diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 64c5004..801c537 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -103,6 +103,11 @@ All notable changes to CableDyn are recorded in this file. The format follows Thorsen et al. (2017) use for it: dominant strain frequency 0.992 Hz against the measured 1.00 Hz, largest r.m.s. strain 7.3 % above the measured largest, station mean 3.6 % above; converged in mesh and time step to 0.2 %. +- Validation case L3-D (`validation/experiments/delta_flume`): cross-flow and in-line VIV of the + Delta Flume riser in the nine blind-trial stepped-current cases of Chaplin et al. (2005b), with + one generic coefficient set and the drag amplification on the in-line drag alone, against the + experimenters' measured envelopes and summaries: dominant mode right in 5 of 9 and within one in + all, mean in-line displacement within 17 % in 7 of 9, cross-flow amplitude −44 % to +4 %. - Theory manual, Published coefficient sets: the VIV coefficient sets of Thorsen et al. (2016, 2017), Ulveseter et al. (2018), Andersen et al. (2024a, b) and Facchinetti et al. (2004), each with its source, its test data and the line-type columns it maps to, and Thorsen et al.'s diff --git a/VALIDATION.md b/VALIDATION.md index 8ebb5fc..cdb2564 100644 --- a/VALIDATION.md +++ b/VALIDATION.md @@ -82,6 +82,7 @@ article's methods, are compared in | **L3-H** | Holcombe static lazy-wave experiment | measured marker geometry | position RMSE 1.07–1.89% of suspended length; peak marker-curvature error 0.34–5.54% | end-restraint bracket | Pass | | **L3-B** | Bergdahl chain experiment, 30 orbit conditions | measured upper-end force | RMSE 1.58 N; MAPE 3.11%; Pearson 0.993; Lin concordance 0.989 | full published matrix | Pass | | **L3-C** | Chaplin Delta Flume riser, still-water natural frequencies | measured modes 1–7 at five tensions | mean error +1.87%, mean absolute 2.28%, largest 4.88% (34 of 35; one outlier reported) | full published table, no fitted parameter | Pass | +| **L3-D** | Chaplin Delta Flume riser in a stepped current, blind-trial cases 1–9, cross-flow and in-line VIV | measured dominant mode, peak cross-flow amplitude, mean in-line displacement, curvature standard deviations | mode right in 5/9, within one in 9/9; mean in-line within ±17% in 7/9 (−25% to +34%); cross-flow amplitude −44% to +4%; cross-flow curvature −39% to +26% | generic coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass measured | | **L3-W** | SJTU steel catenary riser in 0.2 m/s current, cross-flow VIV | measured r.m.s. strain (25 stations) and dominant frequency | frequency 0.992 vs 1.00 Hz; max r.m.s. strain +7.3%, station mean +3.6% | published coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass | | **L-fig** | Along-arc curvature overlay (CableDyn / OrcaFlex / MoorDyn-F ±4×) | 3-code committed record | CableDyn peak 0.11% from OrcaFlex | <0.5% | Pass | | **L4-1** | Coupled platform + mooring | synthetic reference | bit-for-bit | — | Pass | @@ -339,6 +340,24 @@ scripts, results, and source provenance are in separately. 128 elements and ten times the unpublished axial stiffness change no frequency by more than 3e-6 and 1.2e-4. +- **L3-D Delta Flume riser, VIV in a stepped current** + ([Chaplin et al., 2005a](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-chaplin2005); + [Chaplin et al., 2005b](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-chaplin2005b)): + the nine blind-trial cases, the lower 5.94 m of the L3-C riser in 0.16–0.95 m/s, with the top + spring in series and the measured mean top tension set statically. One generic set for all + cases: cross-flow lift 0.8 (f̂0 0.18 ± 0.08), in-line C_x 0.85, α 0.15, C_D 1.2, and the drag + amplification of Chaplin et al. (2005a, Eq. 4) on the in-line drag alone (`VIV AMPLITUDE` with + `VIV DAMPING 0 0 1`). Against the experimenters' processed results, read from the vector + graphics of their blind-trial presentation: the dominant cross-flow mode is right in 5 of 9 + cases and within one in the rest; the largest mean in-line displacement is within ±17% in 7 of + 9 (+34% in case 2, −25% in case 9; the blind predictions under-predicted it by 20–40%); + the largest cross-flow amplitude is −44% to +4%, and the overall standard deviation of the + cross-flow curvature −39% to +26%. Half the time step and 128 elements leave the mode and + change the mean in-line displacement and the cross-flow curvature by at most 2.6% (the in-line + curvature by up to 10%), except in two cases: case 5 beats in the 40 s window (its peak + amplitude moves by up to 20%), and case 9 settles in mode 7 instead of 8 at half the time + step. + - **L3-W SJTU steel catenary riser, cross-flow VIV in uniform current** ([Wang et al., 2014](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-wang2014); [Thorsen et al., 2017](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-thorsen2017)): diff --git a/doc/references.rst b/doc/references.rst index 2bba3c4..9850119 100644 --- a/doc/references.rst +++ b/doc/references.rst @@ -286,6 +286,14 @@ Verification and validation references *Journal of Fluids and Structures* **21**\ (1), 3–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010 +.. _ref-chaplin2005b: + +- **Chaplin, J. R., Bearman, P. W., Cheng, Y., Fontaine, E., Graham, J. M. R., Herfjord, K., + Huera Huarte, F. J., Isherwood, M., Lambrakos, K., Larsen, C. M., Meneghini, J. R., Moe, G., + Pattenden, R. J., Triantafyllou, M. S. & Willden, R. H. J. (2005).** Blind predictions of + laboratory measurements of vortex-induced vibrations of a tension riser. *Journal of Fluids and + Structures* **21**\ (1), 25–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.05.016 + Comparison codes ---------------- diff --git a/doc/theory.rst b/doc/theory.rst index 857d5bc..109f523 100644 --- a/doc/theory.rst +++ b/doc/theory.rst @@ -1451,7 +1451,7 @@ The row serves two uses: - With :math:`(0, 0, 1)` and the drag factor of :ref:`Chaplin et al. (2005) `, the amplification acts on the mean in-line drag alone, as measured, while the cross-flow drag - stays Morison's. + stays Morison's (validation case L3-D, the Delta Flume riser in a stepped current). - :math:`(0.31, 0.89, 0)` is Thorsen's cross-flow model. It drops the linear part :math:`\tfrac12\rho D C_{dn}U\dot y` of Morison's cross-flow damping, so it is consistent with cross-flow VIV alone. An in-line force that turns with the relative flow can then drive an diff --git a/validation/README.md b/validation/README.md index 2e17086..b8612bf 100644 --- a/validation/README.md +++ b/validation/README.md @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ redistributed. | [`RELEASE_0_1_1.md`](RELEASE_0_1_1.md) | The same for v0.1.1 | | [`RELEASE_0_1_0.md`](RELEASE_0_1_0.md) | The same for v0.1.0 | | [`bodies/`](bodies/README.md) | Rigid-body, rod and shared-anchor cases with MoorDyn-C twins, stored references and pass limits | -| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV comparisons | +| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, and Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV comparisons | | [`PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md`](PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md) | Wall time of CableDyn 0.1.0, MoorDyn-C and MoorDyn-F at equal accuracy on five mooring, cable, buoy and coupled cases | | [`performance/`](performance/README.md) | Same-host wall-clock records of the L5 cases: the resolved lazy-wave spans, the one-hour VolturnUS-S mooring and the tension-only chain | | [`PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md`](PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md) | Every CableDyn result in the journal article, re-run with the release defaults and in paper mode | diff --git a/validation/experiments/README.md b/validation/experiments/README.md index 997d8c3..0aa20eb 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/README.md +++ b/validation/experiments/README.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ # Experimental comparisons -This directory lets reviewers reproduce CableDyn's comparisons with four published physical +This directory lets reviewers reproduce CableDyn's comparisons with five published physical experiments. Each subdirectory gives the data source, the translation of the published parameters into a CableDyn model, the assessed quantity, the reproduction commands and the committed results. @@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ committed results. | [`holcombe/`](holcombe/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025), 1:70 static lazy-wave cable | Finite-EI power cable | | [`bergdahl/`](bergdahl/README.md) | Bergdahl et al. (2016), 33 m dynamically scaled chain | Tension-only mooring chain | | [`chaplin/`](chaplin/README.md) | Chaplin et al. (2005), 13.12 m vertical tension riser, still-water natural frequencies | Finite-EI riser, modal analysis | +| [`delta_flume/`](delta_flume/README.md) | Chaplin et al. (2005), 13.12 m vertical tension riser, stepped current, blind-trial cases 1–9 | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV, cross-flow and in-line | | [`wang_scr/`](wang_scr/README.md) | Wang et al. (2014), truncated steel catenary riser in uniform current, cross-flow VIV | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | -The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C and L3-W in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). +The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D and L3-W in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/README.md b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..af9b45f --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,130 @@ + + +# Delta Flume vertical riser in a stepped current: cross-flow and in-line VIV + +This directory compares CableDyn's VIV with the nine blind-trial cases of the Delta Flume riser +tests. Chaplin et al. (2005a), , describe the +riser and the tests, and Chaplin et al. (2005b), +, the blind predictions made for them. The +lower 5.94 m of the 13.12 m riser is in a uniform current of 0.16–0.95 m/s, the rest in still +water. The VIV coefficients are a generic set; nothing is fitted to these measurements. The +still-water natural frequencies of the same riser are case L3-C +([`../chaplin`](../chaplin/README.md)). + +## Model and data + +- **Riser:** as L3-C: 13.12 m between pinned joints, D 28 mm, EI 29.9 N m², mass ratio 3.0 with + the internal water (1.847 kg/m), fresh water, C_a 1. From the project's mechanical-properties + page (University of Southampton, archived; `provenance.json`): EA 5.88 MN, structural damping + 0.33 % of critical, top spring 11.4 kN/m. +- **Top spring:** in series with the riser, one effective axial stiffness + EA_eff = L/(1/k + L/EA) = 1.459e5 N. The unstretched length of each case is iterated until the + static top tension in the current is the case's mean top tension. A rigid top would turn the + current's bow into tension (1799 N instead of 1002 N in case 9) and stiffen the riser. +- **Current:** the towing speed U over the lower 5.94 m (the bottom of the carriage's vacuum + tank), still water above, with a 2 cm linear step between them. +- **Cases (slide 3 of the presentation below):** + + | Case | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | + | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | + | U (m/s) | 0.16 | 0.21 | 0.31 | 0.40 | 0.54 | 0.60 | 0.70 | 0.85 | 0.95 | + | Mean top tension (N) | 405 | 407 | 457 | 506 | 598 | 670 | 743 | 923 | 1002 | + | Std of top tension (N) | 2 | 3 | 3 | 8 | 15 | 14 | 8 | 14 | 65 | + +- **VIV (all cases):** + - synchronisation lift C_l 0.8 in the band f̂0 0.18 ± 0.08; + - in-line force C_x 0.85, α 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018); + - C_D 1.2; + - a `VIV AMPLITUDE` table with C_v 0.8 constant and the drag amplification of Chaplin et al. + (2005a, Eq. 4), CdAmp = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s², s = (A/D)/√2, at A/D 0–1.5; + - `VIV DAMPING` `0 0 1`: the amplification acts on the in-line drag only, and the cross-flow drag + stays Morison's. +- **Measurements:** the experimenters' processed results, from their presentation of the blind + trial (Chaplin et al., Trondheim, October 2004). The slides are vector graphics, so the values are + the plotted coordinates mapped through the tick labels, not a pixel digitisation: + - `measured_summary.csv`, from slides 17–19: maximum cross-flow displacement, maximum mean and + maximum dynamic in-line displacement (in D), and the overall standard deviation of the in-line + and cross-flow curvature (κD). Its `U` column is the speed read from each point; it matches + the tabulated speed within 0.006 m/s, which checks the axis mapping. + - `envelopes/`: the measured envelopes along the riser of each case (slides 7–15), with their + columns, checks and the assumed curvature scale in [`envelopes/README.md`](envelopes/README.md). + - The dominant cross-flow mode numbers 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 6, 7, 7, 7 (slide 23). +- **Assumed:** the 11.4 kN/m top spring (the page also lists 38.1 kN/m, without saying which tests + used which); the 0.33 % structural damping as bending damping of a pure bending mode at 2 Hz (the + page gives no frequency). +- **CableDyn:** 64 elements; dt the largest of 5, 2.5, 2, 1 and 0.5 ms at or below 1/200 of the + shedding period D/(0.18 U) (2.5 ms in cases 1–3, 1 ms in 4–7, 0.5 ms in 8–9); `VIVrmsWindow` + 0.25 s; 40 s, statistics over t > 15 s. +- **Metrics:** x is in-line and y cross-flow, both from the line between the joints. + - dominant cross-flow mode: the pinned-pinned sine with the largest r.m.s. projection of y; + - maximum cross-flow amplitude: the largest half peak-to-peak of y along the riser, against the + slide-18 maximum; + - maximum mean in-line displacement: the largest time mean of x; + - dominant cross-flow frequency (`response_comparison.csv` only): the spectral peak of y a + quarter of the length above the lower joint, at a resolution of 0.04 Hz; + - overall standard deviation of curvature: the r.m.s. over the nodes of the standard deviation + of the curvature (second differences of the node positions), times D. + +## Reproduce + +From the repository root, with `path/to/cabledyn.exe` the release executable or a local build: + +```powershell +python validation/experiments/delta_flume/delta_flume_viv.py ` + path/to/cabledyn.exe validation/experiments/delta_flume/work ` + --summary validation/experiments/delta_flume +``` + +The nine cases run in parallel (`--jobs`), in about two minutes on a 24-core workstation. `--cases` +(for example `5,9`) selects cases; `--segments`, `--dt-scale` and `--spring` change the mesh, the +time step and the top spring. + +## Results + +CableDyn / measured; the measured cross-flow amplitude is the slide-18 maximum, with the half +peak-to-peak of the measured envelope in brackets. + +| Case | U (m/s) | Mode | A_CF/D | Mean IL/D | Std κD, CF | Std κD, IL | Mean top tension (N) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1 | 0.16 | 2 / 2 | 0.653 / 0.757 (0.763) | 1.19 / 1.06 | 5.7e-5 / 9.3e-5 | 3.5e-5 / 5.0e-5 | 409 / 405 | +| 2 | 0.21 | 3 / 3 | 0.601 / 0.579 (0.561) | 1.60 / 1.19 | 1.12e-4 / 0.89e-4 | 7.2e-5 / 3.4e-5 | 413 / 407 | +| 3 | 0.31 | 4 / 4 | 0.629 / 0.779 (0.809) | 3.27 / 3.45 | 2.06e-4 / 2.70e-4 | 0.91e-4 / 1.95e-4 | 476 / 457 | +| 4 | 0.40 | **4** / 5 | 0.692 / 0.674 (0.595) | 4.78 / 4.97 | 2.30e-4 / 3.18e-4 | 1.37e-4 / 2.69e-4 | 541 / 506 | +| 5 | 0.54 | 6 / 6 | 0.779 / 0.843 (0.889) | 6.39 / 6.69 | 4.10e-4 / 4.81e-4 | 2.10e-4 / 2.31e-4 | 656 / 598 | +| 6 | 0.60 | 6 / 6 | 0.606 / 0.709 (0.779) | 6.78 / 8.13 | 4.39e-4 / 4.77e-4 | 2.57e-4 / 4.57e-4 | 734 / 670 | +| 7 | 0.70 | **6** / 7 | 0.737 / 0.777 (0.717) | 8.32 / 8.90 | 4.68e-4 / 6.47e-4 | 2.64e-4 / 3.03e-4 | 836 / 743 | +| 8 | 0.85 | **6** / 7 | 0.781 / 0.907 (0.890) | 9.65 / 11.18 | 4.91e-4 / 6.89e-4 | 2.99e-4 / 4.48e-4 | 1046 / 923 | +| 9 | 0.95 | **8** / 7 | 0.599 / 1.074 (0.996) | 10.16 / 13.51 | 6.88e-4 / 7.36e-4 | 3.70e-4 / 6.24e-4 | 1128 / 1002 | + +- **Dominant cross-flow mode:** right in 5 of 9 cases and within one in the other four (one low in + cases 4, 7 and 8, one high in case 9). Four of the eleven blind predictions found 7 or 8 of the 9 + (slide 24). +- **Mean in-line displacement:** within ±17 % in 7 of 9 cases; +34 % in case 2, where the + measured maximum is 1.2 D, and −25 % in case 9. The blind predictions under-predicted the drag + amplification, and with it the mean in-line displacement, by 20–40 % (slide 26). +- **Cross-flow amplitude:** −44 % to +4 % against the slide-18 maxima (−40 % to +16 % against + the envelopes), within ±12 %, the scatter between the two measured values, in cases 2, 4, 5 + and 7. The −44 % of case 9 goes with the response in mode 8. +- **Curvature:** the cross-flow standard deviation is −39 % to +26 %, low in every case but 2 + (−6 % to −29 % in cases 3–9); the in-line one −53 % to +110 %. The blind predictions' r.m.s. + curvatures were 20 % to 180 % of the measured (slide 26). +- **Top tension:** the static top tension in the current is the measured mean, but the drag + amplification bows the riser further: the mean top tension of the run is 1–13 % above the + measured mean (7–13 % in cases 4–9), so the run is stiffer than the test at the higher + speeds. +- **Convergence (`provenance.json`):** + - cases 1–4 and 6–8: half the time step leaves the mode and changes the mean in-line + displacement and the cross-flow curvature standard deviation by at most 0.6 %, the peak + amplitude by at most 4.5 % and the in-line curvature by at most 10 % (case 8); 128 elements + leave the mode and change them by at most 2.6 %, 4.2 % and 9 %; + - case 5 beats in the 40 s window: its peak amplitude changes by −17 % and −20 % and its + in-line curvature by −10 % and +25 %, while the other metrics move by at most 9 %; + - case 9 has two responses: at half the time step it settles in mode 7 (5.80 Hz, A/D 0.725, + mean in-line displacement 10.63 D), with the base step and with 128 elements in mode 8 + (6.60 Hz), which an 80 s run keeps. +- **Top spring 38.1 kN/m (`--spring 38.1e3`):** the mean top tension of the run is up to 14 % + higher and the mean in-line displacement 2–16 % lower, within ±17 % in 4 of 9 cases; the mode + is right in 5 of 9 (case 9 in mode 7, case 5 in mode 5, case 8 in mode 5). + +`response_comparison.csv` holds the per-case values with their errors, and `summary.json` the +statistics and the SHA-256 of the executable. diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/delta_flume_viv.py b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/delta_flume_viv.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c80fe90 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/delta_flume_viv.py @@ -0,0 +1,451 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""Cross-flow and in-line VIV of the Delta Flume vertical tension riser, blind-trial cases 1-9. + +The nine stepped-current cases of the blind-prediction trial of Chaplin et al. (2005b): the lower +5.94 m of the 13.12 m riser in a uniform current of 0.16-0.95 m/s, the rest in still water. +Writes a deck per case, sets its unstretched length so that the static top tension in the current +is the case's measured mean, runs it, and compares with the measured response: the dominant +cross-flow mode, the largest cross-flow amplitude, the largest mean in-line deflection and the +overall standard deviations of the in-line and cross-flow curvature. + + python delta_flume_viv.py path/to/cabledyn.exe WORKDIR [--cases 1-9] [--segments 64] + [--dt-scale 1] [--tmax 40] [--t0 15] [--spring 11.4e3] [--jobs N] [--summary DIR] + +Sources: + J.R. Chaplin, P.W. Bearman, F.J. Huera Huarte, R.J. Pattenden (2005a), Laboratory measurements + of vortex-induced vibrations of a vertical tension riser in a stepped current, Journal of Fluids + and Structures 21(1), 3-24, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010 (the riser; + Eq. 4, the drag amplification) + J.R. Chaplin, P.W. Bearman, Y. Cheng, E. Fontaine, J.M.R. Graham, K. Herfjord, F.J. Huera + Huarte, M. Isherwood, K. Lambrakos, C.M. Larsen, J.R. Meneghini, G. Moe, R.J. Pattenden, + M.S. Triantafyllou, R.H.J. Willden (2005b), Blind predictions of laboratory measurements of + vortex-induced vibrations of a tension riser, Journal of Fluids and Structures 21(1), 25-40, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.05.016 (the blind-trial cases; the measured + results are those of the authors' presentation of the trial, Trondheim, October 2004) + The project's pages at the University of Southampton (archived): the mechanical properties + (mass, structural damping, axial and top-spring stiffness) and the current zone +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import csv +import hashlib +import json +import math +import os +import shutil +import subprocess +from concurrent.futures import ThreadPoolExecutor +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent + +# The riser (Chaplin et al. 2005a, Sec. 2; the Southampton mechanical-properties page): 13.12 m +# between pinned joints, D 28 mm, EI 29.9 N m^2, mass ratio 3.0 with the internal water +# (1.847 kg/m; the page gives 1.85 kg/m and the 12.1 N/m submerged weight), EA 5.88 MN, +# structural damping 0.33 % of critical, top spring 11.4 kN/m (the page gives 11.4 or 38.1). +LENGTH = 13.12 # m +DIAMETER = 0.028 # m +EI = 29.9 # N m^2 +EA_RISER = 5.88e6 # N +MASS_RATIO = 3.0 +RHO_W = 1000.0 # kg/m^3, fresh water +GRAVITY = 9.80665 # m/s^2 +AREA = math.pi * DIAMETER**2 / 4.0 +MASS = MASS_RATIO * RHO_W * AREA # kg/m +SUBMERGED_WEIGHT = (MASS - RHO_W * AREA) * GRAVITY # N/m +ZETA = 0.0033 # structural damping ratio, as bending damping of a pure bending mode at F_REF +F_REF = 2.0 # Hz (the frequency of the measured damping is not given) +CURRENT_HEIGHT = 5.94 # m: the current zone above the lower joint, still water above +Z_BOTTOM = -14.0 # m, lower joint; the top joint at Z_BOTTOM + LENGTH +WATER_DEPTH = 20.0 # m + +# Blind-trial cases (presentation slide 3): towing speed [m/s] and mean top tension [N] +CASES: dict[int, tuple[float, float]] = { + 1: (0.16, 405.0), + 2: (0.21, 407.0), + 3: (0.31, 457.0), + 4: (0.40, 506.0), + 5: (0.54, 598.0), + 6: (0.60, 670.0), + 7: (0.70, 743.0), + 8: (0.85, 923.0), + 9: (0.95, 1002.0), +} +# Measured dominant cross-flow mode numbers (slide 23) +MEASURED_MODES = {1: 2, 2: 3, 3: 4, 4: 5, 5: 6, 6: 6, 7: 7, 8: 7, 9: 7} + +# VIV set, not fitted to these measurements: synchronisation lift Cl 0.8 in the band +# cF 0.18 +- dF 0.08; in-line force ClX 0.85, alpha 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018); Cd 1.2, Ca 1. +CD, CA, CL, DF, CF = 1.2, 1.0, 0.8, 0.08, 0.18 +CLX, ALPHA = 0.85, 0.15 +CV = 0.8 # the VIV AMPLITUDE table holds Cv = Cl constant +VIV_RMS_WINDOW = 0.25 # s, the same averaging time at every dtM + + +def trapezoid_rows(f: np.ndarray, x: np.ndarray) -> np.ndarray: + """Trapezoidal integral of each row of f over x (NumPy 1.x has no np.trapezoid).""" + return 0.5 * ((f[:, 1:] + f[:, :-1]) * np.diff(x)).sum(axis=1) + + +def drag_amplification(ad: float) -> float: + """Chaplin et al. (2005a, Eq. 4): Cd/Cd0 = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s^2, s = (A/D)/sqrt(2).""" + s = ad / math.sqrt(2.0) + return 1.0 + 2.3 * s + 1.7 * s * s + + +def effective_ea(spring: float) -> float: + """The top spring in series with the riser, as one axial stiffness of the line.""" + return LENGTH / (1.0 / spring + LENGTH / EA_RISER) + + +def time_step(u: float, scale: float) -> float: + """The largest round step at or below 1/200 of the shedding period D/(cF U), times scale.""" + target = DIAMETER / (CF * u) / 200.0 + base = max(s for s in (0.005, 0.0025, 0.002, 0.001, 0.0005) if s <= target) + return base * scale + + +def deck_text( + case: int, l0: float, segments: int, dt: float, tmax: float, ea: float +) -> str: + u, t_top = CASES[case] + amp = "".join( + f"riser {ad:.2f} {CV} {drag_amplification(ad):.5f}\n" + for ad in (0.1 * k for k in range(16)) + ) + return f"""--------------------- CableDyn Input File --------------------------------- +Delta Flume riser, blind-trial case {case}: U {u} m/s, top tension {t_top:g} N +----------------------- LINE TYPES ------------------------------------------ +TypeName Diam Mass EA BA EI Cd_n Cd_t Ca_n Ca_t Cl dF cF +(-) (m) (kg/m) (N) (N-s) (N-m^2) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) +riser {DIAMETER} {MASS:.6f} {ea:.6e} 0.0 {EI}|-{ZETA}|{F_REF} {CD} 0.0 {CA} 0.0 {CL} {DF} {CF} +----------------------- POINTS ---------------------------------------------- +ID Attachment X Y Z M V CdA CA +(-) (-) (m) (m) (m) (kg) (m^3) (m^2) (-) +1 Coupled 0.0 0.0 {Z_BOTTOM + LENGTH:.6f} 0 0 0 0 +2 Fixed 0.0 0.0 {Z_BOTTOM:.6f} 0 0 0 0 +----------------------- LINES ----------------------------------------------- +ID LineType AttachA AttachB UnstrLen NumSegs Outputs +(-) (-) (-) (-) (m) (-) (-) +1 riser 1 2 {l0:.9f} {segments} p +--------------------- VIV ---------------------------------------------- +TypeName ClX alpha +(-) (-) (-) +riser {CLX} {ALPHA} +--------------------- VIV AMPLITUDE ------------------------------------ +TypeName AD Cv CdAmp +(-) (-) (-) (-) +{amp}--------------------- VIV DAMPING ------------------------------------ +TypeName a b c +(-) (-) (-) (-) +riser 0 0 1 +---------------------- OPTIONS ---------------------------------------------- +{RHO_W} rhoW +{GRAVITY} g +{WATER_DEPTH} WtrDpth +{dt:.6f} dtM +{round(tmax / dt) * dt:.6f} TMax +1 Currents +{VIV_RMS_WINDOW} VIVrmsWindow +---------------------- OUTPUTS ----------------------------------------------- +FairTen1 +END +------------------------- need this line -------------------------------------- +""" + + +def write_current(folder: Path, u: float) -> None: + """Uniform U over the lower CURRENT_HEIGHT, still water above (a 2 cm linear step).""" + zc = Z_BOTTOM + CURRENT_HEIGHT + (folder / "current_profile.txt").write_text( + "z ux uy uz\n(m) (m/s) (m/s) (m/s)\n" + f"{-WATER_DEPTH:.3f} {u} 0 0\n{zc - 0.01:.3f} {u} 0 0\n" + f"{zc + 0.01:.3f} 0 0 0\n0.0 0 0 0\n", + encoding="utf-8", + ) + + +def run(exe: Path, folder: Path, stem: str) -> None: + env = dict(os.environ, OMP_NUM_THREADS="1") + proc = subprocess.run( + [str(exe), f"{stem}.dat", stem], + cwd=folder, + capture_output=True, + text=True, + encoding="utf-8", + errors="replace", + env=env, + check=False, + ) + (folder / f"{stem}.console.txt").write_text( + proc.stdout + proc.stderr, encoding="utf-8" + ) + if proc.returncode != 0: + raise SystemExit(f"{folder / stem}: CableDyn exited with {proc.returncode}") + + +def static_top_tension(folder: Path, stem: str) -> float: + rows = (folder / f"{stem}.static.out").read_text(encoding="utf-8").splitlines() + head = rows[1].split() + first = rows[3].split() # node 1, End A, the top joint + return float(first[head.index("Tension")]) + + +def tuned_length(exe: Path, folder: Path, case: int, segments: int, ea: float): + """Unstretched length whose static top tension in the current is the case's mean tension. + + The start is the still-water length, the exact integral of ds / (1 + T(s)/EA) with T falling + by the submerged weight down the riser; the current's bow then raises the tension, and each + iteration corrects the length by the tension error over EA. + """ + t_target = CASES[case][1] + t_bottom = t_target - SUBMERGED_WEIGHT * LENGTH + l0 = ea / SUBMERGED_WEIGHT * math.log((ea + t_target) / (ea + t_bottom)) + for _ in range(12): + stem = "static" + (folder / f"{stem}.dat").write_text( + deck_text(case, l0, segments, 0.005, 0.0, ea), encoding="utf-8" + ) + run(exe, folder, stem) + t = static_top_tension(folder, stem) + if abs(t - t_target) < 0.05: + return l0, t + l0 *= 1.0 + (t - t_target) / ea + raise SystemExit(f"case {case}: the static top tension did not converge ({t} N)") + + +def response(folder: Path, stem: str, t0: float) -> dict: + """Response metrics of a run, statistics over t > t0. + + x is in-line (along the current), y cross-flow, both from the line between the joints. + """ + path = folder / f"{stem}.Line1.p.out" + a = np.loadtxt(path, skiprows=2) + keep = a[:, 0] > t0 + t = a[keep, 0] + xyz = a[keep, 1:].reshape(len(t), -1, 3) + x, y, z = xyz[:, :, 0], xyz[:, :, 1], xyz[:, :, 2] + # height over the chord, 0 at the lower joint + s = (z.mean(axis=0) - Z_BOTTOM) / LENGTH + half_pp = (y.max(axis=0) - y.min(axis=0)) / 2.0 / DIAMETER + x_mean = x.mean(axis=0) / DIAMETER + # dominant cross-flow mode: the largest r.m.s. projection on the pinned-pinned sines + yd = y - y.mean(axis=0) + o = np.argsort(s) + so = s[o] + proj = [ + float( + np.sqrt(np.mean(trapezoid_rows(yd[:, o] * np.sin(n * np.pi * so), so) ** 2)) + ) + for n in range(1, 16) + ] + mode = int(np.argmax(proj)) + 1 + # dominant cross-flow frequency a quarter of the length above the lower joint + j = int(np.argmin(np.abs(s - 0.25))) + sig = yd[:, j] * np.hanning(len(t)) + freq = np.fft.rfftfreq(len(t), t[1] - t[0]) + f_cf = float(freq[1 + int(np.argmax(np.abs(np.fft.rfft(sig))[1:]))]) + # curvature from second differences of the node positions (equal elements along the arc); + # overall standard deviation = r.m.s. over the interior nodes of the standard deviation + ds = LENGTH / (xyz.shape[1] - 1) + kx = (x[:, 2:] - 2.0 * x[:, 1:-1] + x[:, :-2]) / ds**2 + ky = (y[:, 2:] - 2.0 * y[:, 1:-1] + y[:, :-2]) / ds**2 + tension = np.loadtxt(folder / f"{stem}.out", skiprows=2) + tension = tension[tension[:, 0] > t0, 1] + return { + "mode": mode, + "f_cf_hz": f_cf, + "frequency_resolution_hz": float(freq[1]), + "max_cf_half_pp_D": float(half_pp.max()), + "max_il_mean_D": float(x_mean.max()), + "std_curv_il_kD": float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.var(kx, axis=0))) * DIAMETER), + "std_curv_cf_kD": float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.var(ky, axis=0))) * DIAMETER), + "mean_top_tension_N": float(tension.mean()), + "std_top_tension_N": float(tension.std()), + } + + +def measured() -> tuple[dict, dict]: + with open(HERE / "measured_summary.csv", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + summ = { + (r["quantity"], int(r["case"])): float(r["value"]) + for r in csv.DictReader(fh) + } + env = {} + for case in CASES: + with open( + HERE / "envelopes" / f"case{case}_envelopes.csv", encoding="utf-8" + ) as fh: + rows = list(csv.DictReader(fh)) + env[case] = max((float(r["y_max_D"]) - float(r["y_min_D"])) / 2.0 for r in rows) + return summ, env + + +def parse_cases(text: str) -> list[int]: + out: list[int] = [] + for part in text.split(","): + lo, _, hi = part.partition("-") + out += range(int(lo), int(hi or lo) + 1) + if not out or any(c not in CASES for c in out): + raise SystemExit(f"--cases: cases are 1-9, got {text!r}") + return sorted(set(out)) + + +def main() -> None: + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) + ap.add_argument("exe") + ap.add_argument("workdir") + ap.add_argument("--cases", default="1-9", help="for example 1-9, 5 or 5,9") + ap.add_argument("--segments", type=int, default=64) + ap.add_argument( + "--dt-scale", + type=float, + default=1.0, + help="factor of each case's time step (1: 1/200 of the shedding period, rounded down)", + ) + ap.add_argument("--tmax", type=float, default=40.0) + ap.add_argument( + "--t0", type=float, default=15.0, help="start of the statistics [s]" + ) + ap.add_argument( + "--spring", type=float, default=11.4e3, help="top spring stiffness [N/m]" + ) + ap.add_argument("--jobs", type=int, default=min(9, os.cpu_count() or 1)) + ap.add_argument( + "--summary", + default=None, + help="directory for the comparison CSV and summary JSON", + ) + a = ap.parse_args() + found = a.exe if Path(a.exe).is_file() else shutil.which(a.exe) + if found is None: + raise SystemExit(f"CableDyn executable not found: {a.exe}") + exe = Path(found).resolve() + cases = parse_cases(a.cases) + ea = effective_ea(a.spring) + tag = f"n{a.segments}_dt{a.dt_scale:g}_k{a.spring:g}" + + def one(case: int) -> dict: + u, _ = CASES[case] + folder = Path(a.workdir).resolve() / f"case{case}_{tag}" + folder.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + write_current(folder, u) + l0, t_static = tuned_length(exe, folder, case, a.segments, ea) + dt = time_step(u, a.dt_scale) + stem = f"case{case}" + (folder / f"{stem}.dat").write_text( + deck_text(case, l0, a.segments, dt, a.tmax, ea), encoding="utf-8" + ) + run(exe, folder, stem) + out = { + "case": case, + "dt_s": dt, + "unstretched_length_m": l0, + "static_top_tension_N": t_static, + } + out.update(response(folder, stem, a.t0)) + return out + + with ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=max(1, a.jobs)) as pool: + results = list(pool.map(one, cases)) + + summ, env = measured() + + def pct(model: float, meas: float) -> float: + return round(100.0 * (model / meas - 1.0), 1) + + rows = [] + for r in results: + c = r["case"] + u, t_top = CASES[c] + rows.append( + { + "case": c, + "U_m_per_s": u, + "top_tension_N": t_top, + "dt_s": r["dt_s"], + "mode_measured": MEASURED_MODES[c], + "mode_cabledyn": r["mode"], + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": round(r["f_cf_hz"], 3), + "max_cf_D_measured": round(summ[("max_cf_disp_D", c)], 4), + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": round(env[c], 4), + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": round(r["max_cf_half_pp_D"], 4), + "max_cf_error_percent": pct( + r["max_cf_half_pp_D"], summ[("max_cf_disp_D", c)] + ), + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": pct(r["max_cf_half_pp_D"], env[c]), + "max_il_mean_D_measured": round(summ[("max_il_mean_D", c)], 3), + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": round(r["max_il_mean_D"], 3), + "max_il_mean_error_percent": pct( + r["max_il_mean_D"], summ[("max_il_mean_D", c)] + ), + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": f"{summ[('std_curv_cf_kD', c)]:.4e}", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": f"{r['std_curv_cf_kD']:.4e}", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": pct( + r["std_curv_cf_kD"], summ[("std_curv_cf_kD", c)] + ), + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": f"{summ[('std_curv_il_kD', c)]:.4e}", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": f"{r['std_curv_il_kD']:.4e}", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": pct( + r["std_curv_il_kD"], summ[("std_curv_il_kD", c)] + ), + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": round(r["mean_top_tension_N"], 1), + } + ) + print( + f"case {c}: mode {r['mode']}/{MEASURED_MODES[c]}, f_CF {r['f_cf_hz']:.2f} Hz, " + f"A_CF/D {r['max_cf_half_pp_D']:.3f}/{summ[('max_cf_disp_D', c)]:.3f}, " + f"IL mean/D {r['max_il_mean_D']:.2f}/{summ[('max_il_mean_D', c)]:.2f}, " + f"sd kD CF {r['std_curv_cf_kD']:.2e}/{summ[('std_curv_cf_kD', c)]:.2e}, " + f"IL {r['std_curv_il_kD']:.2e}/{summ[('std_curv_il_kD', c)]:.2e}" + ) + + def span(key: str) -> list[float]: + values = [r[key] for r in rows] + return [min(values), max(values)] + + il_err = [r["max_il_mean_error_percent"] for r in rows] + summary = { + "cases": cases, + "segments": a.segments, + "dt_scale": a.dt_scale, + "tmax_s": a.tmax, + "statistics_after_s": a.t0, + "top_spring_N_per_m": a.spring, + "effective_axial_stiffness_N": round(ea, 1), + "modes_right": sum(r["mode_cabledyn"] == r["mode_measured"] for r in rows), + "modes_within_one": sum( + abs(r["mode_cabledyn"] - r["mode_measured"]) <= 1 for r in rows + ), + "il_mean_within_17_percent": sum(abs(e) <= 17.0 for e in il_err), + "il_mean_error_percent_range": span("max_il_mean_error_percent"), + "max_cf_error_percent_range": span("max_cf_error_percent"), + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent_range": span("max_cf_envelope_error_percent"), + "std_curv_cf_error_percent_range": span("std_curv_cf_error_percent"), + "std_curv_il_error_percent_range": span("std_curv_il_error_percent"), + "per_case": rows, + "executable_sha256": hashlib.sha256(exe.read_bytes()).hexdigest(), + } + print(json.dumps({k: v for k, v in summary.items() if k != "per_case"}, indent=2)) + if a.summary: + out = Path(a.summary) + out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + with open( + out / "response_comparison.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8" + ) as fh: + w = csv.DictWriter(fh, fieldnames=list(rows[0]), lineterminator="\n") + w.writeheader() + w.writerows(rows) + (out / "summary.json").write_text( + json.dumps(summary, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n" + ) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/README.md b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c49a105 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ + + +# Measured response envelopes, blind-trial cases 1–9 + +`case_envelopes.csv` holds the measured envelopes along the riser of case N, read from the +measurement curves (the top row of slides 7–15) of the experimenters' presentation of the blind +trial of Chaplin et al. (2005b), . The slides +are vector graphics: each measured curve is a polyline of 102 nearly equally spaced vertices from +one end of the riser to the other, so the values are the plotted vertices, linearly resampled to +101 equally spaced stations, not a pixel digitisation. + +| Column | Meaning | +| --- | --- | +| `z_over_L` | height above the lower joint over the 13.12 m length: 0 at the lower joint (in the current), 1 at the top joint | +| `x_min_D`, `x_mean_D`, `x_max_D` | in-line displacement (along the current) over the diameter: minimum, mean and maximum; zero is the panel edge that the end stations touch | +| `y_min_D`, `y_max_D` | cross-flow displacement over the diameter: minimum and maximum, about the panel centre | +| `kx_rms_D`, `ky_rms_D` | in-line and cross-flow r.m.s. curvature times the diameter (see below) | + +- **Displacement scales:** the in-line panel's `10` tick and the cross-flow panel's `-1` and `1` + ticks. As a check, the largest `x_mean_D` of each case is within 0.05 D (4 %) of the measured + maximum mean in-line displacement of slide 17 (`../measured_summary.csv`). +- **Cross-flow scatter:** half the largest peak-to-peak of the cross-flow envelope differs from + the measured maximum cross-flow displacement of slide 18 by −12 % to +10 %. The experimenters + processed quasi-steady windows of each record, and slide 18 summarises them; this difference is + the scale of the measurement scatter in a peak amplitude. +- **Curvature scale (assumed):** the curvature panels carry no scale. Each shape is scaled so that + its r.m.s. over the 101 stations equals the overall standard deviation of curvature of slide 19 + for the case, assuming that number is the r.m.s. over the span of the r.m.s. curvature. The + shapes and the positions of their peaks do not depend on the assumption; the magnitudes do. diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case1_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case1_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fba4d05 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case1_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019215,0.0019215,0,0 +0.9900,-0.008835,0.017901,0.026852,-0.040876,0.047177,6.3492e-06,1.6376e-05 +0.9800,-0.0091084,0.027331,0.063069,-0.085126,0.091014,1.2212e-05,3.2267e-05 +0.9700,-0.014717,0.044402,0.09522,-0.12707,0.13294,1.8406e-05,4.6756e-05 +0.9600,-0.015259,0.066097,0.12792,-0.17507,0.185,2.4988e-05,6.2761e-05 +0.9500,-0.015259,0.083437,0.154,-0.21563,0.22514,3.1303e-05,7.3985e-05 +0.9400,-0.015259,0.090621,0.18952,-0.25454,0.26,3.7547e-05,8.2517e-05 +0.9300,-0.015002,0.10806,0.21575,-0.29005,0.29136,4.3439e-05,8.9259e-05 +0.9200,-0.0086153,0.12674,0.2436,-0.32334,0.32437,4.9129e-05,9.3376e-05 +0.9100,2.3856e-05,0.14413,0.26683,-0.35316,0.34939,5.3576e-05,9.4635e-05 +0.9000,0.0087751,0.16164,0.29297,-0.38202,0.37681,5.7197e-05,9.3897e-05 +0.8900,0.021503,0.18087,0.32598,-0.41604,0.40712,6.0057e-05,9.0807e-05 +0.8800,0.039055,0.19851,0.34875,-0.43734,0.42756,6.1421e-05,8.5957e-05 +0.8700,0.057226,0.21698,0.3684,-0.46347,0.44965,6.1351e-05,8.0365e-05 +0.8600,0.072822,0.23432,0.39394,-0.49197,0.47193,6.072e-05,7.5187e-05 +0.8500,0.10076,0.25002,0.41227,-0.52161,0.50126,5.8818e-05,7.1183e-05 +0.8400,0.12706,0.26774,0.42677,-0.54938,0.53018,5.6704e-05,6.8927e-05 +0.8300,0.15636,0.28851,0.44183,-0.58327,0.56023,5.3676e-05,7.1039e-05 +0.8200,0.18389,0.30518,0.45579,-0.61273,0.58891,5.0665e-05,7.6146e-05 +0.8100,0.21156,0.32595,0.46493,-0.64087,0.61418,4.7198e-05,8.3043e-05 +0.8000,0.23574,0.34304,0.47212,-0.66164,0.63463,4.3311e-05,9.1522e-05 +0.7900,0.25278,0.35859,0.47312,-0.68164,0.65603,3.9321e-05,0.00010006 +0.7800,0.27706,0.37622,0.47827,-0.69619,0.67568,3.3869e-05,0.0001076 +0.7700,0.28757,0.39536,0.48123,-0.71083,0.6909,2.8293e-05,0.00011408 +0.7600,0.30438,0.41568,0.50344,-0.71802,0.70235,2.1349e-05,0.0001198 +0.7500,0.31561,0.43185,0.52289,-0.71896,0.70843,1.7948e-05,0.00012207 +0.7400,0.32356,0.44954,0.53841,-0.71515,0.71055,1.8235e-05,0.00012162 +0.7300,0.33114,0.46678,0.55804,-0.70577,0.7043,2.2216e-05,0.00011957 +0.7200,0.34034,0.48222,0.58227,-0.69057,0.69377,2.8448e-05,0.00011588 +0.7100,0.34034,0.50126,0.60988,-0.67095,0.67809,3.546e-05,0.00010996 +0.7000,0.34172,0.52156,0.63984,-0.64379,0.65417,4.2243e-05,0.00010251 +0.6900,0.34649,0.54041,0.67884,-0.60885,0.62235,4.8628e-05,9.3562e-05 +0.6800,0.34969,0.5583,0.70779,-0.57681,0.59283,5.3797e-05,8.6545e-05 +0.6700,0.35877,0.57652,0.73806,-0.54291,0.5577,5.785e-05,7.9881e-05 +0.6600,0.37046,0.5933,0.76255,-0.50654,0.51931,6.0783e-05,7.5172e-05 +0.6500,0.38593,0.60927,0.78707,-0.46551,0.48017,6.3756e-05,7.3314e-05 +0.6400,0.40147,0.62837,0.80617,-0.42225,0.43712,6.5923e-05,7.4958e-05 +0.6300,0.42824,0.64755,0.83083,-0.3819,0.38928,6.7605e-05,8.0018e-05 +0.6200,0.44939,0.6643,0.84888,-0.35198,0.36024,6.8512e-05,8.6767e-05 +0.6100,0.46957,0.68642,0.86022,-0.33169,0.34569,6.8512e-05,9.4217e-05 +0.6000,0.4893,0.70943,0.878,-0.31413,0.33319,6.7858e-05,0.00010132 +0.5900,0.51617,0.72735,0.89592,-0.29755,0.32079,6.6058e-05,0.00010673 +0.5800,0.54615,0.74417,0.91066,-0.28217,0.30653,6.356e-05,0.0001098 +0.5700,0.5809,0.76218,0.92065,-0.26395,0.29251,5.9426e-05,0.00011011 +0.5600,0.61441,0.78401,0.92907,-0.24595,0.27862,5.335e-05,0.00010663 +0.5500,0.65007,0.80173,0.93194,-0.22752,0.26637,4.7116e-05,9.9894e-05 +0.5400,0.68768,0.81765,0.93194,-0.20835,0.2528,4.0574e-05,8.9769e-05 +0.5300,0.72693,0.83562,0.93194,-0.18835,0.23682,3.3406e-05,7.6577e-05 +0.5200,0.76841,0.85705,0.93194,-0.17761,0.22293,2.62e-05,6.1214e-05 +0.5100,0.81112,0.87854,0.93194,-0.19067,0.21644,2.0148e-05,4.5642e-05 +0.5000,0.84807,0.89851,0.93194,-0.23024,0.24126,1.6503e-05,3.2247e-05 +0.4900,0.86691,0.91833,0.95923,-0.27941,0.29529,1.765e-05,3.0427e-05 +0.4800,0.87067,0.93578,0.99621,-0.32407,0.3438,2.1935e-05,3.9135e-05 +0.4700,0.87067,0.95225,1.031,-0.37076,0.39208,2.73e-05,5.3548e-05 +0.4600,0.87067,0.96882,1.067,-0.41798,0.43906,3.3197e-05,6.8436e-05 +0.4500,0.87067,0.98666,1.1027,-0.46276,0.48336,3.8612e-05,8.1959e-05 +0.4400,0.87067,1.0036,1.1382,-0.50341,0.52542,4.3211e-05,9.4764e-05 +0.4300,0.87614,1.0225,1.1721,-0.54412,0.57036,4.8061e-05,0.00010723 +0.4200,0.88565,1.0417,1.1988,-0.57757,0.60749,5.1609e-05,0.00011657 +0.4100,0.889,1.0541,1.2246,-0.6038,0.63964,5.4217e-05,0.00012343 +0.4000,0.889,1.0684,1.2517,-0.62684,0.66745,5.6162e-05,0.00012883 +0.3900,0.89425,1.0813,1.2735,-0.64617,0.69296,5.715e-05,0.00013262 +0.3800,0.89823,1.0906,1.2902,-0.6649,0.71453,5.8326e-05,0.0001344 +0.3700,0.89823,1.0945,1.3069,-0.67925,0.73047,5.9443e-05,0.00013382 +0.3600,0.90417,1.1003,1.321,-0.69338,0.74381,6.0838e-05,0.00013042 +0.3500,0.90746,1.1036,1.3243,-0.70628,0.75277,6.2571e-05,0.00012529 +0.3400,0.90746,1.1036,1.3243,-0.71634,0.75739,6.4144e-05,0.00011931 +0.3300,0.91351,1.1036,1.3183,-0.72707,0.75858,6.5553e-05,0.00011343 +0.3200,0.92266,1.0976,1.3091,-0.73857,0.76125,6.5645e-05,0.00010846 +0.3100,0.92579,1.0888,1.2946,-0.74729,0.76484,6.4443e-05,0.00010527 +0.3000,0.93029,1.0853,1.2764,-0.75463,0.76879,6.1667e-05,0.00010552 +0.2900,0.93194,1.0706,1.2504,-0.75948,0.76693,5.6986e-05,0.00010861 +0.2800,0.94123,1.0599,1.2238,-0.75726,0.76619,5.0616e-05,0.00011349 +0.2700,0.94425,1.0438,1.1916,-0.75359,0.76352,4.3369e-05,0.00011904 +0.2600,0.94425,1.0283,1.1569,-0.74543,0.75718,3.6081e-05,0.0001232 +0.2500,0.93137,1.0111,1.1209,-0.73196,0.74442,2.9058e-05,0.00012546 +0.2400,0.91284,0.99257,1.0794,-0.71195,0.72978,2.4017e-05,0.00012478 +0.2300,0.89145,0.96318,1.0429,-0.68708,0.70363,2.2801e-05,0.00012015 +0.2200,0.8735,0.94661,1.0263,-0.65853,0.67797,2.6305e-05,0.00011276 +0.2100,0.85033,0.92136,1.0138,-0.62686,0.64988,3.1387e-05,0.00010229 +0.2000,0.81724,0.89491,1.0068,-0.59224,0.61905,3.727e-05,8.9577e-05 +0.1900,0.78042,0.8673,0.99109,-0.55279,0.58007,4.4119e-05,7.3518e-05 +0.1800,0.73889,0.83497,0.9727,-0.51243,0.54398,5.0741e-05,5.6113e-05 +0.1700,0.69547,0.80725,0.96188,-0.47469,0.50631,5.6849e-05,3.8534e-05 +0.1600,0.64434,0.7693,0.93428,-0.42752,0.46107,6.4167e-05,2.0551e-05 +0.1500,0.6001,0.73391,0.91029,-0.3882,0.42645,7.0194e-05,2.2765e-05 +0.1400,0.55737,0.70027,0.88343,-0.35699,0.4029,7.5667e-05,3.822e-05 +0.1300,0.51114,0.65522,0.85006,-0.33424,0.38433,7.9746e-05,5.6549e-05 +0.1200,0.46805,0.62026,0.81381,-0.31304,0.36532,8.3066e-05,7.282e-05 +0.1100,0.42719,0.57784,0.76333,-0.29441,0.34821,8.4096e-05,8.67e-05 +0.1000,0.37386,0.5241,0.71094,-0.26982,0.32283,8.2569e-05,9.967e-05 +0.0900,0.33021,0.48045,0.65282,-0.24962,0.29878,7.8948e-05,0.00010725 +0.0800,0.28657,0.43978,0.5967,-0.22657,0.2731,7.2763e-05,0.00011064 +0.0700,0.24981,0.38554,0.52718,-0.20147,0.24451,6.5016e-05,0.00010989 +0.0600,0.20937,0.33305,0.46847,-0.17415,0.21335,5.6759e-05,0.00010632 +0.0500,0.17167,0.28857,0.3981,-0.14682,0.18006,4.7244e-05,9.78e-05 +0.0400,0.13716,0.22491,0.31794,-0.11761,0.14562,3.8619e-05,8.5238e-05 +0.0300,0.096617,0.16626,0.23856,-0.08546,0.1088,2.7824e-05,6.6607e-05 +0.0200,0.062774,0.11276,0.15764,-0.055641,0.072613,1.84e-05,4.6219e-05 +0.0100,0.034895,0.052403,0.078546,-0.026942,0.035112,9.0028e-06,2.3073e-05 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019215,0.0019215,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case2_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case2_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..778e4ea --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case2_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.0089508,0.017902,0.026853,-0.044813,0.04324,9.5506e-06,9.3453e-06 +0.9800,0.018104,0.036089,0.054193,-0.092599,0.087445,1.8397e-05,1.8156e-05 +0.9700,0.026872,0.05362,0.085993,-0.13791,0.128,2.5221e-05,2.6574e-05 +0.9600,0.037605,0.072138,0.11896,-0.19272,0.1813,3.2055e-05,3.6789e-05 +0.9500,0.04696,0.090835,0.1466,-0.23791,0.2255,3.563e-05,4.4704e-05 +0.9400,0.056627,0.10897,0.17035,-0.28119,0.26424,3.741e-05,5.2814e-05 +0.9300,0.071277,0.12652,0.18818,-0.31972,0.30283,3.6702e-05,5.9694e-05 +0.9200,0.089955,0.14509,0.21559,-0.35912,0.34369,3.4611e-05,6.7724e-05 +0.9100,0.10734,0.16258,0.23312,-0.39374,0.37831,3.2405e-05,7.4551e-05 +0.9000,0.12484,0.17705,0.25926,-0.425,0.40957,2.9811e-05,8.1273e-05 +0.8900,0.14715,0.1993,0.27904,-0.46185,0.44498,2.7898e-05,8.9278e-05 +0.8800,0.16442,0.21799,0.29659,-0.48857,0.47225,2.7982e-05,9.4969e-05 +0.8700,0.18019,0.24465,0.31476,-0.50976,0.49413,2.899e-05,9.9943e-05 +0.8600,0.19779,0.2619,0.32958,-0.52767,0.51119,3.19e-05,0.00010427 +0.8500,0.21631,0.2777,0.3482,-0.54131,0.53012,3.3932e-05,0.00010747 +0.8400,0.23387,0.29531,0.36631,-0.55227,0.54314,3.542e-05,0.000109 +0.8300,0.2524,0.31617,0.39649,-0.55989,0.55516,3.5268e-05,0.00010953 +0.8200,0.27079,0.3341,0.4142,-0.56215,0.56029,3.4225e-05,0.00010916 +0.8100,0.28848,0.35967,0.43017,-0.5582,0.55973,3.1568e-05,0.00010757 +0.8000,0.30426,0.3773,0.4478,-0.55409,0.55641,2.7736e-05,0.00010595 +0.7900,0.32587,0.39538,0.46538,-0.54537,0.54834,2.3309e-05,0.00010271 +0.7800,0.34866,0.41265,0.48153,-0.531,0.53731,2.0658e-05,9.9723e-05 +0.7700,0.3678,0.43056,0.50881,-0.51581,0.52136,2.0354e-05,9.6186e-05 +0.7600,0.38812,0.4596,0.53303,-0.49289,0.49625,2.5313e-05,9.1518e-05 +0.7500,0.40524,0.47786,0.55756,-0.47046,0.47168,3.0496e-05,8.6715e-05 +0.7400,0.42505,0.49472,0.5752,-0.44514,0.44377,3.5739e-05,8.1718e-05 +0.7300,0.44229,0.51279,0.5925,-0.4164,0.4148,3.9223e-05,7.6209e-05 +0.7200,0.45773,0.53737,0.60788,-0.38689,0.38533,4.178e-05,7.0888e-05 +0.7100,0.47741,0.55582,0.62831,-0.354,0.35311,4.2325e-05,6.431e-05 +0.7000,0.50143,0.57433,0.6513,-0.31849,0.32277,4.0655e-05,5.7747e-05 +0.6900,0.52744,0.59911,0.66303,-0.28785,0.28642,3.5292e-05,4.943e-05 +0.6800,0.55231,0.62161,0.68198,-0.261,0.25677,2.9661e-05,4.2745e-05 +0.6700,0.57863,0.63788,0.69805,-0.23324,0.22528,2.3736e-05,3.6371e-05 +0.6600,0.60321,0.65739,0.70769,-0.20277,0.19863,1.8858e-05,3.1093e-05 +0.6500,0.63038,0.68067,0.7258,-0.17604,0.17846,1.7753e-05,2.8693e-05 +0.6400,0.65598,0.70095,0.74792,-0.16119,0.16823,2.1935e-05,2.8707e-05 +0.6300,0.68066,0.71942,0.77324,-0.1655,0.18249,2.915e-05,3.2564e-05 +0.6200,0.70692,0.74064,0.78998,-0.18384,0.20697,3.511e-05,3.8556e-05 +0.6100,0.72843,0.76215,0.80811,-0.21828,0.23207,3.9793e-05,4.5601e-05 +0.6000,0.74991,0.78116,0.82957,-0.25013,0.25478,4.1957e-05,5.2493e-05 +0.5900,0.77217,0.80319,0.8519,-0.28075,0.27768,4.1762e-05,5.9804e-05 +0.5800,0.7881,0.82383,0.87099,-0.30936,0.30144,3.9437e-05,6.7397e-05 +0.5700,0.80418,0.84588,0.89704,-0.33963,0.32739,3.5864e-05,7.5452e-05 +0.5600,0.81916,0.87127,0.91723,-0.36525,0.35522,3.2103e-05,8.3176e-05 +0.5500,0.83699,0.8891,0.93815,-0.38685,0.3798,2.9603e-05,8.9719e-05 +0.5400,0.85306,0.91065,0.95866,-0.40434,0.40248,2.9075e-05,9.5473e-05 +0.5300,0.86933,0.93368,0.98052,-0.41849,0.42233,3.0846e-05,0.00010049 +0.5200,0.89213,0.95511,1.0086,-0.43337,0.43879,3.4354e-05,0.00010503 +0.5100,0.91797,0.97666,1.0345,-0.4451,0.45148,3.7962e-05,0.00010864 +0.5000,0.94145,0.99663,1.0627,-0.45728,0.46385,4.0579e-05,0.00011167 +0.4900,0.96127,1.02,1.087,-0.46826,0.46951,4.1574e-05,0.00011384 +0.4800,0.97873,1.04,1.1094,-0.47486,0.46951,3.9872e-05,0.00011451 +0.4700,1,1.0629,1.1301,-0.47835,0.46738,3.6492e-05,0.00011364 +0.4600,1.0209,1.0853,1.1466,-0.47707,0.46417,3.2182e-05,0.00011201 +0.4500,1.0431,1.1076,1.1645,-0.47341,0.45931,2.7406e-05,0.00010935 +0.4400,1.0665,1.1293,1.1785,-0.46419,0.44997,2.3909e-05,0.00010535 +0.4300,1.0924,1.1483,1.1943,-0.44802,0.44415,2.4055e-05,9.9932e-05 +0.4200,1.1153,1.1673,1.2114,-0.43062,0.44159,2.7915e-05,9.404e-05 +0.4100,1.1258,1.1797,1.2282,-0.41946,0.43547,3.3165e-05,8.8557e-05 +0.4000,1.1389,1.1941,1.2462,-0.40964,0.42654,3.8387e-05,8.3136e-05 +0.3900,1.157,1.2052,1.2591,-0.39702,0.41368,4.2816e-05,7.8008e-05 +0.3800,1.1702,1.2131,1.2684,-0.38033,0.39721,4.5212e-05,7.3823e-05 +0.3700,1.1792,1.2221,1.2773,-0.36172,0.37729,4.4319e-05,6.9995e-05 +0.3600,1.1833,1.2322,1.2814,-0.33775,0.35075,4.084e-05,6.5971e-05 +0.3500,1.1833,1.2355,1.2814,-0.30787,0.32034,3.4528e-05,6.2531e-05 +0.3400,1.1772,1.2355,1.2814,-0.27962,0.29276,2.8053e-05,5.9002e-05 +0.3300,1.1741,1.2355,1.2754,-0.24828,0.26209,2.2527e-05,5.5155e-05 +0.3200,1.1681,1.2355,1.2662,-0.21297,0.22595,2.1416e-05,5.055e-05 +0.3100,1.165,1.2298,1.2631,-0.19791,0.19339,2.5562e-05,4.5404e-05 +0.3000,1.1582,1.2195,1.2631,-0.19934,0.16736,3.2899e-05,3.9252e-05 +0.2900,1.1485,1.2097,1.2557,-0.20646,0.18307,4.0154e-05,3.3816e-05 +0.2800,1.1327,1.2033,1.2469,-0.21569,0.21342,4.5186e-05,3.1778e-05 +0.2700,1.1143,1.1925,1.2377,-0.22964,0.24826,4.7906e-05,3.2453e-05 +0.2600,1.0988,1.1784,1.2222,-0.25416,0.28069,4.8412e-05,3.6996e-05 +0.2500,1.0816,1.1613,1.2106,-0.28247,0.31015,4.5741e-05,4.4831e-05 +0.2400,1.0631,1.1427,1.1949,-0.31271,0.34218,4.1007e-05,5.471e-05 +0.2300,1.0417,1.1134,1.1682,-0.34671,0.38484,3.3355e-05,6.8169e-05 +0.2200,1.0263,1.089,1.1416,-0.36898,0.42375,2.7441e-05,7.9786e-05 +0.2100,1.0087,1.0699,1.1144,-0.39341,0.45733,2.5168e-05,9.1554e-05 +0.2000,0.97658,1.0379,1.0905,-0.42045,0.48885,2.6181e-05,0.00010308 +0.1900,0.94945,1.0107,1.0563,-0.44739,0.51465,3.1162e-05,0.00011498 +0.1800,0.90812,0.97664,1.0292,-0.4729,0.53763,3.7136e-05,0.00012707 +0.1700,0.87089,0.9414,1.0034,-0.49229,0.55573,4.1477e-05,0.00013808 +0.1600,0.82214,0.90109,0.96262,-0.51011,0.57514,4.4409e-05,0.00015031 +0.1500,0.78596,0.86569,0.92969,-0.52118,0.58235,4.4583e-05,0.00015832 +0.1400,0.74439,0.82401,0.88579,-0.52601,0.5862,4.1961e-05,0.00016476 +0.1300,0.70089,0.77789,0.83918,-0.52294,0.57993,3.734e-05,0.00016772 +0.1200,0.65545,0.73482,0.7988,-0.51265,0.57013,3.2937e-05,0.00016732 +0.1100,0.61156,0.6836,0.74805,-0.49947,0.55622,3.0929e-05,0.00016372 +0.1000,0.55166,0.62216,0.67418,-0.47568,0.5287,3.175e-05,0.00015444 +0.0900,0.50801,0.57852,0.62482,-0.44682,0.49744,3.6549e-05,0.00014299 +0.0800,0.45558,0.52015,0.56319,-0.41355,0.45915,4.141e-05,0.00012852 +0.0700,0.40081,0.46516,0.5081,-0.374,0.41651,4.6165e-05,0.00011262 +0.0600,0.35122,0.40438,0.45012,-0.32855,0.37139,4.8226e-05,9.676e-05 +0.0500,0.29007,0.34506,0.37977,-0.2813,0.3158,4.7784e-05,7.9773e-05 +0.0400,0.23642,0.28016,0.30524,-0.22914,0.26053,4.3508e-05,6.2666e-05 +0.0300,0.16626,0.20262,0.22976,-0.16892,0.19218,3.6277e-05,4.5125e-05 +0.0200,0.11276,0.13957,0.15765,-0.11216,0.1278,2.5117e-05,2.9434e-05 +0.0100,0.0524,0.066875,0.078546,-0.054362,0.063974,1.3231e-05,1.4706e-05 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case3_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case3_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..483c93a --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case3_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.017902,0.044634,0.080322,-0.08023,0.075215,5.2344e-05,5.0451e-05 +0.9800,0.036089,0.096198,0.16542,-0.16424,0.15163,0.00010156,9.8631e-05 +0.9700,0.062035,0.14565,0.2413,-0.24147,0.22163,0.00014393,0.00013773 +0.9600,0.092216,0.20927,0.32867,-0.33068,0.30337,0.0001848,0.00017466 +0.9500,0.13014,0.25364,0.40512,-0.40455,0.36907,0.00020979,0.00019616 +0.9400,0.17341,0.30547,0.46846,-0.46989,0.42726,0.00022405,0.00021032 +0.9300,0.22343,0.35829,0.52698,-0.52474,0.47862,0.00022969,0.00022031 +0.9200,0.28842,0.42289,0.59097,-0.57915,0.52671,0.00022736,0.00023111 +0.9100,0.34668,0.47226,0.63172,-0.62146,0.56037,0.00021671,0.00024382 +0.9000,0.41647,0.52174,0.68109,-0.65609,0.58923,0.00019941,0.00025902 +0.8900,0.50884,0.58553,0.7368,-0.68695,0.61455,0.00016599,0.00027959 +0.8800,0.57885,0.6395,0.77824,-0.7016,0.62723,0.00013479,0.00029446 +0.8700,0.64507,0.7027,0.82407,-0.70961,0.62624,9.848e-05,0.00030427 +0.8600,0.67827,0.75236,0.86529,-0.70833,0.61835,7.2139e-05,0.00030805 +0.8500,0.72357,0.80587,0.91403,-0.69241,0.60242,7.4339e-05,0.00030454 +0.8400,0.75661,0.8644,0.98224,-0.67124,0.58153,0.00010468,0.00029291 +0.8300,0.81039,0.92825,1.0754,-0.62914,0.54558,0.00015339,0.00027206 +0.8200,0.85763,0.98221,1.1528,-0.58541,0.50748,0.00019047,0.00024995 +0.8100,0.90973,1.0422,1.224,-0.53553,0.46244,0.00022075,0.00022632 +0.8000,0.96014,1.0945,1.2939,-0.48111,0.41663,0.00023925,0.00020521 +0.7900,1.014,1.1477,1.3618,-0.41959,0.37166,0.00024689,0.00018643 +0.7800,1.0653,1.2079,1.4205,-0.35787,0.33424,0.0002436,0.0001723 +0.7700,1.1304,1.2622,1.4835,-0.29932,0.30752,0.00022975,0.00015962 +0.7600,1.1964,1.3254,1.5462,-0.25796,0.30805,0.00020375,0.00014725 +0.7500,1.2665,1.3835,1.5952,-0.25287,0.33351,0.00017468,0.00013531 +0.7400,1.3342,1.4344,1.6373,-0.27332,0.36449,0.00014291,0.00012243 +0.7300,1.4057,1.4908,1.68,-0.31657,0.39237,0.00011033,0.00011008 +0.7200,1.4825,1.5502,1.7148,-0.3699,0.41943,8.633e-05,0.00010562 +0.7100,1.551,1.6023,1.7485,-0.42819,0.4406,8.182e-05,0.00011353 +0.7000,1.5782,1.6576,1.7914,-0.48324,0.46611,0.00010403,0.00013717 +0.6900,1.6123,1.7273,1.8785,-0.54712,0.52408,0.00014655,0.000176 +0.6800,1.6488,1.7812,1.9528,-0.59754,0.57593,0.00018429,0.00021029 +0.6700,1.6865,1.8388,2.0257,-0.64377,0.62427,0.00021829,0.00024245 +0.6600,1.7326,1.8896,2.1,-0.68423,0.66373,0.00024346,0.00026847 +0.6500,1.7841,1.946,2.1707,-0.71802,0.69648,0.00025879,0.0002881 +0.6400,1.8421,2.0078,2.2424,-0.74434,0.72061,0.00026143,0.00030157 +0.6300,1.9125,2.068,2.3067,-0.76146,0.73842,0.00024959,0.00030927 +0.6200,1.978,2.1243,2.3564,-0.76793,0.74489,0.00022647,0.00031317 +0.6100,2.0487,2.1822,2.4046,-0.76287,0.75259,0.00019459,0.00031655 +0.6000,2.1176,2.2382,2.4525,-0.75931,0.76548,0.00015777,0.00032057 +0.5900,2.1891,2.2977,2.4931,-0.76254,0.76841,0.00012108,0.00032472 +0.5800,2.2641,2.3546,2.5296,-0.75681,0.76232,9.6529e-05,0.00032823 +0.5700,2.3201,2.4176,2.5701,-0.73847,0.7473,9.9129e-05,0.00032889 +0.5600,2.3505,2.4805,2.6233,-0.706,0.72106,0.00013081,0.00032165 +0.5500,2.3822,2.5355,2.693,-0.66716,0.68903,0.00016728,0.00030777 +0.5400,2.4156,2.5949,2.7601,-0.62037,0.64964,0.00020165,0.00028727 +0.5300,2.4538,2.6528,2.8256,-0.56549,0.59845,0.00023104,0.00025938 +0.5200,2.5073,2.7097,2.8837,-0.49879,0.5379,0.00025305,0.00022533 +0.5100,2.5673,2.7677,2.9399,-0.42802,0.47301,0.00026412,0.00019161 +0.5000,2.6436,2.831,3.005,-0.35105,0.39357,0.00026322,0.00015912 +0.4900,2.7262,2.8965,3.0625,-0.3247,0.30882,0.00024914,0.0001383 +0.4800,2.7995,2.9564,3.1068,-0.34434,0.24037,0.00022699,0.00013229 +0.4700,2.8762,3.0134,3.1492,-0.37497,0.22153,0.00019655,0.00013635 +0.4600,2.9498,3.069,3.1901,-0.4052,0.2611,0.00016126,0.00014651 +0.4500,3.0196,3.1258,3.226,-0.42984,0.31933,0.00012673,0.0001576 +0.4400,3.0947,3.1814,3.2552,-0.44911,0.38022,9.9834e-05,0.00016716 +0.4300,3.1474,3.2409,3.3155,-0.46306,0.44337,9.4125e-05,0.00017554 +0.4200,3.1642,3.2946,3.3939,-0.47905,0.4959,0.0001137,0.00018434 +0.4100,3.1809,3.342,3.458,-0.52353,0.54505,0.00014275,0.00019756 +0.4000,3.1939,3.3798,3.5146,-0.58202,0.59717,0.00017363,0.00021994 +0.3900,3.205,3.4125,3.5621,-0.63559,0.64618,0.00020332,0.00025239 +0.3800,3.2103,3.4431,3.5948,-0.68121,0.68816,0.00022882,0.00029395 +0.3700,3.2136,3.4653,3.6202,-0.7144,0.72027,0.00024793,0.00033795 +0.3600,3.2219,3.4854,3.6442,-0.74857,0.75933,0.00026202,0.0003846 +0.3500,3.225,3.492,3.6706,-0.78312,0.79161,0.00026549,0.00042177 +0.3400,3.2307,3.492,3.6831,-0.80557,0.80421,0.00025904,0.0004439 +0.3300,3.2336,3.492,3.6812,-0.81604,0.80177,0.00024233,0.00045414 +0.3200,3.2336,3.4799,3.6669,-0.81414,0.78484,0.00021478,0.00045056 +0.3100,3.2229,3.4621,3.6377,-0.80009,0.75406,0.00017984,0.00043524 +0.3000,3.2119,3.4299,3.5859,-0.77164,0.71089,0.00013508,0.00040682 +0.2900,3.1927,3.3992,3.5301,-0.73173,0.6653,9.9201e-05,0.00037356 +0.2800,3.1742,3.3592,3.4708,-0.68541,0.62093,9.1891e-05,0.00034039 +0.2700,3.1446,3.3156,3.4338,-0.62839,0.56478,0.00011607,0.00030546 +0.2600,3.079,3.2652,3.4162,-0.56641,0.50571,0.0001551,0.00027166 +0.2500,2.9946,3.2136,3.3863,-0.49936,0.44228,0.00019689,0.00023667 +0.2400,2.8983,3.1545,3.3447,-0.42495,0.37074,0.00023466,0.00020035 +0.2300,2.7926,3.0745,3.2766,-0.3346,0.28553,0.00026731,0.00016166 +0.2200,2.7132,3.0037,3.2244,-0.25688,0.21406,0.00028335,0.00014303 +0.2100,2.6273,2.926,3.1571,-0.18895,0.16905,0.0002884,0.00014914 +0.2000,2.5561,2.8525,3.0753,-0.23027,0.19609,0.00028131,0.00017768 +0.1900,2.4789,2.7635,2.9789,-0.29648,0.2608,0.0002617,0.00022145 +0.1800,2.4061,2.6695,2.8672,-0.36781,0.33032,0.0002315,0.00026708 +0.1700,2.3295,2.576,2.7482,-0.4325,0.39425,0.00019332,0.00030655 +0.1600,2.2351,2.4606,2.5951,-0.50607,0.46086,0.00013983,0.00034458 +0.1500,2.1587,2.3489,2.4512,-0.55347,0.50806,9.6751e-05,0.00036399 +0.1400,2.0499,2.2367,2.348,-0.59125,0.54855,7.4046e-05,0.00037272 +0.1300,1.9274,2.1199,2.257,-0.61485,0.57613,8.9309e-05,0.00037368 +0.1200,1.8024,1.995,2.1613,-0.624,0.59601,0.00012859,0.00036941 +0.1100,1.6748,1.87,2.0542,-0.61857,0.60044,0.00017066,0.00036499 +0.1000,1.5169,1.7161,1.9127,-0.60349,0.59318,0.00021945,0.00036319 +0.0900,1.3861,1.5795,1.7757,-0.578,0.57731,0.00025205,0.00036668 +0.0800,1.2226,1.4247,1.6209,-0.55959,0.55448,0.00027764,0.00037345 +0.0700,1.0642,1.2695,1.4656,-0.53126,0.52597,0.00029283,0.00037847 +0.0600,0.9127,1.1181,1.2975,-0.48996,0.4879,0.00029548,0.00037414 +0.0500,0.76017,0.94585,1.1096,-0.43842,0.43668,0.00028373,0.00035715 +0.0400,0.60473,0.76566,0.91095,-0.36925,0.3713,0.00025556,0.00032117 +0.0300,0.43755,0.56147,0.67334,-0.27953,0.28185,0.00020542,0.00025737 +0.0200,0.28548,0.37181,0.44879,-0.19034,0.1929,0.00014347,0.00018076 +0.0100,0.1425,0.18615,0.22105,-0.092844,0.099088,7.2738e-05,9.1819e-05 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case4_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case4_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2112668 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case4_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.026853,0.068388,0.10407,-0.055635,0.075215,9.6454e-05,7.0734e-05 +0.9800,0.063068,0.14128,0.21049,-0.10961,0.14822,0.00018629,0.00013634 +0.9700,0.095221,0.214,0.31244,-0.16256,0.21762,0.00025688,0.00018946 +0.9600,0.15593,0.30138,0.42766,-0.2309,0.29914,0.0003171,0.00024022 +0.9500,0.2218,0.38126,0.5143,-0.28931,0.36205,0.00033982,0.00027328 +0.9400,0.29315,0.45178,0.59475,-0.34407,0.41117,0.00033586,0.00029911 +0.9300,0.37816,0.52762,0.65877,-0.39292,0.45297,0.00030969,0.00032207 +0.9200,0.47777,0.60823,0.72325,-0.43601,0.48163,0.00025881,0.00034509 +0.9100,0.57665,0.68385,0.77274,-0.46725,0.49843,0.00019534,0.00036215 +0.9000,0.69008,0.76239,0.82502,-0.48841,0.50324,0.00012562,0.00037003 +0.8900,0.81035,0.85941,0.92683,-0.49035,0.48406,7.9491e-05,0.00036335 +0.8800,0.86709,0.93559,1.0379,-0.47916,0.45793,0.00012299,0.0003428 +0.8700,0.91421,1.0159,1.15,-0.45432,0.41616,0.00019967,0.0003089 +0.8600,0.96491,1.0919,1.2429,-0.4151,0.37034,0.00026697,0.00027152 +0.8500,1.0297,1.1724,1.3326,-0.36682,0.31751,0.00031949,0.00023363 +0.8400,1.0895,1.2489,1.4171,-0.3097,0.26171,0.00034778,0.0002064 +0.8300,1.1847,1.3441,1.5002,-0.23728,0.20134,0.00034721,0.00018659 +0.8200,1.2774,1.4308,1.5702,-0.17683,0.16399,0.0003187,0.00017531 +0.8100,1.3861,1.5105,1.6318,-0.13115,0.13861,0.00026681,0.00016126 +0.8000,1.4952,1.5884,1.6984,-0.1278,0.12636,0.00019992,0.00014338 +0.7900,1.6099,1.6745,1.7497,-0.1746,0.15767,0.0001233,0.00012867 +0.7800,1.7126,1.7506,1.8027,-0.21709,0.21229,6.7314e-05,0.0001332 +0.7700,1.7574,1.834,1.8916,-0.26666,0.27295,0.00010027,0.00017028 +0.7600,1.808,1.926,2.0267,-0.32399,0.33002,0.00019027,0.00023204 +0.7500,1.8556,2.0058,2.1398,-0.3657,0.37318,0.00026155,0.00028575 +0.7400,1.9112,2.0869,2.2393,-0.40192,0.41349,0.00031551,0.00032911 +0.7300,1.9827,2.1695,2.3291,-0.43048,0.44752,0.00035043,0.00036016 +0.7200,2.0545,2.2456,2.408,-0.45271,0.47355,0.00036247,0.00037503 +0.7100,2.1441,2.3261,2.4859,-0.4652,0.48992,0.0003486,0.0003757 +0.7000,2.2348,2.4087,2.5547,-0.46662,0.49497,0.0003075,0.00036556 +0.6900,2.3527,2.5011,2.6234,-0.46273,0.4847,0.00023091,0.00034779 +0.6800,2.4693,2.5788,2.6729,-0.45727,0.46379,0.00015195,0.00033372 +0.6700,2.5896,2.6577,2.7249,-0.44655,0.43573,8.4606e-05,0.0003209 +0.6600,2.6835,2.7339,2.8036,-0.42525,0.40252,8.6113e-05,0.00030779 +0.6500,2.7404,2.8127,2.9095,-0.39242,0.35963,0.0001646,0.00029047 +0.6400,2.7891,2.8956,3.0202,-0.34275,0.30382,0.00024904,0.00026389 +0.6300,2.8538,2.9861,3.1308,-0.27193,0.23706,0.00032002,0.00022243 +0.6200,2.9193,3.066,3.2244,-0.19882,0.18296,0.00035934,0.00017744 +0.6100,2.9927,3.1471,3.3076,-0.15631,0.15863,0.00037127,0.00013668 +0.6000,3.0734,3.2294,3.3796,-0.18552,0.16613,0.00035681,0.00011903 +0.5900,3.1603,3.3081,3.4513,-0.2554,0.19775,0.00031759,0.00013763 +0.5800,3.2535,3.3898,3.5134,-0.32167,0.25838,0.0002572,0.00018268 +0.5700,3.3738,3.4801,3.5814,-0.38837,0.34076,0.00017182,0.00023879 +0.5600,3.5001,3.5679,3.6405,-0.44064,0.41526,9.7351e-05,0.00028742 +0.5500,3.5764,3.6516,3.7082,-0.47588,0.47013,0.00010135,0.00031944 +0.5400,3.6185,3.733,3.8091,-0.50072,0.51188,0.00016688,0.00034108 +0.5300,3.6684,3.8094,3.9231,-0.51782,0.54591,0.0002452,0.00035616 +0.5200,3.7321,3.8887,4.0316,-0.53148,0.57481,0.00031233,0.00036729 +0.5100,3.802,3.9721,4.1244,-0.53877,0.59167,0.00035488,0.00037623 +0.5000,3.8914,4.066,4.2212,-0.53891,0.59832,0.00037072,0.00038446 +0.4900,3.9872,4.1522,4.3114,-0.53107,0.59141,0.00035392,0.00038988 +0.4800,4.0814,4.2327,4.3768,-0.5161,0.57513,0.00031377,0.00039001 +0.4700,4.1856,4.3153,4.4341,-0.49395,0.54753,0.00025157,0.00038551 +0.4600,4.2955,4.3981,4.4865,-0.46551,0.51141,0.00017562,0.0003784 +0.4500,4.407,4.4799,4.5413,-0.43501,0.47282,0.00010564,0.00036985 +0.4400,4.4971,4.5554,4.6207,-0.40034,0.42703,9.144e-05,0.00035862 +0.4300,4.551,4.6336,4.7304,-0.34687,0.36303,0.00015908,0.00033958 +0.4200,4.5883,4.7088,4.8319,-0.28251,0.29375,0.00024128,0.00031065 +0.4100,4.6243,4.7681,4.9222,-0.21851,0.22844,0.00030687,0.00027443 +0.4000,4.6633,4.8192,4.9986,-0.16309,0.17896,0.00035327,0.0002376 +0.3900,4.7052,4.8721,5.0535,-0.16232,0.16651,0.00037688,0.00022019 +0.3800,4.7506,4.9151,5.093,-0.22282,0.19312,0.00037459,0.00024244 +0.3700,4.799,4.9496,5.1178,-0.30212,0.25066,0.00034597,0.00029725 +0.3600,4.8554,4.9843,5.1261,-0.38638,0.33723,0.00028627,0.00036854 +0.3500,4.9067,5.0048,5.1192,-0.45873,0.42121,0.00020677,0.00042215 +0.3400,4.9508,5.0149,5.0999,-0.51034,0.48759,0.00012806,0.0004436 +0.3300,4.9419,5.0178,5.0795,-0.54782,0.54119,8.7681e-05,0.00043541 +0.3200,4.9009,5.0121,5.0893,-0.57064,0.5794,0.00013044,0.00039845 +0.3100,4.8518,5.0031,5.1153,-0.57925,0.60236,0.00021014,0.00034501 +0.3000,4.8002,4.9795,5.1261,-0.57523,0.6143,0.00029686,0.00027817 +0.2900,4.747,4.9381,5.1114,-0.56515,0.61286,0.00035825,0.00023133 +0.2800,4.7017,4.8967,5.0816,-0.55156,0.60628,0.00038943,0.00021845 +0.2700,4.6553,4.8379,5.025,-0.53445,0.59104,0.00039489,0.00022885 +0.2600,4.6066,4.7718,4.9517,-0.5166,0.57136,0.00037274,0.00024826 +0.2500,4.5491,4.6962,4.8605,-0.49362,0.54696,0.00032462,0.0002694 +0.2400,4.494,4.6094,4.7447,-0.46266,0.5139,0.000252,0.00029076 +0.2300,4.4148,4.4927,4.5841,-0.41472,0.4683,0.00014715,0.00031481 +0.2200,4.3457,4.3853,4.4381,-0.37158,0.4222,6.0272e-05,0.00033278 +0.2100,4.2102,4.2669,4.3249,-0.326,0.36883,8.9822e-05,0.00033981 +0.2000,4.0589,4.1495,4.2369,-0.277,0.3048,0.00017622,0.00033013 +0.1900,3.8901,4.0167,4.1434,-0.21433,0.22727,0.00026628,0.00029683 +0.1800,3.7214,3.8778,4.0315,-0.1427,0.14666,0.00033742,0.00024151 +0.1700,3.5664,3.7361,3.8994,-0.097125,0.15371,0.00038225,0.00017972 +0.1600,3.3743,3.5511,3.725,-0.16064,0.23645,0.00040285,0.00014794 +0.1500,3.2167,3.3863,3.5632,-0.25134,0.31015,0.00038586,0.0002077 +0.1400,3.066,3.2196,3.3839,-0.33479,0.38961,0.00033984,0.00030529 +0.1300,2.9062,3.0401,3.1699,-0.41054,0.46778,0.00026703,0.00040652 +0.1200,2.7525,2.8496,2.9588,-0.47122,0.53462,0.00017445,0.0004884 +0.1100,2.6089,2.6684,2.7395,-0.51217,0.58905,7.9989e-05,0.00054389 +0.1000,2.3897,2.4329,2.486,-0.54024,0.6273,8.4964e-05,0.00057961 +0.0900,2.1551,2.2381,2.3285,-0.54408,0.64173,0.00018399,0.00058051 +0.0800,1.9094,2.024,2.1495,-0.53301,0.63363,0.00028081,0.00056315 +0.0700,1.6626,1.8025,1.9546,-0.50829,0.61046,0.00035547,0.00053216 +0.0600,1.4182,1.5843,1.7432,-0.47405,0.56936,0.00039862,0.0004927 +0.0500,1.1751,1.3437,1.5032,-0.4232,0.51409,0.00041188,0.00044171 +0.0400,0.93218,1.0835,1.2343,-0.36826,0.43748,0.00038866,0.00037977 +0.0300,0.67291,0.79694,0.91793,-0.28456,0.33676,0.00032166,0.0002965 +0.0200,0.43949,0.52626,0.61258,-0.19439,0.22871,0.00022871,0.00020435 +0.0100,0.20938,0.26178,0.30531,-0.096692,0.11545,0.00011738,0.00010336 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case5_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case5_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0a29120 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case5_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.044634,0.09524,0.14572,-0.069408,0.096368,0.00010265,0.00010314 +0.9800,0.087322,0.20139,0.28883,-0.14186,0.18758,0.00019604,0.00019599 +0.9700,0.14484,0.29211,0.4145,-0.2094,0.27526,0.00026381,0.00026406 +0.9600,0.24145,0.41925,0.55212,-0.28562,0.36951,0.00030953,0.000321 +0.9500,0.33932,0.51712,0.65902,-0.34786,0.44219,0.00031102,0.00035408 +0.9400,0.44868,0.62565,0.74693,-0.39534,0.49541,0.00028016,0.00038351 +0.9300,0.55788,0.72491,0.83106,-0.43901,0.53259,0.00022388,0.00041394 +0.9200,0.70342,0.83337,0.91311,-0.46766,0.56056,0.00014606,0.00044388 +0.9100,0.83422,0.93222,1.012,-0.47578,0.56532,7.7114e-05,0.00045702 +0.9000,0.96213,1.034,1.1487,-0.4652,0.55089,8.8133e-05,0.00044544 +0.8900,1.0617,1.1736,1.3284,-0.4176,0.49996,0.00017508,0.0003913 +0.8800,1.1391,1.2759,1.4559,-0.36426,0.44322,0.00023938,0.0003287 +0.8700,1.2298,1.3824,1.5773,-0.29695,0.37228,0.00028656,0.0002665 +0.8600,1.3238,1.4928,1.6789,-0.22724,0.2984,0.0003068,0.00023786 +0.8500,1.4323,1.6019,1.7772,-0.1575,0.2197,0.00030013,0.0002457 +0.8400,1.5645,1.7133,1.8617,-0.13532,0.17976,0.00026941,0.00026298 +0.8300,1.7204,1.84,1.9478,-0.16346,0.2294,0.00020324,0.00025672 +0.8200,1.8608,1.9517,2.0365,-0.22441,0.26504,0.00013612,0.00022649 +0.8100,1.9929,2.0604,2.132,-0.28299,0.30884,8.7809e-05,0.00019734 +0.8000,2.0827,2.1685,2.2472,-0.33821,0.37869,0.00010271,0.00020996 +0.7900,2.1548,2.2754,2.3866,-0.38751,0.46423,0.00016691,0.00027799 +0.7800,2.223,2.3851,2.5207,-0.43272,0.53567,0.00022899,0.00036038 +0.7700,2.3092,2.4988,2.6571,-0.48423,0.5932,0.00027957,0.0004327 +0.7600,2.4251,2.6277,2.799,-0.5229,0.63286,0.00030534,0.00047122 +0.7500,2.5343,2.736,2.9086,-0.54385,0.64498,0.000301,0.00047139 +0.7400,2.648,2.8431,3.0005,-0.55381,0.64113,0.0002736,0.00045295 +0.7300,2.7802,2.949,3.0877,-0.55617,0.62413,0.00022473,0.0004314 +0.7200,2.9188,3.0543,3.1739,-0.54237,0.59896,0.00016326,0.0004208 +0.7100,3.0616,3.1609,3.2687,-0.51458,0.56985,0.00010688,0.00041979 +0.7000,3.1917,3.2744,3.3918,-0.47345,0.52225,0.00010285,0.00041444 +0.6900,3.2984,3.3996,3.5506,-0.40669,0.44804,0.00017207,0.00038143 +0.6800,3.3801,3.5018,3.6755,-0.34655,0.37755,0.00023717,0.00032477 +0.6700,3.4687,3.6087,3.7921,-0.28746,0.2965,0.00028854,0.00024493 +0.6600,3.5579,3.7106,3.8924,-0.23908,0.22837,0.0003153,0.00017112 +0.6500,3.6638,3.8139,3.9841,-0.20613,0.17763,0.00031512,0.00014582 +0.6400,3.7805,3.9258,4.0678,-0.2048,0.17248,0.00028373,0.00019634 +0.6300,3.9227,4.0454,4.1616,-0.26661,0.25756,0.00021902,0.00027308 +0.6200,4.0607,4.1517,4.2447,-0.34577,0.34513,0.00014759,0.00032495 +0.6100,4.1887,4.2558,4.3282,-0.41178,0.41936,0.00010086,0.00035746 +0.6000,4.2795,4.3592,4.4405,-0.46303,0.48016,0.0001176,0.0003807 +0.5900,4.3427,4.4673,4.5836,-0.50187,0.53113,0.00018408,0.00040625 +0.5800,4.4122,4.5762,4.7155,-0.52862,0.57347,0.00025088,0.000439 +0.5700,4.5033,4.6909,4.8484,-0.54353,0.6076,0.00030281,0.0004785 +0.5600,4.6139,4.8137,4.9748,-0.55377,0.62152,0.00032239,0.00050619 +0.5500,4.7258,4.9202,5.0802,-0.56229,0.6163,0.00031027,0.00050888 +0.5400,4.8521,5.0205,5.1733,-0.56101,0.59234,0.00027281,0.00048769 +0.5300,4.9908,5.1251,5.2575,-0.54568,0.54824,0.0002132,0.00044393 +0.5200,5.136,5.2344,5.3387,-0.51461,0.49085,0.00014194,0.00038488 +0.5100,5.2675,5.3432,5.4334,-0.47049,0.42868,0.00010034,0.0003298 +0.5000,5.3738,5.463,5.5679,-0.40605,0.35201,0.00012884,0.00028709 +0.4900,5.4553,5.5784,5.7098,-0.32425,0.2923,0.00020176,0.00026807 +0.4800,5.5371,5.6852,5.836,-0.2536,0.28127,0.00026054,0.00026176 +0.4700,5.6338,5.7937,5.9589,-0.22785,0.30189,0.00030224,0.00025567 +0.4600,5.7375,5.9018,6.0673,-0.24978,0.32915,0.00031827,0.00025168 +0.4500,5.846,6.0058,6.1698,-0.28149,0.35181,0.00030782,0.00026341 +0.4400,5.9586,6.1087,6.2643,-0.33397,0.37877,0.0002722,0.00030635 +0.4300,6.0874,6.2157,6.3477,-0.41567,0.43117,0.00020964,0.00038926 +0.4200,6.209,6.309,6.4089,-0.47967,0.48735,0.00014454,0.00048139 +0.4100,6.2896,6.3908,6.4563,-0.51813,0.5245,0.00011093,0.00056086 +0.4000,6.3421,6.4636,6.5324,-0.53156,0.5424,0.00013131,0.00061901 +0.3900,6.3769,6.5281,6.6284,-0.52482,0.53793,0.00018609,0.00064565 +0.3800,6.4076,6.5808,6.7113,-0.50783,0.50863,0.00024391,0.00063413 +0.3700,6.4408,6.6239,6.7749,-0.47613,0.45768,0.00028584,0.00058602 +0.3600,6.4799,6.667,6.832,-0.41626,0.38949,0.00030861,0.00049742 +0.3500,6.5164,6.6974,6.872,-0.34058,0.31542,0.00030468,0.00039395 +0.3400,6.5451,6.717,6.8819,-0.27364,0.31037,0.00027968,0.00031278 +0.3300,6.5724,6.7288,6.8779,-0.29174,0.34784,0.0002378,0.00027372 +0.3200,6.5979,6.7262,6.858,-0.36097,0.39465,0.00018706,0.00029001 +0.3100,6.6139,6.7194,6.8258,-0.4301,0.44013,0.00014502,0.00033545 +0.3000,6.6096,6.6963,6.7911,-0.50229,0.49123,0.00013263,0.00039014 +0.2900,6.5576,6.6527,6.7835,-0.5599,0.53764,0.00016499,0.00043022 +0.2800,6.4779,6.6107,6.7723,-0.60318,0.57415,0.000211,0.00045654 +0.2700,6.3959,6.5445,6.7344,-0.64394,0.59648,0.00025605,0.00047599 +0.2600,6.3055,6.4689,6.6719,-0.68296,0.6198,0.00028792,0.00048606 +0.2500,6.2117,6.3871,6.584,-0.71031,0.64492,0.00030355,0.00048433 +0.2400,6.1074,6.2832,6.4651,-0.71721,0.65259,0.000299,0.00046817 +0.2300,5.9906,6.144,6.3084,-0.69742,0.65259,0.00026791,0.00043774 +0.2200,5.8798,6.0247,6.1611,-0.66353,0.64402,0.00022029,0.00042108 +0.2100,5.7597,5.8812,5.9893,-0.61281,0.62054,0.00016058,0.00043359 +0.2000,5.6401,5.7347,5.8149,-0.54776,0.58097,0.00010959,0.00047486 +0.1900,5.4728,5.5624,5.6255,-0.46991,0.52272,0.00010777,0.00052728 +0.1800,5.262,5.3847,5.4672,-0.3865,0.44308,0.00016017,0.00056075 +0.1700,5.051,5.2009,5.317,-0.29519,0.34914,0.00022381,0.00055138 +0.1600,4.7894,4.9649,5.1129,-0.19007,0.21525,0.00028821,0.00047294 +0.1500,4.567,4.7496,4.9193,-0.24323,0.14474,0.00031686,0.00034328 +0.1400,4.3452,4.5232,4.7008,-0.33336,0.25793,0.00031915,0.0001718 +0.1300,4.1216,4.2824,4.4445,-0.4406,0.40545,0.00029081,0.00014344 +0.1200,3.9013,4.0362,4.1713,-0.54625,0.54818,0.00023491,0.00034099 +0.1100,3.688,3.7848,3.8856,-0.66554,0.67191,0.00016047,0.00056601 +0.1000,3.4107,3.4625,3.5241,-0.79054,0.79539,6.3268e-05,0.00082167 +0.0900,3.1225,3.1953,3.2802,-0.85547,0.85791,8.2891e-05,0.00099122 +0.0800,2.7743,2.8885,3.0281,-0.88662,0.89041,0.00017263,0.001127 +0.0700,2.4296,2.5724,2.7552,-0.87789,0.88659,0.00025557,0.0012019 +0.0600,2.0954,2.2584,2.462,-0.84427,0.84719,0.00031281,0.0012168 +0.0500,1.7363,1.9185,2.124,-0.77711,0.78875,0.00034304,0.0011673 +0.0400,1.3836,1.5531,1.7586,-0.68516,0.69525,0.0003373,0.0010491 +0.0300,0.99594,1.1471,1.3137,-0.54415,0.55004,0.0002877,0.00084005 +0.0200,0.65391,0.75781,0.87961,-0.37465,0.38078,0.00020801,0.00058672 +0.0100,0.32282,0.37219,0.43043,-0.19001,0.19241,0.00010738,0.0002976 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case6_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case6_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c6561dc --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case6_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.068388,0.12197,0.17246,-0.076786,0.10473,0.00021061,0.00011033 +0.9800,0.15903,0.25546,0.34881,-0.15678,0.20889,0.00039692,0.00021621 +0.9700,0.24075,0.38079,0.50384,-0.22692,0.30031,0.00052324,0.00030648 +0.9600,0.37649,0.53541,0.66828,-0.3119,0.40248,0.00058814,0.00040676 +0.9500,0.51134,0.66339,0.8056,-0.37322,0.47557,0.00055455,0.00048691 +0.9400,0.65597,0.79475,0.91856,-0.41909,0.53169,0.00044877,0.0005585 +0.9300,0.81503,0.9313,1.0364,-0.4457,0.56076,0.00029585,0.00061147 +0.9200,0.94889,1.0648,1.1925,-0.45217,0.5707,0.00013204,0.00063556 +0.9100,1.0302,1.1898,1.3524,-0.43769,0.55766,0.00017289,0.00061984 +0.9000,1.1175,1.3265,1.521,-0.40643,0.52158,0.00034623,0.0005622 +0.8900,1.2471,1.4893,1.7224,-0.34153,0.45078,0.00052568,0.00044798 +0.8800,1.367,1.6256,1.8752,-0.27526,0.37948,0.00060796,0.00035589 +0.8700,1.4941,1.7599,2.0147,-0.20709,0.29434,0.00062374,0.00029462 +0.8600,1.6397,1.8969,2.1337,-0.14844,0.21442,0.00057346,0.00028046 +0.8500,1.8191,2.0396,2.2375,-0.13923,0.1406,0.0004584,0.00028339 +0.8400,1.9904,2.1741,2.3325,-0.18813,0.18147,0.00031021,0.00027074 +0.8300,2.2182,2.3336,2.4617,-0.25357,0.268,0.00016727,0.00024358 +0.8200,2.3813,2.4745,2.5937,-0.31592,0.33283,0.00020827,0.00025826 +0.8100,2.4651,2.6157,2.7549,-0.37641,0.39335,0.00035718,0.00033331 +0.8000,2.5615,2.7529,2.9242,-0.43531,0.44028,0.00048371,0.00043102 +0.7900,2.6777,2.8923,3.0909,-0.4809,0.48137,0.00056831,0.00051788 +0.7800,2.7964,3.0267,3.2417,-0.50863,0.50991,0.00059633,0.00057169 +0.7700,2.938,3.1678,3.3867,-0.51769,0.54242,0.00056075,0.00059338 +0.7600,3.1258,3.331,3.526,-0.51003,0.56752,0.00045062,0.00059546 +0.7500,3.2986,3.4689,3.6373,-0.50615,0.58548,0.0003183,0.00059957 +0.7400,3.4691,3.6006,3.7602,-0.49778,0.58686,0.00020306,0.00060731 +0.7300,3.6208,3.7369,3.8987,-0.47077,0.56641,0.00018909,0.00060429 +0.7200,3.7088,3.8663,4.0408,-0.4237,0.52282,0.00030514,0.00056762 +0.7100,3.8173,4.0077,4.2014,-0.35954,0.4551,0.00044438,0.00047796 +0.7000,3.9274,4.1413,4.3596,-0.29767,0.3675,0.00054788,0.00033875 +0.6900,4.0785,4.2972,4.5109,-0.22203,0.26072,0.00059669,0.00017728 +0.6800,4.2191,4.4301,4.6241,-0.19947,0.20933,0.00057429,0.00016052 +0.6700,4.3743,4.5637,4.7329,-0.25224,0.22398,0.00049179,0.00028011 +0.6600,4.5391,4.685,4.8276,-0.32748,0.29123,0.00036578,0.00038857 +0.6500,4.7069,4.8185,4.9368,-0.40269,0.37236,0.0002259,0.00044877 +0.6400,4.839,4.9576,5.0915,-0.46341,0.44264,0.00017844,0.00046213 +0.6300,4.9245,5.1047,5.2843,-0.5074,0.50523,0.00031645,0.00045972 +0.6200,5.0136,5.2368,5.4544,-0.53949,0.54662,0.00046909,0.00048604 +0.6100,5.111,5.3692,5.6113,-0.56467,0.5746,0.00057958,0.00054948 +0.6000,5.2243,5.5023,5.7561,-0.58444,0.58828,0.00063113,0.00062446 +0.5900,5.3572,5.6358,5.8807,-0.59448,0.58786,0.00061781,0.0006799 +0.5800,5.5014,5.7673,5.9892,-0.58544,0.5752,0.00054089,0.00069539 +0.5700,5.6812,5.9131,6.0961,-0.55883,0.54262,0.00039452,0.00066249 +0.5600,5.8816,6.0576,6.1887,-0.51454,0.49485,0.00023419,0.00059288 +0.5500,6.0628,6.1852,6.2848,-0.46683,0.44377,0.00019887,0.00052141 +0.5400,6.207,6.3128,6.4189,-0.41669,0.38343,0.00029578,0.00045655 +0.5300,6.3086,6.4448,6.5794,-0.35482,0.30752,0.00043914,0.00039927 +0.5200,6.3991,6.5786,6.7369,-0.27431,0.25094,0.00055334,0.00034979 +0.5100,6.4981,6.7083,6.8811,-0.21164,0.25399,0.00060691,0.00032018 +0.5000,6.6297,6.8583,7.0265,-0.24558,0.27731,0.00059216,0.00032973 +0.4900,6.7726,7.0067,7.1567,-0.356,0.29735,0.00050622,0.00038565 +0.4800,6.9115,7.1329,7.2622,-0.4474,0.3428,0.00038758,0.00044604 +0.4700,7.0604,7.2687,7.3804,-0.52596,0.41698,0.00025911,0.00048842 +0.4600,7.1951,7.4024,7.5188,-0.58535,0.48654,0.00021128,0.00049078 +0.4500,7.3068,7.5272,7.669,-0.62421,0.53763,0.00028465,0.00044961 +0.4400,7.4101,7.649,7.8219,-0.64418,0.5729,0.00041735,0.00037272 +0.4300,7.5199,7.7735,7.9802,-0.64636,0.59358,0.00054031,0.00028746 +0.4200,7.6143,7.8793,8.0995,-0.63182,0.59512,0.00060051,0.00027021 +0.4100,7.7051,7.9641,8.1843,-0.6166,0.58709,0.00059923,0.0003232 +0.4000,7.801,8.0308,8.2374,-0.60676,0.57478,0.00054134,0.00040677 +0.3900,7.8921,8.0859,8.2562,-0.6013,0.55621,0.00043242,0.00048779 +0.3800,7.9713,8.1299,8.2553,-0.59518,0.52968,0.00028307,0.00055503 +0.3700,8.0084,8.1558,8.2404,-0.58159,0.49703,0.00015446,0.00059873 +0.3600,8.0021,8.1696,8.278,-0.55034,0.45717,0.00018635,0.00061661 +0.3500,7.9566,8.1727,8.3372,-0.49601,0.40248,0.00034838,0.00059381 +0.3400,7.905,8.1604,8.3731,-0.42818,0.33936,0.00049056,0.0005322 +0.3300,7.8533,8.1365,8.39,-0.33456,0.25845,0.00059533,0.00043248 +0.3200,7.8056,8.1045,8.3776,-0.23421,0.2331,0.0006432,0.00032033 +0.3100,7.761,8.0644,8.3405,-0.22088,0.26529,0.0006277,0.00026796 +0.3000,7.7189,8.0022,8.2643,-0.28977,0.31751,0.0005368,0.00033295 +0.2900,7.6739,7.9301,8.1658,-0.39446,0.42045,0.00038382,0.00046283 +0.2800,7.6246,7.8459,8.0509,-0.48804,0.53179,0.00020665,0.00056702 +0.2700,7.5634,7.7491,7.932,-0.57779,0.63249,0.00011813,0.00063384 +0.2600,7.4663,7.6506,7.859,-0.64945,0.70895,0.00024585,0.00065138 +0.2500,7.3228,7.527,7.7799,-0.70441,0.76293,0.00042939,0.0006312 +0.2400,7.1597,7.3861,7.6774,-0.73767,0.79813,0.00058146,0.00058793 +0.2300,6.969,7.2069,7.5254,-0.7517,0.80676,0.00068239,0.00053814 +0.2200,6.8088,7.0434,7.3572,-0.74414,0.7939,0.00068667,0.00051572 +0.2100,6.6588,6.8619,7.1438,-0.72362,0.76754,0.00061593,0.00051032 +0.2000,6.5037,6.6686,6.9181,-0.68584,0.72274,0.00048139,0.00051203 +0.1900,6.3328,6.4581,6.6501,-0.63311,0.6592,0.00028779,0.0005041 +0.1800,6.1156,6.2325,6.3887,-0.56363,0.60238,9.5094e-05,0.0004755 +0.1700,5.8686,5.9983,6.1805,-0.48603,0.54173,0.00019506,0.00042002 +0.1600,5.5143,5.6991,5.9339,-0.37646,0.4533,0.0004363,0.00031603 +0.1500,5.2212,5.439,5.7104,-0.2777,0.3673,0.00059587,0.00021746 +0.1400,4.9247,5.1623,5.454,-0.21193,0.28841,0.00069214,0.00019128 +0.1300,4.6183,4.8648,5.16,-0.23539,0.33754,0.0007099,0.00029639 +0.1200,4.3344,4.5666,4.8457,-0.28857,0.39345,0.00064345,0.00045091 +0.1100,4.0604,4.27,4.5181,-0.34685,0.44316,0.00050826,0.00058987 +0.1000,3.7393,3.8979,4.0846,-0.41671,0.49604,0.00027637,0.00071811 +0.0900,3.4686,3.5875,3.7159,-0.46818,0.5297,7.4395e-05,0.00076743 +0.0800,3.1379,3.2369,3.3446,-0.49865,0.55685,0.0002136,0.0007685 +0.0700,2.7502,2.884,3.0323,-0.50354,0.55775,0.00042144,0.00072249 +0.0600,2.3637,2.5327,2.713,-0.48388,0.53839,0.00057584,0.00064899 +0.0500,1.9604,2.1463,2.35,-0.43809,0.48845,0.0006718,0.00055499 +0.0400,1.5555,1.7339,1.9397,-0.37257,0.41924,0.00068287,0.00045297 +0.0300,1.1194,1.2769,1.4527,-0.28437,0.32171,0.00059591,0.00033848 +0.0200,0.73081,0.84413,0.97485,-0.19058,0.21739,0.00043591,0.0002287 +0.0100,0.3548,0.41584,0.4798,-0.096692,0.10967,0.00022704,0.00011438 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case7_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case7_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..851026d --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case7_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.10407,0.13093,0.18141,-0.1063,0.10129,0.00013514,0.00024052 +0.9800,0.21049,0.27061,0.35804,-0.2077,0.19509,0.00025397,0.00045632 +0.9700,0.32927,0.40739,0.52698,-0.2842,0.26899,0.00032962,0.00060945 +0.9600,0.48542,0.57356,0.71484,-0.35414,0.32919,0.00036139,0.00071731 +0.9500,0.63865,0.71682,0.86059,-0.39293,0.3591,0.00032884,0.00073979 +0.9400,0.79309,0.85895,0.99829,-0.40919,0.38052,0.00025248,0.00071896 +0.9300,0.91258,0.99347,1.1158,-0.41202,0.40405,0.00015769,0.00067935 +0.9200,1.0373,1.1454,1.262,-0.40133,0.41433,0.0001107,0.00063411 +0.9100,1.1653,1.2879,1.4045,-0.37579,0.40706,0.00018894,0.00059051 +0.9000,1.2903,1.4246,1.5556,-0.33394,0.37964,0.00028746,0.00053481 +0.8900,1.4669,1.6074,1.7402,-0.26554,0.31199,0.00036664,0.00042688 +0.8800,1.6183,1.7536,1.8752,-0.2208,0.24798,0.00038107,0.00031244 +0.8700,1.792,1.9045,2.0155,-0.19377,0.18598,0.0003425,0.00018282 +0.8600,1.962,2.0477,2.1408,-0.25883,0.21133,0.00026265,0.00011035 +0.8500,2.1471,2.1985,2.2625,-0.35107,0.31437,0.00014938,0.00019488 +0.8400,2.3088,2.3354,2.4254,-0.4343,0.40853,7.7967e-05,0.00031666 +0.8300,2.4531,2.5201,2.6421,-0.52134,0.51211,0.00019086,0.00045294 +0.8200,2.5797,2.6704,2.8179,-0.58091,0.58084,0.00029906,0.00055761 +0.8100,2.7141,2.8225,2.9844,-0.62457,0.63133,0.00037256,0.0006523 +0.8000,2.8529,2.9661,3.1353,-0.65224,0.66333,0.00039751,0.00072812 +0.7900,3.0037,3.1145,3.2832,-0.6602,0.67795,0.00037483,0.00078028 +0.7800,3.1649,3.2612,3.4091,-0.65173,0.67585,0.00031097,0.00079259 +0.7700,3.3364,3.4178,3.5455,-0.62896,0.65423,0.00021425,0.00075502 +0.7600,3.4976,3.5886,3.6905,-0.57233,0.60324,0.00014977,0.00065175 +0.7500,3.6306,3.7319,3.8176,-0.505,0.53789,0.00018937,0.00052945 +0.7400,3.7602,3.8767,3.9573,-0.42438,0.46321,0.00027345,0.00040204 +0.7300,3.9003,4.0258,4.1267,-0.33219,0.37012,0.0003432,0.00028952 +0.7200,4.0474,4.1692,4.2786,-0.24494,0.26942,0.00037423,0.00022446 +0.7100,4.2081,4.3156,4.4275,-0.19473,0.18441,0.00036063,0.00021816 +0.7000,4.3624,4.4648,4.5699,-0.20275,0.20651,0.00030242,0.00025399 +0.6900,4.5358,4.6282,4.7197,-0.2831,0.2807,0.00020333,0.00032399 +0.6800,4.6752,4.7673,4.8537,-0.36474,0.3683,0.00014352,0.0004026 +0.6700,4.7995,4.9072,5.0119,-0.4432,0.45185,0.00016305,0.00049577 +0.6600,4.9151,5.0436,5.1676,-0.5073,0.52004,0.00024323,0.00058763 +0.6500,5.0485,5.1853,5.3285,-0.55845,0.56734,0.00031976,0.00066951 +0.6400,5.1938,5.3312,5.4841,-0.58817,0.59321,0.00036439,0.00073183 +0.6300,5.3626,5.4904,5.6492,-0.58923,0.59155,0.00036046,0.00076329 +0.6200,5.5173,5.6332,5.7858,-0.56441,0.56992,0.00031265,0.00075732 +0.6100,5.6702,5.7735,5.9048,-0.51898,0.53302,0.0002367,0.0007165 +0.6000,5.8099,5.9108,6.0152,-0.45817,0.47966,0.00016477,0.00064189 +0.5900,5.9383,6.0475,6.1275,-0.38756,0.40985,0.00014737,0.00053394 +0.5800,6.0675,6.1861,6.2604,-0.32005,0.33309,0.00020349,0.00040218 +0.5700,6.2213,6.3431,6.4469,-0.26837,0.25424,0.00028892,0.00026535 +0.5600,6.3861,6.5053,6.6239,-0.2405,0.19563,0.00034587,0.0002378 +0.5500,6.5316,6.6454,6.7647,-0.24486,0.197,0.00035707,0.00032659 +0.5400,6.6712,6.7803,6.8896,-0.2841,0.24775,0.000331,0.00044633 +0.5300,6.8118,6.9178,7.0198,-0.3504,0.31303,0.00027148,0.00055073 +0.5200,6.957,7.0611,7.1486,-0.42179,0.3734,0.00019577,0.00062125 +0.5100,7.0959,7.2014,7.2853,-0.4786,0.41925,0.00015718,0.0006554 +0.5000,7.2413,7.3565,7.4734,-0.52423,0.45524,0.00019891,0.00066763 +0.4900,7.3859,7.5084,7.6577,-0.55134,0.48514,0.00028467,0.00067079 +0.4800,7.5209,7.6486,7.8127,-0.55514,0.50137,0.00034727,0.00067493 +0.4700,7.6657,7.7929,7.9615,-0.54044,0.49857,0.00037939,0.00067825 +0.4600,7.8209,7.9316,8.1014,-0.50575,0.47467,0.00036954,0.00067085 +0.4500,7.9756,8.0653,8.2264,-0.45086,0.43379,0.00031931,0.00064272 +0.4400,8.1205,8.2005,8.337,-0.38253,0.37391,0.00023508,0.00058344 +0.4300,8.2641,8.3434,8.4462,-0.29374,0.29644,0.00014362,0.00047668 +0.4200,8.3818,8.4652,8.5558,-0.20088,0.23164,0.0001517,0.00033982 +0.4100,8.4698,8.5724,8.6791,-0.22968,0.24085,0.00023657,0.00020289 +0.4000,8.551,8.6685,8.7941,-0.33443,0.32746,0.00032879,0.00018908 +0.3900,8.6316,8.7466,8.8832,-0.4403,0.4327,0.00039129,0.00034293 +0.3800,8.6894,8.8122,8.9475,-0.53817,0.53116,0.00041003,0.00057539 +0.3700,8.7298,8.8621,8.9904,-0.61508,0.61623,0.00037984,0.00079942 +0.3600,8.7707,8.9044,9.0125,-0.67232,0.69077,0.00029538,0.0010127 +0.3500,8.802,8.9301,9.0095,-0.69498,0.73152,0.00018733,0.0011516 +0.3400,8.8223,8.9356,9.0355,-0.68161,0.73544,0.00014276,0.0011991 +0.3300,8.8229,8.9299,9.0677,-0.64148,0.70927,0.00020469,0.0011651 +0.3200,8.7916,8.9148,9.0771,-0.57696,0.65342,0.00031478,0.0010457 +0.3100,8.7486,8.8856,9.0603,-0.49053,0.57226,0.00040273,0.00086144 +0.3000,8.6971,8.8338,9.0113,-0.36435,0.45041,0.00045384,0.00059094 +0.2900,8.629,8.7711,8.9337,-0.2245,0.31673,0.00043944,0.00030952 +0.2800,8.568,8.698,8.8363,-0.12519,0.19354,0.00037277,0.00016865 +0.2700,8.5,8.6089,8.7109,-0.20367,0.24967,0.00026327,0.00030211 +0.2600,8.4297,8.5048,8.5706,-0.33128,0.37629,0.0001538,0.00051734 +0.2500,8.3128,8.3879,8.4536,-0.45462,0.49965,0.00015227,0.00071669 +0.2400,8.145,8.2485,8.3456,-0.56264,0.60311,0.00025745,0.00088535 +0.2300,7.9283,8.0682,8.1914,-0.65573,0.68489,0.000394,0.0010266 +0.2200,7.7472,7.8964,8.0385,-0.69935,0.71759,0.00046557,0.0010962 +0.2100,7.5561,7.7063,7.8504,-0.70892,0.72502,0.00048473,0.0011191 +0.2000,7.371,7.5066,7.6409,-0.68368,0.70886,0.00044752,0.0010932 +0.1900,7.168,7.2803,7.3858,-0.62112,0.66358,0.00035782,0.0010133 +0.1800,6.9485,7.0343,7.1134,-0.53448,0.5869,0.00023265,0.00088064 +0.1700,6.723,6.7847,6.8357,-0.4361,0.49015,0.00013404,0.00070662 +0.1600,6.3869,6.4524,6.5157,-0.29886,0.34826,0.00019061,0.00044685 +0.1500,6.0709,6.1711,6.2657,-0.17834,0.22059,0.00031537,0.00022439 +0.1400,5.7369,5.8673,5.9946,-0.087892,0.18098,0.00041888,0.00020671 +0.1300,5.3939,5.5433,5.6935,-0.1929,0.29046,0.00047627,0.00041575 +0.1200,5.067,5.2118,5.3763,-0.31468,0.40515,0.00047231,0.00064499 +0.1100,4.7465,4.8802,5.0412,-0.41677,0.49152,0.00041344,0.00082618 +0.1000,4.3518,4.4649,4.6088,-0.52274,0.58335,0.00028347,0.00097676 +0.0900,4.0228,4.1137,4.2283,-0.58142,0.63578,0.00015346,0.0010234 +0.0800,3.6368,3.7172,3.809,-0.61274,0.65553,0.00011889,0.0010073 +0.0700,3.206,3.3213,3.41,-0.61376,0.64544,0.00024123,0.00093465 +0.0600,2.7842,2.9168,3.0289,-0.58701,0.60809,0.00035884,0.00082726 +0.0500,2.321,2.4789,2.6001,-0.53447,0.54429,0.00044169,0.0006922 +0.0400,1.8591,2.0099,2.1443,-0.45798,0.46073,0.00046453,0.00054798 +0.0300,1.3462,1.4792,1.6005,-0.35188,0.34679,0.00041597,0.00039271 +0.0200,0.88827,0.98063,1.0703,-0.23711,0.2361,0.00030818,0.0002553 +0.0100,0.43043,0.4798,0.5322,-0.1169,0.11929,0.00016198,0.00012469 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case8_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case8_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6b8bfcf --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case8_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.09524,0.17246,0.24085,-0.1122,0.13277,0.00020495,0.00024646 +0.9800,0.20139,0.35769,0.48133,-0.22159,0.25974,0.0003807,0.00046913 +0.9700,0.31725,0.53539,0.70861,-0.30997,0.36128,0.00049216,0.00063626 +0.9600,0.49401,0.7462,0.96939,-0.38995,0.45104,0.00053643,0.00076983 +0.9500,0.67707,0.93579,1.1869,-0.43214,0.49728,0.00049604,0.00082657 +0.9400,0.88171,1.1211,1.3993,-0.44875,0.50856,0.00041621,0.00084803 +0.9300,1.0912,1.3046,1.6063,-0.44046,0.49693,0.00035928,0.00085046 +0.9200,1.2349,1.4944,1.8253,-0.40648,0.4597,0.00039095,0.00083685 +0.9100,1.3861,1.6804,2.0086,-0.36468,0.4034,0.00048486,0.00080338 +0.9000,1.5547,1.8574,2.186,-0.34063,0.33751,0.0005732,0.00073209 +0.8900,1.7948,2.0956,2.3887,-0.28684,0.24038,0.00061051,0.00057507 +0.8800,2.001,2.2807,2.5289,-0.2405,0.21395,0.00056719,0.00041104 +0.8700,2.2458,2.4778,2.6543,-0.22047,0.2304,0.00045215,0.00023758 +0.8600,2.4844,2.6653,2.7851,-0.28808,0.30107,0.00030615,0.00017853 +0.8500,2.7451,2.8606,2.9604,-0.38475,0.43393,0.00019855,0.00032078 +0.8400,2.9192,3.0485,3.1748,-0.47548,0.55288,0.00027032,0.00048089 +0.8300,3.0672,3.2766,3.4208,-0.5778,0.68651,0.00045232,0.00063444 +0.8200,3.2035,3.4701,3.6291,-0.65985,0.7837,0.00057091,0.00073001 +0.8100,3.3584,3.6668,3.8538,-0.72973,0.85811,0.00062542,0.00079603 +0.8000,3.517,3.8535,4.0786,-0.78315,0.90599,0.0006134,0.00083879 +0.7900,3.7133,4.0443,4.2891,-0.83189,0.92522,0.00054623,0.00086359 +0.7800,3.9189,4.2325,4.4908,-0.8645,0.91471,0.0004563,0.00086797 +0.7700,4.1679,4.4351,4.7065,-0.86807,0.87323,0.00038914,0.00084481 +0.7600,4.4286,4.6545,4.9513,-0.84745,0.79236,0.00041726,0.0007867 +0.7500,4.6025,4.8459,5.149,-0.80239,0.71094,0.00049661,0.00071509 +0.7400,4.7449,5.0264,5.3243,-0.73534,0.62891,0.00056983,0.00063135 +0.7300,4.9127,5.2179,5.4912,-0.65243,0.54297,0.00060423,0.00053752 +0.7200,5.0895,5.3952,5.6305,-0.55038,0.45926,0.00058436,0.00044375 +0.7100,5.2944,5.5823,5.7577,-0.44036,0.37933,0.0005074,0.00036487 +0.7000,5.5167,5.769,5.9099,-0.34726,0.3348,0.00039101,0.00034745 +0.6900,5.7925,5.9747,6.1526,-0.39917,0.41568,0.00027899,0.00044292 +0.6800,5.9882,6.1473,6.347,-0.48792,0.48368,0.00027839,0.00057699 +0.6700,6.1161,6.3238,6.5354,-0.56197,0.55035,0.00037073,0.00071862 +0.6600,6.23,6.4946,6.7033,-0.61584,0.60012,0.00047614,0.00083137 +0.6500,6.3558,6.6701,6.8669,-0.64781,0.63816,0.00054993,0.00090489 +0.6400,6.5095,6.8503,7.0385,-0.65904,0.66196,0.00056979,0.00093079 +0.6300,6.7003,7.0408,7.2452,-0.65646,0.67389,0.00052483,0.00090805 +0.6200,6.8902,7.2191,7.4466,-0.64231,0.66092,0.00044658,0.00085925 +0.6100,7.0879,7.3944,7.6474,-0.61668,0.62145,0.00037379,0.00079768 +0.6000,7.2924,7.5626,7.8439,-0.57369,0.55989,0.00035514,0.00073123 +0.5900,7.4878,7.731,8.0373,-0.51606,0.47806,0.00040609,0.0006615 +0.5800,7.6452,7.9035,8.2161,-0.44734,0.3868,0.00048955,0.00059155 +0.5700,7.8129,8.0972,8.3937,-0.35744,0.32649,0.00056087,0.00052164 +0.5600,8.0042,8.2924,8.5431,-0.27886,0.33055,0.00057286,0.00048158 +0.5500,8.1946,8.4603,8.6589,-0.28221,0.33792,0.00052299,0.00048742 +0.5400,8.3911,8.6241,8.7694,-0.36421,0.36342,0.00042675,0.00052891 +0.5300,8.6068,8.7935,8.922,-0.46934,0.4222,0.0003063,0.00059657 +0.5200,8.8295,8.9648,9.1197,-0.56411,0.49966,0.00023898,0.00068263 +0.5100,8.9882,9.1352,9.3074,-0.63604,0.57563,0.00029739,0.00077732 +0.5000,9.1096,9.3238,9.5105,-0.68993,0.64757,0.00044225,0.00088928 +0.4900,9.2437,9.5106,9.7012,-0.72013,0.69193,0.00056486,0.0009968 +0.4800,9.3806,9.6793,9.881,-0.72187,0.70844,0.00061957,0.0010709 +0.4700,9.5428,9.8496,10.077,-0.69992,0.69809,0.00061342,0.0011092 +0.4600,9.7265,10.019,10.258,-0.65609,0.65918,0.00054716,0.0010949 +0.4500,9.9209,10.183,10.426,-0.59382,0.59868,0.00044162,0.0010235 +0.4400,10.128,10.345,10.608,-0.51325,0.51689,0.00033641,0.00089451 +0.4300,10.341,10.518,10.806,-0.43019,0.42228,0.00031187,0.00071046 +0.4200,10.465,10.663,10.966,-0.38655,0.37771,0.00039423,0.00055142 +0.4100,10.552,10.787,11.091,-0.3759,0.37924,0.00049558,0.00048558 +0.4000,10.646,10.899,11.186,-0.39731,0.40682,0.00056642,0.00053601 +0.3900,10.746,10.993,11.25,-0.45197,0.44688,0.00058236,0.0006637 +0.3800,10.847,11.076,11.281,-0.53003,0.49958,0.00053597,0.00080833 +0.3700,10.938,11.135,11.282,-0.62072,0.58133,0.00043819,0.0009212 +0.3600,11.029,11.183,11.302,-0.71247,0.68564,0.00029799,0.00099155 +0.3500,11.1,11.214,11.345,-0.7695,0.76681,0.00021863,0.0009948 +0.3400,11.078,11.225,11.383,-0.78937,0.81207,0.0002741,0.00094303 +0.3300,11.011,11.215,11.401,-0.79111,0.8345,0.00039753,0.00084792 +0.3200,10.941,11.18,11.386,-0.77792,0.83973,0.00051194,0.00073098 +0.3100,10.867,11.131,11.339,-0.75984,0.8262,0.00057669,0.00062724 +0.3000,10.778,11.051,11.237,-0.7453,0.7901,0.00058156,0.00055455 +0.2900,10.691,10.945,11.108,-0.73333,0.73689,0.00051221,0.00054722 +0.2800,10.609,10.83,10.982,-0.71675,0.67893,0.00039392,0.0005714 +0.2700,10.515,10.685,10.804,-0.6854,0.603,0.00023898,0.00059656 +0.2600,10.394,10.528,10.636,-0.63403,0.52593,0.00014245,0.00060298 +0.2500,10.202,10.345,10.482,-0.56636,0.44688,0.00021531,0.00058869 +0.2400,9.9657,10.146,10.309,-0.47726,0.40371,0.00036591,0.00055727 +0.2300,9.6851,9.8889,10.073,-0.39446,0.40565,0.00050955,0.00051788 +0.2200,9.4512,9.6566,9.8489,-0.39033,0.40413,0.0005687,0.00050162 +0.2100,9.2078,9.4061,9.586,-0.40249,0.388,0.00056437,0.00051535 +0.2000,8.9701,9.1525,9.3084,-0.42795,0.36487,0.00049839,0.00055937 +0.1900,8.7194,8.8658,8.9946,-0.46019,0.34228,0.00037395,0.00062679 +0.1800,8.4594,8.5585,8.6478,-0.48192,0.36672,0.00021435,0.00069743 +0.1700,8.1769,8.2546,8.3071,-0.49425,0.40746,0.00012348,0.00075316 +0.1600,7.7677,7.8528,7.9297,-0.4869,0.442,0.00024532,0.00079096 +0.1500,7.3823,7.5087,7.629,-0.46712,0.45088,0.00039765,0.00078765 +0.1400,6.981,7.1363,7.2918,-0.44786,0.4385,0.00051349,0.00075679 +0.1300,6.5596,6.7347,6.9186,-0.42878,0.40424,0.00057202,0.00069982 +0.1200,6.15,6.3271,6.5174,-0.40743,0.35541,0.0005589,0.00062527 +0.1100,5.7528,5.9156,6.0951,-0.37141,0.3028,0.00048121,0.00054397 +0.1000,5.2681,5.3997,5.5397,-0.30612,0.22796,0.0003205,0.00045092 +0.0900,4.8609,4.9609,5.0601,-0.24023,0.1967,0.00016033,0.00041312 +0.0800,4.3844,4.4768,4.5634,-0.16251,0.18878,0.00014205,0.00043828 +0.0700,3.869,3.9813,4.1146,-0.16716,0.18174,0.00030448,0.00051844 +0.0600,3.3542,3.4921,3.6498,-0.19052,0.18791,0.00045052,0.00060671 +0.0500,2.8007,2.9557,3.1258,-0.20308,0.2016,0.00055315,0.00067161 +0.0400,2.2395,2.39,2.5588,-0.19355,0.20512,0.0005823,0.00067569 +0.0300,1.6263,1.7599,1.8991,-0.16522,0.18142,0.00052137,0.00059265 +0.0200,1.0612,1.1651,1.2661,-0.11574,0.1354,0.0003869,0.00043743 +0.0100,0.52345,0.57282,0.6223,-0.05821,0.07119,0.00020298,0.00022886 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case9_envelopes.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case9_envelopes.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e2bc748 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/envelopes/case9_envelopes.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +z_over_L,x_min_D,x_mean_D,x_max_D,y_min_D,y_max_D,kx_rms_D,ky_rms_D +1.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 +0.9900,0.13093,0.21411,0.27653,-0.12303,0.13917,0.00027436,0.00029742 +0.9800,0.27061,0.4449,0.54168,-0.2464,0.27073,0.00050256,0.00056923 +0.9700,0.43814,0.66341,0.78672,-0.34781,0.38539,0.00063147,0.00077395 +0.9600,0.67027,0.93702,1.0797,-0.45086,0.51419,0.00064575,0.00094298 +0.9500,0.90527,1.1704,1.3351,-0.51062,0.60501,0.00053228,0.0010212 +0.9400,1.1443,1.401,1.6161,-0.54128,0.66742,0.00037002,0.001055 +0.9300,1.313,1.6253,1.8784,-0.55218,0.70474,0.00030678,0.0010614 +0.9200,1.4852,1.8613,2.164,-0.55783,0.71309,0.00047916,0.0010395 +0.9100,1.6713,2.0911,2.416,-0.53753,0.68896,0.00068956,0.00098342 +0.9000,1.8898,2.3152,2.6517,-0.48126,0.63605,0.00083382,0.00087563 +0.8900,2.2071,2.6058,2.9528,-0.36733,0.52763,0.00086025,0.00066255 +0.8800,2.4927,2.8372,3.1809,-0.26168,0.42937,0.00075583,0.00045921 +0.8700,2.8166,3.0777,3.3932,-0.19136,0.42667,0.00054481,0.00028181 +0.8600,3.0737,3.3065,3.5896,-0.29558,0.56939,0.00033225,0.00028087 +0.8500,3.2807,3.5486,3.8025,-0.43896,0.70825,0.00033739,0.00044598 +0.8400,3.4756,3.7889,4.0121,-0.56511,0.82601,0.00057686,0.00060296 +0.8300,3.7391,4.0664,4.326,-0.69157,0.94082,0.00083731,0.00074103 +0.8200,3.982,4.3096,4.5991,-0.76909,1.0136,0.00095147,0.00082329 +0.8100,4.2338,4.5561,4.8578,-0.8204,1.0758,0.0009371,0.00088948 +0.8000,4.4917,4.7867,5.0726,-0.83961,1.1317,0.00080875,0.00094732 +0.7900,4.7699,5.0324,5.275,-0.8299,1.1623,0.00059406,0.00099859 +0.7800,5.0373,5.258,5.4751,-0.81115,1.1628,0.00039473,0.0010272 +0.7700,5.2756,5.5103,5.7269,-0.79856,1.1369,0.00039824,0.0010183 +0.7600,5.4783,5.7874,6.0427,-0.74944,1.0766,0.00064155,0.00095212 +0.7500,5.6704,6.0245,6.3159,-0.68216,0.99655,0.00082876,0.00085854 +0.7400,5.8836,6.2478,6.5556,-0.58942,0.89787,0.00092003,0.00074672 +0.7300,6.1271,6.4798,6.7772,-0.46672,0.77589,0.00089933,0.00062444 +0.7200,6.3906,6.7013,6.9794,-0.35168,0.64432,0.00077679,0.00051267 +0.7100,6.661,6.9303,7.1754,-0.33014,0.54401,0.00057998,0.00043316 +0.7000,6.928,7.1561,7.3786,-0.33804,0.59781,0.00041141,0.0004337 +0.6900,7.1551,7.4125,7.6499,-0.42108,0.72644,0.00044951,0.0005551 +0.6800,7.3367,7.6263,7.9044,-0.52326,0.82135,0.00062611,0.00070561 +0.6700,7.5444,7.845,8.1446,-0.64164,0.92282,0.0007952,0.00085778 +0.6600,7.7599,8.0502,8.3742,-0.73421,1.0217,0.00088149,0.00097382 +0.6500,7.9742,8.2588,8.618,-0.80396,1.0911,0.00086847,0.0010438 +0.6400,8.1907,8.4763,8.8369,-0.84439,1.1314,0.00075047,0.0010635 +0.6300,8.4355,8.7098,9.0396,-0.85261,1.1368,0.00054962,0.0010404 +0.6200,8.6533,8.9278,9.2098,-0.82341,1.1119,0.00041069,0.001002 +0.6100,8.8724,9.1428,9.364,-0.7766,1.0806,0.00042808,0.00096108 +0.6000,9.0832,9.3487,9.5638,-0.72949,1.0453,0.0005756,0.00091937 +0.5900,9.2789,9.556,9.833,-0.67087,0.98914,0.00073619,0.00086653 +0.5800,9.46,9.7666,10.083,-0.59696,0.91109,0.00083515,0.00079493 +0.5700,9.6885,10.005,10.328,-0.51071,0.79856,0.00084185,0.00069538 +0.5600,9.9421,10.238,10.549,-0.44016,0.68187,0.00073956,0.00059952 +0.5500,10.194,10.445,10.733,-0.43099,0.62262,0.0005842,0.00055898 +0.5400,10.447,10.644,10.902,-0.48698,0.65704,0.00043205,0.0005872 +0.5300,10.679,10.847,11.102,-0.57975,0.74424,0.00037693,0.00068284 +0.5200,10.874,11.056,11.371,-0.67658,0.81225,0.00047758,0.00082305 +0.5100,11.041,11.256,11.642,-0.75544,0.84915,0.00063835,0.00096328 +0.5000,11.219,11.491,11.918,-0.81185,0.85697,0.00077632,0.0010908 +0.4900,11.402,11.721,12.166,-0.84694,0.85937,0.00082588,0.0011636 +0.4800,11.581,11.92,12.368,-0.8889,0.87887,0.00078781,0.0011657 +0.4700,11.772,12.128,12.55,-0.93152,0.89399,0.00067946,0.001099 +0.4600,11.965,12.332,12.72,-0.96359,0.87914,0.00053456,0.00096775 +0.4500,12.146,12.531,12.888,-0.97992,0.84557,0.00042514,0.00079449 +0.4400,12.328,12.725,13.082,-0.96973,0.80027,0.00043089,0.00061125 +0.4300,12.525,12.915,13.308,-0.94057,0.73409,0.00056747,0.00048053 +0.4200,12.69,13.08,13.479,-0.90095,0.67096,0.00070994,0.00047693 +0.4100,12.837,13.21,13.594,-0.86075,0.61864,0.00079206,0.00054005 +0.4000,12.97,13.316,13.668,-0.8129,0.58108,0.00080069,0.00060634 +0.3900,13.087,13.402,13.72,-0.75878,0.55043,0.00073065,0.00064678 +0.3800,13.206,13.472,13.745,-0.74371,0.5487,0.00058856,0.00066153 +0.3700,13.312,13.513,13.749,-0.77229,0.58014,0.00041493,0.00066141 +0.3600,13.374,13.537,13.755,-0.81308,0.60975,0.00028352,0.00065357 +0.3500,13.352,13.538,13.752,-0.84605,0.62106,0.0003476,0.00063902 +0.3400,13.3,13.519,13.761,-0.86475,0.61577,0.00050416,0.00062132 +0.3300,13.225,13.476,13.772,-0.86986,0.62599,0.00065456,0.00060987 +0.3200,13.138,13.409,13.758,-0.86753,0.64597,0.00074892,0.00062217 +0.3100,13.03,13.329,13.694,-0.86474,0.65102,0.00076947,0.00066404 +0.3000,12.906,13.212,13.562,-0.87936,0.6304,0.00070867,0.0007291 +0.2900,12.778,13.068,13.385,-0.90236,0.59947,0.00057692,0.00077344 +0.2800,12.647,12.911,13.195,-0.90957,0.59134,0.00042261,0.00077244 +0.2700,12.464,12.716,12.984,-0.90776,0.57162,0.00029383,0.00072481 +0.2600,12.25,12.513,12.741,-0.89122,0.55698,0.0003028,0.00064608 +0.2500,11.993,12.279,12.491,-0.86668,0.57139,0.0004251,0.00056431 +0.2400,11.697,12.016,12.235,-0.83004,0.58909,0.00057558,0.00051436 +0.2300,11.346,11.698,11.938,-0.78427,0.59985,0.00070513,0.00051565 +0.2200,11.05,11.4,11.655,-0.75037,0.59872,0.00074762,0.0005437 +0.2100,10.761,11.077,11.342,-0.75437,0.58232,0.00072259,0.00056371 +0.2000,10.446,10.743,11.017,-0.75946,0.55911,0.00063341,0.00056434 +0.1900,10.094,10.388,10.635,-0.74834,0.52693,0.00048752,0.00055172 +0.1800,9.7266,10.007,10.225,-0.74312,0.47712,0.0003243,0.00053778 +0.1700,9.3487,9.6246,9.8454,-0.73956,0.43078,0.00026124,0.00053442 +0.1600,8.8638,9.1316,9.4197,-0.71902,0.42436,0.00039191,0.00054868 +0.1500,8.4281,8.7103,9.0588,-0.70062,0.42488,0.00056877,0.00057623 +0.1400,7.9585,8.2567,8.652,-0.66618,0.41604,0.00071573,0.00061413 +0.1300,7.4877,7.7792,8.1978,-0.61252,0.39814,0.00079426,0.00065338 +0.1200,7.0295,7.2907,7.7061,-0.56153,0.38616,0.00078122,0.00067548 +0.1100,6.5526,6.8149,7.2008,-0.54613,0.36663,0.0006812,0.0006633 +0.1000,5.9507,6.209,6.536,-0.51464,0.32979,0.00046523,0.00059428 +0.0900,5.4594,5.7025,5.9689,-0.46703,0.27496,0.00025132,0.00050144 +0.0800,4.9204,5.1355,5.343,-0.40491,0.20759,0.00022167,0.0004238 +0.0700,4.3581,4.5699,4.7659,-0.3274,0.15325,0.00044342,0.00044381 +0.0600,3.7688,4.0084,4.2409,-0.27114,0.16808,0.00065376,0.00054651 +0.0500,3.1345,3.3916,3.6527,-0.257,0.18936,0.00080509,0.00065896 +0.0400,2.5024,2.7424,3.0091,-0.23108,0.19488,0.00085028,0.00071043 +0.0300,1.8105,2.014,2.241,-0.18623,0.16773,0.00076312,0.00065659 +0.0200,1.1794,1.3376,1.4982,-0.13064,0.12208,0.00056799,0.00049794 +0.0100,0.57282,0.66011,0.74146,-0.067831,0.063974,0.00029794,0.00026528 +0.0000,0,0,0,0.0019206,0.0019206,0,0 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/measured_summary.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/measured_summary.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b01519d --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/measured_summary.csv @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +quantity,case,U,value +max_cf_disp_D,1,0.16,0.756538 +max_cf_disp_D,2,0.21,0.578777 +max_cf_disp_D,3,0.309,0.779326 +max_cf_disp_D,4,0.406,0.673778 +max_cf_disp_D,5,0.545,0.842763 +max_cf_disp_D,6,0.605,0.709345 +max_cf_disp_D,7,0.703,0.777016 +max_cf_disp_D,8,0.854,0.906623 +max_cf_disp_D,9,0.951,1.07449 +max_il_mean_D,1,0.161,1.06132 +max_il_mean_D,2,0.211,1.1945 +max_il_mean_D,3,0.31,3.45051 +max_il_mean_D,4,0.407,4.97342 +max_il_mean_D,5,0.546,6.68884 +max_il_mean_D,6,0.606,8.1267 +max_il_mean_D,7,0.704,8.8987 +max_il_mean_D,8,0.855,11.1844 +max_il_mean_D,9,0.953,13.5076 +max_il_dyn_D,1,0.16,0.206466 +max_il_dyn_D,2,0.21,0.0979251 +max_il_dyn_D,3,0.309,0.29709 +max_il_dyn_D,4,0.406,0.243781 +max_il_dyn_D,5,0.545,0.186736 +max_il_dyn_D,6,0.605,0.305004 +max_il_dyn_D,7,0.703,0.16926 +max_il_dyn_D,8,0.854,0.359082 +max_il_dyn_D,9,0.951,0.485263 +std_curv_il_kD,1,0.16,5.04942e-05 +std_curv_il_kD,2,0.21,3.42471e-05 +std_curv_il_kD,3,0.309,0.000194713 +std_curv_il_kD,4,0.406,0.000268844 +std_curv_il_kD,5,0.545,0.000231251 +std_curv_il_kD,6,0.605,0.000457232 +std_curv_il_kD,7,0.703,0.00030285 +std_curv_il_kD,8,0.854,0.000448194 +std_curv_il_kD,9,0.951,0.000623852 +std_curv_cf_kD,1,0.16,9.26657e-05 +std_curv_cf_kD,2,0.21,8.859e-05 +std_curv_cf_kD,3,0.309,0.000270412 +std_curv_cf_kD,4,0.406,0.000317895 +std_curv_cf_kD,5,0.545,0.000480763 +std_curv_cf_kD,6,0.605,0.000477281 +std_curv_cf_kD,7,0.703,0.000647034 +std_curv_cf_kD,8,0.854,0.000688661 +std_curv_cf_kD,9,0.951,0.000735512 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/provenance.json b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/provenance.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5db6580 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/provenance.json @@ -0,0 +1,295 @@ +{ + "source": "Chaplin, Bearman, Huera Huarte & Pattenden (2005a), Journal of Fluids and Structures 21(1), 3-24 (the riser, Sec. 2; the drag amplification, Eq. 4); Chaplin, Bearman, Cheng, Fontaine, Graham, Herfjord, Huera Huarte, Isherwood, Lambrakos, Larsen, Meneghini, Moe, Pattenden, Triantafyllou & Willden (2005b), Journal of Fluids and Structures 21(1), 25-40 (the blind-trial cases); the authors' presentation of the blind trial, 'Blind predictions of laboratory measurements of vortex-induced vibrations of a tension riser', Trondheim, October 2004 (the measured results); the project's pages at the University of Southampton, archived by the Internet Archive (mechanical properties, current zone)", + "doi": [ + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010", + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.05.016" + ], + "archived_pages": [ + "https://web.archive.org/web/20041103155158/http://www.civil.soton.ac.uk:80/hydraulics/riser/mechanical%20properties(1).htm", + "https://web.archive.org/web/20041103154947/http://www.civil.soton.ac.uk:80/hydraulics/riser/benchmarking%20cases(1).htm" + ], + "data_used": "riser: L 13.12 m between pinned joints, D 28 mm, EI 29.9 N m^2, mass ratio 3.0 with the internal water (paper; the page gives 1.85 kg/m), EA 5.88 MN, structural damping 0.33 % of critical, top spring 11.4 kN/m (page); the lower 5.94 m in the current (page); slide 3: towing speeds and mean top tensions of cases 1-9; slides 7-15: the measured envelopes along the riser (envelopes/); slides 17-19: the measured maximum cross-flow displacement, maximum mean and dynamic in-line displacement and overall standard deviations of curvature (measured_summary.csv); slide 23: the measured dominant cross-flow mode numbers", + "extraction": "the slides are vector graphics: the measured points (filled circles of the measurement colour) and curves (polylines of 102 nearly equally spaced vertices along the riser, resampled to 101 equally spaced stations) are read as plotted coordinates and mapped linearly through the panel tick labels; the recovered towing speeds match slide 3 within 0.006 m/s; the envelope maxima of the mean in-line displacement match slide 17 within 0.05 D", + "assumptions": "fresh water, Ca 1 (as L3-C); the 11.4 kN/m top spring of the two the page lists; the structural damping as bending damping of a pure bending mode at 2 Hz; the static top tension in the current (drag unamplified) set to the measured mean; the curvature panels of slides 7-15 have no scale, so each envelope curvature shape is scaled so that its r.m.s. over the stations equals the slide-19 overall standard deviation", + "coefficients": "generic, not fitted to these measurements: Cl 0.8, cF 0.18, dF 0.08; in-line ClX 0.85, alpha 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018); Cd 1.2; VIV AMPLITUDE Cv 0.8 constant with CdAmp = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s^2, s = (A/D)/sqrt(2) (Chaplin et al. 2005a, Eq. 4); VIV DAMPING 0 0 1 (the amplification on the in-line drag only)", + "CableDyn_commit": "7d3998f (dev)", + "validation_date": "2026-11-15", + "executable_name": "cabledyn.exe", + "executable_sha256": "see summary.json", + "compiler": "GNU Fortran 16.2.0", + "build_type": "Release", + "platform": "Windows 11 x86-64", + "segments": 64, + "dt_s": "per case, the largest of 0.005, 0.0025, 0.002, 0.001, 0.0005 at or below 1/200 of D/(0.18 U)", + "sensitivity": { + "dt_half": { + "1": { + "mode": 2, + "f_cf_hz": 0.92, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6535, + "max_il_mean_D": 1.19, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 5.6604e-05, + "std_curv_il_kD": 3.5373e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 408.5 + }, + "2": { + "mode": 3, + "f_cf_hz": 1.36, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.5973, + "max_il_mean_D": 1.603, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00011179, + "std_curv_il_kD": 7.1936e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 412.8 + }, + "3": { + "mode": 4, + "f_cf_hz": 2.0, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6162, + "max_il_mean_D": 3.266, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00020525, + "std_curv_il_kD": 9.146e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 475.5 + }, + "4": { + "mode": 4, + "f_cf_hz": 2.24, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7077, + "max_il_mean_D": 4.782, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00022964, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00013684, + "mean_top_tension_N": 541.4 + }, + "5": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 3.72, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6485, + "max_il_mean_D": 6.542, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00044751, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00018971, + "mean_top_tension_N": 660.1 + }, + "6": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 3.92, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6093, + "max_il_mean_D": 6.804, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00044174, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00025254, + "mean_top_tension_N": 734.5 + }, + "7": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 4.24, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7339, + "max_il_mean_D": 8.319, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00046749, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00026398, + "mean_top_tension_N": 836.1 + }, + "8": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 4.8, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7462, + "max_il_mean_D": 9.654, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00049254, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.0002702, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1045.6 + }, + "9": { + "mode": 7, + "f_cf_hz": 5.8, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7249, + "max_il_mean_D": 10.632, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00064422, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00031337, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1145.9 + } + }, + "segments_128": { + "1": { + "mode": 2, + "f_cf_hz": 0.92, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6526, + "max_il_mean_D": 1.204, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 5.6747e-05, + "std_curv_il_kD": 3.5554e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 408.6 + }, + "2": { + "mode": 3, + "f_cf_hz": 1.36, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.5946, + "max_il_mean_D": 1.637, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00011292, + "std_curv_il_kD": 7.2924e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 413.0 + }, + "3": { + "mode": 4, + "f_cf_hz": 2.0, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6143, + "max_il_mean_D": 3.319, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00020749, + "std_curv_il_kD": 9.4304e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 476.1 + }, + "4": { + "mode": 4, + "f_cf_hz": 2.24, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6642, + "max_il_mean_D": 4.865, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00023121, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00014079, + "mean_top_tension_N": 542.6 + }, + "5": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 3.68, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6224, + "max_il_mean_D": 6.369, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00041739, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00026224, + "mean_top_tension_N": 654.6 + }, + "6": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 3.92, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.5816, + "max_il_mean_D": 6.908, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00044891, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00026562, + "mean_top_tension_N": 736.4 + }, + "7": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 4.24, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7081, + "max_il_mean_D": 8.43, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.0004708, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00028325, + "mean_top_tension_N": 838.5 + }, + "8": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 4.8, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7484, + "max_il_mean_D": 9.845, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00050403, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00027331, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1051.0 + }, + "9": { + "mode": 8, + "f_cf_hz": 6.64, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.5947, + "max_il_mean_D": 10.354, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00071066, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.0003868, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1134.1 + } + }, + "tmax_80_s_cases_5_9": { + "5": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 3.692, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7786, + "max_il_mean_D": 6.427, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00043051, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00020686, + "mean_top_tension_N": 657.3 + }, + "9": { + "mode": 8, + "f_cf_hz": 6.615, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6091, + "max_il_mean_D": 10.155, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00068799, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00036953, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1128.1 + } + }, + "top_spring_38p1_kN_per_m": { + "1": { + "mode": 2, + "f_cf_hz": 0.92, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.65, + "max_il_mean_D": 1.162, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 5.6486e-05, + "std_curv_il_kD": 3.4978e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 415.7 + }, + "2": { + "mode": 3, + "f_cf_hz": 1.4, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6153, + "max_il_mean_D": 1.532, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00010964, + "std_curv_il_kD": 7.2096e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 423.7 + }, + "3": { + "mode": 4, + "f_cf_hz": 2.08, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6316, + "max_il_mean_D": 2.982, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00019748, + "std_curv_il_kD": 9.1888e-05, + "mean_top_tension_N": 504.2 + }, + "4": { + "mode": 4, + "f_cf_hz": 2.32, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6453, + "max_il_mean_D": 4.293, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00023093, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00012918, + "mean_top_tension_N": 591.5 + }, + "5": { + "mode": 5, + "f_cf_hz": 3.24, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7159, + "max_il_mean_D": 5.681, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00034362, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00014224, + "mean_top_tension_N": 728.3 + }, + "6": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 4.04, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.5454, + "max_il_mean_D": 5.702, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00037648, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00030899, + "mean_top_tension_N": 787.9 + }, + "7": { + "mode": 6, + "f_cf_hz": 4.48, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.6894, + "max_il_mean_D": 7.184, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00044718, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00025784, + "mean_top_tension_N": 934.3 + }, + "8": { + "mode": 5, + "f_cf_hz": 4.32, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7633, + "max_il_mean_D": 8.507, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00040298, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00021852, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1187.5 + }, + "9": { + "mode": 7, + "f_cf_hz": 6.16, + "max_cf_half_pp_D": 0.7137, + "max_il_mean_D": 9.123, + "std_curv_cf_kD": 0.00060676, + "std_curv_il_kD": 0.00028333, + "mean_top_tension_N": 1283.9 + } + } + } +} diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/response_comparison.csv b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/response_comparison.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..892ab8d --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/response_comparison.csv @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +case,U_m_per_s,top_tension_N,dt_s,mode_measured,mode_cabledyn,f_cf_cabledyn_hz,max_cf_D_measured,max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope,max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn,max_cf_error_percent,max_cf_envelope_error_percent,max_il_mean_D_measured,max_il_mean_D_cabledyn,max_il_mean_error_percent,std_curv_cf_kD_measured,std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn,std_curv_cf_error_percent,std_curv_il_kD_measured,std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn,std_curv_il_error_percent,mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn +1,0.16,405.0,0.0025,2,2,0.92,0.7565,0.7632,0.6534,-13.6,-14.4,1.061,1.191,12.2,9.2666e-05,5.6648e-05,-38.9,5.0494e-05,3.5410e-05,-29.9,408.5 +2,0.21,407.0,0.0025,3,3,1.36,0.5788,0.5612,0.6012,3.9,7.1,1.194,1.604,34.3,8.8590e-05,1.1170e-04,26.1,3.4247e-05,7.1892e-05,109.9,412.8 +3,0.31,457.0,0.0025,4,4,2.0,0.7793,0.8089,0.6285,-19.4,-22.3,3.451,3.27,-5.2,2.7041e-04,2.0558e-04,-24.0,1.9471e-04,9.1215e-05,-53.2,475.6 +4,0.4,506.0,0.001,5,4,2.24,0.6738,0.5948,0.6918,2.7,16.3,4.973,4.782,-3.8,3.1790e-04,2.2974e-04,-27.7,2.6884e-04,1.3698e-04,-49.0,541.4 +5,0.54,598.0,0.001,6,6,3.72,0.8428,0.8885,0.7786,-7.6,-12.4,6.689,6.386,-4.5,4.8076e-04,4.0956e-04,-14.8,2.3125e-04,2.1049e-04,-9.0,655.8 +6,0.6,670.0,0.001,6,6,3.92,0.7093,0.7792,0.6057,-14.6,-22.3,8.127,6.779,-16.6,4.7728e-04,4.3901e-04,-8.0,4.5723e-04,2.5676e-04,-43.8,733.8 +7,0.7,743.0,0.001,7,6,4.24,0.777,0.717,0.737,-5.1,2.8,8.899,8.321,-6.5,6.4703e-04,4.6781e-04,-27.7,3.0285e-04,2.6416e-04,-12.8,836.2 +8,0.85,923.0,0.0005,7,6,4.8,0.9066,0.8896,0.781,-13.9,-12.2,11.184,9.652,-13.7,6.8866e-04,4.9143e-04,-28.6,4.4819e-04,2.9917e-04,-33.3,1046.0 +9,0.95,1002.0,0.0005,7,8,6.6,1.0745,0.9961,0.599,-44.2,-39.9,13.508,10.155,-24.8,7.3551e-04,6.8775e-04,-6.5,6.2385e-04,3.6999e-04,-40.7,1128.1 diff --git a/validation/experiments/delta_flume/summary.json b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..eb3a877 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/delta_flume/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,261 @@ +{ + "cases": [ + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 5, + 6, + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "segments": 64, + "dt_scale": 1.0, + "tmax_s": 40.0, + "statistics_after_s": 15.0, + "top_spring_N_per_m": 11400.0, + "effective_axial_stiffness_N": 145857.9, + "modes_right": 5, + "modes_within_one": 9, + "il_mean_within_17_percent": 7, + "il_mean_error_percent_range": [ + -24.8, + 34.3 + ], + "max_cf_error_percent_range": [ + -44.2, + 3.9 + ], + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent_range": [ + -39.9, + 16.3 + ], + "std_curv_cf_error_percent_range": [ + -38.9, + 26.1 + ], + "std_curv_il_error_percent_range": [ + -53.2, + 109.9 + ], + "per_case": [ + { + "case": 1, + "U_m_per_s": 0.16, + "top_tension_N": 405.0, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "mode_measured": 2, + "mode_cabledyn": 2, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 0.92, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.7565, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.7632, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.6534, + "max_cf_error_percent": -13.6, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": -14.4, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 1.061, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 1.191, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": 12.2, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "9.2666e-05", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "5.6648e-05", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -38.9, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "5.0494e-05", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "3.5410e-05", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -29.9, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 408.5 + }, + { + "case": 2, + "U_m_per_s": 0.21, + "top_tension_N": 407.0, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "mode_measured": 3, + "mode_cabledyn": 3, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 1.36, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.5788, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.5612, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.6012, + "max_cf_error_percent": 3.9, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": 7.1, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 1.194, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 1.604, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": 34.3, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "8.8590e-05", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "1.1170e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": 26.1, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "3.4247e-05", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "7.1892e-05", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": 109.9, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 412.8 + }, + { + "case": 3, + "U_m_per_s": 0.31, + "top_tension_N": 457.0, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "mode_measured": 4, + "mode_cabledyn": 4, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 2.0, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.7793, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.8089, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.6285, + "max_cf_error_percent": -19.4, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": -22.3, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 3.451, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 3.27, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -5.2, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "2.7041e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "2.0558e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -24.0, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "1.9471e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "9.1215e-05", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -53.2, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 475.6 + }, + { + "case": 4, + "U_m_per_s": 0.4, + "top_tension_N": 506.0, + "dt_s": 0.001, + "mode_measured": 5, + "mode_cabledyn": 4, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 2.24, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.6738, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.5948, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.6918, + "max_cf_error_percent": 2.7, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": 16.3, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 4.973, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 4.782, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -3.8, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "3.1790e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "2.2974e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -27.7, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "2.6884e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "1.3698e-04", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -49.0, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 541.4 + }, + { + "case": 5, + "U_m_per_s": 0.54, + "top_tension_N": 598.0, + "dt_s": 0.001, + "mode_measured": 6, + "mode_cabledyn": 6, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 3.72, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.8428, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.8885, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.7786, + "max_cf_error_percent": -7.6, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": -12.4, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 6.689, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 6.386, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -4.5, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "4.8076e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "4.0956e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -14.8, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "2.3125e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "2.1049e-04", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -9.0, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 655.8 + }, + { + "case": 6, + "U_m_per_s": 0.6, + "top_tension_N": 670.0, + "dt_s": 0.001, + "mode_measured": 6, + "mode_cabledyn": 6, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 3.92, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.7093, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.7792, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.6057, + "max_cf_error_percent": -14.6, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": -22.3, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 8.127, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 6.779, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -16.6, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "4.7728e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "4.3901e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -8.0, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "4.5723e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "2.5676e-04", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -43.8, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 733.8 + }, + { + "case": 7, + "U_m_per_s": 0.7, + "top_tension_N": 743.0, + "dt_s": 0.001, + "mode_measured": 7, + "mode_cabledyn": 6, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 4.24, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.777, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.717, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.737, + "max_cf_error_percent": -5.1, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": 2.8, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 8.899, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 8.321, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -6.5, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "6.4703e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "4.6781e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -27.7, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "3.0285e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "2.6416e-04", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -12.8, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 836.2 + }, + { + "case": 8, + "U_m_per_s": 0.85, + "top_tension_N": 923.0, + "dt_s": 0.0005, + "mode_measured": 7, + "mode_cabledyn": 6, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 4.8, + "max_cf_D_measured": 0.9066, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.8896, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.781, + "max_cf_error_percent": -13.9, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": -12.2, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 11.184, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 9.652, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -13.7, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "6.8866e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "4.9143e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -28.6, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "4.4819e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "2.9917e-04", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -33.3, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 1046.0 + }, + { + "case": 9, + "U_m_per_s": 0.95, + "top_tension_N": 1002.0, + "dt_s": 0.0005, + "mode_measured": 7, + "mode_cabledyn": 8, + "f_cf_cabledyn_hz": 6.6, + "max_cf_D_measured": 1.0745, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_measured_envelope": 0.9961, + "max_cf_half_pp_D_cabledyn": 0.599, + "max_cf_error_percent": -44.2, + "max_cf_envelope_error_percent": -39.9, + "max_il_mean_D_measured": 13.508, + "max_il_mean_D_cabledyn": 10.155, + "max_il_mean_error_percent": -24.8, + "std_curv_cf_kD_measured": "7.3551e-04", + "std_curv_cf_kD_cabledyn": "6.8775e-04", + "std_curv_cf_error_percent": -6.5, + "std_curv_il_kD_measured": "6.2385e-04", + "std_curv_il_kD_cabledyn": "3.6999e-04", + "std_curv_il_error_percent": -40.7, + "mean_top_tension_N_cabledyn": 1128.1 + } + ], + "executable_sha256": "a95b9df931e7f416674785413d8da8a79a204567ef0d4809f455fb41a660a647" +}