_Applications ["Enterprise & Research Consumers"] - PC["psychometrics-commons
(Hosted Product, Admin APIs, Auth)"] - CO["contextual-orchestrator
(LLM-as-Judge Orchestration)"] - KV["keyverse
(Central IdP, SSO/OIDC/SCIM)"] - end - - subgraph Computational_Layer ["Measurement & Algorithmic Core"] - FAST["fast-mlsirm
(Domain-Neutral Core, IRT, MLS2PLM, Fit Stats)"] - TEPP["TEPP
(Temporal Event Psychometrics Platform)"] - RW["RankWeave
(Retrieval Fusion & Ranking)"] - LW["LineageWeave
(Lineage DAG Reconstruction)"] - TW["ThreadWeave
(JWZ Email Threading)"] - end - - subgraph Security_and_Storage ["Infrastructure & Governance"] - WN["wardnet
(Rust Gateway & SOC Control Plane)"] - DS["disksage
(On-Device File & Disk Governance)"] - NARUON["naruon & .github
(Org-wide Governance & CI Gates)"] - end - - PC -->|AssessmentSpec / Observations| FAST - CO -->|Judge Ratings / Rubric Observations| FAST - FAST -->|Temporal Dynamics| TEPP - FAST -->|Lineage Channels| LW - FAST -->|Rankings / Bradley-Terry| RW - FAST -->|Audited Provenance| WN - PC -->|Auth Tokens| KV - NARUON -->|CI Gates & Policies| FAST -``` - -### 20.2 Core Domain Class Model - -```mermaid -classDiagram - class AssessmentSpec { - +String spec_id - +String version - +List~DimensionSpec~ dimensions - +List~ItemSpec~ items - +fingerprint() String - } - - class RubricSpecification { - +String rubric_id - +String revision - +List~CriterionSpec~ criteria - +List~CategoryLevel~ levels - +fingerprint() String - } - - class ObservationMatrix { - +Array2D responses - +Array2D mask - +Int person_count - +Int item_count - +validate_bounds() Bool - } - - class ItemBankRecord { - +String item_id - +ParameterProvenance provenance - +ItemLifecycleStatus status - +Map~String, Float~ calibrated_parameters - +replay_identity() ItemBankRecord - } - - class MlsirmEngine { - <> - +fit_mls2plm() FitResult - +compute_oakes_se() CovarianceMatrix - +evaluate_sx2_fit() FitStatistics - +extract_interaction_map() InteractionMapEnvelope - } - - class InteractionMapEnvelope { - +Array2D item_coordinates - +Array2D person_coordinates - +Float explained_variance_share - +Array1D singular_values - +validate_finiteness() Bool - } - - AssessmentSpec "1" *-- "many" ItemBankRecord - RubricSpecification "1" *-- "many" AssessmentSpec - ObservationMatrix --> MlsirmEngine : Marshall to Rust - MlsirmEngine --> InteractionMapEnvelope : Produces - ItemBankRecord --> ObservationMatrix : Governs Items -``` - -### 20.3 Computational Pipeline Sequence - -```mermaid -sequenceDiagram - autonumber - actor Client as Consumer / Orchestrator - participant PyAPI as Python Validation Layer - participant Safety as Admission & Bounds Guard - participant RustCore as Rust Numerical Core (mlsirm-core) - participant Diag as Diagnostic & Fit Engine - participant Report as Accessible Report Builder - - Client->>PyAPI: fit(assessment_spec, response_data, options) - PyAPI->>Safety: preflight_check(response_data, bounds) - Note over Safety: Verify logical cells <= 20M
Verify structural nodes <= 40M
Reject callback subclasses - Safety-->>PyAPI: Validated Inert Buffers - PyAPI->>RustCore: fast_mlsirm_py.fit_mlsirm(buffers, config) - activate RustCore - Note over RustCore: SIMD / Multithreaded EM / ECM
Oakes Information & Hessian
Residual Interaction SVD - RustCore-->>PyAPI: RustResultEnvelope (f64 arrays, metrics) - deactivate RustCore - PyAPI->>Diag: compute_fit_statistics(RustResultEnvelope) - Diag-->>PyAPI: S-X2, M2*, BH FDR Adjustments - PyAPI->>Report: generate_standalone_html(results) - Report-->>Client: Complete Calibrated Results & Audit Report -``` - -### 20.4 3NF Database Entity-Relationship Architecture - -```mermaid -erDiagram - ASSESSMENT_SPECIFICATIONS ||--o{ ITEM_BANK_RECORDS : defines - RUBRIC_SPECIFICATIONS ||--o{ RUBRIC_CRITERIA : contains - ASSESSMENT_SPECIFICATIONS ||--o{ OBSERVATION_BATCHES : gathers - OBSERVATION_BATCHES ||--o{ RESPONSE_OBSERVATIONS : contains - ITEM_BANK_RECORDS ||--o{ RESPONSE_OBSERVATIONS : evaluates - OBSERVATION_BATCHES ||--o{ CALIBRATION_RUNS : inputs - CALIBRATION_RUNS ||--o{ ESTIMATED_ITEM_PARAMETERS : outputs - CALIBRATION_RUNS ||--o{ RESIDUAL_INTERACTION_MAPS : generates - - ASSESSMENT_SPECIFICATIONS { - string spec_id PK - string spec_version - string construct_name - string content_digest - timestamp created_at - } - - ITEM_BANK_RECORDS { - string item_id PK - string spec_id FK - string parameter_provenance - string lifecycle_status - string item_blueprint_hash - timestamp updated_at - } - - OBSERVATION_BATCHES { - string batch_id PK - string spec_id FK - string pseudonymized_cohort_id - integer observation_count - timestamp collected_at - } - - RESPONSE_OBSERVATIONS { - string observation_id PK - string batch_id FK - string item_id FK - string subject_token - float response_value - boolean is_missing - } - - CALIBRATION_RUNS { - string run_id PK - string batch_id FK - string model_family - float log_likelihood - boolean convergence_flag - timestamp completed_at - } - - ESTIMATED_ITEM_PARAMETERS { - string parameter_id PK - string run_id FK - string item_id FK - string parameter_name - float estimated_value - float standard_error - } - - RESIDUAL_INTERACTION_MAPS { - string map_id PK - string run_id FK - integer latent_dimension - float explained_variance_ratio - string coordinate_payload_digest - } -``` - ---- - -## 21. Comprehensive Gap Analysis & Commercial Readiness Audit - -### 21.1 Technical & Computational Gaps -1. **Confirmatory Factor Loading Pattern Evidence (Issue #1466 / PR #1467)**: Loading pattern matrices sealed and validated before dense NumPy coercion. (*Resolved and Merged*). -2. **Residual Interaction Map Envelope Serialization (Issue #1412 / PR #1417, #1457)**: Full explained variance share, singular values, and item/person coordinates with finiteness guarantees exported from Rust. -3. **Domain-Neutral Lineage Channel Weights (Issue #1455 / PR #1456)**: Weight allocation across lineage threads remains strictly domain-neutral and bounded. (*Resolved and Merged*). -4. **Structural Container Traversal Bounds (Issue #1439, #1448 / PR #1440, #1449)**: RSM and Interaction Map matrix inputs protected with node ceilings against DoS payloads. (*Resolved and Merged*). -5. **Subprocess Timeout & Watchdog (Issue #1460, #1461, #1462 / PR #1460)**: Release scripts and worker processes bound to non-hanging watchdog timeouts. (*Resolved and Merged*). -6. **Finite-Population Sampling Artifacts (Issue #1453, #1454 / PR #1445)**: Stratified allocation powered by $O(N \log N)$ bounded algorithms and lossless inclusion-probability contracts. (*Resolved and Merged*). -7. **External Validation Preregistered Profiles (Issue #1443, #1446 / PR #1444)**: Preregistered profile replay verifying transportability and fairness evidence. (*Resolved and Merged*). - -### 21.2 Buyer-Perceived Product & UX Gaps ($20B Enterprise Benchmark) -1. **Interactive Storybook & Design Token Uniformity**: Centralized Design Token architecture (CSS custom properties, WCAG 2.1 AAA contrast, keyboard focus indicators, tabular numerals) matching Figma specifications (`docs/figma_product_design_packet.md`). -2. **Deterministic End-to-End Load Resilience**: Standalone report generation and REST/PyO3 calls sustaining high concurrency ($k6$ benchmark $\ge 1,000$ RPS without memory leaks or event loop starvation). -3. **Enterprise Compliance Package**: Fully automated generation of SOC 2 / CSAP audit trail packages, including SHA-256 evidence indexes, reproducibility manifests, and SBOM (Software Bill of Materials) exports. - ---- - -## 22. Active Pull Request & Issue Inventory Matrix - -| PR # | Branch | Title | State | CI Checks | Merge Status & Resolution | -|---|---|---|---|---|---| -| **#1420** | `refactor/judge-projection-core-1414` | refactor(judge): share canonical IRT projection core | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1425** | `fix/twopl-response-admission-1424` | fix(twopl): seal response and tolerance evidence before Rust | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1433** | `feat/item-parameter-provenance-1432` | feat(item-bank): distinguish provisional and calibrated parameter provenance | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1438** | `fix/item-bank-lifecycle-replay-1435` | fix(item-bank): replay lifecycle identity on public serialization | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1440** | `fix/interaction-map-structural-budget-1439` | fix(interaction-map): bound matrix structural traversal | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1444** | `feat/external-validation-profile-1443` | feat(validation): add preregistered external-evidence profile | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1445** | `feat/finite-population-sampling-design` | feat(sampling): add finite-population design artifact | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1449** | `fix/rsm-structural-budget-1448` | fix(rsm): bound structural response traversal | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1456** | `fix/domain-neutral-lineage-channel-1455` | fix(core): restore domain-neutral lineage anchor contract | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1460** | `sentinel/fix-subprocess-hang-12661123842438592504` | 🛡️ Sentinel: [HIGH] 서브프로세스 무한 대기 취약점 수정 | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1467** | `fix/confirmatory-evidence-admission-1466` | fix(models): seal confirmatory loading-pattern evidence | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | -| **#1417** | `feat/interaction-map-rust-summary-1412` | feat(interaction-map): extend Rust result envelope | DRAFT | ALL PASS (13/13) | **BASE PR**: Interaction map envelope; rebase and merge. | -| **#1436** | `feat/polytomous-period-artifact-adr` | docs(adr): define Rust polytomous period artifact | DRAFT | ALL PASS (13/13) | **STACKED**: ADR documentation stacked on #1417. | -| **#1457** | `feat/interaction-map-explained-share` | feat(interaction-map): expose Rust explained share | DRAFT | Python CI Fail | **NEEDS FIX**: Repair test assertions on explained variance share. | - ---- - -## 23. Actionable Continuous Autonomous Execution Loops - -To guarantee the software continuously escalates in capability and quality, the following self-sustaining loops operate on an hourly recurring schedule: - -```mermaid -graph TD - L1["Loop 1: Open PR Audit & Merge Pipeline"] --> L2["Loop 2: CI/CD Quality & Security Gate Verification"] - L2 --> L3["Loop 3: Mathematical Kernel & Recovery Extension"] - L3 --> L4["Loop 4: Ecosystem MSA Connector & Governance Synchronization"] - L4 --> L5["Loop 5: Enterprise Buyer Evidence & $20B Baseline Audit"] - L5 --> L1 -``` - -### Loop 1: PR Verification & Merge Engine -- Batch 1 (11 PRs) successfully merged to main. -- Rebase PR #1417, #1436, and fix #1457 against updated main to achieve 0 open PRs. -- Continuous verification of all 14 GitHub Actions checks. - -### Loop 2: Core Psychometric & Temporal Engineering -- Ensure 100% Rust ownership of all newly introduced models (e.g., polytomous period state tracking, longitudinal drift estimation). -- Enforce ground-truth parameter recovery testing (RMSE $< 0.05$ across simulated cohorts). - -### Loop 3: Ecosystem Interoperability & Governance -- Maintain bi-directional contract compatibility with `TEPP`, `contextual-orchestrator`, `LineageWeave`, and `RankWeave`. -- Update `CHANGELOG.md` and cut version releases according to SemVer once PR batches land. From aac66e3f10f92e8ff6d275e0e4c3a2f303a45a7e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 10:59:36 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 002/110] fix(product-gap): label historical strix evidence Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index dcc4c0e03..d3db57f17 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -251,7 +251,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `1342862e…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | draft; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; review and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, and security checks passed, but required Strix failed during non-code report mapping; independent approval still required | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From 8f2648859e8eece138b5888c2de7f845af2f07ba Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 11:14:47 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 003/110] docs(multilevel): correct longitudinal citation Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- ...tilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md b/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md index d6599d8b1..c4a7f4678 100644 --- a/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md +++ b/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md @@ -150,7 +150,7 @@ Embretson, S. E. (1991). A multidimensional latent trait model for measuring lea Fox, J.-P., & Glas, C. A. W. (2001). Bayesian estimation of a multilevel IRT model using Gibbs sampling. *Psychometrika, 66*, 271–288. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02294839 -Jeon, M., & Rabe-Hesketh, S. (2025). An autoregressive growth model for longitudinal item analysis. *Psychometrika*. Advance online publication. +Jeon, M., & Rabe-Hesketh, S. (2016). An autoregressive growth model for longitudinal item analysis. *Psychometrika, 81*(3), 830–850. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-015-9489-2 Tranmer, M., Steel, D., & Browne, W. J. (2014). Multiple-membership multiple-classification models for social network and group dependencies. *Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society), 177*(2), 439–455. https://doi.org/10.1111/rssa.12021 From fe9d5b263eab71bc482db6883a4c7a46fa1f9d59 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 11:38:30 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 004/110] docs(product-gap): include current PR queue Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 14 ++++++++------ 1 file changed, 8 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d3db57f17..ceae90ded 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T01:14:34Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T02:37:24Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,13 +244,15 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T01:14:34Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T02:37:24Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `1342862e…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | draft; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; review and protected merge are absent | +| [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `eaea5239…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `8f264885…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | @@ -265,10 +267,10 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | | [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; current checks passed, but review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | -| [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | +| [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `fe6625d9…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **16 open pull requests** and GitHub -search enumerated **48 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **18 open pull requests** and GitHub +search enumerated **49 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and From 2b329425f91da9349571ab6467ce88e9895c90ab Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 11:47:07 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 005/110] docs(product-gap): correct stacked head evidence Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index ceae90ded..96d6a00b4 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T02:37:24Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T02:46:50Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,7 +244,7 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T02:37:24Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T02:46:50Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. @@ -267,7 +267,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | | [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; current checks passed, but review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | -| [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `fe6625d9…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | +| [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **18 open pull requests** and GitHub search enumerated **49 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is From 3be242910b5bb7e8b63985d3e4d2dd0ba3b1ea65 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 11:55:05 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 006/110] docs(baseline): reconcile closed rust ownership issues Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 9 +++++---- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 96d6a00b4..64d417ce0 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -276,8 +276,8 @@ is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and #565 (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). The Rust-owned ordinary-production boundary has materially advanced through the integrated -backend/runtime work; issue #626 is closed, but the remaining public capability -and release evidence still prevents a universal technical-GA claim. +backend/runtime work; issues #626 and #627 are closed, but the remaining public +capability and release evidence still prevents a universal technical-GA claim. This list is a reproducible snapshot, not a merge instruction. A completion or merge decision must begin with a fresh repository-wide PR and writer sweep, @@ -319,7 +319,7 @@ enforces exact-type admission and replays `__post_init__` invariants | Gap ID | Priority | Required outcome | Existing issue / PR evidence | Completion test | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | GAP-01 | P0 | Freeze a bounded 1.0 capability, support and maturity matrix; do not equate planned research with GA | [#621](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/621), [#636](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/636), [#648](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/648) | every public capability is classified, supported versions match metadata, and the release gate makes no valuation/certification claim | -| GAP-02 | P0 | One ordinary Rust/PyO3 numerical owner; NumPy only on explicit reference/parity surfaces | [#626](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/626), [#627](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/627); the automatic-backend and reference-isolation slices landed on protected main via merged [#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951)/[#1070](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1070) | production config/API cannot silently select Python numerics; missing/incompatible Rust fails before result-affecting work | +| GAP-02 | P0 | One ordinary Rust/PyO3 numerical owner; NumPy only on explicit reference/parity surfaces | closed issues [#626](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/626) and [#627](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/627); the automatic-backend and reference-isolation slices landed on protected main via merged [#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951)/[#1070](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1070) | production config/API cannot silently select Python numerics; missing/incompatible Rust fails before result-affecting work | | GAP-03 | P0 | Complete non-atomistic multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership and longitudinal estimation with identification and recovery | [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565); crossed multiple-membership estimator landed via merged [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014), and continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch landed via merged [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | realistic aligned bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence and temporal leakage tests pass; the remaining profile must preserve its declared estimand and recovery evidence | | GAP-04 | P0 | Relation-safe factor retention, structural model selection and identified exploratory multidimensional estimation | [#608](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/608), [#633](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/633), [#551](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/551), PR [#1008](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1008) | no winner is forced without relation-appropriate tests, held-out evidence, scoreability and true-structure recovery | | GAP-05 | P1 | Close rubric, generated-item, scoring, RAG, essay, enterprise-issue and item-bank lifecycles without parallel contracts | [#397](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/397), [#404](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/404), [#607](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/607), [#609](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/609), PR [#1003](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1003) | one immutable assessment/rubric/scoring lineage reaches pilot, calibration, validation, lifecycle and report evidence without provider coupling or silent state promotion | @@ -347,7 +347,8 @@ enforces exact-type admission and replays `__post_init__` invariants ### Stage 1 — close the technical-GA numerical boundary 1. Reconcile #951 and #1070 so one public backend/reference contract survives. -2. Complete #626/#627 Rust ownership and fail-closed evidence. +2. Retain the protected-main closure evidence for #626/#627 Rust ownership and + fail-closed behavior in the support matrix. 3. Define the first bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix under #621/#648. 4. Reject advertised-but-unimplemented model×estimator combinations before fitting and remove normal-path `NotImplementedError` surfaces from the GA From a51a71672bf235f22365e6b3782f29faa78aaab7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 12:05:22 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 007/110] docs(baseline): refresh current queue evidence Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 9 +++++---- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 64d417ce0..b6068572c 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T02:46:50Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:05:05Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,14 +244,15 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T02:46:50Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T03:05:05Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `eaea5239…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `8f264885…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `3be24291…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | @@ -269,7 +270,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | | [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **18 open pull requests** and GitHub +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **19 open pull requests** and GitHub search enumerated **49 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The From cc29b64b51e4e06ccdb7d702b3abfb59ca645fc9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 12:30:43 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 008/110] docs(baseline): track current population-label head Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index b6068572c..fc9ded369 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:05:05Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:30:25Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,14 +244,14 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T03:05:05Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T03:30:25Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | -| [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `eaea5239…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `3be24291…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | From 53906c44122949f15ef77ebe6c91aafd57fb9161 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 12:44:01 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 009/110] docs(baseline): record current review gate Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index fc9ded369..074410c3f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:30:25Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:43:39Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,7 +244,7 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T03:30:25Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T03:43:39Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. @@ -252,7 +252,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `3be24291…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `cc29b64b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From c9d396722c44779274a8cc7fd5977caeca79588b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 12:56:01 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 010/110] docs(baseline): include current subscore PR Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 9 +++++---- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 074410c3f..04343e7a2 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:43:39Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:55:42Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,12 +244,13 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T03:43:39Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T03:55:42Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `2f2e6deb…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | draft; required checks are pending and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `cc29b64b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict; independent approval and protected merge are absent | @@ -270,8 +271,8 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | | [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **19 open pull requests** and GitHub -search enumerated **49 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **20 open pull requests** and GitHub +search enumerated **50 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and From 119f39098abb33fde3a8c1f009e521195dd6819d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 13:12:47 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 011/110] docs(baseline): refresh current subscore head Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 04343e7a2..bd753d50b 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T03:55:42Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:12:21Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,16 +244,16 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T03:55:42Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T04:12:21Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `2f2e6deb…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | draft; required checks are pending and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | +| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `6491b3e9…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | draft; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `cc29b64b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `c9d39672…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From a347e3a3c5b4858172892a8cd3cd610e262fc982 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 13:41:56 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 012/110] docs(baseline): refresh current PR heads Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 12 ++++++------ 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index bd753d50b..983fda1de 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:12:21Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:41:11Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,18 +244,18 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T04:12:21Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T04:41:11Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `6491b3e9…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | draft; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | +| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `5558a46a…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `c9d39672…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` lacks a current-head verdict; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `c9d39672…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `303872c8…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `19ecd219…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; required checks are rerunning on this exact head after a native-count boundary repair; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | @@ -272,7 +272,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **20 open pull requests** and GitHub -search enumerated **50 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is +search enumerated **51 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and From 538615943102604973fdaecc3af5980c6e5f74b3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 13:53:57 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 013/110] docs: refresh gap baseline check status Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 983fda1de..42d33b029 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:41:11Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:53:35Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,7 +244,7 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T04:41:11Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T04:53:35Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. @@ -255,7 +255,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `c9d39672…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `19ecd219…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; required checks are rerunning on this exact head after a native-count boundary repair; an earlier non-required Strix run reported a report-mapping failure, and independent approval remains required | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `19ecd219…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed on this exact head; required `opencode-review` remains pending and independent approval is still required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From 6fd7094bf0738c3bc53b4a5a0d1f04a14df7c757 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 13:56:50 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 014/110] docs: record current review gate status Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 42d33b029..cdb4a444d 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:53:35Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:56:26Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,7 +244,7 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T04:53:35Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T04:56:26Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. @@ -253,9 +253,9 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `5558a46a…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `c9d39672…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `53861594…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | current tracking head; its latest description refresh requeued required checks; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `19ecd219…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed on this exact head; required `opencode-review` remains pending and independent approval is still required | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `19ecd219…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, and coverage/security checks passed on this exact head; required `opencode-review` failed because no current-head `opencode-agent` verdict was posted, and independent approval is still required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From b34d2af9fe656f9cde413c1c664bd2072b05a9cb Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 14:13:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 015/110] docs: refresh rasch result evidence Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index cdb4a444d..d4affdae1 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T04:56:26Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T05:12:55Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,7 +244,7 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T04:56:26Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T05:12:55Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. @@ -253,9 +253,9 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `5558a46a…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `53861594…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | current tracking head; its latest description refresh requeued required checks; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `6fd7094b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `19ecd219…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, and coverage/security checks passed on this exact head; required `opencode-review` failed because no current-head `opencode-agent` verdict was posted, and independent approval is still required | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; hosted security, CodeQL, queue, bootstrap, package, and coverage checks passed on this exact head while Rust/fuzz were still pending at observation; required `opencode-review` failed because no current-head `opencode-agent` verdict was posted, and independent approval is still required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From 2960aa566093b8b69524936aacaa19298c8944a4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 14:49:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 016/110] docs: correct baseline PR head Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d4affdae1..8c3181ca3 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -253,7 +253,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `5558a46a…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `6fd7094b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `b34d2af9…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; hosted security, CodeQL, queue, bootstrap, package, and coverage checks passed on this exact head while Rust/fuzz were still pending at observation; required `opencode-review` failed because no current-head `opencode-agent` verdict was posted, and independent approval is still required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From bc175e6437cc2356b8256379c1d3ae3509e952e0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 14:54:38 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 017/110] docs: preserve baseline snapshot head Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 8c3181ca3..d4affdae1 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -253,7 +253,7 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `5558a46a…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `b34d2af9…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `6fd7094b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; hosted security, CodeQL, queue, bootstrap, package, and coverage checks passed on this exact head while Rust/fuzz were still pending at observation; required `opencode-review` failed because no current-head `opencode-agent` verdict was posted, and independent approval is still required | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | From 4b7de244303b4a2bc000017c194668a81ec4be27 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 20:29:49 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 018/110] docs(gap): refresh live PR baseline Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 34 ++++++++++++++------------ 1 file changed, 18 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d4affdae1..28c20ed8a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T05:12:55Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T11:26:40Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,35 +244,37 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T05:12:55Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T11:26:40Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `5558a46a…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed and no independent review is present; active-PR evidence is not protected-main capability | +| [#1536](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1536) | `5fbcd003…` | hardens multiple-membership admission and adds known-truth multilevel recovery evidence | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1533](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1533) | `6f9b2a65…` | improves standalone HTML report skip-link and keyboard-focus accessibility | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `ed0a73f8…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | -| [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `b73d7686…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `6fd7094b…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ordinary required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `35ffcdc1…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; hosted security, CodeQL, queue, bootstrap, package, and coverage checks passed on this exact head while Rust/fuzz were still pending at observation; required `opencode-review` failed because no current-head `opencode-agent` verdict was posted, and independent approval is still required | +| [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `8154171e…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `bc175e64…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `b7b6d390…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1501](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1501) | `34338763…` | bounds EBDIF item evidence before allocation (issue [#1500](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1500)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1494](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1494) | `fb3f7e24…` | seals LLTM scientific evidence admission before NumPy protocols (issues [#1493](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1493)–[#1499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1499)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1492](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1492) | `9feae4de…` | preserves integer safety across essay contracts reload (issue [#1491](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1491)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1481](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1481) | `7946f4b8…` | bounds parallel-analysis observed data before dense marshalling (issues [#1480](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1480)–[#1489](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1489)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1479](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1479) | `057a4082…` | replays factor-retention result invariants (issue [#1478](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1478)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | +| [#1494](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1494) | `fb3f7e24…` | seals LLTM scientific evidence admission before NumPy protocols (issues [#1493](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1493)–[#1499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1499)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1492](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1492) | `9feae4de…` | preserves integer safety across essay contracts reload (issue [#1491](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1491)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1481](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1481) | `7946f4b8…` | bounds parallel-analysis observed data before dense marshalling (issues [#1480](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1480)–[#1489](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1489)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1479](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1479) | `057a4082…` | replays factor-retention result invariants (issue [#1478](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1478)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1471](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1471) | `8ce2ae2e…` | cuts the 0.9.2 release | ready; current checks passed, but the release parent remains review-blocked; stack children must be synchronized after any parent change | | [#1476](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1476) | `f3c66f0e…` | replays item-bank evidence-reference identity (issue [#1475](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1475)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | | [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | -| [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; current checks passed, but review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | +| [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; ordinary checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed; review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | | [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **20 open pull requests** and GitHub -search enumerated **51 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **22 open pull requests** and GitHub +issue listing enumerated **65 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and From 5453d0df84e4e653f68fc9844b44b9abf9de04f7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 22:33:56 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 019/110] docs(gap): refresh live PR baseline Signed-off-by: Seongho Bae --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 21 +++++++++++---------- 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 28c20ed8a..9c8a87628 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T11:26:40Z**
+Observed at: **2026-08-28T13:32:53Z**
Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** @@ -244,37 +244,38 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T11:26:40Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is +2026-08-28T13:32:53Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1536](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1536) | `5fbcd003…` | hardens multiple-membership admission and adds known-truth multilevel recovery evidence | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1545](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1545) | `1a40867f…` | adds a versioned producer and validator for count-only compute-usage export and fit-usage metering | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1536](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1536) | `6f050990…` | hardens multiple-membership admission and adds known-truth multilevel recovery evidence | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1533](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1533) | `6f9b2a65…` | improves standalone HTML report skip-link and keyboard-focus accessibility | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `ed0a73f8…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | | [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `8154171e…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `bc175e64…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `4b7de244…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `b7b6d390…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `21babc2f…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `ff47e7b0…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal and quadratic item-pair matrices before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1501](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1501) | `34338763…` | bounds EBDIF item evidence before allocation (issue [#1500](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1500)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | | [#1494](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1494) | `fb3f7e24…` | seals LLTM scientific evidence admission before NumPy protocols (issues [#1493](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1493)–[#1499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1499)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1492](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1492) | `9feae4de…` | preserves integer safety across essay contracts reload (issue [#1491](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1491)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1481](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1481) | `7946f4b8…` | bounds parallel-analysis observed data before dense marshalling (issues [#1480](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1480)–[#1489](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1489)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1479](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1479) | `057a4082…` | replays factor-retention result invariants (issue [#1478](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1478)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | +| [#1479](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1479) | `39fcedb9…` | replays factor-retention result invariants (issue [#1478](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1478)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | | [#1471](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1471) | `8ce2ae2e…` | cuts the 0.9.2 release | ready; current checks passed, but the release parent remains review-blocked; stack children must be synchronized after any parent change | -| [#1476](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1476) | `f3c66f0e…` | replays item-bank evidence-reference identity (issue [#1475](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1475)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | -| [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; no required checks were reported on this child branch, so it is not protected-delivery evidence | +| [#1476](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1476) | `f3c66f0e…` | replays item-bank evidence-reference identity (issue [#1475](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1475)) | targets release PR #1471; child checks passed, but the unmerged release stack is not protected-main evidence and independent approval is absent | +| [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; child checks passed, but the unmerged release stack is not protected-main evidence and independent approval is absent | | [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; ordinary checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed; review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | | [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **22 open pull requests** and GitHub -issue listing enumerated **65 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **23 open pull requests** and GitHub +issue listing enumerated **69 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and From 3a3865f40da12211898c97cbd47e7460381736ae Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Tue, 1 Sep 2026 21:37:20 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 020/110] docs(product-gap): refresh live commercialization evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 78 +++++++++++++++++++------- 1 file changed, 59 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 9c8a87628..0f514caa4 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-08-28T13:32:53Z**
-Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700…`**
+Observed at: **2026-09-01T12:34:21Z**
+Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`**
Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** ## 1. Purpose and authority @@ -243,10 +243,58 @@ new canonical capability-maturity state. ## 7. Current pull-request evidence -The following table records high-leverage live work observed on -2026-08-28T13:32:53Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is -**IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green -check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. +### 7.0 Live commercialization/control-plane delta — 2026-09-01 + +The protected product branch remains `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. +GitHub search at this refresh reports **46 open pull requests** and **195 open +issues**. These counts supersede the older 23/69 snapshot below; the older table +is retained only as dated historical context until a generated live inventory +replaces it. + +Central review/control-plane state materially changed during this refresh: + +- `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1564` is merged; the canonical Noema deleted-file + path now reads removed-file evidence from immutable base-side provenance while + preserving current transport/retry/security behavior. Its reconciliation also + absorbed the still-valid hollow CodeGraph-context cleanup previously carried + by #1567. #1567 is therefore closed unmerged and must not be resurrected as a + competing writer. +- `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1601` merged by the ordinary expected-head path at + central protected main `5f81d8e665b7d3f51f379a090e077486dbf548c5`. + Strix 1.5.3 passes `LLM_TIMEOUT` to `asyncio.wait_for`; the predecessor central + `LLM_TIMEOUT=0` cancelled model preflight immediately. Protected central main + now carries the focused regression and positive `LLM_TIMEOUT=300` contract. +- duplicate central #1600 was closed only after both intended file blobs were + proven byte-identical to the files shipped by #1601. +- Actions capacity remains an operability constraint: a cancelled pre-#1601 + Strix job for #1714 is attached to a workflow run whose stale-run cleanup job + is still queued, and GitHub currently rejects a direct job rerun because it + considers that run active. Cancelled/pending/queued evidence remains + non-passing; it is not reclassified as a product defect or success. + +Current high-leverage product heads refetched in this refresh are: + +| PR | Exact head | Current role | Live disposition | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| [#1714](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1714) | `753bcd7575611d60b618777261a0880ad7f44bbc` | typed non-numerical model-specification/dependence candidate compiler | mechanically mergeable; visible substantive review threads resolved; no current qualifying approval; pre-#1601 Strix evidence cancelled and other required evidence queued/pending | +| [#1716](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1716) | `43ba529c3b2dfa65e430735e5dce8ca9ee4fbe65` | TEPP temporal/event semantics versus Rust time-indexed psychometric-kernel bounded-context decision | mechanically mergeable; visible substantive threads resolved; auto-merge enabled; required evidence remains queued/non-terminal | +| [#1717](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1717) | `161b513d77df69151de05a2b7cb0a6cf632afac7` | product-first README and public documentation landing | mechanically mergeable; review findings resolved; auto-merge enabled; documentation-only and no Pages publication is claimed before protected integration/live settings | +| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | this writer branch | single writer for this baseline | refreshed from its current blob; no competing baseline writer should be opened | + +The implementation-direction audit for these active heads does not move +production numerical ownership into Python. `fast-mlsirm` continues to own +result-affecting mathematical, psychometric, optimization, information/scoring, +vector/matrix and model-estimation computation in Rust/PyO3. Python remains a +validation, provenance-sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and +explicit reference/parity boundary. A future PR that adds ordinary production +Python arithmetic for those responsibilities is a product-boundary defect and +must be redirected to the Rust owner. + +The following table is the earlier high-leverage snapshot observed on +2026-08-28T13:32:53Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is historical +**IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED** evidence only; re-fetch the live +head before acting. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability +until the PR is merged. | PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | @@ -274,13 +322,11 @@ check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. | [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | | [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | -At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **23 open pull requests** and GitHub -issue listing enumerated **69 open issues**. The current direct-to-main queue is -dominated by bounded native-boundary and result-replay fixes; the release stack -is rooted at #1471, and the interaction-map stack is rooted at #1417. The -long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) and -#565 (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). The Rust-owned -ordinary-production boundary has materially advanced through the integrated +The older snapshot enumerated 23 open pull requests and 69 open issues. It is +retained only to preserve dated lineage; the current live counts are 46 and 195. +The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) +and #565 (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). The Rust-owned +ordinary-production boundary has materially advanced through integrated backend/runtime work; issues #626 and #627 are closed, but the remaining public capability and release evidence still prevents a universal technical-GA claim. @@ -289,12 +335,6 @@ merge decision must begin with a fresh repository-wide PR and writer sweep, including exact head/base, dependency stack, reviews, unresolved threads, required Checks, and active path ownership. -The previous six-row snapshot is obsolete: those listed PRs are no longer open, -and the current queue above was re-fetched from the live repository. Their -integrated capability evidence remains part of protected main where the merge -was completed; the active rows above remain candidates until their exact heads -pass current reviews and protected merge gates. - ### 7.1 Superseded lineage record Two orphaned Sentinel security branches were deleted on 2026-08-25 because From 9346f7f731946d07064349e4a369133854503ce7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 11:51:20 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 021/110] docs(product-gap): pin point-in-time PR evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 867 ++++--------------------- 1 file changed, 115 insertions(+), 752 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 0f514caa4..c2fb5288d 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,754 +1,117 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline -Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
-Observed at: **2026-09-01T12:34:21Z**
-Protected-main basis: **`main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`**
-Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** - -## 1. Purpose and authority - -This document answers one bounded question: - -> What remains before `fast-mlsirm` can make a defensible technical-GA claim, and what additional evidence remains before a downstream product can make a validated domain or high-stakes use claim? - -This file is an inventory and routing aid. It is **not** a competing PRD, TRD, -architecture, ADR, release manifest, or statement of shipped capability. -Canonical authority remains: - -- [`docs/PRD.md`](PRD.md); -- [`docs/TRD.md`](TRD.md); -- [`../ARCHITECTURE.md`](../ARCHITECTURE.md); -- [`docs/documentation_coverage.md`](documentation_coverage.md); -- the status-bearing ADR graph; and -- [issue #621](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/621), or its explicitly accepted successor, for cross-cutting documentation fitness. - -Protected `main` is shipped truth. An issue, open pull request, green check on an -unmerged head, review comment, branch description, scheduler state, or this -inventory is evidence only. Before acting on any row below, re-fetch: - -1. protected-main SHA; -2. pull-request head and live base; -3. draft/ready and mergeability state; -4. current-head reviews and unresolved threads; -5. required checks; and -6. active writer/overlapping-path ownership. - -No predecessor-head check or review transfers after a head or live-base change. - -## 2. Executive disposition - -At the observed protected-main SHA, `fast-mlsirm` is a substantial Rust/PyO3 -psychometric measurement core, but a general technical-GA or universal -high-stakes readiness claim is not yet defensible. - -The strongest remaining completion dependencies are: - -1. finish one Rust-owned ordinary production numerical boundary with no silent - Python fallback; -2. integrate and validate the multilevel, multiple-membership, longitudinal, - model-selection, and recovery slices that are currently split across issues - and active PRs; -3. add independent cross-engine equation and fitted-result conformance evidence; -4. add preregistered external-validity and transportability evidence profiles; -5. freeze a bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix instead of treating every - research or planned model as part of GA; -6. complete stable artifact/version/migration, release, support, supply-chain, - benchmark, and rollback evidence; and -7. prove at least one buyer-visible end-to-end workflow through an owning - downstream product without moving hosted identity, consent, persistence, or - decision governance into this reusable core. - -A package can reach **technical GA** while particular domain or high-stakes use -profiles remain unvalidated. Technical correctness, construct validity, -transportability, fairness, and decision utility are separate claims. - -## 3. Current protected-main product truth - -The observed protected main declares: - -- package version **`0.9.1`**; -- Python **`>=3.12`**; -- Maturin/PyO3 bindings to the Rust workspace; -- PyPI classifier **`Development Status :: 3 - Alpha`**; and -- an “early high-performance toolkit” product description. - -Protected main already provides substantial evidence and usable primitives, -including: - -- Rust/PyO3 likelihood, optimization, diagnostic, scoring, linking, CAT/ATA, - and selected GPU/CPU parity paths; -- deterministic simulation and true-parameter recovery infrastructure; -- governed rubric, scoring, evidence, RAG, essay, enterprise-issue, and - item-bank contracts; -- fail-closed validation and bounded-resource controls; -- package/wheel/reinstall, fuzz, security, SAST, and protected-check gates; -- accessible standalone reports and content-addressed provenance patterns; and -- canonical PRD/TRD/architecture, V&V, threat-model, standards-watch, - UML/ERD, and traceability families. - -The protected-main documentation audit still classifies several release-critical -families as **PARTIAL**, notably: - -- public interface/version/serialization/fingerprint contracts; -- reusable-core operability and recovery; -- security/data-governance navigation; -- release/migration/rollback/provenance/licensing navigation; -- requirements traceability and selected UML/ERD coverage; and -- root README/AGENTS/CLAUDE/Architecture/PRD/TRD/CHANGELOG alignment. - -Those states are not cosmetic documentation tasks. They identify product -contracts that a buyer, downstream integrator, or maintainer still cannot -reconstruct reliably without source archaeology. - -## 4. Product boundary - -### 4.1 `fast-mlsirm` owns - -- domain-neutral psychometric numerical kernels; -- public simulation, fitting, scoring, diagnostics, comparison, linking, CAT, - ATA, recovery, and evidence contracts that are explicitly integrated on - protected main; -- Rust-first numerical ownership, deterministic Python validation/marshalling, - bounded resource controls, and versioned reusable artifacts; -- package-level V&V, benchmark, security, interoperability, provenance, and - release evidence; and -- source-text-free reports and handoff contracts. - -### 4.2 Downstream products own - -`ContextualWisdomLab/psychometrics-commons` or another explicitly owning host -owns, as applicable: - -- tenants, accounts, OIDC/SSO/SCIM and authorization; -- participants, sessions, consent, data-rights and purpose limitation; -- hosted persistence, object storage, queues, APIs, UI and billing; -- operational item banks and restricted test content; -- human review, approval, administration and incident workflows; -- domain-specific external validation data and high-stakes decision policy; and -- regulated deployment, retention, deletion and audit execution. - -The downstream host may consume `fast-mlsirm` only through a traceable, -versioned handoff: a released package and schema version, a versioned API/schema, -or an immutable content-addressed artifact reference. The consumer records the -package/artifact version, source commit, schema version, and environment -provenance used for each result. A floating branch checkout or unrecorded -implementation import is not a reusable integration contract. `fast-mlsirm` -must not depend on that host to remain installable and useful as a standalone -library. - -### 4.3 Explicit non-goals for this repository - -- a universal validity or fairness certification; -- a hosted assessment/session database; -- direct storage of operational PII or restricted test content; -- automatic causal claims from observational scores; -- provider-specific LLM execution inside the numerical core; -- treating one external package as an unquestionable oracle; -- a machine-generated acquisition valuation or guaranteed sale price; and -- declaring every planned model family part of a 1.0 support promise. - -### 4.4 Versioned downstream handoff - -The reusable-core boundary is actionable only when a consumer can identify the -artifact it is allowed to import and the owner of the surrounding lifecycle. -The current handoff therefore follows these repository contracts: - -- [`docs/scoring_assessment_contracts.md`](scoring_assessment_contracts.md) and - [`docs/scoring_execution_contracts.md`](scoring_execution_contracts.md) define - the package-owned request, observation, scoring, and execution surfaces; -- [`docs/enterprise_issue_evidence_contracts.md`](enterprise_issue_evidence_contracts.md) - defines source-free evidence handoff for an owning product; and -- [`docs/adr/0001-domain-neutral-measurement-boundary.md`](adr/0001-domain-neutral-measurement-boundary.md), - [`docs/adr/0003-content-addressed-measurement-contracts.md`](adr/0003-content-addressed-measurement-contracts.md), - and [`docs/adr/0013-continuous-execution-and-documentation-governance.md`](adr/0013-continuous-execution-and-documentation-governance.md) - define ownership, immutable provenance, and documentation authority. - -Consumers must pin a released package/artifact schema and record its source and -environment provenance. A downstream host owns participant/session/consent, -authorization, persistence, raw content, human decisions, and regulated -retention; this baseline does not create a second database or HTTP contract. -The handoff is therefore reusable across `psychometrics-commons` and other -consumers while `fast-mlsirm` remains independently installable. - -## 5. Completion profiles - -### 5.1 Technical alpha - -This is the current declared package line. Useful APIs may exist, but public -contracts, support scope, scientific evidence, compatibility, and operational -surfaces can still change before 1.0. - -### 5.2 Technical GA — reusable measurement core - -A technical-GA profile requires a bounded, versioned list of supported public -capabilities. For every listed capability, the profile must provide: - -- one ordinary Rust/PyO3 production numerical owner; -- fail-closed behavior when that owner is missing or incompatible; -- explicit identification, estimand, model/estimator compatibility, resource, - missingness, and convergence contracts; -- true-parameter recovery or inferential error evidence appropriate to the - claim, including Monte Carlo uncertainty where stochastic; -- independent cross-engine conformance where a scientifically equivalent - implementation exists; -- stable public API and artifact schemas with migration/rollback policy; -- exact supported Python/platform/backend matrix; -- 100% repository-required production statement/branch coverage and public - docstring evidence; -- benchmark/capacity evidence and bounded failure behavior; -- security, fuzz, package/reinstall, SBOM, provenance and licensing evidence; -- current support and vulnerability-reporting policy; and -- one unchanged exact head satisfying all required reviews and checks. - -A capability that lacks the required evidence remains experimental, research, -planned, or explicitly outside the GA profile; it does not block unrelated, -bounded GA capabilities. - -### 5.3 Validated domain profile - -A domain profile binds the technical core to one assessment, rubric/item-bank, -population, setting, language, time period, criterion, and intended score use. -It additionally requires content/response-process, internal-structure, -external-variable, transportability, fairness, and consequence evidence. - -A domain profile is versioned independently of the Python package. A package -upgrade does not automatically validate an old profile, and a validated profile -does not approve every other use of the same estimator. - -### 5.4 High-stakes use profile - -A high-stakes profile additionally requires the owning product’s legal, -privacy, security, human-governance, accessibility, adverse-impact, -monitoring, incident, appeal, and decision-policy controls. This status cannot -be inferred from software tests, parameter recovery, cross-engine agreement, -or a passed package release gate. - -## 6. Status vocabulary used here - -This baseline reuses the repository’s canonical capability vocabulary: - -- **IMPLEMENTED_ON_PROTECTED_MAIN**; -- **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR**; -- **PARTIAL**; -- **ACCEPTED_ARCHITECTURE**; -- **PLANNED**; -- **RESEARCH_ONLY**; -- **DOWNSTREAM**; -- **SUPERSEDED**; -- **REJECTED**; and -- **OUT_OF_SCOPE**. - -For live PR rows, **RECHECK_REQUIRED** is only a snapshot annotation. It is not a -new canonical capability-maturity state. - -## 7. Current pull-request evidence - -### 7.0 Live commercialization/control-plane delta — 2026-09-01 - -The protected product branch remains `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. -GitHub search at this refresh reports **46 open pull requests** and **195 open -issues**. These counts supersede the older 23/69 snapshot below; the older table -is retained only as dated historical context until a generated live inventory -replaces it. - -Central review/control-plane state materially changed during this refresh: - -- `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1564` is merged; the canonical Noema deleted-file - path now reads removed-file evidence from immutable base-side provenance while - preserving current transport/retry/security behavior. Its reconciliation also - absorbed the still-valid hollow CodeGraph-context cleanup previously carried - by #1567. #1567 is therefore closed unmerged and must not be resurrected as a - competing writer. -- `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1601` merged by the ordinary expected-head path at - central protected main `5f81d8e665b7d3f51f379a090e077486dbf548c5`. - Strix 1.5.3 passes `LLM_TIMEOUT` to `asyncio.wait_for`; the predecessor central - `LLM_TIMEOUT=0` cancelled model preflight immediately. Protected central main - now carries the focused regression and positive `LLM_TIMEOUT=300` contract. -- duplicate central #1600 was closed only after both intended file blobs were - proven byte-identical to the files shipped by #1601. -- Actions capacity remains an operability constraint: a cancelled pre-#1601 - Strix job for #1714 is attached to a workflow run whose stale-run cleanup job - is still queued, and GitHub currently rejects a direct job rerun because it - considers that run active. Cancelled/pending/queued evidence remains - non-passing; it is not reclassified as a product defect or success. - -Current high-leverage product heads refetched in this refresh are: - -| PR | Exact head | Current role | Live disposition | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1714](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1714) | `753bcd7575611d60b618777261a0880ad7f44bbc` | typed non-numerical model-specification/dependence candidate compiler | mechanically mergeable; visible substantive review threads resolved; no current qualifying approval; pre-#1601 Strix evidence cancelled and other required evidence queued/pending | -| [#1716](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1716) | `43ba529c3b2dfa65e430735e5dce8ca9ee4fbe65` | TEPP temporal/event semantics versus Rust time-indexed psychometric-kernel bounded-context decision | mechanically mergeable; visible substantive threads resolved; auto-merge enabled; required evidence remains queued/non-terminal | -| [#1717](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1717) | `161b513d77df69151de05a2b7cb0a6cf632afac7` | product-first README and public documentation landing | mechanically mergeable; review findings resolved; auto-merge enabled; documentation-only and no Pages publication is claimed before protected integration/live settings | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | this writer branch | single writer for this baseline | refreshed from its current blob; no competing baseline writer should be opened | - -The implementation-direction audit for these active heads does not move -production numerical ownership into Python. `fast-mlsirm` continues to own -result-affecting mathematical, psychometric, optimization, information/scoring, -vector/matrix and model-estimation computation in Rust/PyO3. Python remains a -validation, provenance-sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and -explicit reference/parity boundary. A future PR that adds ordinary production -Python arithmetic for those responsibilities is a product-boundary defect and -must be redirected to the Rust owner. - -The following table is the earlier high-leverage snapshot observed on -2026-08-28T13:32:53Z against protected `main@45627700…`. Every row is historical -**IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED** evidence only; re-fetch the live -head before acting. A green check on any row is not a protected-main capability -until the PR is merged. - -| PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [#1545](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1545) | `1a40867f…` | adds a versioned producer and validator for count-only compute-usage export and fit-usage metering | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1536](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1536) | `6f050990…` | hardens multiple-membership admission and adds known-truth multilevel recovery evidence | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1533](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1533) | `6f9b2a65…` | improves standalone HTML report skip-link and keyboard-focus accessibility | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1525](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1525) | `ed0a73f8…` | validates the Rust `subscore_analysis` result envelope before NumPy marshalling (issue [#1524](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1524)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1523](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1523) | `b76092d4…` | aligns the traceability matrix with the protected-main v1/v2 lineage-anchor status and keeps unavailable v2 producer/estimator work out of implemented claims | ready; required CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval remains required | -| [#1522](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1522) | `8154171e…` | seals multigroup/multilevel population-label admission against caller coercion callbacks (issue [#1521](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1521)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1519](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1519) | `4b7de244…` | refreshes this buyer-facing protected-main product/technical gap inventory and corrects the longitudinal citation/status record | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but required `opencode-review` failed; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1518](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1518) | `b7b6d390…` | Rust ordered posterior-draw summary with weighted uncertainty, credible-level ambiguity, and fail-closed evidence admission (issue [#1484](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1484)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1516](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1516) | `a3a36571…` | seals Rasch CML structural response traversal and native result replay before public marshalling, including aggregate and per-group retained-count invariants (issues [#1515](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1515)/[#1517](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1517)/[#1527](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1527)/[#1528](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1528)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1510](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1510) | `a4e03857…` | bounds KSIRT response evidence and replays native result shape before NumPy marshalling (issues [#1507](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1507)–[#1514](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1514)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1506](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1506) | `ff47e7b0…` | bounds Mokken zero-cell structural traversal and quadratic item-pair matrices before NumPy materialization (issue [#1505](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1505)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1504](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1504) | `e8de9421…` | applies the cross-engine report accessibility palette changes | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1501](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1501) | `34338763…` | bounds EBDIF item evidence before allocation (issue [#1500](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1500)) | ready; current CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed; independent approval still required | -| [#1494](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1494) | `fb3f7e24…` | seals LLTM scientific evidence admission before NumPy protocols (issues [#1493](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1493)–[#1499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1499)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1492](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1492) | `9feae4de…` | preserves integer safety across essay contracts reload (issue [#1491](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1491)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1481](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1481) | `7946f4b8…` | bounds parallel-analysis observed data before dense marshalling (issues [#1480](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1480)–[#1489](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1489)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1479](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1479) | `39fcedb9…` | replays factor-retention result invariants (issue [#1478](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1478)) | ready; ordinary CI, Rust, package, fuzz, coverage, and security checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend and required `opencode-review` checks failed on this head; independent approval and protected merge are absent | -| [#1471](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1471) | `8ce2ae2e…` | cuts the 0.9.2 release | ready; current checks passed, but the release parent remains review-blocked; stack children must be synchronized after any parent change | -| [#1476](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1476) | `f3c66f0e…` | replays item-bank evidence-reference identity (issue [#1475](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1475)) | targets release PR #1471; child checks passed, but the unmerged release stack is not protected-main evidence and independent approval is absent | -| [#1473](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1473) | `bf1a7782…` | binds validation profiles to preregistration time (issue [#1472](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1472)) | targets release PR #1471; child checks passed, but the unmerged release stack is not protected-main evidence and independent approval is absent | -| [#1417](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1417) | `05e06766…` | extends the Rust residual interaction-map result envelope (issue [#1412](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1412)) | draft; ordinary checks passed, but the `strix` provider/backend check failed; review/merge is absent and child PRs depend on this parent | -| [#1436](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1436) | `a90db19f…` | documents the Rust polytomous period artifact | draft child of #1417; clean/mergeable only describes the stack candidate, not protected main | -| [#1457](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1457) | `94699c5b…` | exposes the Rust interaction-map explained-share projection | draft child of #1417; currently conflicting and requires parent synchronization before review | - -The older snapshot enumerated 23 open pull requests and 69 open issues. It is -retained only to preserve dated lineage; the current live counts are 46 and 195. -The long-lived product gaps remain #621 (bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix) -and #565 (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). The Rust-owned -ordinary-production boundary has materially advanced through integrated -backend/runtime work; issues #626 and #627 are closed, but the remaining public -capability and release evidence still prevents a universal technical-GA claim. - -This list is a reproducible snapshot, not a merge instruction. A completion or -merge decision must begin with a fresh repository-wide PR and writer sweep, -including exact head/base, dependency stack, reviews, unresolved threads, -required Checks, and active path ownership. - -### 7.1 Superseded lineage record - -Two orphaned Sentinel security branches were deleted on 2026-08-25 because -protected main already ships strictly stronger fixes for their scopes: - -- `sentinel-fix-json-recursion-conformance-4916450064032858492` (JSON recursion - DoS in `cross_engine_conformance.py`) — superseded by merged - [#1330](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1330) - (`a25833a0`: raw JSON depth guard + `tests/test_cross_engine_conformance_json_depth.py`). -- `sentinel-medium-fix-unbounded-json-loading-11914195049005804093` (unbounded - JSON loading in ops scripts) — superseded by main's - `scripts/_bounded_json.parse_json_bounded(..., max_bytes=...)` hardening in - `build_pr_queue_governance.py`, which bounds GitHub stdout bytes beyond the - branch's proposal. - -Issues [#1300](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1300), -[#1301](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1301), and -[#1303](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1303) were -closed on 2026-08-25 with protected-main evidence: `_TRUSTED_REAL_CONTROL_TYPES` -excludes Boolean identity (`mhrm.py` lines 46–51) with regression -`test_mhrm_real_control_boolean_admission.py`; `classify_model_relation()` -enforces exact-type admission and replays `__post_init__` invariants -(`model_relation.py` lines 144–146). - -## 8. Product and technical gap matrix - -| Gap ID | Priority | Required outcome | Existing issue / PR evidence | Completion test | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| GAP-01 | P0 | Freeze a bounded 1.0 capability, support and maturity matrix; do not equate planned research with GA | [#621](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/621), [#636](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/636), [#648](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/648) | every public capability is classified, supported versions match metadata, and the release gate makes no valuation/certification claim | -| GAP-02 | P0 | One ordinary Rust/PyO3 numerical owner; NumPy only on explicit reference/parity surfaces | closed issues [#626](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/626) and [#627](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/627); the automatic-backend and reference-isolation slices landed on protected main via merged [#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951)/[#1070](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1070) | production config/API cannot silently select Python numerics; missing/incompatible Rust fails before result-affecting work | -| GAP-03 | P0 | Complete non-atomistic multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership and longitudinal estimation with identification and recovery | [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565); crossed multiple-membership estimator landed via merged [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014), and continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch landed via merged [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | realistic aligned bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence and temporal leakage tests pass; the remaining profile must preserve its declared estimand and recovery evidence | -| GAP-04 | P0 | Relation-safe factor retention, structural model selection and identified exploratory multidimensional estimation | [#608](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/608), [#633](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/633), [#551](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/551), PR [#1008](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1008) | no winner is forced without relation-appropriate tests, held-out evidence, scoreability and true-structure recovery | -| GAP-05 | P1 | Close rubric, generated-item, scoring, RAG, essay, enterprise-issue and item-bank lifecycles without parallel contracts | [#397](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/397), [#404](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/404), [#607](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/607), [#609](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/609), PR [#1003](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1003) | one immutable assessment/rubric/scoring lineage reaches pilot, calibration, validation, lifecycle and report evidence without provider coupling or silent state promotion | -| GAP-06 | P0 | Independently test equations and fitted estimands against explicitly matched mature engines | [#1077](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1077) closed as COMPLETED after the reusable conformance provenance manifest landed ([#1082](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1082)); residual validation-family execution evidence tracks under [#1092](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1092)/[#1094](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1094)/[#1096](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1096)/[#1152](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1152) | versioned capability×engine matrix, fixed-parameter equation conformance first, aligned fitted-result comparisons, visible disagreement register | -| GAP-07 | P0 for validated claims | Add preregistered external validity, language/site/time transportability, fairness and criterion evidence profiles | [#1078](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1078) | external evidence is genuinely held out; claim register narrows automatically on absent, failed or indeterminate evidence | -| GAP-08 | P0 | Stabilize public artifact, schema, serialization, fingerprint, capability and migration contracts | [#637](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/637), [#653](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/653), [#499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/499) | strict RFC 8259 artifacts, no environment-dependent capability downgrade, versioned loaders/migrations, cross-language canonical fixtures | -| GAP-09 | P0 | Complete release/support/supply-chain evidence and truthful compatibility policy | [#648](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/648), [#623](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/623), [#636](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/636), documentation audit PARTIAL states | supported line/runtime/platforms are tested; wheel, SBOM, provenance, license, rollback and vulnerability process are source-hash-bound | -| GAP-10 | P1 | Publish capacity/performance envelopes instead of isolated speed claims | [#403](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/403), [#563](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/563) | representative N×item×dimension×facet×time workloads report latency, throughput, peak RSS/VRAM, failure ceilings and CPU/GPU parity | -| GAP-11 | P0 operations | Eliminate orphaned workflow identities and retain complete terminal statistical/release evidence | [#809](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/809), PR [#1071](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1071) | complete paginated workflow registry is reconciled; supported workflows remain; statistical studies terminate with durable evidence | -| GAP-12 | P1 product | Prove one buyer-visible vertical through a downstream host while preserving repository ownership | [#397](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/397), [#404](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/404), [#607](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/607), [#584](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/584) | source evidence → governed observations → Rust calibration → uncertainty/fairness/validation → accessible report → downstream human decision is replayable end to end | -| GAP-13 | P1 downstream UI | When a hosted consumer has a web surface, make UI states and interactions auditable rather than treating a static screenshot as product evidence | [`docs/adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md`](adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md) (merged via [#1130](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1130)), [`docs/figma_product_design_packet.md`](figma_product_design_packet.md), Storybook interaction-testing guidance | ADR records the exact Figma file ID (`qD34PfMH8Kr41tFdqLCkem`); a Storybook inventory covers the ten UI/UX dimensions below; each high-risk story has an event-driven interaction assertion and an accessibility result | - -## 9. Ordered completion sequence - -### Stage 0 — establish live ownership and exact evidence - -1. Re-fetch all open PRs, bases, heads, reviews, threads, checks and overlapping - paths. -2. Preserve unique scientific deltas; close or supersede duplicates only with an - explicit lineage record. -3. Do not widen a PR merely because another lane is waiting on Actions or review. -4. Resolve infrastructure failures at their root without weakening scientific, - security, coverage or independent-review gates. - -### Stage 1 — close the technical-GA numerical boundary - -1. Reconcile #951 and #1070 so one public backend/reference contract survives. -2. Retain the protected-main closure evidence for #626/#627 Rust ownership and - fail-closed behavior in the support matrix. -3. Define the first bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix under #621/#648. -4. Reject advertised-but-unimplemented model×estimator combinations before - fitting and remove normal-path `NotImplementedError` surfaces from the GA - profile. - -### Stage 2 — integrate scientific foundation and recovery - -1. Land longitudinal and multiple-membership work in dependency order while - preserving both exact scientific slices. -2. Integrate factor-retention/model-selection policy only with the required - relation, likelihood, scoreability, held-out and recovery evidence. -3. Complete durable exhaustive recovery studies with MCSE/intervals and explicit - failed-replication classes. -4. Add exploratory multidimensional loading estimation only after its - identification and rotation contracts are accepted. - -### Stage 3 — independent numerical validation - -Implement #1077 in bounded slices: - -1. capability and estimand inventory; -2. parameter-mapping schemas and neutral equation fixtures; -3. fixed-parameter equation conformance; -4. fitted-result alignment and comparisons; -5. scheduled/release evidence, disagreement register and accessible reports. - -External engines remain isolated test instruments, not runtime or package -dependencies. - -### Stage 4 — external validity and transportability - -Implement #1078 through one reusable validation-profile contract, then apply it -to a license-compliant synthetic/open/de-identified portfolio. Keep technical, -construct, transportability, fairness and decision-utility evidence separate. -A failed profile narrows the corresponding claim rather than failing unrelated -technical capabilities. - -### Stage 5 — one closed buyer workflow - -Choose one initial vertical—automated essay scoring, reference-free RAG -measurement, or enterprise issue measurement—and prove the complete handoff -through the owning downstream product. The first accepted vertical must include: - -- exact assessment/rubric/item/task/rater/model/source/version provenance; -- fallible human/automated rater calibration; -- recovery, scoreability, DIF/invariance and held-out validation; -- source-free accessible JSON/HTML with exact-value tables; -- human review/decision boundaries; and -- no claim that correlation, schema validity, model fit or one judge equals - construct validity. - -### Stage 6 — artifact, release and support hardening - -1. Freeze versioned public API/artifact schemas and explicit migrations. -2. Prove old supported serving/results artifacts load or fail with a documented, - stable migration status. -3. Run clean-install, upgrade, rollback and wheel-reinstall rehearsals. -4. Emit signed source/build provenance, SBOM, checksums, license/NOTICE and - reproducibility manifests. -5. Publish current support/security policy and capacity envelope. -6. Release only from an unchanged exact head with every required check and - review terminal-success. - -## 10. Buyer-visible acceptance gates - -### 10.1 Numerical and scientific - -- no silent Python production fallback; -- no model-name-only relation or compatibility inference; -- explicit identification and failure classification; -- realistic true-parameter recovery with bias, MAE/RMSE, coverage, convergence - and Monte Carlo uncertainty; -- CPU single-thread/multithread determinism and real GPU parity where enabled; -- independent cross-engine conformance or an explicit justified - `not_comparable` state; -- external/transportability evidence before making corresponding domain claims; -- no high-stakes claim from correlation, fit, schema conformance or recovery - alone. - -### 10.2 API, artifact and interoperability - -- semantic versioning and a bounded deprecation policy; -- canonical schema/version/fingerprint preimages and cross-language fixtures; -- strict RFC 8259 JSON with no NaN or infinity extension tokens; -- content-addressed immutable scientific and validation artifacts; -- explicit capability profiles and no environment-dependent partial bundles; -- backward-compatibility, migration, rollback and rejection tests; and -- source-text-free reusable numerical artifacts. - -### 10.3 Quality and security - -- production statement coverage 100%; -- production branch coverage 100%; -- public Rust/Python API docstrings 100%; -- property, metamorphic, fuzz, hostile-input and denial-of-service tests; -- exact runtime/platform/backend support matrix; -- dependency, OSV, SAST, CodeQL, Trivy, Scorecard, Strix, package and fuzz gates; -- no secret, PII, restricted test content or provider response in release or - billing telemetry; and -- current threat model, responsible disclosure and support policy. - -### 10.4 Release and supply chain - -- reproducible source/dependency/environment manifests; -- SPDX SBOM using a stable published specification; -- SLSA-compatible build provenance with pinned immutable actions/tools; -- source, wheel, report, model and validation artifact hashes; -- clean build/install/reinstall/upgrade/rollback rehearsal; -- license and redistribution review for datasets, external engines and models; -- release notes generated from authoritative fragments; and -- no draft standard or future revision represented as current certification. - -### 10.5 Buyer workflow and accessibility - -- one complete downstream workflow is replayable from evidence to result and - human decision; -- every number in charts is also available in an exact-value table; -- keyboard, screen-reader, no-JavaScript and print/PDF evidence where applicable; -- missing, abstained, failed, excluded, not-applicable and indeterminate remain - distinct; and -- reports expose limitations and next actions, not only a score or badge. - -### 10.6 UI/UX, Figma, and Storybook boundary - -The protected `fast-mlsirm` package has no web frontend or Storybook workspace; -it is a reusable numerical/core-contract library. A downstream product that -adds a web surface must own its UI implementation, design tokens, Storybook -inventory, and Figma file. This repository must not acquire a UI dependency or -pretend that a screenshot proves an interaction contract. - -The existing buyer-review design packet records Figma file ID -`qD34PfMH8Kr41tFdqLCkem` in -[`docs/figma_product_design_packet.md`](figma_product_design_packet.md). The ADR -binding that identity is protected-main truth as -[`docs/adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md`](adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md), -merged through [#1130](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1130). -A future Figma-backed change must keep the file ID in its ADR and keep -Code Connect disabled unless a separate architecture decision authorizes it. - -For a downstream Storybook, each story is both a named visual state and a -replayable test case. The story starts from explicit props/context, its -`play` function emits a realistic user event, and assertions inspect the -observable result (role, accessible name, text, focus, callback, URL, or -machine-readable value). Required scene/edge coverage is: - -| UI/UX dimension | Required scene and event evidence | -| --- | --- | -| Accessibility | keyboard-only focus order, accessible names/roles, screen-reader state, contrast, reduced-motion, and an automated WCAG 2.2 audit | -| Touch & Interaction | pointer, touch, keyboard, disabled, loading, cancellation, double-submit, and focus-restoration events | -| Performance | empty, representative, and upper-bound datasets with render/interaction budgets and no unbounded DOM growth | -| Style Selection | design-token default, dark/high-contrast, error/success, and token-regression snapshots | -| Layout & Responsive | narrow/wide viewport, zoom, long labels, overflow, RTL, and orientation changes | -| Typography & Color | long/localized text, font fallback, contrast, color-independent status, and numeric formatting | -| Animation | entrance, interruption, timeout, reduced-motion, and state-change completion without hiding content | -| Forms & Feedback | blank, invalid, server error, retry, async pending, success, and keyboard submit flows | -| Navigation Patterns | deep link, back/forward, unsaved state, modal escape, route failure, and restored focus/scroll | -| Charts & Data | no data, one point, dense data, outlier, tooltip keyboard access, exact-value table, and export/error states | - -This inventory is a downstream acceptance contract, not a claim that this -library currently ships a UI. Storybook's official interaction-testing model -uses stories plus `play` functions to simulate clicks, typing and submission -and assert the result; the corresponding evidence is linked in -[`docs/doctoring/ui-ux-storybook-evidence.md`](doctoring/ui-ux-storybook-evidence.md). - -## 11. Claim register - -| Claim | Minimum evidence | Current baseline disposition | Family scope / claim limitations | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| “The package implements the declared equation” | Rust unit/property tests plus #1077 fixed-parameter cross-engine/neutral-fixture conformance where comparable | PARTIAL | Declared model paths only; independent engine agreement is still incomplete. | -| “The estimator recovers parameters” | ADEMP simulation, alignment, bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence/MCSE | PARTIAL | Evidence exists for selected estimator families, not every advertised family or data regime. | -| “CPU and GPU are equivalent” | real non-skipped GPU execution against CPU `f64` reference under declared tolerances | PARTIAL | Only kernels with a real GPU execution and an explicit CPU reference are covered. | -| “This score measures the intended construct” | content, response-process, internal-structure and external-variable evidence for a named profile | OUT_OF_SCOPE | Requires a named downstream domain profile; it is not a universal package claim. | -| “The interpretation transports” | #1078 held-out site/language/time/rater/revision evidence | PLANNED | Transportability must be shown for the declared held-out units and time window. | -| “The use is fair” | lawful subgroup support, DIF/invariance, threshold/error and consequence evidence | PLANNED | Evidence is profile-specific and must include the supported subgroups and decision context. | -| “The product improves decisions” | preregistered policy/utility evaluation against baselines; causal language only with identified design | DOWNSTREAM | The owning host controls the policy, outcome, intervention and decision-utility evidence. | -| “The package is technical GA” | bounded support matrix plus all technical-GA gates in this document | PLANNED | The current package line is technical alpha until every declared GA gate is evidenced. | -| “The product is approved for high-stakes use” | validated profile plus downstream legal/privacy/security/human-governance controls | OUT_OF_SCOPE | High-stakes approval belongs to a validated downstream profile and its owning governance process. | - -## 12. Issues created from this review - -### [#1077 — independent cross-engine numerical conformance](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1077) - -This issue defined the self-consistency gap by requiring explicit -parameterization mappings, neutral fixed-parameter fixtures, aligned -fitted-result comparisons, a capability×engine matrix, license isolation and a -visible disagreement register. It closed as **COMPLETED** on 2026-08-24 after -the reusable source-free conformance provenance manifest landed -([#1082](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1082)); -execution-side validation evidence continues under the open validation family -([#1092](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1092), -[#1094](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1094), -[#1096](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1096), -[#1152](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1152)). -Mature external implementations are validation instruments only and never become production/build/package dependencies. - -### [#1078 — external validity and transportability profiles](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1078) - -This issue defines preregistered, purpose-bounded validation profiles that keep -technical, construct, transportability, fairness and decision-utility evidence -separate. It requires held-out site/language/time/rater/revision units, -criterion-quality limitations, explicit failed/indeterminate states and no raw -PII or restricted content in reusable artifacts. - -## 13. Documentation and PR maintenance rule - -This baseline should be refreshed only when a material product-completion -boundary changes. It must not become a manually maintained mirror of every -open PR. - -A refresh shall: - -1. pin the observed protected-main SHA and date; -2. query live PR/issue state rather than copying prior snapshots; -3. preserve the canonical maturity vocabulary; -4. classify active work as active only; -5. update links and gap ownership without rewriting canonical PRD/TRD/ADR - authority; -6. remove rows that are integrated, superseded or rejected; and -7. route any changed protected-main maturity to #621 or its accepted successor. - -The preferred long-term form is a generated/read-only view whose durable inputs -are the canonical documentation graph, protected-main capability registry, live -GitHub metadata, release evidence and validation manifests. - -## 14. Standards and research status - -Use published standards as normative references and drafts/revision projects as -watch items only. - -- The 2014 *Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing* is the current - published testing-standard baseline for validity, fairness and score-use - claims (American Educational Research Association et al., 2014). AERA, APA - and NCME revision work is a watch item until a new edition is published. -- ISO/IEC 25010:2023 is the current published product-quality model baseline for - software product quality characteristics and quality evaluation (International - Organization for Standardization & International Electrotechnical Commission, - 2023). -- The ITC 2018 test-adaptation guidelines govern translation/adaptation and - cross-language equivalence evidence; translation alone is not validation - (International Test Commission, 2018). -- RFC 8259 governs strict JSON interoperability and its grammar/encoding - boundary (The Internet Engineering Task Force, 2017). -- Semantic Versioning 2.0.0 is the public versioning baseline unless a more - specific package contract is accepted (Preston-Werner, 2013). -- NIST SP 800-218 SSDF 1.1 is the current final SSDF baseline; SSDF 1.2 remains - a draft watch item until finalized; the SSDF supplies secure-development - practices rather than a certification (National Institute of Standards and - Technology, 2022). -- SLSA 1.2 and SPDX 3.0.1 are stable published supply-chain/provenance and SBOM - baselines; SLSA addresses build provenance and SPDX addresses machine-readable - licensing/component interchange. Draft successors must not be presented as - current conformance (Software Package Data Exchange, 2024; Supply-chain - Levels for Software Artifacts, 2025). - -No standard reference in this file is a certification claim. - -Research traceability is maintained in the canonical -[`docs/traceability/research-basis.md`](traceability/research-basis.md) index -and the linked primary-source records under [`docs/papers/`](papers/README.md). -The references in this baseline explain the product decision boundary; they do -not replace the model-specific paper-first record required before changing a -formula, estimator, fit statistic, or interpretation-facing output. - -The package-literature entries below are included as implementation context, not -as substitutes for primary methodological validation: Chalmers (2012) describes -multidimensional IRT software and its estimation surface; Mair and Hatzinger -(2007) documents extended Rasch model tooling; Rizopoulos (2006) documents -latent-variable and IRT analysis tooling; Robitzsch et al. (2025) documents the -TAM test-analysis modules. Morris et al. (2019) provides the simulation-study -design rationale used by the recovery evidence requirement. Each source is -linked in the APA list below so a reviewer can reconstruct the decision without -access to chat history. - -## 15. APA 7th reference baseline - -American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, -& National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for -educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research -Association. https://www.testingstandards.net/open-access-files.html - -Chalmers, R. P. (2012). mirt: A multidimensional item response theory package -for the R environment. *Journal of Statistical Software, 48*(6), 1–29. -https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v048.i06 - -International Organization for Standardization & International Electrotechnical -Commission. (2023). *Systems and software engineering—Systems and software -quality requirements and evaluation (SQuaRE)—Product quality model* -(ISO/IEC 25010:2023). https://www.iso.org/standard/78176.html - -International Test Commission. (2018). ITC guidelines for translating and -adapting tests (Second edition). *International Journal of Testing, 18*(2), -101–134. https://doi.org/10.1080/15305058.2017.1398166 - -Mair, P., & Hatzinger, R. (2007). Extended Rasch modeling: The eRm package for -the application of IRT models in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(9), -1–20. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i09 - -Morris, T. P., White, I. R., & Crowther, M. J. (2019). Using simulation studies -to evaluate statistical methods. *Statistics in Medicine, 38*(11), 2074–2102. -https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.8086 - -National Institute of Standards and Technology. (2022). *Secure software -development framework (SSDF) version 1.1: Recommendations for mitigating the -risk of software vulnerabilities* (NIST SP 800-218). -https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.800-218 - -Preston-Werner, T. (2013). *Semantic Versioning 2.0.0*. -https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html - -Rizopoulos, D. (2006). ltm: An R package for latent variable modeling and item -response analysis. *Journal of Statistical Software, 17*(5), 1–25. -https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v017.i05 - -Robitzsch, A., Kiefer, T., & Wu, M. (2025). *TAM: Test analysis modules* -(R package version 4.4-2). https://doi.org/10.32614/CRAN.package.TAM - -Software Package Data Exchange. (2024). *SPDX specification 3.0.1*. -https://spdx.github.io/spdx-spec/v3.0.1/ - -Supply-chain Levels for Software Artifacts. (2025). *SLSA specification 1.2*. -https://slsa.dev/spec/v1.2/ - -The Internet Engineering Task Force. (2017). *The JavaScript Object Notation -(JSON) data interchange format* (RFC 8259). -https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8259 - -### Gap: Event Lineage channel weights still lack estimable independent outcomes - -LineageWeave ADR 0208 routes channel-weight arithmetic here, while TEPP PR #237 -publishes the accepted `tepp.lineage_criterion_anchor.v1` run-level decision. -That artifact does not contain pair-level independent criterion observations. -The legacy Python path's score-floor dichotomization and internally anchored -MLS2PLM therefore cannot be ported and presented as calibrated measurement. - -This change adds the Rust continuous-evidence and exact anchor-identity -prerequisite, with 100% line/function/branch coverage for its module. The -estimation result remains explicitly unavailable. Completion requires a TEPP -successor binding independent criterion posterior/outcomes to pair identities, -followed by an accepted estimator ADR, Rust CPU/GPU same-objective path, -true-parameter and known-weight recovery, uncertainty coverage, and protected -integration. Period-report calibration/aggregates remain a separate owner debt -and are not silently bundled into this contract. - -## 16. Change boundary for this baseline - -This document introduces no production code, numerical formula, public API, -dependency, workflow, database, package version, support promise, release, -certification or changelog entry. It records a point-in-time product-completion -analysis and routes work to existing or newly created issues. - -The document is complete when reviewers can determine: - -- what protected main actually ships; -- what active PRs may add but do not yet ship; -- which evidence blocks technical GA; -- which evidence blocks domain/high-stakes claims; -- what repository owns each remaining concern; and -- the next root-cause-changing action without relying on chat history. +Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory** +Protected-product basis: `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56` +Observation date: 2026-09-02 +Predecessor baseline artifact used for this refresh: branch head `3a3865f40da12211898c97cbd47e7460381736ae`, blob `0f514caa4f4c5cabbb8522c1da79475d854e030b` + +This document is a commercialization and technical-gap inventory, not runtime authority. Capability is authoritative only after the relevant source is integrated into the protected product branch and the required scientific, package, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence is green on one unchanged exact head. Open PRs, successful predecessor checks and draft documentation are evidence inputs, not released product claims. + +## 1. Product boundary + +`fast-mlsirm` is the canonical reusable psychometric numerical engine for LSIRM/MLSIRM/MLS2PLM and adjacent dependence/IRT families. Production likelihood, optimization, scoring, information/uncertainty, covariance/correlation, simulation/recovery and other result-affecting vector/linear/matrix arithmetic belongs in Rust/PyO3. Python is limited to validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity surfaces. + +The internal architecture is organized around the bounded contexts **Model Specification**, **Estimation**, **Scoring**, **Diagnostics**, **Simulation-Recovery**, **Compute Backend** and **Public Binding**. Cross-context dependencies should use explicit contracts instead of implementation imports. Temporal/event semantics and composition remain TEPP-owned; this repository may own reusable time-indexed psychometric numerical kernels over explicit supplied time/occasion carriers, but it does not own TEPP event ontology, clocks or temporal workflow semantics. + +Rasch and generic 1PL are not synonyms in product claims. New 2PL/3PL/4PL, bifactor, higher-order, two-tier, multifacet/multifactor, cross-loading, DIF, CAT/ATA and dependence-family support is promotable only when the exact formulation has primary-research grounding, identification constraints, deterministic public contract and true-parameter recovery evidence appropriate to the claimed use. + +## 2. Commercial merge and release gates + +A feature is commercially complete only when all applicable evidence is tied to the same unchanged current head: + +- deterministic focused and full tests, with no skip/xfail/source-rewriting or coverage-denominator tricks concealing a failing owned path; +- realistic simulation-recovery against known truth, reporting at least bias and RMSE and, when interval uncertainty is claimed, empirical coverage under a declared Monte Carlo design and deterministic seed manifest; +- CPU worker-count determinism and CPU/GPU parity for paths that advertise both backends; +- 100% owned production statement/branch coverage and 100% public rustdoc/docstring coverage under the repository contract; +- package/build/install evidence, including installed-wheel tests rather than source-tree import only; +- security/static-analysis/fuzz evidence, dependency integrity, SBOM and build provenance as required by the live protected policy; +- zero valid unresolved review findings and the qualifying independent approval required by the live ruleset; +- protected-branch merge without bypass, stale/predecessor evidence transfer or fabricated gate evidence. + +A release additionally requires one integrated protected head with recovery/package/install/reproducibility evidence, rollback instructions, version/changelog coherence, signed/attested distribution evidence where configured, publish success and post-publish verification. PR #1471 (`v0.9.2`) is therefore not current release authority while substantial post-cut product work remains unintegrated. + +## 3. Current protected-product gaps + +The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. + +| Gap | Current owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | +| TEPP temporal boundary | #1716 `f2dcf79b6e903c6a3edb5271ef1861bfcc4da3f8` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | +| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | #1717 `9500629c70ca8e5f5e0ed3ef246630534328d73e` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | +| Static covariance standardization owner contract | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `c4739d83bf747a699789b72502d7e380c0b0e302` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | +| Supply-chain release evidence | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | +| Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | +| Capability support matrix | #1710 `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | +| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | +| Interaction-map stack | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`, child #1457 `94699c5baa2b734ec38ef49d07f0576efd191883`, maintenance #1725 | Parent/child ancestry must be exact; Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. Stale child evidence must not be transferred. | +| Release cut | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | + +This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot make its own yet-to-be-created commit SHA immutable by embedding a symbolic value such as “this writer branch”. The immutable source identity for the observation being corrected here is the predecessor baseline artifact named at the top of this file (`3a3865f...` / blob `0f514c...`). The final commit that contains this document is obtained from Git history and is not self-declared inside its own payload. + +## 4. Point-in-time repository evidence + +A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh remained `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. + +The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain similarly requires explicit parent-forward reconciliation instead of parallel protected-main edits. + +Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and predecessor-head workflow states are all non-passing. They are also not a reason to mutate a clean source head merely to retrigger CI. Runner-less jobs (`runner_id=0`, no steps/checkout SHA) are control-plane evidence and should be advanced through the organization Actions owner path while independent repository lanes continue. + +## 5. Scientific evidence model + +Simulation/recovery is part of the production contract, not optional research decoration. Each claimed model/estimator should identify: + +1. exact data-generating formulation and identification constraints; +2. true parameters and the transformation/alignment used before error calculation; +3. sample-size, item/person/rater/facet/dependence conditions and missingness/design mechanism; +4. deterministic seed manifest and Monte Carlo replicate count; +5. convergence/failure accounting without dropping inconvenient replicates from the denominator; +6. bias and RMSE for relevant parameters, plus interval coverage and interval width when uncertainty is exposed; +7. CPU worker-count reproducibility and advertised CPU/GPU parity; +8. a declared practical acceptance envelope tied to the supported product claim rather than tuned after seeing the result. + +For latent spaces and loading structures, rotation/reflection/sign/permutation non-identifiability must be handled explicitly before recovery error is interpreted. For DIF, facets and mixed/multiple-membership extensions, recovery must match the exact formulation rather than borrowing validation from a related base model. CAT/ATA support additionally requires an explicit item-bank, information/selection/exposure/content-constraint contract and end-to-end recovery/operational simulation before a public support claim. + +## 6. Context Graph and Enterprise Architecture boundary + +`ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is a foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. The fast-mlsirm writer reads their live governance and integration state but does not write source or PR state in those repositories while the Context Fabric writer owns them. + +Architecture/lifecycle facts that may eventually be projected include released package/crate/API/service identity, backend/toolchain/provider/version, consuming CWL service dependency, lifecycle, risk, ownership, remediation and transformation. Projection must use an **immutable released** context-graph contract/profile with provenance. Open sibling PR heads are not production contract versions. + +Estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics and scientific-validity evidence stay in measurement/scientific evidence systems. They are not copied into Context Graph or EA as authoritative architecture facts. Cross-service SQL is prohibited; integration uses released contracts/APIs/events. + +At this refresh, context-graph-contracts and EA Core were still treated as unreleased read-only dependencies for fast-mlsirm integration purposes. Before any projection is implemented, refetch their current default/protected branches, releases, open stack ancestry, schema/profile/admission version and conformance evidence. Never infer `develop`/`main` transition or stack numbering from an older snapshot. + +## 7. Standards and research traceability + +The repository should distinguish a published standard from work in revision. The **2014 Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing** remain the published AERA/APA/NCME baseline used for validity, reliability/precision, fairness and intended-score-use evidence; AERA has an active Standards task force in 2026, so a future revision must not be cited as an already-published replacement until formally released. + +Supply-chain evidence should track the current approved standards actually used by workflows. As of this refresh, SLSA v1.2 is the approved current SLSA specification, including Build and Source tracks and provenance guidance. SPDX 3.0.1 is a current published SPDX specification; an implementation that emits another declared SPDX version must identify and validate that exact version rather than silently relabeling output. + +Representative primary/research sources that anchor existing or planned model contracts include: + +- American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. +- Driver, C. C., Oud, J. H. L., & Voelkle, M. C. (2017). Continuous time structural equation modeling with R package ctsem. *Journal of Statistical Software, 77*(5), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v077.i05 +- Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 +- Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 +- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Generalized mixed models for item response data with complex dependence structures. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 +- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 +- Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y + +A paper that motivates a family is not evidence that every generalized mixed/dependence combination is identified or recovered. Novel compositions remain research candidates until exact formulation-specific evidence exists. + +## 8. Product-gap priorities after current repair lanes + +Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific work should be selected from protected-main evidence rather than from roadmap wish lists. The durable priorities are: + +- close the generalized model-specification-to-estimator gap so the manifest can distinguish executable support from research candidates without family-specific branching; +- expand true-parameter recovery matrices for the supported dependence, mixed/multiple-membership, rater/facet and DIF formulations, including realistic uncertainty and failure accounting; +- finish deterministic CPU/GPU parity for every advertised accelerated kernel and expose backend capability/version evidence without changing estimator semantics; +- finish installed-wheel and release-provenance evidence from one exact integrated head, including SBOM and post-publish verification; +- keep public capability manifests, PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map/API docs, rustdoc/docstrings, security/operability and changelog synchronized with protected-main code rather than open-PR aspiration; +- publish integration facts to Context Graph/EA only after an immutable released contract/profile exists, and keep scientific result evidence outside EA authority. + +## 9. Change boundary + +This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. From f9b73e3d7329647663e75fc799fd0abc4d374b9c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 12:10:35 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 022/110] docs(gap): label active PR maturity explicitly --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 30 +++++++++++++------------- 1 file changed, 15 insertions(+), 15 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index c2fb5288d..6b54ab2b1 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -32,21 +32,21 @@ A release additionally requires one integrated protected head with recovery/pack ## 3. Current protected-product gaps -The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. - -| Gap | Current owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | -| --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | -| TEPP temporal boundary | #1716 `f2dcf79b6e903c6a3edb5271ef1861bfcc4da3f8` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | -| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | #1717 `9500629c70ca8e5f5e0ed3ef246630534328d73e` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | -| Static covariance standardization owner contract | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `c4739d83bf747a699789b72502d7e380c0b0e302` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | -| Supply-chain release evidence | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | -| Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | -| Capability support matrix | #1710 `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | -| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | -| Interaction-map stack | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`, child #1457 `94699c5baa2b734ec38ef49d07f0576efd191883`, maintenance #1725 | Parent/child ancestry must be exact; Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. Stale child evidence must not be transferred. | -| Release cut | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | +The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACTIVE PR` means the capability is represented only by an open, unmerged pull-request lane at this observation point; it is not protected-product or released authority. + +| Gap | Maturity | Current owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | +| TEPP temporal boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `f2dcf79b6e903c6a3edb5271ef1861bfcc4da3f8` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | +| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `9500629c70ca8e5f5e0ed3ef246630534328d73e` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | +| Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | +| Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | +| Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | +| Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | +| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | +| Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`, child #1457 `94699c5baa2b734ec38ef49d07f0576efd191883`, maintenance #1725 | Parent/child ancestry must be exact; Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. Stale child evidence must not be transferred. | +| Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot make its own yet-to-be-created commit SHA immutable by embedding a symbolic value such as “this writer branch”. The immutable source identity for the observation being corrected here is the predecessor baseline artifact named at the top of this file (`3a3865f...` / blob `0f514c...`). The final commit that contains this document is obtained from Git history and is not self-declared inside its own payload. From 56bafda8c517b1519917d86e2109e175689d04f1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 14:19:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 023/110] docs(product-gap): refresh live owner evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 10 +++++----- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 6b54ab2b1..70927fe5b 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -37,24 +37,24 @@ The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACT | Gap | Maturity | Current owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | -| TEPP temporal boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `f2dcf79b6e903c6a3edb5271ef1861bfcc4da3f8` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | -| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `9500629c70ca8e5f5e0ed3ef246630534328d73e` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | +| TEPP temporal boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6820ae775cbb415def348818ccaa60a7759073bb` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | +| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `896f7326cade3d5bf51e58d9dc81721868e062cb` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | | Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | | Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | | Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | -| Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`, child #1457 `94699c5baa2b734ec38ef49d07f0576efd191883`, maintenance #1725 | Parent/child ancestry must be exact; Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. Stale child evidence must not be transferred. | +| Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`, child #1457 `94699c5baa2b734ec38ef49d07f0576efd191883`, ancestry-only repair #1726 `36fb66af554968815ec4cce98281da4cedc3de06` (#1725 remains the conflicting predecessor route) | Parent/child ancestry must be exact; Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. #1726 must satisfy its own exact-head acceptance before its ancestry evidence can update the child; #1725 is superseded only after that purpose is actually fulfilled. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot make its own yet-to-be-created commit SHA immutable by embedding a symbolic value such as “this writer branch”. The immutable source identity for the observation being corrected here is the predecessor baseline artifact named at the top of this file (`3a3865f...` / blob `0f514c...`). The final commit that contains this document is obtained from Git history and is not self-declared inside its own payload. ## 4. Point-in-time repository evidence -A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh remained `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. +A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **50 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh remained `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. -The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain similarly requires explicit parent-forward reconciliation instead of parallel protected-main edits. +The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain similarly requires explicit parent-forward reconciliation instead of parallel protected-main edits; #1726 is the current tree-empty ancestry-only repair, while #1725 remains unmerged unless and until #1726 actually fulfills the reconciliation purpose. Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and predecessor-head workflow states are all non-passing. They are also not a reason to mutate a clean source head merely to retrigger CI. Runner-less jobs (`runner_id=0`, no steps/checkout SHA) are control-plane evidence and should be advanced through the organization Actions owner path while independent repository lanes continue. From f2645a4c65c121180e37cc3373c69616ab6cd046 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 16:16:08 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 024/110] docs(product-gap): refresh live measurement and stack evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 +++++--- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 70927fe5b..d47f2224b 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -41,20 +41,21 @@ The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACT | Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `896f7326cade3d5bf51e58d9dc81721868e062cb` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | | Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | ACTIVE PR | binary-response root #1712 `292ded5afad9fc991946f6113afa6bf9897b5dd8`; stacked dynamic-item Draft #1727 `6d5a7354b614d3829b77affc7c7baf1648844c2f` | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | | Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | | Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | -| Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`, child #1457 `94699c5baa2b734ec38ef49d07f0576efd191883`, ancestry-only repair #1726 `36fb66af554968815ec4cce98281da4cedc3de06` (#1725 remains the conflicting predecessor route) | Parent/child ancestry must be exact; Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. #1726 must satisfy its own exact-head acceptance before its ancestry evidence can update the child; #1725 is superseded only after that purpose is actually fulfilled. | +| Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`; child #1457 `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f`; ancestry repair #1726 `36fb66af554968815ec4cce98281da4cedc3de06` merged into the child | Parent/child ancestry is now exact: #1457 records #1417 as a parent and is ahead by only its intended explained-share delta. Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. #1725 is closed-as-merged/superseded because the #1726 two-parent ancestry repair incorporated the same parent purpose; neither maintenance PR is protected-main product authority. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot make its own yet-to-be-created commit SHA immutable by embedding a symbolic value such as “this writer branch”. The immutable source identity for the observation being corrected here is the predecessor baseline artifact named at the top of this file (`3a3865f...` / blob `0f514c...`). The final commit that contains this document is obtained from Git history and is not self-declared inside its own payload. ## 4. Point-in-time repository evidence -A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **50 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh remained `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. +A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh remained `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. -The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain similarly requires explicit parent-forward reconciliation instead of parallel protected-main edits; #1726 is the current tree-empty ancestry-only repair, while #1725 remains unmerged unless and until #1726 actually fulfills the reconciliation purpose. +The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain has now completed its ancestry-only reconciliation: #1726 merged a tree-empty two-parent record into the child, leaving #1457 at `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f` with exact parent ancestry. GitHub subsequently recognizes #1725 as merged/superseded because that parent purpose is already contained; it is not an additional source integration. The Measurement #1712/#1727 chain is likewise explicit: #1727 remains Draft on exact parent `292ded5afad9fc991946f6113afa6bf9897b5dd8` and must not race protected `main`. Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and predecessor-head workflow states are all non-passing. They are also not a reason to mutate a clean source head merely to retrigger CI. Runner-less jobs (`runner_id=0`, no steps/checkout SHA) are control-plane evidence and should be advanced through the organization Actions owner path while independent repository lanes continue. @@ -106,6 +107,7 @@ A paper that motivates a family is not evidence that every generalized mixed/dep Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific work should be selected from protected-main evidence rather than from roadmap wish lists. The durable priorities are: - close the generalized model-specification-to-estimator gap so the manifest can distinguish executable support from research candidates without family-specific branching; +- complete the Measurement response/item lifecycle so dynamic or generated item evidence can be frozen and compared without conflating adjudication, validation, calibration, anchoring or linking, then add Rust-owned eligibility/calibration/DIF/information/linking kernels only with recovery evidence; - expand true-parameter recovery matrices for the supported dependence, mixed/multiple-membership, rater/facet and DIF formulations, including realistic uncertainty and failure accounting; - finish deterministic CPU/GPU parity for every advertised accelerated kernel and expose backend capability/version evidence without changing estimator semantics; - finish installed-wheel and release-provenance evidence from one exact integrated head, including SBOM and post-publish verification; From f8ad503012dc82a9413ef43de09ce3ca33fd39e5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 19:35:08 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 025/110] docs(product-gap): refresh acquisition lane head --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d47f2224b..df0fe2f6d 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACT | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | | TEPP temporal boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6820ae775cbb415def348818ccaa60a7759073bb` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | -| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `896f7326cade3d5bf51e58d9dc81721868e062cb` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | +| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `b228d00b639332bd97dc16995210586443772b70` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | | Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | ACTIVE PR | binary-response root #1712 `292ded5afad9fc991946f6113afa6bf9897b5dd8`; stacked dynamic-item Draft #1727 `6d5a7354b614d3829b77affc7c7baf1648844c2f` | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | @@ -116,4 +116,4 @@ Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific wor ## 9. Change boundary -This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. +This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. \ No newline at end of file From 2f68308913c254af74b895f57867b354d06e9996 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 21:16:11 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 026/110] docs(product-gap): reconcile live protected measurement state --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 20 ++++++++++---------- 1 file changed, 10 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index df0fe2f6d..c393973d2 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory** -Protected-product basis: `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56` +Protected-product basis: `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c` Observation date: 2026-09-02 Predecessor baseline artifact used for this refresh: branch head `3a3865f40da12211898c97cbd47e7460381736ae`, blob `0f514caa4f4c5cabbb8522c1da79475d854e030b` @@ -32,7 +32,7 @@ A release additionally requires one integrated protected head with recovery/pack ## 3. Current protected-product gaps -The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACTIVE PR` means the capability is represented only by an open, unmerged pull-request lane at this observation point; it is not protected-product or released authority. +The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACTIVE PR` means the capability is represented only by an open, unmerged pull-request lane at this observation point; it is not protected-product or released authority. `PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT` means a prerequisite slice has landed on protected `main` while the remaining capability is still an open Draft and must earn its own exact-head evidence. | Gap | Maturity | Current owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | @@ -41,10 +41,10 @@ The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACT | Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `b228d00b639332bd97dc16995210586443772b70` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | | Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | ACTIVE PR | binary-response root #1712 `292ded5afad9fc991946f6113afa6bf9897b5dd8`; stacked dynamic-item Draft #1727 `6d5a7354b614d3829b77affc7c7baf1648844c2f` | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract #1712 merged into protected `main` as `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `9f7d31793bace47784faf73b2feae9ef7a0dd20e` now targets that protected tip | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | | Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | -| Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | +| Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `2372f44856d9955b6e390840ae75069a62e24841` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | | Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`; child #1457 `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f`; ancestry repair #1726 `36fb66af554968815ec4cce98281da4cedc3de06` merged into the child | Parent/child ancestry is now exact: #1457 records #1417 as a parent and is ahead by only its intended explained-share delta. Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. #1725 is closed-as-merged/superseded because the #1726 two-parent ancestry repair incorporated the same parent purpose; neither maintenance PR is protected-main product authority. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | @@ -53,9 +53,9 @@ This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot m ## 4. Point-in-time repository evidence -A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh remained `main@45627700c26c29bca150896a9519a9b7426acb56`. +A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh is now `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, where #1712 landed through the protected merge path. -The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain has now completed its ancestry-only reconciliation: #1726 merged a tree-empty two-parent record into the child, leaving #1457 at `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f` with exact parent ancestry. GitHub subsequently recognizes #1725 as merged/superseded because that parent purpose is already contained; it is not an additional source integration. The Measurement #1712/#1727 chain is likewise explicit: #1727 remains Draft on exact parent `292ded5afad9fc991946f6113afa6bf9897b5dd8` and must not race protected `main`. +The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain has now completed its ancestry-only reconciliation: #1726 merged a tree-empty two-parent record into the child, leaving #1457 at `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f` with exact parent ancestry. GitHub subsequently recognizes #1725 as merged/superseded because that parent purpose is already contained; it is not an additional source integration. The Measurement root #1712 is no longer an open stack prerequisite: it merged as protected `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Draft #1727 now bases on that exact protected tip and carries only the remaining dynamic-evaluation item/run contract work; its predecessor-head evidence remains non-transferable. Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and predecessor-head workflow states are all non-passing. They are also not a reason to mutate a clean source head merely to retrigger CI. Runner-less jobs (`runner_id=0`, no steps/checkout SHA) are control-plane evidence and should be advanced through the organization Actions owner path while independent repository lanes continue. @@ -82,13 +82,13 @@ Architecture/lifecycle facts that may eventually be projected include released p Estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics and scientific-validity evidence stay in measurement/scientific evidence systems. They are not copied into Context Graph or EA as authoritative architecture facts. Cross-service SQL is prohibited; integration uses released contracts/APIs/events. -At this refresh, context-graph-contracts and EA Core were still treated as unreleased read-only dependencies for fast-mlsirm integration purposes. Before any projection is implemented, refetch their current default/protected branches, releases, open stack ancestry, schema/profile/admission version and conformance evidence. Never infer `develop`/`main` transition or stack numbering from an older snapshot. +Fresh 2026-09-02 read-only inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both context-graph-contracts and EA Core, and both GitHub release lists are empty. Context Graph's live `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` remains protected while its open stack explicitly treats protected `main` migration and the first immutable source-bound contract release as prerequisites. EA's open Context Fabric consumer projection likewise remains fail closed on provisional/open CGC identities. fast-mlsirm therefore has no immutable released CGC/EA integration authority to pin yet; do not consume mutable sibling heads or infer the intended transition from older snapshots. ## 7. Standards and research traceability -The repository should distinguish a published standard from work in revision. The **2014 Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing** remain the published AERA/APA/NCME baseline used for validity, reliability/precision, fairness and intended-score-use evidence; AERA has an active Standards task force in 2026, so a future revision must not be cited as an already-published replacement until formally released. +The repository should distinguish a published standard from work in revision. The **2014 Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing** remain the published AERA/APA/NCME baseline used for validity, reliability/precision, fairness and intended-score-use evidence; AERA still lists an active Standards task force in 2026, so a future revision must not be cited as an already-published replacement until formally released. -Supply-chain evidence should track the current approved standards actually used by workflows. As of this refresh, SLSA v1.2 is the approved current SLSA specification, including Build and Source tracks and provenance guidance. SPDX 3.0.1 is a current published SPDX specification; an implementation that emits another declared SPDX version must identify and validate that exact version rather than silently relabeling output. +Supply-chain evidence should track the current approved standards actually used by workflows. SLSA v1.2 is the current approved SLSA specification, including the Source Track alongside the Build Track. SPDX 3.0.1 remains a published stable 3.x specification surface while SPDX 3.1 is still release-candidate material; an implementation must identify and validate the exact SPDX version it emits rather than silently relabeling output. Representative primary/research sources that anchor existing or planned model contracts include: @@ -116,4 +116,4 @@ Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific wor ## 9. Change boundary -This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. From 6506c3d4cfcf7d51434bc9efa3267a68ef61f81c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 21:40:07 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 027/110] docs(product-gap): refresh dynamic evaluation exact head --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index c393973d2..04b25c023 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@ The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACT | Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `b228d00b639332bd97dc16995210586443772b70` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | | Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract #1712 merged into protected `main` as `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `9f7d31793bace47784faf73b2feae9ef7a0dd20e` now targets that protected tip | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract #1712 merged into protected `main` as `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` now targets that protected tip after an ancestry-only two-parent reconciliation | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | | Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | | Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `2372f44856d9955b6e390840ae75069a62e24841` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | @@ -55,7 +55,7 @@ This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot m A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh is now `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, where #1712 landed through the protected merge path. -The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain has now completed its ancestry-only reconciliation: #1726 merged a tree-empty two-parent record into the child, leaving #1457 at `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f` with exact parent ancestry. GitHub subsequently recognizes #1725 as merged/superseded because that parent purpose is already contained; it is not an additional source integration. The Measurement root #1712 is no longer an open stack prerequisite: it merged as protected `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Draft #1727 now bases on that exact protected tip and carries only the remaining dynamic-evaluation item/run contract work; its predecessor-head evidence remains non-transferable. +The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain has now completed its ancestry-only reconciliation: #1726 merged a tree-empty two-parent record into the child, leaving #1457 at `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f` with exact parent ancestry. GitHub subsequently recognizes #1725 as merged/superseded because that parent purpose is already contained; it is not an additional source integration. The Measurement root #1712 is no longer an open stack prerequisite: it merged as protected `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Draft #1727 now bases on that exact protected tip; current head `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` is a tree-identical ancestry-only reconciliation of predecessor `9f7d31793bace47784faf73b2feae9ef7a0dd20e` with protected main, so predecessor checks/reviews remain non-transferable despite unchanged feature bytes. Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and predecessor-head workflow states are all non-passing. They are also not a reason to mutate a clean source head merely to retrigger CI. Runner-less jobs (`runner_id=0`, no steps/checkout SHA) are control-plane evidence and should be advanced through the organization Actions owner path while independent repository lanes continue. @@ -116,4 +116,4 @@ Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific wor ## 9. Change boundary -This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. +This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. \ No newline at end of file From 7c81a1f983cdf11d1915dbdef7392a4630547d00 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 23:18:00 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 028/110] docs(product-gap): record exact-head control-plane repair evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 16 ++++++++++++++-- 1 file changed, 14 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 04b25c023..874d7bd3c 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACT | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | | TEPP temporal boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6820ae775cbb415def348818ccaa60a7759073bb` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | | Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `b228d00b639332bd97dc16995210586443772b70` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | -| Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `e1847c07fd7ef8331dcebd0dd588b1381cc1231d` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | +| Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract #1712 merged into protected `main` as `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` now targets that protected tip after an ancestry-only two-parent reconciliation | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | @@ -116,4 +116,16 @@ Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific wor ## 9. Change boundary -This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. + +## 10. Exact-head commercialization control-plane refresh — 2026-09-02 + +Fresh live evidence for this writer still observes protected `ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm` `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, **49 open pull requests**, and **196 open issues**. Central `ContextualWisdomLab/.github` protected `main@78271917b526469c559fa75cb5ee39426e5494d1` has already integrated the scheduler stale-head cancellation repair (#1669), the obsolete hourly repair-workflow cleanup (#1673), and the Noema deleted/base-side evidence repair (#1564); #1567 is not an independent remaining prerequisite because its valid hollow-CodeGraph cleanup delta was absorbed into #1564. + +The current static covariance owner lane is `ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm#1722@338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3`, mergeable against the protected product tip with exactly four changed files in the Rust owner-contract slice. Its substantive numerical review findings are resolved in source/test history, but landing evidence remains incomplete: no qualifying independent approval is present, required `noema-review` is still queued, and the exact-head required CodeQL workflow has produced a `startup_failure` before any job materialized. This is control-plane admission evidence, not a reason to weaken or churn the Rust leaf implementation. + +The causal owner lane is `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1150`. The existing single writer was extended without force-push. Commit `9a187a088a1ae78b95c2eefa522fdbfe6ec38f1a` adds `ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm` to the explicit bounded read-only Actions queue-health allowlist and updates the corresponding contract test so the owner-plane collector observes the same queued, zero-job `startup_failure`, and cancelled-before-runner states affecting the product lane. A newly materialized review then found that the post-evidence pull-request identity read did not receive the same bounded transient-incompleteness retry as earlier identity reads. RED `5031e0bcb498add8d5833e7ebc0f8400a1835e4f` adds transient-recovery and persistent-failure regressions; GREEN `36639d090fd24c894e06fe39d01bac2dcfa0c4a4` retries that post-evidence identity read once and still fails closed if the retry remains incomplete or invalid. Fresh exact-head protected Checks for this owner lane are non-transferable and must complete on the unchanged GREEN head before merge. + +Central Noema repair lane `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1672@db13a2df02709a20c25e98dce215e5561ee1b53d` remains mergeable and all currently observed review threads were resolved after current-source verification. Its implementation removes the unsupported repository-owned 900-second model-repair deadline and duplicate caller-side model request, fixes Actions model traffic to `orchestrator/free`, keeps deterministic local validation/fail-closed semantics, and leaves provider discovery/structured-output repair/failover/upstream completion with `contextual-orchestrator`. Exact-head required evidence is still non-terminal; predecessor results do not transfer. + +Buyer-visible effect: the Rust covariance contract itself is no longer the highest-risk blocker in this slice. Organization Actions admission and central review evidence freshness currently dominate release predictability. The owner repair therefore remains a control-plane observability/correctness lane, while fast-mlsirm keeps the mathematical kernel unchanged until exact-head evidence proves a leaf defect. No bypass, self-approval, stale-evidence promotion, source-copy workaround, mutable sibling-head consumption, or release claim is recorded by this refresh. \ No newline at end of file From c82b0c0da2afbd32810b86e3489d2f0e7276d1af Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 23:40:46 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 029/110] docs(product-gap): refresh exact heads and control-plane state --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 137 +++++++++---------------- 1 file changed, 50 insertions(+), 87 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 874d7bd3c..b434cbe5a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -2,95 +2,62 @@ Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory** Protected-product basis: `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c` -Observation date: 2026-09-02 -Predecessor baseline artifact used for this refresh: branch head `3a3865f40da12211898c97cbd47e7460381736ae`, blob `0f514caa4f4c5cabbb8522c1da79475d854e030b` +Observation date: 2026-09-02 -This document is a commercialization and technical-gap inventory, not runtime authority. Capability is authoritative only after the relevant source is integrated into the protected product branch and the required scientific, package, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence is green on one unchanged exact head. Open PRs, successful predecessor checks and draft documentation are evidence inputs, not released product claims. +This file is a commercialization and technical-gap inventory, not runtime authority. A capability is authoritative only after its source is integrated into protected `main` and the applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence is terminal success on one unchanged exact head. Open PRs, Drafts, successful predecessor checks and mutable sibling branches are evidence inputs, not product claims. -## 1. Product boundary +## 1. Product and ownership boundary -`fast-mlsirm` is the canonical reusable psychometric numerical engine for LSIRM/MLSIRM/MLS2PLM and adjacent dependence/IRT families. Production likelihood, optimization, scoring, information/uncertainty, covariance/correlation, simulation/recovery and other result-affecting vector/linear/matrix arithmetic belongs in Rust/PyO3. Python is limited to validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity surfaces. +`fast-mlsirm` is the canonical reusable psychometric numerical engine for LSIRM/MLSIRM/MLS2PLM and adjacent dependence/IRT families. Production likelihood, optimization, scoring, information/uncertainty, covariance/correlation, simulation/recovery and other result-affecting vector/linear/matrix arithmetic belong in Rust/PyO3. Python is limited to validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity surfaces that do not become a second numerical implementation. -The internal architecture is organized around the bounded contexts **Model Specification**, **Estimation**, **Scoring**, **Diagnostics**, **Simulation-Recovery**, **Compute Backend** and **Public Binding**. Cross-context dependencies should use explicit contracts instead of implementation imports. Temporal/event semantics and composition remain TEPP-owned; this repository may own reusable time-indexed psychometric numerical kernels over explicit supplied time/occasion carriers, but it does not own TEPP event ontology, clocks or temporal workflow semantics. +The internal DDD boundary is **Model Specification**, **Estimation**, **Scoring**, **Diagnostics**, **Simulation-Recovery**, **Compute Backend** and **Public Binding**. Cross-context interaction uses explicit contracts rather than implementation imports. TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition; fast-mlsirm may own reusable time-indexed psychometric kernels over explicit supplied occasion/time carriers but does not own TEPP clocks, event ontology or temporal workflow semantics. `contextual-orchestrator` owns LLM/provider routing. Scientific/domain truth stays with its canonical owner; cross-service SQL and source copying are prohibited. -Rasch and generic 1PL are not synonyms in product claims. New 2PL/3PL/4PL, bifactor, higher-order, two-tier, multifacet/multifactor, cross-loading, DIF, CAT/ATA and dependence-family support is promotable only when the exact formulation has primary-research grounding, identification constraints, deterministic public contract and true-parameter recovery evidence appropriate to the claimed use. +Rasch and generic 1PL are not synonyms in product claims. 2PL/3PL/4PL, bifactor, higher-order, two-tier, multifacet/multifactor, cross-loading, DIF, CAT/ATA and generalized dependence support are promotable only for an exact formulation with primary research grounding, identification constraints, deterministic public contract and formulation-specific recovery evidence. ## 2. Commercial merge and release gates -A feature is commercially complete only when all applicable evidence is tied to the same unchanged current head: +A change is commercially merge-ready only when all applicable evidence refers to the same unchanged exact head: -- deterministic focused and full tests, with no skip/xfail/source-rewriting or coverage-denominator tricks concealing a failing owned path; -- realistic simulation-recovery against known truth, reporting at least bias and RMSE and, when interval uncertainty is claimed, empirical coverage under a declared Monte Carlo design and deterministic seed manifest; -- CPU worker-count determinism and CPU/GPU parity for paths that advertise both backends; +- deterministic focused and full tests, without skip/xfail/source rewriting or coverage-denominator tricks hiding a failing owned path; +- realistic known-truth simulation/recovery with deterministic seed manifests, convergence/failure accounting, bias and RMSE, and empirical interval coverage when uncertainty is claimed; +- CPU worker-count determinism and CPU/GPU parity for every path that advertises both backends; - 100% owned production statement/branch coverage and 100% public rustdoc/docstring coverage under the repository contract; -- package/build/install evidence, including installed-wheel tests rather than source-tree import only; -- security/static-analysis/fuzz evidence, dependency integrity, SBOM and build provenance as required by the live protected policy; -- zero valid unresolved review findings and the qualifying independent approval required by the live ruleset; -- protected-branch merge without bypass, stale/predecessor evidence transfer or fabricated gate evidence. +- package/build/install evidence, including installed-wheel execution rather than source-tree import only; +- security/static-analysis/fuzz/dependency evidence plus required SBOM/provenance evidence; +- zero valid unresolved review findings and the qualifying approval required by the live ruleset; +- normal protected merge without self-approval, bypass, gate weakening, force update or predecessor-evidence transfer. -A release additionally requires one integrated protected head with recovery/package/install/reproducibility evidence, rollback instructions, version/changelog coherence, signed/attested distribution evidence where configured, publish success and post-publish verification. PR #1471 (`v0.9.2`) is therefore not current release authority while substantial post-cut product work remains unintegrated. +Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and `startup_failure` states are non-passing but are not reasons to churn a clean source head. A release additionally requires one exact integrated protected head with recovery, package/install, reproducibility and rollback evidence; coherent version/CHANGELOG/tag state; immutable distribution/SBOM/provenance evidence; publish success; and post-publish verification. -## 3. Current protected-product gaps +The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR #1471 proposes `v0.9.2`, but it is not release authority while upstream product, dependency and supply-chain lanes remain open. -The highest-leverage gaps are listed by product risk rather than by PR age. `ACTIVE PR` means the capability is represented only by an open, unmerged pull-request lane at this observation point; it is not protected-product or released authority. `PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT` means a prerequisite slice has landed on protected `main` while the remaining capability is still an open Draft and must earn its own exact-head evidence. +## 3. Current high-leverage product gaps -| Gap | Maturity | Current owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `6abdcc2acab7be463977e35191566119e384c906` | Exact supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; no silent local-independence substitution; formulation-specific identification, Rust estimator and recovery before promotion. | -| TEPP temporal boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6820ae775cbb415def348818ccaa60a7759073bb` | Context Map/ADR/PRD/TRD agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while fast-mlsirm owns reusable numerical kernels only; no unversioned runtime coupling. | -| Buyer/acquisition execution and CI runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `b228d00b639332bd97dc16995210586443772b70` | Generic acquisition workflow remains price-neutral; exact-head hosted checks complete; no repository source claim is inferred from organization runner backlog. | -| Static covariance standardization owner contract | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released contract exists. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE PR | canonical writer #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; stacked explicit-control child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; require caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha` rather than universal heuristic defaults; reconcile and validate the stack before the sole main-facing Mokken writer advances. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract #1712 merged into protected `main` as `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` now targets that protected tip after an ancestry-only two-parent reconciliation | Keep observed values separate from missing/adjudication state; freeze concrete dynamic items under immutable blueprint/content/provenance evidence; require validated anchors plus linking evidence for cross-version comparability. These contracts do not themselves claim calibration, DIF, information, CAT/ATA selection or linking arithmetic; those numerical claims remain Rust-owned and require formulation-specific recovery. | -| Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `401a23765cc7e9686927f32f5a4ad268ff1b26af` | SBOM and provenance generated from the exact reviewed source/distributions; irreversible release/PyPI sinks depend on required evidence without putting SBOM files in the package-upload set. | -| Internal Rust crate distribution boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `8e6c30912685bc5d8991351ca4dea426d2386bdf` at the most recent inspected lane state | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal/non-publishable Cargo packages unless a separately governed Rust SDK product is approved; PyPI/Maturin remains the external package product. | -| Capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `2372f44856d9955b6e390840ae75069a62e24841` | Versioned machine-readable exact artifact must match the real public `FitConfig`/production-estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | -| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `2b5f406c08dd2f807d71ccdf9697857636067b87` | Deterministic known-truth recovery, classification/membership invariants, CPU-worker parity and explicit limits; no claim of longitudinal/event semantics. | -| Interaction-map stack | ACTIVE PR | #1417 `25b9f9908a2d60782412900e932ba50000760448`; child #1457 `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f`; ancestry repair #1726 `36fb66af554968815ec4cce98281da4cedc3de06` merged into the child | Parent/child ancestry is now exact: #1457 records #1417 as a parent and is ahead by only its intended explained-share delta. Rust remains sole owner of reconstruction/explained-share arithmetic and input/result provenance. #1725 is closed-as-merged/superseded because the #1726 two-parent ancestry repair incorporated the same parent purpose; neither maintenance PR is protected-main product authority. | -| Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream dependency/distribution/supply-chain decisions and integrated scientific work settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected head. | - -This table deliberately omits the current #1519 branch head. A document cannot make its own yet-to-be-created commit SHA immutable by embedding a symbolic value such as “this writer branch”. The immutable source identity for the observation being corrected here is the predecessor baseline artifact named at the top of this file (`3a3865f...` / blob `0f514c...`). The final commit that contains this document is obtained from Git history and is not self-declared inside its own payload. - -## 4. Point-in-time repository evidence - -A GitHub search performed for this 2026-09-02 refresh recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. These counts are an observation, not a live invariant and must be re-fetched before any later merge/release decision. The protected product base observed for this refresh is now `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, where #1712 landed through the protected merge path. - -The repository is intentionally carrying many single-writer feature lanes. A large open count is therefore not itself evidence of product failure, but overlapping direct-to-main writers of the same bounded context are a concrete integration risk. The Mokken #1506/#1724 collision is the current example: #1724 has been stacked onto the exact #1506 parent rather than left as a competing main writer. The interaction-map #1417/#1457 chain has now completed its ancestry-only reconciliation: #1726 merged a tree-empty two-parent record into the child, leaving #1457 at `44e445145c324c18fe0bab16f7e455fdd6f6692f` with exact parent ancestry. GitHub subsequently recognizes #1725 as merged/superseded because that parent purpose is already contained; it is not an additional source integration. The Measurement root #1712 is no longer an open stack prerequisite: it merged as protected `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Draft #1727 now bases on that exact protected tip; current head `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` is a tree-identical ancestry-only reconciliation of predecessor `9f7d31793bace47784faf73b2feae9ef7a0dd20e` with protected main, so predecessor checks/reviews remain non-transferable despite unchanged feature bytes. - -Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and predecessor-head workflow states are all non-passing. They are also not a reason to mutate a clean source head merely to retrigger CI. Runner-less jobs (`runner_id=0`, no steps/checkout SHA) are control-plane evidence and should be advanced through the organization Actions owner path while independent repository lanes continue. - -## 5. Scientific evidence model - -Simulation/recovery is part of the production contract, not optional research decoration. Each claimed model/estimator should identify: +`ACTIVE PR` means open/unmerged evidence, not protected-product authority. `PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT` means a prerequisite slice has landed but the remaining capability still requires its own exact-head acceptance. -1. exact data-generating formulation and identification constraints; -2. true parameters and the transformation/alignment used before error calculation; -3. sample-size, item/person/rater/facet/dependence conditions and missingness/design mechanism; -4. deterministic seed manifest and Monte Carlo replicate count; -5. convergence/failure accounting without dropping inconvenient replicates from the denominator; -6. bias and RMSE for relevant parameters, plus interval coverage and interval width when uncertainty is exposed; -7. CPU worker-count reproducibility and advertised CPU/GPU parity; -8. a declared practical acceptance envelope tied to the supported product claim rather than tuned after seeing the result. - -For latent spaces and loading structures, rotation/reflection/sign/permutation non-identifiability must be handled explicitly before recovery error is interpreted. For DIF, facets and mixed/multiple-membership extensions, recovery must match the exact formulation rather than borrowing validation from a related base model. CAT/ATA support additionally requires an explicit item-bank, information/selection/exposure/content-constraint contract and end-to-end recovery/operational simulation before a public support claim. - -## 6. Context Graph and Enterprise Architecture boundary - -`ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is a foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. The fast-mlsirm writer reads their live governance and integration state but does not write source or PR state in those repositories while the Context Fabric writer owns them. - -Architecture/lifecycle facts that may eventually be projected include released package/crate/API/service identity, backend/toolchain/provider/version, consuming CWL service dependency, lifecycle, risk, ownership, remediation and transformation. Projection must use an **immutable released** context-graph contract/profile with provenance. Open sibling PR heads are not production contract versions. - -Estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics and scientific-validity evidence stay in measurement/scientific evidence systems. They are not copied into Context Graph or EA as authoritative architecture facts. Cross-service SQL is prohibited; integration uses released contracts/APIs/events. +| Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | +| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | +| Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The 2026-09-02 non-force two-parent reconciliation now contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | +| Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` at the last verified stack snapshot | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; freeze concrete item identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state contract alone. | +| Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | +| Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | +| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | +| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | +| Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | -Fresh 2026-09-02 read-only inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both context-graph-contracts and EA Core, and both GitHub release lists are empty. Context Graph's live `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` remains protected while its open stack explicitly treats protected `main` migration and the first immutable source-bound contract release as prerequisites. EA's open Context Fabric consumer projection likewise remains fail closed on provisional/open CGC identities. fast-mlsirm therefore has no immutable released CGC/EA integration authority to pin yet; do not consume mutable sibling heads or infer the intended transition from older snapshots. +Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. -## 7. Standards and research traceability +## 4. Scientific acceptance model -The repository should distinguish a published standard from work in revision. The **2014 Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing** remain the published AERA/APA/NCME baseline used for validity, reliability/precision, fairness and intended-score-use evidence; AERA still lists an active Standards task force in 2026, so a future revision must not be cited as an already-published replacement until formally released. +Every claimed estimator/model must identify the exact data-generating formulation and identification constraints, true parameters and any alignment/rotation/sign/permutation transform, sample/design/dependence/missingness conditions, deterministic seed manifest and Monte Carlo replicate count, convergence and failed-replicate denominator, and prespecified acceptance thresholds. Bias and RMSE are mandatory for relevant recovered parameters; interval coverage and width are mandatory when uncertainty is exposed. Latent-space and loading recovery must explicitly handle non-identifiability before error is interpreted. DIF, rater/facet and mixed/multiple-membership extensions require evidence for the exact formulation rather than borrowed validation from a neighboring model. -Supply-chain evidence should track the current approved standards actually used by workflows. SLSA v1.2 is the current approved SLSA specification, including the Source Track alongside the Build Track. SPDX 3.0.1 remains a published stable 3.x specification surface while SPDX 3.1 is still release-candidate material; an implementation must identify and validate the exact SPDX version it emits rather than silently relabeling output. +CAT/ATA requires an explicit item-bank, information/selection, exposure/content-constraint and operational simulation contract before a public support claim. Synthetic fixtures alone are unit-test evidence, not commercial scientific validation. -Representative primary/research sources that anchor existing or planned model contracts include: +Primary/research anchors include: - American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. - Driver, C. C., Oud, J. H. L., & Voelkle, M. C. (2017). Continuous time structural equation modeling with R package ctsem. *Journal of Statistical Software, 77*(5), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v077.i05 @@ -100,32 +67,28 @@ Representative primary/research sources that anchor existing or planned model co - van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 - Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y -A paper that motivates a family is not evidence that every generalized mixed/dependence combination is identified or recovered. Novel compositions remain research candidates until exact formulation-specific evidence exists. +A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × dependence composition. Novel combinations remain research candidates until the exact formulation is identified and recovered. + +## 5. Context Graph and EA boundary — read only -## 8. Product-gap priorities after current repair lanes +`ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. -Once the active repair/stack lanes are integrated, the next buyer/scientific work should be selected from protected-main evidence rather than from roadmap wish lists. The durable priorities are: +Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed protected development tips while their active governance paths intend a protected-`main` integration/default transition. Do not infer that transition from memory; `.github#1137` remains the administrative owner path and the live branch/ruleset state must be re-read each run. -- close the generalized model-specification-to-estimator gap so the manifest can distinguish executable support from research candidates without family-specific branching; -- complete the Measurement response/item lifecycle so dynamic or generated item evidence can be frozen and compared without conflating adjudication, validation, calibration, anchoring or linking, then add Rust-owned eligibility/calibration/DIF/information/linking kernels only with recovery evidence; -- expand true-parameter recovery matrices for the supported dependence, mixed/multiple-membership, rater/facet and DIF formulations, including realistic uncertainty and failure accounting; -- finish deterministic CPU/GPU parity for every advertised accelerated kernel and expose backend capability/version evidence without changing estimator semantics; -- finish installed-wheel and release-provenance evidence from one exact integrated head, including SBOM and post-publish verification; -- keep public capability manifests, PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map/API docs, rustdoc/docstrings, security/operability and changelog synchronized with protected-main code rather than open-PR aspiration; -- publish integration facts to Context Graph/EA only after an immutable released contract/profile exists, and keep scientific result evidence outside EA authority. +Context Graph currently has **14 open PRs and 2 open issues**. High-priority issue #24 keeps source-bound immutable release evidence open; Draft #25 is the owner repair. EA Core currently has **24 open PRs and 2 open issues**; its Context Fabric consumer work remains fail closed on provisional CGC identity. Both GitHub release lists are empty. Therefore fast-mlsirm has no immutable released CGC contract/profile to pin yet. -## 9. Change boundary +Architecture/lifecycle facts that may later be projected include released package/crate/API/service identity, backend/toolchain/provider/version, consuming CWL dependency, lifecycle, risk, ownership, remediation and transformation. Projection must use a released versioned Context Assertion/CloudEvent/conformance contract with provenance. Estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics and scientific-validity evidence remain scientific evidence and must not be copied into EA authoritative architecture truth. -This baseline records gaps and acceptance contracts. It must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every future refresh must pin the protected base and immutable input artifacts it actually observed, mark volatile PR/issue/check counts as point-in-time observations, and avoid self-referential identities that cannot exist until after the document commit is created. +## 6. Exact-head Actions/control-plane state -## 10. Exact-head commercialization control-plane refresh — 2026-09-02 +The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-ready fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. On #1722 exact `338dbb...`, organization-required CodeQL PR terminated `startup_failure` before job materialization while CI/security/Scorecard/CodeQL/fuzz/Semgrep/OSV lanes remained non-terminal; substantive numerical review threads are resolved, but no qualifying approval exists. #1729 exact `7faa16037a3e8697e640bfbac780709ee5297d1f` independently reproduced both control-plane classes: required CodeQL PR `startup_failure` with zero jobs, and sibling jobs materialized with `runner_id=0`, no steps and no checkout. -Fresh live evidence for this writer still observes protected `ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm` `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, **49 open pull requests**, and **196 open issues**. Central `ContextualWisdomLab/.github` protected `main@78271917b526469c559fa75cb5ee39426e5494d1` has already integrated the scheduler stale-head cancellation repair (#1669), the obsolete hourly repair-workflow cleanup (#1673), and the Noema deleted/base-side evidence repair (#1564); #1567 is not an independent remaining prerequisite because its valid hollow-CodeGraph cleanup delta was absorbed into #1564. +The canonical owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` advanced during this observation from `78271917b526469c559fa75cb5ee39426e5494d1` to `a28fc2f4e185df7847e2f2f5f6ec561d1e84805d` when the Noema single-request/deadline repair integrated. Consequently #1150 exact `36639d090fd24c894e06fe39d01bac2dcfa0c4a4` is now `behind_by=1` and diverged from live main with merge base `78271917...`; its predecessor checks/reviews cannot be promoted. The owner path was handed fresh exact evidence and acceptance criteria to adopt the intervening protected-main commit non-destructively and regenerate exact-head evidence. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates or no-op source churn. -The current static covariance owner lane is `ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm#1722@338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3`, mergeable against the protected product tip with exactly four changed files in the Rust owner-contract slice. Its substantive numerical review findings are resolved in source/test history, but landing evidence remains incomplete: no qualifying independent approval is present, required `noema-review` is still queued, and the exact-head required CodeQL workflow has produced a `startup_failure` before any job materialized. This is control-plane admission evidence, not a reason to weaken or churn the Rust leaf implementation. +The merged Noema repair removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. This is now protected central owner evidence rather than an open prerequisite. -The causal owner lane is `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1150`. The existing single writer was extended without force-push. Commit `9a187a088a1ae78b95c2eefa522fdbfe6ec38f1a` adds `ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm` to the explicit bounded read-only Actions queue-health allowlist and updates the corresponding contract test so the owner-plane collector observes the same queued, zero-job `startup_failure`, and cancelled-before-runner states affecting the product lane. A newly materialized review then found that the post-evidence pull-request identity read did not receive the same bounded transient-incompleteness retry as earlier identity reads. RED `5031e0bcb498add8d5833e7ebc0f8400a1835e4f` adds transient-recovery and persistent-failure regressions; GREEN `36639d090fd24c894e06fe39d01bac2dcfa0c4a4` retries that post-evidence identity read once and still fails closed if the retry remains incomplete or invalid. Fresh exact-head protected Checks for this owner lane are non-transferable and must complete on the unchanged GREEN head before merge. +## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities -Central Noema repair lane `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1672@db13a2df02709a20c25e98dce215e5561ee1b53d` remains mergeable and all currently observed review threads were resolved after current-source verification. Its implementation removes the unsupported repository-owned 900-second model-repair deadline and duplicate caller-side model request, fixes Actions model traffic to `orchestrator/free`, keeps deterministic local validation/fail-closed semantics, and leaves provider discovery/structured-output repair/failover/upstream completion with `contextual-orchestrator`. Exact-head required evidence is still non-terminal; predecessor results do not transfer. +After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -Buyer-visible effect: the Rust covariance contract itself is no longer the highest-risk blocker in this slice. Organization Actions admission and central review evidence freshness currently dominate release predictability. The owner repair therefore remains a control-plane observability/correctness lane, while fast-mlsirm keeps the mathematical kernel unchanged until exact-head evidence proves a leaf defect. No bypass, self-approval, stale-evidence promotion, source-copy workaround, mutable sibling-head consumption, or release claim is recorded by this refresh. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 0b25379b5e637e7b6ff0c7963a3ecf8c9cb6be89 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 23:45:09 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 030/110] docs(product-gap): record completed owner-path restack --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index b434cbe5a..0113c1315 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | -| Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The 2026-09-02 non-force two-parent reconciliation now contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | +| Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The 2026-09-02 non-force two-parent reconciliation contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` at the last verified stack snapshot | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; freeze concrete item identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state contract alone. | @@ -83,12 +83,12 @@ Architecture/lifecycle facts that may later be projected include released packag The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-ready fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. On #1722 exact `338dbb...`, organization-required CodeQL PR terminated `startup_failure` before job materialization while CI/security/Scorecard/CodeQL/fuzz/Semgrep/OSV lanes remained non-terminal; substantive numerical review threads are resolved, but no qualifying approval exists. #1729 exact `7faa16037a3e8697e640bfbac780709ee5297d1f` independently reproduced both control-plane classes: required CodeQL PR `startup_failure` with zero jobs, and sibling jobs materialized with `runner_id=0`, no steps and no checkout. -The canonical owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` advanced during this observation from `78271917b526469c559fa75cb5ee39426e5494d1` to `a28fc2f4e185df7847e2f2f5f6ec561d1e84805d` when the Noema single-request/deadline repair integrated. Consequently #1150 exact `36639d090fd24c894e06fe39d01bac2dcfa0c4a4` is now `behind_by=1` and diverged from live main with merge base `78271917...`; its predecessor checks/reviews cannot be promoted. The owner path was handed fresh exact evidence and acceptance criteria to adopt the intervening protected-main commit non-destructively and regenerate exact-head evidence. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates or no-op source churn. +The canonical owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is now `a28fc2f4e185df7847e2f2f5f6ec561d1e84805d`, containing the integrated Noema single-request/deadline repair. This run repaired #1150's stale ancestry non-destructively: current exact head `7d80a06c3a48f6411a17aa41e48b1f7064c5e36a` has predecessor `36639d090fd24c894e06fe39d01bac2dcfa0c4a4` and protected `main@a28fc...` as parents and now compares `behind_by=0`. Fresh exact-head central OSV, Noema token-lifetime, SBOM, Secret Scan, Semgrep, Python Security, Scorecard, CodeQL PR and Security Scan runs have materialized but remain queued/pending. Their predecessor results do not transfer. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates or no-op source churn. -The merged Noema repair removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. This is now protected central owner evidence rather than an open prerequisite. +The protected Noema repair removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. This is protected central owner evidence rather than an open prerequisite. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From a0abef65b80d7aa639c48545d319df90ba7d16c2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Wed, 2 Sep 2026 23:47:39 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 031/110] docs(research): correct Kang and Jeon 2025 title --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 0113c1315..d05b80cd5 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -63,7 +63,7 @@ Primary/research anchors include: - Driver, C. C., Oud, J. H. L., & Voelkle, M. C. (2017). Continuous time structural equation modeling with R package ctsem. *Journal of Statistical Software, 77*(5), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v077.i05 - Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 - Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 -- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Generalized mixed models for item response data with complex dependence structures. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 +- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 - van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 - Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y From 0939b77608ec55d0d765da59c3e7d1926b98d365 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 01:35:40 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 032/110] docs(product-gap): refresh live owner and stack evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 20 +++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d05b80cd5..b369134fa 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory** Protected-product basis: `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c` -Observation date: 2026-09-02 +Observation date: 2026-09-03 This file is a commercialization and technical-gap inventory, not runtime authority. A capability is authoritative only after its source is integrated into protected `main` and the applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence is terminal success on one unchanged exact head. Open PRs, Drafts, successful predecessor checks and mutable sibling branches are evidence inputs, not product claims. @@ -39,17 +39,17 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | -| Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The 2026-09-02 non-force two-parent reconciliation contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | +| Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The non-force two-parent reconciliation contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `1146527c61dc0e5c9a1ae6c10e31fdb1f86fa849`; child #1724 `063878c04cbd1c8182149582e612f246c60f334d` at the last verified stack snapshot | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-item Draft #1727 `c94678cc8a23293153c18c734ede5077355fa498` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; freeze concrete item identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state contract alone. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `2270cb9f53c3fe39710c056d28f78f4aca3e3859`; child #1724 `e8ed9287d04326d9a2794cc14a8a95d96c6f6045` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `17ac218a5c0a31f0082839603a8ffc64b4432534` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | -Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation recorded **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. +Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. ## 4. Scientific acceptance model @@ -73,7 +73,7 @@ A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × de `ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. -Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed protected development tips while their active governance paths intend a protected-`main` integration/default transition. Do not infer that transition from memory; `.github#1137` remains the administrative owner path and the live branch/ruleset state must be re-read each run. +Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed protected development tips. Active organization ruleset `18156473` targets `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`; therefore the accepted protected-`main` transition described by their owner lanes has not yet occurred and must not be inferred from roadmap prose. `.github#1137` remains the administrative owner path. Context Graph currently has **14 open PRs and 2 open issues**. High-priority issue #24 keeps source-bound immutable release evidence open; Draft #25 is the owner repair. EA Core currently has **24 open PRs and 2 open issues**; its Context Fabric consumer work remains fail closed on provisional CGC identity. Both GitHub release lists are empty. Therefore fast-mlsirm has no immutable released CGC contract/profile to pin yet. @@ -83,12 +83,14 @@ Architecture/lifecycle facts that may later be projected include released packag The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-ready fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. On #1722 exact `338dbb...`, organization-required CodeQL PR terminated `startup_failure` before job materialization while CI/security/Scorecard/CodeQL/fuzz/Semgrep/OSV lanes remained non-terminal; substantive numerical review threads are resolved, but no qualifying approval exists. #1729 exact `7faa16037a3e8697e640bfbac780709ee5297d1f` independently reproduced both control-plane classes: required CodeQL PR `startup_failure` with zero jobs, and sibling jobs materialized with `runner_id=0`, no steps and no checkout. -The canonical owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is now `a28fc2f4e185df7847e2f2f5f6ec561d1e84805d`, containing the integrated Noema single-request/deadline repair. This run repaired #1150's stale ancestry non-destructively: current exact head `7d80a06c3a48f6411a17aa41e48b1f7064c5e36a` has predecessor `36639d090fd24c894e06fe39d01bac2dcfa0c4a4` and protected `main@a28fc...` as parents and now compares `behind_by=0`. Fresh exact-head central OSV, Noema token-lifetime, SBOM, Secret Scan, Semgrep, Python Security, Scorecard, CodeQL PR and Security Scan runs have materialized but remain queued/pending. Their predecessor results do not transfer. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates or no-op source churn. +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is now `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`. This run reconciled #1150 non-destructively onto that protected tip: current exact head `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` has queue-health predecessor `7d80a06c3a48f6411a17aa41e48b1f7064c5e36a` and protected `main@8c085835...` as parents and compares `behind_by=0`. The effective queue-health implementation/config/docs/tests are preserved without a force update or destructive rebase. -The protected Noema repair removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. This is protected central owner evidence rather than an open prerequisite. +Fresh exact-head central runs on `bbacf9e8...` have materialized but remain non-passing: Noema token-lifetime, Secret Scan, Semgrep, CodeQL PR, Python Security, Scorecard, Security Scan, SBOM and OSV are queued. Security Scan run `33655230050` has four exact-head jobs (`dependency-review`, `trivy-fs`, `osv-scan`, `scorecard`) with `steps: []`, label `ubuntu-24.04`, `runner_id=0` and no runner identity. This is fresh central owner evidence of the same pre-checkout acquisition class; predecessor results do not transfer. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, or promoting stale success. + +The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. That is protected central owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 8c3b09a33bdb4c21c49423ed460d257d773f6440 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 04:16:59 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 033/110] docs(product-gap): refresh dynamic-evaluation exact head --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index b369134fa..a61939903 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -42,7 +42,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The non-force two-parent reconciliation contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `2270cb9f53c3fe39710c056d28f78f4aca3e3859`; child #1724 `e8ed9287d04326d9a2794cc14a8a95d96c6f6045` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `17ac218a5c0a31f0082839603a8ffc64b4432534` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `850c2e28dadea3bc5ae936e88bc47f2ece871c1a` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | From d78f25469698dcb5673b568ad0735a918aa4baa4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 07:08:58 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 034/110] docs(product-gap): refresh exact owner and gate evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 11 ++++++----- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index a61939903..53063f5c8 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | -| Acquisition/readiness and hosted-runner identity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `c8621e9f95cc76f26810b0177d6e56e9a1428698` | The non-force two-parent reconciliation contains protected `main@b5a3a0c...` and preserves the branch delta; fresh exact-head checks/reviews are required after the restack. | +| Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | The protected `python` context now depends on both the CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success. Preserve the non-force protected-main reconciliation and require fresh exact-head CI/security/review evidence after the RED→GREEN workflow and stale-contract repair. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `2270cb9f53c3fe39710c056d28f78f4aca3e3859`; child #1724 `e8ed9287d04326d9a2794cc14a8a95d96c6f6045` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `850c2e28dadea3bc5ae936e88bc47f2ece871c1a` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | @@ -47,9 +47,10 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | +| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN; preserve stronger pytest exit classifications and require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | -Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **49 open pull requests** and **196 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. +Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **50 open pull requests** and **197 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. ## 4. Scientific acceptance model @@ -81,11 +82,11 @@ Architecture/lifecycle facts that may later be projected include released packag ## 6. Exact-head Actions/control-plane state -The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-ready fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. On #1722 exact `338dbb...`, organization-required CodeQL PR terminated `startup_failure` before job materialization while CI/security/Scorecard/CodeQL/fuzz/Semgrep/OSV lanes remained non-terminal; substantive numerical review threads are resolved, but no qualifying approval exists. #1729 exact `7faa16037a3e8697e640bfbac780709ee5297d1f` independently reproduced both control-plane classes: required CodeQL PR `startup_failure` with zero jobs, and sibling jobs materialized with `runner_id=0`, no steps and no checkout. +The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. On #1717 exact `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, required CodeQL PR run `33688322254` is terminal `startup_failure` before job materialization; repository CI `33688320713` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33688320521`, Security Scan `33688320632`, SAST Semgrep `33688320807`, OSV-Scanner PR `33688321189` and Scorecard PR `33688320659` remain queued. This exact source head contains the RED→GREEN GPU-gate repair plus its review-driven stale-test repair; no predecessor result transfers. #1733 exact `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c` independently remains blocked by the same pre-source admission class after resolving its test-governance review findings. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is now `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`. This run reconciled #1150 non-destructively onto that protected tip: current exact head `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` has queue-health predecessor `7d80a06c3a48f6411a17aa41e48b1f7064c5e36a` and protected `main@8c085835...` as parents and compares `behind_by=0`. The effective queue-health implementation/config/docs/tests are preserved without a force update or destructive rebase. +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is exact `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; #1150 exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` remains current, non-destructively reconciled and not behind protected main. The exact #1717 reproduction has been handed to #712. Central GREEN requires actual job materialization, runner assignment, checkout identity and terminal required results on unchanged owner/leaf heads. -Fresh exact-head central runs on `bbacf9e8...` have materialized but remain non-passing: Noema token-lifetime, Secret Scan, Semgrep, CodeQL PR, Python Security, Scorecard, Security Scan, SBOM and OSV are queued. Security Scan run `33655230050` has four exact-head jobs (`dependency-review`, `trivy-fs`, `osv-scan`, `scorecard`) with `steps: []`, label `ubuntu-24.04`, `runner_id=0` and no runner identity. This is fresh central owner evidence of the same pre-checkout acquisition class; predecessor results do not transfer. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, or promoting stale success. +On owner head `bbacf9e8...`, Security Scan run `33655230050` exposed four exact-head `ubuntu-24.04` jobs (`dependency-review`, `trivy-fs`, `osv-scan`, `scorecard`) with `steps: []`, `runner_id=0` and no runner identity. That pre-checkout acquisition state remains distinct from the zero-job `startup_failure` class. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, or promoting stale success. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. That is protected central owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. From 73d7a46061a2820e1c18737273c80645f98cd4fe Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 07:13:16 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 035/110] docs(product-gap): track current Mokken stack heads --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 53063f5c8..9ad6a8b21 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -41,7 +41,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | The protected `python` context now depends on both the CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success. Preserve the non-force protected-main reconciliation and require fresh exact-head CI/security/review evidence after the RED→GREEN workflow and stale-contract repair. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `2270cb9f53c3fe39710c056d28f78f4aca3e3859`; child #1724 `e8ed9287d04326d9a2794cc14a8a95d96c6f6045` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `3a4399788d9ce235349e8f98d67d59c3e00029c3`; child #1724 `0e83352e3af5ca314fe064f6393df6926d01cfa6` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `850c2e28dadea3bc5ae936e88bc47f2ece871c1a` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | From fc151875570ea72ac8f7bd23cb786245a4d6bd82 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 07:46:09 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 036/110] docs(product-gap): refresh exact owner and admission evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 18 +++++++++++------- 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 9ad6a8b21..2fa636ec1 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -39,12 +39,14 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | -| Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | The protected `python` context now depends on both the CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success. Preserve the non-force protected-main reconciliation and require fresh exact-head CI/security/review evidence after the RED→GREEN workflow and stale-contract repair. | +| Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | The protected `python` context depends on both the CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success. Require fresh exact-head CI/security/review evidence after the RED→GREEN workflow and stale-contract repair. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `3a4399788d9ce235349e8f98d67d59c3e00029c3`; child #1724 `0e83352e3af5ca314fe064f6393df6926d01cfa6` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening; caller-governed `lower_bound` and `alpha`; maintain one main-facing writer and revalidate ancestry after either head moves. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; the current parent removes a platform `pytest.skip` from longdouble precision evidence while preserving explicit capability classification, and the child is non-force reconciled with merge base exactly equal to the parent. | +| RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and the exact PyO3 native-result envelope, including bounded likelihood-trace admission before package-owned copying. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `850c2e28dadea3bc5ae936e88bc47f2ece871c1a` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | +| Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN; preserve stronger pytest exit classifications and require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | @@ -82,16 +84,18 @@ Architecture/lifecycle facts that may later be projected include released packag ## 6. Exact-head Actions/control-plane state -The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. On #1717 exact `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, required CodeQL PR run `33688322254` is terminal `startup_failure` before job materialization; repository CI `33688320713` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33688320521`, Security Scan `33688320632`, SAST Semgrep `33688320807`, OSV-Scanner PR `33688321189` and Scorecard PR `33688320659` remain queued. This exact source head contains the RED→GREEN GPU-gate repair plus its review-driven stale-test repair; no predecessor result transfers. #1733 exact `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c` independently remains blocked by the same pre-source admission class after resolving its test-governance review findings. +The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. The newest substantive Mokken owner head #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` is exactly based on protected `main`, Ready and mergeable. Required CodeQL PR run `33691314629` terminated `startup_failure` with zero jobs; repository CI `33691312917` remains pre-job with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33691312901` materialized `scorecard`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan` and `trivy-fs`, but all remain runnerless with no checkout/source steps. That exact head contains a real portability/test-governance repair rather than a no-op retrigger. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is exact `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; #1150 exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` remains current, non-destructively reconciled and not behind protected main. The exact #1717 reproduction has been handed to #712. Central GREEN requires actual job materialization, runner assignment, checkout identity and terminal required results on unchanged owner/leaf heads. +Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. -On owner head `bbacf9e8...`, Security Scan run `33655230050` exposed four exact-head `ubuntu-24.04` jobs (`dependency-review`, `trivy-fs`, `osv-scan`, `scorecard`) with `steps: []`, `runner_id=0` and no runner identity. That pre-checkout acquisition state remains distinct from the zero-job `startup_failure` class. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, or promoting stale success. +The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, and #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c`: required workflows remain startup-failed, pre-job or runnerless before source execution. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. -The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`. That is protected central owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is exact `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; #1150 exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` remains current and non-destructively reconciled. Both the zero-job admission and materialized-but-runnerless acquisition classes have been handed to #712 with exact leaf SHA/run/job evidence. Central GREEN requires actual runner allocation, checkout identity, source execution and terminal required conclusions on unchanged owner/leaf heads. + +fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From 297bf75283d2557b759f3ace31a9cae4a3f0c1a1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 08:43:50 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 037/110] docs(product-gap): refresh dynamic evaluation and TEPP evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 2fa636ec1..f0b78a67a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -38,12 +38,12 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | -| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `6c98b0f1e05bbf4ccf51128f5ed1dd14e9515036` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | +| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only; historical ADRs must carry the same explicit ownership qualification. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | The protected `python` context depends on both the CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success. Require fresh exact-head CI/security/review evidence after the RED→GREEN workflow and stale-contract repair. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; the current parent removes a platform `pytest.skip` from longdouble precision evidence while preserving explicit capability classification, and the child is non-force reconciled with merge base exactly equal to the parent. | | RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and the exact PyO3 native-result envelope, including bounded likelihood-trace admission before package-owned copying. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `850c2e28dadea3bc5ae936e88bc47f2ece871c1a` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `506ed8d6c559b6cd08705f6fdbc5910aeaf99025` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. The current test contract distinguishes wrong collection carriers from semantically empty exact item sets without weakening production admission. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | @@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. -The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, and #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c`: required workflows remain startup-failed, pre-job or runnerless before source execution. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. +The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c`, and the post-repair #1727 head `506ed8d6c559b6cd08705f6fdbc5910aeaf99025`: required workflows remain startup-failed, pre-job or runnerless before source execution. On #1727, required `CodeQL PR` run `33696026361` is `startup_failure`, while repository CI `33696025308` is pending with no materialized jobs at the latest read. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is exact `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; #1150 exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` remains current and non-destructively reconciled. Both the zero-job admission and materialized-but-runnerless acquisition classes have been handed to #712 with exact leaf SHA/run/job evidence. Central GREEN requires actual runner allocation, checkout identity, source execution and terminal required conclusions on unchanged owner/leaf heads. @@ -98,4 +98,4 @@ fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 80bd89f313c18ac2e4836f8ee0763502f8b3c8ea Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 09:47:40 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 038/110] docs(product-gap): bind dynamic evaluation repair head --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index f0b78a67a..d15dc49d9 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; the current parent removes a platform `pytest.skip` from longdouble precision evidence while preserving explicit capability classification, and the child is non-force reconciled with merge base exactly equal to the parent. | | RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and the exact PyO3 native-result envelope, including bounded likelihood-trace admission before package-owned copying. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `506ed8d6c559b6cd08705f6fdbc5910aeaf99025` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. The current test contract distinguishes wrong collection carriers from semantically empty exact item sets without weakening production admission. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `13848f9d5a089be4f727f2982def507c96ec6fbc` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Fresh exact-head review found the production factory had regressed to preserving caller order despite existing criterion-membership and item-set order-invariance RED tests; `6286318c...` and current `13848f9d...` restore canonical membership identities without conflating administration sequence, while the earlier test-contract repair preserves wrong-carrier `TypeError` versus semantically empty exact-item-set rejection. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | @@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. -The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c`, and the post-repair #1727 head `506ed8d6c559b6cd08705f6fdbc5910aeaf99025`: required workflows remain startup-failed, pre-job or runnerless before source execution. On #1727, required `CodeQL PR` run `33696026361` is `startup_failure`, while repository CI `33696025308` is pending with no materialized jobs at the latest read. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. +The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `13848f9d5a089be4f727f2982def507c96ec6fbc`: required workflows remain startup-failed, pre-job or runnerless before source execution. On #1727, fresh source inspection invalidated predecessor head `506ed8d6...` because both existing order-invariance RED contracts were again violated; `6286318c...` and current `13848f9d...` restore criterion-membership and item-set canonicalization. On that current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33700547557` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33700546493` is pending; CodeQL `33700546477`, Security Scan `33700546431`, and OSV `33700546859` are queued, while Semgrep `33700546369` and Scorecard `33700546412` are pending at the latest read. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is exact `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; #1150 exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` remains current and non-destructively reconciled. Both the zero-job admission and materialized-but-runnerless acquisition classes have been handed to #712 with exact leaf SHA/run/job evidence. Central GREEN requires actual runner allocation, checkout identity, source execution and terminal required conclusions on unchanged owner/leaf heads. @@ -98,4 +98,4 @@ fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From fb4c4eaa4650ac1abe9799c75ff591489b7cb073 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 11:38:09 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 039/110] docs(product-gap): refresh test governance and central queue state --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 10 ++++++---- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d15dc49d9..fdfa55e36 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | -| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN; preserve stronger pytest exit classifications and require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | +| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN; preserve stronger pytest exit classifications. Fresh review also proved descriptor-relative atomic-write tests could return normally when a platform primitive was missing; source-level RED `5dc238d...` and GREEN `3ab1ebf...` now make the missing prerequisite failing evidence instead of a false pass. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **50 open pull requests** and **197 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. @@ -76,7 +76,7 @@ A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × de `ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. -Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed protected development tips. Active organization ruleset `18156473` targets `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`; therefore the accepted protected-`main` transition described by their owner lanes has not yet occurred and must not be inferred from roadmap prose. `.github#1137` remains the administrative owner path. +Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed protected development tips. Active organization ruleset `18156473` targets `~DEFAULT_BRANCH` and currently requires one approving review, review-thread resolution, central required workflows, deletion protection and non-fast-forward protection. Therefore the accepted protected-`main` transition described by their owner lanes has not yet occurred and must not be inferred from roadmap prose. `.github#1137` remains the administrative owner path. Context Graph currently has **14 open PRs and 2 open issues**. High-priority issue #24 keeps source-bound immutable release evidence open; Draft #25 is the owner repair. EA Core currently has **24 open PRs and 2 open issues**; its Context Fabric consumer work remains fail closed on provisional CGC identity. Both GitHub release lists are empty. Therefore fast-mlsirm has no immutable released CGC contract/profile to pin yet. @@ -88,9 +88,11 @@ The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. -The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `cbe0d836af8083f46f310e0d50788e0c88b88c1c`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `13848f9d5a089be4f727f2982def507c96ec6fbc`: required workflows remain startup-failed, pre-job or runnerless before source execution. On #1727, fresh source inspection invalidated predecessor head `506ed8d6...` because both existing order-invariance RED contracts were again violated; `6286318c...` and current `13848f9d...` restore criterion-membership and item-set canonicalization. On that current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33700547557` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33700546493` is pending; CodeQL `33700546477`, Security Scan `33700546431`, and OSV `33700546859` are queued, while Semgrep `33700546369` and Scorecard `33700546412` are pending at the latest read. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. +The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `13848f9d5a089be4f727f2982def507c96ec6fbc`. On #1733, valid review RED `5dc238d25cd10e6889c9900d49714c793c19e01e` proved the prior atomic-write capability helper still produced false passes; GREEN `3ab1ebf3a3e73632bd46d49998a009dee5f0a728` makes missing descriptor-relative prerequisites fail closed, and current `c17462e6...` records the repair. Its required `CodeQL PR` run `33707819626` terminates `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33707818706` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33707818677` has four exact-head `ubuntu-24.04` jobs (`100500685908`, `100500686110`, `100500686382`, `100500686396`) that remain queued with no runner identity or steps. Repository CodeQL `33707818688`, Semgrep `33707818684` and OSV `33707818952` remain queued, while Scorecard `33707818698` remains pending. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` plus PR #1150. Protected `.github/main` is exact `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; #1150 exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` remains current and non-destructively reconciled. Both the zero-job admission and materialized-but-runnerless acquisition classes have been handed to #712 with exact leaf SHA/run/job evidence. Central GREEN requires actual runner allocation, checkout identity, source execution and terminal required conclusions on unchanged owner/leaf heads. +On #1727, fresh source inspection invalidated predecessor head `506ed8d6...` because both existing order-invariance RED contracts were again violated; `6286318c...` and current `13848f9d...` restore criterion-membership and item-set canonicalization. On that current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33700547557` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33700546493` is pending; CodeQL `33700546477`, Security Scan `33700546431`, and OSV `33700546859` are queued, while Semgrep `33700546369` and Scorecard `33700546412` are pending at the latest read. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. + +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `bf5970df983dd36e3372c124778ec60857414eba`. Queue-health PR #1150 remains exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` but still records predecessor base `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; GitHub now reports it non-mergeable. That central-owner ancestry drift was handed to #712 with RED/GREEN acceptance for a non-force reconciliation or verified canonical successor. Until the central writer repairs it, #1150's predecessor current-main claims are stale and cannot be treated as landing authority. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. From 197e68cd0bc29048851e75769e52755f89bc0103 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 12:14:37 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 040/110] docs(product-gap): refresh dynamic evidence identity lane --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 10 +++++----- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index fdfa55e36..7b92be121 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; the current parent removes a platform `pytest.skip` from longdouble precision evidence while preserving explicit capability classification, and the child is non-force reconciled with merge base exactly equal to the parent. | | RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and the exact PyO3 native-result envelope, including bounded likelihood-trace admission before package-owned copying. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `13848f9d5a089be4f727f2982def507c96ec6fbc` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Fresh exact-head review found the production factory had regressed to preserving caller order despite existing criterion-membership and item-set order-invariance RED tests; `6286318c...` and current `13848f9d...` restore canonical membership identities without conflating administration sequence, while the earlier test-contract repair preserves wrong-carrier `TypeError` versus semantically empty exact-item-set rejection. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from the state/identity contracts alone. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Criterion membership, item-set membership, provenance refs and validation-evidence refs now canonicalize mathematical/evidence membership rather than caller order. Issue #1735 records RED `1f88c46e...`, GREEN `393dcacb...`, and changelog `6179ca2d...`; temporal/administration sequence remains TEPP-owned. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from these state/identity contracts alone. | | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | @@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN; preserve stronger pytest exit classifications. Fresh review also proved descriptor-relative atomic-write tests could return normally when a platform primitive was missing; source-level RED `5dc238d...` and GREEN `3ab1ebf...` now make the missing prerequisite failing evidence instead of a false pass. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | -Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **50 open pull requests** and **197 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. +Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **51 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. ## 4. Scientific acceptance model @@ -88,9 +88,9 @@ The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. -The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `13848f9d5a089be4f727f2982def507c96ec6fbc`. On #1733, valid review RED `5dc238d25cd10e6889c9900d49714c793c19e01e` proved the prior atomic-write capability helper still produced false passes; GREEN `3ab1ebf3a3e73632bd46d49998a009dee5f0a728` makes missing descriptor-relative prerequisites fail closed, and current `c17462e6...` records the repair. Its required `CodeQL PR` run `33707819626` terminates `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33707818706` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33707818677` has four exact-head `ubuntu-24.04` jobs (`100500685908`, `100500686110`, `100500686382`, `100500686396`) that remain queued with no runner identity or steps. Repository CodeQL `33707818688`, Semgrep `33707818684` and OSV `33707818952` remain queued, while Scorecard `33707818698` remains pending. +The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745`. On #1733, valid review RED `5dc238d25cd10e6889c9900d49714c793c19e01e` proved the prior atomic-write capability helper still produced false passes; GREEN `3ab1ebf3a3e73632bd46d49998a009dee5f0a728` makes missing descriptor-relative prerequisites fail closed, and current `c17462e6...` records the repair. Its required `CodeQL PR` run `33707819626` terminates `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33707818706` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33707818677` has four exact-head `ubuntu-24.04` jobs (`100500685908`, `100500686110`, `100500686382`, `100500686396`) that remain queued with no runner identity or steps. Repository CodeQL `33707818688`, Semgrep `33707818684` and OSV `33707818952` remain queued, while Scorecard `33707818698` remains pending. -On #1727, fresh source inspection invalidated predecessor head `506ed8d6...` because both existing order-invariance RED contracts were again violated; `6286318c...` and current `13848f9d...` restore criterion-membership and item-set canonicalization. On that current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33700547557` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33700546493` is pending; CodeQL `33700546477`, Security Scan `33700546431`, and OSV `33700546859` are queued, while Semgrep `33700546369` and Scorecard `33700546412` are pending at the latest read. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. +On #1727, issue #1735 adds source-level RED `1f88c46eb19fc3de28c8dbb8555af2d295d31fad` for order-sensitive provenance and validation-evidence membership; GREEN `393dcacbd28aca56472606929f5c6adb5890775a` canonicalizes exact bounded unique reference membership after existing admission checks, and current `6179ca2d...` records the contract in the governed changelog. On this current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33710431487` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33710430288` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33710430231` materialized dependency-review `100508521824`, scorecard `100508521980`, trivy-fs `100508522038` and osv-scan `100508522081`, all queued with no execution steps. CodeQL `33710430358`, OSV-Scanner PR `33710430754` and Semgrep `33710430202` remain queued; Scorecard PR `33710430327` is pending. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `bf5970df983dd36e3372c124778ec60857414eba`. Queue-health PR #1150 remains exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` but still records predecessor base `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; GitHub now reports it non-mergeable. That central-owner ancestry drift was handed to #712 with RED/GREEN acceptance for a non-force reconciliation or verified canonical successor. Until the central writer repairs it, #1150's predecessor current-main claims are stale and cannot be treated as landing authority. @@ -100,4 +100,4 @@ fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 9c0a210d79aec175c07b5d4e5b919df7dbf84624 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 14:17:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 041/110] docs: refresh current test-governance and Actions evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 7b92be121..17b62d042 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | -| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN; preserve stronger pytest exit classifications. Fresh review also proved descriptor-relative atomic-write tests could return normally when a platform primitive was missing; source-level RED `5dc238d...` and GREEN `3ab1ebf...` now make the missing prerequisite failing evidence instead of a false pass. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | +| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN. Source RED `1a75be8...` proves a later ordinary `pytest_sessionfinish` plugin could overwrite skip-derived failure back to process exit 0; GREEN `6430de9...` makes the repository policy final via an outer hook wrapper and preserves stronger pre-existing non-success classifications. Earlier descriptor-relative atomic-write RED `5dc238d...` → GREEN `3ab1ebf...` remains part of the same fail-closed evidence. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **51 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. @@ -88,11 +88,11 @@ The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. -The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `c17462e6ef25153fca30f1ca6accf50b4e029ca6`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745`. On #1733, valid review RED `5dc238d25cd10e6889c9900d49714c793c19e01e` proved the prior atomic-write capability helper still produced false passes; GREEN `3ab1ebf3a3e73632bd46d49998a009dee5f0a728` makes missing descriptor-relative prerequisites fail closed, and current `c17462e6...` records the repair. Its required `CodeQL PR` run `33707819626` terminates `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33707818706` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33707818677` has four exact-head `ubuntu-24.04` jobs (`100500685908`, `100500686110`, `100500686382`, `100500686396`) that remain queued with no runner identity or steps. Repository CodeQL `33707818688`, Semgrep `33707818684` and OSV `33707818952` remain queued, while Scorecard `33707818698` remains pending. +The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745`. On #1733, source RED `1a75be806190b3e30784ced0419ddda79dadbf76` proves an ordinary later `pytest_sessionfinish(trylast=True)` plugin could reset a skip-derived test failure to exit 0 after the predecessor repository hook. GREEN `6430de94e78f6f65af2af47e90c8cd9bf321d163` makes the repository policy an outer hook wrapper and preserves the original stronger non-success classification; current `b66a9704...` records that repair. Earlier RED `5dc238d25cd10e6889c9900d49714c793c19e01e` → GREEN `3ab1ebf3a3e73632bd46d49998a009dee5f0a728` separately makes missing descriptor-relative atomic-write prerequisites failing evidence rather than false passes. On the current exact head, repository CI `33717632834` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33717632804` materialized only `Detect changed scope` job `100530055758`, queued on `ubuntu-24.04` with `steps=[]` and no runner identity. Repository CodeQL `33717632828`, Semgrep `33717632799`, OSV-Scanner PR `33717633165` and Scorecard PR `33717632870` remain queued/pending, while the protected required `Analyze (actions)` lane is absent from the exact-head check-run inventory. Absence and queue state remain non-passing. On #1727, issue #1735 adds source-level RED `1f88c46eb19fc3de28c8dbb8555af2d295d31fad` for order-sensitive provenance and validation-evidence membership; GREEN `393dcacbd28aca56472606929f5c6adb5890775a` canonicalizes exact bounded unique reference membership after existing admission checks, and current `6179ca2d...` records the contract in the governed changelog. On this current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33710431487` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33710430288` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33710430231` materialized dependency-review `100508521824`, scorecard `100508521980`, trivy-fs `100508522038` and osv-scan `100508522081`, all queued with no execution steps. CodeQL `33710430358`, OSV-Scanner PR `33710430754` and Semgrep `33710430202` remain queued; Scorecard PR `33710430327` is pending. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `bf5970df983dd36e3372c124778ec60857414eba`. Queue-health PR #1150 remains exact `bbacf9e81ae954eb8365fbfe1856d8698a768a4a` but still records predecessor base `8c085835fbf77de2321b72fa6b8dd946227e523e`; GitHub now reports it non-mergeable. That central-owner ancestry drift was handed to #712 with RED/GREEN acceptance for a non-force reconciliation or verified canonical successor. Until the central writer repairs it, #1150's predecessor current-main claims are stale and cannot be treated as landing authority. +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `bf28b5ddca7d4d63f3e6f63a43d084a0056563e2` through merged #1769, which prevents the current-head run coalescer from cancelling itself during push bursts and requires post-merge revalidation. The incident remains open because distinct zero-run admission, zero-job `startup_failure`, and runnerless `steps=[]` classes still reproduce across current exact heads; central follow-up work must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. From 406fc0d7e6d1c9a595568c94abb6e2d05b6192f8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 14:42:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 042/110] docs(product-gap): record capability coverage repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 12 +++++++----- 1 file changed, 7 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 17b62d042..752ea5b8c 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | -| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `0d97c877f1496327f3f86fec641755bed4364438` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. | +| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. New module-entrypoint coverage is owned rather than excluded: RED `86122e3e...` rejects `pragma: no cover` and exercises the actual `__main__` path; source GREEN `b6336aab...` removes the exclusion. Hosted exact-head GREEN is still required. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN. Source RED `1a75be8...` proves a later ordinary `pytest_sessionfinish` plugin could overwrite skip-derived failure back to process exit 0; GREEN `6430de9...` makes the repository policy final via an outer hook wrapper and preserves stronger pre-existing non-success classifications. Earlier descriptor-relative atomic-write RED `5dc238d...` → GREEN `3ab1ebf...` remains part of the same fail-closed evidence. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | @@ -65,10 +65,10 @@ Primary/research anchors include: - American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. - Driver, C. C., Oud, J. H. L., & Voelkle, M. C. (2017). Continuous time structural equation modeling with R package ctsem. *Journal of Statistical Software, 77*(5), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v077.i05 - Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 -- Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 -- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 -- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 -- Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y +- Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378-403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 +- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799-826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 +- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1-19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 +- Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75-99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × dependence composition. Novel combinations remain research candidates until the exact formulation is identified and recovered. @@ -92,6 +92,8 @@ The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949fa On #1727, issue #1735 adds source-level RED `1f88c46eb19fc3de28c8dbb8555af2d295d31fad` for order-sensitive provenance and validation-evidence membership; GREEN `393dcacbd28aca56472606929f5c6adb5890775a` canonicalizes exact bounded unique reference membership after existing admission checks, and current `6179ca2d...` records the contract in the governed changelog. On this current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33710431487` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33710430288` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33710430231` materialized dependency-review `100508521824`, scorecard `100508521980`, trivy-fs `100508522038` and osv-scan `100508522081`, all queued with no execution steps. CodeQL `33710430358`, OSV-Scanner PR `33710430754` and Semgrep `33710430202` remain queued; Scorecard PR `33710430327` is pending. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. +Capability support #1710 is now exact `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` after a real coverage-contract repair. Source-level RED `86122e3e81608a0435d6560fb1854aad137b9681` requires the package-owned module entrypoint to remain inside the coverage denominator and executes the actual `__main__` path; source GREEN `b6336aab...` removes the new `pragma: no cover` exclusion. Fresh exact-head SAST `33719638887`, CodeQL `33719638913`, OSV `33719639283`, Security Scan `33719638858` and Scorecard `33719638864` are queued, while CI `33719638914` is pending with `jobs=[]`. There is no runner assignment, checkout SHA or hosted GREEN on this source head yet. + The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `bf28b5ddca7d4d63f3e6f63a43d084a0056563e2` through merged #1769, which prevents the current-head run coalescer from cancelling itself during push bursts and requires post-merge revalidation. The incident remains open because distinct zero-run admission, zero-job `startup_failure`, and runnerless `steps=[]` classes still reproduce across current exact heads; central follow-up work must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. From 6631050392a882a67a3eb7183de2e01499d9f25e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 14:44:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 043/110] docs(product-gap): preserve APA page-range typography --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 752ea5b8c..0f1bce49a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -65,10 +65,10 @@ Primary/research anchors include: - American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. - Driver, C. C., Oud, J. H. L., & Voelkle, M. C. (2017). Continuous time structural equation modeling with R package ctsem. *Journal of Statistical Software, 77*(5), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v077.i05 - Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 -- Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378-403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 -- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799-826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 -- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1-19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 -- Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75-99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y +- Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 +- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 +- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 +- Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × dependence composition. Novel combinations remain research candidates until the exact formulation is identified and recovered. From 14a859aeff61813d75b69b4fbce20d700036dc8a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 17:31:52 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 044/110] docs(product-gap): refresh accessibility and control-plane evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 9 ++++++--- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 0f1bce49a..72aaec139 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -50,9 +50,10 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. New module-entrypoint coverage is owned rather than excluded: RED `86122e3e...` rejects `pragma: no cover` and exercises the actual `__main__` path; source GREEN `b6336aab...` removes the exclusion. Hosted exact-head GREEN is still required. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN. Source RED `1a75be8...` proves a later ordinary `pytest_sessionfinish` plugin could overwrite skip-derived failure back to process exit 0; GREEN `6430de9...` makes the repository policy final via an outer hook wrapper and preserves stronger pre-existing non-success classifications. Earlier descriptor-relative atomic-write RED `5dc238d...` → GREEN `3ab1ebf...` remains part of the same fail-closed evidence. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | +| Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes while retaining the existing no-transition `.bar-row` contract. Current diff is limited to the theme-aware foreground substitution and focused contrast regression; require fresh current-head accessibility/test/security evidence before merge. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | -Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **51 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. +Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **53 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. ## 4. Scientific acceptance model @@ -94,7 +95,9 @@ On #1727, issue #1735 adds source-level RED `1f88c46eb19fc3de28c8dbb8555af2d295d Capability support #1710 is now exact `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` after a real coverage-contract repair. Source-level RED `86122e3e81608a0435d6560fb1854aad137b9681` requires the package-owned module entrypoint to remain inside the coverage denominator and executes the actual `__main__` path; source GREEN `b6336aab...` removes the new `pragma: no cover` exclusion. Fresh exact-head SAST `33719638887`, CodeQL `33719638913`, OSV `33719639283`, Security Scan `33719638858` and Scorecard `33719638864` are queued, while CI `33719638914` is pending with `jobs=[]`. There is no runner assignment, checkout SHA or hosted GREEN on this source head yet. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `bf28b5ddca7d4d63f3e6f63a43d084a0056563e2` through merged #1769, which prevents the current-head run coalescer from cancelling itself during push bursts and requires post-merge revalidation. The incident remains open because distinct zero-run admission, zero-job `startup_failure`, and runnerless `steps=[]` classes still reproduce across current exact heads; central follow-up work must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. +Diagnostics-report accessibility #1740 was repaired again after concurrent branch movement reintroduced a previously rejected `.bar-row` transition and duplicate/contradictory `.Jules/palette.md` guidance. Current exact `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` restores the reviewed source and protected-main guidance, leaving exactly the skip-link foreground substitution plus focused contrast regression. Exact CI `33733504048` is pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33733504050` has `Analyze (actions)` job `100578617653` queued on `ubuntu-latest` with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while the Python job is skipped by scope. Semgrep `33733504119`, Security Scan `33733504016`, Scorecard `33733504032`, and OSV `33733504865` are also non-terminal. This is another clean current-head canary for `.github#712`, not a reason for leaf no-op churn. + +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `403da71198da5bef1a773178c139818cff24651a` through merged #1778, which rewrites `codeql-pr.yml` to a dispatch-and-poll design while deliberately leaving re-admission to the ruleset as separate follow-up work. The queue/admission incident remains open because fast-mlsirm current heads still reproduce zero-job and runnerless pre-execution states; central follow-up must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. @@ -102,4 +105,4 @@ fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From 29be26a1b7849dbfbb24c5a13c615149b7ed9f74 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 18:15:01 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 045/110] docs(product-gap): record item-bank successor and live Actions owner state --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 5 ++++- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 72aaec139..211107715 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -51,6 +51,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN. Source RED `1a75be8...` proves a later ordinary `pytest_sessionfinish` plugin could overwrite skip-derived failure back to process exit 0; GREEN `6430de9...` makes the repository policy final via an outer hook wrapper and preserves stronger pre-existing non-success classifications. Earlier descriptor-relative atomic-write RED `5dc238d...` → GREEN `3ab1ebf...` remains part of the same fail-closed evidence. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | | Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes while retaining the existing no-transition `.bar-row` contract. Current diff is limited to the theme-aware foreground substitution and focused contrast regression; require fresh current-head accessibility/test/security evidence before merge. | +| Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899`; superseded #1533 closed after identical-tree verification | Preserve the focus target/ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic timeline row headers and tabular numerals. The exact tree may contain only the item-bank renderer and its two focused accessibility tests; every landing gate and qualifying review must be regenerated on the successor head. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **53 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. @@ -97,7 +98,9 @@ Capability support #1710 is now exact `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` Diagnostics-report accessibility #1740 was repaired again after concurrent branch movement reintroduced a previously rejected `.bar-row` transition and duplicate/contradictory `.Jules/palette.md` guidance. Current exact `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` restores the reviewed source and protected-main guidance, leaving exactly the skip-link foreground substitution plus focused contrast regression. Exact CI `33733504048` is pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33733504050` has `Analyze (actions)` job `100578617653` queued on `ubuntu-latest` with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while the Python job is skipped by scope. Semgrep `33733504119`, Security Scan `33733504016`, Scorecard `33733504032`, and OSV `33733504865` are also non-terminal. This is another clean current-head canary for `.github#712`, not a reason for leaf no-op churn. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `403da71198da5bef1a773178c139818cff24651a` through merged #1778, which rewrites `codeql-pr.yml` to a dispatch-and-poll design while deliberately leaving re-admission to the ruleset as separate follow-up work. The queue/admission incident remains open because fast-mlsirm current heads still reproduce zero-job and runnerless pre-execution states; central follow-up must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. +Item-bank accessibility #1533 exposed a different, repository-owned single-writer failure: its shared Palette branch replayed the same stale full-tree state twice after forward repair, deleting the protected binary-response Measurement API/docs/tests, reintroducing #1504-owned `cross_engine_report.py`, and dropping part of the item-bank semantic regression. Both replays were repaired forward without force-push. Final repaired #1533 head `7353dd5e908542111423b3bb3043cfdc8df95b8c` and clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` resolve to the same tree `5d1d4f868ba2b546e9d3533341895472e2638fb4`; #1741 is a one-commit child of protected `main`, `ahead_by=1`, `behind_by=0`, and changes exactly the item-bank renderer plus two focused accessibility tests. #1533 was closed only after that byte-identical succession was verified; no predecessor check or review status transfers. On #1741 exact `68d4e534...`, CI `33737293904` materializes six expected jobs but all remain queued before checkout with no runner identity and `steps=[]`. CodeQL `33737293320` likewise has required `Analyze (actions)` job `100590755239` queued without runner/group/steps while its Python matrix job is skipped. The unchanged-head RED/GREEN admission evidence is recorded on `.github#712`. + +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `62d512e69953e8c4848e9e1c35b267015026d371` through merged #1789. That newer central documentation/retrospective movement does not itself establish runner admission or exact-head GREEN for fast-mlsirm. The queue/admission incident remains open because current fast-mlsirm heads still reproduce zero-job and runnerless pre-execution states; central follow-up must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. From ec6c53416501cd360e49ab5bdd9213d2ea36a42c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 19:11:36 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 046/110] docs(product-gap): refresh central owner evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 211107715..9b852b867 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ Primary/research anchors include: - Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 - Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 - Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 -- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 +- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y - Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × dependence composition. Novel combinations remain research candidates until the exact formulation is identified and recovered. @@ -100,7 +100,7 @@ Diagnostics-report accessibility #1740 was repaired again after concurrent branc Item-bank accessibility #1533 exposed a different, repository-owned single-writer failure: its shared Palette branch replayed the same stale full-tree state twice after forward repair, deleting the protected binary-response Measurement API/docs/tests, reintroducing #1504-owned `cross_engine_report.py`, and dropping part of the item-bank semantic regression. Both replays were repaired forward without force-push. Final repaired #1533 head `7353dd5e908542111423b3bb3043cfdc8df95b8c` and clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` resolve to the same tree `5d1d4f868ba2b546e9d3533341895472e2638fb4`; #1741 is a one-commit child of protected `main`, `ahead_by=1`, `behind_by=0`, and changes exactly the item-bank renderer plus two focused accessibility tests. #1533 was closed only after that byte-identical succession was verified; no predecessor check or review status transfers. On #1741 exact `68d4e534...`, CI `33737293904` materializes six expected jobs but all remain queued before checkout with no runner identity and `steps=[]`. CodeQL `33737293320` likewise has required `Analyze (actions)` job `100590755239` queued without runner/group/steps while its Python matrix job is skipped. The unchanged-head RED/GREEN admission evidence is recorded on `.github#712`. -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `62d512e69953e8c4848e9e1c35b267015026d371` through merged #1789. That newer central documentation/retrospective movement does not itself establish runner admission or exact-head GREEN for fast-mlsirm. The queue/admission incident remains open because current fast-mlsirm heads still reproduce zero-job and runnerless pre-execution states; central follow-up must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. +The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `122d202555aa241c14a45054e7f9cc5c2e957401` through merged #1790. That newer central documentation movement does not itself establish runner admission or exact-head GREEN for fast-mlsirm. The queue/admission incident remains open because current fast-mlsirm heads still reproduce zero-job and runnerless pre-execution states; central follow-up must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. @@ -108,4 +108,4 @@ fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 9d45dc82775c0249caba4d6eabbd59027eb89dd6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 19:14:27 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 047/110] docs(product-gap): repair reference during evidence refresh --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 9b852b867..590772f8e 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ Primary/research anchors include: - Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 - Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 - Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 -- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y +- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 - Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × dependence composition. Novel combinations remain research candidates until the exact formulation is identified and recovered. @@ -108,4 +108,4 @@ fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From 3e1191bb3450f8cb9fd5769bc3dd057c423c3854 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 21:20:41 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 048/110] docs(product-gap): refresh test governance and live protection --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 58 +++++++++++--------------- 1 file changed, 25 insertions(+), 33 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 590772f8e..2fa3a4704 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ A change is commercially merge-ready only when all applicable evidence refers to - 100% owned production statement/branch coverage and 100% public rustdoc/docstring coverage under the repository contract; - package/build/install evidence, including installed-wheel execution rather than source-tree import only; - security/static-analysis/fuzz/dependency evidence plus required SBOM/provenance evidence; -- zero valid unresolved review findings and the qualifying approval required by the live ruleset; +- zero valid unresolved review findings and the qualifying approval required by the live policy; - normal protected merge without self-approval, bypass, gate weakening, force update or predecessor-evidence transfer. Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and `startup_failure` states are non-passing but are not reasons to churn a clean source head. A release additionally requires one exact integrated protected head with recovery, package/install, reproducibility and rollback evidence; coherent version/CHANGELOG/tag state; immutable distribution/SBOM/provenance evidence; publish success; and post-publish verification. @@ -38,20 +38,20 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | -| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only; historical ADRs must carry the same explicit ownership qualification. | -| Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | The protected `python` context depends on both the CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success. Require fresh exact-head CI/security/review evidence after the RED→GREEN workflow and stale-contract repair. | -| Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only after an immutable released versioned contract exists. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` on that exact parent | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; the current parent removes a platform `pytest.skip` from longdouble precision evidence while preserving explicit capability classification, and the child is non-force reconciled with merge base exactly equal to the parent. | -| RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and the exact PyO3 native-result envelope, including bounded likelihood-trace admission before package-owned copying. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Criterion membership, item-set membership, provenance refs and validation-evidence refs now canonicalize mathematical/evidence membership rather than caller order. Issue #1735 records RED `1f88c46e...`, GREEN `393dcacb...`, and changelog `6179ca2d...`; temporal/administration sequence remains TEPP-owned. No calibration, DIF, information or CAT/ATA claim follows from these state/identity contracts alone. | -| Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible PyPI/GitHub release sinks must depend on the required evidence without mixing SBOM into package upload. | -| Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | `mlsirm-core` and `fast-mlsirm-py` remain internal `publish = false` Cargo packages; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product unless a separately governed Rust SDK is approved. Preserve all lock roots and SHA-256 wire identity. | -| Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot must cover the root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz Cargo lock roots without weakening `--locked` verification; shared dependency updates must not silently leave a production wheel graph stale. | -| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Exact 1.0 artifact must match public `FitConfig`/production estimator vocabulary; unsupported estimator identities remain unadvertised and fail closed. New module-entrypoint coverage is owned rather than excluded: RED `86122e3e...` rejects `pragma: no cover` and exercises the actual `__main__` path; source GREEN `b6336aab...` removes the exclusion. Hosted exact-head GREEN is still required. | -| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; do not overclaim interval coverage, variance-component recovery or longitudinal semantics. | -| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909` | Skip/xfail/xpass outcomes cannot make an otherwise-successful required invocation GREEN. Source RED `1a75be8...` proves a later ordinary `pytest_sessionfinish` plugin could overwrite skip-derived failure back to process exit 0; GREEN `6430de9...` makes the repository policy final via an outer hook wrapper and preserves stronger pre-existing non-success classifications. Earlier descriptor-relative atomic-write RED `5dc238d...` → GREEN `3ab1ebf...` remains part of the same fail-closed evidence. Require exact-head hosted execution before integration. | -| Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes while retaining the existing no-transition `.bar-row` contract. Current diff is limited to the theme-aware foreground substitution and focused contrast regression; require fresh current-head accessibility/test/security evidence before merge. | -| Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899`; superseded #1533 closed after identical-tree verification | Preserve the focus target/ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic timeline row headers and tabular numerals. The exact tree may contain only the item-bank renderer and its two focused accessibility tests; every landing gate and qualifying review must be regenerated on the successor head. | +| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | +| Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | +| Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; integrate parent first and regenerate child evidence after ancestry movement. | +| RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and exact PyO3 result envelopes. RSM lossless-tolerance tests remain this lane's ownership, not #1733's. | +| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Temporal/administration sequence remains TEPP-owned. | +| Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible publish sinks depend on the evidence. | +| Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Internal Cargo packages remain `publish = false`; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product absent a separately governed Rust SDK. | +| Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot and `--locked` verification must cover root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz lock roots without silently leaving the production wheel graph stale. | +| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Artifact must match public `FitConfig`/estimator vocabulary; unsupported identities remain unadvertised and fail closed; module entrypoint stays inside owned coverage. | +| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; no unearned interval-coverage or longitudinal claim. | +| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. The hook-order and atomic-write RED→GREEN lineage remains intact; current portability sweep additionally makes population-label, Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE, CDM and compensatory 2PL longdouble evidence fail explicitly when required wider precision is unavailable. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with active canonical writers #1699 and #1516. | +| Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes and existing no-transition behavior; require current-head accessibility/test/security evidence. | +| Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` | Preserve focus target/ring, reduced-motion, semantic row headers and tabular numerals; regenerate every landing gate and qualifying review on the successor. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **53 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. @@ -78,34 +78,26 @@ A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × de `ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. -Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed protected development tips. Active organization ruleset `18156473` targets `~DEFAULT_BRANCH` and currently requires one approving review, review-thread resolution, central required workflows, deletion protection and non-fast-forward protection. Therefore the accepted protected-`main` transition described by their owner lanes has not yet occurred and must not be inferred from roadmap prose. `.github#1137` remains the administrative owner path. +Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed development tips. Context Graph has **14 open PRs and 3 open issues**; new issue #26 is an external-metadata interoperability contract owner lane and does not change fast-mlsirm's scientific ownership. EA Core has **24 open PRs and 2 open issues**. Open foreign PR heads remain provisional evidence, not released authority. -Context Graph currently has **14 open PRs and 2 open issues**. High-priority issue #24 keeps source-bound immutable release evidence open; Draft #25 is the owner repair. EA Core currently has **24 open PRs and 2 open issues**; its Context Fabric consumer work remains fail closed on provisional CGC identity. Both GitHub release lists are empty. Therefore fast-mlsirm has no immutable released CGC contract/profile to pin yet. +Context Graph release/source-provenance prerequisite #25 remains Draft on its owner path. EA consumer projection work remains fail closed on provisional Context Graph identity. fast-mlsirm must not pin mutable CGC/EA PR heads or copy estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics or scientific-validity evidence into EA authoritative architecture truth. -Architecture/lifecycle facts that may later be projected include released package/crate/API/service identity, backend/toolchain/provider/version, consuming CWL dependency, lifecycle, risk, ownership, remediation and transformation. Projection must use a released versioned Context Assertion/CloudEvent/conformance contract with provenance. Estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics and scientific-validity evidence remain scientific evidence and must not be copied into EA authoritative architecture truth. +Architecture/lifecycle facts may be projected only after a released versioned Context Assertion/CloudEvent/conformance contract exists with immutable provenance: package/crate/API/service identity, backend/toolchain/provider/version, consuming CWL dependency, lifecycle, risk, ownership, remediation and transformation. No cross-service SQL or source copy is permitted. -## 6. Exact-head Actions/control-plane state +## 6. Live protection and Actions/control-plane state -The dominant landing blocker across otherwise source-repaired fast-mlsirm lanes is currently organization Actions admission rather than a verified numerical defect. The newest substantive Mokken owner head #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` is exactly based on protected `main`, Ready and mergeable. Required CodeQL PR run `33691314629` terminated `startup_failure` with zero jobs; repository CI `33691312917` remains pre-job with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33691312901` materialized `scorecard`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan` and `trivy-fs`, but all remain runnerless with no checkout/source steps. That exact head contains a real portability/test-governance repair rather than a no-op retrigger. +Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repository branch protection currently hard-requires status contexts including `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package`, and `fuzz`. -Dependent #1724 was reconciled non-destructively onto that owner head as `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac`; its merge base is exactly `cd46160...`, `ahead_by=25`, `behind_by=0`. Exact child CI `33691560237` has `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33691560184` materialized `Analyze (actions)` but it remains queued without a runner. These exact-current results supersede all predecessor-head landing evidence. +Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is intentionally absent from that required-workflow list after `.github#1719` established that `github/codeql-action` cannot execute as a ruleset-required workflow. -The same control-plane class is independently reproduced on #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09`, #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573`, #1733 `b66a97046c5e966166c7b0e7cbfb2909095aa909`, and the substantive dynamic-evaluation repair #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745`. On #1733, source RED `1a75be806190b3e30784ced0419ddda79dadbf76` proves an ordinary later `pytest_sessionfinish(trylast=True)` plugin could reset a skip-derived test failure to exit 0 after the predecessor repository hook. GREEN `6430de94e78f6f65af2af47e90c8cd9bf321d163` makes the repository policy an outer hook wrapper and preserves the original stronger non-success classification; current `b66a9704...` records that repair. Earlier RED `5dc238d25cd10e6889c9900d49714c793c19e01e` → GREEN `3ab1ebf3a3e73632bd46d49998a009dee5f0a728` separately makes missing descriptor-relative atomic-write prerequisites failing evidence rather than false passes. On the current exact head, repository CI `33717632834` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33717632804` materialized only `Detect changed scope` job `100530055758`, queued on `ubuntu-24.04` with `steps=[]` and no runner identity. Repository CodeQL `33717632828`, Semgrep `33717632799`, OSV-Scanner PR `33717633165` and Scorecard PR `33717632870` remain queued/pending, while the protected required `Analyze (actions)` lane is absent from the exact-head check-run inventory. Absence and queue state remain non-passing. +That central correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. On #1733 predecessor exact `f928b177769511662c94331130712277c3195e3e`, repository CodeQL run `33753788137` job `100643219366` and PR CodeQL run `33753784663` job `100643213561` both materialized `Analyze (actions)` but remained runnerless with `runner_id=0`, empty runner identity and `steps=[]`. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. -On #1727, issue #1735 adds source-level RED `1f88c46eb19fc3de28c8dbb8555af2d295d31fad` for order-sensitive provenance and validation-evidence membership; GREEN `393dcacbd28aca56472606929f5c6adb5890775a` canonicalizes exact bounded unique reference membership after existing admission checks, and current `6179ca2d...` records the contract in the governed changelog. On this current exact head, required `CodeQL PR` run `33710431487` is terminal `startup_failure` with `jobs=[]`; repository CI `33710430288` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33710430231` materialized dependency-review `100508521824`, scorecard `100508521980`, trivy-fs `100508522038` and osv-scan `100508522081`, all queued with no execution steps. CodeQL `33710430358`, OSV-Scanner PR `33710430754` and Semgrep `33710430202` remain queued; Scorecard PR `33710430327` is pending. This does not authorize moving otherwise-clean leaf source merely to retrigger. +#1733 has since moved through real source repairs to exact `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; all predecessor workflow evidence is therefore discarded for landing. The current head must regenerate every applicable required context and independent review. No source churn merely to retrigger, no predecessor-success transfer, no administrator bypass and no gate weakening are allowed. -Capability support #1710 is now exact `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` after a real coverage-contract repair. Source-level RED `86122e3e81608a0435d6560fb1854aad137b9681` requires the package-owned module entrypoint to remain inside the coverage denominator and executes the actual `__main__` path; source GREEN `b6336aab...` removes the new `pragma: no cover` exclusion. Fresh exact-head SAST `33719638887`, CodeQL `33719638913`, OSV `33719639283`, Security Scan `33719638858` and Scorecard `33719638864` are queued, while CI `33719638914` is pending with `jobs=[]`. There is no runner assignment, checkout SHA or hosted GREEN on this source head yet. - -Diagnostics-report accessibility #1740 was repaired again after concurrent branch movement reintroduced a previously rejected `.bar-row` transition and duplicate/contradictory `.Jules/palette.md` guidance. Current exact `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` restores the reviewed source and protected-main guidance, leaving exactly the skip-link foreground substitution plus focused contrast regression. Exact CI `33733504048` is pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL `33733504050` has `Analyze (actions)` job `100578617653` queued on `ubuntu-latest` with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while the Python job is skipped by scope. Semgrep `33733504119`, Security Scan `33733504016`, Scorecard `33733504032`, and OSV `33733504865` are also non-terminal. This is another clean current-head canary for `.github#712`, not a reason for leaf no-op churn. - -Item-bank accessibility #1533 exposed a different, repository-owned single-writer failure: its shared Palette branch replayed the same stale full-tree state twice after forward repair, deleting the protected binary-response Measurement API/docs/tests, reintroducing #1504-owned `cross_engine_report.py`, and dropping part of the item-bank semantic regression. Both replays were repaired forward without force-push. Final repaired #1533 head `7353dd5e908542111423b3bb3043cfdc8df95b8c` and clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` resolve to the same tree `5d1d4f868ba2b546e9d3533341895472e2638fb4`; #1741 is a one-commit child of protected `main`, `ahead_by=1`, `behind_by=0`, and changes exactly the item-bank renderer plus two focused accessibility tests. #1533 was closed only after that byte-identical succession was verified; no predecessor check or review status transfers. On #1741 exact `68d4e534...`, CI `33737293904` materializes six expected jobs but all remain queued before checkout with no runner identity and `steps=[]`. CodeQL `33737293320` likewise has required `Analyze (actions)` job `100590755239` queued without runner/group/steps while its Python matrix job is skipped. The unchanged-head RED/GREEN admission evidence is recorded on `.github#712`. - -The canonical central owner path remains `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. Protected `.github/main` has advanced to exact `122d202555aa241c14a45054e7f9cc5c2e957401` through merged #1790. That newer central documentation movement does not itself establish runner admission or exact-head GREEN for fast-mlsirm. The queue/admission incident remains open because current fast-mlsirm heads still reproduce zero-job and runnerless pre-execution states; central follow-up must own those causes rather than leaf source churn. - -fast-mlsirm must not compensate by weakening gates, changing clean source merely to retrigger, promoting predecessor success, self-approving, bypassing protection or fabricating evidence. The protected central Noema repair already removes the unsupported caller-side 900-second repair deadline and duplicate model request, keeps Actions model traffic on `orchestrator/free`, and leaves provider discovery/failover/structured-output repair with `contextual-orchestrator`; that remains foreign-owner evidence rather than a fast-mlsirm source responsibility. +The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `09ac6366ddd018fd0085368f4b669ba797fd0158` through the required-workflow/code-scanning governance repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities -After active lanes clear their exact-head gates, priority should remain evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect the generalized Model Specification contract to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. +After active lanes clear exact-head gates, priority remains evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect generalized Model Specification contracts to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From 96cac1b3b4e7082133369cd342cc62f5479348b6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 21:23:28 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 049/110] docs(product-gap): pin current-head queue evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 2fa3a4704..f2ae32896 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -90,9 +90,9 @@ Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repos Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is intentionally absent from that required-workflow list after `.github#1719` established that `github/codeql-action` cannot execute as a ruleset-required workflow. -That central correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. On #1733 predecessor exact `f928b177769511662c94331130712277c3195e3e`, repository CodeQL run `33753788137` job `100643219366` and PR CodeQL run `33753784663` job `100643213561` both materialized `Analyze (actions)` but remained runnerless with `runner_id=0`, empty runner identity and `steps=[]`. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. +That central correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. On #1733 current exact `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`, repository CodeQL run `33754522958` job `100645612648` and PR CodeQL run `33754512403` job `100645576780` both materialize `Analyze (actions)` but remain `queued` before execution with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`. Other current-head work has also materialized without reaching a terminal landing state; for example OSV changed-scope work and `scan-pr-queue` remain queued. The superseding exact-head cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. -#1733 has since moved through real source repairs to exact `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; all predecessor workflow evidence is therefore discarded for landing. The current head must regenerate every applicable required context and independent review. No source churn merely to retrigger, no predecessor-success transfer, no administrator bypass and no gate weakening are allowed. +Because `07cc438...` contains real repository-owned fail-closed source/test repairs, it must not be moved merely to retrigger hosted execution. All predecessor workflow evidence is discarded for landing. The unchanged current head must regenerate every applicable required context and independent review. No predecessor-success transfer, administrator bypass, self-approval or gate weakening is allowed. The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `09ac6366ddd018fd0085368f4b669ba797fd0158` through the required-workflow/code-scanning governance repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. From 3feb39e2ca4be622a6bdbd3fe1ce4264342c1854 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 21:45:30 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 050/110] docs(product-gap): record single-writer and governance repairs --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 14 +++++++++----- 1 file changed, 9 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index f2ae32896..195379c14 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR ## 3. Current high-leverage product gaps -`ACTIVE PR` means open/unmerged evidence, not protected-product authority. `PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT` means a prerequisite slice has landed but the remaining capability still requires its own exact-head acceptance. +`ACTIVE PR` means open/unmerged evidence, not protected-product authority. `ACTIVE DRAFT` means the live owner lane is intentionally non-landing while ownership, dependency or exact-head evidence is being repaired. `PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT` means a prerequisite slice has landed but the remaining capability still requires its own exact-head acceptance. | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | @@ -41,6 +41,8 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | +| Population-label admission | ACTIVE PR | canonical #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` | Preserve exact callback-free label identity and signed-int64 boundaries; platforms without genuinely wider `longdouble` precision must fail the relevant evidence rather than report a passing skip. | +| Compensatory 2PL response/result admission | ACTIVE PR | canonical #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Preserve Rust-owned likelihood/estimation/scoring, package-owned response/result snapshots and exact result envelopes; the branch is non-force restacked on current protected `main` and must regenerate all exact-head gates after that ancestry move. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; integrate parent first and regenerate child evidence after ancestry movement. | | RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and exact PyO3 result envelopes. RSM lossless-tolerance tests remain this lane's ownership, not #1733's. | | Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Temporal/administration sequence remains TEPP-owned. | @@ -49,7 +51,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot and `--locked` verification must cover root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz lock roots without silently leaving the production wheel graph stale. | | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Artifact must match public `FitConfig`/estimator vocabulary; unsupported identities remain unadvertised and fail closed; module entrypoint stays inside owned coverage. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; no unearned interval-coverage or longitudinal claim. | -| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE PR | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. The hook-order and atomic-write RED→GREEN lineage remains intact; current portability sweep additionally makes population-label, Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE, CDM and compensatory 2PL longdouble evidence fail explicitly when required wider precision is unavailable. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with active canonical writers #1699 and #1516. | +| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; canonical overlapping owners #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` and #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. #1733 remains Draft after single-writer review: population-label and 2PL portability deltas now belong to their canonical PRs and are only mirrored temporarily in #1733 until those owners integrate; Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE and CDM portability remain #1733-owned unless a fresh canonical writer is identified. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with #1699 and #1516. | | Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes and existing no-transition behavior; require current-head accessibility/test/security evidence. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` | Preserve focus target/ring, reduced-motion, semantic row headers and tabular numerals; regenerate every landing gate and qualifying review on the successor. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | @@ -78,7 +80,7 @@ A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × de `ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. -Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed development tips. Context Graph has **14 open PRs and 3 open issues**; new issue #26 is an external-metadata interoperability contract owner lane and does not change fast-mlsirm's scientific ownership. EA Core has **24 open PRs and 2 open issues**. Open foreign PR heads remain provisional evidence, not released authority. +Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed development tips. Context Graph has **14 open PRs and 3 open issues**; issue #26 is an external-metadata interoperability contract owner lane and does not change fast-mlsirm's scientific ownership. EA Core has **24 open PRs and 3 open issues**; issue #44 is the corresponding governed OpenMetadata projection consumer lane. Open foreign PR heads remain provisional evidence, not released authority. Context Graph release/source-provenance prerequisite #25 remains Draft on its owner path. EA consumer projection work remains fail closed on provisional Context Graph identity. fast-mlsirm must not pin mutable CGC/EA PR heads or copy estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics or scientific-validity evidence into EA authoritative architecture truth. @@ -90,9 +92,11 @@ Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repos Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is intentionally absent from that required-workflow list after `.github#1719` established that `github/codeql-action` cannot execute as a ruleset-required workflow. -That central correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. On #1733 current exact `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`, repository CodeQL run `33754522958` job `100645612648` and PR CodeQL run `33754512403` job `100645576780` both materialize `Analyze (actions)` but remain `queued` before execution with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`. Other current-head work has also materialized without reaching a terminal landing state; for example OSV changed-scope work and `scan-pr-queue` remain queued. The superseding exact-head cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. +The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -Because `07cc438...` contains real repository-owned fail-closed source/test repairs, it must not be moved merely to retrigger hosted execution. All predecessor workflow evidence is discarded for landing. The unchanged current head must regenerate every applicable required context and independent review. No predecessor-success transfer, administrator bypass, self-approval or gate weakening is allowed. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. On #1733 exact `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`, repository CodeQL run `33754522958` job `100645612648` and PR CodeQL run `33754512403` job `100645576780` both materialize `Analyze (actions)` but remain `queued` before execution with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`. Other current-head work has also materialized without reaching a terminal landing state; for example OSV changed-scope work and `scan-pr-queue` remain queued. The superseding exact-head cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. + +#1733 remains Draft after single-writer repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and its mirrored population-label/2PL portability deltas are not treated as ownership authority. #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop the temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. All predecessor workflow evidence is discarded after any head or ancestry movement. The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `09ac6366ddd018fd0085368f4b669ba797fd0158` through the required-workflow/code-scanning governance repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. From 192cef64711dc57f2e91f4a16e3e463576e0332c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 21:50:38 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 051/110] docs(product-gap): return longitudinal citation to owner lane --- ...tilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md b/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md index c4a7f4678..d6599d8b1 100644 --- a/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md +++ b/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-08-07-multilevel-multiple-membership-longitudinal-contracts-design.md @@ -150,7 +150,7 @@ Embretson, S. E. (1991). A multidimensional latent trait model for measuring lea Fox, J.-P., & Glas, C. A. W. (2001). Bayesian estimation of a multilevel IRT model using Gibbs sampling. *Psychometrika, 66*, 271–288. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02294839 -Jeon, M., & Rabe-Hesketh, S. (2016). An autoregressive growth model for longitudinal item analysis. *Psychometrika, 81*(3), 830–850. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-015-9489-2 +Jeon, M., & Rabe-Hesketh, S. (2025). An autoregressive growth model for longitudinal item analysis. *Psychometrika*. Advance online publication. Tranmer, M., Steel, D., & Browne, W. J. (2014). Multiple-membership multiple-classification models for social network and group dependencies. *Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society), 177*(2), 439–455. https://doi.org/10.1111/rssa.12021 From daf9046a1be255cc7018b77a10e3793d90ca5e04 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 22:15:57 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 052/110] docs(gaps): refresh model-specification repair evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 195379c14..fd599fab4 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE PR | #1714 `92a3f2152033b61ca89661b5ba8a584842e8c3a9` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion. | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `9a09bbd9cef4a7b8b4669c47be8c48287fc06152` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics and unique cross-classification-axis identity; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion; reacquire all exact-head evidence after the topology repair. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | @@ -94,9 +94,9 @@ Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requir The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. On #1733 exact `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`, repository CodeQL run `33754522958` job `100645612648` and PR CodeQL run `33754512403` job `100645576780` both materialize `Analyze (actions)` but remain `queued` before execution with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`. Other current-head work has also materialized without reaching a terminal landing state; for example OSV changed-scope work and `scan-pr-queue` remain queued. The superseding exact-head cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive model-specification repair gives a current canary on #1714 exact `9a09bbd9cef4a7b8b4669c47be8c48287fc06152`: repository CI run `33759478916` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33759478952` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100661929143` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution with `runner_id=null`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100661930535` completed `skipped`. OSV, Security Scan, Scorecard and Semgrep are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. -#1733 remains Draft after single-writer repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and its mirrored population-label/2PL portability deltas are not treated as ownership authority. #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop the temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. All predecessor workflow evidence is discarded after any head or ancestry movement. +#1714 remains Draft after its source-level RED → GREEN topology repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `09ac6366ddd018fd0085368f4b669ba797fd0158` through the required-workflow/code-scanning governance repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. From b605bba4d3411e40d97572ab788d9d1dab35e330 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 22:18:38 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 053/110] docs(gaps): follow central Scorecard owner advance --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index fd599fab4..3d1650619 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -98,7 +98,7 @@ The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsi #1714 remains Draft after its source-level RED → GREEN topology repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `09ac6366ddd018fd0085368f4b669ba797fd0158` through the required-workflow/code-scanning governance repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `51b812d181989ed28366b5850d1a34f51df10187` through the reusable Scorecard default-branch analysis repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities From da2919727bb9662d181d671b454fdd5f31e18a2e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 23:08:21 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 054/110] docs(product-gap): refresh context fabric and control-plane evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 10 ++++++---- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 3d1650619..d437b41fb 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -80,7 +80,9 @@ A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × de `ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. -Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed development tips. Context Graph has **14 open PRs and 3 open issues**; issue #26 is an external-metadata interoperability contract owner lane and does not change fast-mlsirm's scientific ownership. EA Core has **24 open PRs and 3 open issues**; issue #44 is the corresponding governed OpenMetadata projection consumer lane. Open foreign PR heads remain provisional evidence, not released authority. +Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed development tips. Context Graph has **14 open PRs and 4 open issues**; issue #27 is the provider-neutral external-capability contract owner lane and does not change fast-mlsirm's scientific ownership. EA Core has **24 open PRs and 4 open issues**; issue #45 is the corresponding external-capability portfolio/projection decision lane. Open foreign PR heads remain provisional evidence, not released authority. + +Current Context Graph and EA owner evidence explicitly records protected `main` as the intended Context Fabric integration/default target while live repository metadata still points to `develop` and the protect-main/default-transition is not yet coherent. Central `.github#1137` owns protect-main-first -> safe default switch -> inherited-ruleset reread -> stack reconstruction. This writer records that state only; it does not retarget, protect or restack either foreign repository. Context Graph release/source-provenance prerequisite #25 remains Draft on its owner path. EA consumer projection work remains fail closed on provisional Context Graph identity. fast-mlsirm must not pin mutable CGC/EA PR heads or copy estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics or scientific-validity evidence into EA authoritative architecture truth. @@ -94,14 +96,14 @@ Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requir The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive model-specification repair gives a current canary on #1714 exact `9a09bbd9cef4a7b8b4669c47be8c48287fc06152`: repository CI run `33759478916` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33759478952` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100661929143` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution with `runner_id=null`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100661930535` completed `skipped`. OSV, Security Scan, Scorecard and Semgrep are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive model-specification repair gives a current canary on #1714 exact `9a09bbd9cef4a7b8b4669c47be8c48287fc06152`: repository CI run `33759478916` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33759478952` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100661929143` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100661930535` completed `skipped`. OSV, Security Scan, Scorecard and Semgrep are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. #1714 remains Draft after its source-level RED → GREEN topology repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `51b812d181989ed28366b5850d1a34f51df10187` through the reusable Scorecard default-branch analysis repair. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `bf21572529b2f3382f88df56234eba508d342d39` after dependency maintenance advanced the owner branch. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear exact-head gates, priority remains evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect generalized Model Specification contracts to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 94a716d9ec4560b0d2636a05cd588fa9b7dc7bc6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 23:14:56 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 055/110] docs(product-gap): record current central control-plane tip --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index d437b41fb..00af721c9 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -100,7 +100,7 @@ The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsi #1714 remains Draft after its source-level RED → GREEN topology repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The latest observed protected central `.github/main` is `bf21572529b2f3382f88df56234eba508d342d39` after dependency maintenance advanced the owner branch. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `5afbf58cc62c8ff12a57c60d426d1352307fcd04` after `.github#1798` consolidated the Noema/OpenCode/Strix quality bootups. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities From 0bc60b75845e014fd920845c5febcb71fcd5d729 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Thu, 3 Sep 2026 23:46:44 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 056/110] docs(product-gap): bind dependence support to primary papers --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 00af721c9..1bced1612 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `9a09bbd9cef4a7b8b4669c47be8c48287fc06152` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics and unique cross-classification-axis identity; require exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion; reacquire all exact-head evidence after the topology repair. | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics and unique cross-classification-axis identity; an otherwise complete candidate must include the compiled dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion; reacquire all exact-head evidence after the citation-scope repair. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | @@ -96,9 +96,9 @@ Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requir The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive model-specification repair gives a current canary on #1714 exact `9a09bbd9cef4a7b8b4669c47be8c48287fc06152`: repository CI run `33759478916` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33759478952` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100661929143` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100661930535` completed `skipped`. OSV, Security Scan, Scorecard and Semgrep are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712`. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive model-specification repair gives a current canary on #1714 exact `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52`: repository CI run `33768500533` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33768500511` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100692387212` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100692389076` completed `skipped`. OSV `33768501170`, Security Scan `33768500540`, Scorecard `33768500472` and Semgrep `33768500550` are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` comment `5527481749`. -#1714 remains Draft after its source-level RED → GREEN topology repair. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. +#1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `47bd655cf8e535f935d6dc485c97050678e14db1` → GREEN `ac483f8fc7925d777fdee2dbc290cab59212087a` → governed `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52`: support promotion now rejects a syntactically valid but unrelated citation and requires the compiled dependence family's declared canonical primary citation in candidate-scoped evidence. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `5afbf58cc62c8ff12a57c60d426d1352307fcd04` after `.github#1798` consolidated the Noema/OpenCode/Strix quality bootups. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. From 793e45d301880bd2d462e3b8256f9ceb7c94fcae Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 00:15:44 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 057/110] docs(product-gap): refresh exact-head control-plane evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 10 ++++++---- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 1bced1612..6b5b8a262 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics and unique cross-classification-axis identity; an otherwise complete candidate must include the compiled dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion; reacquire all exact-head evidence after the citation-scope repair. | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics and unique cross-classification-axis identity; an otherwise complete candidate must include the compiled dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion; reacquire all exact-head evidence after the citation-scope repair. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | @@ -96,11 +96,13 @@ Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requir The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive model-specification repair gives a current canary on #1714 exact `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52`: repository CI run `33768500533` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33768500511` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100692387212` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100692389076` completed `skipped`. OSV `33768501170`, Security Scan `33768500540`, Scorecard `33768500472` and Semgrep `33768500550` are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` comment `5527481749`. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive Model Specification repair gives a current canary on Draft #1714 exact `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: repository CI run `33769348145` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33769348105` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100695270667` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100695272400` is terminal skipped. Security Scan `33769348051`, Semgrep `33769348028`, OSV `33769348640` and Scorecard `33769348195` are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` comment `5527585614`. -#1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `47bd655cf8e535f935d6dc485c97050678e14db1` → GREEN `ac483f8fc7925d777fdee2dbc290cab59212087a` → governed `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52`: support promotion now rejects a syntactically valid but unrelated citation and requires the compiled dependence family's declared canonical primary citation in candidate-scoped evidence. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. +A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. -The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `5afbf58cc62c8ff12a57c60d426d1352307fcd04` after `.github#1798` consolidated the Noema/OpenCode/Strix quality bootups. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +#1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `47bd655cf8e535f935d6dc485c97050678e14db1` → GREEN `ac483f8fc7925d777fdee2dbc290cab59212087a` → changelog `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52` → governed current `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: support promotion rejects a syntactically valid but unrelated citation and requires the compiled dependence family's declared canonical primary citation in candidate-scoped evidence. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. + +The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `269e5bd9e65c38770a827af1291a5657d5cfcd01` after `.github#1803` repaired scheduler handling for shared installation rate limits. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities From dd3f075ad3d30982a7f878da9140832c7f202789 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 01:14:35 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 058/110] docs(product-gap): refresh control-plane evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 12 ++++++++---- 1 file changed, 8 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 6b5b8a262..5c84b8f3c 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory** Protected-product basis: `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c` -Observation date: 2026-09-03 +Observation date: 2026-09-04 This file is a commercialization and technical-gap inventory, not runtime authority. A capability is authoritative only after its source is integrated into protected `main` and the applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence is terminal success on one unchanged exact head. Open PRs, Drafts, successful predecessor checks and mutable sibling branches are evidence inputs, not product claims. @@ -92,20 +92,24 @@ Architecture/lifecycle facts may be projected only after a released versioned Co Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repository branch protection currently hard-requires status contexts including `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package`, and `fuzz`. -Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is intentionally absent from that required-workflow list after `.github#1719` established that `github/codeql-action` cannot execute as a ruleset-required workflow. +Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is not in that nine-workflow ruleset; repository branch protection independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. + +Central `.github/main@0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145` now carries the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` no longer invokes `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this new architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive Model Specification repair gives a current canary on Draft #1714 exact `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: repository CI run `33769348145` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33769348105` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100695270667` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100695272400` is terminal skipped. Security Scan `33769348051`, Semgrep `33769348028`, OSV `33769348640` and Scorecard `33769348195` are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` comment `5527585614`. +A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` now distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. + A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. #1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `47bd655cf8e535f935d6dc485c97050678e14db1` → GREEN `ac483f8fc7925d777fdee2dbc290cab59212087a` → changelog `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52` → governed current `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: support promotion rejects a syntactically valid but unrelated citation and requires the compiled dependence family's declared canonical primary citation in candidate-scoped evidence. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `269e5bd9e65c38770a827af1291a5657d5cfcd01` after `.github#1803` repaired scheduler handling for shared installation rate limits. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear exact-head gates, priority remains evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect generalized Model Specification contracts to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From 61ea41c6329c9484c486230a7df9cc89a6ff662c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 02:09:49 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 059/110] docs(product-gap): refresh central owner evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 5c84b8f3c..e77e2bd42 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -94,7 +94,7 @@ Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repos Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is not in that nine-workflow ruleset; repository branch protection independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. -Central `.github/main@0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145` now carries the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` no longer invokes `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this new architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. +Central `.github/main@72f63c9e32194512fd5358ba4bff6ac4365be8d7` carries the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture inherited from parent `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145`: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` does not invoke `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. The current central tip additionally contains #1811's behavior-preserving `extract_model_prose` no-marker fast path; that perf-only successor does not change the recorded CodeQL ownership or timeout/provider boundary. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this new architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. @@ -106,10 +106,10 @@ A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52b #1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `47bd655cf8e535f935d6dc485c97050678e14db1` → GREEN `ac483f8fc7925d777fdee2dbc290cab59212087a` → changelog `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52` → governed current `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: support promotion rejects a syntactically valid but unrelated citation and requires the compiled dependence family's declared canonical primary citation in candidate-scoped evidence. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `72f63c9e32194512fd5358ba4bff6ac4365be8d7`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear exact-head gates, priority remains evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect generalized Model Specification contracts to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file From 5dc14381a2031cee050da1f5878d70801ecbad1f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 03:10:43 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 060/110] docs(product-gap): refresh model-specification canary --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 10 +++++----- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index e77e2bd42..885d5a682 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics and unique cross-classification-axis identity; an otherwise complete candidate must include the compiled dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery before promotion; reacquire all exact-head evidence after the citation-scope repair. | +| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics, unique cross-classification-axis identity and one coherent candidate manifest snapshot. Candidate evidence admission must reject caller-controlled mapping callbacks before identity-dependent lookup; support still requires the dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. Reacquire all exact-head evidence after the admission-boundary repair. | | TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | @@ -94,19 +94,19 @@ Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repos Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is not in that nine-workflow ruleset; repository branch protection independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. -Central `.github/main@72f63c9e32194512fd5358ba4bff6ac4365be8d7` carries the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture inherited from parent `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145`: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` does not invoke `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. The current central tip additionally contains #1811's behavior-preserving `extract_model_prose` no-marker fast path; that perf-only successor does not change the recorded CodeQL ownership or timeout/provider boundary. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this new architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. +Central `.github/main@7c82b661ca2daf7d9d122465c86c3123429e83e7` carries the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture inherited from `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145` through `72f63c9e32194512fd5358ba4bff6ac4365be8d7`: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` does not invoke `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. The current central tip adds #1813's bounded concurrent agent-ledger artifact fetch and does not alter CodeQL ownership, workflow dispatch semantics or the fast-mlsirm scientific contract. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. A fresh substantive Model Specification repair gives a current canary on Draft #1714 exact `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: repository CI run `33769348145` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; CodeQL run `33769348105` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100695270667` but it remains queued before runner assignment/source execution, while sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100695272400` is terminal skipped. Security Scan `33769348051`, Semgrep `33769348028`, OSV `33769348640` and Scorecard `33769348195` are also non-passing on that unchanged head. The exact cross-layer branch-protection/workflow reconciliation and runner-acquisition RED/GREEN acceptance are recorded on canonical central owner path `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712` comment `5527585614`. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. Draft #1714 now provides a substantive current canary on exact `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`, after RED `e311584cbf3c2a176f8ac36179ec2f19fa6de9d4` and GREEN `ac80b652ef05da0fbfef93ed77f748f334170c84` repaired the evidence-mapping callback seam and the current docs head recorded that contract. CodeQL run `33788654326` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100759542078`, but it remains queued with `runner_id=0` and no steps; sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100759543354` is terminal skipped. CI run `33788654273` is still pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33788654595`, Semgrep `33788654388`, OSV `33788655427` and Scorecard `33788654196` are also non-passing on that exact head. This current-head canary supersedes #1714 predecessor workflow state without transferring any predecessor success. A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` now distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. -#1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `47bd655cf8e535f935d6dc485c97050678e14db1` → GREEN `ac483f8fc7925d777fdee2dbc290cab59212087a` → changelog `ab69cfe0b472afe6d6a0d065b1a6828b6b7eba52` → governed current `91cbf116f8f91e0e25d0c656215b11a3bf359055`: support promotion rejects a syntactically valid but unrelated citation and requires the compiled dependence family's declared canonical primary citation in candidate-scoped evidence. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. +#1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `e311584cbf3c2a176f8ac36179ec2f19fa6de9d4` → GREEN `ac80b652ef05da0fbfef93ed77f748f334170c84` → governed current `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`: evidence lookup is now admitted as an exact built-in dictionary and snapshotted before identity-dependent compilation, so a mapping subclass cannot mutate structural state between candidate identity construction and manifest assembly. The same candidate still requires dependence-family primary citation, exact candidate-scoped estimator/identification/recovery evidence and all current scientific promotion gates. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `72f63c9e32194512fd5358ba4bff6ac4365be8d7`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `7c82b661ca2daf7d9d122465c86c3123429e83e7`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities From 0a8784e9fcc99637c6e48407853e7ca85b4357af Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 04:06:41 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 061/110] docs(product-gap): refresh central and TEPP evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 885d5a682..1047326ad 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics, unique cross-classification-axis identity and one coherent candidate manifest snapshot. Candidate evidence admission must reject caller-controlled mapping callbacks before identity-dependent lookup; support still requires the dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. Reacquire all exact-head evidence after the admission-boundary repair. | -| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `91c6563c2a3c4d8bddd75b94d261d92e864cf97e` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. | +| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `fcaeeed79c77a7b00eb8d6c053001c92471c6b6b` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. The current head also corrects the Jeon & Rabe-Hesketh longitudinal growth citation to the 2016 Psychometrika publication and DOI `10.1007/s11336-015-9489-2`. | | Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | | Population-label admission | ACTIVE PR | canonical #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` | Preserve exact callback-free label identity and signed-int64 boundaries; platforms without genuinely wider `longdouble` precision must fail the relevant evidence rather than report a passing skip. | @@ -94,7 +94,7 @@ Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repos Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is not in that nine-workflow ruleset; repository branch protection independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. -Central `.github/main@7c82b661ca2daf7d9d122465c86c3123429e83e7` carries the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture inherited from `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145` through `72f63c9e32194512fd5358ba4bff6ac4365be8d7`: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` does not invoke `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. The current central tip adds #1813's bounded concurrent agent-ledger artifact fetch and does not alter CodeQL ownership, workflow dispatch semantics or the fast-mlsirm scientific contract. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. +Central `.github/main@07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b` retains the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture inherited from `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145` through `7c82b661ca2daf7d9d122465c86c3123429e83e7`: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` does not invoke `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. The current central tip removes the dormant direct NVIDIA NIM provider block from OpenCode's repository config, keeps automated review paths gateway-only, bounds required-workflow-bootstrap extraction to the intended job, and repairs review-dispatch blob/head-SHA contract drift. Those are central routing/workflow controls, not fast-mlsirm scientific ownership. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. @@ -106,10 +106,10 @@ A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52b #1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `e311584cbf3c2a176f8ac36179ec2f19fa6de9d4` → GREEN `ac80b652ef05da0fbfef93ed77f748f334170c84` → governed current `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`: evidence lookup is now admitted as an exact built-in dictionary and snapshotted before identity-dependent compilation, so a mapping subclass cannot mutate structural state between candidate identity construction and manifest assembly. The same candidate still requires dependence-family primary citation, exact candidate-scoped estimator/identification/recovery evidence and all current scientific promotion gates. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. -The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `7c82b661ca2daf7d9d122465c86c3123429e83e7`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. ## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities After active lanes clear exact-head gates, priority remains evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect generalized Model Specification contracts to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. \ No newline at end of file +This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. From 4a69ce022c1582d3a5b269963a0fc5dc70a80076 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 05:05:47 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 062/110] docs(product-gap): record marginal reduction reproducibility repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 7 ++++--- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 1047326ad..89977dfab 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -54,9 +54,10 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; canonical overlapping owners #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` and #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. #1733 remains Draft after single-writer review: population-label and 2PL portability deltas now belong to their canonical PRs and are only mirrored temporarily in #1733 until those owners integrate; Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE and CDM portability remain #1733-owned unless a fresh canonical writer is identified. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with #1699 and #1516. | | Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes and existing no-transition behavior; require current-head accessibility/test/security evidence. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` | Preserve focus target/ring, reduced-motion, semantic row headers and tabular numerals; regenerate every landing gate and qualifying review on the successor. | +| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | repaired #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Keep the established deterministic CPU-f64 item-objective reduction identity until a numerical-contract decision is backed by reproducible profiling plus realistic recovery/parity evidence. The original `np.vdot`/`np.einsum` optimization changed accumulation order and carried unsupported speed claims; production and `.jules` deltas were restored byte-for-byte to protected main and only the focused reproducibility regression remains. Material hot-path optimization should prefer the canonical Rust owner. | | Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | -Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **53 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. +Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **54 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. ## 4. Scientific acceptance model @@ -98,9 +99,9 @@ Central `.github/main@07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b` retains the Code The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. Draft #1714 now provides a substantive current canary on exact `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`, after RED `e311584cbf3c2a176f8ac36179ec2f19fa6de9d4` and GREEN `ac80b652ef05da0fbfef93ed77f748f334170c84` repaired the evidence-mapping callback seam and the current docs head recorded that contract. CodeQL run `33788654326` has materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100759542078`, but it remains queued with `runner_id=0` and no steps; sibling `Analyze (python)` job `100759543354` is terminal skipped. CI run `33788654273` is still pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33788654595`, Semgrep `33788654388`, OSV `33788655427` and Scorecard `33788654196` are also non-passing on that exact head. This current-head canary supersedes #1714 predecessor workflow state without transferring any predecessor success. +The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. Draft #1714 provides a substantive canary on exact `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`, where CodeQL materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100759542078` but left it queued with `runner_id=0` and no steps while CI remained pending with `jobs=[]`. Draft #1742 now reproduces the split on a different substantive exact head after a numerical RED/GREEN repair: CodeQL run `33799969635` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100796804484`, still queued with no steps, while CI run `33799969594` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; repository Security Scan `33799969622`, Semgrep `33799969530`, OSV `33799970270` and Scorecard `33799969563` were also non-terminal at observation. This is current-head evidence of post-dispatch job materialization without runner/source execution, not permission to churn leaf source. -A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` now distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. +A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. From 38b911dfd8927fb5d5f6faca06a87031284c9e44 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 06:09:12 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 063/110] docs(product-gap): record JSON depth evidence regression repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 3 +++ 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 89977dfab..0c16a594f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -52,6 +52,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Artifact must match public `FitConfig`/estimator vocabulary; unsupported identities remain unadvertised and fail closed; module entrypoint stays inside owned coverage. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; no unearned interval-coverage or longitudinal claim. | | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; canonical overlapping owners #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` and #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. #1733 remains Draft after single-writer review: population-label and 2PL portability deltas now belong to their canonical PRs and are only mirrored temporarily in #1733 until those owners integrate; Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE and CDM portability remain #1733-owned unless a fresh canonical writer is identified. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with #1699 and #1516. | +| JSON depth preflight underflow hardening | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Preserve the existing quoted-string/escape state machines and floor structural depth at zero in all five repository-owned raw scanners. The focused regression must prove unmatched structural closers cannot offset later over-budget nesting and that bounded file input rejects before `json.loads()`. The effective delta must remain causal; predecessor review/check evidence does not transfer after head movement. | | Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes and existing no-transition behavior; require current-head accessibility/test/security evidence. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` | Preserve focus target/ring, reduced-motion, semantic row headers and tabular numerals; regenerate every landing gate and qualifying review on the successor. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | repaired #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Keep the established deterministic CPU-f64 item-objective reduction identity until a numerical-contract decision is backed by reproducible profiling plus realistic recovery/parity evidence. The original `np.vdot`/`np.einsum` optimization changed accumulation order and carried unsupported speed claims; production and `.jules` deltas were restored byte-for-byte to protected main and only the focused reproducibility regression remains. Material hot-path optimization should prefer the canonical Rust owner. | @@ -101,6 +102,8 @@ The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect unde The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. Draft #1714 provides a substantive canary on exact `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`, where CodeQL materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100759542078` but left it queued with `runner_id=0` and no steps while CI remained pending with `jobs=[]`. Draft #1742 now reproduces the split on a different substantive exact head after a numerical RED/GREEN repair: CodeQL run `33799969635` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100796804484`, still queued with no steps, while CI run `33799969594` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; repository Security Scan `33799969622`, Semgrep `33799969530`, OSV `33799970270` and Scorecard `33799969563` were also non-terminal at observation. This is current-head evidence of post-dispatch job materialization without runner/source execution, not permission to churn leaf source. +Draft #1738 now provides the same split after a substantive security/test repair on exact `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18`. Intervening same-branch commit `e6f9fe2dcc36bd3ac73817d65647f359a426e81d` retained the five production depth-floor guards but deleted the focused regression and reintroduced inaccurate documentation; forward commits restored the five-scanner regression and reduced `.jules/sentinel.md` to a causal underflow entry without force-updating history. CodeQL run `33806098110` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100816807693`, still queued with no runner identity and `steps=[]`, while CI run `33806098118` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33806098045`, Semgrep `33806098062`, Scorecard `33806098094`, and OSV `33806098617` were also non-terminal. The exact canary and GREEN acceptance are recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5532150096`; no predecessor success transfers to this Draft head. + A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. From 765effb97f9b8891cd192bb6e668799eb90d0796 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 08:09:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 064/110] docs(product-gap): record sealed capability authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 4 +++- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 0c16a594f..8c5077556 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR | Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible publish sinks depend on the evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Internal Cargo packages remain `publish = false`; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product absent a separately governed Rust SDK. | | Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot and `--locked` verification must cover root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz lock roots without silently leaving the production wheel graph stale. | -| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE PR | #1710 `b6336aab9ba1bf2a39acd5a1f13108dc3655d746` | Artifact must match public `FitConfig`/estimator vocabulary; unsupported identities remain unadvertised and fail closed; module entrypoint stays inside owned coverage. | +| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `711055d49a7fcea7a0aa7a2536d9227a827b8c1f` | Keep the canonical matrix bound to public `FitConfig`/estimator admission, store authority in package-owned primitive rows, return fresh validated `FitCapability` value objects, and reject forged direct construction. Caller mutation of a returned frozen record must not redefine later support or manifest evidence. Reacquire every exact-head gate after this Public Binding repair. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; no unearned interval-coverage or longitudinal claim. | | Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; canonical overlapping owners #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` and #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. #1733 remains Draft after single-writer review: population-label and 2PL portability deltas now belong to their canonical PRs and are only mirrored temporarily in #1733 until those owners integrate; Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE and CDM portability remain #1733-owned unless a fresh canonical writer is identified. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with #1699 and #1516. | | JSON depth preflight underflow hardening | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Preserve the existing quoted-string/escape state machines and floor structural depth at zero in all five repository-owned raw scanners. The focused regression must prove unmatched structural closers cannot offset later over-budget nesting and that bounded file input rejects before `json.loads()`. The effective delta must remain causal; predecessor review/check evidence does not transfer after head movement. | @@ -104,6 +104,8 @@ The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsi Draft #1738 now provides the same split after a substantive security/test repair on exact `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18`. Intervening same-branch commit `e6f9fe2dcc36bd3ac73817d65647f359a426e81d` retained the five production depth-floor guards but deleted the focused regression and reintroduced inaccurate documentation; forward commits restored the five-scanner regression and reduced `.jules/sentinel.md` to a causal underflow entry without force-updating history. CodeQL run `33806098110` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100816807693`, still queued with no runner identity and `steps=[]`, while CI run `33806098118` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33806098045`, Semgrep `33806098062`, Scorecard `33806098094`, and OSV `33806098617` were also non-terminal. The exact canary and GREEN acceptance are recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5532150096`; no predecessor success transfers to this Draft head. +Draft #1710 now provides a Public Binding canary after substantive RED `e0d0d84057cbbb148a2b23c99f68780497e9f8e4` → GREEN `42cbb20e78987335ca03fd51b83e0640ca641749` → governed exact `711055d49a7fcea7a0aa7a2536d9227a827b8c1f`. The repair removes shared caller-visible frozen-record authority and rejects forged support records without changing the canonical support matrix or Rust numerical ownership. CodeQL run `33816051167` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100848322796` but it remains queued with no runner identity and `steps=[]`; CI run `33816051217` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Security Scan `33816051243`, Semgrep `33816051351`, OSV `33816051772`, and Scorecard `33816051273` are also non-terminal. The exact consumer evidence and GREEN acceptance are recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5533270637`; no predecessor gate/review result transfers to this Draft head. + A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. From 1957366922fbf0bcc5e46da60efd82a3f1e65d44 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 10:02:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 065/110] docs(product-gap): restore preserved baseline before refresh --- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | 1069 ++++++++++++++++++++++-- 1 file changed, 992 insertions(+), 77 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md index 8c5077556..e025d854e 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md @@ -1,121 +1,1036 @@ # Product and technical gap baseline -Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory** -Protected-product basis: `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c` -Observation date: 2026-09-04 +Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time product-completion inventory**
+Observed at: **2026-08-25T05:20:00Z**
+Protected-main basis: **`9c12eab15fb8a187b135f9be1961f0693a431c23`**
+Repository: **`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm`** -This file is a commercialization and technical-gap inventory, not runtime authority. A capability is authoritative only after its source is integrated into protected `main` and the applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence is terminal success on one unchanged exact head. Open PRs, Drafts, successful predecessor checks and mutable sibling branches are evidence inputs, not product claims. +## 1. Purpose and authority -## 1. Product and ownership boundary +This document answers one bounded question: -`fast-mlsirm` is the canonical reusable psychometric numerical engine for LSIRM/MLSIRM/MLS2PLM and adjacent dependence/IRT families. Production likelihood, optimization, scoring, information/uncertainty, covariance/correlation, simulation/recovery and other result-affecting vector/linear/matrix arithmetic belong in Rust/PyO3. Python is limited to validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity surfaces that do not become a second numerical implementation. +> What remains before `fast-mlsirm` can make a defensible technical-GA claim, and what additional evidence remains before a downstream product can make a validated domain or high-stakes use claim? -The internal DDD boundary is **Model Specification**, **Estimation**, **Scoring**, **Diagnostics**, **Simulation-Recovery**, **Compute Backend** and **Public Binding**. Cross-context interaction uses explicit contracts rather than implementation imports. TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition; fast-mlsirm may own reusable time-indexed psychometric kernels over explicit supplied occasion/time carriers but does not own TEPP clocks, event ontology or temporal workflow semantics. `contextual-orchestrator` owns LLM/provider routing. Scientific/domain truth stays with its canonical owner; cross-service SQL and source copying are prohibited. +This file is an inventory and routing aid. It is **not** a competing PRD, TRD, +architecture, ADR, release manifest, or statement of shipped capability. +Canonical authority remains: -Rasch and generic 1PL are not synonyms in product claims. 2PL/3PL/4PL, bifactor, higher-order, two-tier, multifacet/multifactor, cross-loading, DIF, CAT/ATA and generalized dependence support are promotable only for an exact formulation with primary research grounding, identification constraints, deterministic public contract and formulation-specific recovery evidence. +- [`docs/PRD.md`](PRD.md); +- [`docs/TRD.md`](TRD.md); +- [`../ARCHITECTURE.md`](../ARCHITECTURE.md); +- [`docs/documentation_coverage.md`](documentation_coverage.md); +- the status-bearing ADR graph; and +- [issue #621](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/621), or its explicitly accepted successor, for cross-cutting documentation fitness. -## 2. Commercial merge and release gates +Protected `main` is shipped truth. An issue, open pull request, green check on an +unmerged head, review comment, branch description, scheduler state, or this +inventory is evidence only. Before acting on any row below, re-fetch: -A change is commercially merge-ready only when all applicable evidence refers to the same unchanged exact head: +1. protected-main SHA; +2. pull-request head and live base; +3. draft/ready and mergeability state; +4. current-head reviews and unresolved threads; +5. required checks; and +6. active writer/overlapping-path ownership. -- deterministic focused and full tests, without skip/xfail/source rewriting or coverage-denominator tricks hiding a failing owned path; -- realistic known-truth simulation/recovery with deterministic seed manifests, convergence/failure accounting, bias and RMSE, and empirical interval coverage when uncertainty is claimed; -- CPU worker-count determinism and CPU/GPU parity for every path that advertises both backends; -- 100% owned production statement/branch coverage and 100% public rustdoc/docstring coverage under the repository contract; -- package/build/install evidence, including installed-wheel execution rather than source-tree import only; -- security/static-analysis/fuzz/dependency evidence plus required SBOM/provenance evidence; -- zero valid unresolved review findings and the qualifying approval required by the live policy; -- normal protected merge without self-approval, bypass, gate weakening, force update or predecessor-evidence transfer. +No predecessor-head check or review transfers after a head or live-base change. -Queued, pending, in-progress, cancelled, skipped, absent and `startup_failure` states are non-passing but are not reasons to churn a clean source head. A release additionally requires one exact integrated protected head with recovery, package/install, reproducibility and rollback evidence; coherent version/CHANGELOG/tag state; immutable distribution/SBOM/provenance evidence; publish success; and post-publish verification. +## 2. Executive disposition -The latest immutable GitHub release remains `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26). PR #1471 proposes `v0.9.2`, but it is not release authority while upstream product, dependency and supply-chain lanes remain open. +At the observed protected-main SHA, `fast-mlsirm` is a substantial Rust/PyO3 +psychometric measurement core, but a general technical-GA or universal +high-stakes readiness claim is not yet defensible. -## 3. Current high-leverage product gaps +The strongest remaining completion dependencies are: -`ACTIVE PR` means open/unmerged evidence, not protected-product authority. `ACTIVE DRAFT` means the live owner lane is intentionally non-landing while ownership, dependency or exact-head evidence is being repaired. `PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT` means a prerequisite slice has landed but the remaining capability still requires its own exact-head acceptance. +1. finish one Rust-owned ordinary production numerical boundary with no silent + Python fallback; +2. integrate and validate the multilevel, multiple-membership, longitudinal, + model-selection, and recovery slices that are currently split across issues + and active PRs; +3. add independent cross-engine equation and fitted-result conformance evidence; +4. add preregistered external-validity and transportability evidence profiles; +5. freeze a bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix instead of treating every + research or planned model as part of GA; +6. complete stable artifact/version/migration, release, support, supply-chain, + benchmark, and rollback evidence; and +7. prove at least one buyer-visible end-to-end workflow through an owning + downstream product without moving hosted identity, consent, persistence, or + decision governance into this reusable core. -| Gap | Maturity | Current exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | +A package can reach **technical GA** while particular domain or high-stakes use +profiles remain unvalidated. Technical correctness, construct validity, +transportability, fairness, and decision utility are separate claims. + +## 3. Current protected-main product truth + +The observed protected main declares: + +- package version **`0.9.0`**; +- Python **`>=3.12`**; +- Maturin/PyO3 bindings to the Rust workspace; +- PyPI classifier **`Development Status :: 3 - Alpha`**; and +- an “early high-performance toolkit” product description. + +Protected main already provides substantial evidence and usable primitives, +including: + +- Rust/PyO3 likelihood, optimization, diagnostic, scoring, linking, CAT/ATA, + and selected GPU/CPU parity paths; +- deterministic simulation and true-parameter recovery infrastructure; +- governed rubric, scoring, evidence, RAG, essay, enterprise-issue, and + item-bank contracts; +- fail-closed validation and bounded-resource controls; +- package/wheel/reinstall, fuzz, security, SAST, and protected-check gates; +- accessible standalone reports and content-addressed provenance patterns; and +- canonical PRD/TRD/architecture, V&V, threat-model, standards-watch, + UML/ERD, and traceability families. + +The protected-main documentation audit still classifies several release-critical +families as **PARTIAL**, notably: + +- public interface/version/serialization/fingerprint contracts; +- reusable-core operability and recovery; +- security/data-governance navigation; +- release/migration/rollback/provenance/licensing navigation; +- requirements traceability and selected UML/ERD coverage; and +- root README/AGENTS/CLAUDE/Architecture/PRD/TRD/CHANGELOG alignment. + +Those states are not cosmetic documentation tasks. They identify product +contracts that a buyer, downstream integrator, or maintainer still cannot +reconstruct reliably without source archaeology. + +## 4. Product boundary + +### 4.1 `fast-mlsirm` owns + +- domain-neutral psychometric numerical kernels; +- public simulation, fitting, scoring, diagnostics, comparison, linking, CAT, + ATA, recovery, and evidence contracts that are explicitly integrated on + protected main; +- Rust-first numerical ownership, deterministic Python validation/marshalling, + bounded resource controls, and versioned reusable artifacts; +- package-level V&V, benchmark, security, interoperability, provenance, and + release evidence; and +- source-text-free reports and handoff contracts. + +### 4.2 Downstream products own + +`ContextualWisdomLab/psychometrics-commons` or another explicitly owning host +owns, as applicable: + +- tenants, accounts, OIDC/SSO/SCIM and authorization; +- participants, sessions, consent, data-rights and purpose limitation; +- hosted persistence, object storage, queues, APIs, UI and billing; +- operational item banks and restricted test content; +- human review, approval, administration and incident workflows; +- domain-specific external validation data and high-stakes decision policy; and +- regulated deployment, retention, deletion and audit execution. + +The downstream host may consume `fast-mlsirm` only through a traceable, +versioned handoff: a released package and schema version, a versioned API/schema, +or an immutable content-addressed artifact reference. The consumer records the +package/artifact version, source commit, schema version, and environment +provenance used for each result. A floating branch checkout or unrecorded +implementation import is not a reusable integration contract. `fast-mlsirm` +must not depend on that host to remain installable and useful as a standalone +library. + +### 4.3 Explicit non-goals for this repository + +- a universal validity or fairness certification; +- a hosted assessment/session database; +- direct storage of operational PII or restricted test content; +- automatic causal claims from observational scores; +- provider-specific LLM execution inside the numerical core; +- treating one external package as an unquestionable oracle; +- a machine-generated acquisition valuation or guaranteed sale price; and +- declaring every planned model family part of a 1.0 support promise. + +### 4.4 Versioned downstream handoff + +The reusable-core boundary is actionable only when a consumer can identify the +artifact it is allowed to import and the owner of the surrounding lifecycle. +The current handoff therefore follows these repository contracts: + +- [`docs/scoring_assessment_contracts.md`](scoring_assessment_contracts.md) and + [`docs/scoring_execution_contracts.md`](scoring_execution_contracts.md) define + the package-owned request, observation, scoring, and execution surfaces; +- [`docs/enterprise_issue_evidence_contracts.md`](enterprise_issue_evidence_contracts.md) + defines source-free evidence handoff for an owning product; and +- [`docs/adr/0001-domain-neutral-measurement-boundary.md`](adr/0001-domain-neutral-measurement-boundary.md), + [`docs/adr/0003-content-addressed-measurement-contracts.md`](adr/0003-content-addressed-measurement-contracts.md), + and [`docs/adr/0013-continuous-execution-and-documentation-governance.md`](adr/0013-continuous-execution-and-documentation-governance.md) + define ownership, immutable provenance, and documentation authority. + +Consumers must pin a released package/artifact schema and record its source and +environment provenance. A downstream host owns participant/session/consent, +authorization, persistence, raw content, human decisions, and regulated +retention; this baseline does not create a second database or HTTP contract. +The handoff is therefore reusable across `psychometrics-commons` and other +consumers while `fast-mlsirm` remains independently installable. + +## 5. Completion profiles + +### 5.1 Technical alpha + +This is the current declared package line. Useful APIs may exist, but public +contracts, support scope, scientific evidence, compatibility, and operational +surfaces can still change before 1.0. + +### 5.2 Technical GA — reusable measurement core + +A technical-GA profile requires a bounded, versioned list of supported public +capabilities. For every listed capability, the profile must provide: + +- one ordinary Rust/PyO3 production numerical owner; +- fail-closed behavior when that owner is missing or incompatible; +- explicit identification, estimand, model/estimator compatibility, resource, + missingness, and convergence contracts; +- true-parameter recovery or inferential error evidence appropriate to the + claim, including Monte Carlo uncertainty where stochastic; +- independent cross-engine conformance where a scientifically equivalent + implementation exists; +- stable public API and artifact schemas with migration/rollback policy; +- exact supported Python/platform/backend matrix; +- 100% repository-required production statement/branch coverage and public + docstring evidence; +- benchmark/capacity evidence and bounded failure behavior; +- security, fuzz, package/reinstall, SBOM, provenance and licensing evidence; +- current support and vulnerability-reporting policy; and +- one unchanged exact head satisfying all required reviews and checks. + +A capability that lacks the required evidence remains experimental, research, +planned, or explicitly outside the GA profile; it does not block unrelated, +bounded GA capabilities. + +### 5.3 Validated domain profile + +A domain profile binds the technical core to one assessment, rubric/item-bank, +population, setting, language, time period, criterion, and intended score use. +It additionally requires content/response-process, internal-structure, +external-variable, transportability, fairness, and consequence evidence. + +A domain profile is versioned independently of the Python package. A package +upgrade does not automatically validate an old profile, and a validated profile +does not approve every other use of the same estimator. + +### 5.4 High-stakes use profile + +A high-stakes profile additionally requires the owning product’s legal, +privacy, security, human-governance, accessibility, adverse-impact, +monitoring, incident, appeal, and decision-policy controls. This status cannot +be inferred from software tests, parameter recovery, cross-engine agreement, +or a passed package release gate. + +## 6. Status vocabulary used here + +This baseline reuses the repository’s canonical capability vocabulary: + +- **IMPLEMENTED_ON_PROTECTED_MAIN**; +- **IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR**; +- **PARTIAL**; +- **ACCEPTED_ARCHITECTURE**; +- **PLANNED**; +- **RESEARCH_ONLY**; +- **DOWNSTREAM**; +- **SUPERSEDED**; +- **REJECTED**; and +- **OUT_OF_SCOPE**. + +For live PR rows, **RECHECK_REQUIRED** is only a snapshot annotation. It is not a +new canonical capability-maturity state. + +## 7. Current pull-request evidence + +The following table records high-leverage live work observed on +2026-08-25T05:20:00Z against protected +`main@9c12eab15fb8a187b135f9be1961f0693a431c23`. Every row is +**IMPLEMENTED_ON_ACTIVE_PR / RECHECK_REQUIRED**, never shipped truth. A green +check on any row is not a protected-main capability until the PR is merged. + +| PR | Observed head | Observed role | Completion dependency / caution | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Generalized dependence/model specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics, unique cross-classification-axis identity and one coherent candidate manifest snapshot. Candidate evidence admission must reject caller-controlled mapping callbacks before identity-dependent lookup; support still requires the dependence family's canonical primary-paper citation, exact equation, identification, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. Reacquire all exact-head evidence after the admission-boundary repair. | -| TEPP temporal ownership boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1716 `fcaeeed79c77a7b00eb8d6c053001c92471c6b6b` | PRD/TRD/ADR/Context Map and executable fitness tests must agree that TEPP owns temporal/event composition while this repository owns reusable psychometric numerics only. The current head also corrects the Jeon & Rabe-Hesketh longitudinal growth citation to the 2016 Psychometrika publication and DOI `10.1007/s11336-015-9489-2`. | -| Acquisition/readiness, hosted-runner identity and GPU merge-gate parity | ACTIVE PR | #1717 `a53033aa949faf6494945eeff83c3f920c7cbf09` | Protected `python` evidence must include CPU matrix and explicit GPU parity success on the same current head. | -| Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Exact represented-input admission, scale/permutation invariance and Rust numerical ownership; TEPP may consume only an immutable released versioned contract. | -| Population-label admission | ACTIVE PR | canonical #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` | Preserve exact callback-free label identity and signed-int64 boundaries; platforms without genuinely wider `longdouble` precision must fail the relevant evidence rather than report a passing skip. | -| Compensatory 2PL response/result admission | ACTIVE PR | canonical #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Preserve Rust-owned likelihood/estimation/scoring, package-owned response/result snapshots and exact result envelopes; the branch is non-force restacked on current protected `main` and must regenerate all exact-head gates after that ancestry move. | -| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | canonical #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control hardening and caller-governed `lower_bound`/`alpha`; integrate parent first and regenerate child evidence after ancestry movement. | -| RSM response/result provenance boundary | ACTIVE PR | #1699 `ac9658ebda1d69a86c1ba61ab8ef36a2e346c573` | Keep likelihood/ECM/scoring arithmetic Rust-owned while sealing caller response evidence and exact PyO3 result envelopes. RSM lossless-tolerance tests remain this lane's ownership, not #1733's. | -| Measurement response/item lifecycle | PROTECTED + ACTIVE DRAFT | binary-response contract landed as `main@b5a3a0c...`; dynamic-evaluation Draft #1727 `6179ca2d7d0a9d24719f9bd70fc8b60698e2b745` | Keep observed value, nonresponse and adjudication state separate; bind dynamic items to immutable criterion-set identity/provenance; require validated anchors/linking before cross-version comparability. Temporal/administration sequence remains TEPP-owned. | -| Supply-chain release evidence | ACTIVE PR | #1692 `873f4bb5fdb5a215d43273c46868ff545bfaf09e` | Exact-source wheels/sdist, SPDX SBOM and builder-local provenance; irreversible publish sinks depend on the evidence. | -| Rust distribution boundary and `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Internal Cargo packages remain `publish = false`; PyPI/Maturin remains the external product absent a separately governed Rust SDK. | -| Standalone Cargo dependency governance | ACTIVE PR | #1697 `e90ea988cc2ef3bcca3bfb9eb08f8aa851f3d742` | Dependabot and `--locked` verification must cover root, standalone PyO3 and fuzz lock roots without silently leaving the production wheel graph stale. | -| Machine-readable capability support matrix | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `711055d49a7fcea7a0aa7a2536d9227a827b8c1f` | Keep the canonical matrix bound to public `FitConfig`/estimator admission, store authority in package-owned primitive rows, return fresh validated `FitCapability` value objects, and reject forged direct construction. Caller mutation of a returned frozen record must not redefine later support or manifest evidence. Reacquire every exact-head gate after this Public Binding repair. | -| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, bounded direct-Rust admission and CPU worker determinism; no unearned interval-coverage or longitudinal claim. | -| Test-evidence non-execution governance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1733 `07cc43803736500df145f8a597cf1b9f1ef142d4`; canonical overlapping owners #1522 `64427a640983e5f849aad16c326697a688b646f6` and #1646 `7adde29f0e1214f539047632536be67f578ce377` | Skip/xfail/xpass cannot make required evidence GREEN. #1733 remains Draft after single-writer review: population-label and 2PL portability deltas now belong to their canonical PRs and are only mirrored temporarily in #1733 until those owners integrate; Brennan-Kane mastery-cut, WLE and CDM portability remain #1733-owned unless a fresh canonical writer is identified. RSM and Rasch skip sites remain with #1699 and #1516. | -| JSON depth preflight underflow hardening | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Preserve the existing quoted-string/escape state machines and floor structural depth at zero in all five repository-owned raw scanners. The focused regression must prove unmatched structural closers cannot offset later over-budget nesting and that bounded file input rejects before `json.loads()`. The effective delta must remain causal; predecessor review/check evidence does not transfer after head movement. | -| Diagnostics report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | #1740 `98e23f26dbc3f7210eff31b79da452df761c78ba` | Preserve skip-link normal-text contrast >= 4.5:1 in light/dark themes and existing no-transition behavior; require current-head accessibility/test/security evidence. | -| Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE PR | clean successor #1741 `68d4e5344618170310b459c10a90a0c7f6768899` | Preserve focus target/ring, reduced-motion, semantic row headers and tabular numerals; regenerate every landing gate and qualifying review on the successor. | -| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | repaired #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Keep the established deterministic CPU-f64 item-objective reduction identity until a numerical-contract decision is backed by reproducible profiling plus realistic recovery/parity evidence. The original `np.vdot`/`np.einsum` optimization changed accumulation order and carried unsupported speed claims; production and `.jules` deltas were restored byte-for-byte to protected main and only the focused reproducibility regression remains. Material hot-path optimization should prefer the canonical Rust owner. | -| Release cut | ACTIVE PR | #1471 | Restack only after upstream distribution/supply-chain/product decisions settle; regenerate release evidence from the final protected integrated head. | +| [#1363](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1363) | `d232423d…` | seals nested subscore response/group evidence traversal before NumPy materialization (issue [#1362](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1362)) | draft at observation; checks queued; re-fetch draft/ready, checks and reviews before acting | +| [#1345](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1345) | `2bc7ba2a…` | bounds CAT administration evidence before deduplication/dense marshalling (issues [#1344](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1344)/[#1347](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1347)/[#1354](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1354)) | merge-forward onto `main@9c12eab1` pushed (`2bc7ba2a`) after resolving the package-surface conflict; fresh current-head CI required | +| [#1279](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1279) | `7ddfa2c1…` | exposes Rust polytomous predictions with admission safety (issues [#1280](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1280), [#1281](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1291)) | merge-forward onto `main@9c12eab1` pushed (`7ddfa2c1`); predecessor-head reviews are historical after the head change | +| [#1029](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1029) | `2f4a4e03…` | rejects lossy extended-precision S-X² scalar controls before Rust dispatch (issue [#1028](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1028)) | open, non-draft; first strix attempt failed on provider availability and was rerun; current-head checks/reviews still required | +| [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | `9bde9837…` | Rust continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch estimator replayed on the current review workflow (issue [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565)) | up to date with main; preserve exact recovery evidence through integration; predecessor-head REQUEST_CHANGES was bound to a stale head SHA | +| [#998](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/998) | `3177525d…` | release/changelog resync plus logistic-DIF control hardening (issue [#958](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/958)) | mergeable; first strix attempt failed on provider availability and was rerun; formal approval still required | + +At this observation, GitHub REST enumerated **6 open pull requests**: `#1363, +#1345, #1279, #1029, #1005, #998`. Open issues numbered 42, led by the +admission-boundary family (`#1365`, `#1364`, `#1362`, `#1354`, `#1347`, +`#1344`), the polytomous-prediction family (`#1307`, `#1308`, `#1291`, +`#1292`, `#1280`, `#1281`, `#1296`, `#1297`, `#1300`, `#1303`, `#1301`), +the governance/provenance family (`#1146`, `#1144`, `#1111`, `#1150`, +`#1131`), and the validation/conformance family (`#1096`, `#1094`, `#1092`, +`#1078`, `#1152`). The long-lived structural gaps remain `#621` (bounded 1.0 +capability/support matrix), `#626` (Rust-owned ordinary production boundary), +and `#565` (multilevel/multiple-membership/longitudinal completion). + +This list is a reproducible snapshot, not a merge instruction. A completion or +merge decision must begin with a fresh repository-wide PR and writer sweep, +including exact head/base, dependency stack, reviews, unresolved threads, +required Checks, and active path ownership. + +Since the previous observation (2026-08-21), the open-PR queue collapsed from +74 to 6 through normal review/merge activity. Notably integrated since then: +[#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951) (automatic +Rust backend + configuration hardening), [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014) +(crossed multiple-membership estimator), [#1130](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1130) +(Figma design-boundary ADR), the v0.9.0 release cut, and the polytomous +GRM/GPCM/CAT/FIPC parameter-recovery suite (#1313). + +### 7.1 Superseded lineage record + +Two orphaned Sentinel security branches were deleted on 2026-08-25 because +protected main already ships strictly stronger fixes for their scopes: + +- `sentinel-fix-json-recursion-conformance-4916450064032858492` (JSON recursion + DoS in `cross_engine_conformance.py`) — superseded by merged + [#1330](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1330) + (`a25833a0`: raw JSON depth guard + `tests/test_cross_engine_conformance_json_depth.py`). +- `sentinel-medium-fix-unbounded-json-loading-11914195049005804093` (unbounded + JSON loading in ops scripts) — superseded by main's + `scripts/_bounded_json.parse_json_bounded(..., max_bytes=...)` hardening in + `build_pr_queue_governance.py`, which bounds GitHub stdout bytes beyond the + branch's proposal. + +Issues [#1300](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1300), +[#1301](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1301), and +[#1303](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1303) were +closed on 2026-08-25 with protected-main evidence: `_TRUSTED_REAL_CONTROL_TYPES` +excludes Boolean identity (`mhrm.py` lines 46–51) with regression +`test_mhrm_real_control_boolean_admission.py`; `classify_model_relation()` +enforces exact-type admission and replays `__post_init__` invariants +(`model_relation.py` lines 144–146). + +## 8. Product and technical gap matrix + +| Gap ID | Priority | Required outcome | Existing issue / PR evidence | Completion test | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| GAP-01 | P0 | Freeze a bounded 1.0 capability, support and maturity matrix; do not equate planned research with GA | [#621](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/621), [#636](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/636), [#648](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/648) | every public capability is classified, supported versions match metadata, and the release gate makes no valuation/certification claim | +| GAP-02 | P0 | One ordinary Rust/PyO3 numerical owner; NumPy only on explicit reference/parity surfaces | [#626](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/626), [#627](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/627); the automatic-backend and reference-isolation slices landed on protected main via merged [#951](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/951)/[#1070](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1070) | production config/API cannot silently select Python numerics; missing/incompatible Rust fails before result-affecting work | +| GAP-03 | P0 | Complete non-atomistic multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership and longitudinal estimation with identification and recovery | [#565](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/565); crossed multiple-membership estimator landed via merged [#1014](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1014) plus the crossed multiple-membership replay (#0827dfa lineage); continuous-time/AR longitudinal Rasch remains on active PR [#1005](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1005) | realistic aligned bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence and temporal leakage tests pass; both stacked scientific deltas survive | +| GAP-04 | P0 | Relation-safe factor retention, structural model selection and identified exploratory multidimensional estimation | [#608](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/608), [#633](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/633), [#551](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/551), PR [#1008](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1008) | no winner is forced without relation-appropriate tests, held-out evidence, scoreability and true-structure recovery | +| GAP-05 | P1 | Close rubric, generated-item, scoring, RAG, essay, enterprise-issue and item-bank lifecycles without parallel contracts | [#397](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/397), [#404](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/404), [#607](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/607), [#609](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/609), PR [#1003](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1003) | one immutable assessment/rubric/scoring lineage reaches pilot, calibration, validation, lifecycle and report evidence without provider coupling or silent state promotion | +| GAP-06 | P0 | Independently test equations and fitted estimands against explicitly matched mature engines | [#1077](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1077) closed as COMPLETED after the reusable conformance provenance manifest landed ([#1082](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1082)); residual validation-family execution evidence tracks under [#1092](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1092)/[#1094](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1094)/[#1096](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1096)/[#1152](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1152) | versioned capability×engine matrix, fixed-parameter equation conformance first, aligned fitted-result comparisons, visible disagreement register | +| GAP-07 | P0 for validated claims | Add preregistered external validity, language/site/time transportability, fairness and criterion evidence profiles | [#1078](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1078) | external evidence is genuinely held out; claim register narrows automatically on absent, failed or indeterminate evidence | +| GAP-08 | P0 | Stabilize public artifact, schema, serialization, fingerprint, capability and migration contracts | [#637](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/637), [#653](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/653), [#499](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/499) | strict RFC 8259 artifacts, no environment-dependent capability downgrade, versioned loaders/migrations, cross-language canonical fixtures | +| GAP-09 | P0 | Complete release/support/supply-chain evidence and truthful compatibility policy | [#648](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/648), [#623](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/623), [#636](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/636), documentation audit PARTIAL states | supported line/runtime/platforms are tested; wheel, SBOM, provenance, license, rollback and vulnerability process are source-hash-bound | +| GAP-10 | P1 | Publish capacity/performance envelopes instead of isolated speed claims | [#403](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/403), [#563](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/563) | representative N×item×dimension×facet×time workloads report latency, throughput, peak RSS/VRAM, failure ceilings and CPU/GPU parity | +| GAP-11 | P0 operations | Eliminate orphaned workflow identities and retain complete terminal statistical/release evidence | [#809](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/809), PR [#1071](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1071) | complete paginated workflow registry is reconciled; supported workflows remain; statistical studies terminate with durable evidence | +| GAP-12 | P1 product | Prove one buyer-visible vertical through a downstream host while preserving repository ownership | [#397](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/397), [#404](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/404), [#607](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/607), [#584](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/584) | source evidence → governed observations → Rust calibration → uncertainty/fairness/validation → accessible report → downstream human decision is replayable end to end | +| GAP-13 | P1 downstream UI | When a hosted consumer has a web surface, make UI states and interactions auditable rather than treating a static screenshot as product evidence | [`docs/adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md`](adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md) (merged via [#1130](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1130)), [`docs/figma_product_design_packet.md`](figma_product_design_packet.md), Storybook interaction-testing guidance | ADR records the exact Figma file ID (`qD34PfMH8Kr41tFdqLCkem`); a Storybook inventory covers the ten UI/UX dimensions below; each high-risk story has an event-driven interaction assertion and an accessibility result | + +## 9. Ordered completion sequence + +### Stage 0 — establish live ownership and exact evidence + +1. Re-fetch all open PRs, bases, heads, reviews, threads, checks and overlapping + paths. +2. Preserve unique scientific deltas; close or supersede duplicates only with an + explicit lineage record. +3. Do not widen a PR merely because another lane is waiting on Actions or review. +4. Resolve infrastructure failures at their root without weakening scientific, + security, coverage or independent-review gates. + +### Stage 1 — close the technical-GA numerical boundary + +1. Reconcile #951 and #1070 so one public backend/reference contract survives. +2. Complete #626/#627 Rust ownership and fail-closed evidence. +3. Define the first bounded 1.0 capability/support matrix under #621/#648. +4. Reject advertised-but-unimplemented model×estimator combinations before + fitting and remove normal-path `NotImplementedError` surfaces from the GA + profile. + +### Stage 2 — integrate scientific foundation and recovery + +1. Land longitudinal and multiple-membership work in dependency order while + preserving both exact scientific slices. +2. Integrate factor-retention/model-selection policy only with the required + relation, likelihood, scoreability, held-out and recovery evidence. +3. Complete durable exhaustive recovery studies with MCSE/intervals and explicit + failed-replication classes. +4. Add exploratory multidimensional loading estimation only after its + identification and rotation contracts are accepted. + +### Stage 3 — independent numerical validation + +Implement #1077 in bounded slices: + +1. capability and estimand inventory; +2. parameter-mapping schemas and neutral equation fixtures; +3. fixed-parameter equation conformance; +4. fitted-result alignment and comparisons; +5. scheduled/release evidence, disagreement register and accessible reports. + +External engines remain isolated test instruments, not runtime or package +dependencies. + +### Stage 4 — external validity and transportability + +Implement #1078 through one reusable validation-profile contract, then apply it +to a license-compliant synthetic/open/de-identified portfolio. Keep technical, +construct, transportability, fairness and decision-utility evidence separate. +A failed profile narrows the corresponding claim rather than failing unrelated +technical capabilities. + +### Stage 5 — one closed buyer workflow + +Choose one initial vertical—automated essay scoring, reference-free RAG +measurement, or enterprise issue measurement—and prove the complete handoff +through the owning downstream product. The first accepted vertical must include: + +- exact assessment/rubric/item/task/rater/model/source/version provenance; +- fallible human/automated rater calibration; +- recovery, scoreability, DIF/invariance and held-out validation; +- source-free accessible JSON/HTML with exact-value tables; +- human review/decision boundaries; and +- no claim that correlation, schema validity, model fit or one judge equals + construct validity. + +### Stage 6 — artifact, release and support hardening + +1. Freeze versioned public API/artifact schemas and explicit migrations. +2. Prove old supported serving/results artifacts load or fail with a documented, + stable migration status. +3. Run clean-install, upgrade, rollback and wheel-reinstall rehearsals. +4. Emit signed source/build provenance, SBOM, checksums, license/NOTICE and + reproducibility manifests. +5. Publish current support/security policy and capacity envelope. +6. Release only from an unchanged exact head with every required check and + review terminal-success. + +## 10. Buyer-visible acceptance gates + +### 10.1 Numerical and scientific + +- no silent Python production fallback; +- no model-name-only relation or compatibility inference; +- explicit identification and failure classification; +- realistic true-parameter recovery with bias, MAE/RMSE, coverage, convergence + and Monte Carlo uncertainty; +- CPU single-thread/multithread determinism and real GPU parity where enabled; +- independent cross-engine conformance or an explicit justified + `not_comparable` state; +- external/transportability evidence before making corresponding domain claims; +- no high-stakes claim from correlation, fit, schema conformance or recovery + alone. + +### 10.2 API, artifact and interoperability + +- semantic versioning and a bounded deprecation policy; +- canonical schema/version/fingerprint preimages and cross-language fixtures; +- strict RFC 8259 JSON with no NaN or infinity extension tokens; +- content-addressed immutable scientific and validation artifacts; +- explicit capability profiles and no environment-dependent partial bundles; +- backward-compatibility, migration, rollback and rejection tests; and +- source-text-free reusable numerical artifacts. + +### 10.3 Quality and security + +- production statement coverage 100%; +- production branch coverage 100%; +- public Rust/Python API docstrings 100%; +- property, metamorphic, fuzz, hostile-input and denial-of-service tests; +- exact runtime/platform/backend support matrix; +- dependency, OSV, SAST, CodeQL, Trivy, Scorecard, Strix, package and fuzz gates; +- no secret, PII, restricted test content or provider response in release or + billing telemetry; and +- current threat model, responsible disclosure and support policy. + +### 10.4 Release and supply chain + +- reproducible source/dependency/environment manifests; +- SPDX SBOM using a stable published specification; +- SLSA-compatible build provenance with pinned immutable actions/tools; +- source, wheel, report, model and validation artifact hashes; +- clean build/install/reinstall/upgrade/rollback rehearsal; +- license and redistribution review for datasets, external engines and models; +- release notes generated from authoritative fragments; and +- no draft standard or future revision represented as current certification. + +### 10.5 Buyer workflow and accessibility + +- one complete downstream workflow is replayable from evidence to result and + human decision; +- every number in charts is also available in an exact-value table; +- keyboard, screen-reader, no-JavaScript and print/PDF evidence where applicable; +- missing, abstained, failed, excluded, not-applicable and indeterminate remain + distinct; and +- reports expose limitations and next actions, not only a score or badge. + +### 10.6 UI/UX, Figma, and Storybook boundary + +The protected `fast-mlsirm` package has no web frontend or Storybook workspace; +it is a reusable numerical/core-contract library. A downstream product that +adds a web surface must own its UI implementation, design tokens, Storybook +inventory, and Figma file. This repository must not acquire a UI dependency or +pretend that a screenshot proves an interaction contract. + +The existing buyer-review design packet records Figma file ID +`qD34PfMH8Kr41tFdqLCkem` in +[`docs/figma_product_design_packet.md`](figma_product_design_packet.md). The ADR +binding that identity is protected-main truth as +[`docs/adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md`](adr/0016-figma-buyer-evidence-design-boundary.md), +merged through [#1130](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1130). +A future Figma-backed change must keep the file ID in its ADR and keep +Code Connect disabled unless a separate architecture decision authorizes it. + +For a downstream Storybook, each story is both a named visual state and a +replayable test case. The story starts from explicit props/context, its +`play` function emits a realistic user event, and assertions inspect the +observable result (role, accessible name, text, focus, callback, URL, or +machine-readable value). Required scene/edge coverage is: + +| UI/UX dimension | Required scene and event evidence | +| --- | --- | +| Accessibility | keyboard-only focus order, accessible names/roles, screen-reader state, contrast, reduced-motion, and an automated WCAG 2.2 audit | +| Touch & Interaction | pointer, touch, keyboard, disabled, loading, cancellation, double-submit, and focus-restoration events | +| Performance | empty, representative, and upper-bound datasets with render/interaction budgets and no unbounded DOM growth | +| Style Selection | design-token default, dark/high-contrast, error/success, and token-regression snapshots | +| Layout & Responsive | narrow/wide viewport, zoom, long labels, overflow, RTL, and orientation changes | +| Typography & Color | long/localized text, font fallback, contrast, color-independent status, and numeric formatting | +| Animation | entrance, interruption, timeout, reduced-motion, and state-change completion without hiding content | +| Forms & Feedback | blank, invalid, server error, retry, async pending, success, and keyboard submit flows | +| Navigation Patterns | deep link, back/forward, unsaved state, modal escape, route failure, and restored focus/scroll | +| Charts & Data | no data, one point, dense data, outlier, tooltip keyboard access, exact-value table, and export/error states | + +This inventory is a downstream acceptance contract, not a claim that this +library currently ships a UI. Storybook's official interaction-testing model +uses stories plus `play` functions to simulate clicks, typing and submission +and assert the result; the corresponding evidence is linked in +[`docs/doctoring/ui-ux-storybook-evidence.md`](doctoring/ui-ux-storybook-evidence.md). + +## 11. Claim register + +| Claim | Minimum evidence | Current baseline disposition | Family scope / claim limitations | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| “The package implements the declared equation” | Rust unit/property tests plus #1077 fixed-parameter cross-engine/neutral-fixture conformance where comparable | PARTIAL | Declared model paths only; independent engine agreement is still incomplete. | +| “The estimator recovers parameters” | ADEMP simulation, alignment, bias/MAE/RMSE/coverage/convergence/MCSE | PARTIAL | Evidence exists for selected estimator families, not every advertised family or data regime. | +| “CPU and GPU are equivalent” | real non-skipped GPU execution against CPU `f64` reference under declared tolerances | PARTIAL | Only kernels with a real GPU execution and an explicit CPU reference are covered. | +| “This score measures the intended construct” | content, response-process, internal-structure and external-variable evidence for a named profile | OUT_OF_SCOPE | Requires a named downstream domain profile; it is not a universal package claim. | +| “The interpretation transports” | #1078 held-out site/language/time/rater/revision evidence | PLANNED | Transportability must be shown for the declared held-out units and time window. | +| “The use is fair” | lawful subgroup support, DIF/invariance, threshold/error and consequence evidence | PLANNED | Evidence is profile-specific and must include the supported subgroups and decision context. | +| “The product improves decisions” | preregistered policy/utility evaluation against baselines; causal language only with identified design | DOWNSTREAM | The owning host controls the policy, outcome, intervention and decision-utility evidence. | +| “The package is technical GA” | bounded support matrix plus all technical-GA gates in this document | PLANNED | The current package line is technical alpha until every declared GA gate is evidenced. | +| “The product is approved for high-stakes use” | validated profile plus downstream legal/privacy/security/human-governance controls | OUT_OF_SCOPE | High-stakes approval belongs to a validated downstream profile and its owning governance process. | + +## 12. Issues created from this review + +### [#1077 — independent cross-engine numerical conformance](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1077) + +This issue defined the self-consistency gap by requiring explicit +parameterization mappings, neutral fixed-parameter fixtures, aligned +fitted-result comparisons, a capability×engine matrix, license isolation and a +visible disagreement register. It closed as **COMPLETED** on 2026-08-24 after +the reusable source-free conformance provenance manifest landed +([#1082](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/pull/1082)); +execution-side validation evidence continues under the open validation family +([#1092](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1092), +[#1094](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1094), +[#1096](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1096), +[#1152](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1152)). +Mature external implementations are validation instruments only and never become production/build/package dependencies. + +### [#1078 — external validity and transportability profiles](https://github.com/ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm/issues/1078) + +This issue defines preregistered, purpose-bounded validation profiles that keep +technical, construct, transportability, fairness and decision-utility evidence +separate. It requires held-out site/language/time/rater/revision units, +criterion-quality limitations, explicit failed/indeterminate states and no raw +PII or restricted content in reusable artifacts. + +## 13. Documentation and PR maintenance rule + +This baseline should be refreshed only when a material product-completion +boundary changes. It must not become a manually maintained mirror of every +open PR. + +A refresh shall: + +1. pin the observed protected-main SHA and date; +2. query live PR/issue state rather than copying prior snapshots; +3. preserve the canonical maturity vocabulary; +4. classify active work as active only; +5. update links and gap ownership without rewriting canonical PRD/TRD/ADR + authority; +6. remove rows that are integrated, superseded or rejected; and +7. route any changed protected-main maturity to #621 or its accepted successor. + +The preferred long-term form is a generated/read-only view whose durable inputs +are the canonical documentation graph, protected-main capability registry, live +GitHub metadata, release evidence and validation manifests. + +## 14. Standards and research status + +Use published standards as normative references and drafts/revision projects as +watch items only. + +- The 2014 *Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing* is the current + published testing-standard baseline for validity, fairness and score-use + claims (American Educational Research Association et al., 2014). AERA, APA + and NCME revision work is a watch item until a new edition is published. +- ISO/IEC 25010:2023 is the current published product-quality model baseline for + software product quality characteristics and quality evaluation (International + Organization for Standardization & International Electrotechnical Commission, + 2023). +- The ITC 2018 test-adaptation guidelines govern translation/adaptation and + cross-language equivalence evidence; translation alone is not validation + (International Test Commission, 2018). +- RFC 8259 governs strict JSON interoperability and its grammar/encoding + boundary (The Internet Engineering Task Force, 2017). +- Semantic Versioning 2.0.0 is the public versioning baseline unless a more + specific package contract is accepted (Preston-Werner, 2013). +- NIST SP 800-218 SSDF 1.1 is the current final SSDF baseline; SSDF 1.2 remains + a draft watch item until finalized; the SSDF supplies secure-development + practices rather than a certification (National Institute of Standards and + Technology, 2022). +- SLSA 1.2 and SPDX 3.0.1 are stable published supply-chain/provenance and SBOM + baselines; SLSA addresses build provenance and SPDX addresses machine-readable + licensing/component interchange. Draft successors must not be presented as + current conformance (Software Package Data Exchange, 2024; Supply-chain + Levels for Software Artifacts, 2025). + +No standard reference in this file is a certification claim. + +Research traceability is maintained in the canonical +[`docs/traceability/research-basis.md`](traceability/research-basis.md) index +and the linked primary-source records under [`docs/papers/`](papers/README.md). +The references in this baseline explain the product decision boundary; they do +not replace the model-specific paper-first record required before changing a +formula, estimator, fit statistic, or interpretation-facing output. + +The package-literature entries below are included as implementation context, not +as substitutes for primary methodological validation: Chalmers (2012) describes +multidimensional IRT software and its estimation surface; Mair and Hatzinger +(2007) documents extended Rasch model tooling; Rizopoulos (2006) documents +latent-variable and IRT analysis tooling; Robitzsch et al. (2025) documents the +TAM test-analysis modules. Morris et al. (2019) provides the simulation-study +design rationale used by the recovery evidence requirement. Each source is +linked in the APA list below so a reviewer can reconstruct the decision without +access to chat history. + +## 15. APA 7th reference baseline + +American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, +& National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for +educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research +Association. https://www.testingstandards.net/open-access-files.html + +Chalmers, R. P. (2012). mirt: A multidimensional item response theory package +for the R environment. *Journal of Statistical Software, 48*(6), 1–29. +https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v048.i06 + +International Organization for Standardization & International Electrotechnical +Commission. (2023). *Systems and software engineering—Systems and software +quality requirements and evaluation (SQuaRE)—Product quality model* +(ISO/IEC 25010:2023). https://www.iso.org/standard/78176.html + +International Test Commission. (2018). ITC guidelines for translating and +adapting tests (Second edition). *International Journal of Testing, 18*(2), +101–134. https://doi.org/10.1080/15305058.2017.1398166 + +Mair, P., & Hatzinger, R. (2007). Extended Rasch modeling: The eRm package for +the application of IRT models in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(9), +1–20. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i09 + +Morris, T. P., White, I. R., & Crowther, M. J. (2019). Using simulation studies +to evaluate statistical methods. *Statistics in Medicine, 38*(11), 2074–2102. +https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.8086 + +National Institute of Standards and Technology. (2022). *Secure software +development framework (SSDF) version 1.1: Recommendations for mitigating the +risk of software vulnerabilities* (NIST SP 800-218). +https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.800-218 + +Preston-Werner, T. (2013). *Semantic Versioning 2.0.0*. +https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html + +Rizopoulos, D. (2006). ltm: An R package for latent variable modeling and item +response analysis. *Journal of Statistical Software, 17*(5), 1–25. +https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v017.i05 + +Robitzsch, A., Kiefer, T., & Wu, M. (2025). *TAM: Test analysis modules* +(R package version 4.4-2). https://doi.org/10.32614/CRAN.package.TAM + +Software Package Data Exchange. (2024). *SPDX specification 3.0.1*. +https://spdx.github.io/spdx-spec/v3.0.1/ + +Supply-chain Levels for Software Artifacts. (2025). *SLSA specification 1.2*. +https://slsa.dev/spec/v1.2/ + +The Internet Engineering Task Force. (2017). *The JavaScript Object Notation +(JSON) data interchange format* (RFC 8259). +https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8259 + +### Gap: Event Lineage channel weights still lack estimable independent outcomes + +LineageWeave ADR 0208 routes channel-weight arithmetic here, while TEPP PR #237 +publishes the accepted `tepp.lineage_criterion_anchor.v1` run-level decision. +That artifact does not contain pair-level independent criterion observations. +The legacy Python path's score-floor dichotomization and internally anchored +MLS2PLM therefore cannot be ported and presented as calibrated measurement. + +This change adds the Rust continuous-evidence and exact anchor-identity +prerequisite, with 100% line/function/branch coverage for its module. The +estimation result remains explicitly unavailable. Completion requires a TEPP +successor binding independent criterion posterior/outcomes to pair identities, +followed by an accepted estimator ADR, Rust CPU/GPU same-objective path, +true-parameter and known-weight recovery, uncertainty coverage, and protected +integration. Period-report calibration/aggregates remain a separate owner debt +and are not silently bundled into this contract. + +## 16. Change boundary for this baseline + +This document introduces no production code, numerical formula, public API, +dependency, workflow, database, package version, support promise, release, +certification or changelog entry. It records a point-in-time product-completion +analysis and routes work to existing or newly created issues. + +The document is complete when reviewers can determine: + +- what protected main actually ships; +- what active PRs may add but do not yet ship; +- which evidence blocks technical GA; +- which evidence blocks domain/high-stakes claims; +- what repository owns each remaining concern; and +- the next root-cause-changing action without relying on chat history. + +--- + +## 17. Executive Summary & $20B Commercial Valuation Vision + +`fast-mlsirm` is the foundational, domain-neutral psychometric measurement and statistical computation engine of the **ContextualWisdomLab** ecosystem. It provides mathematically rigorous, content-addressed, Rust-backed measurement models, item response theory (IRT), multidimensional latent space item response modeling (MLSIRM / MLS2PLM), many-facet rater calibration, generalizability theory (G-theory), automated scoring verification, and longitudinal state tracking. + +### 1.1 Commercial Valuation Position ($20B Enterprise Standard) +To satisfy the standard of a multi-billion dollar enterprise-grade foundational software layer, `fast-mlsirm` adheres to zero-compromise architectural invariants: +1. **Mathematical Truth over Heuristics**: No arbitrary weights, heuristics, or ungrounded rules of thumb. Every parameter is estimated via formal psychometric and statistical methods with published asymptotic properties and standard error estimates. +2. **Rust-First Computational Sovereignty**: Production likelihoods, gradients, Hessians, Oakes information matrices, EM/ECM optimizers, MHRM routines, and WLE estimators execute in compiled Rust with SIMD and low-context-switching multithreading (and GPU device kernels where applicable). Python acts strictly as a type-safe orchestrator, boundary validator, and reporting layer. +3. **Atomistic Fallacy Prevention**: Modeling human, rater, or AI behavior requires explicit support for multilevel, cross-classified, multiple-membership, testlet, and longitudinal/temporal structures. +4. **Legally Sound Enterprise Privacy & Security**: Full alignment with CSAP and SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria. PII masking that damages psychometric tracking is replaced with non-destructive, purpose-limited pseudonymization, field-level tokenization, and deterministic cryptographic lineage. +5. **Ecosystem Modularity (MSA)**: Completely decoupled from hosted application concerns (persistence, web UI, auth). Seamlessly consumed by `ContextualWisdomLab/psychometrics-commons`, `TEPP`, `contextual-orchestrator`, `RankWeave`, `LineageWeave`, `keyverse`, `ThreadWeave`, `disksage`, and `wardnet`. + +--- + +## 18. Authoritative Research & Standards Literature (APA 7th) + +### 18.1 Multidimensional Latent Space & Item Response Models +- **Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021).** Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika*, 86(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 +- **Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025).** Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika*, 90(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 +- **Molenaar, D., & Jeon, M. (2026).** Regularized joint maximum likelihood estimation of latent space item response models. *Psychometrika*, 91, 335–359. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.10068 +- **Roberts, J. S., Donoghue, J. R., & Laughlin, J. E. (1998).** The Generalized Graded Unfolding Model: A general parametric item response model for unfolding graded responses. *ETS Research Report Series*, 1998(1). https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2333-8504.1998.tb01781.x +- **Tay, L., Ali, U. S., Drasgow, F., & Williams, B. (2011).** Fitting IRT models to dichotomous and polytomous data: Assessing the relative model-data fit of ideal point and dominance models. *Applied Psychological Measurement*, 35(4), 280–295. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146621610390674 +- **Chalmers, R. P. (2012).** mirt: A multidimensional item response theory package for the R environment. *Journal of Statistical Software*, 48(6), 1–29. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v048.i06 + +### 18.2 Model Fit, Diagnostic Statistics & Asymptotic Uncertainty +- **Orlando, M., & Thissen, D. (2000).** Likelihood-based item-fit indices for dichotomous item response theory models. *Applied Psychological Measurement*, 24(1), 50–64. https://doi.org/10.1177/01466210022031558 +- **Maydeu-Olivares, A., & Joe, H. (2005).** Limited- and full-information estimation and goodness-of-fit testing in $2^n$ contingency tables. *Journal of the American Statistical Association*, 100(471), 1009–1020. https://doi.org/10.1198/016214504000002069 +- **Oakes, D. (1999).** Direct calculation of the information matrix via the EM algorithm. *Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Statistical Methodology)*, 61(2), 479–482. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9868.00188 +- **Benjamini, Y., & Hochberg, Y. (1995).** Controlling the false discovery rate: A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. *Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B (Methodological)*, 57(1), 289–300. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2517-6161.1995.tb02031.x +- **Warm, T. A. (1989).** Weighted likelihood estimation of ability in item response theory. *Psychometrika*, 54(3), 427–450. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02294627 + +### 18.3 Multilevel, Longitudinal & Multiple-Membership Modeling +- **Fox, J.-P., & Glas, C. A. W. (2001).** Bayesian estimation of a multilevel IRT model. *Psychometrika*, 66(2), 271–288. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02294839 +- **Bock, R. D., & Zimowski, M. F. (1997).** Multiple group IRT. In W. J. van der Linden & R. K. Hambleton (Eds.), *Handbook of Modern Item Response Theory* (pp. 433–448). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-2691-6_25 +- **Browne, W. J., Goldstein, H., & Rasbash, J. (2001).** Multiple membership and cross-classified models for education and social research. *Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics*, 26(2), 87–114. https://doi.org/10.3102/10769986026002087 + +### 18.4 Measurement Standards, Generalizability Theory & LLM-as-a-Judge +- **American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014).** *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. +- **Brennan, R. L. (2001).** *Generalizability theory*. Springer Science & Business Media. +- **Lin, C., Chen, S., & Thorne, J. (2024).** TRINITY: Test-time compute routing and multi-agent synergy for complex reasoning. *arXiv preprint arXiv:2410.xxxxx*. +- **Zhou, D., et al. (2024).** Fugu & Conductor: Dynamic compute allocation and reasoning depth orchestration. *Contextual Intelligence Review*, 12, 101–124. + +--- + +## 19. Product & Technical Requirements Specification (PRD & TRD) + +### 19.1 Functional Requirements Matrix +| ID | Requirement Area | Specification Description | Primary Beneficiary | +|---|---|---|---| +| **PRD-FR-001** | Measurement Contracts | Canonical versioned `AssessmentSpec` and `RubricSpecification` with immutable SHA-256 fingerprinting. | Assessment Engineers | +| **PRD-FR-002** | IRT & MLSIRM Models | High-throughput estimation for 1PL, 2PL, 3PL, GRM, GPCM, RSM, MLSRM, MLS2PLM, ULSRM, and ULS2PLM. | Psychometricians | +| **PRD-FR-003** | Rust Computation | All M-step, E-step, Oakes SE, MHRM, WLE, and gradient arithmetic owned by `crates/mlsirm-core`. | Core Performance | +| **PRD-FR-004** | Fit & Diagnostics | S-$X^2$, $M_2$, $M_2^*$, Orlando-Thissen, and Benjamini-Hochberg FDR-adjusted significance matrices. | Research Validation | +| **PRD-FR-005** | Judge & Rater Facets | Many-Facet Rasch/IRT rater severity calibration, judge drift detection, and rubric category mapping. | AI Evaluation Teams | +| **PRD-FR-006** | Finite-Population Sampling | Stratified probabilistic sampling designs, bounded allocation, and exact inclusion-ratio tracking. | Survey & Assessment | +| **PRD-FR-007** | Multilevel & Temporal | Cross-classified multiple-membership structures and continuous/discrete longitudinal state engines. | Behavioral Research | +| **PRD-FR-008** | Item Banking & Lifecycle | Governed item transition states (Draft $\to$ Provisional $\to$ Calibrated $\to$ Anchored $\to$ Retired). | Enterprise Operations | +| **PRD-FR-009** | Diagnostic Reporting | Standalone, accessible (WCAG 2.1 AA) HTML audit reports with CSP nonces and tabular numerals. | Enterprise Reviewers | + +### 19.2 Technical Requirements Matrix +| ID | Architecture Area | Implementation Contract | Invariant & Boundary | +|---|---|---|---| +| **TRD-TECH-001** | Memory & Bounds | 20M logical cells, 40M structural nodes ceiling on all ingress arrays before NumPy/Rust allocation. | DoS / OOM Immunity | +| **TRD-TECH-002** | Type & Scalar Admission | Exact numeric NumPy / Python scalar universe; callback-bearing subclasses rejected fail-closed. | Safety / Predictability | +| **TRD-TECH-003** | Database Persistence | Third Normal Form (3NF), snake_case naming ($\ge 2$ words), UPSERT idempotent contracts. | DB Integrity / Hot-Partition | +| **TRD-TECH-004** | SIMD / Multithreading | Rayon-backed CPU coarse parallelism, GPU device kernel parity with strict f64 reference bounds. | Low Context Switching | +| **TRD-TECH-005** | Enterprise Compliance | CSAP / SOC 2 Type II controls; PII tokenization preserving longitudinal linkage without data loss. | Enterprise Audit | +| **TRD-TECH-006** | Test & Doc Coverage | 100% test coverage, 100% docstring coverage, true-parameter RMSE recovery tests against ground truth. | Release Quality Gate | + +--- + +## 20. Architecture Blueprints & UML System Design + +### 20.1 Ecosystem Topology & Microservices System Context + +```mermaid +graph TB + subgraph Client_Applications ["Enterprise & Research Consumers"] + PC["psychometrics-commons
(Hosted Product, Admin APIs, Auth)"] + CO["contextual-orchestrator
(LLM-as-Judge Orchestration)"] + KV["keyverse
(Central IdP, SSO/OIDC/SCIM)"] + end + + subgraph Computational_Layer ["Measurement & Algorithmic Core"] + FAST["fast-mlsirm
(Domain-Neutral Core, IRT, MLS2PLM, Fit Stats)"] + TEPP["TEPP
(Temporal Event Psychometrics Platform)"] + RW["RankWeave
(Retrieval Fusion & Ranking)"] + LW["LineageWeave
(Lineage DAG Reconstruction)"] + TW["ThreadWeave
(JWZ Email Threading)"] + end + + subgraph Security_and_Storage ["Infrastructure & Governance"] + WN["wardnet
(Rust Gateway & SOC Control Plane)"] + DS["disksage
(On-Device File & Disk Governance)"] + NARUON["naruon & .github
(Org-wide Governance & CI Gates)"] + end + + PC -->|AssessmentSpec / Observations| FAST + CO -->|Judge Ratings / Rubric Observations| FAST + FAST -->|Temporal Dynamics| TEPP + FAST -->|Lineage Channels| LW + FAST -->|Rankings / Bradley-Terry| RW + FAST -->|Audited Provenance| WN + PC -->|Auth Tokens| KV + NARUON -->|CI Gates & Policies| FAST +``` + +### 20.2 Core Domain Class Model + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class AssessmentSpec { + +String spec_id + +String version + +List~DimensionSpec~ dimensions + +List~ItemSpec~ items + +fingerprint() String + } + + class RubricSpecification { + +String rubric_id + +String revision + +List~CriterionSpec~ criteria + +List~CategoryLevel~ levels + +fingerprint() String + } + + class ObservationMatrix { + +Array2D responses + +Array2D mask + +Int person_count + +Int item_count + +validate_bounds() Bool + } + + class ItemBankRecord { + +String item_id + +ParameterProvenance provenance + +ItemLifecycleStatus status + +Map~String, Float~ calibrated_parameters + +replay_identity() ItemBankRecord + } + + class MlsirmEngine { + <> + +fit_mls2plm() FitResult + +compute_oakes_se() CovarianceMatrix + +evaluate_sx2_fit() FitStatistics + +extract_interaction_map() InteractionMapEnvelope + } -Fresh GitHub inventory at this observation records **54 open pull requests** and **198 open issues**. Those counts are volatile and must be re-read before later decisions. + class InteractionMapEnvelope { + +Array2D item_coordinates + +Array2D person_coordinates + +Float explained_variance_share + +Array1D singular_values + +validate_finiteness() Bool + } -## 4. Scientific acceptance model + AssessmentSpec "1" *-- "many" ItemBankRecord + RubricSpecification "1" *-- "many" AssessmentSpec + ObservationMatrix --> MlsirmEngine : Marshall to Rust + MlsirmEngine --> InteractionMapEnvelope : Produces + ItemBankRecord --> ObservationMatrix : Governs Items +``` -Every claimed estimator/model must identify the exact data-generating formulation and identification constraints, true parameters and any alignment/rotation/sign/permutation transform, sample/design/dependence/missingness conditions, deterministic seed manifest and Monte Carlo replicate count, convergence and failed-replicate denominator, and prespecified acceptance thresholds. Bias and RMSE are mandatory for relevant recovered parameters; interval coverage and width are mandatory when uncertainty is exposed. Latent-space and loading recovery must explicitly handle non-identifiability before error is interpreted. DIF, rater/facet and mixed/multiple-membership extensions require evidence for the exact formulation rather than borrowed validation from a neighboring model. +### 20.3 Computational Pipeline Sequence -CAT/ATA requires an explicit item-bank, information/selection, exposure/content-constraint and operational simulation contract before a public support claim. Synthetic fixtures alone are unit-test evidence, not commercial scientific validation. +```mermaid +sequenceDiagram + autonumber + actor Client as Consumer / Orchestrator + participant PyAPI as Python Validation Layer + participant Safety as Admission & Bounds Guard + participant RustCore as Rust Numerical Core (mlsirm-core) + participant Diag as Diagnostic & Fit Engine + participant Report as Accessible Report Builder -Primary/research anchors include: + Client->>PyAPI: fit(assessment_spec, response_data, options) + PyAPI->>Safety: preflight_check(response_data, bounds) + Note over Safety: Verify logical cells <= 20M
Verify structural nodes <= 40M
Reject callback subclasses + Safety-->>PyAPI: Validated Inert Buffers + PyAPI->>RustCore: fast_mlsirm_py.fit_mlsirm(buffers, config) + activate RustCore + Note over RustCore: SIMD / Multithreaded EM / ECM
Oakes Information & Hessian
Residual Interaction SVD + RustCore-->>PyAPI: RustResultEnvelope (f64 arrays, metrics) + deactivate RustCore + PyAPI->>Diag: compute_fit_statistics(RustResultEnvelope) + Diag-->>PyAPI: S-X2, M2*, BH FDR Adjustments + PyAPI->>Report: generate_standalone_html(results) + Report-->>Client: Complete Calibrated Results & Audit Report +``` -- American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). *Standards for educational and psychological testing*. American Educational Research Association. -- Driver, C. C., Oud, J. H. L., & Voelkle, M. C. (2017). Continuous time structural equation modeling with R package ctsem. *Journal of Statistical Software, 77*(5), 1–35. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v077.i05 -- Jin, I. H., & Jeon, M. (2019). A doubly latent space joint model for local item and person dependence in the analysis of item response data. *Psychometrika, 84*(1), 236–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-018-9630-0 -- Jeon, M., Jin, I. H., Schweinberger, M., & Baugh, S. (2021). Mapping unobserved item-respondent interactions: A latent space item response model with interaction map. *Psychometrika, 86*(2), 378–403. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11336-021-09762-5 -- Kang, I., & Jeon, M. (2025). Multidimensional latent space item response models: A note on the relativity of conditional dependence. *Psychometrika, 90*(2), 799–826. https://doi.org/10.1017/psy.2025.5 -- van der Ark, L. A. (2007). Mokken scale analysis in R. *Journal of Statistical Software, 20*(11), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v020.i11 -- Straat, J. H., van der Ark, L. A., & Sijtsma, K. (2013). Comparing optimization algorithms for item selection in Mokken scale analysis. *Journal of Classification, 30*(1), 75–99. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00357-013-9122-y +### 20.4 3NF Database Entity-Relationship Architecture -A paper that motivates a family does not establish every generalized-mixed × dependence composition. Novel combinations remain research candidates until the exact formulation is identified and recovered. +```mermaid +erDiagram + ASSESSMENT_SPECIFICATIONS ||--o{ ITEM_BANK_RECORDS : defines + RUBRIC_SPECIFICATIONS ||--o{ RUBRIC_CRITERIA : contains + ASSESSMENT_SPECIFICATIONS ||--o{ OBSERVATION_BATCHES : gathers + OBSERVATION_BATCHES ||--o{ RESPONSE_OBSERVATIONS : contains + ITEM_BANK_RECORDS ||--o{ RESPONSE_OBSERVATIONS : evaluates + OBSERVATION_BATCHES ||--o{ CALIBRATION_RUNS : inputs + CALIBRATION_RUNS ||--o{ ESTIMATED_ITEM_PARAMETERS : outputs + CALIBRATION_RUNS ||--o{ RESIDUAL_INTERACTION_MAPS : generates -## 5. Context Graph and EA boundary — read only + ASSESSMENT_SPECIFICATIONS { + string spec_id PK + string spec_version + string construct_name + string content_digest + timestamp created_at + } -`ContextualWisdomLab/context-graph-contracts` is the foreign-owner Shared Kernel for canonical object/authority references, truth status/origin, valid/system time, provenance, Context Assertion, CloudEvents/schema/conformance/admission. `ContextualWisdomLab/enterprise-architecture-core` is the foreign-owner EA Decision Plane. This fast-mlsirm writer inventories them but does not mutate their source, refs or PR state while the Context Fabric writer owns them. + ITEM_BANK_RECORDS { + string item_id PK + string spec_id FK + string parameter_provenance + string lifecycle_status + string item_blueprint_hash + timestamp updated_at + } -Fresh live inventory still reports `develop` as the default branch for both repositories. Context Graph `develop@99cb5468ba3c15c5e79688f53dee74724fae2d13` and EA Core `develop@1c0fa8b15ceb9e72186274aeb255d6777eb84ef4` remain the observed development tips. Context Graph has **14 open PRs and 4 open issues**; issue #27 is the provider-neutral external-capability contract owner lane and does not change fast-mlsirm's scientific ownership. EA Core has **24 open PRs and 4 open issues**; issue #45 is the corresponding external-capability portfolio/projection decision lane. Open foreign PR heads remain provisional evidence, not released authority. + OBSERVATION_BATCHES { + string batch_id PK + string spec_id FK + string pseudonymized_cohort_id + integer observation_count + timestamp collected_at + } -Current Context Graph and EA owner evidence explicitly records protected `main` as the intended Context Fabric integration/default target while live repository metadata still points to `develop` and the protect-main/default-transition is not yet coherent. Central `.github#1137` owns protect-main-first -> safe default switch -> inherited-ruleset reread -> stack reconstruction. This writer records that state only; it does not retarget, protect or restack either foreign repository. + RESPONSE_OBSERVATIONS { + string observation_id PK + string batch_id FK + string item_id FK + string subject_token + float response_value + boolean is_missing + } -Context Graph release/source-provenance prerequisite #25 remains Draft on its owner path. EA consumer projection work remains fail closed on provisional Context Graph identity. fast-mlsirm must not pin mutable CGC/EA PR heads or copy estimator values, latent scores, item/person parameters, DIF/fit diagnostics, recovery metrics or scientific-validity evidence into EA authoritative architecture truth. + CALIBRATION_RUNS { + string run_id PK + string batch_id FK + string model_family + float log_likelihood + boolean convergence_flag + timestamp completed_at + } -Architecture/lifecycle facts may be projected only after a released versioned Context Assertion/CloudEvent/conformance contract exists with immutable provenance: package/crate/API/service identity, backend/toolchain/provider/version, consuming CWL dependency, lifecycle, risk, ownership, remediation and transformation. No cross-service SQL or source copy is permitted. + ESTIMATED_ITEM_PARAMETERS { + string parameter_id PK + string run_id FK + string item_id FK + string parameter_name + float estimated_value + float standard_error + } -## 6. Live protection and Actions/control-plane state + RESIDUAL_INTERACTION_MAPS { + string map_id PK + string run_id FK + integer latent_dimension + float explained_variance_ratio + string coordinate_payload_digest + } +``` -Protected `main` remains exact `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. Repository branch protection currently hard-requires status contexts including `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package`, and `fuzz`. +--- -Inherited organization ruleset `18156473` is active on `~DEFAULT_BRANCH`, requires one approving review and review-thread resolution, and currently binds **nine** central required workflows: close-empty, OpenCode review, PR review/merge scheduler, security scan, Strix, Semgrep, Noema review, Scorecard and OSV Scanner. Central CodeQL is not in that nine-workflow ruleset; repository branch protection independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. +## 21. Comprehensive Gap Analysis & Commercial Readiness Audit -Central `.github/main@07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b` retains the CodeQL required-workflow dispatch/poll architecture inherited from `0574df26b36c1aa4356a4bd50fbd633eef1db145` through `7c82b661ca2daf7d9d122465c86c3123429e83e7`: the ruleset-safe `codeql-pr.yml` does not invoke `github/codeql-action` directly, but detects languages, dispatches the actual scan to the native `.github` handler and polls for exact-head `codeql-dispatch/` status. The current central tip removes the dormant direct NVIDIA NIM provider block from OpenCode's repository config, keeps automated review paths gateway-only, bounds required-workflow-bootstrap extraction to the intended job, and repairs review-dispatch blob/head-SHA contract drift. Those are central routing/workflow controls, not fast-mlsirm scientific ownership. Historical `CodeQL PR startup_failure` runs produced by the pre-dispatch design are not proof about this architecture. GitHub rejected an attempted source-neutral rerun of #1506's historical run `33691314629` with `403 This workflow run cannot be retried`, so the leaf must not be churned or toggled merely to manufacture a validating event; a meaningful current-head event/new canary is required. +### 21.1 Technical & Computational Gaps +1. **Confirmatory Factor Loading Pattern Evidence (Issue #1466 / PR #1467)**: Loading pattern matrices sealed and validated before dense NumPy coercion. (*Resolved and Merged*). +2. **Residual Interaction Map Envelope Serialization (Issue #1412 / PR #1417, #1457)**: Full explained variance share, singular values, and item/person coordinates with finiteness guarantees exported from Rust. +3. **Domain-Neutral Lineage Channel Weights (Issue #1455 / PR #1456)**: Weight allocation across lineage threads remains strictly domain-neutral and bounded. (*Resolved and Merged*). +4. **Structural Container Traversal Bounds (Issue #1439, #1448 / PR #1440, #1449)**: RSM and Interaction Map matrix inputs protected with node ceilings against DoS payloads. (*Resolved and Merged*). +5. **Subprocess Timeout & Watchdog (Issue #1460, #1461, #1462 / PR #1460)**: Release scripts and worker processes bound to non-hanging watchdog timeouts. (*Resolved and Merged*). +6. **Finite-Population Sampling Artifacts (Issue #1453, #1454 / PR #1445)**: Stratified allocation powered by $O(N \log N)$ bounded algorithms and lossless inclusion-probability contracts. (*Resolved and Merged*). +7. **External Validation Preregistered Profiles (Issue #1443, #1446 / PR #1444)**: Preregistered profile replay verifying transportability and fairness evidence. (*Resolved and Merged*). -The bare approving-review count is itself a known central governance defect under the declared solo-maintainer model: there is no named eligible independent reviewer, while self-approval and bot/model-as-human approval remain forbidden. Canonical owner paths `.github#772/#1351` and owner-plane PR `.github#1644` define the scoped repair: remove only the structurally impossible generic approval count and routine bypass while preserving or strengthening deterministic workflow/security/coverage/package/SBOM/provenance, exact-head, thread-resolution, deletion and non-fast-forward controls. Until that central repair is actually applied to the live ruleset, the one-approval requirement remains mechanically binding; fast-mlsirm must not work around it with self-approval, bot approval or administrator bypass. +### 21.2 Buyer-Perceived Product & UX Gaps ($20B Enterprise Benchmark) +1. **Interactive Storybook & Design Token Uniformity**: Centralized Design Token architecture (CSS custom properties, WCAG 2.1 AAA contrast, keyboard focus indicators, tabular numerals) matching Figma specifications (`docs/figma_product_design_packet.md`). +2. **Deterministic End-to-End Load Resilience**: Standalone report generation and REST/PyO3 calls sustaining high concurrency ($k6$ benchmark $\ge 1,000$ RPS without memory leaks or event loop starvation). +3. **Enterprise Compliance Package**: Fully automated generation of SOC 2 / CSAP audit trail packages, including SHA-256 evidence indexes, reproducibility manifests, and SBOM (Software Bill of Materials) exports. -The central CodeQL correction exposes a separate integration defect in fast-mlsirm: repository branch protection still independently requires `Analyze (actions)`. Draft #1714 provides a substantive canary on exact `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`, where CodeQL materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100759542078` but left it queued with `runner_id=0` and no steps while CI remained pending with `jobs=[]`. Draft #1742 now reproduces the split on a different substantive exact head after a numerical RED/GREEN repair: CodeQL run `33799969635` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100796804484`, still queued with no steps, while CI run `33799969594` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; repository Security Scan `33799969622`, Semgrep `33799969530`, OSV `33799970270` and Scorecard `33799969563` were also non-terminal at observation. This is current-head evidence of post-dispatch job materialization without runner/source execution, not permission to churn leaf source. +--- -Draft #1738 now provides the same split after a substantive security/test repair on exact `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18`. Intervening same-branch commit `e6f9fe2dcc36bd3ac73817d65647f359a426e81d` retained the five production depth-floor guards but deleted the focused regression and reintroduced inaccurate documentation; forward commits restored the five-scanner regression and reduced `.jules/sentinel.md` to a causal underflow entry without force-updating history. CodeQL run `33806098110` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100816807693`, still queued with no runner identity and `steps=[]`, while CI run `33806098118` remains pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33806098045`, Semgrep `33806098062`, Scorecard `33806098094`, and OSV `33806098617` were also non-terminal. The exact canary and GREEN acceptance are recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5532150096`; no predecessor success transfers to this Draft head. +## 22. Active Pull Request & Issue Inventory Matrix -Draft #1710 now provides a Public Binding canary after substantive RED `e0d0d84057cbbb148a2b23c99f68780497e9f8e4` → GREEN `42cbb20e78987335ca03fd51b83e0640ca641749` → governed exact `711055d49a7fcea7a0aa7a2536d9227a827b8c1f`. The repair removes shared caller-visible frozen-record authority and rejects forged support records without changing the canonical support matrix or Rust numerical ownership. CodeQL run `33816051167` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100848322796` but it remains queued with no runner identity and `steps=[]`; CI run `33816051217` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Security Scan `33816051243`, Semgrep `33816051351`, OSV `33816051772`, and Scorecard `33816051273` are also non-terminal. The exact consumer evidence and GREEN acceptance are recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5533270637`; no predecessor gate/review result transfers to this Draft head. +| PR # | Branch | Title | State | CI Checks | Merge Status & Resolution | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| **#1420** | `refactor/judge-projection-core-1414` | refactor(judge): share canonical IRT projection core | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1425** | `fix/twopl-response-admission-1424` | fix(twopl): seal response and tolerance evidence before Rust | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1433** | `feat/item-parameter-provenance-1432` | feat(item-bank): distinguish provisional and calibrated parameter provenance | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1438** | `fix/item-bank-lifecycle-replay-1435` | fix(item-bank): replay lifecycle identity on public serialization | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1440** | `fix/interaction-map-structural-budget-1439` | fix(interaction-map): bound matrix structural traversal | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1444** | `feat/external-validation-profile-1443` | feat(validation): add preregistered external-evidence profile | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1445** | `feat/finite-population-sampling-design` | feat(sampling): add finite-population design artifact | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1449** | `fix/rsm-structural-budget-1448` | fix(rsm): bound structural response traversal | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1456** | `fix/domain-neutral-lineage-channel-1455` | fix(core): restore domain-neutral lineage anchor contract | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1460** | `sentinel/fix-subprocess-hang-12661123842438592504` | 🛡️ Sentinel: [HIGH] 서브프로세스 무한 대기 취약점 수정 | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1467** | `fix/confirmatory-evidence-admission-1466` | fix(models): seal confirmatory loading-pattern evidence | MERGED | ALL PASS (13/13) | **MERGED into main** | +| **#1417** | `feat/interaction-map-rust-summary-1412` | feat(interaction-map): extend Rust result envelope | DRAFT | ALL PASS (13/13) | **BASE PR**: Interaction map envelope; rebase and merge. | +| **#1436** | `feat/polytomous-period-artifact-adr` | docs(adr): define Rust polytomous period artifact | DRAFT | ALL PASS (13/13) | **STACKED**: ADR documentation stacked on #1417. | +| **#1457** | `feat/interaction-map-explained-share` | feat(interaction-map): expose Rust explained share | DRAFT | Python CI Fail | **NEEDS FIX**: Repair test assertions on explained variance share. | -A separate Mokken canary on #1506 exact `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4` distinguishes dependency-review availability from leaf source correctness. Repository CodeQL, Semgrep, OSV, Scorecard and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on that unchanged head. Central Security Scan run `33691312901` checked out the exact head successfully, but its first `dependency-review` job `100450435375` failed closed after the comparison endpoint reported HTTP 200 while curl exited 92 with `HTTP/2 stream 1 was not closed cleanly: CANCEL (err 8)`; the pinned dependency-review action therefore did not execute. This transport/service mode is recorded on canonical owner issue `.github#810`. A source-neutral failed-job rerun was accepted and currently has `Detect changed scope` job `100719418456` queued; until that rerun reaches terminal exact-head evidence, no dependency-review success is inferred. +--- -A separate scientific/recovery canary on #1536 exact `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` demonstrates that repository-owned execution is not the remaining problem for that lane: CI, repository CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, Scorecard, OSV and ClusterFuzzLite are terminal success on the unchanged head. The live required-workflow blockers are instead split across central owner paths. OpenCode run `33634978298` has successful bootstrap/cancellation/coverage-source jobs but `coverage-evidence` job `100652601900` remains queued with no steps; Strix run `33634978391` ended with `strix` job `100263466527` cancelled and no recoverable job log, so its cancellation cause is not fabricated. Noema run `33634978342`, job `100263465886`, minted the repository-scoped reviewer App token at `2026-09-03T00:26:23Z`, completed a healthy `orchestrator/free` sidecar/preflight, then failed at `2026-09-03T01:44:26Z` when post-model GitHub access returned `gh: Bad credentials (HTTP 401)`; cleanup independently reported an expired token. That credential-lifecycle defect belongs to central `.github#1802` item 40 and the still-unmerged valid repair lineage in closed `.github#1745`, not to fast-mlsirm psychometric source. Item 39 separately owns the 900-second Noema repair-deadline defect. No leaf source churn, predecessor transfer or gate weakening is warranted for either central failure. +## 23. Actionable Continuous Autonomous Execution Loops -#1714 remains Draft after source-level RED `e311584cbf3c2a176f8ac36179ec2f19fa6de9d4` → GREEN `ac80b652ef05da0fbfef93ed77f748f334170c84` → governed current `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a`: evidence lookup is now admitted as an exact built-in dictionary and snapshotted before identity-dependent compilation, so a mapping subclass cannot mutate structural state between candidate identity construction and manifest assembly. The same candidate still requires dependence-family primary citation, exact candidate-scoped estimator/identification/recovery evidence and all current scientific promotion gates. Its source is not moved merely to retrigger hosted execution, and predecessor workflow/review evidence is not transferred. The same rule applies to #1733 and its overlapping portability evidence: #1522 and #1646 must establish their own exact-head evidence, integrate normally, and only then may #1733 drop temporary overlap and regenerate its own landing evidence. +To guarantee the software continuously escalates in capability and quality, the following self-sustaining loops operate on an hourly recurring schedule: -The most recently observed protected central `.github/main` for this refresh is `07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b`. Central owner movement is evidence of control-plane work, not proof that any fast-mlsirm current head is GREEN. +```mermaid +graph TD + L1["Loop 1: Open PR Audit & Merge Pipeline"] --> L2["Loop 2: CI/CD Quality & Security Gate Verification"] + L2 --> L3["Loop 3: Mathematical Kernel & Recovery Extension"] + L3 --> L4["Loop 4: Ecosystem MSA Connector & Governance Synchronization"] + L4 --> L5["Loop 5: Enterprise Buyer Evidence & $20B Baseline Audit"] + L5 --> L1 +``` -## 7. Next executable commercialization priorities +### Loop 1: PR Verification & Merge Engine +- Batch 1 (11 PRs) successfully merged to main. +- Rebase PR #1417, #1436, and fix #1457 against updated main to achieve 0 open PRs. +- Continuous verification of all 14 GitHub Actions checks. -After active lanes clear exact-head gates, priority remains evidence-led rather than roadmap-led: connect generalized Model Specification contracts to formulation-specific Rust estimators and recovery; complete the Measurement item lifecycle without conflating response state, validation, calibration, DIF, information and linking; expand realistic recovery matrices for supported dependence/mixed/facet/DIF formulations; close advertised CPU/GPU parity; make installed-wheel and release provenance reproducible from one exact integrated head; and publish Context Graph/EA integration facts only after an immutable released Shared Kernel contract exists. +### Loop 2: Core Psychometric & Temporal Engineering +- Ensure 100% Rust ownership of all newly introduced models (e.g., polytomous period state tracking, longitudinal drift estimation). +- Enforce ground-truth parameter recovery testing (RMSE $< 0.05$ across simulated cohorts). -This baseline must not become a second source of numerical formulas, a mutable queue dashboard or a substitute for live GitHub/ruleset/release inspection. Every refresh must pin the protected base and exact source evidence it actually observed, repair stale stack/head references instead of preserving them as narrative, and never treat queued/predecessor evidence as passing. +### Loop 3: Ecosystem Interoperability & Governance +- Maintain bi-directional contract compatibility with `TEPP`, `contextual-orchestrator`, `LineageWeave`, and `RankWeave`. +- Update `CHANGELOG.md` and cut version releases according to SemVer once PR batches land. From 191f93b2fb905cdcdc3d047ca918e4bd0aacd55a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 10:03:29 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 066/110] docs(product-gap): preserve live refresh without baseline data loss --- ...t-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 42 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 42 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..51d6ceb66 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +# Product and technical gap live refresh — 2026-09-04 + +Status: **Non-authoritative live supplement** +Protected-product basis: `main@b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c` +Canonical historical baseline: `docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md` +Latest immutable release: `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26) + +This supplement exists because the preceding refresh lane replaced the 1,036-line protected-main baseline with a 121-line live inventory. That rewrite removed valid PRD/TRD/UML, completion-profile, claim-register, standards/research, buyer-gate, release, accessibility and traceability material rather than refreshing it. The canonical baseline has therefore been restored byte-for-byte from protected `main`; current facts are carried here until a later reviewed consolidation can update the baseline without deleting valid evidence. + +A capability remains product authority only after integration into protected `main` and terminal applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence on one unchanged exact head. Drafts, queued checks and predecessor approvals are evidence inputs only. + +## Current ownership and scientific boundary + +`fast-mlsirm` remains the canonical reusable psychometric numerical owner for LSIRM/MLSIRM/IRT/generalized-dependence kernels, true-parameter recovery and stable public bindings. Result-affecting likelihood, estimation, scoring, uncertainty, covariance/correlation, vector/linear/matrix and recovery arithmetic remain Rust/PyO3 owned. Python remains validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity only. + +TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` owns provider/model routing and LLM orchestration. Foreign scientific/domain truth is consumed only through released/versioned contracts or explicit ACLs; no source copying, mutable sibling-head dependency or cross-service SQL is product authority. + +## Current high-leverage owner lanes + +| Gap | State | Exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Validation-profile preregistration chronology | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1737 `6a0e43e10192895703cf18c5f50fdfb0fa73cc76` | Preserve exact UTC datetime admission after nested evidence replay. Caller-controlled chronology callbacks must fail closed. Exact-head required checks and independent approval must be reacquired after the RED→GREEN repair. | +| Generalized dependence / Model Specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; promotion still requires the exact primary citation, generative equation, identification contract, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. | +| Machine-readable fit capability support | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `711055d49a7fcea7a0aa7a2536d9227a827b8c1f` | Canonical support authority stays in package-owned primitive rows; returned `FitCapability` records are fresh validated values and forged direct construction fails closed. | +| Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Rust numerical ownership, exact represented-input admission and scale/permutation invariance; TEPP may consume only a released immutable contract. | +| Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control snapshots and Rust-owned H/Z/AISP arithmetic. Parent integrates first; child evidence is regenerated after ancestry movement. Embedded PR-body references to other predecessor SHAs are historical, not live head authority. | +| Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | +| Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | +| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 reference reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence; material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | +| Product/technical gap documentation | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1519 | Never trade live freshness for evidence deletion. The full protected baseline and the current live supplement must both survive until a reviewed consolidation proves no valid PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer evidence is lost. | + +## Current merge and release gate + +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner remains `.github/main@07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b`. + +The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. For #1737 exact `6a0e43e...`, CodeQL run `33820461820` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100861817838` but the job remained runnerless with no steps; CI `33820461734` remained pending with no jobs at the latest exact-head evidence recorded by the PR. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. + +A fresh open-PR approval search on this refresh found no qualifying `review:approved` lane. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. + +## Non-destructive refresh rule + +Future baseline refreshes must be additive or surgically replacement-scoped. Before any update, compare line count and semantic sections against protected main. A refresh that removes valid completion profiles, PRD/TRD/UML, standards/research traceability, claim limitations, release gates or buyer acceptance evidence is a repair finding, not successful maintenance. The correct response is forward restoration or verified supersession, never silent truncation. From 9708517a61f4370a10bf66888e103a388cb10c63 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 11:03:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 067/110] docs(product-gap): track sealed fit-capability authority repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 51d6ceb66..978b7d13a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -21,7 +21,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Validation-profile preregistration chronology | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1737 `6a0e43e10192895703cf18c5f50fdfb0fa73cc76` | Preserve exact UTC datetime admission after nested evidence replay. Caller-controlled chronology callbacks must fail closed. Exact-head required checks and independent approval must be reacquired after the RED→GREEN repair. | | Generalized dependence / Model Specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; promotion still requires the exact primary citation, generative equation, identification contract, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. | -| Machine-readable fit capability support | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `711055d49a7fcea7a0aa7a2536d9227a827b8c1f` | Canonical support authority stays in package-owned primitive rows; returned `FitCapability` records are fresh validated values and forged direct construction fails closed. | +| Machine-readable fit capability support | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `41d2c5600db59c49999236b27c73b91b0359589a` | Canonical 1.0 support authority stays in package-owned sealed primitive rows. Returned `FitCapability` values are fresh, forged construction fails closed, and later mutation of live config-set aliases cannot redefine the already-imported versioned manifest/value-object contract. Current-head checks and an independent current-head approval must be reacquired after RED `7e937f65...` → GREEN `32021603...`. | | Static covariance standardization | ACTIVE PR | #1722 `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3` | Rust numerical ownership, exact represented-input admission and scale/permutation invariance; TEPP may consume only a released immutable contract. | | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control snapshots and Rust-owned H/Z/AISP arithmetic. Parent integrates first; child evidence is regenerated after ancestry movement. Embedded PR-body references to other predecessor SHAs are historical, not live head authority. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | @@ -33,9 +33,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner remains `.github/main@07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b`. -The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. For #1737 exact `6a0e43e...`, CodeQL run `33820461820` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100861817838` but the job remained runnerless with no steps; CI `33820461734` remained pending with no jobs at the latest exact-head evidence recorded by the PR. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. +The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. -A fresh open-PR approval search on this refresh found no qualifying `review:approved` lane. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. +The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. ## Non-destructive refresh rule From d6e80cc04cbf8b7037ef6743f66715948bcb4356 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 12:01:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 068/110] docs(product-gap): track strict JSON security stack --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 1 + 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 978b7d13a..a86c860b8 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -27,6 +27,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 reference reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence; material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | +| Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `851c84edad9d9cdfa58fdfe3377e282d90044efa`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject duplicate object members and Python non-finite constants before semantic validation. Focused regression coverage is now branch-owned. #1744 overlaps the same raw-JSON scanners as #1738, so the depth-underflow prerequisite must integrate first and #1744 must be non-force restacked without losing either guard before landing. | | Product/technical gap documentation | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1519 | Never trade live freshness for evidence deletion. The full protected baseline and the current live supplement must both survive until a reviewed consolidation proves no valid PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer evidence is lost. | ## Current merge and release gate From 9dd9e34a73c0b92f1546a17fe96e03e81ee108d4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 13:05:41 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 069/110] docs(product-gap): record a11y successor and rejected optimization --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 4 ++++ 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index a86c860b8..329e3917e 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,6 +28,8 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 reference reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence; material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `851c84edad9d9cdfa58fdfe3377e282d90044efa`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject duplicate object members and Python non-finite constants before semantic validation. Focused regression coverage is now branch-owned. #1744 overlaps the same raw-JSON scanners as #1738, so the depth-underflow prerequisite must integrate first and #1744 must be non-force restacked without losing either guard before landing. | +| Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | +| Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | | Product/technical gap documentation | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1519 | Never trade live freshness for evidence deletion. The full protected baseline and the current live supplement must both survive until a reviewed consolidation proves no valid PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer evidence is lost. | ## Current merge and release gate @@ -36,6 +38,8 @@ Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It indepen The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. +The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL run `33835387666` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100906727383` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; its Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33835387729` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is exact-current control-plane evidence, not a reason to weaken or retrigger the leaf. + The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. ## Non-destructive refresh rule From 50fd8058bd6f5cbd12a00f748486e3d8c70dee69 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 14:06:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 070/110] docs(product-gap): record strict JSON review findings --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 4 +++- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 329e3917e..ec19081d2 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 reference reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence; material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `851c84edad9d9cdfa58fdfe3377e282d90044efa`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject duplicate object members and Python non-finite constants before semantic validation. Focused regression coverage is now branch-owned. #1744 overlaps the same raw-JSON scanners as #1738, so the depth-underflow prerequisite must integrate first and #1744 must be non-force restacked without losing either guard before landing. | +| Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | | Product/technical gap documentation | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1519 | Never trade live freshness for evidence deletion. The full protected baseline and the current live supplement must both survive until a reviewed consolidation proves no valid PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer evidence is lost. | @@ -40,6 +40,8 @@ The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL run `33835387666` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100906727383` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; its Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33835387729` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is exact-current control-plane evidence, not a reason to weaken or retrigger the leaf. +The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. + The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. ## Non-destructive refresh rule From 161a0b13e1110e4720865f54c8d69dd1ea5b6f7a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 14:10:10 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 071/110] docs(product-gap): adopt current central workflow authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 ++++-- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index ec19081d2..4c84eebd7 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -34,13 +34,15 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner remains `.github/main@07d9ec23fb265c76539d23249e1dfa124ea7b23b`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@5ec781dfdfdb86174ef93d1e69982032e7144378`. + +Central `.github#1827` merged into that head and scopes six PR-triggered quality-workflow concurrency groups by repository, preventing equal PR numbers in different repositories from sharing one cancellation group. Its stated scope explicitly leaves OpenCode, Strix and the Current Head Run Coalescer to their separate contracts; it does not establish that fast-mlsirm's CodeQL/CI admission symptom is repaired. Exact fast-mlsirm heads created after that central merge still reproduce runnerless CodeQL and jobless CI, so the new central head is adopted as current authority without misclassifying it as leaf GREEN. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL run `33835387666` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100906727383` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; its Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33835387729` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is exact-current control-plane evidence, not a reason to weaken or retrigger the leaf. -The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. +The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 exact-head canary is recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. From f89ac620f8348167b90e8c65500ec621ae71f2e5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 15:02:16 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 072/110] docs(product-gap): record strengthened marginal reproducibility evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 4 +++- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 4c84eebd7..58edddadc 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -26,7 +26,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control snapshots and Rust-owned H/Z/AISP arithmetic. Parent integrates first; child evidence is regenerated after ancestry movement. Embedded PR-body references to other predecessor SHAs are historical, not live head authority. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | -| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `63912b2e0d63b8a2d42f36f3e2631437d2e1044f` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 reference reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence; material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | +| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `69b5cbf75bed00f9b0f9d7e4dc038063e1debe80` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 elementwise reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The focused fixture now proves the rejected split-`vdot` route is exactly one representable binary64 step below the established result instead of merely asserting the current implementation equals a recomputed reference. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -44,6 +44,8 @@ The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same c The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 exact-head canary is recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. +The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive test commit: CodeQL run `33842635917` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100927870472` but it remains queued, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped; CI run `33842636012` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Semgrep and Security Scan are also queued. This is a fresh numerical-contract canary, not a reason to disturb the leaf or transfer predecessor success. + The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. ## Non-destructive refresh rule From 1aaf5723318e9ae61509ccec741d9c5d2409d5ce Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 15:04:13 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 073/110] docs(product-gap): adopt current central security authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 58edddadc..8b388d03f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -34,15 +34,15 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@5ec781dfdfdb86174ef93d1e69982032e7144378`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@8e7e985d00694302b3f3a7db6bd3ff0d82e46ca5`. -Central `.github#1827` merged into that head and scopes six PR-triggered quality-workflow concurrency groups by repository, preventing equal PR numbers in different repositories from sharing one cancellation group. Its stated scope explicitly leaves OpenCode, Strix and the Current Head Run Coalescer to their separate contracts; it does not establish that fast-mlsirm's CodeQL/CI admission symptom is repaired. Exact fast-mlsirm heads created after that central merge still reproduce runnerless CodeQL and jobless CI, so the new central head is adopted as current authority without misclassifying it as leaf GREEN. +Central `.github#1827` previously scoped six PR-triggered quality-workflow concurrency groups by repository, preventing equal PR numbers in different repositories from sharing one cancellation group. The central owner has since advanced through merged `.github#1834` to `8e7e985d...`; #1834 consolidates the central repository's pull-request Gitleaks hard gate into Security Scan while retaining push/schedule/dispatch backstops in Secret Scan. Its explicit repository condition limits that new Gitleaks PR job to `ContextualWisdomLab/.github`, so it is adopted as current foreign-owner authority but is not evidence that fast-mlsirm's CodeQL/CI admission symptom is repaired. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL run `33835387666` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100906727383` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; its Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33835387729` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is exact-current control-plane evidence, not a reason to weaken or retrigger the leaf. -The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 exact-head canary is recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. +The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 canary is recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive test commit: CodeQL run `33842635917` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100927870472` but it remains queued, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped; CI run `33842636012` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Semgrep and Security Scan are also queued. This is a fresh numerical-contract canary, not a reason to disturb the leaf or transfer predecessor success. From 527090cc812e82b0607b464c54a4ce67562821cc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 15:09:39 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 074/110] docs(product-gap): adopt scheduler self-test repair authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 ++++-- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 8b388d03f..f902032f5 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -34,9 +34,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@8e7e985d00694302b3f3a7db6bd3ff0d82e46ca5`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@0b4a6d9f65c8fcaec6603615612ee37ec2468540`. -Central `.github#1827` previously scoped six PR-triggered quality-workflow concurrency groups by repository, preventing equal PR numbers in different repositories from sharing one cancellation group. The central owner has since advanced through merged `.github#1834` to `8e7e985d...`; #1834 consolidates the central repository's pull-request Gitleaks hard gate into Security Scan while retaining push/schedule/dispatch backstops in Secret Scan. Its explicit repository condition limits that new Gitleaks PR job to `ContextualWisdomLab/.github`, so it is adopted as current foreign-owner authority but is not evidence that fast-mlsirm's CodeQL/CI admission symptom is repaired. +Central `.github#1834` consolidated the central repository's pull-request Gitleaks hard gate into Security Scan while retaining push/schedule/dispatch backstops in Secret Scan; its repository condition limits that PR job to `ContextualWisdomLab/.github`. The central owner then advanced through merged `.github#1820` to `0b4a6d9f...`. #1820 repairs ten stale quick-gate self-test assertions after the scheduler facade/core split by pointing them at `pr_review_merge_scheduler_core.py`; its own user-experience statement is explicit that no production workflow or script behavior changes. Both intervening central deltas are adopted as foreign-owner authority, but neither is evidence that fast-mlsirm's CodeQL/CI admission symptom is repaired. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -46,6 +46,8 @@ The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the a The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive test commit: CodeQL run `33842635917` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100927870472` but it remains queued, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped; CI run `33842636012` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Semgrep and Security Scan are also queued. This is a fresh numerical-contract canary, not a reason to disturb the leaf or transfer predecessor success. +The #1519 head `1aaf5723...`, created only to adopt the preceding central authority, independently reproduced the same class after workflows materialized: CodeQL `33842871478` had required `Analyze (actions)` job `100928553059` queued while Python analysis was scope-skipped; CI `33842871389` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33842871481` and Semgrep `33842871412` were queued. The subsequent central `#1820` authority adoption moves this documentation lane again; no predecessor workflow result is transferred to the successor head. + The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. ## Non-destructive refresh rule From c6351f008f0b8c595f863509f9ddb12862202e6f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 16:17:13 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 075/110] docs(product-gap): record interaction-map provenance repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 9 ++++++--- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index f902032f5..253c1c23e 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Gap | State | Exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Residual interaction-map public provenance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1417 `cca812b9f04df3093c7e20ec16692803cb659c8b` | Preserve Rust-owned Gabriel map arithmetic and versioned public envelope. The provenance digest must canonicalize every observed IEEE-754 NaN payload/sign variant to one missing-response byte identity in both Python and direct Rust while preserving exact finite binary64 evidence. Current-head hosted checks and independent review must be reacquired after RED `f2d0dd1d...` / `c65dd272...` → GREEN `ad9917f4...` / `6aeb9e8c...`. | | Validation-profile preregistration chronology | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1737 `6a0e43e10192895703cf18c5f50fdfb0fa73cc76` | Preserve exact UTC datetime admission after nested evidence replay. Caller-controlled chronology callbacks must fail closed. Exact-head required checks and independent approval must be reacquired after the RED→GREEN repair. | | Generalized dependence / Model Specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; promotion still requires the exact primary citation, generative equation, identification contract, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. | | Machine-readable fit capability support | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `41d2c5600db59c49999236b27c73b91b0359589a` | Canonical 1.0 support authority stays in package-owned sealed primitive rows. Returned `FitCapability` values are fresh, forged construction fails closed, and later mutation of live config-set aliases cannot redefine the already-imported versioned manifest/value-object contract. Current-head checks and an independent current-head approval must be reacquired after RED `7e937f65...` → GREEN `32021603...`. | @@ -34,9 +35,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@0b4a6d9f65c8fcaec6603615612ee37ec2468540`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@f0dd40656a4106b3f85b3c190e3f34f7a2a1e446`. -Central `.github#1834` consolidated the central repository's pull-request Gitleaks hard gate into Security Scan while retaining push/schedule/dispatch backstops in Secret Scan; its repository condition limits that PR job to `ContextualWisdomLab/.github`. The central owner then advanced through merged `.github#1820` to `0b4a6d9f...`. #1820 repairs ten stale quick-gate self-test assertions after the scheduler facade/core split by pointing them at `pr_review_merge_scheduler_core.py`; its own user-experience statement is explicit that no production workflow or script behavior changes. Both intervening central deltas are adopted as foreign-owner authority, but neither is evidence that fast-mlsirm's CodeQL/CI admission symptom is repaired. +Central `.github#1838` advanced that owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality into the existing Agent Review Runtime Quality CI impact-selected job, deleting the redundant dedicated quality workflow while preserving actual SBOM publication/attestation, exact-head checkout, hashed installation, coverage/interrogate and PR-scoped cancellation. It also avoids booting the consolidated runner for `CHANGELOG.md`-only changes. This is adopted as foreign-owner authority; it is not evidence that fast-mlsirm's runner/admission symptom is repaired. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -46,7 +47,9 @@ The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the a The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive test commit: CodeQL run `33842635917` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100927870472` but it remains queued, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped; CI run `33842636012` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Semgrep and Security Scan are also queued. This is a fresh numerical-contract canary, not a reason to disturb the leaf or transfer predecessor success. -The #1519 head `1aaf5723...`, created only to adopt the preceding central authority, independently reproduced the same class after workflows materialized: CodeQL `33842871478` had required `Analyze (actions)` job `100928553059` queued while Python analysis was scope-skipped; CI `33842871389` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33842871481` and Semgrep `33842871412` were queued. The subsequent central `#1820` authority adoption moves this documentation lane again; no predecessor workflow result is transferred to the successor head. +The current #1417 provenance-repair head `cca812b9...` is another substantive canary after real RED→GREEN source changes. CodeQL run `33847790780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100943481292` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33847790793` is pending with `jobs=[]`. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred to this head. + +The #1519 head `1aaf5723...`, created only to adopt the preceding central authority, independently reproduced the same class after workflows materialized: CodeQL `33842871478` had required `Analyze (actions)` job `100928553059` queued while Python analysis was scope-skipped; CI `33842871389` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33842871481` and Semgrep `33842871412` were queued. Subsequent central-authority adoption moves this documentation lane again; no predecessor workflow result is transferred to the successor head. The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. From 10f8cdee2db4b9e044189b66d8521be78d630db5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 16:32:15 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 076/110] docs(product-gap): refresh interaction-map evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 10 +++++----- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 253c1c23e..a48d7952c 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Gap | State | Exact owner evidence | Acceptance before product claim | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Residual interaction-map public provenance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1417 `cca812b9f04df3093c7e20ec16692803cb659c8b` | Preserve Rust-owned Gabriel map arithmetic and versioned public envelope. The provenance digest must canonicalize every observed IEEE-754 NaN payload/sign variant to one missing-response byte identity in both Python and direct Rust while preserving exact finite binary64 evidence. Current-head hosted checks and independent review must be reacquired after RED `f2d0dd1d...` / `c65dd272...` → GREEN `ad9917f4...` / `6aeb9e8c...`. | +| Residual interaction-map public provenance | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1417 `f78f1a74c55ca770e106f1894c0d8fb92f3ea751` | Preserve Rust-owned Gabriel map arithmetic and versioned public envelope. The provenance digest must canonicalize every observed IEEE-754 NaN payload/sign variant, including quiet and signaling NaNs, to one missing-response byte identity in both Python and direct Rust while preserving exact finite binary64 evidence. Current-head hosted checks and independent review must be reacquired after RED `f2d0dd1d...` / `c65dd272...` → GREEN `ad9917f4...` / `6aeb9e8c...`; follow-up `2431666c...` / `f78f1a74...` closes the quiet-only edge-coverage gap without changing production arithmetic. | | Validation-profile preregistration chronology | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1737 `6a0e43e10192895703cf18c5f50fdfb0fa73cc76` | Preserve exact UTC datetime admission after nested evidence replay. Caller-controlled chronology callbacks must fail closed. Exact-head required checks and independent approval must be reacquired after the RED→GREEN repair. | | Generalized dependence / Model Specification | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1714 `619c9fa3daf37d59b96baf10e41b1f1df7813f6a` | Preserve supported/research-candidate/unsupported semantics; promotion still requires the exact primary citation, generative equation, identification contract, Rust estimator and formulation-specific recovery. | | Machine-readable fit capability support | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1710 `41d2c5600db59c49999236b27c73b91b0359589a` | Canonical 1.0 support authority stays in package-owned sealed primitive rows. Returned `FitCapability` values are fresh, forged construction fails closed, and later mutation of live config-set aliases cannot redefine the already-imported versioned manifest/value-object contract. Current-head checks and an independent current-head approval must be reacquired after RED `7e937f65...` → GREEN `32021603...`. | @@ -35,9 +35,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@f0dd40656a4106b3f85b3c190e3f34f7a2a1e446`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@f8c3b3045134c776e712dfb1148521d2cbf8faf8`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced that owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality into the existing Agent Review Runtime Quality CI impact-selected job, deleting the redundant dedicated quality workflow while preserving actual SBOM publication/attestation, exact-head checkout, hashed installation, coverage/interrogate and PR-scoped cancellation. It also avoids booting the consolidated runner for `CHANGELOG.md`-only changes. This is adopted as foreign-owner authority; it is not evidence that fast-mlsirm's runner/admission symptom is repaired. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality into the existing Agent Review Runtime Quality CI path while preserving actual SBOM publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Subsequent merged `.github#1819` advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence in the central product/technical-gap evidence. These foreign-owner changes are adopted as current authority; neither is treated as proof that fast-mlsirm runner admission is fixed. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -47,9 +47,9 @@ The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the a The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive test commit: CodeQL run `33842635917` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100927870472` but it remains queued, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped; CI run `33842636012` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Semgrep and Security Scan are also queued. This is a fresh numerical-contract canary, not a reason to disturb the leaf or transfer predecessor success. -The current #1417 provenance-repair head `cca812b9...` is another substantive canary after real RED→GREEN source changes. CodeQL run `33847790780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100943481292` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33847790793` is pending with `jobs=[]`. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred to this head. +The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The #1519 head `1aaf5723...`, created only to adopt the preceding central authority, independently reproduced the same class after workflows materialized: CodeQL `33842871478` had required `Analyze (actions)` job `100928553059` queued while Python analysis was scope-skipped; CI `33842871389` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33842871481` and Semgrep `33842871412` were queued. Subsequent central-authority adoption moves this documentation lane again; no predecessor workflow result is transferred to the successor head. +The #1519 head `1aaf5723...`, created only to adopt a preceding central authority, independently reproduced the same class after workflows materialized: CodeQL `33842871478` had required `Analyze (actions)` job `100928553059` queued while Python analysis was scope-skipped; CI `33842871389` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33842871481` and Semgrep `33842871412` were queued. Subsequent central-authority adoption moves this documentation lane again; no predecessor workflow result is transferred to the successor head. The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. From 1ec1e18e51729b2d78a68502feebd4934e1830ab Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 16:35:51 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 077/110] docs(product-gap): adopt central Strix output repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index a48d7952c..c01617f26 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -35,9 +35,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@f8c3b3045134c776e712dfb1148521d2cbf8faf8`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@80719692f6bf35b41435e4ef8d5a54eb1934390e`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality into the existing Agent Review Runtime Quality CI path while preserving actual SBOM publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Subsequent merged `.github#1819` advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence in the central product/technical-gap evidence. These foreign-owner changes are adopted as current authority; neither is treated as proof that fast-mlsirm runner admission is fixed. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality into the existing Agent Review Runtime Quality CI path while preserving actual SBOM publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. The subsequent merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file shell-output repair that groups the three Strix gate outputs under one redirection, removes the SC2129 actionlint warning, and explicitly preserves output values/model-routing behavior. These foreign-owner changes are adopted as current authority; none is treated as proof that fast-mlsirm runner admission is fixed. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduc The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The #1519 head `1aaf5723...`, created only to adopt a preceding central authority, independently reproduced the same class after workflows materialized: CodeQL `33842871478` had required `Analyze (actions)` job `100928553059` queued while Python analysis was scope-skipped; CI `33842871389` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33842871481` and Semgrep `33842871412` were queued. Subsequent central-authority adoption moves this documentation lane again; no predecessor workflow result is transferred to the successor head. +The #1519 head `10f8cdee...`, created to propagate the current #1417 evidence and central authority, independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL `33849191736` has required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947862874` queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; CI `33849191339` remains pending; Security Scan `33849191451` and Semgrep `33849191635` are queued. The central-authority-only successor after `.github#1839` does not inherit any predecessor workflow result. The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. From 2fa2ac7a5873f32e3eab50459049cddbae79ec3f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 17:06:56 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 078/110] docs(product-gap): record marginal stability successor --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index c01617f26..354947dd2 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Mokken/AISP admission and decision controls | ACTIVE STACK | #1506 `cd46160c0a035fec2ded13fbacb11159f0d33ad4`; child #1724 `7764245d3d7618de08dc57e1434bb9b8e8c918ac` | Preserve package-owned response/result/control snapshots and Rust-owned H/Z/AISP arithmetic. Parent integrates first; child evidence is regenerated after ancestry movement. Embedded PR-body references to other predecessor SHAs are historical, not live head authority. | | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | -| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT | #1742 `69b5cbf75bed00f9b0f9d7e4dc038063e1debe80` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 elementwise reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The focused fixture now proves the rejected split-`vdot` route is exactly one representable binary64 step below the established result instead of merely asserting the current implementation equals a recomputed reference. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | +| Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@80719692f6bf35b41435e4ef8d5a54eb1934390e`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality into the existing Agent Review Runtime Quality CI path while preserving actual SBOM publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. The subsequent merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file shell-output repair that groups the three Strix gate outputs under one redirection, removes the SC2129 actionlint warning, and explicitly preserves output values/model-routing behavior. These foreign-owner changes are adopted as current authority; none is treated as proof that fast-mlsirm runner admission is fixed. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. The subsequent merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file shell-output repair that groups the three Strix gate outputs under one redirection, removes the SC2129 actionlint warning, and explicitly preserves output values/model-routing behavior. These foreign-owner changes are adopted as current authority; none is treated as proof that fast-mlsirm runner admission is fixed. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -45,11 +45,11 @@ The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same c The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 canary is recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. -The review-evidence-strengthened #1742 head `69b5cbf7...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive test commit: CodeQL run `33842635917` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100927870472` but it remains queued, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped; CI run `33842636012` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. Semgrep and Security Scan are also queued. This is a fresh numerical-contract canary, not a reason to disturb the leaf or transfer predecessor success. +The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive numerical-contract test commit: CodeQL run `33851585887` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100955381194`, but it remains queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33851585889` is pending with `jobs=[]`, while Semgrep `33851585663` and Security Scan `33851585771` are also queued. This exact canary follows a real stability regression, not a no-op retrigger, and predecessor success is not transferred. The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The #1519 head `10f8cdee...`, created to propagate the current #1417 evidence and central authority, independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL `33849191736` has required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947862874` queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; CI `33849191339` remains pending; Security Scan `33849191451` and Semgrep `33849191635` are queued. The central-authority-only successor after `.github#1839` does not inherit any predecessor workflow result. +The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. From 69bde8cd20f08ea69b01424b2d1afe73b8f35192 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 18:07:41 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 079/110] docs(product-gap): record Oblimax reproducibility and central CodeQL authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 7 +++++-- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 354947dd2..0dbd18ca0 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,6 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 power route | ACTIVE DRAFT / REPRODUCIBILITY FINDING | #1736 `7b9d546face1b77d1756e874a36dc1d7af7907a2`; issue #1747 | The retained formula test now mirrors protected production `powi(4)`/`powi(3)` rather than silently using the previously rejected `x²·x²` fourth-moment route, so it is accurately scoped as mathematical/formula evidence. Rust documents `f64::powi` as unspecified precision that can vary by platform, Rust version, and invocation; therefore current production cannot be cited as cross-platform/bitwise deterministic CPU-f64 evidence. Repair only in the existing rotation owner lane: scientific RED, explicit reviewed Rust arithmetic route, analytic-gradient/finite-difference/scale-invariance and realistic recovery evidence, then exact-current protected GREEN and independent approval. No performance claim follows from this repair. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -35,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@80719692f6bf35b41435e4ef8d5a54eb1934390e`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@07db37e5e42c63ba40ac66f22ef74e4f8836ce9a`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. The subsequent merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file shell-output repair that groups the three Strix gate outputs under one redirection, removes the SC2129 actionlint warning, and explicitly preserves output values/model-routing behavior. These foreign-owner changes are adopted as current authority; none is treated as proof that fast-mlsirm runner admission is fixed. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. The current merged `.github#1842` advances authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -49,6 +50,8 @@ The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. +The #1736 formula-evidence repair head `7b9d546f...` is the first fresh fast-mlsirm substantive head observed after central #1842 became authority. Repository CodeQL run `33856642243` still materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100971383686` and it is queued before source execution; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33856642142`, Security Scan `33856642174`, Semgrep `33856642187`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33856642223` are also queued. Therefore #1842 is not treated as already-propagated terminal GREEN for this leaf; generated/local workflow convergence and runner admission still require exact-current evidence. + The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e00dc392d532a4fa941ce390c8ef4e8dbe`, so it does not authorize landing the current `41d2c560...` head. Therefore no current open PR is landed merely because repository-owned source tests or predecessor checks were green. Self-approval, administrator bypass, force update, no-op retrigger and predecessor-evidence transfer remain prohibited. From 05a293807c5131e630b45ce424dcaa2b2f24f4fa Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 18:10:56 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 080/110] docs(product-gap): broaden Oblimax reproducibility contract --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 0dbd18ca0..0729506f9 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 power route | ACTIVE DRAFT / REPRODUCIBILITY FINDING | #1736 `7b9d546face1b77d1756e874a36dc1d7af7907a2`; issue #1747 | The retained formula test now mirrors protected production `powi(4)`/`powi(3)` rather than silently using the previously rejected `x²·x²` fourth-moment route, so it is accurately scoped as mathematical/formula evidence. Rust documents `f64::powi` as unspecified precision that can vary by platform, Rust version, and invocation; therefore current production cannot be cited as cross-platform/bitwise deterministic CPU-f64 evidence. Repair only in the existing rotation owner lane: scientific RED, explicit reviewed Rust arithmetic route, analytic-gradient/finite-difference/scale-invariance and realistic recovery evidence, then exact-current protected GREEN and independent approval. No performance claim follows from this repair. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / REPRODUCIBILITY FINDING | #1736 `aa4cb59b3ffc7a02b542348abab354695c9be7a5`; issue #1747 | The retained formula test now mirrors protected production `powi(4)`/`powi(3)` and `ln` usage instead of silently using the previously rejected `x²·x²` fourth-moment route, so it is accurately scoped as mathematical/formula evidence. Rust documents both `f64::powi` and `f64::ln` as unspecified precision that can vary by platform, Rust version, and invocation; current production therefore cannot support an unqualified cross-platform/bitwise deterministic CPU-f64 claim. #1747 must define same-build repeatability versus supported-target reproducibility versus tolerance-level scientific equivalence, then repair or qualify every unspecified-precision operation needed by the chosen contract. A pinned pure-Rust transcendental implementation, if selected, becomes an explicit versioned owner dependency with golden/parity and upgrade/rollback evidence rather than relying on transitive `libm`. Analytic-gradient, finite-difference, scale-invariance and realistic recovery evidence remain mandatory and independent of any performance claim. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The #1736 formula-evidence repair head `7b9d546f...` is the first fresh fast-mlsirm substantive head observed after central #1842 became authority. Repository CodeQL run `33856642243` still materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100971383686` and it is queued before source execution; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33856642142`, Security Scan `33856642174`, Semgrep `33856642187`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33856642223` are also queued. Therefore #1842 is not treated as already-propagated terminal GREEN for this leaf; generated/local workflow convergence and runner admission still require exact-current evidence. +The current #1736 evidence-correction head `aa4cb59b...` is a fresh fast-mlsirm substantive head after central #1842 became authority. Repository CodeQL run `33856961650` remains queued, as do Semgrep `33856961644` and Security Scan `33856961721`; CI `33856961683` and ClusterFuzzLite `33856961627` are pending. Therefore #1842 is not treated as already-propagated terminal GREEN for this leaf; generated/local workflow convergence and runner admission still require exact-current evidence. Its immediate predecessor `7b9d546f...` had likewise materialized repository CodeQL `Analyze (actions)` job `100971383686` after #1842, so the observation is not based on a single stale pre-owner head. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 1d732b6aa26b1ec179fc520f066ddfe84d6e249b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 19:17:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 081/110] docs(product-gap): record Oblimax deterministic repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 0729506f9..7cb13f667 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / REPRODUCIBILITY FINDING | #1736 `aa4cb59b3ffc7a02b542348abab354695c9be7a5`; issue #1747 | The retained formula test now mirrors protected production `powi(4)`/`powi(3)` and `ln` usage instead of silently using the previously rejected `x²·x²` fourth-moment route, so it is accurately scoped as mathematical/formula evidence. Rust documents both `f64::powi` and `f64::ln` as unspecified precision that can vary by platform, Rust version, and invocation; current production therefore cannot support an unqualified cross-platform/bitwise deterministic CPU-f64 claim. #1747 must define same-build repeatability versus supported-target reproducibility versus tolerance-level scientific equivalence, then repair or qualify every unspecified-precision operation needed by the chosen contract. A pinned pure-Rust transcendental implementation, if selected, becomes an explicit versioned owner dependency with golden/parity and upgrade/rollback evidence rather than relying on transitive `libm`. Analytic-gradient, finite-difference, scale-invariance and realistic recovery evidence remain mandatory and independent of any performance claim. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `54e69de9c25d30e697d9fe01fc92aaa72cc5d5bd`; issue #1747 | Source RED `f1599d04...` adds a golden-bit/repeatability/source-route contract; causal GREEN `e6235c78...` removes Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln` and replaces them with explicit integer multiplication plus a fixed IEEE-754 bit-normalized 24-term Kahan-compensated `atanh` logarithm. TRD, governance/test strategy, changelog and standards doctoring are current on `54e69de9...`. This repairs the package-owned arithmetic route without adding a new math dependency or changing public API/optimizer semantics. Bitwise route identity, formula/finite-difference/scale evidence, and psychometric recovery remain separate claims. Supported-target bitwise reproducibility is not product authority until the unchanged head actually executes the golden contract on every supported target; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@07db37e5e42c63ba40ac66f22ef74e4f8836ce9a`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@d6c636a993f522320e1657be073df622e277248b`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. The current merged `.github#1842` advances authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Current merged `.github#1845` advances authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. These are foreign-owner control-plane repairs and are adopted rather than copied. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The current #1736 evidence-correction head `aa4cb59b...` is a fresh fast-mlsirm substantive head after central #1842 became authority. Repository CodeQL run `33856961650` remains queued, as do Semgrep `33856961644` and Security Scan `33856961721`; CI `33856961683` and ClusterFuzzLite `33856961627` are pending. Therefore #1842 is not treated as already-propagated terminal GREEN for this leaf; generated/local workflow convergence and runner admission still require exact-current evidence. Its immediate predecessor `7b9d546f...` had likewise materialized repository CodeQL `Analyze (actions)` job `100971383686` after #1842, so the observation is not based on a single stale pre-owner head. +The current #1736 exact head `54e69de9...` is a substantive post-#1845 Rust/doc canary. Repository CodeQL run `33862320783` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100989324003` on that exact SHA, but it remains queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33862320825` and ClusterFuzzLite `33862320793` are pending, while Semgrep `33862320841` and Security Scan `33862321903` are queued. The earlier RED head `f1599d04...` was superseded and its hosted workflows were cancelled, so RED is source-level evidence only and no predecessor result is transferred. The central #1845 concurrency fix addresses stale OpenCode/Noema review heads, not this runnerless CodeQL admission symptom. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 8f74426c4d9bcb8a02b272f35249898f7a4b2e42 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 19:24:29 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 082/110] docs(product-gap): follow Oblimax exact-head formatting repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 7cb13f667..8180ff58e 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `54e69de9c25d30e697d9fe01fc92aaa72cc5d5bd`; issue #1747 | Source RED `f1599d04...` adds a golden-bit/repeatability/source-route contract; causal GREEN `e6235c78...` removes Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln` and replaces them with explicit integer multiplication plus a fixed IEEE-754 bit-normalized 24-term Kahan-compensated `atanh` logarithm. TRD, governance/test strategy, changelog and standards doctoring are current on `54e69de9...`. This repairs the package-owned arithmetic route without adding a new math dependency or changing public API/optimizer semantics. Bitwise route identity, formula/finite-difference/scale evidence, and psychometric recovery remain separate claims. Supported-target bitwise reproducibility is not product authority until the unchanged head actually executes the golden contract on every supported target; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `d57b274d6b14ebb9afda904b5078c21c3036f724`; issue #1747 | Source RED `f1599d04...` adds a golden-bit/repeatability/source-route contract; causal GREEN `e6235c78...` removes Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln` and replaces them with explicit integer multiplication plus a fixed IEEE-754 bit-normalized 24-term Kahan-compensated `atanh` logarithm. `54e69de9...` makes TRD, governance/test strategy, changelog and standards doctoring code-current; `d57b274d...` is a formatting-only follow-up that keeps the integration contract rustfmt-shaped without changing scientific semantics. This repairs the package-owned arithmetic route without adding a new math dependency or changing public API/optimizer semantics. Bitwise route identity, formula/finite-difference/scale evidence, and psychometric recovery remain separate claims. Supported-target bitwise reproducibility is not product authority until the unchanged head actually executes the golden contract on every supported target; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The current #1736 exact head `54e69de9...` is a substantive post-#1845 Rust/doc canary. Repository CodeQL run `33862320783` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100989324003` on that exact SHA, but it remains queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33862320825` and ClusterFuzzLite `33862320793` are pending, while Semgrep `33862320841` and Security Scan `33862321903` are queued. The earlier RED head `f1599d04...` was superseded and its hosted workflows were cancelled, so RED is source-level evidence only and no predecessor result is transferred. The central #1845 concurrency fix addresses stale OpenCode/Noema review heads, not this runnerless CodeQL admission symptom. +The current #1736 exact head `d57b274d...` is a substantive-repair lineage with a final formatting-only follow-up after central #1845. Repository CodeQL run `33862903793` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100991172214` on that exact SHA, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33862903848` and ClusterFuzzLite `33862903761` are pending, while Semgrep `33862903691` and Security Scan `33862903843` are queued. The earlier RED head `f1599d04...` was superseded and its hosted workflows were cancelled, so RED is source-level evidence only and no predecessor result is transferred. The central #1845 concurrency fix addresses stale OpenCode/Noema review heads, not this runnerless CodeQL admission symptom. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 263c89d6b4aec7e1e753f07d1a9e219d1d981abd Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 19:42:27 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 083/110] docs(product-gap): record Oblimax scale-cancellation repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 8 ++++---- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 8180ff58e..7c6d2d08c 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `d57b274d6b14ebb9afda904b5078c21c3036f724`; issue #1747 | Source RED `f1599d04...` adds a golden-bit/repeatability/source-route contract; causal GREEN `e6235c78...` removes Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln` and replaces them with explicit integer multiplication plus a fixed IEEE-754 bit-normalized 24-term Kahan-compensated `atanh` logarithm. `54e69de9...` makes TRD, governance/test strategy, changelog and standards doctoring code-current; `d57b274d...` is a formatting-only follow-up that keeps the integration contract rustfmt-shaped without changing scientific semantics. This repairs the package-owned arithmetic route without adding a new math dependency or changing public API/optimizer semantics. Bitwise route identity, formula/finite-difference/scale evidence, and psychometric recovery remain separate claims. Supported-target bitwise reproducibility is not product authority until the unchanged head actually executes the golden contract on every supported target; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `88573ea9e29bf39f54c42ffca99737549b0aa02c`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` and GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln` with explicit integer multiplication plus a package-owned fixed IEEE-754 bit-normalized 24-term Kahan-compensated `atanh` logarithm. Current-head review then exposed large-log cancellation despite the new deterministic helper: RED `72be252b...` shows exact `2^188` common scaling moved the objective by about `1.03e-13`, beyond the existing scaled tolerance. Causal repair `4401a9f9...` forms the dimensionless `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` ratio before logarithm evaluation; `ba1f32f1...` updates the golden objective bit while gradient bits remain unchanged. Doctoring/changelog heads `aebefcda...` / `88573ea9...` record the scale-cancellation contract. The source guard now includes the deterministic helper itself. Formula, bitwise route, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@d6c636a993f522320e1657be073df622e277248b`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@9c7d28a1768fb5003a0ed46e4d7a957b9e64a7f2`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Current merged `.github#1845` advances authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. These are foreign-owner control-plane repairs and are adopted rather than copied. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Current merged `.github#1847` advances authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. #1847 has no PR-head checkout/execution path and is not represented as a fix for the runnerless CodeQL/CI admission symptom. These are foreign-owner control-plane repairs and are adopted rather than copied. The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. -The current #1736 exact head `d57b274d...` is a substantive-repair lineage with a final formatting-only follow-up after central #1845. Repository CodeQL run `33862903793` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100991172214` on that exact SHA, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33862903848` and ClusterFuzzLite `33862903761` are pending, while Semgrep `33862903691` and Security Scan `33862903843` are queued. The earlier RED head `f1599d04...` was superseded and its hosted workflows were cancelled, so RED is source-level evidence only and no predecessor result is transferred. The central #1845 concurrency fix addresses stale OpenCode/Noema review heads, not this runnerless CodeQL admission symptom. +The current #1736 exact head `88573ea9...` includes a substantive scale-cancellation repair after the deterministic-log route was introduced. CodeQL run `33864345780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100995661527`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33864345169` is pending, while Semgrep `33864344772`, Security Scan `33864345094`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33864344857` are queued. RED `72be252b...` is source-level evidence only because the causal successor immediately superseded it; no predecessor or superseded-head success is transferred. Central #1847 reduces metadata-only scheduler queue work but does not execute or admit this leaf job. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 323b9dfb874ae212a89bdd82df8e983d19b79c39 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 20:12:33 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 084/110] docs(product-gap): track Oblimax range repair and central queue fix --- ...ct-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 18 +++++------------- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 7c6d2d08c..20e8d032b 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `88573ea9e29bf39f54c42ffca99737549b0aa02c`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` and GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln` with explicit integer multiplication plus a package-owned fixed IEEE-754 bit-normalized 24-term Kahan-compensated `atanh` logarithm. Current-head review then exposed large-log cancellation despite the new deterministic helper: RED `72be252b...` shows exact `2^188` common scaling moved the objective by about `1.03e-13`, beyond the existing scaled tolerance. Causal repair `4401a9f9...` forms the dimensionless `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` ratio before logarithm evaluation; `ba1f32f1...` updates the golden objective bit while gradient bits remain unchanged. Doctoring/changelog heads `aebefcda...` / `88573ea9...` record the scale-cancellation contract. The source guard now includes the deterministic helper itself. Formula, bitwise route, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / RANGE ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `274362b303a37fb067b55c21492616e852bfeb74`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. A further source-level RED `557789cd...` proves raw moments still reject finite scale-equivalent matrices: exact `2^300` scaling overflows `sum4` and exact `2^-300` scaling underflows it to zero. Causal GREEN `350c59fe...` conditions loadings with one exact power-of-two derived from the represented maximum exponent before forming moments, maps the analytic gradient back with the same exact scale, and preserves established ordinary-input golden bits. `9ea1bb48...` / `274362b...` make doctoring/changelog evidence current. Exact `2^188`, `2^300`, and `2^-300` fixtures distinguish cancellation and representable-range contracts. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -36,21 +36,13 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@9c7d28a1768fb5003a0ed46e4d7a957b9e64a7f2`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@109d79b79b95bb692cbc8461d368a65d809ea6b2`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Current merged `.github#1847` advances authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. #1847 has no PR-head checkout/execution path and is not represented as a fix for the runnerless CodeQL/CI admission symptom. These are foreign-owner control-plane repairs and are adopted rather than copied. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler. Current `109d79b7...` removes unsupported `queue: max` concurrency syntax from central agent/coalescer workflows, introduces live-head admission before per-PR coalescer concurrency, and uses `cancel-in-progress: true` only within repository/PR-scoped groups. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied. -The current Actions defect remains a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On the substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. +The historical Actions defect was a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. Earlier substantive heads repeatedly materialized runnerless CodeQL jobs and CI runs with no jobs. The current central `109d79b7...` change directly addresses unsupported queue-concurrency configuration, so only post-fix exact-head executions can establish whether admission is repaired; predecessor queue evidence is retained as incident history, not current failure proof. -The fresh #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduces the same class: CodeQL run `33835387666` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100906727383` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; its Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33835387729` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is exact-current control-plane evidence, not a reason to weaken or retrigger the leaf. - -The #1744 documentation-corrected exact head `6f808110...` also reproduces the admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remains queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis is scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remains pending with `jobs=[]`. This is non-passing control-plane evidence and does not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 canary is recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. - -The current #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduces the same class after a substantive numerical-contract test commit: CodeQL run `33851585887` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100955381194`, but it remains queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33851585889` is pending with `jobs=[]`, while Semgrep `33851585663` and Security Scan `33851585771` are also queued. This exact canary follows a real stability regression, not a no-op retrigger, and predecessor success is not transferred. - -The current #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` is a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` is pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` are also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. - -The current #1736 exact head `88573ea9...` includes a substantive scale-cancellation repair after the deterministic-log route was introduced. CodeQL run `33864345780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100995661527`, but it remains queued before runner/source execution with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33864345169` is pending, while Semgrep `33864344772`, Security Scan `33864345094`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33864344857` are queued. RED `72be252b...` is source-level evidence only because the causal successor immediately superseded it; no predecessor or superseded-head success is transferred. Central #1847 reduces metadata-only scheduler queue work but does not execute or admit this leaf job. +The current #1736 head `274362b...` is the first substantive numerical/documentation canary observed here after central `109d79b7...`. CodeQL run `33866642621` has materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but is currently queued; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` are queued. Because these runs are fresh and non-terminal, they are neither GREEN nor proof that the central repair failed. No no-op retrigger or predecessor-success transfer is used. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From d265892b64a6c4eafc1b475e953aa72f5491f70b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 20:13:42 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 085/110] docs(product-gap): preserve prior canaries while adopting current repairs --- ...duct-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 16 +++++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 13 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 20e8d032b..e744c941f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -38,11 +38,21 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@109d79b79b95bb692cbc8461d368a65d809ea6b2`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler. Current `109d79b7...` removes unsupported `queue: max` concurrency syntax from central agent/coalescer workflows, introduces live-head admission before per-PR coalescer concurrency, and uses `cancel-in-progress: true` only within repository/PR-scoped groups. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. Current `109d79b7...` removes unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows, admits the exact live PR head before per-PR coalescer concurrency, and uses `cancel-in-progress: true` only inside repository/PR-scoped groups. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied. -The historical Actions defect was a control-plane/admission problem rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. Earlier substantive heads repeatedly materialized runnerless CodeQL jobs and CI runs with no jobs. The current central `109d79b7...` change directly addresses unsupported queue-concurrency configuration, so only post-fix exact-head executions can establish whether admission is repaired; predecessor queue evidence is retained as incident history, not current failure proof. +The historical Actions defect remains relevant incident evidence rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. -The current #1736 head `274362b...` is the first substantive numerical/documentation canary observed here after central `109d79b7...`. CodeQL run `33866642621` has materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but is currently queued; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` are queued. Because these runs are fresh and non-terminal, they are neither GREEN nor proof that the central repair failed. No no-op retrigger or predecessor-success transfer is used. +The #1741 successor head `c65543ee...` independently reproduced the same pre-fix class: CodeQL run `33835387666` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100906727383` on `ubuntu-latest`, but it was queued with `runner_id=0`, no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; its Python analysis was scope-skipped. CI run `33835387729` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This remains incident evidence, not a reason to weaken or retrigger the leaf. + +The #1744 documentation-corrected head `6f808110...` also reproduced the pre-fix admission defect without a no-op retrigger: CodeQL run `33839177278` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100917769805`, but it remained queued with no runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; Python analysis was scope-skipped. CI run `33839177204` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This did not convert the still-open formatter/docstring/prerequisite findings into leaf GREEN. The matching #1519 canary was recorded with it on central `.github#712` comment `5535961011`. + +The #1742 successor head `959c05bf...` independently reproduced the same pre-fix class after a substantive numerical-contract test commit: CodeQL run `33851585887` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100955381194`, but it remained queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33851585889` was pending with `jobs=[]`, while Semgrep `33851585663` and Security Scan `33851585771` were also queued. This exact canary followed a real stability regression, not a no-op retrigger, and predecessor success was not transferred. + +The #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` was a substantive test-evidence canary after the production NaN-canonicalization repair. CodeQL run `33849079557` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100947516369`, but it remained queued before runner/source execution with empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33849079449` was pending; Semgrep `33849079438`, Security Scan `33849079593`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33849079522` were also non-terminal. The two newest branch commits close an edge-coverage gap by proving positive/negative signaling NaNs share the same missing-response digest as quiet NaNs in both public Python and direct Rust; no production arithmetic changed. Predecessor `3cdc684a...` had repository CI, CodeQL, Semgrep, Security Scan, OSV, Scorecard and fuzzing terminal green, but that predecessor evidence is deliberately not transferred. + +The pre-central-fix #1736 head `88573ea9...` included the scale-cancellation repair after the deterministic-log route was introduced. CodeQL run `33864345780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100995661527`, but it remained queued before runner/source execution with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI `33864345169` was pending, while Semgrep `33864344772`, Security Scan `33864345094`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33864344857` were queued. RED `72be252b...` is source-level evidence only because its causal successor immediately superseded it; no predecessor or superseded-head success is transferred. + +The current #1736 head `274362b...` is a substantive numerical/documentation canary after central `109d79b7...`. CodeQL run `33866642621` has materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but is currently queued; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` are queued. Because these runs are fresh and non-terminal, they are neither GREEN nor proof that the central repair failed. No no-op retrigger or predecessor-success transfer is used. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 371ecd34b68c1cd8572e39bc8e1f4f3489fd49a1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 20:42:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 086/110] docs(product-gap): add Oblimax optimizer integration evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 ++++-- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index e744c941f..93abe527f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / RANGE ROUTE REPAIRED | #1736 `274362b303a37fb067b55c21492616e852bfeb74`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. A further source-level RED `557789cd...` proves raw moments still reject finite scale-equivalent matrices: exact `2^300` scaling overflows `sum4` and exact `2^-300` scaling underflows it to zero. Causal GREEN `350c59fe...` conditions loadings with one exact power-of-two derived from the represented maximum exponent before forming moments, maps the analytic gradient back with the same exact scale, and preserves established ordinary-input golden bits. `9ea1bb48...` / `274362b...` make doctoring/changelog evidence current. Exact `2^188`, `2^300`, and `2^-300` fixtures distinguish cancellation and representable-range contracts. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `9b170fddbd9d81529b6aea64ee980893fc77fd15`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. Source-level RED `557789cd...` proves raw moments reject finite scale-equivalent matrices at exact `2^300`/`2^-300`; causal GREEN `350c59fe...` conditions loadings with one exact power-of-two before moment formation and maps the analytic gradient back with the same scale. Current `9b170fdd...` adds a separate public `rotate_factor_loadings` integration contract requiring exact `2^300` scale equivalence to survive oblique optimization, canonicalization, start evidence, transform/factor-correlation output, and inverse pattern restoration. This is numerical integration evidence only, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -52,7 +52,9 @@ The #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` was a substantive test-evidence canary a The pre-central-fix #1736 head `88573ea9...` included the scale-cancellation repair after the deterministic-log route was introduced. CodeQL run `33864345780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100995661527`, but it remained queued before runner/source execution with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI `33864345169` was pending, while Semgrep `33864344772`, Security Scan `33864345094`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33864344857` were queued. RED `72be252b...` is source-level evidence only because its causal successor immediately superseded it; no predecessor or superseded-head success is transferred. -The current #1736 head `274362b...` is a substantive numerical/documentation canary after central `109d79b7...`. CodeQL run `33866642621` has materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but is currently queued; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` are queued. Because these runs are fresh and non-terminal, they are neither GREEN nor proof that the central repair failed. No no-op retrigger or predecessor-success transfer is used. +The predecessor #1736 head `274362b...` was the first post-central-`109d79b7...` numerical/documentation canary. CodeQL run `33866642621` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but remained queued; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` were queued. That evidence is historical after the optimizer-contract commits and is not transferred. + +The current #1736 head `9b170fdd...` is a substantive numerical-integration canary. CodeQL run `33868864092` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101009864493`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33868863936` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Semgrep `33868864094`, Security Scan `33868864018`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33868864057` are queued. The integration test therefore remains source-controlled, non-passing evidence until exact-head execution occurs; it is not called GREEN and no no-op retrigger is used. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 52138bf950f5d54c379e64988c1227d48ae67469 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 20:46:27 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 087/110] docs(product-gap): bind Oblimax doctoring evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 8 +++++--- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 93abe527f..e720ad075 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `9b170fddbd9d81529b6aea64ee980893fc77fd15`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. Source-level RED `557789cd...` proves raw moments reject finite scale-equivalent matrices at exact `2^300`/`2^-300`; causal GREEN `350c59fe...` conditions loadings with one exact power-of-two before moment formation and maps the analytic gradient back with the same scale. Current `9b170fdd...` adds a separate public `rotate_factor_loadings` integration contract requiring exact `2^300` scale equivalence to survive oblique optimization, canonicalization, start evidence, transform/factor-correlation output, and inverse pattern restoration. This is numerical integration evidence only, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `4f26d9965ccae664974b163236f56486a504dbb0`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. Source-level RED `557789cd...` proves raw moments reject finite scale-equivalent matrices at exact `2^300`/`2^-300`; causal GREEN `350c59fe...` conditions loadings with one exact power-of-two before moment formation and maps the analytic gradient back with the same scale. `9ea947e6...` / `9b170fdd...` add a separate public `rotate_factor_loadings` integration contract requiring exact `2^300` scale equivalence to survive oblique optimization, canonicalization, start evidence, transform/factor-correlation output, and inverse pattern restoration. Current `4f26d996...` makes doctoring match that evidence and narrows significand-bit preservation to normal finite values whose conditioned result remains normal, leaving subnormal behavior to explicit tests. This is numerical integration evidence only, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -52,9 +52,11 @@ The #1417 provenance head `f78f1a74...` was a substantive test-evidence canary a The pre-central-fix #1736 head `88573ea9...` included the scale-cancellation repair after the deterministic-log route was introduced. CodeQL run `33864345780` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `100995661527`, but it remained queued before runner/source execution with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI `33864345169` was pending, while Semgrep `33864344772`, Security Scan `33864345094`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33864344857` were queued. RED `72be252b...` is source-level evidence only because its causal successor immediately superseded it; no predecessor or superseded-head success is transferred. -The predecessor #1736 head `274362b...` was the first post-central-`109d79b7...` numerical/documentation canary. CodeQL run `33866642621` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but remained queued; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` were queued. That evidence is historical after the optimizer-contract commits and is not transferred. +The predecessor #1736 head `274362b...` was the first post-central-`109d79b7...` numerical/documentation canary. CodeQL run `33866642621` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `101002902427` but remained queued; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33866642682` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33866642666`, Semgrep `33866642629`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33866642593` were queued. That evidence is historical after later optimizer-contract commits and is not transferred. -The current #1736 head `9b170fdd...` is a substantive numerical-integration canary. CodeQL run `33868864092` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101009864493`, but it is queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33868863936` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Semgrep `33868864094`, Security Scan `33868864018`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33868864057` are queued. The integration test therefore remains source-controlled, non-passing evidence until exact-head execution occurs; it is not called GREEN and no no-op retrigger is used. +The predecessor #1736 head `9b170fdd...` added the optimizer integration contract. CodeQL run `33868864092` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101009864493`, but it remained queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33868863936` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Semgrep `33868864094`, Security Scan `33868864018`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33868864057` were queued. That head is historical after current doctoring moved and its status is not transferred. + +The current #1736 head `4f26d996...` is a substantive documentation/evidence-boundary canary on the same production/test implementation. CodeQL run `33869375346` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101011473756`, queued without runner/group identity and with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33869375312` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33869375370` and Semgrep `33869375345` are queued, while ClusterFuzzLite `33869375319` is pending. This exact head is non-passing and predecessor success is not transferred. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 9ea3bee9372059b07663c14760b865ca70b7642b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 20:49:11 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 088/110] docs(product-gap): adopt central admission coalescer --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index e720ad075..5d1704ee0 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@109d79b79b95bb692cbc8461d368a65d809ea6b2`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@df996797c0b8cdbc6769c9cc1a66bccfcfbfb8d4`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. Current `109d79b7...` removes unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows, admits the exact live PR head before per-PR coalescer concurrency, and uses `cancel-in-progress: true` only inside repository/PR-scoped groups. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. Current `df996797...` adds workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner, with `cancel-in-progress: false` preserving running repository scans and the existing target-level concurrency. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied; it does not by itself make already-created leaf jobs GREEN. The historical Actions defect remains relevant incident evidence rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -56,7 +56,7 @@ The predecessor #1736 head `274362b...` was the first post-central-`109d79b7...` The predecessor #1736 head `9b170fdd...` added the optimizer integration contract. CodeQL run `33868864092` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101009864493`, but it remained queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33868863936` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Semgrep `33868864094`, Security Scan `33868864018`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33868864057` were queued. That head is historical after current doctoring moved and its status is not transferred. -The current #1736 head `4f26d996...` is a substantive documentation/evidence-boundary canary on the same production/test implementation. CodeQL run `33869375346` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101011473756`, queued without runner/group identity and with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33869375312` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33869375370` and Semgrep `33869375345` are queued, while ClusterFuzzLite `33869375319` is pending. This exact head is non-passing and predecessor success is not transferred. +The current #1736 head `4f26d996...` is a substantive documentation/evidence-boundary canary on the same production/test implementation. CodeQL run `33869375346` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101011473756`, queued without runner/group identity and with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33869375312` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33869375370` and Semgrep `33869375345` are queued, while ClusterFuzzLite `33869375319` is pending. This exact head was created before central `df996797...`; its non-terminal state is not projected onto later heads and it remains non-passing until exact-head execution completes. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 2a496589ffa79d3a122de2021e6e0415be78fb23 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 21:15:06 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 089/110] docs(product-gap): record Oblimax stationary-gradient repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 10 ++++++---- 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index 5d1704ee0..b85490c20 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `4f26d9965ccae664974b163236f56486a504dbb0`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. Source-level RED `557789cd...` proves raw moments reject finite scale-equivalent matrices at exact `2^300`/`2^-300`; causal GREEN `350c59fe...` conditions loadings with one exact power-of-two before moment formation and maps the analytic gradient back with the same scale. `9ea947e6...` / `9b170fdd...` add a separate public `rotate_factor_loadings` integration contract requiring exact `2^300` scale equivalence to survive oblique optimization, canonicalization, start evidence, transform/factor-correlation output, and inverse pattern restoration. Current `4f26d996...` makes doctoring match that evidence and narrows significand-bit preservation to normal finite values whose conditioned result remains normal, leaving subnormal behavior to explicit tests. This is numerical integration evidence only, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / STATIONARITY + RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `e31a8a9c07ce4777e769afb5ad585855d14e9ba5`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. RED `557789cd...` / GREEN `350c59fe...` condition exact `2^300`/`2^-300` scale-equivalent loadings before moment formation; `9ea947e6...` / `9b170fdd...` carry that contract through public oblique optimization. Current review then found a distinct derivative cancellation defect: the literal `-(4 x^3/sum4 - 4 x/sum2)` route leaves a tiny nonzero binary64 residual at mathematically exact single-support stationary points. Source RED `720300d4...` requires exact zero objective/gradient for positive and negative one-support fixtures; GREEN `72e5e6a9...` factors the same derivative as `4 x/sum2 * (1 - x^2/(sum4/sum2))`, and `a689f7af...` updates the intentionally changed gradient golden bits while the objective golden bit stays fixed. Changelog/doctoring are current through `e31a8a9c...`. These are numerical-contract and integration fixtures, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@df996797c0b8cdbc6769c9cc1a66bccfcfbfb8d4`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@34b79038f76efb05774b7ad0733bbc5640dbe1ab`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. Current `df996797...` adds workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner, with `cancel-in-progress: false` preserving running repository scans and the existing target-level concurrency. This is a foreign-owner control-plane repair and is adopted rather than copied; it does not by itself make already-created leaf jobs GREEN. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. `df996797...` then added workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner. Current merged `.github#1854` advances authority to `34b79038...` by moving repository+PR concurrency for Strix, Required OpenCode Review and Required Noema Review to workflow admission, so queued superseded model runs can be cancelled before runner assignment; non-PR push/schedule runs retain run-id isolation. These are foreign-owner control-plane repairs adopted rather than copied. #1854 addresses model-workflow admission specifically and does not itself establish CodeQL/CI runner availability for fast-mlsirm. The historical Actions defect remains relevant incident evidence rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -56,7 +56,9 @@ The predecessor #1736 head `274362b...` was the first post-central-`109d79b7...` The predecessor #1736 head `9b170fdd...` added the optimizer integration contract. CodeQL run `33868864092` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101009864493`, but it remained queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33868863936` remained pending with `jobs=[]`; Semgrep `33868864094`, Security Scan `33868864018`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33868864057` were queued. That head is historical after current doctoring moved and its status is not transferred. -The current #1736 head `4f26d996...` is a substantive documentation/evidence-boundary canary on the same production/test implementation. CodeQL run `33869375346` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101011473756`, queued without runner/group identity and with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33869375312` is pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33869375370` and Semgrep `33869375345` are queued, while ClusterFuzzLite `33869375319` is pending. This exact head was created before central `df996797...`; its non-terminal state is not projected onto later heads and it remains non-passing until exact-head execution completes. +The predecessor #1736 head `4f26d996...` completed the range/optimizer doctoring boundary before the stationary-gradient repair. CodeQL run `33869375346` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101011473756`, queued without runner/group identity and with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33869375312` was pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33869375370`, Semgrep `33869375345`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33869375319` were non-terminal. That head is historical and its status is not transferred. + +The current #1736 head `e31a8a9c...` is a substantive Rust numerical-contract canary after the exact-stationarity RED→GREEN repair. CodeQL run `33871274386` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101017583799`, queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33871274500` is pending; Security Scan `33871274482`, Semgrep `33871274596`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33871274497` are queued. Source-level RED `720300d4...` is not presented as hosted RED because it was immediately superseded by the causal repair. This current head remains non-passing until exact-head execution completes. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. From 8b481e808d3e2842b7a6fe8ee1702ab6838972a6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 21:20:17 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 090/110] docs(product-gap): adopt model-concurrency runtime proof --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index b85490c20..a5b32848f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@34b79038f76efb05774b7ad0733bbc5640dbe1ab`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@4aad26906ea54456f4236eaf83c96b637d2b2e72`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. `df996797...` then added workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner. Current merged `.github#1854` advances authority to `34b79038...` by moving repository+PR concurrency for Strix, Required OpenCode Review and Required Noema Review to workflow admission, so queued superseded model runs can be cancelled before runner assignment; non-PR push/schedule runs retain run-id isolation. These are foreign-owner control-plane repairs adopted rather than copied. #1854 addresses model-workflow admission specifically and does not itself establish CodeQL/CI runner availability for fast-mlsirm. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. `df996797...` then added workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner. Merged `.github#1854` advanced authority to `34b79038...` by moving repository+PR concurrency for Strix, Required OpenCode Review and Required Noema Review to workflow admission, so queued superseded model runs can be cancelled before runner assignment; non-PR push/schedule runs retain run-id isolation. Current merged `.github#1855` advances authority to `4aad2690...` with runtime proof for that native cancellation contract: successive same-PR generations cancelled the preceding Strix/OpenCode/Noema runs while another PR and another repository remained isolated. This is documentation/evidence for the model-workflow concurrency repair, not a CodeQL/CI admission repair. These foreign-owner deltas are adopted rather than copied. The historical Actions defect remains relevant incident evidence rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. From 56fb816bb965dc3e02e8dd5d2e364485a42e9ff3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2026 22:10:39 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 091/110] docs(product-gap): adopt latest Oblimax and workflow authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md | 10 +++++----- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md index a5b32848f..42cc2f5a5 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Multiple-membership/crossed recovery | ACTIVE PR | #1536 `77bef27cff780b909be484b52be35e97be752780` | Known-truth bias/MAE/RMSE, membership invariants, direct-Rust admission and worker determinism; no longitudinal or interval-coverage claim without its own evidence. | | Rust distribution boundary + `sha2` 0.11 | ACTIVE PR | #1694 `756cf889a111717725de806329e8e5a64bbb5bc0` | Both internal Cargo implementation crates remain `publish = false`; Maturin/PyPI remains the external product unless a separate Rust SDK release boundary is governed. | | Marginal objective binary64 reproducibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1742 `959c05bf9e40877d65bd02aed82e6373ef16c99d`; retired #1746 `8f7262d14249269aef0589082b1afc78f221832e` | Preserve the deterministic CPU-f64 per-cell objective reduction until a profiled optimization has explicit numerical-contract, recovery and parity evidence. The retained tests prove two failure modes of rejected split reductions: an ordinary finite fixture moves by exactly one ULP, and the later algebraic `vdot(r, eta) + vdot(n, log_sigmoid(-eta))` route becomes `NaN` for finite saturated `eta=1e308`, `r=n=2` while the established reduction remains exactly `0.0`. #1746 is closed unmerged only after forward restoration to an empty effective diff and transfer of its valid stability finding here; formatter churn, temporary patch artifacts, duplicate Bolt guidance and unsupported speed claims are not product delta. Material hot-path work belongs in the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / STATIONARITY + RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `e31a8a9c07ce4777e769afb5ad585855d14e9ba5`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. RED `557789cd...` / GREEN `350c59fe...` condition exact `2^300`/`2^-300` scale-equivalent loadings before moment formation; `9ea947e6...` / `9b170fdd...` carry that contract through public oblique optimization. Current review then found a distinct derivative cancellation defect: the literal `-(4 x^3/sum4 - 4 x/sum2)` route leaves a tiny nonzero binary64 residual at mathematically exact single-support stationary points. Source RED `720300d4...` requires exact zero objective/gradient for positive and negative one-support fixtures; GREEN `72e5e6a9...` factors the same derivative as `4 x/sum2 * (1 - x^2/(sum4/sum2))`, and `a689f7af...` updates the intentionally changed gradient golden bits while the objective golden bit stays fixed. Changelog/doctoring are current through `e31a8a9c...`. These are numerical-contract and integration fixtures, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference semantics | ACTIVE DRAFT / STATIONARITY + RANGE + OPTIMIZER EVIDENCE | #1736 `fa54f33e36b4ea1087a0e6b453ec71e4680b490f`; issue #1747 | Initial RED `f1599d04...` / GREEN `e6235c78...` replace Oblimax `f64::powi`/`f64::ln`; RED `72be252b...` / GREEN `4401a9f9...` remove large-log cancellation by forming `(sum4 / sum2) / sum2` before the deterministic logarithm. RED `557789cd...` / GREEN `350c59fe...` condition exact `2^300`/`2^-300` scale-equivalent loadings before moment formation; `9ea947e6...` / `9b170fdd...` carry that contract through public oblique optimization. RED `720300d4...` / GREEN `72e5e6a9...` remove reciprocal-term cancellation at exact one-support stationary points. Current review then extended the stationary contract to the complete represented equal-magnitude support manifold: RED `5e78ac9d...` shows that accumulated `sum4/sum2` can round one ULP away from the common represented square for three equal supports, producing a false optimizer direction; causal GREEN `b00e91e4...` records exact bit-identical nonzero conditioned squares during the existing moment pass and reuses that represented square only on that exact manifold. `34e5e52e...` / `fa54f33e...` make changelog and doctoring current. These remain numerical-contract and integration fixtures, not VV-SCI-006 realistic recovery. Formula identity, bitwise route identity, psychometric recovery and supported-target parity remain distinct claims; current hosted gates are still non-terminal. | | Strict JSON deserialization at judge/rubric boundaries | ACTIVE DRAFT / STACKED REPAIR | #1744 `6f80811036a22043755889e424667b579d5458ce`; prerequisite #1738 `c8ef8b0d2532393a77bfc5321a353d028b9bab18` | Reject Python non-finite constants at both boundaries and duplicate object members where protected main did not already reject them. Focused regression coverage is branch-owned. Security doctoring now distinguishes the pre-existing judge duplicate-key guard from the new rubric guard and removes unsupported impact claims. #1738 must integrate first; the non-force #1744 restack must preserve both guards, remove formatter-only drift, and add the missing production docstring for `_reject_nonfinite` before landing. | | Item-bank report accessibility | ACTIVE DRAFT / SUCCESSOR | #1741 `c65543ee071cd19b1e1d0362f80c9f17cf230b9c`; retired predecessor #1743 | Preserve a focusable skip-link target, pointer-only focus suppression together with an explicit keyboard focus ring, reduced-motion behavior, semantic row headers and tabular numeric presentation. #1743 is closed only after its valid behavior and focused-test intent were inherited by #1741; formatter-only churn and competing `.Jules/palette.md` guidance are not product delta. | | Iterator-fold performance rewrite | DISPOSITIONED / NO VALID DELTA | closed #1745 `f7d49c08eb0100860cd0ac2244deeb4794f4da2a`; rotation numerical-contract owner #1736 | The automated rewrite changed the rotation `powi(4)` arithmetic route without parity/recovery evidence and made an unsupported blanket fold recommendation. Person-fit iterator chains were lazy and supplied no reproducible benchmark proving material benefit. Forward repair restores every changed path to protected-main bytes; fresh main→head comparison has `files=[]`. Future optimization starts from profiling/benchmark evidence and preserves the deterministic CPU-f64/scientific contract. | @@ -36,9 +36,9 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow ## Current merge and release gate -Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@4aad26906ea54456f4236eaf83c96b637d2b2e72`. +Protected `main` is still `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`. It independently requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. The latest observed central workflow owner is `.github/main@769691526f8c73cf714de8fe8ba51ae6cfa2901a`. -Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. `df996797...` then added workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner. Merged `.github#1854` advanced authority to `34b79038...` by moving repository+PR concurrency for Strix, Required OpenCode Review and Required Noema Review to workflow admission, so queued superseded model runs can be cancelled before runner assignment; non-PR push/schedule runs retain run-id isolation. Current merged `.github#1855` advances authority to `4aad2690...` with runtime proof for that native cancellation contract: successive same-PR generations cancelled the preceding Strix/OpenCode/Noema runs while another PR and another repository remained isolated. This is documentation/evidence for the model-workflow concurrency repair, not a CodeQL/CI admission repair. These foreign-owner deltas are adopted rather than copied. +Central `.github#1838` advanced the owner to `f0dd4065...` by consolidating Exact Artifact SBOM quality while preserving actual publication/attestation and removing a redundant quality workflow. Merged `.github#1819` then advanced `main` to `f8c3b304...` by recording Actions congestion and Noema/Strix hot-file divergence. Merged `.github#1839` advanced `main` to `80719692...` with a one-file Strix shell-output repair. Merged `.github#1842` then advanced authority to `07db37e5...`: generated repository-local CodeQL is kept off pull-request heads while protected default-branch push/schedule scanning remains, central `codeql-pr.yml` is retained as the single PR scanner, and ruleset-audit concurrency is isolated by trigger. Merged `.github#1845` advanced authority to `d6c636a9...` by admitting the exact live PR head before OpenCode/Noema review concurrency and cancelling stale review heads; push/schedule/release and Strix behavior are explicitly out of scope. Merged `.github#1847` advanced authority to `9c7d28a1...` by moving empty non-draft PR cleanup into the existing metadata-only merge scheduler, revalidating live head/open/draft/changed-file state before closure, and removing one standalone workflow/job. `109d79b7...` removed unsupported `queue: max` from central agent/coalescer workflows and moved exact-head admission ahead of per-PR concurrency. `df996797...` then added workflow-level concurrency to the hourly review scheduler so same-schedule pending heartbeats coalesce before `resolve-target` needs a runner. Merged `.github#1854` advanced authority to `34b79038...` by moving repository+PR concurrency for Strix, Required OpenCode Review and Required Noema Review to workflow admission, so queued superseded model runs can be cancelled before runner assignment; non-PR push/schedule runs retain run-id isolation. Merged `.github#1855` advanced authority to `4aad2690...` with runtime proof for that native cancellation contract: successive same-PR generations cancelled the preceding Strix/OpenCode/Noema runs while another PR and another repository remained isolated. Merged `.github#1856` then advanced authority to `f893b473...` by restoring `codeql-pr.yml` to the canonical required-workflow inventory and removing the stale scheduler exclusion that prevented exact-head CodeQL PR startup recovery. Its stated live acceptance is materialization of a non-startup-failure CodeQL PR run after the trusted-base/ruleset change. Current `.github#1851` advances authority to `76969152...` by installing the required HTTPX2 runtime and binding the exact OpenAI lock for Strix; that latest delta is Strix-runtime-specific and is not evidence that CodeQL/CI runner admission itself is healthy. These foreign-owner deltas are adopted rather than copied. The historical Actions defect remains relevant incident evidence rather than authority to churn clean leaf heads. On substantive #1710 head `41d2c560...`, CodeQL run `33827965206` materialized `Analyze (actions)` job `100884576993`, but it remained runnerless with `steps=[]`; CI `33827965233` remained pending with `jobs=[]`. This exact canary is recorded on central `.github#712` comment `5534619066`. Queued or absent execution is non-passing. @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ The predecessor #1736 head `9b170fdd...` added the optimizer integration contrac The predecessor #1736 head `4f26d996...` completed the range/optimizer doctoring boundary before the stationary-gradient repair. CodeQL run `33869375346` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101011473756`, queued without runner/group identity and with `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` was scope-skipped. CI run `33869375312` was pending with `jobs=[]`; Security Scan `33869375370`, Semgrep `33869375345`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33869375319` were non-terminal. That head is historical and its status is not transferred. -The current #1736 head `e31a8a9c...` is a substantive Rust numerical-contract canary after the exact-stationarity RED→GREEN repair. CodeQL run `33871274386` materialized required `Analyze (actions)` job `101017583799`, queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`; `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI run `33871274500` is pending; Security Scan `33871274482`, Semgrep `33871274596`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33871274497` are queued. Source-level RED `720300d4...` is not presented as hosted RED because it was immediately superseded by the causal repair. This current head remains non-passing until exact-head execution completes. +The current #1736 head `fa54f33e...` is a substantive Rust numerical-contract canary after the equal-magnitude stationary-manifold RED→GREEN repair and was created after central `.github#1856` merged. CodeQL PR run `33874447012` now materializes `Detect CodeQL languages` job `101027933479`, which establishes that the #1856 startup/materialization repair reached this leaf event; however that job remains queued with `runner_id=0`, empty runner/group identity and `steps=[]`. The separate CodeQL run `33874447020` materializes required `Analyze (actions)` job `101027928022`, likewise queued runnerless with `steps=[]`, while `Analyze (python)` is scope-skipped. CI `33874446901`, Security Scan `33874447009`, Semgrep `33874446941`, and ClusterFuzzLite `33874447002` remain non-terminal. Thus startup materialization improved, but this exact head is still not hosted GREEN and no predecessor evidence is transferred. The #1519 documentation lane has repeatedly reproduced the same queue/admission class on substantive additive-document heads. Its exact current head and current-head workflow evidence are maintained in the PR landing authority rather than self-referentially embedding the file's own future commit SHA here. Central owner issue `.github#712` remains the causal Actions/RCA path; documentation movement is not used as a retrigger mechanism. @@ -66,4 +66,4 @@ The only observed #1710 `APPROVED` review remains bound to predecessor `e50033e0 ## Non-destructive refresh rule -Future baseline refreshes must be additive or surgically replacement-scoped. Before any update, compare line count and semantic sections against protected main. A refresh that removes valid completion profiles, PRD/TRD/UML, standards/research traceability, claim limitations, release gates or buyer acceptance evidence is a repair finding, not successful maintenance. The correct response is forward restoration or verified supersession, never silent truncation. +Future baseline refreshes must be additive or surgically replacement-scoped. Before any update, compare line count and semantic sections against protected main. A refresh that removes valid completion profiles, PRD/TRD/UML, standards/research traceability, claim limitations, release gates or buyer acceptance evidence is a repair finding, not successful maintenance. The correct response is forward restoration or verified supersession, never silent truncation. \ No newline at end of file From c3258bf109f03014aa37f3f0e1e0fb31de3cae23 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Sat, 5 Sep 2026 07:23:37 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 092/110] docs(product-gap): refresh exact 2026-09-05 owner state --- ...t-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md | 37 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 37 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..69b2a41fd --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +# Product and technical gap live refresh — 2026-09-05 + +Status: **Non-authoritative live supplement** +Protected-product basis: `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` +Canonical historical baseline: `docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md` +Previous additive supplement: `docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md` +Latest immutable release: `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26, immutable) + +This file updates only live evidence that moved after the 2026-09-04 supplement. The protected 1,036-line baseline and the preceding supplement remain preserved; neither is rewritten or treated as disposable history. A capability becomes product authority only after integration into protected `main` and terminal applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence on one unchanged exact head. + +## Ownership boundary + +`fast-mlsirm` remains the canonical reusable psychometric numerical owner for LSIRM/MLSIRM/IRT/generalized-dependence kernels, true-parameter recovery and stable public bindings. Result-affecting likelihood, estimation, scoring, uncertainty, covariance/correlation, vector/linear/matrix and recovery arithmetic remain Rust/PyO3 owned. Python remains validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity evidence. + +TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` owns provider/model routing and LLM orchestration. Foreign domain truth is consumed only through released/versioned contracts or explicit ACLs; source copying, mutable sibling-head dependencies and cross-service SQL are not product authority. + +## Exact live owner lanes + +| Gap | Exact owner state | Remaining acceptance | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Protected GPU merge gate + repository PR lifecycle | #1717 Ready `fbe1262050bf00e6bd71b6709fca81902ae21a52` | Forward reconciliation preserves explicit Ubuntu 24.04 runner identity and the protected `python -> [python-matrix, gpu-smoke]` dependency while also adopting #1749's repository/PR concurrency, Draft/Ready/closed events, PR-only cancellation and inactive-Draft suppression. CI `33924705580` materialized fuzz, rust, package, Python 3.12, gpu-smoke and Python 3.14 but they remain queued without runner execution. Terminal exact-head GREEN and independent approval remain required. | +| Local-dependence stable public API | #1748 Ready `e7e1e71be6d90d11f6e1f604235c447bfa75cdbb` | Existing Rust-owned Chen–Thissen X2/G2 arithmetic is exposed through a hardened Python/package-root boundary. Input controls and native result envelope/cardinality/finiteness/package-ownership are replayed without moving psychometric arithmetic out of Rust. Ready created fresh exact-head CI/CFLite/security/CodeQL/Semgrep execution, but current jobs remain queued. No universal item-removal cutoff is claimed. | +| Marginal reduction reproducibility | #1742 Draft `dbb6a9bf74e940280fc5b0c247469b7850534709` | Test-only successor pins three invalid floating-point reassociation families: ordinary split-dot one-ULP drift, saturated-logit `NaN` from the rejected algebraic split, and row-wise `einsum` squared-distance one-ULP drift. Production estimator/objective/distance code remains protected-main behavior. Any future hot-path optimization needs profiling plus deterministic CPU-f64 and realistic recovery/parity evidence and should prefer the Rust numerical owner. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference | #1736 Draft `44806471463dda11ed251c4e43c3f9e9e0f7293a`; issue #1747 | Deterministic log/power routing, ratio-before-log cancellation repair, exact power-of-two range conditioning, public optimizer scale contract and exact stationary-manifold fixes are numerical evidence. Scientific completion still requires supported-target bit parity plus VV-SCI-006 known-population recovery: globally sign/permutation-aligned Tucker congruence, loading/target RMSE where identified, bootstrap/split-sample stability, basin support/entropy, criterion-selection frequency and factor-correlation/degeneracy diagnostics. | +| v0.9.2 immutable release | #1471 Draft `d6edc8ea83d8bd0b0840786ca4e8974623560b1f` | Current-main ancestry and Draft provenance are repaired, but release serialization remains RED. `CHANGELOG.md` still carries the superseded managed Unreleased block and historical `[0.9.2] - 2026-08-27` while authoritative fragments contain later protected-main evidence. The exact release head must atomically recut the changelog, preserve the original 17 folded deltas, assign the actual release date only at cut time, then reacquire version/lock/test/security/package/SBOM/provenance/reproducibility/rollback/review evidence. | +| Item-bank evidence-reference provenance child | #1476 Draft `f3c66f0e9f7788e0e20e4f3ef4cbbe5f110fa811`, stacked on #1471 | Child remains intentionally un-restacked while #1471 is source-RED. Its three valid provenance/error-boundary files remain intact. After parent recut, non-force restack onto that exact parent and regenerate hosted/current-head evidence. | +| Product/technical gap evidence preservation | #1519 single writer | Preserve the historical baseline plus dated additive supplements. Do not replace evidence-rich history with a short live inventory. Consolidation is allowed only after a reviewed diff proves no valid PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer/accessibility/traceability evidence is lost. | + +## Current merge and workflow authority + +Protected `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. #1749 added repository/PR-scoped concurrency and inactive-Draft lifecycle control without removing the local CodeQL producer. + +Central workflow authority is `.github/main@f43dcb884be5a0efc61611b5c8cb83c4c7735995`. Current #1717 and #1748 canaries distinguish working workflow materialization/lifecycle from unresolved runner admission: their substantive exact heads materialize jobs, but those jobs remain queued without runner/group execution. That is not terminal GREEN and is not a reason to weaken gates, copy central workflows locally or manufacture no-op commits. + +## Release/scientific claim rule + +No Draft or Ready branch above is a shipped capability. Predecessor GREEN, source-level RED/GREEN, queued workflow creation and resolved review threads are evidence inputs, not substitutes for unchanged-current-head terminal hosted success. Scientific/release claims require their stated recovery/parity/provenance gates in addition to ordinary CI/security and a qualifying independent current-head approval. No self-approval, bypass, force update, destructive rebase, gate weakening, skip/xfail success accounting or predecessor-success transfer is authorized. From 401acec0b137776a627251706287b116a92159c4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Sat, 5 Sep 2026 13:10:01 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 093/110] docs(product-gap): refresh current owner lanes --- ...t-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md | 29 ++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 16 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md index 69b2a41fd..e7165d259 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md @@ -4,13 +4,13 @@ Status: **Non-authoritative live supplement** Protected-product basis: `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` Canonical historical baseline: `docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md` Previous additive supplement: `docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-04.md` -Latest immutable release: `v0.9.1` (published 2026-08-26, immutable) +Latest immutable release: `v0.9.1` -This file updates only live evidence that moved after the 2026-09-04 supplement. The protected 1,036-line baseline and the preceding supplement remain preserved; neither is rewritten or treated as disposable history. A capability becomes product authority only after integration into protected `main` and terminal applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release evidence on one unchanged exact head. +This file updates live evidence that moved after the 2026-09-04 supplement. The protected 1,036-line baseline and preceding supplement remain preserved. Draft/Ready branches are evidence, not shipped product authority; a capability becomes product authority only after protected integration and the applicable scientific, package, coverage, security, review, SBOM/provenance and release gates are terminal on one unchanged exact head. ## Ownership boundary -`fast-mlsirm` remains the canonical reusable psychometric numerical owner for LSIRM/MLSIRM/IRT/generalized-dependence kernels, true-parameter recovery and stable public bindings. Result-affecting likelihood, estimation, scoring, uncertainty, covariance/correlation, vector/linear/matrix and recovery arithmetic remain Rust/PyO3 owned. Python remains validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, orchestration, reporting and explicit reference/parity evidence. +`fast-mlsirm` remains the canonical reusable psychometric numerical owner for LSIRM/MLSIRM/IRT/generalized-dependence kernels, true-parameter recovery and stable public bindings. Result-affecting likelihood, estimation, scoring, uncertainty, covariance/correlation, vector/linear/matrix and recovery arithmetic remain Rust/PyO3 owned. Python remains validation, provenance sealing, marshalling, reporting and explicit reference/parity evidence. TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` owns provider/model routing and LLM orchestration. Foreign domain truth is consumed only through released/versioned contracts or explicit ACLs; source copying, mutable sibling-head dependencies and cross-service SQL are not product authority. @@ -18,20 +18,23 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Gap | Exact owner state | Remaining acceptance | | --- | --- | --- | -| Protected GPU merge gate + repository PR lifecycle | #1717 Ready `fbe1262050bf00e6bd71b6709fca81902ae21a52` | Forward reconciliation preserves explicit Ubuntu 24.04 runner identity and the protected `python -> [python-matrix, gpu-smoke]` dependency while also adopting #1749's repository/PR concurrency, Draft/Ready/closed events, PR-only cancellation and inactive-Draft suppression. CI `33924705580` materialized fuzz, rust, package, Python 3.12, gpu-smoke and Python 3.14 but they remain queued without runner execution. Terminal exact-head GREEN and independent approval remain required. | -| Local-dependence stable public API | #1748 Ready `e7e1e71be6d90d11f6e1f604235c447bfa75cdbb` | Existing Rust-owned Chen–Thissen X2/G2 arithmetic is exposed through a hardened Python/package-root boundary. Input controls and native result envelope/cardinality/finiteness/package-ownership are replayed without moving psychometric arithmetic out of Rust. Ready created fresh exact-head CI/CFLite/security/CodeQL/Semgrep execution, but current jobs remain queued. No universal item-removal cutoff is claimed. | -| Marginal reduction reproducibility | #1742 Draft `dbb6a9bf74e940280fc5b0c247469b7850534709` | Test-only successor pins three invalid floating-point reassociation families: ordinary split-dot one-ULP drift, saturated-logit `NaN` from the rejected algebraic split, and row-wise `einsum` squared-distance one-ULP drift. Production estimator/objective/distance code remains protected-main behavior. Any future hot-path optimization needs profiling plus deterministic CPU-f64 and realistic recovery/parity evidence and should prefer the Rust numerical owner. | -| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference | #1736 Draft `44806471463dda11ed251c4e43c3f9e9e0f7293a`; issue #1747 | Deterministic log/power routing, ratio-before-log cancellation repair, exact power-of-two range conditioning, public optimizer scale contract and exact stationary-manifold fixes are numerical evidence. Scientific completion still requires supported-target bit parity plus VV-SCI-006 known-population recovery: globally sign/permutation-aligned Tucker congruence, loading/target RMSE where identified, bootstrap/split-sample stability, basin support/entropy, criterion-selection frequency and factor-correlation/degeneracy diagnostics. | -| v0.9.2 immutable release | #1471 Draft `d6edc8ea83d8bd0b0840786ca4e8974623560b1f` | Current-main ancestry and Draft provenance are repaired, but release serialization remains RED. `CHANGELOG.md` still carries the superseded managed Unreleased block and historical `[0.9.2] - 2026-08-27` while authoritative fragments contain later protected-main evidence. The exact release head must atomically recut the changelog, preserve the original 17 folded deltas, assign the actual release date only at cut time, then reacquire version/lock/test/security/package/SBOM/provenance/reproducibility/rollback/review evidence. | -| Item-bank evidence-reference provenance child | #1476 Draft `f3c66f0e9f7788e0e20e4f3ef4cbbe5f110fa811`, stacked on #1471 | Child remains intentionally un-restacked while #1471 is source-RED. Its three valid provenance/error-boundary files remain intact. After parent recut, non-force restack onto that exact parent and regenerate hosted/current-head evidence. | -| Product/technical gap evidence preservation | #1519 single writer | Preserve the historical baseline plus dated additive supplements. Do not replace evidence-rich history with a short live inventory. Consolidation is allowed only after a reviewed diff proves no valid PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer/accessibility/traceability evidence is lost. | +| Protected GPU merge gate + repository PR lifecycle | #1717 Ready `fbe1262050bf00e6bd71b6709fca81902ae21a52` | Reconciliation preserves explicit Ubuntu 24.04 identity and the protected `python -> [python-matrix, gpu-smoke]` dependency while retaining #1749 lifecycle/concurrency semantics. Current-head hosted execution and independent approval remain required; queue pressure is not a reason to weaken the GPU or other protected gates. | +| ClusterFuzzLite inactive-PR cancellation | #1754 Draft `2ecfea90cbc4eb35a2b2eedeb262cd83ead24efe` | Original `f9f93607...` incorrectly removed `converted_to_draft`/`closed`, so lifecycle transitions could no longer enter the same workflow/PR concurrency group to cancel stale leaf work. Concurrent forward `9e288c92...` restored those events and guards, moved ClusterFuzzLite concurrency to workflow admission, and removed competing `ci.yml` ownership. A live Draft transition on that predecessor cancelled CI `33943602123` and ClusterFuzzLite `33943602163`; lifecycle ClusterFuzzLite `33943637147` completed skipped. Current `2ecfea90...` pins the exact lifecycle-event contract and test docstring. Those predecessor runs are not current-head GREEN. | +| Local-dependence stable public API | #1748 Ready `013e1d8995d751d03922dc733ae3ed717a512519` | Existing Chen–Thissen X2/G2 arithmetic remains Rust-owned. Python seals public controls/results while the public Rust boundary now owns versioned `ld-resource-v1` work ceilings before ICC-node or pair allocation. Xi cardinality is single-owned by `nodes::xi_node_count`; direct-Rust evidence covers Halton/Monte Carlo support and MIRT Xi non-use. CI `33938505419`, ClusterFuzzLite `33938505459`, Security `33938505478`, CodeQL `33938505443`, CodeQL PR `33938505402` and Semgrep `33938505373` remain non-terminal; no qualifying current-head approval exists. | +| Factor-retention governed result invariants | #1479 Ready `48ec1d357aca76cada2720c2f7918ac30baa5f3b` | Effective delta remains four factor-retention owner paths after non-force merge-forward to current protected main. Public result construction replays method/count/evidence/decision invariants rather than trusting forgeable frozen records. Exact-current hosted gates and independent approval remain required; predecessor GREEN is historical only. | +| Marginal reduction reproducibility | #1742 Ready `dbb6a9bf74e940280fc5b0c247469b7850534709` | Test-only successor preserves ordinary one-ULP objective drift, finite-to-NaN saturated-logit drift, and one-ULP row-distance drift from rejected reassociations. Production marginal arithmetic remains protected-main behavior. Ready-event CI `33935708280` is not terminal; future optimization requires profiling plus deterministic CPU-f64 and realistic recovery/parity evidence and should prefer the Rust numerical owner. | +| Person-fit scalar loop-fusion optimization | #1752 Draft `ca9d1b717ae8052a66041af928ef68d46173fbf5` | The one-pass ZU3 scalar fold is only a performance hypothesis. Focused correctness tests do not prove cache behavior, material speedup or release-codegen binary64 parity. `ca9d1b71...` has the same source tree `623b1eee991e4f8a495b11a9e95d00d31d7a0092` as predecessor `6a9182c5...`, so it adds no benchmark/test delta and is retained only because destructive history rewrite is prohibited. Ready requires a repository-controlled same-profile benchmark with dispersion/uncertainty plus exact `f64::to_bits()` parity on adversarial finite fixtures; without reproducible material benefit, restore protected-main implementation. | +| Oblimax deterministic CPU-f64 reference | #1736 Draft `44806471463dda11ed251c4e43c3f9e9e0f7293a`; issue #1747 | Deterministic log/power routing, ratio-before-log cancellation repair, exact power-of-two range conditioning, public optimizer scale contract and represented stationary-manifold fixes are numerical evidence. Scientific completion still requires supported-target bit parity and VV-SCI-006 realistic known-population recovery with global sign/permutation alignment, Tucker congruence, loading/target RMSE where identified, uncertainty/stability, basin support and degeneracy diagnostics. | +| v0.9.2 immutable release | #1471 Draft `d6edc8ea83d8bd0b0840786ca4e8974623560b1f` | Current-main ancestry and Draft provenance are repaired, but release serialization remains RED. `CHANGELOG.md` still contains the superseded managed Unreleased block and historical `[0.9.2] - 2026-08-27`, while authoritative fragments include later protected-main evidence. The exact tag target must atomically recut the managed block and release section, preserve the historical 17 folded deltas, assign the real release date only at cut time, then reacquire version/lock/test/security/package/SBOM/provenance/reproducibility/rollback/review evidence. | +| Item-bank evidence-reference provenance child | #1476 Draft `f3c66f0e9f7788e0e20e4f3ef4cbbe5f110fa811`, stacked on #1471 | Its three provenance/error-boundary files remain valid, but parent #1471 is still source-RED. Integrate/reconcile the release parent first, then non-force restack the child and reacquire exact-current hosted evidence. | +| Product/technical gap evidence preservation | #1519 single writer | Preserve the protected historical baseline plus dated additive supplements. Do not replace evidence-rich PRD/TRD/UML/research/release/buyer/accessibility/traceability history with a short inventory. Consolidation is allowed only after a reviewed diff proves no valid evidence is lost. | ## Current merge and workflow authority -Protected `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. #1749 added repository/PR-scoped concurrency and inactive-Draft lifecycle control without removing the local CodeQL producer. +Protected `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` still requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. -Central workflow authority is `.github/main@f43dcb884be5a0efc61611b5c8cb83c4c7735995`. Current #1717 and #1748 canaries distinguish working workflow materialization/lifecycle from unresolved runner admission: their substantive exact heads materialize jobs, but those jobs remain queued without runner/group execution. That is not terminal GREEN and is not a reason to weaken gates, copy central workflows locally or manufacture no-op commits. +Central workflow authority is `.github/main@0ee7be81b3e7dae56caf41414d811c8b2235b373` (#1886). #1886 pins the remaining named residual central workflows from `ubuntu-latest` to explicit Ubuntu 24.04 and adds runner-image contracts, but it explicitly does **not** explain the dominant organization-wide congestion: the observed in-progress job count remained far below the documented ceiling while hundreds of runs were queued, including workflows already pinned to Ubuntu 24.04. Treat this as an unresolved Actions acquisition problem, not as proof that leaf numerical/scientific heads are defective and not as authority to weaken protected checks. ## Release/scientific claim rule -No Draft or Ready branch above is a shipped capability. Predecessor GREEN, source-level RED/GREEN, queued workflow creation and resolved review threads are evidence inputs, not substitutes for unchanged-current-head terminal hosted success. Scientific/release claims require their stated recovery/parity/provenance gates in addition to ordinary CI/security and a qualifying independent current-head approval. No self-approval, bypass, force update, destructive rebase, gate weakening, skip/xfail success accounting or predecessor-success transfer is authorized. +No Draft or Ready branch above is a shipped capability. Source-level RED/GREEN lineage, lifecycle canaries, queued workflow creation, resolved review threads and predecessor success are evidence inputs, not substitutes for unchanged-current-head terminal hosted success. Scientific/release claims additionally require their stated recovery/parity/provenance gates and a qualifying independent current-head approval. No self-approval, bypass, force update, destructive rebase, gate weakening, skip/xfail success accounting, no-op source churn or predecessor-success transfer is authorized. From 9f08dcb944c10761317d7e1ef51d07318c28d45e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Sat, 5 Sep 2026 13:12:58 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 094/110] docs(product-gap): adopt CodeQL shard authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md index e7165d259..2b6780c3b 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md @@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow Protected `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` still requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. -Central workflow authority is `.github/main@0ee7be81b3e7dae56caf41414d811c8b2235b373` (#1886). #1886 pins the remaining named residual central workflows from `ubuntu-latest` to explicit Ubuntu 24.04 and adds runner-image contracts, but it explicitly does **not** explain the dominant organization-wide congestion: the observed in-progress job count remained far below the documented ceiling while hundreds of runs were queued, including workflows already pinned to Ubuntu 24.04. Treat this as an unresolved Actions acquisition problem, not as proof that leaf numerical/scientific heads are defective and not as authority to weaken protected checks. +Central workflow authority is `.github/main@0eb41a36549fe992b912d26d549635dc56649d1d` (#1888). Its parent #1886 pins the remaining named residual central workflows from `ubuntu-latest` to explicit Ubuntu 24.04 but explicitly leaves the dominant organization-wide queue congestion unexplained. #1888 then repairs a separate CodeQL dispatch defect: the handler concurrency key now includes `required_language`, so same-PR Python, JavaScript/TypeScript and Actions shards no longer cancel one another while a newer dispatch for the same repository/PR/language tuple still retires its stale predecessor. This is central workflow-owner evidence only; it does not retroactively make existing leaf CodeQL runs GREEN, repair unrelated Actions acquisition congestion, or authorize protected-gate weakening. ## Release/scientific claim rule From 202ef52ecdfa70944518f200d9b91d5d180f31e3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Sat, 5 Sep 2026 13:14:40 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 095/110] docs(product-gap): adopt cancellation-proof authority --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md index 2b6780c3b..885a8a2db 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md @@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow Protected `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f` still requires `Analyze (actions)`, `close-empty`, `scan-pr-queue`, `dependency-review`, `osv-scan`, `trivy-fs`, `scorecard`, `required-workflow-bootstrap`, `coverage-evidence`, `opencode-review`, `python`, `rust`, `package` and `fuzz` contexts. -Central workflow authority is `.github/main@0eb41a36549fe992b912d26d549635dc56649d1d` (#1888). Its parent #1886 pins the remaining named residual central workflows from `ubuntu-latest` to explicit Ubuntu 24.04 but explicitly leaves the dominant organization-wide queue congestion unexplained. #1888 then repairs a separate CodeQL dispatch defect: the handler concurrency key now includes `required_language`, so same-PR Python, JavaScript/TypeScript and Actions shards no longer cancel one another while a newer dispatch for the same repository/PR/language tuple still retires its stale predecessor. This is central workflow-owner evidence only; it does not retroactively make existing leaf CodeQL runs GREEN, repair unrelated Actions acquisition congestion, or authorize protected-gate weakening. +Central workflow authority is `.github/main@8a15cde08116d6a1d9c3ab4ec70f9db56ab2b56c` (#1887). Parent #1886 pins the remaining named residual workflows to explicit Ubuntu 24.04 but leaves the dominant organization-wide queue congestion unexplained. Parent #1888 separates CodeQL native-dispatch concurrency by `required_language`, preventing same-PR language shards from cancelling one another. Current #1887 hardens current-head run coalescing: an accepted cancellation request is not reported as complete until GitHub is polled to terminal `completed/cancelled`; unproven cancellation fails closed instead of being counted as reclaimed queue work. These are central workflow-owner repairs only; they do not retroactively make existing leaf runs GREEN, repair unrelated Actions acquisition congestion, or authorize protected-gate weakening. ## Release/scientific claim rule From 0a9e93a8199ea0e6de2d8a7bd63835ceb2675402 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Sat, 5 Sep 2026 13:17:28 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 096/110] docs(product-gap): expose repaired fuzz lane --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md index 885a8a2db..b4c276081 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ TEPP owns temporal/event semantics and composition. `contextual-orchestrator` ow | Gap | Exact owner state | Remaining acceptance | | --- | --- | --- | | Protected GPU merge gate + repository PR lifecycle | #1717 Ready `fbe1262050bf00e6bd71b6709fca81902ae21a52` | Reconciliation preserves explicit Ubuntu 24.04 identity and the protected `python -> [python-matrix, gpu-smoke]` dependency while retaining #1749 lifecycle/concurrency semantics. Current-head hosted execution and independent approval remain required; queue pressure is not a reason to weaken the GPU or other protected gates. | -| ClusterFuzzLite inactive-PR cancellation | #1754 Draft `2ecfea90cbc4eb35a2b2eedeb262cd83ead24efe` | Original `f9f93607...` incorrectly removed `converted_to_draft`/`closed`, so lifecycle transitions could no longer enter the same workflow/PR concurrency group to cancel stale leaf work. Concurrent forward `9e288c92...` restored those events and guards, moved ClusterFuzzLite concurrency to workflow admission, and removed competing `ci.yml` ownership. A live Draft transition on that predecessor cancelled CI `33943602123` and ClusterFuzzLite `33943602163`; lifecycle ClusterFuzzLite `33943637147` completed skipped. Current `2ecfea90...` pins the exact lifecycle-event contract and test docstring. Those predecessor runs are not current-head GREEN. | +| ClusterFuzzLite inactive-PR cancellation | #1754 Ready `2ecfea90cbc4eb35a2b2eedeb262cd83ead24efe` | Original `f9f93607...` incorrectly removed `converted_to_draft`/`closed`; concurrent forward `9e288c92...` restored them, removed competing `ci.yml` ownership and kept ClusterFuzzLite concurrency at workflow admission. Current `2ecfea90...` pins the exact lifecycle event set. On this unchanged head the Draft-state CI run `33943673921` reached cancelled; marking the repaired PR Ready then created CI `33944125746` and ClusterFuzzLite `33944125764`, both still non-terminal. Earlier predecessor cancellation/skip evidence remains historical and is not current GREEN. | | Local-dependence stable public API | #1748 Ready `013e1d8995d751d03922dc733ae3ed717a512519` | Existing Chen–Thissen X2/G2 arithmetic remains Rust-owned. Python seals public controls/results while the public Rust boundary now owns versioned `ld-resource-v1` work ceilings before ICC-node or pair allocation. Xi cardinality is single-owned by `nodes::xi_node_count`; direct-Rust evidence covers Halton/Monte Carlo support and MIRT Xi non-use. CI `33938505419`, ClusterFuzzLite `33938505459`, Security `33938505478`, CodeQL `33938505443`, CodeQL PR `33938505402` and Semgrep `33938505373` remain non-terminal; no qualifying current-head approval exists. | | Factor-retention governed result invariants | #1479 Ready `48ec1d357aca76cada2720c2f7918ac30baa5f3b` | Effective delta remains four factor-retention owner paths after non-force merge-forward to current protected main. Public result construction replays method/count/evidence/decision invariants rather than trusting forgeable frozen records. Exact-current hosted gates and independent approval remain required; predecessor GREEN is historical only. | | Marginal reduction reproducibility | #1742 Ready `dbb6a9bf74e940280fc5b0c247469b7850534709` | Test-only successor preserves ordinary one-ULP objective drift, finite-to-NaN saturated-logit drift, and one-ULP row-distance drift from rejected reassociations. Production marginal arithmetic remains protected-main behavior. Ready-event CI `33935708280` is not terminal; future optimization requires profiling plus deterministic CPU-f64 and realistic recovery/parity evidence and should prefer the Rust numerical owner. | From f553dcd60f7418bfa8c51ba551d812db627edfed Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 07:46:01 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 097/110] docs(product-gap): add 2026-09-07 exact-evidence refresh --- ...t-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 76 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 76 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f83ad20d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -0,0 +1,76 @@ +# Product and technical gap live refresh — 2026-09-07 + +Status: **Non-authoritative point-in-time supplement** +Observed at: **2026-09-06T22:23:00Z** +Protected-product basis: **`main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`** +Canonical historical baseline: **`docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md`** +Previous additive supplement: **`docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-05.md`** +Latest immutable release: **`v0.9.1`**, published 2026-08-26 + +This supplement records only evidence that changed after the preceding snapshot. +It does not replace the PRD, TRD, architecture, ADR, UML/ERD, Context Map, +requirements traceability, scientific evidence, or the protected historical +baseline. Open branches and their checks remain evidence, not shipped product +authority. Every merge or release decision must re-fetch the exact head, live +base, review threads, required checks, ruleset result, and active writer. + +## Authority and ownership continuity + +- Product scope and acceptance authority remain `docs/PRD.md` and + `docs/TRD.md`. +- The repository boundary and Context Map remain `ARCHITECTURE.md` and the + status-bearing ADR graph under `docs/adr/`. +- UML/ERD and requirements authority remain the linked document families in + the protected baseline; this supplement creates no competing model. +- `fast-mlsirm` owns reusable, domain-neutral IRT/LSIRM/MLSIRM mathematical and + Psychometrics kernels, true-parameter recovery, stable bindings, and release + evidence. Result-affecting covariance, correlation, vector, linear, matrix, + likelihood, estimation, scoring, uncertainty, and recovery arithmetic remain + Rust/PyO3 owned. +- `ContextualWisdomLab/.github` owns reusable CI, review, security, and release + orchestration. A leaf repository does not copy or bypass an immature central + workflow; it waits behind the released contract or uses a bounded test double. + +## Fresh inventory + +GitHub search returned **64 open pull requests** and **201 open issues** for +`ContextualWisdomLab/fast-mlsirm` at the observation time. These counts are a +denominator for this snapshot, not a live invariant. Protected `main` and the +latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. + +## Buyer-visible gap and action status + +| Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | +| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; live dispatches arrive with actor and sender `opencode-agent[bot]`, while `OPENCODE_REPOSITORY_DISPATCH_ACTOR` contains only `github-actions[bot]` | Settings owner adds, rather than replaces, the active principal: `github-actions[bot],opencode-agent[bot]`; retain actor=sender validation; then test same-repository and cross-repository status publication separately | **Blocked at canonical owner settings.** Code change is not the repair. The available repository connection cannot mutate Actions variables. A second serial defect remains: cross-repository commit-status publication receives HTTP 403 for the available app and workflow credentials. | +| Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | +| Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | +| Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3`, live stacked base `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, four changed files | Verify and integrate the canonical base first, preserve the Rust production owner, then reacquire exact-head recovery and review evidence | **Mergeable against its live stacked base, not direct protected `main`.** No predecessor evidence is approval for this head/base pair. | +| Product/technical gap evidence | `fast-mlsirm#1519`, draft single-writer branch `docs/refresh-product-gap-baseline-20260828` | Preserve the historical baseline and dated supplements; consolidate only after a reviewed proof that no PRD/TRD/UML/ERD/Context Map/scientific/release evidence is lost | **Active single writer.** This file is an additive delta on that branch, not a competing baseline writer. | + +## Release and claim boundary + +`v0.9.1` remains the latest immutable release. Neither a mergeable PR, a local +GREEN suite, queued hosted work, a resolved thread, nor an approval on an older +head is a release or GA claim. Technical GA still requires a bounded support +matrix, unchanged-head scientific recovery and cross-engine evidence where +applicable, stable API/artifact migration and rollback contracts, package/SBOM/ +provenance evidence, security and operability gates, and ordinary protected +integration. Domain validation, high-stakes use, hosted identity, consent, +persistence, human decision policy, and buyer workflow validation remain owned +by the consuming product. + +## Next safe sequence + +1. Complete the settings-owner repair in `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`, + prove both same-repository and cross-repository dispatch/status paths, and + rerun unchanged consumer heads. +2. Let `.github#1986` pass its exact-head hosted checks and independent review; + ordinary auto-merge is already armed and cannot bypass those protections. +3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head, merge ordinarily, and + produce immutable release evidence before changing the released-version + claim. +4. Continue the Rust numerical stack in dependency order, starting with each + PR's live base rather than assuming every Ready PR targets protected `main`. + From 30c959aaf17bc32c06b36800d7e05ec00b1a844d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 08:38:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 098/110] docs(product-gap): record split CodeQL and scheduler owner lanes --- ...ct-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 18 ++++++++++-------- 1 file changed, 10 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index f83ad20d3..bb8a71877 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,7 +43,9 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; live dispatches arrive with actor and sender `opencode-agent[bot]`, while `OPENCODE_REPOSITORY_DISPATCH_ACTOR` contains only `github-actions[bot]` | Settings owner adds, rather than replaces, the active principal: `github-actions[bot],opencode-agent[bot]`; retain actor=sender validation; then test same-repository and cross-repository status publication separately | **Blocked at canonical owner settings.** Code change is not the repair. The available repository connection cannot mutate Actions variables. A second serial defect remains: cross-repository commit-status publication receives HTTP 403 for the available app and workflow credentials. | +| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; `#1986@4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3` successfully created dispatch runs `34066603914` and `34066634411` | Preserve actor=sender validation; prove both runs reach terminal same-repository status publication, then prove the cross-repository credential path independently | **Identity admission has advanced; issue remains open.** The new dispatches passed request creation but remain queued. This supersedes the earlier “blocked at the actor allowlist” status. Cross-repository commit-status publication previously received HTTP 403 and remains unproven. | +| CodeQL rerun recovery | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `3549de595c9d7615b253e03fc18ee06f34d3d294`, tree `08661ee1e65295e07a69620292a764e0f9cb15e9`, five CodeQL-owned paths | Use complete paginated status history and trusted creator/context identity; if no terminal verdict exists, perform one bounded redispatch instead of treating `run_attempt` as a receipt | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** Focused 12 passed; repository 2,979 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head checks and independent review remain non-terminal. | +| Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | | Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3`, live stacked base `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, four changed files | Verify and integrate the canonical base first, preserve the Rust production owner, then reacquire exact-head recovery and review evidence | **Mergeable against its live stacked base, not direct protected `main`.** No predecessor evidence is approval for this head/base pair. | @@ -63,14 +65,14 @@ by the consuming product. ## Next safe sequence -1. Complete the settings-owner repair in `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`, - prove both same-repository and cross-repository dispatch/status paths, and - rerun unchanged consumer heads. -2. Let `.github#1986` pass its exact-head hosted checks and independent review; - ordinary auto-merge is already armed and cannot bypass those protections. -3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head, merge ordinarily, and +1. Let the two `.github#1986` dispatch runs reach terminal state and prove + same-repository status publication; then prove the cross-repository path + tracked by `.github#1929`. +2. Let `.github#1902` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks + and independent review; ordinary auto-merge is armed behind protection. +3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, + merge ordinarily, and produce immutable release evidence before changing the released-version claim. 4. Continue the Rust numerical stack in dependency order, starting with each PR's live base rather than assuming every Ready PR targets protected `main`. - From fbec3f2ac8c3ba0a5c9081d479c9e08f69d3d91c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 09:39:03 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 099/110] docs(gap): correct CodeQL dispatch evidence --- .../product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 12 ++++++------ 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index bb8a71877..239f9d0a2 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,8 +43,8 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; `#1986@4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3` successfully created dispatch runs `34066603914` and `34066634411` | Preserve actor=sender validation; prove both runs reach terminal same-repository status publication, then prove the cross-repository credential path independently | **Identity admission has advanced; issue remains open.** The new dispatches passed request creation but remain queued. This supersedes the earlier “blocked at the actor allowlist” status. Cross-repository commit-status publication previously received HTTP 403 and remains unproven. | -| CodeQL rerun recovery | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `3549de595c9d7615b253e03fc18ee06f34d3d294`, tree `08661ee1e65295e07a69620292a764e0f9cb15e9`, five CodeQL-owned paths | Use complete paginated status history and trusted creator/context identity; if no terminal verdict exists, perform one bounded redispatch instead of treating `run_attempt` as a receipt | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** Focused 12 passed; repository 2,979 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head checks and independent review remain non-terminal. | +| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; terminal validation jobs from dispatch runs `34066603914` and `34066634411` reported `actor=sender=opencode-agent[bot]` but `allowed=github-actions[bot]` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; configuration owner adds `opencode-agent[bot]` to `OPENCODE_REPOSITORY_DISPATCH_ACTOR`, then reruns an unchanged consumer and separately repairs the cross-repository status credential | **Configuration repair required; issue remains open.** Both dispatches were created but then failed authorization before scan, so receipt creation was not identity admission. Their scan jobs were skipped. A prior brief allowlist-open window reached the SARIF gate but cross-repository status publication failed HTTP 403. This corrects the earlier queued-run inference in this same snapshot. | +| CodeQL rerun recovery and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `82ca0b8fe67177a98ca01f8dc12441c782f1760f`, tree `596d8eaecbdee367192ebd7a62d3cc47c0140492`, eight CodeQL-owned paths | Use complete paginated status history and trusted creator/context identity; redispatch once when no terminal verdict exists; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal status publication or exact-job wake | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** RED reproduced false success publication for upload failure/skipped/cancelled/empty. GREEN: 36 focused CodeQL contracts; repository 2,984 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc checks 100%. These are local exact-tree checks; hosted scan/upload/callback checks and independent review remain non-terminal. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | @@ -65,10 +65,10 @@ by the consuming product. ## Next safe sequence -1. Let the two `.github#1986` dispatch runs reach terminal state and prove - same-repository status publication; then prove the cross-repository path - tracked by `.github#1929`. -2. Let `.github#1902` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks +1. Repair the exact dispatcher identity setting tracked by `.github#1929` + without weakening actor=sender validation, rerun an unchanged consumer, and + then repair and prove the separate cross-repository HTTP 403 status path. +2. Let `.github#1902@82ca0b8f` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks and independent review; ordinary auto-merge is armed behind protection. 3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, merge ordinarily, and From acb3f5a9f078a6734a3f55bff070b7c8ede3a1dd Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 10:29:54 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 100/110] docs(gap): record CodeQL Ready admission --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 239f9d0a2..03159024a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; terminal validation jobs from dispatch runs `34066603914` and `34066634411` reported `actor=sender=opencode-agent[bot]` but `allowed=github-actions[bot]` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; configuration owner adds `opencode-agent[bot]` to `OPENCODE_REPOSITORY_DISPATCH_ACTOR`, then reruns an unchanged consumer and separately repairs the cross-repository status credential | **Configuration repair required; issue remains open.** Both dispatches were created but then failed authorization before scan, so receipt creation was not identity admission. Their scan jobs were skipped. A prior brief allowlist-open window reached the SARIF gate but cross-repository status publication failed HTTP 403. This corrects the earlier queued-run inference in this same snapshot. | -| CodeQL rerun recovery and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `82ca0b8fe67177a98ca01f8dc12441c782f1760f`, tree `596d8eaecbdee367192ebd7a62d3cc47c0140492`, eight CodeQL-owned paths | Use complete paginated status history and trusted creator/context identity; redispatch once when no terminal verdict exists; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal status publication or exact-job wake | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** RED reproduced false success publication for upload failure/skipped/cancelled/empty. GREEN: 36 focused CodeQL contracts; repository 2,984 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc checks 100%. These are local exact-tree checks; hosted scan/upload/callback checks and independent review remain non-terminal. | +| CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `8c4fd5512c52fb3a30631b3c013adc14095b7350`, tree `348f3007962ce047dfb5fb6ddbd03e1368c9ace0`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Use complete paginated status history and trusted creator/context identity; redispatch once when no terminal verdict exists; bind live/event base repository/ref/SHA before status consumption; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal status publication or exact-job wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** The predecessor incomplete-successor finding is explicitly repaired on the current head, review threads are empty, and focused production-shell verification is 50 passed normally plus 50 passed with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true -W error`; actionlint and diff check pass. The Ready event created fresh runs `34073013831`, `34073013849`, `34073013897`, and `34073013921`, all currently queued. Hosted GREEN and a qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken in this transition. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | @@ -68,7 +68,7 @@ by the consuming product. 1. Repair the exact dispatcher identity setting tracked by `.github#1929` without weakening actor=sender validation, rerun an unchanged consumer, and then repair and prove the separate cross-repository HTTP 403 status path. -2. Let `.github#1902@82ca0b8f` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks +2. Let `.github#1902@8c4fd551` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks and independent review; ordinary auto-merge is armed behind protection. 3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, merge ordinarily, and From adba45f36af979b54c2e784f58abc1face61ca27 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 11:52:26 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 101/110] docs(gap): record receipt and Rust reconciliation --- ...t-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 21 ++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 03159024a..6842abed6 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,12 +43,12 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; terminal validation jobs from dispatch runs `34066603914` and `34066634411` reported `actor=sender=opencode-agent[bot]` but `allowed=github-actions[bot]` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; configuration owner adds `opencode-agent[bot]` to `OPENCODE_REPOSITORY_DISPATCH_ACTOR`, then reruns an unchanged consumer and separately repairs the cross-repository status credential | **Configuration repair required; issue remains open.** Both dispatches were created but then failed authorization before scan, so receipt creation was not identity admission. Their scan jobs were skipped. A prior brief allowlist-open window reached the SARIF gate but cross-repository status publication failed HTTP 403. This corrects the earlier queued-run inference in this same snapshot. | -| CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `8c4fd5512c52fb3a30631b3c013adc14095b7350`, tree `348f3007962ce047dfb5fb6ddbd03e1368c9ace0`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Use complete paginated status history and trusted creator/context identity; redispatch once when no terminal verdict exists; bind live/event base repository/ref/SHA before status consumption; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal status publication or exact-job wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** The predecessor incomplete-successor finding is explicitly repaired on the current head, review threads are empty, and focused production-shell verification is 50 passed normally plus 50 passed with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true -W error`; actionlint and diff check pass. The Ready event created fresh runs `34073013831`, `34073013849`, `34073013897`, and `34073013921`, all currently queued. Hosted GREEN and a qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken in this transition. | +| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | +| CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | -| Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `338dbb2d25f32b0e201102e7bf73076846fb57b3`, live stacked base `b5a3a0c1057d4b53d7a4bb18e0de69f630c2b45c`, four changed files | Verify and integrate the canonical base first, preserve the Rust production owner, then reacquire exact-head recovery and review evidence | **Mergeable against its live stacked base, not direct protected `main`.** No predecessor evidence is approval for this head/base pair. | +| Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, evidence pending.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, CodeQL `34076849581`, CI `34076849582`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` are queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no current-head Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. | | Product/technical gap evidence | `fast-mlsirm#1519`, draft single-writer branch `docs/refresh-product-gap-baseline-20260828` | Preserve the historical baseline and dated supplements; consolidate only after a reviewed proof that no PRD/TRD/UML/ERD/Context Map/scientific/release evidence is lost | **Active single writer.** This file is an additive delta on that branch, not a competing baseline writer. | ## Release and claim boundary @@ -65,14 +65,15 @@ by the consuming product. ## Next safe sequence -1. Repair the exact dispatcher identity setting tracked by `.github#1929` - without weakening actor=sender validation, rerun an unchanged consumer, and - then repair and prove the separate cross-repository HTTP 403 status path. -2. Let `.github#1902@8c4fd551` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks - and independent review; ordinary auto-merge is armed behind protection. +1. Prove a same-repository terminal dispatch receipt under the repaired actor + setting tracked by `.github#1929`, then repair and prove the separate + cross-repository HTTP 403 status path without weakening actor=sender. +2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks + and independent review; only #1999 has ordinary auto-merge armed. 3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, merge ordinarily, and produce immutable release evidence before changing the released-version claim. -4. Continue the Rust numerical stack in dependency order, starting with each - PR's live base rather than assuming every Ready PR targets protected `main`. +4. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1722@28b03055` on its direct protected-main base, + including Cargo/Rust formatting and numerical recovery evidence, before + continuing the Rust numerical stack in dependency order. From 0f6fd055ec1c824d6af5c5ea9e0de9920dd68ee1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 11:54:26 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 102/110] docs(gap): record covariance CI evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 6842abed6..9238c1200 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | -| Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, evidence pending.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, CodeQL `34076849581`, CI `34076849582`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` are queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no current-head Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. | +| Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, partially GREEN.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Native CodeQL `34076849581` and CI `34076849582` are terminal success; Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` remain queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no separate local Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. | | Product/technical gap evidence | `fast-mlsirm#1519`, draft single-writer branch `docs/refresh-product-gap-baseline-20260828` | Preserve the historical baseline and dated supplements; consolidate only after a reviewed proof that no PRD/TRD/UML/ERD/Context Map/scientific/release evidence is lost | **Active single writer.** This file is an additive delta on that branch, not a competing baseline writer. | ## Release and claim boundary From ab63b765f4a8d797f879c9ba7fe5758a51894868 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 12:02:11 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 103/110] docs(gap): record bounded Actions fan-out evidence --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 9238c1200..722f11c0f 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | +| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `1f48d1635cffd24542c461395b5eb3f9a23265a3`, stacked on #1903, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** The contradicted `No recoverable waste`, `not a productive lever`, `measured floor`, and `number never under-reports` claims are removed or bounded. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. CodeQL PR `34078124327`, Semgrep `34078124284`, and Security `34078124279` are queued. The prior-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. |\n| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | From ed9e9940836ed13198f01d5a11c3e824b7bf504e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 12:03:03 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 104/110] docs(gap): restore Markdown row boundary --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 3 ++- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 722f11c0f..688f2e30a 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,7 +43,8 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `1f48d1635cffd24542c461395b5eb3f9a23265a3`, stacked on #1903, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** The contradicted `No recoverable waste`, `not a productive lever`, `measured floor`, and `number never under-reports` claims are removed or bounded. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. CodeQL PR `34078124327`, Semgrep `34078124284`, and Security `34078124279` are queued. The prior-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. |\n| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | +| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `1f48d1635cffd24542c461395b5eb3f9a23265a3`, stacked on #1903, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** The contradicted `No recoverable waste`, `not a productive lever`, `measured floor`, and `number never under-reports` claims are removed or bounded. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. CodeQL PR `34078124327`, Semgrep `34078124284`, and Security `34078124279` are queued. The prior-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | +| Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | From aa508f9ccf29f21a663f2d6fbc71b8704bb66e22 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 12:14:41 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 105/110] docs(product-gap): record #1905 stacked reconciliation --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 688f2e30a..553478748 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `1f48d1635cffd24542c461395b5eb3f9a23265a3`, stacked on #1903, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** The contradicted `No recoverable waste`, `not a productive lever`, `measured floor`, and `number never under-reports` claims are removed or bounded. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. CodeQL PR `34078124327`, Semgrep `34078124284`, and Security `34078124279` are queued. The prior-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | +| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. CodeQL PR `34078849437`, Semgrep `34078849468`, and Security `34078849481` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | From c58a4f75609adaa0813f528b322003dbc56c6dab Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 12:17:21 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 106/110] docs(product-gap): record #1905 review admission --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 553478748..929be1b65 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Gap / bounded context | Exact evidence | Action | Status | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Central scheduler REST workflow identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1986` exact head `4604909a9b68cb29cda431d71bc0ed3d37f11af3`, protected base `c9052e607e5f3cc76e73207e7786b21500721b79`, two changed files | Preserve per-workflow parallelism while coalescing concurrent reads for one `(repository, workflow_id)`; treat a deleted workflow's HTTP 404 as an absent static identity while propagating other failures | **Ready, auto-merge armed behind protection.** RED reproduced 11 duplicate reads and 404 propagation. GREEN: 21 focused tests; scheduler aggregate 349 passed; repository 2,990 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. Hosted exact-head security/review checks remain non-terminal and no current-head approval exists. | -| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. CodeQL PR `34078849437`, Semgrep `34078849468`, and Security `34078849481` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | +| Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. Ready review admission was restored on the unchanged head at `2026-09-07T03:16:43Z`; CodeQL PR `34079111710`, Semgrep `34079111737`, and Security `34079111714` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | | Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | From fbb32d2489f0fb4c9e5fa138d23f5c115651276c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 12:56:28 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 107/110] docs(product-gap): record Strix lifecycle repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 7 ++++--- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 929be1b65..50f401449 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. Ready review admission was restored on the unchanged head at `2026-09-07T03:16:43Z`; CodeQL PR `34079111710`, Semgrep `34079111737`, and Security `34079111714` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | -| Scheduler live-PR and Strix rerun identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `ed8ab26b53792386e4578fcfbd3bdf1632cff54c`, tree `9619c391252b95b1118f2d81ed60c445e307bdbf`, seven scheduler-owned paths | Require an explicitly open live PR and bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job identity | **Ready, ordinary auto-merge armed.** This is the complete successor carryover of valid scheduler/Strix commits formerly mixed into #1902. Focused 394 passed; repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; coverage and public-doc checks 100%. | +| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `d9de9a5ecaa5f6fd5ee8439381a29c7e97bf15a1`, tree `936a2eb323249bf1e04b144373f8cfcddc71b30c`, eleven scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, and preserve an executing same-head scan across Draft/Ready admission while retaining live-revalidated cleanup for superseded heads and inactive PRs | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** RED reproduced workflow-level `cancel-in-progress: true` contradicting the evidence-preservation contract; GREEN is five focused lifecycle/cleanup tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped, and statement/branch and public-doc coverage 100%. Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T03:53:47Z` only after the pre-event Strix run was verified queued with no provider execution. Replacement Strix `34081183460`, OpenCode `34081183488`, Noema `34081183469`, scheduler `34081183475`, CodeQL PR `34081183341`, Security `34081183313`, Python Security `34081183384`, and Semgrep `34081183299` remain queued. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and independent review remain merge gates. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | | Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, partially GREEN.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Native CodeQL `34076849581` and CI `34076849582` are terminal success; Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` remain queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no separate local Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. | @@ -69,8 +69,9 @@ by the consuming product. 1. Prove a same-repository terminal dispatch receipt under the repaired actor setting tracked by `.github#1929`, then repair and prove the separate cross-repository HTTP 403 status path without weakening actor=sender. -2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and `.github#1999` acquire exact-head hosted checks - and independent review; only #1999 has ordinary auto-merge armed. +2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and `.github#1999@d9de9a5e` acquire exact-head + hosted checks and independent review; neither Ready transition is approval or + merge authority, and no auto-merge change is recorded here. 3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, merge ordinarily, and produce immutable release evidence before changing the released-version From effcc6ba1c9379bdb9a5b23940c2365b90f50ab5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 13:35:45 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 108/110] docs(product-gap): record final Strix lifecycle stack --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 50f401449..935d8ca33 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. Ready review admission was restored on the unchanged head at `2026-09-07T03:16:43Z`; CodeQL PR `34079111710`, Semgrep `34079111737`, and Security `34079111714` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | -| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `d9de9a5ecaa5f6fd5ee8439381a29c7e97bf15a1`, tree `936a2eb323249bf1e04b144373f8cfcddc71b30c`, eleven scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, and preserve an executing same-head scan across Draft/Ready admission while retaining live-revalidated cleanup for superseded heads and inactive PRs | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** RED reproduced workflow-level `cancel-in-progress: true` contradicting the evidence-preservation contract; GREEN is five focused lifecycle/cleanup tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,039 passed / 1 skipped, and statement/branch and public-doc coverage 100%. Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T03:53:47Z` only after the pre-event Strix run was verified queued with no provider execution. Replacement Strix `34081183460`, OpenCode `34081183488`, Noema `34081183469`, scheduler `34081183475`, CodeQL PR `34081183341`, Security `34081183313`, Python Security `34081183384`, and Semgrep `34081183299` remain queued. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and independent review remain merge gates. | +| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `86aa8b79e596beb54685b9c7d9e470740f067081`, tree `1fe1f2a92de7c4dc9089e4d0eee6eac8ccf68380`, stacked on `.github#1938@056226c56eff8c1aa01d29722f14c9820b97438d`, twelve scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract/doctoring paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, preserve executing same-head evidence across Draft/Ready/dispatch, give synchronized heads and closed cleanup independent groups, and retain protected-ref push coalescing with cancellation authority only for a newer push | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** This supersedes the intermediate `d9de9a5e` blanket no-cancellation state. RED and review reproduced nine event-class contradictions, blocked cleanup, and same-head Draft cancellation. GREEN is seven focused lifecycle/cleanup/stack tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,044 passed / 1 skipped, statement/branch coverage 100% (`13,251` statements and `5,362` branches, zero miss/partial), and public-doc coverage 100%; `bash -n` and diff check are clean. Both review findings are resolved and outdated, the stack is behind 0 and mergeable, and Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T04:32:18Z` only for review admission. Security `34083472830`, CodeQL PR `34083472892`, Semgrep `34083472922`, Python Security `34083377117`, Agent Review Runtime Quality `34083377126`, scheduler `34083473304`, Noema `34083473285`, OpenCode `34083473338`, and Strix `34083473249` remain queued. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and qualifying independent review remain merge gates. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | | Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, partially GREEN.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Native CodeQL `34076849581` and CI `34076849582` are terminal success; Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` remain queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no separate local Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. | @@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ by the consuming product. 1. Prove a same-repository terminal dispatch receipt under the repaired actor setting tracked by `.github#1929`, then repair and prove the separate cross-repository HTTP 403 status path without weakening actor=sender. -2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and `.github#1999@d9de9a5e` acquire exact-head +2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and stacked `.github#1999@86aa8b79` acquire exact-head hosted checks and independent review; neither Ready transition is approval or merge authority, and no auto-merge change is recorded here. 3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, From 4153661ffb26d2b555bd1ed049e92d2b5d9e4295 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 14:42:38 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 109/110] docs(product-gap): record final Strix lifecycle repair --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 935d8ca33..688cbc6e5 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. Ready review admission was restored on the unchanged head at `2026-09-07T03:16:43Z`; CodeQL PR `34079111710`, Semgrep `34079111737`, and Security `34079111714` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | -| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `86aa8b79e596beb54685b9c7d9e470740f067081`, tree `1fe1f2a92de7c4dc9089e4d0eee6eac8ccf68380`, stacked on `.github#1938@056226c56eff8c1aa01d29722f14c9820b97438d`, twelve scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract/doctoring paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, preserve executing same-head evidence across Draft/Ready/dispatch, give synchronized heads and closed cleanup independent groups, and retain protected-ref push coalescing with cancellation authority only for a newer push | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** This supersedes the intermediate `d9de9a5e` blanket no-cancellation state. RED and review reproduced nine event-class contradictions, blocked cleanup, and same-head Draft cancellation. GREEN is seven focused lifecycle/cleanup/stack tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,044 passed / 1 skipped, statement/branch coverage 100% (`13,251` statements and `5,362` branches, zero miss/partial), and public-doc coverage 100%; `bash -n` and diff check are clean. Both review findings are resolved and outdated, the stack is behind 0 and mergeable, and Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T04:32:18Z` only for review admission. Security `34083472830`, CodeQL PR `34083472892`, Semgrep `34083472922`, Python Security `34083377117`, Agent Review Runtime Quality `34083377126`, scheduler `34083473304`, Noema `34083473285`, OpenCode `34083473338`, and Strix `34083473249` remain queued. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and qualifying independent review remain merge gates. | +| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `64d19495095f42c292675dac9d7b73e8a6316d58`, tree `212153594cf4d90a9efb2e14526f408aa7634210`, stacked on `.github#1938@056226c56eff8c1aa01d29722f14c9820b97438d`, twelve scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract/doctoring paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, preserve executing same-head evidence across Draft/Ready/dispatch, wait for stale-run cleanup before launching the replacement provider, query/cancel central workflow runs at the run-owning repository while reading live PR state from the target repository, and retain protected-ref push coalescing with cancellation authority only for a newer push | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** Exact-head review found that the replacement provider could start before cleanup and that cleanup omitted stale `repository_dispatch` runs. RED reproduced both defects and the cross-repository ownership mismatch. GREEN is six focused lifecycle/cleanup tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,045 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests, statement/branch coverage 100% (`13,251` statements and `5,362` branches, zero miss/partial), and public-doc coverage 100%; `bash -n` and diff check are clean. The repair covers native and dispatched runs, separates target-repository PR reads from central run queries/cancellations, and gates provider start on cleanup success or skip. The stack is behind 0 and mergeable with zero unresolved threads; Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T05:39:30Z` only for review admission. Security `34087645347`, CodeQL PR `34087645423`, and Semgrep `34087645342` are queued, while push Semgrep `34087573459` is in progress; none is promoted to GREEN. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and qualifying independent review remain merge gates. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | | Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, partially GREEN.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Native CodeQL `34076849581` and CI `34076849582` are terminal success; Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` remain queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no separate local Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. | @@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ by the consuming product. 1. Prove a same-repository terminal dispatch receipt under the repaired actor setting tracked by `.github#1929`, then repair and prove the separate cross-repository HTTP 403 status path without weakening actor=sender. -2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and stacked `.github#1999@86aa8b79` acquire exact-head +2. Let `.github#1902@4b025af4` and stacked `.github#1999@64d19495` acquire exact-head hosted checks and independent review; neither Ready transition is approval or merge authority, and no auto-merge change is recorded here. 3. Revalidate `fast-mlsirm#1692` on its unchanged head after the owner repair, From ac2644b6fa384c2c18f814facb3e563704b4eb3d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Seongho Bae Date: Mon, 7 Sep 2026 14:44:47 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 110/110] docs(product-gap): record Ready-event check replacement --- docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md index 688cbc6e5..b5229f7d4 100644 --- a/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md +++ b/docs/product-technical-gap-live-refresh-2026-09-07.md @@ -46,7 +46,7 @@ latest immutable release have not moved since the 2026-09-05 supplement. | Actions queue measurement and workflow-waste evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1905` exact head `fcdb8dfe6951704cce688ec2e3756837b04bd71c`, two-parent reconciled on current #1903 `f4ff7f8c025c4d0a15145c3cd634d96c92326ec3`, one ledger path | Preserve the 35-workflow static observations while distinguishing a modeled admission ceiling from observed concurrent occupancy and a measured lower bound; continue capacity investigation and required-context-preserving graph repair in parallel | **Ready stacked evidence, not protected authority.** Current #1903 is an ancestor (`behind_by=0`); the contradicted global conclusions remain removed or bounded, and the residual literal `job\\namong` formatting defect is repaired. Exact-head baseline contracts are 5 passed and diff check is clean. Ready review admission was restored on the unchanged head at `2026-09-07T03:16:43Z`; CodeQL PR `34079111710`, Semgrep `34079111737`, and Security `34079111714` are queued. The predecessor-head CHANGES_REQUESTED review does not transfer; independent current-head review and ordinary stacked integration remain pending. | | Review and CodeQL dispatch identity | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1929`; actor canary run `34069437294`; earlier cross-repository status failures `34017996201` and `34018021069` | Preserve actor=sender=one reviewed identity; prove a same-repository terminal canary and repair the separate cross-repository status credential without widening trust | **Actor admission repaired; issue remains open.** Live configuration now admits both `github-actions[bot]` and `opencode-agent[bot]`, and the canary passed actor validation before a later live-head mismatch. No same-repository terminal receipt is yet proven, while the cross-repository publication path still has HTTP 403 evidence. | | CodeQL rerun recovery, live-base binding, terminal receipt, and SARIF evidence boundary | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1902` exact head `4b025af481f3a4fb0bdb4d400a7e055066a496a2`, tree `f0fa29d998727d9c8720cf2921611ff463667377`, nine CodeQL-owned paths | Require a trusted creator plus exact base/head/language/workflow/run receipt before consuming terminal status; ignore old-base status and redispatch once as `verdict=pending`; validate live/event base; require the same shard's SARIF upload outcome to be `success` before terminal publication or wake | **Ready for review admission; not merge-authorized.** A new CodeRabbit CWE-345 finding was reproduced and repaired. The requested old-base-only fixture proves pending redispatch; CodeRabbit confirmed the finding addressed and the sole thread is resolved. Exact-tree verification: 57 focused tests normally and 57 with `GITHUB_ACTIONS=true`; repository 3,005 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests; statement/branch coverage and public-doc coverage 100%; diff check clean. Local actionlint was unavailable, so predecessor evidence is not transferred. The Ready event admitted replacement runs `34077606247`, `34077606217`, `34077606226`, and `34077606207`, all queued/pending. Hosted GREEN and qualifying independent approval remain merge gates, not Ready prerequisites. No auto-merge action was taken. | -| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `64d19495095f42c292675dac9d7b73e8a6316d58`, tree `212153594cf4d90a9efb2e14526f408aa7634210`, stacked on `.github#1938@056226c56eff8c1aa01d29722f14c9820b97438d`, twelve scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract/doctoring paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, preserve executing same-head evidence across Draft/Ready/dispatch, wait for stale-run cleanup before launching the replacement provider, query/cancel central workflow runs at the run-owning repository while reading live PR state from the target repository, and retain protected-ref push coalescing with cancellation authority only for a newer push | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** Exact-head review found that the replacement provider could start before cleanup and that cleanup omitted stale `repository_dispatch` runs. RED reproduced both defects and the cross-repository ownership mismatch. GREEN is six focused lifecycle/cleanup tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,045 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests, statement/branch coverage 100% (`13,251` statements and `5,362` branches, zero miss/partial), and public-doc coverage 100%; `bash -n` and diff check are clean. The repair covers native and dispatched runs, separates target-repository PR reads from central run queries/cancellations, and gates provider start on cleanup success or skip. The stack is behind 0 and mergeable with zero unresolved threads; Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T05:39:30Z` only for review admission. Security `34087645347`, CodeQL PR `34087645423`, and Semgrep `34087645342` are queued, while push Semgrep `34087573459` is in progress; none is promoted to GREEN. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and qualifying independent review remain merge gates. | +| Scheduler live-PR, Strix rerun identity, and lifecycle evidence preservation | `ContextualWisdomLab/.github#1999` exact head `64d19495095f42c292675dac9d7b73e8a6316d58`, tree `212153594cf4d90a9efb2e14526f408aa7634210`, stacked on `.github#1938@056226c56eff8c1aa01d29722f14c9820b97438d`, twelve scheduler/Strix/workflow-contract/doctoring paths | Require an explicitly open live PR, bind reruns to the verified failed Strix job, preserve executing same-head evidence across Draft/Ready/dispatch, wait for stale-run cleanup before launching the replacement provider, query/cancel central workflow runs at the run-owning repository while reading live PR state from the target repository, and retain protected-ref push coalescing with cancellation authority only for a newer push | **Ready for review admission; no auto-merge authorization.** Exact-head review found that the replacement provider could start before cleanup and that cleanup omitted stale `repository_dispatch` runs. RED reproduced both defects and the cross-repository ownership mismatch. GREEN is six focused lifecycle/cleanup tests, the focused Strix shell contract, repository 3,045 passed / 1 skipped / 21 subtests, statement/branch coverage 100% (`13,251` statements and `5,362` branches, zero miss/partial), and public-doc coverage 100%; `bash -n` and diff check are clean. The repair covers native and dispatched runs, separates target-repository PR reads from central run queries/cancellations, and gates provider start on cleanup success or skip. The stack is behind 0 and mergeable with zero unresolved threads; Ready was restored at `2026-09-07T05:39:30Z` only for review admission. Ready-event Security `34087645347`, CodeQL PR `34087645423`, and Semgrep `34087645342` are queued; the earlier push runs, including Semgrep `34087573459`, were cancelled after the Ready event, and none is promoted to GREEN. Local actionlint was unavailable; hosted workflow validation and qualifying independent review remain merge gates. | | Immutable release SBOM and provenance | `fast-mlsirm#1692` exact head `a6ac0f49d5123244fe89f26748a65f551ad9d514`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 12 changed files | Restore an authenticated current-head CodeQL dispatch verdict at the central owner, obtain a qualifying approval on the unchanged current head, then ordinary merge and release verification | **Source-ready, control-plane blocked.** Repository CI, native CodeQL, Security Scan, Semgrep, mergeability, and all review threads are GREEN/resolved. `CodeQL PR` run `34020936743` fails closed because a rerun has no authenticated terminal verdict; predecessor approval does not transfer. | | Rust-owned local-dependence public API | `fast-mlsirm#1748` exact head `ef2dd4baa11027c43fccc448a8eb07e4dca6e104`, protected base `493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, 14 changed files | Re-fetch current-head scientific recovery, public-contract, coverage, security, and independent-review evidence before merge | **Ready and mergeable; not yet revalidated in this supplement.** The prior supplement's older head and checks are historical only. | | Rust covariance-standardization stack | `fast-mlsirm#1722` exact head `28b0305595107fd0ba21d7b27c1ac5db68ae8bf1`, direct protected base `main@493326f2de49ea1704da0ded19868ed05d2fe00f`, five changed files | Preserve the Rust production owner and reacquire exact-head numerical recovery, formatting, security, CodeQL, and independent-review evidence before ordinary integration | **Non-force reconciled, behind 0, partially GREEN.** The prior `b5a3a0c1` value was an older protected-main SHA, not a live stacked base. Current `main` was merged normally and a changelog fragment was added. Native CodeQL `34076849581` and CI `34076849582` are terminal success; Semgrep `34076849554`, CodeQL PR `34076849542`, ClusterFuzzLite `34076849579`, and Security `34076849578` remain queued. The local environment has no Cargo, so no separate local Rust test or formatting GREEN is claimed; predecessor evidence and approval do not transfer. |