Skip to content

Commit daa70d9

Browse files
authored
Merge pull request #2 from MrScripty/implementation/authoring-publication-evidence-a1
feat(standards): clarify publication and preflight evidence
2 parents 149ba31 + 8260489 commit daa70d9

37 files changed

Lines changed: 4474 additions & 178 deletions

‎docs/plans/README.md‎

Lines changed: 15 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,8 +1,11 @@
11
# Active Repository Work
22

33
[Standards Library Effectiveness Restructure](standards-library-effectiveness/plan.md)
4-
is the explicitly active plan. Remaining work includes manual semantic-ownership
5-
reviews D001–D010, downstream pilots, migration publication, and final acceptance.
4+
remains active for manual semantic-ownership reviews D001–D010, downstream pilots,
5+
migration publication, and final acceptance. [Authoring Publication and Evidence
6+
Clarity](authoring-publication-evidence/plan.md) is also active, beginning with its
7+
A1 publication-observation and early-evidence slice. These plans own separate
8+
objectives; neither changes the other's acceptance state.
69

710
- [Current plan and next slice](standards-library-effectiveness/plan.md)
811
- [Execution ledger](standards-library-effectiveness/execution-ledger.md)
@@ -13,6 +16,16 @@ Completed prerequisites do not close the parent objective. See the
1316
[archive](../archive/README.md) for accepted and superseded plans, and the
1417
[decision index](../decisions/README.md) for current architecture.
1518

19+
## Authoring Publication and Evidence Clarity
20+
21+
[Authoring Publication and Evidence Clarity](authoring-publication-evidence/plan.md)
22+
owns publication receipts, fresh checkout observations, early evidence failures,
23+
explicit evidence binding, guarded reconciliation, and focused blocker/reuse
24+
explanations. A1 implementation is complete and in final verification; later
25+
milestones remain Planned with their separate gates. Begin A2 only after A1 is
26+
accepted and merged to `main`. The plan preserves existing publication
27+
authorization and records each acceptance claim at its current evidence state.
28+
1629
## Accepted Agent Interface Work
1730

1831
[Standards Agent Interface](standards-agent-interface/plan.md) delivers focused

‎docs/plans/authoring-publication-evidence/execution-ledger.md‎

Lines changed: 324 additions & 0 deletions
Large diffs are not rendered by default.
Lines changed: 23 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
1+
# Authoring Publication and Evidence Clarity — issues
2+
3+
These issues are new observations or explicit design gates. Existing accepted
4+
refactors and historical external-review decisions remain unchanged.
5+
6+
| ID | Type | Disposition and owner |
7+
| --- | --- | --- |
8+
| B0 | Baseline CI / fixture | Resolved in A1 with a test-owned unexposed standard and unchanged Security exposure. Direct and warm-cache fixture cases pass on the committed candidate; no hosted exact-candidate CI result is claimed. |
9+
| F1 | Publication reporting | Resolved in A1: apply, recovery, and status expose durable receipt facts separately from read-only checkout/index observations. Checkout reconciliation writes remain A3. |
10+
| F2 | Evidence phase binding | Resolved for repository-content@1 in A1: side-effect-free preflight catches destination mismatch before readiness, while final apply repeats the check. A2 adds explicitly bound immutable artifacts. |
11+
| F3 | Diagnostics | Resolved in A1: the evidence producer reports phase/reference/digest/source context; legacy path/field/observed details are bounded for authoring and omitted for application purpose. |
12+
| F4 | Focused reuse | One unchanged obligation requires a new submission because focused revise omits prior Analysis reuse. Existing helper passed the real successor in memory. A4 composes it; final readiness is never copied. |
13+
| F5 | Exposure explanation | Confirmed Router needs-review is hidden by generic preview rejection. A4 retains denial and exposes only authoring-permitted blocker context. |
14+
| G1 | Evidence carrier proof | Proposed self-contained bundle keeps current four-field repository-content carrier. A2 must prove original-content provenance, exact validation, authorized export and cold receipt use before expansion. If incompatible, own a versioned redesign, not a source-label workaround. |
15+
| G2 | Reconciliation write ownership | Two-tree trials cover ordinary carry-forward and conflict refusal only. A3 must prove supported layouts, stale/partial outcomes and explicit cooperative ownership; no atomic multi-resource claim is made. |
16+
| G3 | Original run / model evidence | Original session handles/transcript and current live model are not available. Current-code reproductions are not a replay of that session. A5 owns a newly authorized comparable fixture run. |
17+
| G4 | Versions and old history | Actual persisted records constrain changes. Keep their source meaning and explicit version support; new bundle/intent kinds do not justify blanket migration or old-handle reset. |
18+
| D1 | Deferred UI/response ideas | No new short-ID resolver, larger eager catalog, universal schemas/examples tool, or automatic final-approval transfer. Consider only after measured remaining friction and a new admission. |
19+
20+
No acceptance claim is satisfied solely by the planning probes. No unrelated source
21+
repair or accepted plan is included. New findings during implementation are assigned
22+
to the existing owner/write set unless they alter scope, authority or retained
23+
meaning.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)