Skip to content

Commit c322e59

Browse files
logan-ncclaude
andcommitted
EXP - DOC - s28 complete: full-grid reference converged; certificate global-scale blindness identified
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LzbLFQKyuRE5DYZmLokKmk
1 parent c0a3447 commit c322e59

1 file changed

Lines changed: 19 additions & 2 deletions

File tree

handoff/issue376/RESULTS.md

Lines changed: 19 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1248,8 +1248,25 @@ raw-increment certificate ~20× (certify what the ODE consumes, post-Schur, inst
12481248
Frobenius core floor was derived for ideal ξ ~ ψ^|m|/2 and has no justification for kinetic
12491249
increments that grow toward the axis.
12501250

1251-
Pending: dense_off (psi_accuracy 3e-4, ~2× auto grid) — is the full-grid et[1] itself converged
1252-
with respect to the equilibrium grid?
1251+
1252+
### Convergence check closes the loop: the full-grid reference is converged, and the certificate's blind spot is identified
1253+
1254+
dense_off (psi_accuracy 3e-4 → 367-knot auto grid): et[1] = 1.005671 − 0.259474i — **1.6e-4 from
1255+
the 288-knot value** (steps 225,127, unchanged; structure-driven, confirmed a third time). The
1256+
full-grid DIII-D kinetic answer is therefore converged in kernel tolerance (2.7e-7) AND
1257+
equilibrium grid (1.6e-4); the certified grid's 14–17% deviation is unambiguously certification
1258+
error.
1259+
1260+
**Why the certificate is blind to it (the design flaw, now precisely identified)**: the residual
1261+
test is `max-element residual ≤ tol · max|T|` with max|T| the family's GLOBAL maximum. For G that
1262+
scale is 6.7e6 (edge/rational-dominated), while the near-axis increment is ~1e3 — only 1.6e-4 of
1263+
scale, far under any practical tol, so the core passes the certificate while being grossly
1264+
under-resolved. But the EL ODE responds to LOCAL derivative structure, and 94% of its work is
1265+
exactly there. The auto grid resolves it only coincidentally (its ideal-driven core packing lands
1266+
where the kinetic divergence lives). Fix candidates, pending the physics decision on near-axis
1267+
validity: a local (per-region or solution-amplitude-weighted) certificate scale, certifying the
1268+
post-Schur f0/K/G the ODE consumes, and dropping the ideal-derived Frobenius core floor for
1269+
kinetic increments.
12531270

12541271
## Implications / ranked follow-ups
12551272

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)