RC8: integrate certified #292 runtime recovery fixes - #298
Conversation
Jumpstile
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Independent adversarial review from Oh My Pi recorded as HOLD. Source identity matched the certified SHA and no certified-head mismatch was found. Integration remains blocked pending: (1) exact-head CI completion, (2) release-gate acceptance of this review, (3) decision on whether PR #295/#294 governance cleanup is part of the accepted RC8 source, (4) #290 live documentation/wiki freshness completion, and (5) RC8 identity/version transition plus final package/release integrity evidence. Exact-head CI run 32787088125 has since completed successfully; that specific blocker is now resolved. Do not merge or package until the remaining blockers are explicitly dispositioned.
Release-gate disposition after Oh My Pi adversarial review: HOLDThe independent adversarial review is accepted into the gate record. Source identity for the current PR head passed: One blocker has since cleared: exact-head CI run Remaining blockers before integration/release:
Release-gate decision: do not merge PR #298 yet. Rather than create another intermediate SHA and recertify repeatedly, assemble the final RC8 integration candidate once, then certify that final source. No package, tag, release, publication, wiki update, or Scripts mirror is authorized by this disposition. |
Desktop reviewer integration review: PASS; overall RC8 release gate remains HOLDDesktop reviewer independently verified the current PR #298 integration state at exact head SHA Passes
DispositionThe integration review itself passes. However, overall RC8 merge/release disposition remains HOLD because #290 live documentation/wiki freshness remains incomplete, and the accepted Oh My Pi adversarial review identified additional release-phase blockers that still require explicit disposition before final RC8 source/package acceptance (notably final RC8 identity/version transition and final source-set decision including #295/#294 governance cleanup). Do not merge/package/tag/release/publish/update wiki/mirror Scripts yet. |
Round ownership change: Oh My Pi implementing final RC8 remediationFor this round, the implementation/remediation role is explicitly assigned to Oh My Pi, not Desktop reviewer. Desktop reviewer's completed PR #298 integration review remains valid evidence for the current certified head. Arcade reviewer remains certification-only and should stay idle until a new final RC8 integration candidate exists. Oh My Pi is authorized this round to assemble the final RC8 candidate on a new branch from current
Do not merge #298 in place and do not mutate the already-certified branch while claiming its certification still applies. Produce a new exact candidate SHA, validate it, and report all changed files/conflict resolutions. Live wiki updates, packaging, tagging, release publication, and Scripts mirror remain unauthorized until the new candidate clears review, #290, CI, and guarded ARCADE certification. |
Purpose
Integrate the guarded-ARCADE-certified RC8 #292 candidate into
main.Certified source identity
review/rc8-package-runtime-ux-fixes92f17207ddb30cd0b0fc75cb346453d20613f92000dc82fce3a0641a894354811bd0e02c4truefalse43ce860bf1a6d887ddc050292f2b8e71d26b5ab718fedc8460882bc426b17bc4Why this PR is required now
The certified SHA currently has no GitHub check runs because CI runs on pushes to
mainor pull requests targetingmain/ the RC8 review branch. Opening this PR againstmainshould provide the required exact-head-SHA CI evidence without changing the certified commit.Release boundary
This PR does not authorize publication. Before merge/release disposition:
No package, tag, release, publication, wiki update, or Scripts mirror is performed by opening this PR.
Closes/relates to #292; keep #292 open until its remaining package-identity/release bookkeeping is satisfied.