diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 39dbcb6..29c376c 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -123,6 +123,15 @@ All notable changes to CableDyn are recorded in this file. The format follows dominant frequency and σ/D: the set Ulveseter et al. (2019) fitted to these tests matches strain (r.m.s. log error 0.178), frequency and amplitude together; Andersen et al.'s (2024b) sheared-flow average 0.186; the generic set, blind, 0.277. +- Validation case L3-F (`validation/experiments/flotant`): VIV of the FLOTANT OD 48 mm + power-cable specimen of de Wilde et al. (2021) with its 200 kg clump weight at the 40 tow + speeds, cross-flow and in-line A/D_rms at three stations, with three published coefficient + sets none of which is fitted to these tests, on a structure identified from the specimen's + in-air and in-water RAOs. The set of Ulveseter et al. (2019) gives the first cross-flow peak + (0.755 against 0.776 at mid-length) but responds from a lower speed and releases 1.2 Ur late + (cross-flow r.m.s. log error 0.731); the generic set is 38 % low at the peak and releases at + the measured speed (0.594); the wake oscillator of Facchinetti et al. (2004) is 62 % low + (1.208). - Theory manual, Published coefficient sets: the VIV coefficient sets of Thorsen et al. (2016, 2017), Ulveseter et al. (2018), Andersen et al. (2024a, b) and Facchinetti et al. (2004), each with its source, its test data and the line-type columns it maps to, and Thorsen et al.'s diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 5d9a19e..1f6aa90 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -171,9 +171,9 @@ layout is described in the architecture notes in the repository. ## Validation CableDyn is verified against analytical solutions and compared with MoorDyn, -OrcaFlex, six published physical experiments (Holcombe lazy-wave, Bergdahl dynamic +OrcaFlex, seven published physical experiments (Holcombe lazy-wave, Bergdahl dynamic chain, Chaplin riser natural frequencies and stepped-current VIV, Wang catenary-riser VIV, -NDP high-mode riser VIV), the IEA 15 MW VolturnUS-S reference systems, and coupled OpenFAST runs. Results, +NDP high-mode riser VIV, FLOTANT power-cable VIV), the IEA 15 MW VolturnUS-S reference systems, and coupled OpenFAST runs. Results, acceptance criteria, and reproduction commands are in the [validation record](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/validation.html); data and scripts are in [`validation/`](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/validation.html). diff --git a/VALIDATION.md b/VALIDATION.md index 4f68327..c2e73f4 100644 --- a/VALIDATION.md +++ b/VALIDATION.md @@ -86,6 +86,7 @@ article's methods, are compared in | **L3-D** | Chaplin Delta Flume riser in a stepped current, blind-trial cases 1–9, cross-flow and in-line VIV | measured dominant mode, peak cross-flow amplitude, mean in-line displacement, curvature standard deviations | mode right in 5/9, within one in 9/9; mean in-line within ±17% in 7/9 (−25% to +34%); cross-flow amplitude −45% to +4%; cross-flow curvature −39% to +26% | generic coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass measured | | **L3-W** | SJTU steel catenary riser in 0.2 m/s current, cross-flow VIV | measured r.m.s. strain (25 stations) and dominant frequency | frequency 0.992 vs 1.00 Hz; max r.m.s. strain +7.3%, station mean +3.6% | published coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass | | **L3-N** | NDP 38 m high-mode riser in uniform flow, 0.3–2.4 m/s (22 tests), cross-flow VIV | measured maximum r.m.s. cross-flow strain, dominant frequency, spatial-mean σ/D | strain r.m.s. log error: Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.178, Andersen et al. (2024b) 0.186, generic set 0.277, Thorsen et al. (2016) 0.363 (their own simulation 0.187); f D/U 0.145 / 0.134 / 0.192 / 0.193 vs 0.143 measured | generic set blind; the other sets fitted by their authors to NDP tests (implementation check) | Pass measured | +| **L3-F** | FLOTANT OD 48 mm power-cable specimen with a 200 kg clump, tow tests at 0.025–1.0 m/s (40 tests), cross-flow and in-line VIV | measured A/D_rms (σ/OD) at 1/2L, 3/4L and L (de Wilde et al. 2021, App. 3) | CF r.m.s. log error (Ur ≥ 3): Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.731, generic set 0.594, wake oscillator 1.208; first peak at 1/2L 0.755 / 0.483 / 0.296 vs 0.776 measured; release Ur 7.06 / 5.89 / 5.30 vs 5.88 | published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests; structure identified from the specimen's in-air and in-water RAOs | Pass measured | | **L-fig** | Along-arc curvature overlay (CableDyn / OrcaFlex / MoorDyn-F ±4×) | 3-code committed record | CableDyn peak 0.11% from OrcaFlex | <0.5% | Pass | | **L4-1** | Coupled platform + mooring | synthetic reference | bit-for-bit | — | Pass | | **L4-1b** | VolturnUS-S coupled platform + power cable | OpenFAST v5.0.0 (CompMooring 5 vs 3) | platform DOFs <0.6% (3-seed DLC-1.1); fairlead and anchor <0.001% static | <3% platform | Pass | @@ -305,8 +306,9 @@ initialisation. ### Physical experiments -No line or load parameter is fitted to any of the experiments. Inputs, reduction -scripts, results, and source provenance are in +No line or load parameter is fitted to the measurements a case is compared with (L3-F +identifies its structure from forced-oscillation tests of the same specimen, separate from +the tow tests it predicts). Inputs, reduction scripts, results, and source provenance are in [`validation/experiments`](https://github.com/SMI-Lab-Inha/CableDyn/tree/main/validation/experiments). - **L3-H Holcombe static lazy-wave test** @@ -401,6 +403,32 @@ scripts, results, and source provenance are in 0.184 and 0.375 for the generic, Andersen, Ulveseter and Thorsen sets, f D/U within 0.001 and σ/D within 1.4%. +- **L3-F FLOTANT power-cable specimen, cross-flow and in-line VIV in tow tests** + ([de Wilde et al., 2021](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-dewilde2021)): + the 6.4 m OD 48 mm cable hanging from the carriage with its 200 kg clump weight, towed at the 40 + speeds of 0.025–1.0 m/s, compared with the measured A/D_rms (σ/OD) at 1/2L, 3/4L and L, the + model's displacements processed as the report's accelerometer motions (tilt term, 3.5 rad/s + high-pass). The line follows the report's FEM tables node by node. The structure the tests + leave open is identified from the specimen's forced-oscillation RAOs, not from the tow data: + the cable's EI (1650 N m², where the tables' 3000 N m² needs an empirical factor to match the + resonance) and bending damping from the in-air RAOs (resonance at the measured 1.7 Hz, peaks + 7.4 and 7.2 against 8.7 and 5.9 at 5 and 10 mm), and in water a bending link chain and a + laterally restrained clump that reproduce the measured split of the first mode (peaks 1.2 and + 1.9 Hz against 1.3 and 1.8 Hz; r.m.s. log error 0.46 against 1.19 with MARIN's fixed clump). + Three published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests (r.m.s. log error of the cross-flow + A/D_rms over the three stations, Ur ≥ 3): + - the set Ulveseter et al. (2019) fitted to the NDP riser gives the first peak at mid-length, + 0.755 at Ur 5.30 against 0.776 at Ur 5.58, but responds from a lower speed (0.42 against + 0.18 at Ur 3.53), releases at Ur 7.06 against 5.88 and holds 0.64–0.71 above Ur 9 where the + test falls to 0.18–0.44: 0.731; + - the generic set is 38% low at the peak (0.483) and releases at the measured Ur: 0.594; + - the wake oscillator of Facchinetti et al. (2004) is 62% low (0.296): 1.208. + + No set predicts the speed range of the lock-in. With MARIN's fixed clump or a free clump the + same set scores 0.721 and 0.692 but releases at Ur 8.83 and 9.12 and misses the in-water RAOs. + Half the time step, two elements per table element and 120 s runs change no A/D_rms by more + than 0.006 at five speeds; the default run reproduces the committed record byte for byte. + ## L4 coupled OpenFAST - **L4-1 synthetic** (`l4_platform_mooring`): 6-DOF platform moored by three taut diff --git a/doc/references.rst b/doc/references.rst index 74e5fa9..1003799 100644 --- a/doc/references.rst +++ b/doc/references.rst @@ -308,6 +308,14 @@ Verification and validation references Offshore and Arctic Engineering (OMAE2011)*, Volume 7: CFD and VIV; Offshore Geotechnics, 511–522. https://doi.org/10.1115/OMAE2011-49820 +.. _ref-dewilde2021: + +- **de Wilde, J., Heijnsdijk, R. & de Ridder, E.-J. (2021).** *D5.5 – Report on VIV + (hydrodynamic) behaviour.* FLOTANT project deliverable 210430-FLT-WP5_D-5-5_V0 (MARIN report + 30995-53-DWB), Maritime Research Institute Netherlands, 30 April 2021. EU Horizon 2020 grant + agreement 815289 (https://doi.org/10.3030/815289); public deliverable, no DOI. + https://flotantproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/210430_FLT-D5.5_VIV_test_v0.pdf + Comparison codes ---------------- diff --git a/validation/README.md b/validation/README.md index 1e0d17d..ccda055 100644 --- a/validation/README.md +++ b/validation/README.md @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ redistributed. | [`RELEASE_0_1_1.md`](RELEASE_0_1_1.md) | The same for v0.1.1 | | [`RELEASE_0_1_0.md`](RELEASE_0_1_0.md) | The same for v0.1.0 | | [`bodies/`](bodies/README.md) | Rigid-body, rod and shared-anchor cases with MoorDyn-C twins, stored references and pass limits | -| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV and Trim et al. (2005) NDP high-mode riser VIV comparisons | +| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV, Trim et al. (2005) NDP high-mode riser VIV and de Wilde et al. (2021) FLOTANT power-cable VIV comparisons | | [`PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md`](PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md) | Wall time of CableDyn 0.1.0, MoorDyn-C and MoorDyn-F at equal accuracy on five mooring, cable, buoy and coupled cases | | [`performance/`](performance/README.md) | Same-host wall-clock records of the L5 cases: the resolved lazy-wave spans, the one-hour VolturnUS-S mooring and the tension-only chain | | [`PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md`](PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md) | Every CableDyn result in the journal article, re-run with the release defaults and in paper mode | diff --git a/validation/experiments/README.md b/validation/experiments/README.md index 71f4091..c9b32e2 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/README.md +++ b/validation/experiments/README.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ # Experimental comparisons -This directory lets reviewers reproduce CableDyn's comparisons with six published physical +This directory lets reviewers reproduce CableDyn's comparisons with seven published physical experiments. Each subdirectory gives the data source, the translation of the published parameters into a CableDyn model, the assessed quantity, the reproduction commands and the committed results. @@ -15,5 +15,6 @@ committed results. | [`delta_flume/`](delta_flume/README.md) | Chaplin et al. (2005), 13.12 m vertical tension riser, stepped current, blind-trial cases 1–9 | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV, cross-flow and in-line | | [`wang_scr/`](wang_scr/README.md) | Wang et al. (2014), truncated steel catenary riser in uniform current, cross-flow VIV | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | | [`ndp_riser/`](ndp_riser/README.md) | Trim et al. (2005), NDP 38 m high-mode riser in uniform flow, cross-flow VIV with a generic and three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | +| [`flotant/`](flotant/README.md) | de Wilde et al. (2021), FLOTANT OD 48 mm power-cable specimen with a clump weight, tow tests and forced-oscillation RAOs, cross-flow and in-line VIV with three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI cable, synchronisation and wake-oscillator VIV | -The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D, L3-W and L3-N in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). +The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D, L3-W, L3-N and L3-F in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/README.md b/validation/experiments/flotant/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..439e8d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,341 @@ + + +# FLOTANT OD 48 mm research cable: VIV in tow tests + +This directory compares CableDyn with the tests of a power-cable specimen at MARIN for the EU +project FLOTANT: de Wilde, Heijnsdijk & de Ridder (2021), Deliverable D5.5, MARIN report +30995-53-DWB, a public deliverable without a DOI, +. A 6.4 m +cable of 48 mm outer diameter, a simplified 1:3 model of a 66 kV inter-array cable, hung +vertically from the towing carriage with a 200 kg clump weight below it and was towed at 40 +speeds from 0.025 to 1.0 m/s. The report gives the cross-flow and in-line A/D_rms at three +stations against the reduced velocity. The same specimen was forced by a hexapod in air and in +water, and those RAOs are used here to set up and check the structural model. + +The tow tests are predicted with three published VIV coefficient sets, none of them fitted to +these tests. The structure is identified from the forced-oscillation tests of the same specimen +only, never from the tow data. + +In short: on the identified structure the set of Ulveseter et al. (2019), fitted by them to +another riser, gives the height of the first cross-flow peak at mid-length (0.755 against +0.776), but it responds from a lower speed, holds the lock-in 1.2 Ur longer than the test and +stays high over the upper branch. The generic set is 38 % low at the peak and releases at the +measured speed; the wake oscillator is 62 % low. The r.m.s. log errors over the three stations +are 0.73, 0.59 and 1.21, large for all three sets. + +## The test (D5.5) + +- **Specimen (Table 2-1):** OD 48 mm, 6.4 m, 2.8 kg/m; 9.7 N/m in water (Table 2-2). +- **Set-up in water (Secs. 2.4, 2.5):** from the top, the carriage (or the hexapod), a + six-component force frame, a Cardan joint, the cable, a Cardan joint, a swivel, a load cell + and the clump weight. Tension 1970 N at the top and 1436 N at the bottom (Table 6-1). +- **Instrumentation (Sec. 3):** accelerometers at 1/2L, 3/4L and L from the top of the cable + (L is its lower end). The motions are the accelerations integrated twice, high-passed at + 3.5 rad/s for the tow tests (Table 3-4). +- **A/D (Sec. 3.4.4):** Appendix 3 plots the standard-deviation A/D, A/D_rms = σ/OD (p. 53: + "The presented results are for standard deviation A/Drms"); the nominal A/D is √2 σ/OD. The + first peak is A/D_rms 0.78 (nominal 1.10) at Ur 5.7. +- **Ur (Secs. 3.4.3, 6.3):** Ur = V/(OD f1) with f1 = 1.77 Hz. +- **Tow tests (Table 6-2):** one test per speed, 0.025 m/s apart, the towing direction + alternating from 0.15 m/s on (forwards at odd multiples of 0.025 m/s from there, backwards at + even ones). Each test is analysed over its steady part, 37.5 s at 1.0 m/s up to 580 s at + 0.025 m/s. + +### Caveats of the data + +- **The Ur basis.** Ur uses f1 = 1.77 Hz, while Sec. 5.3 calls the 1.3 Hz peak of the in-water + RAOs the first mode. The origin of 1.77 Hz is not given. On a 1.3 Hz basis every Ur would be + 1.36 times larger. The comparison here is made at the tested speeds, so the basis only + labels the axis; all Ur values here are on the report's 1.77 Hz basis. +- **The bottom tension.** Table 6-1 gives 1436 N at the bottom, while the in-water FEM table of + Sec. 5.4 gives 1687–1702 N along the chain above the clump, whose submerged weight it gives as + 1710.5 N. The cable's own wet weight (about 62 N) cannot explain a 534 N difference + between top and bottom. The model takes the FEM table; its static top tension is in the + results. +- **Towing direction.** Speed and direction are confounded (one test per speed). Between Ur 5.8 + and 9.2 the backward tests are mostly lower than the forward tests at the neighbouring speeds + (at 1/2L, 0.30–0.46 against 0.42–0.56). The report attributes small differences to the coil + curvature the specimen kept. The model is symmetric; the statistics are given over all tests + and per direction. +- **Displacements from accelerometers.** The accelerometers tilt with the cable, so the + derived displacement holds a gravity term g θ/ω² (θ the slope of the cable), which the + report does not remove. The model output is processed the same way (below); without the term + the cross-flow A/D_rms of the three sets changes by up to 5 % at 1/2L, 8 % at 3/4L and + 25 % at L for Ur ≥ 3, and the r.m.s. log errors by at most 0.07. +- **Not reported:** response frequencies (only the acceleration orbits of one test, Fig. 6-1), + repeat tests and uncertainties. + +## Model + +### Structure + +The line follows the report's node-by-node FEM input tables (Sec. 4.5 in air, Sec. 5.4 in +water; `fem_air.csv`, `fem_water.csv`): 101 nodes 0.0765 m apart, with the lumped masses, the +weights and the static tensions. Each table element is one CableDyn element (`--refine N` +splits it into N), grouped into runs by the label of its lower node: steel links (EI 1e6 N m², +rigid next to the cable), Cardan joints and the wire (EI 1 N m², hinges) and the cable. + +- **Water:** fresh, 1000 kg/m³. The report does not state it; the 2.8 kg/m and 9.7 N/m of + Table 2-2 at OD 48 mm imply 1000 kg/m³. The cable's diameter is the OD; the other parts take + the diameter of the displaced volume of their weight in the table. +- **Axial compliance:** the counterweight (air) or clump (water) keeps the tension nearly + constant. The model uses an axial spring k_ax = 20 kN/m in series with the table's EA, as + EA_eff = L/(1/k_ax + L/EA), with the unstretched lengths set so that the static tensions are + the table's. + +What the tests do not give, and how it was identified: + +- **Cable bending stiffness and damping, from the in-air RAOs (Appendix 1, 200 kg).** EI is not + measured: the tables' EI = 3.0 kN m² reproduces the in-air resonance (10.7 rad/s) only with + an empirical factor λ = 1.10 that MARIN introduced in the tensioned-beam formula to match it + (Sec. 4.5). The 2.8 % damping ratio of Sec. 4.4 is a single-degree-of-freedom fit, with an + assumed participation factor of 0.5, to one peak. Here a linear section was identified on a grid + of EI and the bending damping Bb (the `EI|Bb` form of the LINE TYPES EI column) against the + surge RAOs at 5 and 10 mm: EI near 1500 N m² puts the resonance at the measured frequency + (3000 puts it 5–6 % high), and the 10 mm peak needs a larger Bb than the 5 mm one (about 160 + against 110 N m² s): the peak falls with amplitude faster than a linear section can follow, + as the report notes. The model takes EI 1650 N m² and Bb 130 N m² s, between the two. The ends of the in-air rig are Cardan + joints, a swivel and a pulley, whose friction is in the measured loss: Bb is an upper bound + for the cable's own damping. +- **The lower end in water, from the in-water RAOs (Appendix 2, 200 kg, 5 mm, 1.0–3.0 Hz).** + The measured RAO has two peaks at 1/2L, at 1.3 and 1.8 Hz, with a notch at 1.5–1.6 Hz; + at 1.8 Hz station L moves little (surge 0.55 against 4.40 at 1/2L). MARIN's FEM table fixes the clump node and makes + the chain rigid (`--end table`); that model, and the same with the clump as a free point mass + (`--end free`, a `Free` End B), have one peak near 1.2–1.3 Hz. The model used here + (`--end identified`) has two elements below the cable that the tests point to, identified on + grids against the surge and sway RAOs over 1.0–3.0 Hz (run with sea-water density; the check + below, at 1000 kg/m³, gives the scores of this model): + - the link chain and its load cell bend with EI 100 N m² (best on surge; 250 N m² on + sway), neither a hinge (EI 1, which gives a spurious mode with large motion at L at + 2.6–2.7 Hz) nor rigid; + - the clump (200 kg, its displaced volume, C_d A 0.05 m² assumed, C_a 1) is a point load on + a short rigid segment held laterally by a spring K = 32.5 kN/m and a damper 20 N s/m (the + best K on sway, the cross-flow direction of the tow tests; 30 kN/m on surge), modelled as a + clamped cantilever post, K = 3 EI_p/l³ (l = 0.3 m), from a still anchor. + + This end is phenomenological: an impedance that reproduces the measured split of the first + mode, not a measured property of the rig. The damper hardly matters (1–80 N s/m changed the + RAO score by 0.004 in the identification grid). The clump's geometry and the chain are not described in the report. + +The RAO check (below) runs the model as identified. The line is axisymmetric, so one +forcing direction stands for surge and sway. + +### Hydrodynamics + +Uniform current along x over the whole line (the carriage speed), cross-flow (CF) along y. +C_D 1.2 and C_a 1 on the cable and the hardware. Three published VIV coefficient sets on the +cable, `--sets`: + +| Set | Source | Values | Fitted to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| `uls19` | Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1 and Sec. 4.1 | C_v,y 0.85, f̂0 0.144 ± 0.064, in-line C_v,x 0.75, α 0.15, C_hh 1.5, C_D 1.2, C_M 2 | the NDP 38 m riser in uniform flow: blind here | +| `b1` | The generic set of the Delta Flume riser case | C_l 0.8, f̂0 0.18 ± 0.08; in-line C_x 0.85, α 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018, Table 3); `VIV AMPLITUDE` C_v 0.8 with the drag amplification of Chaplin et al. (2005, Eq. 4); `VIV DAMPING` `0 0 1` | nothing from these tests: blind | +| `wake` | Facchinetti et al. (2004) | `WAKE OSCILLATOR` C_L0 0.3, St 0.2, ε 0.3, A 12; Morison drag | rigid-cylinder lift and lock-in data: blind | + +The values were checked against the source articles. + +### Run and processing + +- dt 2 ms, 60 s, statistics over t > 20 s (frequency resolution 0.025 Hz). The tests' steady + windows are longer (37.5–580 s, Table 6-2). +- **As the report processes the measurement:** each station's displacement plus the gravity + term of its tilted accelerometer, g θ/ω² (θ from the two neighbouring nodes), high-passed at + 3.5 rad/s, then A/D_rms = σ/OD. `response_comparison.csv` also holds the plain displacement + (`..._displacement`). +- Ur = V/(OD f1) with f1 = 1.77 Hz. +- The dominant CF frequency at 1/2L is the spectral peak of the high-passed displacement. +- **Statistics:** the r.m.s. log error, √(mean (ln ratio)²), over the tests from the onset the + report states, Ur ≥ 3 (30 speeds, 0.275–1.0 m/s); CF and in line, per station and over all + three. The peak is the largest CF A/D_rms at 1/2L; the release is the first tested Ur above + the peak where it falls below 70 % of the peak. +- **RAOs:** a harmonic at the forcing frequency fitted over the last 10 s of each forced run + (5 periods of cosine ramp, then 25 s), of the displacement plus the tilt term, over the + hexapod amplitude; scored as the r.m.s. log error over the stations, in air over the resonance + band 1.4–2.0 Hz (1/8L, 1/4L, 1/2L, 3/4L from the bottom), in water over 1.0–3.0 Hz (1/2L, + 3/4L, L from the top). + +### Measurements + +`extract_d55.py` reads the report's PDF (not distributed; PyMuPDF, NumPy, SciPy and Pillow): + +- `fem_air.csv`, `fem_water.csv`: the FEM input tables of Secs. 4.5 and 5.4, from the text. +- `measured_rao.csv`: the 5 and 10 mm RAOs of Appendices 1 and 2 (200 kg, surge and sway). + The charts are vector graphics: each series is read as plotted coordinates through the tick + labels (axis residual at most 1.2e-3); the frequencies fall on the 0.1 Hz test grid. The + axis is labelled "[rad]" and is in rad/s. +- `measured_tow_ad.csv`: Appendix 3, A/D_rms against Ur at the three stations, in line (X) and + cross-flow (Y), 40 points per chart (39 for Y at L, where an edge marker is clipped). The + charts are raster images (1386 × 867): the axes are calibrated on the grey grid lines (Ur + residual 0.004) and the markers found by colour. Every point maps to a tested speed, + V = Ur OD f1, within 0.0085 m/s of the 0.025 m/s grid; the CF peak at 1/2L reads 0.776 at Ur + 5.58 (the report: 0.78 at 5.7). + +The data are digitised from the report; its figures are not reproduced. + +## Reproduce + +From the repository root, with `path/to/cabledyn.exe` the release executable or a local build: + +```powershell +python validation/experiments/flotant/flotant_viv.py ` + path/to/cabledyn.exe validation/experiments/flotant/work --jobs 24 ` + --summary validation/experiments/flotant +``` + +The default is the committed record: the three sets at the 40 tested speeds (120 runs) and the +90 forced-oscillation runs, about 15 minutes with 24 parallel runs on a 24-core workstation; +each run reproduces its row of the record. `--parts tow` or `--parts rao`, `--sets` and +`--speeds` (comma lists; quote them in PowerShell, `--speeds "0.45,0.475"`) select parts; +`--end` changes the lower end of the tow model; `--dt`, `--refine` and `--tmax` the time step, +the mesh and the run length. A run whose folder holds the same input files and executable is not repeated; `--keep` +keeps the output tables (about 14 MB a tow run). + +## Results + +`response_comparison.csv` holds every tow run (all stations, both components, the measured +value at the same speed, the response frequency and the mean top tension), +`rao_comparison.csv` every forced run, `summary.json` the statistics and the SHA-256 of the +executable, and `provenance.json` the sources, assumptions and sensitivity runs. + +### Structure: the forced-oscillation RAOs + +r.m.s. log error of the RAOs over the stations and the band; peaks of the RAO at 1/2L (Hz: +RAO). + +| Case | Band | Surge | Sway | CableDyn peaks | Measured, surge | Measured, sway | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Air, 5 mm | 1.4–2.0 Hz | 0.227 | 0.278 | 1.7: 7.39 | 1.7: 8.68 | 1.7: 9.14 | +| Air, 10 mm | 1.4–2.0 Hz | 0.209 | 0.230 | 1.7: 7.23 | 1.7: 5.88 | 1.7: 6.40 | +| Water, 5 mm, MARIN's table end (`table`) | 1.0–3.0 Hz | 1.186 | 1.216 | 1.3: 3.94; 2.5: 1.36 | 1.3: 4.25; 1.8: 4.40 | 1.3: 4.31; 1.9: 2.99 | +| Water, 5 mm, free clump (`free`) | 1.0–3.0 Hz | 1.174 | 1.208 | 1.4: 3.68; 2.6: 1.31 | as above | as above | +| Water, 5 mm, identified end (`identified`) | 1.0–3.0 Hz | **0.459** | **0.743** | 1.2: 3.76; 1.9: 2.45 | as above | as above | + +- **In air** the resonance is at the measured 1.7 Hz. With one linear damping the peak is 15 % + below the 5 mm test and 23 % above the 10 mm test, which brackets the amplitude dependence the + test shows. +- **In water** only the identified end gives the two peaks and the notch between them. The upper + peak is low (2.45 against 4.40 in surge; the test frequencies are 0.1 Hz apart about a sharp + peak), the lower one is 0.1 Hz low, and station L moves too much at the upper peak (1.18 + against 0.55 at 1.8 Hz in surge). The sway fit is worse (0.743), since K and the chain EI are + the best values of different directions (above). The fixed and the free clump give one peak + near 1.3–1.4 Hz and a next mode at 2.5–2.6 Hz that the test does not have. + +### Tow tests + +Cross-flow (CF) and in-line (IL) A/D_rms over the 30 tests with Ur ≥ 3 at the three stations; +the ratio is CableDyn over measured at the same speed. + +| Set | Fitted to these tests | CF r.m.s. log error (1/2L, 3/4L, L) | CF ratio, median | IL r.m.s. log error | CF peak at 1/2L (Ur, f) | Release Ur | Top tension (N) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Measured | | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0.776 (5.58) | 5.88 | 1970 | +| `uls19` | no | 0.731 (0.690, 0.605, 0.876) | 1.60 | 0.742 | 0.755 (5.30, 1.25 Hz) | 7.06 | 1962–2076 | +| `b1` | no | **0.594** (0.497, 0.479, 0.769) | 0.95 | 1.017 | 0.483 (3.83, 1.25 Hz) | 5.89 | 1962–2185 | +| `wake` | no | 1.208 (1.190, 1.291, 1.137) | 0.41 | (no in-line VIV) | 0.296 (4.41, 1.30 Hz) | 5.30 | 1962–2031 | + +The measured top tension is Table 6-1's; the model's runs from the still-water value to the +mean at 1.0 m/s. + +Cross-flow A/D_rms at 1/2L at every test from Ur 2.9, with the dominant cross-flow frequency of +`uls19`: + +| V (m/s) | Ur | Direction | Measured | `uls19` | `b1` | `wake` | f (Hz), `uls19` | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 0.250 | 2.94 | backwards | 0.03 | 0.10 | 0.36 | 0.17 | 0.97 | +| 0.275 | 3.24 | forwards | 0.11 | 0.25 | 0.42 | 0.22 | 1.07 | +| 0.300 | 3.53 | backwards | 0.18 | 0.42 | 0.46 | 0.26 | 1.15 | +| 0.325 | 3.83 | forwards | 0.31 | 0.54 | 0.48 | 0.28 | 1.18 | +| 0.350 | 4.12 | backwards | 0.43 | 0.62 | 0.47 | 0.29 | 1.20 | +| 0.375 | 4.41 | forwards | 0.50 | 0.67 | 0.47 | 0.30 | 1.20 | +| 0.400 | 4.71 | backwards | 0.67 | 0.72 | 0.46 | 0.28 | 1.23 | +| 0.425 | 5.00 | forwards | 0.70 | 0.74 | 0.46 | 0.25 | 1.25 | +| 0.450 | 5.30 | backwards | 0.66 | 0.75 | 0.44 | 0.17 | 1.25 | +| 0.475 | 5.59 | forwards | 0.78 | 0.74 | 0.43 | 0.19 | 1.30 | +| 0.500 | 5.88 | backwards | 0.30 | 0.74 | 0.32 | 0.21 | 1.32 | +| 0.525 | 6.18 | forwards | 0.52 | 0.70 | 0.34 | 0.22 | 1.35 | +| 0.550 | 6.47 | backwards | 0.33 | 0.65 | 0.36 | 0.22 | 1.38 | +| 0.575 | 6.77 | forwards | 0.42 | 0.57 | 0.38 | 0.22 | 1.43 | +| 0.600 | 7.06 | backwards | 0.46 | 0.48 | 0.39 | 0.21 | 1.82 | +| 0.625 | 7.36 | forwards | 0.52 | 0.52 | 0.40 | 0.20 | 1.82 | +| 0.650 | 7.65 | backwards | 0.43 | 0.56 | 0.41 | 0.18 | 1.85 | +| 0.675 | 7.95 | forwards | 0.56 | 0.59 | 0.42 | 0.15 | 1.88 | +| 0.700 | 8.24 | backwards | 0.38 | 0.62 | 0.44 | 0.04 | 1.90 | +| 0.725 | 8.53 | forwards | 0.56 | 0.65 | 0.44 | 0.05 | 1.90 | +| 0.750 | 8.83 | backwards | 0.36 | 0.68 | 0.45 | 0.06 | 1.93 | +| 0.775 | 9.12 | forwards | 0.44 | 0.70 | 0.45 | 0.06 | 1.95 | +| 0.800 | 9.42 | backwards | 0.37 | 0.71 | 0.45 | 0.07 | 2.00 | +| 0.825 | 9.71 | forwards | 0.35 | 0.71 | 0.45 | 0.07 | 2.02 | +| 0.850 | 10.01 | backwards | 0.30 | 0.71 | 0.45 | 0.08 | 2.08 | +| 0.875 | 10.30 | forwards | 0.21 | 0.70 | 0.45 | 0.08 | 2.12 | +| 0.900 | 10.59 | backwards | 0.28 | 0.70 | 0.45 | 0.09 | 2.17 | +| 0.925 | 10.89 | forwards | 0.20 | 0.69 | 0.45 | 0.09 | 2.23 | +| 0.950 | 11.18 | backwards | 0.18 | 0.67 | 0.45 | 0.09 | 2.27 | +| 0.975 | 11.48 | forwards | 0.21 | 0.66 | 0.45 | 0.09 | 2.33 | +| 1.000 | 11.77 | backwards | 0.20 | 0.64 | 0.19 | 0.09 | 2.38 | + +- **`uls19`** (Ulveseter et al. 2019, fitted to another riser): + - the first peak is 0.755 at Ur 5.30 against 0.776 at Ur 5.58, and from Ur 4.7 to 5.6 the + model is within 0.10 of every test (0.72–0.75 against 0.66–0.78); + - the rise starts at a lower speed: 0.25–0.67 against 0.11–0.50 at Ur 3.24–4.41; + - the lock-in holds to Ur 6.77 (0.57) and releases at Ur 7.06, 1.2 Ur after the measured + release at 5.88; the response stays on the lower in-water mode (1.2–1.4 Hz) up to there and + moves to the upper one (1.8–2.0 Hz) at the release; + - on the upper branch, Ur 7.0–8.0, it is within 0.03 of the forward tests (0.52–0.59 against + 0.52–0.56); above Ur 9 it holds 0.64–0.71 where the test falls to 0.18–0.44; + - in line at 1/2L it is about half the measured value during the lock-in (0.08–0.13 against + 0.14–0.23 at Ur 4.1–5.6) and mostly above it after the release; + - below the compared range it responds at Ur 1.47 (0.11 at 1.3 Hz, f D/U 0.49), where the + test shows none (0.002). +- **`b1`** (generic): a plateau of 0.42–0.48 from Ur 3.24 to 5.59, 38 % below the measured + peak, from an early onset (0.36 at Ur 2.94 against 0.03); the release falls at the measured + Ur (5.89); the upper branch is 0.32–0.45. The in-line response during the lock-in is well + below the measured one (0.01–0.06 against 0.03–0.23). +- **`wake`** (Facchinetti et al. 2004): 0.22–0.30 up to Ur 5 on the lower mode, 62 % below the + measured peak; on the upper mode from Ur 5.30 (0.15–0.22) and on a higher one (2.975–3.45 Hz, + 0.04–0.09) from Ur 8.24. The model has no in-line VIV force, so its in-line response is the + drag's alone. +- **By direction** (1/2L, cross-flow r.m.s. log error, forward / backward tests): `uls19` + 0.647 / 0.729, `b1` 0.564 / 0.419, `wake` 1.214 / 1.164. The forward tests are the larger + ones on the upper branch, which suits `uls19` and not `b1`. +- **No set predicts these tests.** The height of the first peak is reproduced by `uls19`, its + speed range by none: `uls19` locks in too early and too long, `b1` releases at the right speed + at 62 % of the amplitude, and the wake oscillator is too weak. + +### Lower end and the tow prediction + +`uls19` at all 40 speeds with the other two lower ends (`--end`; `provenance.json`): + +| End | CF r.m.s. log error (1/2L) | CF peak at 1/2L (Ur) | Release Ur | RAO r.m.s. log error, surge | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| `identified` | 0.731 (0.690) | 0.755 (5.30) | 7.06 | 0.459 | +| `table` (MARIN's fixed clump) | 0.721 (0.433) | 0.805 (5.59) | 8.83 | 1.186 | +| `free` (a `Free` End B) | 0.692 (0.429) | 0.811 (5.59) | 9.12 | 1.174 | + +With the fixed or free clump the response at 1/2L drops to 0.19–0.36 from Ur 9.4, which lowers +the error there, while station L moves 0.53–0.67 against the measured 0.14–0.32 and the lock-in +releases 2.9–3.2 Ur late. The tow score over the three stations does not separate the ends; +the identified end is used because it reproduces the RAOs. Every end releases late. + +### Convergence + +At 0.30, 0.45, 0.50, 0.60 and 0.80 m/s for the three sets (`provenance.json`): + +- half the time step (1 ms) changes no A/D_rms by more than 0.006 (cross-flow at most 2.1 %) + and the dominant frequency by at most one bin; +- two elements per table element change no A/D_rms by more than 0.004 (cross-flow at most + 1.4 %), and the frequency not at all; +- 120 s runs (100 s of statistics) change no A/D_rms by more than 0.005 (cross-flow at most + 1.0 %). + +For the RAOs, two elements per table element and half the time step change every r.m.s. log +error by at most 0.001. + +## Limitations + +- The structure below the cable is an identified impedance, not a measured one, and the + in-water upper peak and station L are not matched closely; the cable's EI and damping come + from the in-air tests, whose losses include the end fixtures. +- The tow tests are single runs per speed with the direction alternating, without repeats or + uncertainties; the forward and backward tests differ on the upper branch. +- The measured response frequencies are not published, so the mode a set locks in to cannot be + checked against the test except through the amplitudes of the three stations. +- The data are digitised from figures (Appendix 3 from raster images, ±0.004 in Ur). diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/extract_d55.py b/validation/experiments/flotant/extract_d55.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3492f61 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/extract_d55.py @@ -0,0 +1,336 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""Extract the data of the FLOTANT D5.5 report used by flotant_viv.py from the report's PDF. + + python extract_d55.py path/to/210430_FLT-D5.5_VIV_test_v0.pdf [OUTDIR] + +Writes, by default next to this script: + fem_air.csv, fem_water.csv the node-by-node FEM input tables (Sec. 4.5, in air, and Sec. 5.4, + in water): element label, position, accelerometer station, X Y Z, + constraint flags, lumped mass [kg], weight [N] (submerged in water), + static tension [N], EA [N], EI [N m^2] + measured_rao.csv the RAOs of Appendix 1 (in air, 200 kg, surge and sway) and Appendix + 2 (in water, 200 kg, surge and sway) at 5 and 10 mm + measured_tow_ad.csv A/D_rms against Ur of the 200 kg tow tests, Appendix 3 + +The RAO charts are vector graphics: a series is a polyline with filled markers of one colour, +named by the legend entry beside the same marker; data coordinates follow from the tick-label +words by a linear map per chart (the frequency axis is labelled "[rad]" and is in rad/s). The +Appendix 3 charts are embedded raster images (1386 x 867 px) with the tick labels inside the +raster: their axes are calibrated on the light-grey gridlines (Ur -10, -5, 0, 5, 10; A/D from 0 +in the steps of PLOTS) and the markers are the tab:blue discs. Each digitised Ur is checked +against the test speeds of Table 6-2 (multiples of 0.025 m/s, V = |Ur| OD f1, OD 0.048 m, +f1 1.77 Hz). + +Needs PyMuPDF, NumPy, SciPy and Pillow; the report is not distributed with CableDyn. +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import csv +import io +import re +import sys +from collections import defaultdict +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np +import pymupdf +from PIL import Image +from scipy import ndimage +from scipy.cluster.vq import kmeans2 + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +OD, F1 = 0.048, 1.77 + +# ---------------------------------------------------------------- FEM input tables +FEM_PAGES = {"air": (58, 59), "water": (49, 50)} +ROW = re.compile( + r"(?P\d+)\s+(?P[A-Za-z]+)\s+(?P-?\d+\.\d+)\s+(?:(?P\d\.\d+L?|L|Hex|Top)\s+)?" + r"(?P-?\d+\.\d+)\s+(?P-?\d+\.\d+)\s+(?P-?\d+\.\d+)\s+(?P[01])(?=\s)\s+(?P[01])(?=\s)\s+" + r"(?P[01])(?=\s)\s+(?P[01])(?=\s)" + r"(?:\s+(?P-?[\d.]+)\s+(?P-?[\d.]+)\s+(?P-?[\d.]+)\s+(?P[\d.E+-]+)\s+(?P[\d.E+-]+))?" +) + + +def fem_tables(doc, out: Path) -> None: + for medium, pages in FEM_PAGES.items(): + text = re.sub(r"\s+", " ", " ".join(doc[p - 1].get_text() for p in pages)) + rows = [] + for m in ROW.finditer(text): + d = m.groupdict() + if rows and int(d["node"]) != rows[-1]["node"] + 1: + continue + if not rows and int(d["node"]) != 0: + continue + rows.append( + { + "node": int(d["node"]), + "element": d["el"], + "pos": float(d["pos"]), + "acc": d["acc"] or "", + "x": float(d["x"]), + "y": float(d["y"]), + "z": float(d["z"]), + "fixed": "".join(d[k] for k in ("c1", "c2", "c3", "c4")), + "mass": float(d["m"]) if d["m"] else None, + "weight": float(d["w"]) if d["w"] else None, + "tension": float(d["t"]) if d["t"] else None, + "EA": float(d["ea"]) if d["ea"] and d["ea"] not in "-" else None, + "EI": float(d["ei"]) if d["ei"] and d["ei"] not in "-" else None, + } + ) + with open(out / f"fem_{medium}.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + w = csv.DictWriter(fh, fieldnames=list(rows[0]), lineterminator="\n") + w.writeheader() + w.writerows(rows) + cab = [r for r in rows if r["element"] == "Cable"] + print( + f"fem_{medium}.csv: {len(rows)} nodes, {len(cab)} cable nodes, total lumped mass " + f"{sum(r['mass'] or 0 for r in rows):.2f} kg" + ) + + +# ---------------------------------------------------------------- RAOs (Appendices 1 and 2) +RAO_PAGES = {63: ("air", "X"), 64: ("air", "Y"), 67: ("water", "X"), 68: ("water", "Y")} +NUM = re.compile(r"^-?\d+,\d+$") + + +def num(s: str) -> float: + return float(s.replace(",", ".")) + + +def linear_fit(pairs): + n = len(pairs) + mx = sum(p for p, _ in pairs) / n + mv = sum(v for _, v in pairs) / n + a = sum((p - mx) * (v - mv) for p, v in pairs) / sum( + (p - mx) ** 2 for p, _ in pairs + ) + res = max(abs(mv + a * (p - mx) - v) for p, v in pairs) + return (lambda q: mv + a * (q - mx)), res + + +def axis_map(words, box): + """Linear maps (x -> data, y -> data) from the tick labels around the chart box.""" + x0, y0, _, y1 = box + yt = [ + ((w[1] + w[3]) / 2, num(w[4])) + for w in words # y labels carry two decimals, x labels one + if re.match(r"^-?\d+,\d\d$", w[4]) + and w[2] < x0 + 30 + and y0 - 8 < (w[1] + w[3]) / 2 < y1 + 8 + ] + # x ticks: the row of numbers on one baseline with the most entries in the chart's band + rows = defaultdict(list) + for w in words: + if NUM.match(w[4]) and w[0] > x0 - 10 and y0 - 8 < (w[1] + w[3]) / 2 < y1 + 20: + rows[round(w[1])].append(w) + xt = [((w[0] + w[2]) / 2, num(w[4])) for w in max(rows.values(), key=len)] + fx, rx = linear_fit(xt) + fy, ry = linear_fit(yt) + return fx, fy, rx, ry + + +def raos(doc, out: Path) -> None: + rows_all = [] + for pg, (medium, motion) in RAO_PAGES.items(): + page = doc[pg - 1] + words = page.get_text("words") + ticks = sorted( + (w for w in words if NUM.match(w[4]) and w[0] < 110), key=lambda w: w[1] + ) + mid = page.rect.height / 2 # the RAO chart is the upper one of the page + upper = [w for w in ticks if w[1] < mid] + ys = [(w[1] + w[3]) / 2 for w in upper] + xs = [w for w in words if NUM.match(w[4]) and w[1] < mid and w[0] > 110] + box = (min(w[2] for w in upper) + 2, min(ys), max(w[2] for w in xs), max(ys)) + fx, fy, rx, ry = axis_map(words, box) + markers: dict[tuple, list] = defaultdict(list) + for g in page.get_drawings(): + if g.get("type") != "fs" or g.get("fill") is None: + continue + r = g["rect"] + if r.width > 8 or r.height > 8: + continue + markers[tuple(round(c, 3) for c in g["fill"])].append( + ((r.x0 + r.x1) / 2, (r.y0 + r.y1) / 2) + ) + legend: dict[tuple, str] = {} + for col, pts in markers.items(): + for cx, cy in pts: + if box[3] + 25 < cy < box[3] + 140 and col not in legend: + row = sorted( + ( + w + for w in words + if abs((w[1] + w[3]) / 2 - cy) < 3 and cx < w[0] < cx + 120 + ), + key=lambda w: w[0], + ) + legend[col] = " ".join(w[4] for w in row[:5]) + n = 0 + for col, pts in markers.items(): + m = re.match( + r"([XY])_(\w+?)\s*\[m\]\s*-\s*amp\s*(\d+)mm", legend.get(col, "") + ) + if not m or int(m.group(3)) not in (5, 10): + continue + for cx, cy in pts: + if box[0] - 3 <= cx <= box[2] + 3 and box[1] - 3 <= cy <= box[3] + 3: + omega = fx(cx) + rows_all.append( + ( + medium, + motion, + m.group(2), + int(m.group(3)), + round(omega / (2 * np.pi), 1), + round(omega, 4), + round(fy(cy), 4), + pg, + ) + ) + n += 1 + print( + f"p{pg} ({medium}, {motion}): {n} points, axis residual {rx:.2g} rad/s, {ry:.2g}" + ) + rows_all.sort() + with open(out / "measured_rao.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + w = csv.writer(fh, lineterminator="\n") + w.writerow( + [ + "medium", + "motion", + "station", + "amp_mm", + "f_hz", + "omega_rad_s", + "rao", + "page", + ] + ) + w.writerows(rows_all) + + +# ---------------------------------------------------------------- tow tests (Appendix 3) +PLOTS = { # (page, image index): component, station, A/D gridline step + (70, 2): ("X", "1_2L", 0.05), + (70, 3): ("Y", "1_2L", 0.1), + (71, 2): ("X", "3_4L", 0.05), + (71, 3): ("Y", "3_4L", 0.1), + (72, 2): ("X", "L", 0.02), + (72, 3): ("Y", "L", 0.1), +} +UR_GRID = [-10.0, -5.0, 0.0, 5.0, 10.0] + + +def gridlines(mask: np.ndarray, axis: int, min_frac: float) -> list[float]: + """Centres of the runs of rows (axis=1) or columns (axis=0) that are mostly gridline grey.""" + frac = mask.mean(axis=axis) + idx = np.flatnonzero(frac > min_frac * frac.max()) + runs, cur = [], [idx[0]] + for i in idx[1:]: + if i == cur[-1] + 1: + cur.append(i) + else: + runs.append(cur) + cur = [i] + runs.append(cur) + return [float(np.mean(r)) for r in runs] + + +def digitise(image: Image.Image, step: float): + a = np.asarray(image.convert("RGB")).astype(int) + grey = np.all(np.abs(a - 230) <= 3, axis=2) + blue = ( + (np.abs(a[..., 0] - 31) < 25) + & (np.abs(a[..., 1] - 119) < 25) + & (np.abs(a[..., 2] - 180) < 25) + ) + cols = gridlines(grey, axis=0, min_frac=0.6) + rows = sorted( + gridlines(grey, axis=1, min_frac=0.6), reverse=True + ) # bottom (A/D 0) first + if len(cols) != len(UR_GRID): + raise SystemExit(f"found {len(cols)} vertical gridlines {cols}") + yvals = [step * k for k in range(len(rows))] + ax, bx = np.polyfit(cols, UR_GRID, 1) + ay, by = np.polyfit(rows, yvals, 1) + resx = max(abs(ax * c + bx - u) for c, u in zip(cols, UR_GRID)) + lab, n = ndimage.label(blue) + sizes = ndimage.sum(blue, lab, range(1, n + 1)) + med = float(np.median([s for s in sizes if s > 60])) + pts = [] + for i in [i + 1 for i, s in enumerate(sizes) if s > 0.4 * med]: + yy, xx = np.nonzero(lab == i) + cx, cy = xx.mean(), yy.mean() + if cy < 0.08 * a.shape[0] and cx > 0.85 * a.shape[1]: + continue # the legend marker + k = round(len(xx) / med) + if ( + k >= 2 + ): # overlapping markers (the slowest speeds): split the blob into k discs + xy = np.column_stack([xx, yy]).astype(float) + init = np.column_stack( + [np.linspace(xx.min() + 7, xx.max() - 7, k), np.full(k, cy)] + ) + cent, _ = kmeans2(xy, init, minit="matrix", seed=1) + pts += [(ax * cent[j, 0] + bx, ay * cent[j, 1] + by) for j in range(k)] + continue + pts.append((ax * cx + bx, ay * cy + by)) + return sorted(pts), resx + + +def tow(doc, out: Path) -> None: + rows = [] + for (pg, idx), (comp, st, step) in PLOTS.items(): + xref = doc[pg - 1].get_images(full=True)[idx][0] + image = Image.open(io.BytesIO(pymupdf.Pixmap(doc, xref).tobytes("png"))) + pts, resx = digitise(image, step) + print( + f"p{pg} image {idx} ({comp}, {st}): {len(pts)} points, Ur axis residual {resx:.3f}" + ) + for ur, ad in pts: + v = abs(ur) * OD * F1 + rows.append( + ( + st, + comp, + "forwards" if ur > 0 else "backwards", + round(abs(ur), 3), + round(v, 4), + f"{round(v / 0.025) * 0.025:.3f}", + round(ad, 4), + ) + ) + dv = max(abs(r[4] - float(r[5])) for r in rows) + print(f"speed check: |V - nearest multiple of 0.025 m/s| at most {dv:.4f} m/s") + with open(out / "measured_tow_ad.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + w = csv.writer(fh, lineterminator="\n") + w.writerow( + [ + "station", + "component", + "direction", + "Ur", + "V_digitised", + "V_test", + "AD_rms", + ] + ) + w.writerows(sorted(rows, key=lambda r: (r[0], r[1], float(r[5])))) + + +def main() -> None: + doc = pymupdf.open(sys.argv[1]) + out = Path(sys.argv[2]) if len(sys.argv) > 2 else HERE + out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + fem_tables(doc, out) + raos(doc, out) + tow(doc, out) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/fem_air.csv b/validation/experiments/flotant/fem_air.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c8245cc --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/fem_air.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +node,element,pos,acc,x,y,z,fixed,mass,weight,tension,EA,EI +0,Top,7.344,Top,0.0,0.0,0.0,1110,,,,, +1,Wire,7.267,,0.0,0.0,-0.076,0000,0.1,0.98,1996.0,100000000.0,1.0 +2,Wire,7.191,,0.0,0.0,-0.153,0000,0.1,0.98,1995.0,100000000.0,1.0 +3,Wire,7.114,,0.0,0.0,-0.229,0000,0.1,0.98,1994.0,100000000.0,1.0 +4,Wire,7.038,,0.0,0.0,-0.306,0000,0.1,0.98,1993.0,100000000.0,1.0 +5,Wire,6.961,,0.0,0.0,-0.382,0000,0.1,0.98,1992.0,100000000.0,1.0 +6,Steel,6.885,,0.0,0.0,-0.459,0000,1.12,10.99,1991.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +7,Joint,6.808,,0.0,0.0,-0.535,0000,0.1,0.98,1980.0,100000000.0,1.0 +8,Steel,6.732,,0.0,0.0,-0.612,0000,3.5,34.34,1979.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +9,Steel,6.655,,0.0,0.0,-0.688,0000,3.5,34.34,1945.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +10,Joint,6.579,,0.0,0.0,-0.765,0000,0.1,0.98,1910.0,100000000.0,1.0 +11,Steel,6.502,,0.0,0.0,-0.841,0000,2.89,28.35,1909.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +12,Cable,6.426,,0.0,0.0,-0.918,0000,0.214,2.1,1881.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +13,Cable,6.349,,0.0,0.0,-0.994,0000,0.214,2.1,1879.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +14,Cable,6.273,,0.0,0.0,-1.071,0000,0.214,2.1,1877.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +15,Cable,6.196,,0.0,0.0,-1.147,0000,0.214,2.1,1875.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +16,Cable,6.12,,0.0,0.0,-1.224,0000,0.214,2.1,1873.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +17,Cable,6.043,,0.0,0.0,-1.3,0000,0.214,2.1,1870.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +18,Cable,5.967,,0.0,0.0,-1.377,0000,0.214,2.1,1868.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +19,Cable,5.89,,0.0,0.0,-1.453,0000,0.214,2.1,1866.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +20,Cable,5.814,,0.0,0.0,-1.53,0000,0.214,2.1,1864.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +21,Cable,5.737,,0.0,0.0,-1.606,0000,0.214,2.1,1862.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +22,Cable,5.661,,0.0,0.0,-1.683,0000,0.214,2.1,1860.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +23,Cable,5.584,,0.0,0.0,-1.759,0000,0.214,2.1,1858.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +24,Cable,5.508,,0.0,0.0,-1.836,0000,0.214,2.1,1856.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +25,Cable,5.431,,0.0,0.0,-1.912,0000,0.214,2.1,1854.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +26,Cable,5.355,,0.0,0.0,-1.989,0000,0.214,2.1,1852.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +27,Cable,5.278,,0.0,0.0,-2.065,0000,0.214,2.1,1849.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +28,Cable,5.202,,0.0,0.0,-2.142,0000,0.214,2.1,1847.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +29,Cable,5.125,,0.0,0.0,-2.218,0000,0.214,2.1,1845.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +30,Cable,5.049,,0.0,0.0,-2.295,0000,0.214,2.1,1843.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +31,Cable,4.972,,0.0,0.0,-2.371,0000,0.214,2.1,1841.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +32,Cable,4.896,,0.0,0.0,-2.448,0000,0.214,2.1,1839.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +33,Cable,4.819,0.750,0.0,0.0,-2.524,0000,0.214,2.1,1837.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +34,Cable,4.743,,0.0,0.0,-2.601,0000,0.214,2.1,1835.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +35,Cable,4.666,,0.0,0.0,-2.677,0000,0.214,2.1,1833.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +36,Cable,4.59,,0.0,0.0,-2.754,0000,0.214,2.1,1831.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +37,Cable,4.513,,0.0,0.0,-2.83,0000,0.214,2.1,1828.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +38,Cable,4.437,,0.0,0.0,-2.907,0000,0.214,2.1,1826.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +39,Cable,4.36,,0.0,0.0,-2.983,0000,0.214,2.1,1824.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +40,Cable,4.284,,0.0,0.0,-3.06,0000,0.214,2.1,1822.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +41,Cable,4.207,,0.0,0.0,-3.136,0000,0.214,2.1,1820.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +42,Cable,4.131,,0.0,0.0,-3.213,0000,0.214,2.1,1818.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +43,Cable,4.054,,0.0,0.0,-3.289,0000,0.214,2.1,1816.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +44,Cable,3.978,,0.0,0.0,-3.366,0000,0.214,2.1,1814.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +45,Cable,3.901,,0.0,0.0,-3.442,0000,0.214,2.1,1812.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +46,Cable,3.825,,0.0,0.0,-3.519,0000,0.214,2.1,1810.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +47,Cable,3.748,,0.0,0.0,-3.595,0000,0.214,2.1,1807.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +48,Cable,3.672,,0.0,0.0,-3.672,0000,0.214,2.1,1805.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +49,Cable,3.595,,0.0,0.0,-3.748,0000,0.214,2.1,1803.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +50,Cable,3.519,,0.0,0.0,-3.825,0000,0.214,2.1,1801.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +51,Cable,3.442,,0.0,0.0,-3.901,0000,0.214,2.1,1799.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +52,Cable,3.366,,0.0,0.0,-3.978,0000,0.214,2.1,1797.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +53,Cable,3.289,,0.0,0.0,-4.054,0000,0.214,2.1,1795.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +54,Cable,3.213,0.500,0.0,0.0,-4.131,0000,0.214,2.1,1793.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +55,Cable,3.136,,0.0,0.0,-4.207,0000,0.214,2.1,1791.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +56,Cable,3.06,,0.0,0.0,-4.284,0000,0.214,2.1,1789.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +57,Cable,2.983,,0.0,0.0,-4.36,0000,0.214,2.1,1786.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +58,Cable,2.907,,0.0,0.0,-4.437,0000,0.214,2.1,1784.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +59,Cable,2.83,,0.0,0.0,-4.513,0000,0.214,2.1,1782.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +60,Cable,2.754,,0.0,0.0,-4.59,0000,0.214,2.1,1780.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +61,Cable,2.677,,0.0,0.0,-4.666,0000,0.214,2.1,1778.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +62,Cable,2.601,,0.0,0.0,-4.743,0000,0.214,2.1,1776.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +63,Cable,2.524,,0.0,0.0,-4.819,0000,0.214,2.1,1774.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +64,Cable,2.448,,0.0,0.0,-4.896,0000,0.214,2.1,1772.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +65,Cable,2.371,,0.0,0.0,-4.972,0000,0.214,2.1,1770.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +66,Cable,2.295,,0.0,0.0,-5.049,0000,0.214,2.1,1768.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +67,Cable,2.218,,0.0,0.0,-5.125,0000,0.214,2.1,1765.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +68,Cable,2.142,,0.0,0.0,-5.202,0000,0.214,2.1,1763.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +69,Cable,2.065,,0.0,0.0,-5.278,0000,0.214,2.1,1761.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +70,Cable,1.989,,0.0,0.0,-5.355,0000,0.214,2.1,1759.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +71,Cable,1.912,,0.0,0.0,-5.431,0000,0.214,2.1,1757.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +72,Cable,1.836,,0.0,0.0,-5.508,0000,0.214,2.1,1755.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +73,Cable,1.759,,0.0,0.0,-5.584,0000,0.214,2.1,1753.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +74,Cable,1.683,,0.0,0.0,-5.661,0000,0.214,2.1,1751.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +75,Cable,1.606,0.250,0.0,0.0,-5.737,0000,0.214,2.1,1749.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +76,Cable,1.53,,0.0,0.0,-5.814,0000,0.214,2.1,1747.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +77,Cable,1.453,,0.0,0.0,-5.89,0000,0.214,2.1,1744.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +78,Cable,1.377,,0.0,0.0,-5.967,0000,0.214,2.1,1742.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +79,Cable,1.3,,0.0,0.0,-6.043,0000,0.214,2.1,1740.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +80,Cable,1.224,,0.0,0.0,-6.12,0000,0.214,2.1,1738.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +81,Cable,1.147,,0.0,0.0,-6.196,0000,0.214,2.1,1736.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +82,Cable,1.071,,0.0,0.0,-6.273,0000,0.214,2.1,1734.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +83,Cable,0.994,,0.0,0.0,-6.349,0000,0.214,2.1,1732.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +84,Cable,0.918,,0.0,0.0,-6.426,0000,0.214,2.1,1730.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +85,Cable,0.841,0.125,0.0,0.0,-6.502,0000,0.214,2.1,1728.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +86,Cable,0.765,,0.0,0.0,-6.579,0000,0.214,2.1,1726.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +87,Cable,0.688,,0.0,0.0,-6.655,0000,0.214,2.1,1723.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +88,Cable,0.612,,0.0,0.0,-6.732,0000,0.214,2.1,1721.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +89,Cable,0.535,,0.0,0.0,-6.808,0000,0.214,2.1,1719.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +90,Cable,0.459,,0.0,0.0,-6.885,0000,0.214,2.1,1717.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +91,Cable,0.382,,0.0,0.0,-6.961,0000,0.214,2.1,1715.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +92,Cable,0.306,,0.0,0.0,-7.038,0000,0.214,2.1,1713.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +93,Cable,0.229,,0.0,0.0,-7.114,0000,0.214,2.1,1711.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +94,Cable,0.153,,0.0,0.0,-7.191,0000,0.214,2.1,1709.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +95,Cable,0.076,,0.0,0.0,-7.267,0000,0.214,2.1,1707.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +96,Cable,0.0,,0.0,0.0,-7.344,0000,0.214,2.1,1705.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +97,Steel,-0.076,,0.0,0.0,-7.42,0000,2.89,28.35,1702.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +98,Joint,-0.153,,0.0,0.0,-7.497,0000,0.1,0.98,1674.0,100000000.0,1.0 +99,Steel,-0.229,,0.0,0.0,-7.573,0000,5.21,51.11,1673.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +100,Joint,-0.306,Hex,0.0,0.0,-7.65,1110,,,,, diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/fem_water.csv b/validation/experiments/flotant/fem_water.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7f1d70a --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/fem_water.csv @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +node,element,pos,acc,x,y,z,fixed,mass,weight,tension,EA,EI +0,Joint,-0.307,Hex,0.0,0.0,0.0,1110,,,,, +1,Steel,-0.23,,0.0,0.0,-0.077,0000,5.21,44.6,1921.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +2,Joint,-0.153,,0.0,0.0,-0.153,0000,0.1,0.9,1877.0,100000000.0,1.0 +3,Steel,-0.077,,0.0,0.0,-0.23,0000,2.89,24.7,1876.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +4,Cable,0.0,,0.0,0.0,-0.307,0000,0.214,0.7,1851.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +5,Cable,0.077,,0.0,0.0,-0.384,0000,0.214,0.7,1850.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +6,Cable,0.153,,0.0,0.0,-0.46,0000,0.214,0.7,1850.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +7,Cable,0.23,,0.0,0.0,-0.537,0000,0.214,0.7,1849.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +8,Cable,0.307,,0.0,0.0,-0.614,0000,0.214,0.7,1848.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +9,Cable,0.384,,0.0,0.0,-0.691,0000,0.214,0.7,1847.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +10,Cable,0.46,,0.0,0.0,-0.767,0000,0.214,0.7,1847.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +11,Cable,0.537,,0.0,0.0,-0.844,0000,0.214,0.7,1846.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +12,Cable,0.614,,0.0,0.0,-0.921,0000,0.214,0.7,1845.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +13,Cable,0.691,,0.0,0.0,-0.997,0000,0.214,0.7,1844.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +14,Cable,0.767,,0.0,0.0,-1.074,0000,0.214,0.7,1844.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +15,Cable,0.844,,0.0,0.0,-1.151,0000,0.214,0.7,1843.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +16,Cable,0.921,,0.0,0.0,-1.228,0000,0.214,0.7,1842.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +17,Cable,0.997,,0.0,0.0,-1.304,0000,0.214,0.7,1841.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +18,Cable,1.074,,0.0,0.0,-1.381,0000,0.214,0.7,1841.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +19,Cable,1.151,,0.0,0.0,-1.458,0000,0.214,0.7,1840.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +20,Cable,1.228,,0.0,0.0,-1.535,0000,0.214,0.7,1839.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +21,Cable,1.304,,0.0,0.0,-1.611,0000,0.214,0.7,1838.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +22,Cable,1.381,,0.0,0.0,-1.688,0000,0.214,0.7,1838.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +23,Cable,1.458,,0.0,0.0,-1.765,0000,0.214,0.7,1837.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +24,Cable,1.535,,0.0,0.0,-1.841,0000,0.214,0.7,1836.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +25,Cable,1.611,,0.0,0.0,-1.918,0000,0.214,0.7,1835.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +26,Cable,1.688,,0.0,0.0,-1.995,0000,0.214,0.7,1835.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +27,Cable,1.765,,0.0,0.0,-2.072,0000,0.214,0.7,1834.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +28,Cable,1.841,,0.0,0.0,-2.148,0000,0.214,0.7,1833.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +29,Cable,1.918,,0.0,0.0,-2.225,0000,0.214,0.7,1832.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +30,Cable,1.995,,0.0,0.0,-2.302,0000,0.214,0.7,1832.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +31,Cable,2.072,,0.0,0.0,-2.378,0000,0.214,0.7,1831.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +32,Cable,2.148,,0.0,0.0,-2.455,0000,0.214,0.7,1830.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +33,Cable,2.225,,0.0,0.0,-2.532,0000,0.214,0.7,1829.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +34,Cable,2.302,,0.0,0.0,-2.609,0000,0.214,0.7,1829.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +35,Cable,2.378,,0.0,0.0,-2.685,0000,0.214,0.7,1828.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +36,Cable,2.455,,0.0,0.0,-2.762,0000,0.214,0.7,1827.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +37,Cable,2.532,,0.0,0.0,-2.839,0000,0.214,0.7,1826.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +38,Cable,2.609,,0.0,0.0,-2.916,0000,0.214,0.7,1826.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +39,Cable,2.685,,0.0,0.0,-2.992,0000,0.214,0.7,1825.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +40,Cable,2.762,,0.0,0.0,-3.069,0000,0.214,0.7,1824.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +41,Cable,2.839,,0.0,0.0,-3.146,0000,0.214,0.7,1824.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +42,Cable,2.916,,0.0,0.0,-3.222,0000,0.214,0.7,1823.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +43,Cable,2.992,,0.0,0.0,-3.299,0000,0.214,0.7,1822.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +44,Cable,3.069,,0.0,0.0,-3.376,0000,0.214,0.7,1821.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +45,Cable,3.146,,0.0,0.0,-3.453,0000,0.214,0.7,1821.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +46,Cable,3.222,0.50L,0.0,0.0,-3.529,0000,0.214,0.7,1820.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +47,Cable,3.299,,0.0,0.0,-3.606,0000,0.214,0.7,1819.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +48,Cable,3.376,,0.0,0.0,-3.683,0000,0.214,0.7,1818.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +49,Cable,3.453,,0.0,0.0,-3.76,0000,0.214,0.7,1818.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +50,Cable,3.529,,0.0,0.0,-3.836,0000,0.214,0.7,1817.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +51,Cable,3.606,,0.0,0.0,-3.913,0000,0.214,0.7,1816.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +52,Cable,3.683,,0.0,0.0,-3.99,0000,0.214,0.7,1815.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +53,Cable,3.76,,0.0,0.0,-4.066,0000,0.214,0.7,1815.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +54,Cable,3.836,,0.0,0.0,-4.143,0000,0.214,0.7,1814.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +55,Cable,3.913,,0.0,0.0,-4.22,0000,0.214,0.7,1813.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +56,Cable,3.99,,0.0,0.0,-4.297,0000,0.214,0.7,1812.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +57,Cable,4.066,,0.0,0.0,-4.373,0000,0.214,0.7,1812.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +58,Cable,4.143,,0.0,0.0,-4.45,0000,0.214,0.7,1811.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +59,Cable,4.22,,0.0,0.0,-4.527,0000,0.214,0.7,1810.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +60,Cable,4.297,,0.0,0.0,-4.604,0000,0.214,0.7,1809.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +61,Cable,4.373,,0.0,0.0,-4.68,0000,0.214,0.7,1809.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +62,Cable,4.45,,0.0,0.0,-4.757,0000,0.214,0.7,1808.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +63,Cable,4.527,,0.0,0.0,-4.834,0000,0.214,0.7,1807.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +64,Cable,4.604,,0.0,0.0,-4.91,0000,0.214,0.7,1806.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +65,Cable,4.68,,0.0,0.0,-4.987,0000,0.214,0.7,1806.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +66,Cable,4.757,,0.0,0.0,-5.064,0000,0.214,0.7,1805.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +67,Cable,4.834,0.75L,0.0,0.0,-5.141,0000,0.214,0.7,1804.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +68,Cable,4.91,,0.0,0.0,-5.217,0000,0.214,0.7,1803.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +69,Cable,4.987,,0.0,0.0,-5.294,0000,0.214,0.7,1803.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +70,Cable,5.064,,0.0,0.0,-5.371,0000,0.214,0.7,1802.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +71,Cable,5.141,,0.0,0.0,-5.447,0000,0.214,0.7,1801.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +72,Cable,5.217,,0.0,0.0,-5.524,0000,0.214,0.7,1801.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +73,Cable,5.294,,0.0,0.0,-5.601,0000,0.214,0.7,1800.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +74,Cable,5.371,,0.0,0.0,-5.678,0000,0.214,0.7,1799.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +75,Cable,5.447,,0.0,0.0,-5.754,0000,0.214,0.7,1798.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +76,Cable,5.524,,0.0,0.0,-5.831,0000,0.214,0.7,1798.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +77,Cable,5.601,,0.0,0.0,-5.908,0000,0.214,0.7,1797.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +78,Cable,5.678,,0.0,0.0,-5.985,0000,0.214,0.7,1796.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +79,Cable,5.754,,0.0,0.0,-6.061,0000,0.214,0.7,1795.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +80,Cable,5.831,,0.0,0.0,-6.138,0000,0.214,0.7,1795.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +81,Cable,5.908,,0.0,0.0,-6.215,0000,0.214,0.7,1794.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +82,Cable,5.985,,0.0,0.0,-6.291,0000,0.214,0.7,1793.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +83,Cable,6.061,,0.0,0.0,-6.368,0000,0.214,0.7,1792.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +84,Cable,6.138,,0.0,0.0,-6.445,0000,0.214,0.7,1792.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +85,Cable,6.215,,0.0,0.0,-6.522,0000,0.214,0.7,1791.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +86,Cable,6.291,,0.0,0.0,-6.598,0000,0.214,0.7,1790.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +87,Cable,6.368,,0.0,0.0,-6.675,0000,0.214,0.7,1789.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +88,Cable,6.445,L,0.0,0.0,-6.752,0000,0.214,0.7,1789.0,100000000.0,3000.0 +89,Steel,6.522,,0.0,0.0,-6.829,0000,2.89,24.7,1788.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +90,Joint,6.598,,0.0,0.0,-6.905,0000,0.1,0.9,1763.0,100000000.0,1.0 +91,Steel,6.675,,0.0,0.0,-6.982,0000,3.5,29.9,1762.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +92,Steel,6.752,,0.0,0.0,-7.059,0000,3.5,29.9,1732.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +93,Joint,6.829,,0.0,0.0,-7.135,0000,0.1,0.9,1702.0,100000000.0,1.0 +94,Steel,6.905,,0.0,0.0,-7.212,0000,0.335,2.9,1702.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +95,Chain,6.982,,0.0,0.0,-7.289,0000,0.335,2.9,1699.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +96,Chain,7.059,,0.0,0.0,-7.366,0000,0.335,2.9,1696.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +97,Sensor,7.135,,0.0,0.0,-7.442,0000,0.335,2.9,1693.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +98,Chain,7.212,,0.0,0.0,-7.519,0000,0.335,2.9,1690.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +99,Chain,7.289,,0.0,0.0,-7.596,0000,0.335,2.9,1687.0,100000000.0,10000000000.0 +100,Clump,7.366,,0.0,0.0,-7.673,1110,200.0,1710.5,-23.0,, diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/flotant_viv.py b/validation/experiments/flotant/flotant_viv.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..21290ae --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/flotant_viv.py @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""VIV of the FLOTANT OD 48 mm research cable towed at 200 kg, and its forced-oscillation RAOs. + +The tests of de Wilde, Heijnsdijk & de Ridder (2021, FLOTANT Deliverable D5.5, MARIN): a 6.4 m +OD 48 mm cable hanging from the towing carriage with a 200 kg clump weight, towed at 0.025-1.0 +m/s, and the same cable forced by a hexapod in air and in water. Writes a deck per case, runs +them in parallel and compares: + tow cross-flow and in-line A/D_rms (sigma/OD) at 1/2L, 3/4L and L against the measured + values of Appendix 3, for three published VIV coefficient sets; + rao the RAOs of the stations in air (Appendix 1) and in water (Appendix 2), the structural + check of the model: in air the cable section, in water three models of the lower end. + + python flotant_viv.py path/to/cabledyn.exe WORKDIR [--parts tow,rao] [--sets uls19,b1,wake] + [--speeds all | 0.3,0.475,...] [--end identified|table|free] [--dt 0.002] [--refine 1] + [--tmax 60] [--t0 20] [--jobs N] [--keep] [--summary DIR] + +Sources: + J. de Wilde, R. Heijnsdijk, E.-J. de Ridder (2021), D5.5 - Report on VIV (hydrodynamic) + behaviour, FLOTANT deliverable 210430-FLT-WP5_D-5-5_V0 (MARIN report 30995-53-DWB), + https://flotantproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/210430_FLT-D5.5_VIV_test_v0.pdf + (the set-up, Sec. 2; processing, Sec. 3.4; FEM input, Secs. 4.5 and 5.4; Tables 6-1 and 6-2; + Appendices 1-3) + J.V. Ulveseter, M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2019), Simulating fundamental and higher + harmonic VIV of slender structures, Applied Ocean Research 90, 101856, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apor.2019.101856 (Table 1, Sec. 4.1) + J.V. Ulveseter, M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2018), Time domain simulation of riser + VIV in current and irregular waves, Marine Structures 60, 241-260, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2018.04.001 (Table 3) + J.R. Chaplin, P.W. Bearman, F.J. Huera Huarte, R.J. Pattenden (2005), Laboratory measurements + of vortex-induced vibrations of a vertical tension riser in a stepped current, Journal of + Fluids and Structures 21(1), 3-24, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010 (Eq. 4) + M.L. Facchinetti, E. de Langre, F. Biolley (2004), Coupling of structure and wake oscillators + in vortex-induced vibrations, Journal of Fluids and Structures 19(2), 123-140, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2003.12.004 +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import csv +import hashlib +import json +import math +import os +import shutil +import subprocess +from concurrent.futures import ThreadPoolExecutor +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +GRAVITY = 9.80665 # m/s^2 +# Fresh water: the report does not state the density; Table 2-2's 2.8 kg/m and 9.7 N/m in +# water at OD 48 mm imply 1000 kg/m^3. +RHO = {"air": 1.225, "water": 1000.0} +OD = 0.048 # m (Table 2-1) +F1_UR = 1.77 # Hz, the frequency of Ur in Appendix 3 (Sec. 6.3) +W_HIGHPASS = ( + 3.5 # rad/s, the tow-test filter of the double-integrated accelerations (Table 3-4) +) + +# The structure. The line follows the report's FEM input tables (fem_air.csv, fem_water.csv) +# node for node; the cable section and the lower end in water are identified from the RAOs +# (see the README). +EA_TABLE = 1.0e8 # N, the tables' EA +EI_STEEL = 1.0e6 # N m^2, steel links (rigid next to the cable) +EI_HINGE = 1.0 # N m^2, the Cardan joints and the steel wire +CABLE_EI = 1650.0 # N m^2, identified from the in-air RAOs (the tables give 3000) +CABLE_BB = 130.0 # N m^2 s, bending damping, identified from the in-air RAOs +K_AX = ( + 2.0e4 # N/m, the counterweight (air) or clump (water) as an axial spring in series +) +# The identified lower end in water: the link chain and load cell resist bending (CHAIN_EI) and +# the clump, a point mass on a short rigid segment, is held laterally by a spring END_K and +# damper END_C, modelled as a clamped cantilever post of length POST_LEN (K = 3 EI_p / l^3). +CHAIN_EI = 100.0 # N m^2 +END_K = 32500.0 # N/m +END_C = 20.0 # N s/m +POST_LEN = 0.30 # m +CLUMP_SEG = 0.10 # m +POST_TENSION = ( + 1000.0 # N, the static tension the post and segment lengths are stretched for +) +CLUMP_MASS = 200.0 # kg +CLUMP_WEIGHT = 1710.5 # N in water (Sec. 5.4 table, the clump node) +CLUMP_CDA = 0.05 # m^2, assumed (not given) +CD, CA = 1.2, 1.0 # the cable and the hardware +ENDS = ("identified", "table", "free") +SPEEDS = [round(0.025 * k, 3) for k in range(1, 41)] # Table 6-2 [m/s] +STATIONS = { # table node of each accelerometer -> station + "water": {46: "1_2L", 67: "3_4L", 88: "L"}, + "air": {85: "1_8L", 75: "1_4L", 54: "1_2L", 33: "3_4L"}, +} +# The forced-oscillation cases compared: the measured frequencies of Appendices 1 and 2 at +# 5 and 10 mm in a band about the first modes. The line is axisymmetric, so one direction (X) +# of forcing stands for both; it is compared with the surge and the sway tests. +RAO_CASES = { + ("air", 5): [round(1.0 + 0.1 * k, 1) for k in range(16)], + ("air", 10): [round(1.0 + 0.1 * k, 1) for k in range(11)], + ("water", 5): [round(1.0 + 0.1 * k, 1) for k in range(21)], +} +RAO_SCORE_BAND = {"air": (1.4, 2.0), "water": (1.0, 3.0)} # Hz +RAO_WINDOW = 10.0 # s, the harmonic fit at the end of each forced run +UR_MIN = 3.0 # the compared tow tests: from the onset the report states (Sec. 6.3) +RELEASE_FRACTION = 0.7 # release: the first test above the peak below 70 % of the peak +ANALYSIS = "1" # part of the reuse key: bump when an analysis changes + + +def chaplin_amplification(ad: float) -> float: + """Chaplin et al. (2005, Eq. 4): Cd/Cd0 = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s^2, s = (A/D)/sqrt(2).""" + s = ad / math.sqrt(2.0) + return 1.0 + 2.3 * s + 1.7 * s * s + + +# Coefficient sets on the cable: LINE TYPES Cl dF cF; VIV row (ClX, alpha, Chh); VIV AMPLITUDE +# with Chaplin's drag amplification; VIV DAMPING (a, b, c); WAKE OSCILLATOR (CL0, St, eps, A). +SETS: dict[str, dict] = { + "uls19": { + "label": "Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1, Chh 1.5", + "fitted": "the NDP riser in uniform flow; blind here", + "cl": (0.85, 0.064, 0.144), + "viv": (0.75, 0.15, 1.5), + "amp": False, + "damping": None, + "wake": None, + }, + "b1": { + "label": "generic set (Delta Flume case)", + "fitted": "no; blind", + "cl": (0.8, 0.08, 0.18), + "viv": (0.85, 0.15, None), + "amp": True, + "damping": (0, 0, 1), + "wake": None, + }, + "wake": { + "label": "Facchinetti et al. (2004) wake oscillator", + "fitted": "rigid-cylinder data; blind", + "cl": (0, 0.08, 0.18), + "viv": None, + "amp": False, + "damping": None, + "wake": (0.3, 0.2, 0.3, 12), + }, +} + + +def load_table(medium: str) -> list[dict]: + with open(HERE / f"fem_{medium}.csv", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + rows = list(csv.DictReader(fh)) + for r in rows: + for k in ("pos", "x", "y", "z", "mass", "weight", "tension", "EA", "EI"): + r[k] = float(r[k]) if r[k] not in ("", "None") else None + return rows + + +def clump_volume() -> float: + return (CLUMP_MASS * GRAVITY - CLUMP_WEIGHT) / (RHO["water"] * GRAVITY) + + +def line_runs(medium: str, end: str) -> tuple[list[dict], list, float]: + """The line as runs of equal table elements, End A (top) first. + + Each table element (0.0765 m) is one element of the run labelled by its lower table node + (Wire, Steel, Joint, Cable, Chain, Sensor), with the node's lumped mass over the element + and, in water, the diameter of the displaced volume of the table's weight (the cable: OD). + The unstretched lengths give the table's static tensions with the effective axial stiffness + EA_eff = L / (1/k_ax + L/EA). Returns (rows, runs, EA_eff); a run is + [(label, mass per m, diameter, EI), length, elements]. + """ + rows = load_table(medium) + ltot = abs(rows[-1]["z"] - rows[0]["z"]) + ea_eff = ltot / (1.0 / K_AX + ltot / EA_TABLE) + elems = [] + for k in range(1, len(rows)): + src, lab = rows[k], rows[k]["element"] + if k == len(rows) - 1: + # the element into the end point (the hexapod joint in air, the clump in water): + # the end node's lumped mass is not line mass + prev = rows[k - 1] + if lab in ("Clump", "Hex", "Top"): + lab = prev["element"] + src = dict(prev) + if lab == "Joint": + src["mass"] = 0.1 + src["weight"] = 0.1 * GRAVITY * (1.0 if medium == "air" else 0.87) + dz = abs(rows[k]["z"] - rows[k - 1]["z"]) + l0 = dz / (1.0 + src["tension"] / ea_eff) + m = src["mass"] / dz + if lab == "Cable": + diam = OD + elif medium == "water": + vol = max( + (m * GRAVITY - src["weight"] / dz) / (RHO["water"] * GRAVITY), 0.0 + ) + diam = math.sqrt(4.0 * vol / math.pi) if vol else 0.05 + else: + diam = 0.05 + ei = ( + CABLE_EI + if lab == "Cable" + else (EI_HINGE if lab in ("Joint", "Wire") else EI_STEEL) + ) + if end == "identified" and medium == "water" and lab in ("Chain", "Sensor"): + ei = CHAIN_EI + elems.append((lab, l0, m, diam, ei)) + if end == "identified" and medium == "water": + # the clump as a point load on a light rigid segment, then the post to a still anchor + stretch = 1.0 + POST_TENSION / ea_eff + elems += [("Clumpseg", CLUMP_SEG / 2.0 / stretch, 1.0, 0.05, EI_STEEL)] * 2 + elems += [ + ("Post", POST_LEN / 4.0 / stretch, 1.0, 0.02, END_K * POST_LEN**3 / 3.0) + ] * 4 + # consecutive elements of one label form a run; mass and diameter are length-weighted means + # (the table's 0.076/0.077 m spacing would otherwise split every run) + groups: list[list] = [] + for e in elems: + if groups and groups[-1][0][0] == e[0]: + groups[-1].append(e) + else: + groups.append([e]) + runs = [] + for g in groups: + lg = sum(e[1] for e in g) + m = sum(e[2] * e[1] for e in g) / lg + dsq = sum(e[3] ** 2 * e[1] for e in g) / lg # keeps the displaced volume + runs.append([(g[0][0], m, math.sqrt(dsq), g[0][4]), lg, len(g)]) + return rows, runs, ea_eff + + +def station_nodes(medium: str, refine: int) -> dict[str, int]: + """CableDyn node of each station: table node k is node k * refine + 1.""" + return {st: k * refine + 1 for k, st in STATIONS[medium].items()} + + +def deck( + medium: str, + end: str, + hset: str | None, + current: float, + motion: tuple[float, float] | None, + dt: float, + tmax: float, + refine: int, +) -> dict[str, str]: + """The deck and its input files: {file name: text}.""" + rows, runs, ea_eff = line_runs(medium, end) + s = SETS[hset] if hset else None + types, secs, cable = [], [], [] + for i, ((lab, m, diam, ei), l0, n) in enumerate(runs): + tname = f"{lab.lower()}{i}" + cl = "0 0.08 0.18" + cd, ca = CD, CA + if lab == "Post": + bb = END_C * POST_LEN**3 / 3.0 + eicol = f"{ei:.9g}|{bb:.9g}" + cd, ca = 0.0, 0.0 + elif lab == "Cable": + eicol = f"{CABLE_EI:g}|{CABLE_BB:g}" + if s: + cl = " ".join(f"{v:g}" for v in s["cl"]) + cable.append(tname) + else: + eicol = f"{ei:g}" + types.append( + f"{tname} {diam:.6f} {m:.6f} {ea_eff:.6e} 0.0 {eicol} {cd} 0.0 {ca} 0.0 {cl}" + ) + secs.append(f"1 {tname} {l0:.9f} {n * refine}") + z_top, z_bot = rows[0]["z"], rows[-1]["z"] + extra = "" + if end == "identified" and medium == "water": + arc = 0.0 + for (lab, *_), l0, _n in runs: + if lab == "Clumpseg": + arc += 0.5 * l0 + break + arc += l0 + extra += ( + "--------------------- ATTACHMENTS ----------------------------------\n" + "LineID ArcLength Mass Volume CdA Ca\n(-) (m) (kg) (m^3) (m^2) (-)\n" + f"1 {arc:.9f} {CLUMP_MASS} {clump_volume():.6f} {CLUMP_CDA} 1.0\n" + "--------------------- END CONNECTIONS -------------------------------\n" + "LineID End Stiffness EzX EzY EzZ\n(-) (-) (N-m/rad) (-) (-) (-)\n" + "1 B Rigid 0 0 -1\n" + ) + z_bot -= CLUMP_SEG + POST_LEN + if s and s["viv"]: + clx, alpha, chh = s["viv"] + cols, vals = "ClX alpha", f"{clx} {alpha}" + if chh is not None: + cols, vals = cols + " Chh", vals + f" {chh}" + extra += ( + "--------------------- VIV ----------------------------------------------\n" + f"TypeName {cols}\n(-){' (-)' * len(cols.split())}\n" + + "".join(f"{c} {vals}\n" for c in cable) + ) + if s and s["amp"]: + extra += ( + "--------------------- VIV AMPLITUDE ------------------------------------\n" + "TypeName AD Cv CdAmp\n(-) (-) (-) (-)\n" + + "".join( + f"{c} {0.1 * k:.2f} {s['cl'][0]} {chaplin_amplification(0.1 * k):.5f}\n" + for c in cable + for k in range(16) + ) + ) + if s and s["damping"]: + a, b, c3 = s["damping"] + extra += ( + "--------------------- VIV DAMPING ------------------------------------\n" + "TypeName a b c\n(-) (-) (-) (-)\n" + + "".join(f"{c} {a} {b} {c3}\n" for c in cable) + ) + if s and s["wake"]: + extra += ( + "--------------------- WAKE OSCILLATOR ----------------------------------\n" + "TypeName CL0 St eps A\n(-) (-) (-) (-) (-)\n" + + "".join(f"{c} {' '.join(f'{v:g}' for v in s['wake'])}\n" for c in cable) + ) + bottom = f"2 Coupled 0.0 0.0 {z_bot:.6f} 0 0 0 0" + if end == "free" and medium == "water": + bottom = f"2 Free 0.0 0.0 {z_bot:.6f} {CLUMP_MASS} {clump_volume():.6f} {CLUMP_CDA} 1.0" + nodes = station_nodes(medium, refine) + outs = ["FairTen1"] + [ + f"L1N{j + d}p{c}" for j in nodes.values() for d in (-1, 0, 1) for c in "xyz" + ] + files: dict[str, str] = {} + if current: + files["current_profile.txt"] = ( + f"z ux uy uz\n(m) (m/s) (m/s) (m/s)\n{z_bot - 2.0:.3f} {current} 0 0\n0.0 {current} 0 0\n" + ) + title = f"FLOTANT D5.5 OD 48 mm cable, {medium}, end {end}" + ( + f", tow {current} m/s, set {hset}" if current else f", forced {motion}" + ) + files[ + "flotant.dat" + ] = f"""--------------------- CableDyn Input File --------------------------------- +{title} +----------------------- LINE TYPES ------------------------------------------ +TypeName Diam Mass EA BA EI Cd_n Cd_t Ca_n Ca_t Cl dF cF +(-) (m) (kg/m) (N) (N-s) (N-m^2) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) +{chr(10).join(types)} +----------------------- POINTS ---------------------------------------------- +ID Attachment X Y Z M V CdA CA +(-) (-) (m) (m) (m) (kg) (m^3) (m^2) (-) +1 Coupled 0.0 0.0 {z_top:.6f} 0 0 0 0 +{bottom} +----------------------- LINES ----------------------------------------------- +ID NodeA NodeB Outputs +(-) (-) (-) (-) +1 1 2 - +----------------------- SECTIONS -------------------------------------------- +LineID LineType Length NumSegs +(-) (-) (m) (-) +{chr(10).join(secs)} +{extra}---------------------- OPTIONS ---------------------------------------------- +{RHO[medium]} rhoW +{GRAVITY} g +{abs(z_bot) + 2.0:.3f} WtrDpth +{dt:.6f} dtM +{tmax:.6f} TMax +{"1 Currents" + chr(10) if current else ""}{"motion.txt" if motion else "0"} motionFile +---------------------- OUTPUTS ----------------------------------------------- +{chr(10).join(outs)} +END +------------------------- need this line -------------------------------------- +""" + if motion: + files["motion.txt"] = motion_text(medium, end, z_top, z_bot, motion, dt, tmax) + return files + + +def motion_text(medium, end, z_top, z_bot, motion, dt, tmax) -> str: + """The hexapod (the bottom point in air, the top point in water) moves in x as A sin(w t), + reached over a 5-period cosine ramp; the other Coupled point is still.""" + amp, f = motion + hexapod = 2 if medium == "air" else 1 + points = ( + ((1, z_top),) + if (end == "free" and medium == "water") + else ((1, z_top), (2, z_bot)) + ) + w, tr = 2.0 * math.pi * f, 5.0 / f + lines = ["# time point x y z vx vy vz ax ay az"] + for k in range(round(tmax / dt) + 1): + t = k * dt + if t < tr: + r = 0.5 * (1.0 - math.cos(math.pi * t / tr)) + dr = 0.5 * math.pi / tr * math.sin(math.pi * t / tr) + ddr = 0.5 * (math.pi / tr) ** 2 * math.cos(math.pi * t / tr) + else: + r, dr, ddr = 1.0, 0.0, 0.0 + sn, cs = math.sin(w * t), math.cos(w * t) + for pid, z0 in points: + x = vx = ax = 0.0 + if pid == hexapod: + x = amp * r * sn + vx = amp * (dr * sn + r * w * cs) + ax = amp * (ddr * sn + 2.0 * dr * w * cs - r * w * w * sn) + lines.append( + f"{t:.6f} {pid} {x:.9e} {0.0:.9e} {z0:.9e} {vx:.9e} {0.0:.9e} " + f"{0.0:.9e} {ax:.9e} {0.0:.9e} {0.0:.9e}" + ) + return "\n".join(lines) + "\n" + + +def read_output(out: Path) -> tuple[list[str], np.ndarray]: + with open(out, encoding="utf-8") as fh: + fh.readline() + head = fh.readline().split() + fh.readline() + a = np.loadtxt(fh) + return head, a + + +def highpass(x: np.ndarray, theta: np.ndarray | None, dt: float) -> np.ndarray: + """The displacement as the report derives it from an accelerometer that tilts with the + cable: x + g theta / omega^2 (the gravity component on the tilted sensor axis, with theta + the slope dx/dz; theta None leaves it out), high-passed at W_HIGHPASS rad/s.""" + f = np.fft.rfftfreq(len(x), dt) + w = 2.0 * np.pi * f + sp = np.fft.rfft(x - x.mean()) + keep = w >= W_HIGHPASS + if theta is not None: + sp[keep] += GRAVITY * np.fft.rfft(theta - theta.mean())[keep] / w[keep] ** 2 + sp[~keep] = 0.0 + return np.fft.irfft(sp, len(x)) + + +def slope(a: np.ndarray, head: list[str], j: int, c: str) -> np.ndarray: + """dx/dz at node j from its neighbours (central difference).""" + xm, xp = a[:, head.index(f"L1N{j - 1}p{c}")], a[:, head.index(f"L1N{j + 1}p{c}")] + zm, zp = a[:, head.index(f"L1N{j - 1}pz")], a[:, head.index(f"L1N{j + 1}pz")] + return (xm - xp) / (zm - zp) + + +def analyse_tow(out: Path, u: float, t0: float, refine: int) -> dict: + """A/D_rms = sigma / OD of each station and direction over t > t0, as measured (with the + tilt term) and of the displacement itself; the dominant cross-flow frequency at 1/2L.""" + head, a = read_output(out) + k = a[:, 0] > t0 + a = a[k] + dt = float(a[1, 0] - a[0, 0]) + res: dict = {"mean_top_tension_N": float(a[:, head.index("FairTen1")].mean())} + for st, j in station_nodes("water", refine).items(): + for comp, c in (("IL", "x"), ("CF", "y")): + x = a[:, head.index(f"L1N{j}p{c}")] + res[f"AD_{comp}_{st}"] = float( + highpass(x, slope(a, head, j, c), dt).std() / OD + ) + res[f"AD_{comp}_{st}_displacement"] = float( + highpass(x, None, dt).std() / OD + ) + j = station_nodes("water", refine)["1_2L"] + y = highpass(a[:, head.index(f"L1N{j}py")], None, dt) + f = np.fft.rfftfreq(len(y), dt) + fp = float(f[int(np.argmax(np.abs(np.fft.rfft(y))))]) + res["f_cf_1_2L_hz"] = fp + res["fD_over_U_cf_1_2L"] = fp * OD / u + res["frequency_resolution_hz"] = float(1.0 / (len(y) * dt)) + return res + + +def harmonic(t: np.ndarray, x: np.ndarray, w: float) -> complex: + m = np.column_stack([np.sin(w * t), np.cos(w * t), np.ones_like(t)]) + c, *_ = np.linalg.lstsq(m, x, rcond=None) + return complex(c[0], c[1]) + + +def analyse_rao(out: Path, medium: str, amp: float, f: float, refine: int) -> dict: + """RAO of each station along the forcing over the last RAO_WINDOW s: the harmonic of + x + g theta / omega^2 (as the accelerometers measure it) over the hexapod amplitude.""" + head, a = read_output(out) + t = a[:, 0] + k = t > t[-1] - RAO_WINDOW + w = 2.0 * math.pi * f + res = {} + for st, j in station_nodes(medium, refine).items(): + x = a[k, head.index(f"L1N{j}px")] + th = slope(a[k], head, j, "x") + res[f"RAO_{st}"] = abs(harmonic(t[k], x + GRAVITY * th / w**2, w)) / amp + res[f"RAO_{st}_displacement"] = abs(harmonic(t[k], x, w)) / amp + return res + + +def run_case( + exe: Path, folder: Path, files: dict, analyse, key: str, keep: bool, sha: str +) -> dict: + """Write the deck, run it and analyse it. A folder that holds the same input files run by + the same executable is not run again: its result is reused when the analysis key is also + the same, and its output is analysed again if it was kept.""" + folder.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + result, out, ran = ( + folder / "result.json", + folder / "flotant.out", + folder / "executable_sha256.txt", + ) + same = all( + (folder / n).is_file() and (folder / n).read_text(encoding="utf-8") == v + for n, v in files.items() + ) + if same and result.is_file(): + old = json.loads(result.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + if old.pop("reuse_key", None) == f"{sha}:{key}": + return old + if not ( + same and out.is_file() and ran.is_file() and ran.read_text().strip() == sha + ): + # A run that fails or is interrupted must not leave the previous model's result next + # to the new inputs, where the next attempt would reuse it. + result.unlink(missing_ok=True) + ran.unlink(missing_ok=True) + out.unlink(missing_ok=True) + for n, v in files.items(): + (folder / n).write_text(v, encoding="utf-8", newline="\n") + proc = subprocess.run( + [str(exe), "flotant.dat", "flotant"], + cwd=folder, + capture_output=True, + text=True, + encoding="utf-8", + errors="replace", + env=dict(os.environ, OMP_NUM_THREADS="1"), + check=False, + ) + (folder / "console.txt").write_text(proc.stdout + proc.stderr, encoding="utf-8") + if proc.returncode != 0: + raise SystemExit(f"{folder}: CableDyn exited with {proc.returncode}") + ran.write_text(sha + "\n", encoding="utf-8") + res = analyse(out) + result.write_text( + json.dumps({**res, "reuse_key": f"{sha}:{key}"}, indent=1) + "\n", + encoding="utf-8", + ) + if not keep: + out.unlink() + return res + + +def read_csv(name: str) -> list[dict]: + with open(HERE / name, encoding="utf-8") as fh: + return list(csv.DictReader(fh)) + + +def rms_log(ratios: list[float]) -> float | None: + return float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.log(ratios) ** 2))) if ratios else None + + +def fmt(value: float | None, spec: str = ".3f") -> str: + """A score for the console; n/a when no test of the selection enters it (Ur < UR_MIN).""" + return "n/a" if value is None else format(value, spec) + + +def peak_and_release(points: list[tuple[float, float]]) -> dict: + """The largest A/D, its Ur, and the release: the first Ur above the peak at which A/D + falls below RELEASE_FRACTION of the peak (None when it never does).""" + points = sorted(points) + i = max(range(len(points)), key=lambda k: points[k][1]) + ur_p, ad_p = points[i] + rel = next((ur for ur, ad in points[i + 1 :] if ad < RELEASE_FRACTION * ad_p), None) + return {"peak_AD": ad_p, "peak_Ur": ur_p, "release_Ur": rel} + + +def parse_speeds(text: str) -> list[float]: + if text == "all": + return SPEEDS + out = sorted({round(float(v), 3) for v in text.split(",")}) + if not out or any(v not in SPEEDS for v in out): + raise SystemExit( + f"--speeds: the tests are 0.025, 0.050, ..., 1.000 m/s, got {text!r}" + ) + return out + + +def compare_tow(results: list[dict], sets: list[str]) -> tuple[list[dict], dict]: + meas: dict = {} + for r in read_csv("measured_tow_ad.csv"): + comp = "CF" if r["component"] == "Y" else "IL" + meas[(r["station"], comp, float(r["V_test"]))] = ( + float(r["AD_rms"]), + float(r["Ur"]), + r["direction"], + ) + rows, per_set = [], {} + stations = list(STATIONS["water"].values()) + for s in sets: + rs = sorted((r for r in results if r["set"] == s), key=lambda r: r["U_m_per_s"]) + ratios: dict = {} + for r in rs: + u = r["U_m_per_s"] + ur = u / (OD * F1_UR) + row = {"set": s, "U_m_per_s": u, "Ur": round(ur, 3)} + for comp in ("CF", "IL"): + for st in stations: + mv = meas.get((st, comp, u)) + model = r[f"AD_{comp}_{st}"] + row[f"AD_{comp}_{st}_measured"] = mv[0] if mv else "" + row[f"AD_{comp}_{st}_cabledyn"] = round(model, 4) + row[f"AD_{comp}_{st}_cabledyn_displacement"] = round( + r[f"AD_{comp}_{st}_displacement"], 4 + ) + if mv: + row["direction"] = mv[2] + if mv and ur >= UR_MIN: + ratios.setdefault((comp, st), []).append(model / mv[0]) + ratios.setdefault((comp, st, mv[2]), []).append(model / mv[0]) + row["f_cf_1_2L_hz"] = round(r["f_cf_1_2L_hz"], 3) + row["fD_U_cf_1_2L"] = round(r["fD_over_U_cf_1_2L"], 4) + row["mean_top_tension_N"] = round(r["mean_top_tension_N"], 1) + rows.append(row) + model_pts = [(r["U_m_per_s"] / (OD * F1_UR), r["AD_CF_1_2L"]) for r in rs] + meas_pts = [ + (mv[1], mv[0]) + for (st, comp, u), mv in meas.items() + if st == "1_2L" and comp == "CF" and u in [r["U_m_per_s"] for r in rs] + ] + pk = peak_and_release(model_pts) + f_at_peak = next( + r["f_cf_1_2L_hz"] + for r in rs + if abs(r["U_m_per_s"] / (OD * F1_UR) - pk["peak_Ur"]) < 1e-9 + ) + cf_all = [q for st in stations for q in ratios.get(("CF", st), [])] + il_all = [q for st in stations for q in ratios.get(("IL", st), [])] + per_set[s] = { + "label": SETS[s]["label"], + "fitted_to": SETS[s]["fitted"], + "speeds": [r["U_m_per_s"] for r in rs], + "compared_tests": f"Ur >= {UR_MIN:g}", + "cf_rms_log_error_all_stations": rms_log(cf_all), + "cf_ratio_median_all_stations": float(np.median(cf_all)) + if cf_all + else None, + "il_rms_log_error_all_stations": rms_log(il_all), + "il_ratio_median_all_stations": float(np.median(il_all)) + if il_all + else None, + "cf_rms_log_error": { + st: rms_log(ratios.get(("CF", st), [])) for st in stations + }, + "il_rms_log_error": { + st: rms_log(ratios.get(("IL", st), [])) for st in stations + }, + "cf_rms_log_error_1_2L_by_direction": { + d: rms_log(ratios.get(("CF", "1_2L", d), [])) + for d in ("forwards", "backwards") + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak": {**pk, "f_hz_at_peak": f_at_peak}, + "cf_1_2L_peak_measured": peak_and_release(meas_pts) if meas_pts else None, + "mean_top_tension_N_range": [ + round(min(r["mean_top_tension_N"] for r in rs)), + round(max(r["mean_top_tension_N"] for r in rs)), + ], + } + p, q = per_set[s]["cf_1_2L_peak"], per_set[s]["cf_1_2L_peak_measured"] + print( + f"{s}: CF r.m.s. log error {fmt(per_set[s]['cf_rms_log_error_all_stations'])} " + f"(1/2L {fmt(per_set[s]['cf_rms_log_error']['1_2L'])}), IL " + f"{fmt(per_set[s]['il_rms_log_error_all_stations'])}; 1/2L peak {p['peak_AD']:.3f} at Ur " + f"{p['peak_Ur']:.2f} ({p['f_hz_at_peak']:.2f} Hz), release Ur {p['release_Ur']}" + + ( + f" | measured {q['peak_AD']:.3f} at {q['peak_Ur']:.2f}, release {q['release_Ur']}" + if q + else "" + ) + ) + return rows, per_set + + +def compare_rao(results: list[dict]) -> tuple[list[dict], dict]: + meas: dict = {} + for r in read_csv("measured_rao.csv"): + meas[ + (r["medium"], r["motion"], r["station"], int(r["amp_mm"]), float(r["f_hz"])) + ] = float(r["rao"]) + rows, summary = [], {} + for r in sorted( + results, key=lambda r: (r["medium"], r["end"], r["amp_mm"], r["f_hz"]) + ): + for st in STATIONS[r["medium"]].values(): + row = {k: r[k] for k in ("medium", "end", "amp_mm", "f_hz")} + row["station"] = st + row["rao_cabledyn"] = round(r[f"RAO_{st}"], 4) + row["rao_cabledyn_displacement"] = round(r[f"RAO_{st}_displacement"], 4) + for motion, name in (("X", "surge"), ("Y", "sway")): + row[f"rao_measured_{name}"] = meas.get( + (r["medium"], motion, st, r["amp_mm"], r["f_hz"]), "" + ) + rows.append(row) + groups = sorted({(r["medium"], r["end"], r["amp_mm"]) for r in rows}) + for medium, end, amp in groups: + lo, hi = RAO_SCORE_BAND[medium] + g = [ + r + for r in rows + if (r["medium"], r["end"], r["amp_mm"]) == (medium, end, amp) + ] + entry = {} + for name in ("surge", "sway"): + err = [ + math.log(r["rao_cabledyn"] / r[f"rao_measured_{name}"]) + for r in g + if r[f"rao_measured_{name}"] != "" + and lo - 1e-9 <= r["f_hz"] <= hi + 1e-9 + ] + half = sorted( + (r for r in g if r["station"] == "1_2L"), key=lambda r: r["f_hz"] + ) + mh = [ + (r["f_hz"], r[f"rao_measured_{name}"]) + for r in half + if r[f"rao_measured_{name}"] != "" + ] + entry[name] = { + "rms_log_error": float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.square(err)))) + if err + else None, + "band_hz": [lo, hi], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": local_peaks( + [(r["f_hz"], r["rao_cabledyn"]) for r in half] + ), + "peaks_1_2L_measured": local_peaks(mh), + } + summary[f"{medium}_{end}_{amp}mm"] = entry + print( + f"rao {medium:5s} {end:10s} {amp:2d} mm: r.m.s. log error surge {entry['surge']['rms_log_error']:.3f}, " + f"sway {entry['sway']['rms_log_error']:.3f}; 1/2L peaks {entry['surge']['peaks_1_2L_cabledyn']} " + f"(surge test {entry['surge']['peaks_1_2L_measured']}, sway {entry['sway']['peaks_1_2L_measured']})" + ) + return rows, summary + + +def local_peaks(pts: list[tuple[float, float]], n: int = 2) -> list[list[float]]: + """The n highest local maxima [f, RAO] of a sampled curve, in frequency order.""" + pts = sorted(pts) + i = [ + k + for k in range(1, len(pts) - 1) + if pts[k][1] >= pts[k - 1][1] and pts[k][1] >= pts[k + 1][1] + ] + top = sorted(i, key=lambda k: -pts[k][1])[:n] + return [[pts[k][0], round(pts[k][1], 3)] for k in sorted(top)] + + +def main() -> None: + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) + ap.add_argument("exe") + ap.add_argument("workdir") + ap.add_argument("--parts", default="tow,rao", help="comma list of tow, rao") + ap.add_argument( + "--sets", default=",".join(SETS), help="comma list of " + ", ".join(SETS) + ) + ap.add_argument( + "--speeds", default="all", help="comma list of tow speeds [m/s], or all" + ) + ap.add_argument( + "--end", + default="identified", + choices=ENDS, + help="the lower end of the tow model", + ) + ap.add_argument("--dt", type=float, default=0.002) + ap.add_argument("--refine", type=int, default=1, help="elements per table element") + ap.add_argument("--tmax", type=float, default=60.0, help="tow run length [s]") + ap.add_argument( + "--t0", type=float, default=20.0, help="start of the tow statistics [s]" + ) + ap.add_argument("--jobs", type=int, default=os.cpu_count() or 1) + ap.add_argument("--keep", action="store_true", help="keep the output tables") + ap.add_argument( + "--summary", + default=None, + help="directory for the comparison CSVs and summary JSON", + ) + a = ap.parse_args() + found = a.exe if Path(a.exe).is_file() else shutil.which(a.exe) + if found is None: + raise SystemExit(f"CableDyn executable not found: {a.exe}") + exe = Path(found).resolve() + sha = hashlib.sha256(exe.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + parts = [p.strip() for p in a.parts.split(",") if p.strip()] + if not parts or any(p not in ("tow", "rao") for p in parts): + raise SystemExit(f"--parts: choose from tow, rao, got {a.parts!r}") + sets = [s.strip() for s in a.sets.split(",") if s.strip()] + if not sets or any(s not in SETS for s in sets): + raise SystemExit(f"--sets: choose from {', '.join(SETS)}, got {a.sets!r}") + speeds = parse_speeds(a.speeds) + tag = f"dt{a.dt:g}_r{a.refine}" + work = Path(a.workdir).resolve() + jobs = [] + if "tow" in parts: + tmax = round(a.tmax / a.dt) * a.dt + for s in sets: + for u in speeds: + files = deck("water", a.end, s, u, None, a.dt, tmax, a.refine) + folder = work / f"tow_{s}_{a.end}_v{u:.3f}_{tag}_t{a.tmax:g}" + key = f"tow:{a.t0:g}:{ANALYSIS}" + + def an(out, u=u): + return analyse_tow(out, u, a.t0, a.refine) + + jobs.append( + ({"part": "tow", "set": s, "U_m_per_s": u}, folder, files, an, key) + ) + if "rao" in parts: + for (medium, amp), freqs in RAO_CASES.items(): + for end in ENDS if medium == "water" else ("table",): + for f in freqs: + tmax = round((5.0 / f + 25.0) / a.dt) * a.dt + files = deck( + medium, end, None, 0.0, (amp / 1000.0, f), a.dt, tmax, a.refine + ) + folder = work / f"rao_{medium}_{end}_a{amp}mm_f{f:.2f}_{tag}" + + def an(out, medium=medium, amp=amp, f=f): + return analyse_rao(out, medium, amp / 1000.0, f, a.refine) + + info = { + "part": "rao", + "medium": medium, + "end": end, + "amp_mm": amp, + "f_hz": f, + } + jobs.append( + (info, folder, files, an, f"rao:{RAO_WINDOW:g}:{ANALYSIS}") + ) + + def one(job): + info, folder, files, an, key = job + return {**info, **run_case(exe, folder, files, an, key, a.keep, sha)} + + with ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=max(1, min(a.jobs, len(jobs)))) as pool: + results = list(pool.map(one, jobs)) + summary: dict = { + "dt_s": a.dt, + "elements_per_table_element": a.refine, + "tow": None, + "rao": None, + "executable_sha256": sha, + } + tow_rows = rao_rows = None + if "tow" in parts: + tow_rows, per_set = compare_tow( + [r for r in results if r["part"] == "tow"], sets + ) + summary["tow"] = { + "end": a.end, + "tmax_s": a.tmax, + "statistics_after_s": a.t0, + "highpass_rad_s": W_HIGHPASS, + "Ur_frequency_hz": F1_UR, + "release_fraction_of_peak": RELEASE_FRACTION, + "per_set": per_set, + } + if "rao" in parts: + rao_rows, summary["rao"] = compare_rao( + [r for r in results if r["part"] == "rao"] + ) + if a.summary: + out = Path(a.summary) + out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + for name, rows in ( + ("response_comparison.csv", tow_rows), + ("rao_comparison.csv", rao_rows), + ): + if rows: + with open(out / name, "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + fields = list(dict.fromkeys(k for r in rows for k in r)) + w = csv.DictWriter(fh, fieldnames=fields, lineterminator="\n") + w.writeheader() + w.writerows(rows) + (out / "summary.json").write_text( + json.dumps(summary, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n" + ) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/measured_rao.csv b/validation/experiments/flotant/measured_rao.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..533cd74 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/measured_rao.csv @@ -0,0 +1,670 @@ +medium,motion,station,amp_mm,f_hz,omega_rad_s,rao,page +air,X,1_2L,5,0.5,3.1414,0.4766,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,0.6,3.7652,0.5462,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,0.7,4.3951,0.5984,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,0.8,5.025,0.6332,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,0.9,5.6489,0.6941,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.0,6.2787,0.755,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.1,6.9086,0.8334,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.2,7.5325,0.9378,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.3,8.1623,1.0857,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.4,8.7922,1.3468,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.7993,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.6,10.046,2.9393,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.7,10.6758,8.6826,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.8,11.3057,4.845,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,1.9,11.9296,2.5825,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.0,12.5594,1.7036,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.1,13.1893,1.1466,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.2,13.8192,0.8247,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.3,14.4431,0.5897,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.4,15.0729,0.3983,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.5,15.7028,0.2155,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.6,16.3267,0.0589,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.7,16.9566,0.2155,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.8,17.5864,0.4853,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,2.9,18.2163,1.0422,63 +air,X,1_2L,5,3.0,18.8402,2.9567,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,0.5,3.1354,0.4766,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,0.6,3.7652,0.5375,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,0.7,4.3951,0.5984,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,0.8,5.025,0.6506,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,0.9,5.6489,0.7028,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.0,6.2787,0.7724,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.1,6.9086,0.8682,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.2,7.5325,0.99,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.3,8.1623,1.164,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.4,8.7922,1.4686,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.5,9.4221,2.1213,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.6,10.046,4.3316,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.7,10.6758,5.8806,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.8,11.3297,3.4614,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,1.9,11.9356,2.1387,63 +air,X,1_2L,10,2.0,12.5594,1.7819,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,0.5,3.1414,0.7028,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,0.6,3.7652,0.755,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,0.7,4.3951,0.7985,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,0.8,5.025,0.8334,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,0.9,5.6489,0.8769,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.0,6.2787,0.9291,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.1,6.9086,0.9813,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.2,7.5325,1.0596,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.3,8.1623,1.1727,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.4,8.7922,1.3642,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.6862,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.6,10.046,2.4955,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.7,10.6758,6.2547,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.8,11.3057,3.0785,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,1.9,11.9296,1.3555,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.0,12.5594,0.6854,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.1,13.1893,0.2764,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.2,13.8192,0.085,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.3,14.4431,0.2329,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.4,15.0729,0.3983,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.5,15.7028,0.5636,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.6,16.3267,0.7289,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.7,16.9566,0.9204,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.8,17.5864,1.2162,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,2.9,18.2163,1.9124,63 +air,X,1_4L,5,3.0,18.8402,3.5919,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,0.5,3.1354,0.6941,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,0.6,3.7652,0.755,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,0.7,4.3951,0.7985,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,0.8,5.025,0.8508,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,0.9,5.6489,0.8943,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.0,6.2787,0.9465,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.1,6.9086,1.0248,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.2,7.5325,1.1118,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.3,8.1623,1.2424,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.4,8.7922,1.4599,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.9472,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.6,10.046,3.5484,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.7,10.6758,4.114,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.8,11.3297,2.1039,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,1.9,11.9356,1.1031,63 +air,X,1_4L,10,2.0,12.5594,0.7985,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,0.5,3.1414,0.7898,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,0.6,3.7652,0.8421,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,0.7,4.3951,0.8769,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,0.8,5.025,0.903,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,0.9,5.6489,0.9378,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.0,6.2787,0.9639,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.1,6.9086,1.0074,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.2,7.5325,1.0509,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.3,8.1623,1.1205,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.4,8.7922,1.2424,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.4512,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.6,10.046,1.9472,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.7,10.6758,4.0009,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.8,11.3057,1.6426,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,1.9,11.9296,0.4766,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.0,12.5594,0.1459,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.1,13.1893,0.3286,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.2,13.8192,0.4853,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.3,14.4431,0.6071,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.4,15.0729,0.7202,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.5,15.7028,0.8334,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.6,16.3267,0.9378,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.7,16.9566,1.0596,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.8,17.5864,1.2598,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,2.9,18.2163,1.7645,63 +air,X,1_8L,5,3.0,18.8402,2.6347,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,0.5,3.1354,0.7811,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,0.6,3.7652,0.8334,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,0.7,4.3951,0.8769,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,0.8,5.025,0.9117,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,0.9,5.6489,0.9465,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.0,6.2787,0.99,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.1,6.9086,1.0335,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.2,7.5325,1.0944,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.3,8.1623,1.1727,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.4,8.7922,1.312,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.6252,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.6,10.046,2.6521,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.7,10.6758,2.539,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.8,11.3297,1.0596,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,1.9,11.9356,0.4157,63 +air,X,1_8L,10,2.0,12.5594,0.2242,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,0.5,3.1414,0.2503,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,0.6,3.7652,0.3112,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,0.7,4.3951,0.3547,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,0.8,5.025,0.3895,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,0.9,5.6489,0.4331,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.0,6.2787,0.4853,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.1,6.9086,0.5549,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.2,7.5325,0.6419,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.3,8.1623,0.7724,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.4,8.7922,1.0074,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.4077,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.6,10.046,2.4345,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.7,10.6758,7.8472,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.8,11.3057,4.6275,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,1.9,11.9296,2.6608,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.0,12.5594,1.9124,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.1,13.1893,1.4338,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.2,13.8192,1.1727,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.3,14.4431,1.0074,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.4,15.0729,0.8943,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.5,15.7028,0.7985,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.6,16.3267,0.7289,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.7,16.9566,0.6767,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.8,17.5864,0.6593,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,2.9,18.2163,0.7289,63 +air,X,3_4L,5,3.0,18.8402,0.6332,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,0.5,3.1354,0.2503,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,0.6,3.7652,0.3025,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,0.7,4.3951,0.3547,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,0.8,5.025,0.3983,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,0.9,5.6489,0.4418,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.0,6.2787,0.5027,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.1,6.9086,0.581,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.2,7.5325,0.6941,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.3,8.1623,0.8334,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.4,8.7922,1.1031,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.6775,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.6,10.046,3.6615,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.7,10.6758,5.4019,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.8,11.3297,3.3744,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,1.9,11.9356,2.2257,63 +air,X,3_4L,10,2.0,12.5594,1.9385,63 +air,X,L,5,0.5,3.1414,0.0415,63 +air,X,L,5,0.6,3.7652,0.0589,63 +air,X,L,5,0.7,4.3951,0.0937,63 +air,X,L,5,0.8,5.025,0.1198,63 +air,X,L,5,0.9,5.6489,0.1546,63 +air,X,L,5,1.0,6.2787,0.1807,63 +air,X,L,5,1.1,6.9086,0.2155,63 +air,X,L,5,1.2,7.5325,0.2677,63 +air,X,L,5,1.3,8.1623,0.3286,63 +air,X,L,5,1.4,8.7922,0.4505,63 +air,X,L,5,1.5,9.4221,0.6506,63 +air,X,L,5,1.6,10.046,1.2162,63 +air,X,L,5,1.7,10.6758,4.2359,63 +air,X,L,5,1.8,11.3057,2.6869,63 +air,X,L,5,1.9,11.9296,1.6775,63 +air,X,L,5,2.0,12.5594,1.312,63 +air,X,L,5,2.1,13.1893,1.077,63 +air,X,L,5,2.2,13.8192,0.9639,63 +air,X,L,5,2.3,14.4431,0.9204,63 +air,X,L,5,2.4,15.0729,0.9204,63 +air,X,L,5,2.5,15.7028,0.9378,63 +air,X,L,5,2.6,16.3267,0.99,63 +air,X,L,5,2.7,16.9566,1.077,63 +air,X,L,5,2.8,17.5864,1.312,63 +air,X,L,5,2.9,18.2163,1.9733,63 +air,X,L,5,3.0,18.8402,3.7398,63 +air,X,L,10,0.5,3.1354,0.0415,63 +air,X,L,10,0.6,3.7652,0.0589,63 +air,X,L,10,0.7,4.3951,0.0937,63 +air,X,L,10,0.8,5.025,0.1285,63 +air,X,L,10,0.9,5.6489,0.1546,63 +air,X,L,10,1.0,6.2787,0.1894,63 +air,X,L,10,1.1,6.9086,0.2242,63 +air,X,L,10,1.2,7.5325,0.2764,63 +air,X,L,10,1.3,8.1623,0.346,63 +air,X,L,10,1.4,8.7922,0.4766,63 +air,X,L,10,1.5,9.4221,0.7811,63 +air,X,L,10,1.6,10.046,1.8428,63 +air,X,L,10,1.7,10.6758,2.9741,63 +air,X,L,10,1.8,11.3297,1.982,63 +air,X,L,10,1.9,11.9356,1.399,63 +air,X,L,10,2.0,12.5594,1.2685,63 +air,Y,1_2L,5,0.5,3.1369,0.5149,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,0.6,3.7661,0.579,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,0.7,4.3952,0.6323,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,0.8,5.0244,0.6857,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,0.9,5.6471,0.7391,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.0,6.2763,0.8032,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.1,6.9054,0.8886,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.2,7.5346,0.9953,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.3,8.1637,1.1341,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.4,8.7929,1.3263,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.7107,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.6,10.0448,3.0666,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.7,10.674,9.1417,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.8,11.3031,5.597,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,1.9,11.9323,3.2268,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.0,12.5614,1.9883,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.1,13.1906,1.5292,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.2,13.8133,1.2729,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.3,14.4425,1.006,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.4,15.0717,0.7818,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.5,15.7008,0.611,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.6,16.33,0.4615,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.7,16.9591,0.3227,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.8,17.5883,0.2053,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,2.9,18.211,0.0878,64 +air,Y,1_2L,5,3.0,18.8402,0.1412,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,0.5,3.1369,0.5149,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,0.6,3.7661,0.5683,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,0.7,4.3952,0.6323,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,0.8,5.0244,0.6857,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,0.9,5.6471,0.7391,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.0,6.2763,0.8138,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.1,6.9054,0.8886,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.2,7.5346,0.9953,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.3,8.1637,1.1448,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.4,8.7929,1.3584,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.9563,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.6,10.0448,3.3549,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.7,10.674,6.3978,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.8,11.3031,3.6325,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,1.9,11.9323,3.0132,64 +air,Y,1_2L,10,2.0,12.5614,1.8495,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,0.5,3.1369,0.7391,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,0.6,3.7661,0.7925,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,0.7,4.3952,0.8352,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,0.8,5.0244,0.8779,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,0.9,5.6471,0.9206,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.0,6.2763,0.974,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.1,6.9054,1.0274,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.2,7.5346,1.1021,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.3,8.1637,1.1875,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.4,8.7929,1.3263,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.5932,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.6,10.0448,2.5862,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.7,10.674,6.7714,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.8,11.3031,3.7072,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,1.9,11.9323,1.8495,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.0,12.5614,0.942,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.1,13.1906,0.5683,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.2,13.8133,0.312,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.3,14.4425,0.1092,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.4,15.0717,0.1626,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.5,15.7008,0.3014,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.6,16.33,0.4188,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.7,16.9591,0.5363,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.8,17.5883,0.643,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,2.9,18.211,0.7711,64 +air,Y,1_4L,5,3.0,18.8402,0.9099,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,0.5,3.1369,0.7391,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,0.6,3.7661,0.7925,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,0.7,4.3952,0.8352,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,0.8,5.0244,0.8779,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,0.9,5.6471,0.9206,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.0,6.2763,0.974,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.1,6.9054,1.0274,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.2,7.5346,1.1021,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.3,8.1637,1.2089,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.4,8.7929,1.3584,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.7961,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.6,10.0448,2.8317,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.7,10.674,4.508,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.8,11.3031,2.2766,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,1.9,11.9323,1.7854,64 +air,Y,1_4L,10,2.0,12.5614,0.8672,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,0.5,3.1369,0.8352,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,0.6,3.7661,0.8886,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,0.7,4.3952,0.9206,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,0.8,5.0244,0.942,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,0.9,5.6471,0.974,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.0,6.2763,1.006,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.1,6.9054,1.0381,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.2,7.5346,1.0808,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.3,8.1637,1.1341,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.4,8.7929,1.2089,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.3797,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.6,10.0448,2.0203,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.7,10.674,4.4653,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.8,11.3031,2.1164,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,1.9,11.9323,0.8245,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.0,12.5614,0.2587,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.1,13.1906,0.1946,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.2,13.8133,0.3334,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.3,14.4425,0.4829,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.4,15.0717,0.5896,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.5,15.7008,0.675,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.6,16.33,0.7498,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.7,16.9591,0.8245,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.8,17.5883,0.8886,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,2.9,18.211,0.9633,64 +air,Y,1_8L,5,3.0,18.8402,1.0487,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,0.5,3.1369,0.8352,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,0.6,3.7661,0.8779,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,0.7,4.3952,0.9099,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,0.8,5.0244,0.942,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,0.9,5.6471,0.974,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.0,6.2763,1.006,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.1,6.9054,1.0381,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.2,7.5346,1.0808,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.3,8.1637,1.1448,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.4,8.7929,1.2409,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.5185,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.6,10.0448,2.1911,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.7,10.674,2.8317,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.8,11.3031,1.1982,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,1.9,11.9323,0.8566,64 +air,Y,1_8L,10,2.0,12.5614,0.2159,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,0.5,3.1369,0.2693,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,0.6,3.7661,0.3334,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,0.7,4.3952,0.3868,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,0.8,5.0244,0.4295,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,0.9,5.6471,0.4829,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.0,6.2763,0.5363,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.1,6.9054,0.611,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.2,7.5346,0.7071,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.3,8.1637,0.8352,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.4,8.7929,1.0167,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.5,9.4221,1.3584,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.6,10.0448,2.5328,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.7,10.674,8.074,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.8,11.3031,5.1806,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,1.9,11.9323,3.152,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.0,12.5614,2.0844,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.1,13.1906,1.7107,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.2,13.8133,1.5399,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.3,14.4425,1.337,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.4,15.0717,1.1662,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.5,15.7008,1.0487,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.6,16.33,0.9526,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.7,16.9591,0.8779,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.8,17.5883,0.8245,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,2.9,18.211,0.7818,64 +air,Y,3_4L,5,3.0,18.8402,0.7605,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,0.5,3.1369,0.2693,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,0.6,3.7661,0.3334,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,0.7,4.3952,0.3761,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,0.8,5.0244,0.4295,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,0.9,5.6471,0.4829,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.0,6.2763,0.5363,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.1,6.9054,0.611,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.2,7.5346,0.7071,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.3,8.1637,0.8459,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.4,8.7929,1.0381,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.5,9.4221,1.5505,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.6,10.0448,2.7677,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.7,10.674,5.7892,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.8,11.3031,3.451,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,1.9,11.9323,2.9172,64 +air,Y,3_4L,10,2.0,12.5614,1.9135,64 +air,Y,L,5,0.5,3.1369,0.0451,64 +air,Y,L,5,0.6,3.7661,0.0665,64 +air,Y,L,5,0.7,4.3952,0.1092,64 +air,Y,L,5,0.8,5.0244,0.1412,64 +air,Y,L,5,0.9,5.6471,0.1626,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.0,6.2763,0.1946,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.1,6.9054,0.2373,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.2,7.5346,0.28,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.3,8.1637,0.3441,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.4,8.7929,0.4295,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.5,9.4221,0.5896,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.6,10.0448,1.1448,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.7,10.674,4.0062,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.8,11.3031,2.6075,64 +air,Y,L,5,1.9,11.9323,1.6573,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.0,12.5614,1.1555,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.1,13.1906,0.9953,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.2,13.8133,0.942,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.3,14.4425,0.8779,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.4,15.0717,0.8138,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.5,15.7008,0.7818,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.6,16.33,0.7605,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.7,16.9591,0.7605,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.8,17.5883,0.7818,64 +air,Y,L,5,2.9,18.211,0.8245,64 +air,Y,L,5,3.0,18.8402,0.8886,64 +air,Y,L,10,0.5,3.1369,0.0451,64 +air,Y,L,10,0.6,3.7661,0.0665,64 +air,Y,L,10,0.7,4.3952,0.1092,64 +air,Y,L,10,0.8,5.0244,0.1412,64 +air,Y,L,10,0.9,5.6471,0.1626,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.0,6.2763,0.1946,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.1,6.9054,0.2373,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.2,7.5346,0.28,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.3,8.1637,0.3441,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.4,8.7929,0.4402,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.5,9.4221,0.6857,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.6,10.0448,1.2623,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.7,10.674,2.9812,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.8,11.3031,1.8175,64 +air,Y,L,10,1.9,11.9323,1.5399,64 +air,Y,L,10,2.0,12.5614,1.0594,64 +water,X,1_2L,5,0.5,3.1386,0.7306,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,0.7,4.3938,0.7912,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,0.8,5.0245,0.8661,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,0.9,5.6491,0.9945,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.0,6.2798,1.212,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.1,6.9043,1.6113,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.2,7.535,2.6596,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.3,8.1657,4.2464,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.4,8.7902,1.5151,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.5,9.4209,0.424,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.6,10.0454,0.2814,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.7,10.6762,1.3154,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.8,11.3069,4.4032,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,1.9,11.9314,2.6062,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.0,12.5621,1.8182,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.1,13.1866,1.3618,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.2,13.8173,1.0694,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.3,14.4418,0.8483,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.4,15.0725,0.7057,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.5,15.7032,0.5951,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.6,16.334,0.5167,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.7,16.9585,0.4311,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.8,17.583,0.3598,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,2.9,18.2137,0.2671,67 +water,X,1_2L,5,3.0,18.8444,0.1387,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,0.5,3.1386,0.7306,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,0.6,3.7631,0.7485,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,0.7,4.3938,0.7948,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,0.8,5.0245,0.8697,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,0.9,5.6491,0.9981,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.0,6.2798,1.2013,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.1,6.9043,1.5971,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.2,7.535,2.6311,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.3,8.1657,3.1909,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.4,8.7902,1.4438,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.5,9.4209,0.3598,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.6,10.0454,0.4703,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.7,10.6762,2.1498,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.8,11.3069,2.9627,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,1.9,11.9314,1.9857,67 +water,X,1_2L,10,2.0,12.5621,1.3831,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,0.5,3.1386,0.4846,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,0.7,4.3938,0.5452,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,0.8,5.0245,0.6165,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,0.9,5.6491,0.7342,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.0,6.2798,0.941,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.1,6.9043,1.3332,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.2,7.535,2.3994,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.3,8.1657,4.4603,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.4,8.7902,1.9643,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.5,9.4209,0.9267,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.6,10.0454,0.399,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.7,10.6762,0.4062,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.8,11.3069,2.8985,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,1.9,11.9314,1.9037,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.0,12.5621,1.4438,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.1,13.1866,1.1728,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.2,13.8173,1.0088,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.3,14.4418,0.8947,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.4,15.0725,0.834,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.5,15.7032,0.8126,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.6,16.334,0.8019,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.7,16.9585,0.8198,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.8,17.583,0.8554,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,2.9,18.2137,0.916,67 +water,X,3_4L,5,3.0,18.8444,1.1086,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,0.5,3.1386,0.4882,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,0.6,3.7631,0.506,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,0.7,4.3938,0.5488,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,0.8,5.0245,0.6201,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,0.9,5.6491,0.7378,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.0,6.2798,0.9339,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.1,6.9043,1.3225,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.2,7.535,2.3708,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.3,8.1657,3.3015,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.4,8.7902,1.8003,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.5,9.4209,0.8554,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.6,10.0454,0.2885,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.7,10.6762,1.0266,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.8,11.3069,1.943,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,1.9,11.9314,1.4937,67 +water,X,3_4L,10,2.0,12.5621,1.1835,67 +water,X,L,5,0.5,3.1386,0.2172,67 +water,X,L,5,0.7,4.3938,0.2457,67 +water,X,L,5,0.8,5.0245,0.2849,67 +water,X,L,5,0.9,5.6491,0.3527,67 +water,X,L,5,1.0,6.2798,0.4775,67 +water,X,L,5,1.1,6.9043,0.7306,67 +water,X,L,5,1.2,7.535,1.4616,67 +water,X,L,5,1.3,8.1657,3.1981,67 +water,X,L,5,1.4,8.7902,1.7433,67 +water,X,L,5,1.5,9.4209,1.1086,67 +water,X,L,5,1.6,10.0454,0.9018,67 +water,X,L,5,1.7,10.6762,0.8733,67 +water,X,L,5,1.8,11.3069,0.5524,67 +water,X,L,5,1.9,11.9314,0.2065,67 +water,X,L,5,2.0,12.5621,0.0853,67 +water,X,L,5,2.1,13.1866,0.0924,67 +water,X,L,5,2.2,13.8173,0.1387,67 +water,X,L,5,2.3,14.4418,0.1815,67 +water,X,L,5,2.4,15.0725,0.2207,67 +water,X,L,5,2.5,15.7032,0.2742,67 +water,X,L,5,2.6,16.334,0.3063,67 +water,X,L,5,2.7,16.9585,0.3776,67 +water,X,L,5,2.8,17.583,0.4525,67 +water,X,L,5,2.9,18.2137,0.5773,67 +water,X,L,5,3.0,18.8444,0.9374,67 +water,X,L,10,0.5,3.1386,0.2207,67 +water,X,L,10,0.6,3.7631,0.2243,67 +water,X,L,10,0.7,4.3938,0.2457,67 +water,X,L,10,0.8,5.0245,0.2885,67 +water,X,L,10,0.9,5.6491,0.3562,67 +water,X,L,10,1.0,6.2798,0.4775,67 +water,X,L,10,1.1,6.9043,0.7271,67 +water,X,L,10,1.2,7.535,1.4509,67 +water,X,L,10,1.3,8.1657,2.3744,67 +water,X,L,10,1.4,8.7902,1.5186,67 +water,X,L,10,1.5,9.4209,1.0765,67 +water,X,L,10,1.6,10.0454,0.8626,67 +water,X,L,10,1.7,10.6762,0.8269,67 +water,X,L,10,1.8,11.3069,0.4097,67 +water,X,L,10,1.9,11.9314,0.1815,67 +water,X,L,10,2.0,12.5621,0.2457,67 +water,Y,1_2L,5,0.5,3.1386,0.7283,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,0.6,3.7631,0.7461,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,0.7,4.3938,0.7887,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,0.8,5.0245,0.8739,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,0.9,5.6491,1.0052,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.0,6.2798,1.2146,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.1,6.9043,1.5519,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.2,7.535,2.4003,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.3,8.1657,4.3136,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.4,8.7902,2.6274,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.5,9.4209,1.1082,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.6,10.0454,0.4266,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.7,10.6762,0.1284,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.8,11.3007,2.6949,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,1.9,11.9314,2.9931,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.0,12.5621,2.3612,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.1,13.1866,1.6761,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.2,13.8173,1.3247,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.3,14.4418,1.0585,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.4,15.0725,0.8419,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.5,15.7032,0.6822,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.6,16.3278,0.6005,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.7,16.9585,0.5899,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.8,17.583,0.5224,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,2.9,18.2137,0.4621,68 +water,Y,1_2L,5,3.0,18.8444,0.3982,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,0.5,3.1386,0.7319,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,0.6,3.7631,0.7425,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,0.7,4.3938,0.7887,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,0.8,5.0245,0.8703,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,0.9,5.6491,0.9981,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.0,6.2798,1.204,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.1,6.9043,1.5874,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.2,7.535,2.4429,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.3,8.1657,3.3303,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.4,8.7902,1.4738,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.5,9.4209,0.778,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.6,10.0454,0.2314,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.7,10.6762,1.4454,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.8,11.3069,2.3754,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,1.9,11.9314,1.4631,68 +water,Y,1_2L,10,2.0,12.5621,1.7897,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,0.5,3.1386,0.4834,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,0.6,3.7631,0.5082,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,0.7,4.3938,0.5437,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,0.8,5.0245,0.6218,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,0.9,5.6491,0.7425,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.0,6.2798,0.9449,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.1,6.9043,1.275,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.2,7.535,2.1305,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.3,8.1657,4.2816,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.4,8.7902,2.9576,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.5,9.4209,1.5554,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.6,10.0454,0.9129,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.7,10.6762,0.5686,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.8,11.3007,1.5057,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,1.9,11.9314,2.0595,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.0,12.5621,1.6761,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.1,13.1866,1.2572,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.2,13.8173,1.0372,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.3,14.4418,0.8952,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.4,15.0725,0.81,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.5,15.7032,0.7638,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.6,16.3278,0.7461,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.7,16.9585,0.7248,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.8,17.583,0.7319,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,2.9,18.2137,0.7603,68 +water,Y,3_4L,5,3.0,18.8444,0.8135,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,0.5,3.1386,0.4869,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,0.6,3.7631,0.5011,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,0.7,4.3938,0.5437,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,0.8,5.0245,0.6183,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,0.9,5.6491,0.739,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.0,6.2798,0.9378,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.1,6.9043,1.3105,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.2,7.535,2.1802,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.3,8.1657,3.2948,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.4,8.7902,1.5164,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.5,9.4209,1.243,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.6,10.0454,0.7496,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.7,10.6762,0.4976,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.8,11.3069,1.5874,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,1.9,11.9314,0.8384,68 +water,Y,3_4L,10,2.0,12.5621,1.2146,68 +water,Y,L,5,0.5,3.1386,0.2172,68 +water,Y,L,5,0.6,3.7631,0.2278,68 +water,Y,L,5,0.7,4.3938,0.242,68 +water,Y,L,5,0.8,5.0245,0.2846,68 +water,Y,L,5,0.9,5.6491,0.3556,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.0,6.2798,0.4763,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.1,6.9043,0.6893,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.2,7.535,1.2501,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.3,8.1657,2.7978,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.4,8.7902,2.2192,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.5,9.4209,1.3886,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.6,10.0454,1.023,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.7,10.6762,0.9307,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.8,11.3007,0.8845,68 +water,Y,L,5,1.9,11.9314,0.4408,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.0,12.5621,0.3166,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.1,13.1866,0.1923,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.2,13.8173,0.1604,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.3,14.4418,0.0965,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.4,15.0725,0.061,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.5,15.7032,0.1391,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.6,16.3278,0.2172,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.7,16.9585,0.1178,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.8,17.583,0.1604,68 +water,Y,L,5,2.9,18.2137,0.203,68 +water,Y,L,5,3.0,18.8444,0.274,68 +water,Y,L,10,0.5,3.1386,0.2207,68 +water,Y,L,10,0.6,3.7631,0.2207,68 +water,Y,L,10,0.7,4.3938,0.242,68 +water,Y,L,10,0.8,5.0245,0.2846,68 +water,Y,L,10,0.9,5.6491,0.3556,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.0,6.2798,0.4763,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.1,6.9043,0.7141,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.2,7.535,1.2927,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.3,8.1657,2.1908,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.4,8.7902,1.204,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.5,9.4209,1.2288,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.6,10.0454,0.9804,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.7,10.6762,0.849,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.8,11.3069,0.5615,68 +water,Y,L,10,1.9,11.9314,0.4302,68 +water,Y,L,10,2.0,12.5621,0.2243,68 diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/measured_tow_ad.csv b/validation/experiments/flotant/measured_tow_ad.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..534feb0 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/measured_tow_ad.csv @@ -0,0 +1,240 @@ +station,component,direction,Ur,V_digitised,V_test,AD_rms +1_2L,X,forwards,0.283,0.0241,0.025,0.0026 +1_2L,X,forwards,0.59,0.0502,0.050,0.0037 +1_2L,X,forwards,0.875,0.0743,0.075,0.0036 +1_2L,X,forwards,1.178,0.1001,0.100,0.0045 +1_2L,X,forwards,1.481,0.1258,0.125,0.0032 +1_2L,X,backwards,1.755,0.1491,0.150,0.0025 +1_2L,X,forwards,2.06,0.175,0.175,0.0039 +1_2L,X,backwards,2.341,0.1989,0.200,0.0028 +1_2L,X,forwards,2.625,0.223,0.225,0.0042 +1_2L,X,backwards,2.942,0.25,0.250,0.0056 +1_2L,X,forwards,3.225,0.274,0.275,0.0293 +1_2L,X,backwards,3.527,0.2997,0.300,0.0335 +1_2L,X,forwards,3.817,0.3243,0.325,0.0994 +1_2L,X,backwards,4.117,0.3498,0.350,0.1409 +1_2L,X,forwards,4.413,0.3749,0.375,0.1776 +1_2L,X,backwards,4.706,0.3998,0.400,0.1959 +1_2L,X,forwards,5.005,0.4252,0.425,0.2096 +1_2L,X,backwards,5.281,0.4487,0.450,0.1911 +1_2L,X,forwards,5.571,0.4733,0.475,0.2343 +1_2L,X,backwards,5.898,0.5011,0.500,0.0605 +1_2L,X,forwards,6.17,0.5242,0.525,0.1176 +1_2L,X,backwards,6.471,0.5498,0.550,0.0608 +1_2L,X,forwards,6.769,0.5751,0.575,0.0865 +1_2L,X,backwards,7.058,0.5996,0.600,0.0729 +1_2L,X,forwards,7.355,0.6249,0.625,0.1019 +1_2L,X,backwards,7.642,0.6492,0.650,0.0604 +1_2L,X,forwards,7.936,0.6742,0.675,0.1134 +1_2L,X,backwards,8.227,0.699,0.700,0.059 +1_2L,X,forwards,8.521,0.7239,0.725,0.1059 +1_2L,X,backwards,8.823,0.7496,0.750,0.064 +1_2L,X,forwards,9.101,0.7732,0.775,0.0902 +1_2L,X,backwards,9.413,0.7997,0.800,0.0835 +1_2L,X,forwards,9.713,0.8252,0.825,0.0706 +1_2L,X,backwards,10.005,0.85,0.850,0.0841 +1_2L,X,forwards,10.298,0.8749,0.875,0.0496 +1_2L,X,backwards,10.592,0.8999,0.900,0.0858 +1_2L,X,forwards,10.878,0.9242,0.925,0.0554 +1_2L,X,backwards,11.186,0.9504,0.950,0.0467 +1_2L,X,forwards,11.408,0.9692,0.975,0.0601 +1_2L,X,backwards,11.69,0.9932,1.000,0.0622 +1_2L,Y,forwards,0.292,0.0248,0.025,0.0007 +1_2L,Y,forwards,0.59,0.0501,0.050,0.0007 +1_2L,Y,forwards,0.89,0.0756,0.075,0.0007 +1_2L,Y,forwards,1.191,0.1012,0.100,0.0011 +1_2L,Y,forwards,1.515,0.1287,0.125,0.0015 +1_2L,Y,backwards,1.738,0.1476,0.150,0.0018 +1_2L,Y,forwards,2.064,0.1754,0.175,0.0056 +1_2L,Y,backwards,2.355,0.2001,0.200,0.0034 +1_2L,Y,forwards,2.646,0.2248,0.225,0.0151 +1_2L,Y,backwards,2.938,0.2496,0.250,0.0313 +1_2L,Y,forwards,3.227,0.2742,0.275,0.112 +1_2L,Y,backwards,3.527,0.2997,0.300,0.1788 +1_2L,Y,forwards,3.811,0.3238,0.325,0.3134 +1_2L,Y,backwards,4.116,0.3497,0.350,0.4322 +1_2L,Y,forwards,4.403,0.3741,0.375,0.5 +1_2L,Y,backwards,4.697,0.399,0.400,0.673 +1_2L,Y,forwards,4.999,0.4247,0.425,0.7005 +1_2L,Y,backwards,5.275,0.4482,0.450,0.6561 +1_2L,Y,forwards,5.583,0.4744,0.475,0.7755 +1_2L,Y,backwards,5.884,0.4999,0.500,0.3032 +1_2L,Y,forwards,6.168,0.524,0.525,0.5204 +1_2L,Y,backwards,6.47,0.5497,0.550,0.3282 +1_2L,Y,forwards,6.767,0.5749,0.575,0.4236 +1_2L,Y,backwards,7.058,0.5997,0.600,0.4623 +1_2L,Y,forwards,7.346,0.6241,0.625,0.5162 +1_2L,Y,backwards,7.632,0.6485,0.650,0.4317 +1_2L,Y,forwards,7.931,0.6738,0.675,0.5637 +1_2L,Y,backwards,8.239,0.7,0.700,0.3839 +1_2L,Y,forwards,8.504,0.7225,0.725,0.5636 +1_2L,Y,backwards,8.815,0.7489,0.750,0.3642 +1_2L,Y,forwards,9.104,0.7735,0.775,0.4436 +1_2L,Y,backwards,9.417,0.8001,0.800,0.3672 +1_2L,Y,forwards,9.7,0.8241,0.825,0.3473 +1_2L,Y,backwards,9.997,0.8493,0.850,0.2972 +1_2L,Y,forwards,10.302,0.8752,0.875,0.2073 +1_2L,Y,backwards,10.598,0.9004,0.900,0.2812 +1_2L,Y,forwards,10.877,0.9241,0.925,0.1989 +1_2L,Y,backwards,11.184,0.9502,0.950,0.1751 +1_2L,Y,forwards,11.378,0.9667,0.975,0.2142 +1_2L,Y,backwards,11.675,0.9919,1.000,0.1993 +3_4L,X,forwards,0.287,0.0244,0.025,0.0023 +3_4L,X,forwards,0.59,0.0501,0.050,0.0033 +3_4L,X,forwards,0.874,0.0743,0.075,0.0032 +3_4L,X,forwards,1.182,0.1004,0.100,0.0045 +3_4L,X,forwards,1.503,0.1277,0.125,0.0034 +3_4L,X,backwards,1.761,0.1496,0.150,0.0023 +3_4L,X,forwards,2.069,0.1758,0.175,0.0039 +3_4L,X,backwards,2.355,0.2001,0.200,0.0028 +3_4L,X,forwards,2.639,0.2242,0.225,0.0047 +3_4L,X,backwards,2.929,0.2489,0.250,0.007 +3_4L,X,forwards,3.224,0.2739,0.275,0.0314 +3_4L,X,backwards,3.528,0.2998,0.300,0.0424 +3_4L,X,forwards,3.815,0.3241,0.325,0.0952 +3_4L,X,backwards,4.118,0.3498,0.350,0.1293 +3_4L,X,forwards,4.414,0.375,0.375,0.1656 +3_4L,X,backwards,4.719,0.4009,0.400,0.2093 +3_4L,X,forwards,5.002,0.425,0.425,0.1988 +3_4L,X,backwards,5.293,0.4497,0.450,0.1963 +3_4L,X,forwards,5.58,0.474,0.475,0.225 +3_4L,X,backwards,5.881,0.4997,0.500,0.0687 +3_4L,X,forwards,6.173,0.5245,0.525,0.1249 +3_4L,X,backwards,6.471,0.5498,0.550,0.0743 +3_4L,X,forwards,6.77,0.5752,0.575,0.0909 +3_4L,X,backwards,7.048,0.5988,0.600,0.0704 +3_4L,X,forwards,7.351,0.6245,0.625,0.1075 +3_4L,X,backwards,7.646,0.6496,0.650,0.062 +3_4L,X,forwards,7.935,0.6742,0.675,0.1142 +3_4L,X,backwards,8.25,0.7009,0.700,0.0636 +3_4L,X,forwards,8.524,0.7242,0.725,0.0999 +3_4L,X,backwards,8.828,0.7501,0.750,0.0608 +3_4L,X,forwards,9.104,0.7734,0.775,0.0854 +3_4L,X,backwards,9.413,0.7997,0.800,0.074 +3_4L,X,forwards,9.7,0.8241,0.825,0.0755 +3_4L,X,backwards,10.014,0.8508,0.850,0.069 +3_4L,X,forwards,10.305,0.8755,0.875,0.0708 +3_4L,X,backwards,10.588,0.8996,0.900,0.0735 +3_4L,X,forwards,10.881,0.9244,0.925,0.0751 +3_4L,X,backwards,11.179,0.9498,0.950,0.0394 +3_4L,X,forwards,11.405,0.969,0.975,0.0824 +3_4L,X,backwards,11.693,0.9934,1.000,0.0615 +3_4L,Y,forwards,0.269,0.0229,0.025,0.0002 +3_4L,Y,forwards,0.582,0.0494,0.050,0.0008 +3_4L,Y,forwards,0.876,0.0744,0.075,0.0008 +3_4L,Y,forwards,1.17,0.0994,0.100,0.0012 +3_4L,Y,forwards,1.469,0.1248,0.125,0.0013 +3_4L,Y,backwards,1.76,0.1495,0.150,0.0013 +3_4L,Y,forwards,2.042,0.1735,0.175,0.0054 +3_4L,Y,backwards,2.337,0.1986,0.200,0.0033 +3_4L,Y,forwards,2.623,0.2228,0.225,0.0154 +3_4L,Y,backwards,2.935,0.2493,0.250,0.0299 +3_4L,Y,forwards,3.23,0.2744,0.275,0.1091 +3_4L,Y,backwards,3.528,0.2997,0.300,0.1731 +3_4L,Y,forwards,3.817,0.3243,0.325,0.3053 +3_4L,Y,backwards,4.112,0.3494,0.350,0.4169 +3_4L,Y,forwards,4.407,0.3744,0.375,0.4949 +3_4L,Y,backwards,4.705,0.3997,0.400,0.6509 +3_4L,Y,forwards,4.99,0.424,0.425,0.6955 +3_4L,Y,backwards,5.29,0.4494,0.450,0.6469 +3_4L,Y,forwards,5.58,0.474,0.475,0.7627 +3_4L,Y,backwards,5.908,0.502,0.500,0.2772 +3_4L,Y,forwards,6.167,0.5239,0.525,0.5191 +3_4L,Y,backwards,6.467,0.5494,0.550,0.2639 +3_4L,Y,forwards,6.769,0.5751,0.575,0.3605 +3_4L,Y,backwards,7.071,0.6007,0.600,0.3369 +3_4L,Y,forwards,7.35,0.6245,0.625,0.4009 +3_4L,Y,backwards,7.645,0.6495,0.650,0.3155 +3_4L,Y,forwards,7.948,0.6753,0.675,0.4325 +3_4L,Y,backwards,8.236,0.6997,0.700,0.3016 +3_4L,Y,forwards,8.52,0.7239,0.725,0.4169 +3_4L,Y,backwards,8.83,0.7502,0.750,0.2686 +3_4L,Y,forwards,9.106,0.7736,0.775,0.3378 +3_4L,Y,backwards,9.414,0.7998,0.800,0.2916 +3_4L,Y,forwards,9.695,0.8237,0.825,0.2935 +3_4L,Y,backwards,9.997,0.8494,0.850,0.229 +3_4L,Y,forwards,10.279,0.8733,0.875,0.282 +3_4L,Y,backwards,10.595,0.9001,0.900,0.2494 +3_4L,Y,forwards,10.875,0.9239,0.925,0.2994 +3_4L,Y,backwards,11.178,0.9497,0.950,0.1391 +3_4L,Y,forwards,11.375,0.9665,0.975,0.2965 +3_4L,Y,backwards,11.68,0.9923,1.000,0.1855 +L,X,forwards,0.277,0.0235,0.025,0.0013 +L,X,forwards,0.589,0.0501,0.050,0.0021 +L,X,forwards,0.875,0.0744,0.075,0.0021 +L,X,forwards,1.176,0.0999,0.100,0.003 +L,X,forwards,1.47,0.1249,0.125,0.0023 +L,X,backwards,1.76,0.1495,0.150,0.0015 +L,X,forwards,2.048,0.174,0.175,0.0026 +L,X,backwards,2.368,0.2012,0.200,0.002 +L,X,forwards,2.609,0.2217,0.225,0.0027 +L,X,backwards,2.943,0.25,0.250,0.0035 +L,X,forwards,3.228,0.2743,0.275,0.0147 +L,X,backwards,3.527,0.2997,0.300,0.0203 +L,X,forwards,3.815,0.3241,0.325,0.0363 +L,X,backwards,4.116,0.3497,0.350,0.0485 +L,X,forwards,4.415,0.3751,0.375,0.0612 +L,X,backwards,4.707,0.3999,0.400,0.1027 +L,X,forwards,5.002,0.425,0.425,0.0708 +L,X,backwards,5.289,0.4494,0.450,0.0901 +L,X,forwards,5.576,0.4737,0.475,0.08 +L,X,backwards,5.881,0.4997,0.500,0.0492 +L,X,forwards,6.169,0.5241,0.525,0.06 +L,X,backwards,6.471,0.5498,0.550,0.056 +L,X,forwards,6.765,0.5748,0.575,0.0479 +L,X,backwards,7.056,0.5995,0.600,0.0363 +L,X,forwards,7.357,0.6251,0.625,0.0661 +L,X,backwards,7.659,0.6507,0.650,0.0221 +L,X,forwards,7.941,0.6747,0.675,0.0791 +L,X,backwards,8.237,0.6998,0.700,0.0231 +L,X,forwards,8.52,0.7239,0.725,0.0417 +L,X,backwards,8.811,0.7486,0.750,0.0212 +L,X,forwards,9.107,0.7737,0.775,0.0296 +L,X,backwards,9.419,0.8002,0.800,0.0307 +L,X,forwards,9.707,0.8247,0.825,0.037 +L,X,backwards,9.992,0.8489,0.850,0.0331 +L,X,forwards,10.33,0.8777,0.875,0.0427 +L,X,backwards,10.595,0.9001,0.900,0.0539 +L,X,forwards,10.893,0.9255,0.925,0.0428 +L,X,backwards,11.175,0.9494,0.950,0.0402 +L,X,forwards,11.405,0.969,0.975,0.0483 +L,X,backwards,11.695,0.9936,1.000,0.0607 +L,Y,forwards,0.284,0.0241,0.025,0.0006 +L,Y,forwards,0.582,0.0494,0.050,0.0006 +L,Y,forwards,0.876,0.0744,0.075,0.0009 +L,Y,forwards,1.168,0.0992,0.100,0.0012 +L,Y,forwards,1.476,0.1254,0.125,0.0013 +L,Y,backwards,1.749,0.1486,0.150,0.0016 +L,Y,forwards,2.052,0.1744,0.175,0.0036 +L,Y,backwards,2.345,0.1993,0.200,0.0029 +L,Y,forwards,2.639,0.2242,0.225,0.0101 +L,Y,backwards,2.933,0.2492,0.250,0.0183 +L,Y,forwards,3.226,0.2741,0.275,0.0642 +L,Y,backwards,3.531,0.3,0.300,0.1034 +L,Y,forwards,3.813,0.3239,0.325,0.1798 +L,Y,backwards,4.114,0.3496,0.350,0.249 +L,Y,forwards,4.403,0.3741,0.375,0.3048 +L,Y,backwards,4.705,0.3998,0.400,0.4077 +L,Y,forwards,4.992,0.4241,0.425,0.4464 +L,Y,backwards,5.288,0.4493,0.450,0.4428 +L,Y,forwards,5.582,0.4742,0.475,0.5057 +L,Y,backwards,5.883,0.4999,0.500,0.2339 +L,Y,forwards,6.164,0.5237,0.525,0.4014 +L,Y,backwards,6.468,0.5495,0.550,0.1171 +L,Y,forwards,6.76,0.5743,0.575,0.2417 +L,Y,backwards,7.048,0.5988,0.600,0.0954 +L,Y,forwards,7.363,0.6255,0.625,0.2001 +L,Y,backwards,7.64,0.6491,0.650,0.064 +L,Y,forwards,7.942,0.6748,0.675,0.1969 +L,Y,backwards,8.252,0.7011,0.700,0.0864 +L,Y,forwards,8.518,0.7237,0.725,0.1152 +L,Y,backwards,8.82,0.7493,0.750,0.0774 +L,Y,forwards,9.109,0.7739,0.775,0.1076 +L,Y,backwards,9.414,0.7999,0.800,0.1358 +L,Y,forwards,9.7,0.8241,0.825,0.1506 +L,Y,backwards,10.0,0.8496,0.850,0.1536 +L,Y,forwards,10.292,0.8744,0.875,0.2415 +L,Y,backwards,10.606,0.9011,0.900,0.265 +L,Y,forwards,10.878,0.9242,0.925,0.2954 +L,Y,backwards,11.176,0.9496,0.950,0.2593 +L,Y,forwards,11.405,0.9689,0.975,0.3181 diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/provenance.json b/validation/experiments/flotant/provenance.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..77c39db --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/provenance.json @@ -0,0 +1,434 @@ +{ + "source": "de Wilde, Heijnsdijk & de Ridder (2021), D5.5 - Report on VIV (hydrodynamic) behaviour, FLOTANT deliverable 210430-FLT-WP5_D-5-5_V0, MARIN report 30995-53-DWB, 30 April 2021 (Tables 2-1, 2-2, 3-4, 6-1, 6-2; Secs. 2.3-2.5, 3.4, 4.4, 4.5, 5.3, 5.4, 6.3; Appendices 1-3); Ulveseter, Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2019), Applied Ocean Research 90, 101856 (Table 1, Sec. 4.1); Ulveseter, Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2018), Marine Structures 60, 241-260 (Table 3); Chaplin, Bearman, Huera Huarte & Pattenden (2005), Journal of Fluids and Structures 21(1), 3-24 (Eq. 4); Facchinetti, de Langre & Biolley (2004), Journal of Fluids and Structures 19(2), 123-140 (Secs. 2-3)", + "report_url": "https://flotantproject.eu/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/210430_FLT-D5.5_VIV_test_v0.pdf", + "report_sha256": "0b1f1b06f84c3d44fe0ecc2c114feb5bc82911a84d29411d3197ca935810511b", + "report_doi": "none (a public project deliverable, dissemination level PU); the project's CORDIS record lists it under Results; grant agreement 815289, https://doi.org/10.3030/815289", + "doi": [ + "10.1016/j.apor.2019.101856", + "10.1016/j.marstruc.2018.04.001", + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010", + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2003.12.004" + ], + "bibliographic_data": "the report's title page, document number and authors from the PDF; volumes, issues and pages of the articles from Crossref (api.crossref.org), 2026-11-16", + "data_used": "FEM input tables in air (Sec. 4.5) and in water (Sec. 5.4): 101 nodes, element labels, positions, lumped masses, weights, static tensions, EA, EI, accelerometer stations; RAOs at 5 and 10 mm, 200 kg, surge and sway, in air (Appendix 1, pp. 63-64) and in water (Appendix 2, pp. 67-68); A/D_rms = sigma/OD against Ur of the 40 tow tests at 200 kg, cross-flow (Y) and in line (X), at 1/2L, 3/4L and L (Appendix 3, pp. 70-72); test speeds and directions (Table 6-2); top and bottom tensions (Table 6-1); OD, length, mass (Table 2-1) and wet weight (Table 2-2); the tow-test high-pass of 3.5 rad/s (Table 3-4); f1 = 1.77 Hz for Ur (Sec. 6.3)", + "extraction": "extract_d55.py: the FEM tables from the PDF text; the RAO charts, vector graphics, as plotted coordinates mapped through the tick labels (axis residual at most 1.2e-3 rad/s and 1e-3), series named by the legend marker colour; the Appendix 3 charts, embedded 1386 x 867 raster images, calibrated on the grey grid lines (Ur residual 0.004), markers found by colour (40 points per chart, 39 for Y at L where an edge marker is clipped), each mapped to a tested speed within 0.0085 m/s", + "identified_structure": "from the forced-oscillation RAOs of the same specimen, not from the tow data: cable EI 1650 N m^2 and bending damping Bb 130 N m^2 s from the in-air surge RAOs at 5 and 10 mm (the tables' EI 3000 N m^2 matches the in-air resonance only with MARIN's empirical factor lambda 1.10, Sec. 4.5); in water the link chain and load cell with EI 100 N m^2 and the clump held laterally by K 32.5 kN/m and C 20 N s/m (a cantilever post of 0.3 m from a still anchor), from the surge and sway RAOs over 1.0-3.0 Hz (MARIN's table fixes the clump node and makes the chain rigid)", + "assumptions": "fresh water 1000 kg/m^3 (not stated; Table 2-2's 2.8 kg/m and 9.7 N/m at OD 48 mm imply it); the cable's diameter the OD, the other parts the diameter of the displaced volume of their table weight; the counterweight or clump as an axial spring k_ax 20 kN/m in series with the tables' EA, the unstretched lengths set for the tables' static tensions; uniform current over the whole line; Cd 1.2 and Ca 1 on the cable and the hardware; the clump's drag area 0.05 m^2 (not given); the accelerometers' axes normal to the cable, so the model's displacement takes the gravity term g theta/omega^2 the measurement holds", + "coefficients": { + "uls19": "Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1, fitted by them to the NDP riser in uniform flow (Sec. 4.1, Chh 1.5): Cd 1.2, CM 2, Cl 0.85, cF 0.144, dF 0.064; VIV ClX 0.75, alpha 0.15, Chh 1.5; blind here", + "b1": "the generic set of the Delta Flume riser case, nothing fitted to these tests: Cl 0.8, cF 0.18, dF 0.08, Cd 1.2; VIV ClX 0.85, alpha 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018, Table 3); VIV AMPLITUDE Cv 0.8 with CdAmp = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s^2, s = (A/D)/sqrt(2), at A/D 0-1.5 (Chaplin et al. 2005, Eq. 4); VIV DAMPING 0 0 1", + "wake": "Facchinetti et al. (2004): WAKE OSCILLATOR CL0 0.3, St 0.2, eps 0.3, A 12 (their values from rigid-cylinder lift and lock-in data in the literature), LINE TYPES Cl 0, Cd 1.2; cross-flow only" + }, + "processing": "statistics over t > 20 s of 60 s runs; each station's displacement plus g theta/omega^2, high-passed at 3.5 rad/s, A/D_rms = sigma/OD; Ur = V/(OD f1), f1 1.77 Hz; r.m.s. log errors over the tests with Ur >= 3; release: the first tested Ur above the 1/2L cross-flow peak at which A/D_rms falls below 70 % of the peak; RAOs: harmonic fit over the last 10 s of 5/f + 25 s runs, scored over 1.4-2.0 Hz in air and 1.0-3.0 Hz in water", + "CableDyn_commit": "3d779fb (dev)", + "validation_date": "2026-11-17", + "executable_name": "cabledyn.exe", + "executable_sha256": "see summary.json", + "compiler": "GNU Fortran 16.2.0", + "build_type": "Release", + "platform": "Windows 11 x86-64", + "dt_s": 0.002, + "tmax_s": 60.0, + "statistics_after_s": 20.0, + "reproduction": "the default command, run into a new work directory with the executable of summary.json, reproduces response_comparison.csv, rao_comparison.csv and summary.json byte for byte", + "sensitivity": { + "note": "tow: A/D_rms at the given speeds [m/s] against response_comparison.csv; rao: r.m.s. log errors against summary.json; end_*: the full uls19 sweep with another lower end", + "dt_0p001": { + "uls19": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4193, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4192, + "AD_CF_L": 0.2864, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0804, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.15 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7556, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.7757, + "AD_CF_L": 0.5686, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1154, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.275 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7326, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.7724, + "AD_CF_L": 0.5994, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1311, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.325 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4879, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2829, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3289, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0903, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.825 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7087, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.463, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1695, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1238, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.0 + } + }, + "b1": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4632, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4779, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3493, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0098, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.25 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4392, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4753, + "AD_CF_L": 0.383, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0563, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.35 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.3244, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.185, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1455, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0438, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.875 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.3886, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2445, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1218, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0525, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.95 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4496, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.3261, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0623, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0685, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.175 + } + }, + "wake": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2552, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2628, + "AD_CF_L": 0.19, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0092, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.225 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.1707, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.0825, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0787, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0037, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.825 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2079, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1136, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0665, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0049, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.875 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2139, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1387, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0176, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0047, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.0 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.0682, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.0797, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1708, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0015, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 3.1 + } + } + }, + "refine_2": { + "uls19": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4177, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4174, + "AD_CF_L": 0.285, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0804, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.15 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7558, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.7763, + "AD_CF_L": 0.5696, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1166, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.25 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7366, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.7766, + "AD_CF_L": 0.6023, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1313, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.325 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.485, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2813, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3343, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0906, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.825 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7096, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4626, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1757, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1243, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.0 + } + }, + "b1": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4635, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4779, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3488, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0101, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.25 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4452, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4814, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3871, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0542, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.35 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.3233, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1835, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1465, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0443, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.85 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.3893, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2447, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1238, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0524, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.95 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.452, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.3276, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0633, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0679, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.175 + } + }, + "wake": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2553, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2628, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1901, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0092, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.225 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.1707, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.0825, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0787, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0037, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.825 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.208, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1137, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0666, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0049, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.875 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2139, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1387, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0175, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0047, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.0 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.0683, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.0798, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1714, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0015, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 3.1 + } + } + }, + "tmax_120": { + "uls19": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4195, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4194, + "AD_CF_L": 0.2864, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0799, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.14 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7577, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.7789, + "AD_CF_L": 0.5727, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1154, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.26 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7316, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.771, + "AD_CF_L": 0.5972, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1339, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.32 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4857, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2802, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3346, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0906, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.82 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.7094, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4634, + "AD_CF_L": 0.174, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.1247, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.99 + } + }, + "b1": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4638, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.4782, + "AD_CF_L": 0.349, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0101, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.25 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4438, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.48, + "AD_CF_L": 0.3862, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0539, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.35 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.3231, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.184, + "AD_CF_L": 0.147, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0444, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.86 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.3903, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2442, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1229, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0525, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.94 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.4516, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.3274, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0632, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0693, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.18 + } + }, + "wake": { + "0.3": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2552, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.2626, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1898, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0092, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.23 + }, + "0.45": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.1707, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.0824, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0787, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0037, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.83 + }, + "0.5": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.208, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1137, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0665, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0049, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 1.88 + }, + "0.6": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.2138, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.1387, + "AD_CF_L": 0.0175, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0047, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 2.0 + }, + "0.8": { + "AD_CF_1_2L": 0.0682, + "AD_CF_3_4L": 0.0797, + "AD_CF_L": 0.1708, + "AD_IL_1_2L": 0.0015, + "f_cf_1_2L_hz": 3.11 + } + } + }, + "rao_refine_2": { + "air_table_5mm": { + "surge": 0.2272, + "sway": 0.2779 + }, + "air_table_10mm": { + "surge": 0.2086, + "sway": 0.23 + }, + "water_free_5mm": { + "surge": 1.1745, + "sway": 1.2077 + }, + "water_identified_5mm": { + "surge": 0.4592, + "sway": 0.744 + }, + "water_table_5mm": { + "surge": 1.1864, + "sway": 1.2157 + } + }, + "rao_dt_0p001": { + "air_table_5mm": { + "surge": 0.227, + "sway": 0.2771 + }, + "air_table_10mm": { + "surge": 0.2088, + "sway": 0.2295 + }, + "water_free_5mm": { + "surge": 1.1743, + "sway": 1.2076 + }, + "water_identified_5mm": { + "surge": 0.4587, + "sway": 0.743 + }, + "water_table_5mm": { + "surge": 1.1863, + "sway": 1.2157 + } + }, + "end_table_uls19": { + "cf_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.7208, + "il_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.9264, + "cf_1_2L_peak_AD": 0.8047, + "cf_1_2L_peak_Ur": 5.591, + "cf_1_2L_release_Ur": 8.828 + }, + "end_free_uls19": { + "cf_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.6921, + "il_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.942, + "cf_1_2L_peak_AD": 0.8106, + "cf_1_2L_peak_Ur": 5.591, + "cf_1_2L_release_Ur": 9.122 + } + } +} diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/rao_comparison.csv b/validation/experiments/flotant/rao_comparison.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3c24225 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/rao_comparison.csv @@ -0,0 +1,298 @@ +medium,end,amp_mm,f_hz,station,rao_cabledyn,rao_cabledyn_displacement,rao_measured_surge,rao_measured_sway +air,table,5,1.0,1_8L,1.0256,1.0314,0.9639,1.006 +air,table,5,1.0,1_4L,0.987,1.0011,0.9291,0.974 +air,table,5,1.0,1_2L,0.8127,0.8462,0.755,0.8032 +air,table,5,1.0,3_4L,0.5281,0.5768,0.4853,0.5363 +air,table,5,1.1,1_8L,1.0961,1.0927,1.0074,1.0381 +air,table,5,1.1,1_4L,1.0834,1.0891,0.9813,1.0274 +air,table,5,1.1,1_2L,0.932,0.9594,0.8334,0.8886 +air,table,5,1.1,3_4L,0.6274,0.6723,0.5549,0.611 +air,table,5,1.2,1_8L,1.1887,1.1762,1.0509,1.0808 +air,table,5,1.2,1_4L,1.2129,1.2104,1.0596,1.1021 +air,table,5,1.2,1_2L,1.0962,1.1185,0.9378,0.9953 +air,table,5,1.2,3_4L,0.7654,0.8084,0.6419,0.7071 +air,table,5,1.3,1_8L,1.3193,1.2964,1.1205,1.1341 +air,table,5,1.3,1_4L,1.3991,1.3876,1.1727,1.1875 +air,table,5,1.3,1_2L,1.3374,1.3551,1.0857,1.1341 +air,table,5,1.3,3_4L,0.9708,1.0139,0.7724,0.8352 +air,table,5,1.4,1_8L,1.5214,1.4844,1.2424,1.2089 +air,table,5,1.4,1_4L,1.6925,1.6691,1.3642,1.3263 +air,table,5,1.4,1_2L,1.7256,1.7388,1.3468,1.3263 +air,table,5,1.4,3_4L,1.3061,1.3522,1.0074,1.0167 +air,table,5,1.5,1_8L,1.8807,1.8205,1.4512,1.3797 +air,table,5,1.5,1_4L,2.224,2.1812,1.6862,1.5932 +air,table,5,1.5,1_2L,2.4449,2.4519,1.7993,1.7107 +air,table,5,1.5,3_4L,1.9368,1.9909,1.4077,1.3584 +air,table,5,1.6,1_8L,2.6614,2.5509,1.9472,2.0203 +air,table,5,1.6,1_4L,3.4129,3.3281,2.4955,2.5862 +air,table,5,1.6,1_2L,4.1013,4.0964,2.9393,3.0666 +air,table,5,1.6,3_4L,3.4156,3.4905,2.4345,2.5328 +air,table,5,1.7,1_8L,3.8529,3.6436,4.0009,4.4653 +air,table,5,1.7,1_4L,5.526,5.3548,6.2547,6.7714 +air,table,5,1.7,1_2L,7.3857,7.3508,8.6826,9.1417 +air,table,5,1.7,3_4L,6.4965,6.6065,7.8472,8.074 +air,table,5,1.8,1_8L,1.653,1.5286,1.6426,2.1164 +air,table,5,1.8,1_4L,2.8318,2.721,3.0785,3.7072 +air,table,5,1.8,1_2L,4.3487,4.3132,4.845,5.597 +air,table,5,1.8,3_4L,4.0782,4.1293,4.6275,5.1806 +air,table,5,1.9,1_8L,0.5598,0.5033,0.4766,0.8245 +air,table,5,1.9,1_4L,1.2803,1.2159,1.3555,1.8495 +air,table,5,1.9,1_2L,2.3609,2.3337,2.5825,3.2268 +air,table,5,1.9,3_4L,2.3818,2.4025,2.6608,3.152 +air,table,5,2.0,1_8L,0.2467,0.2565,0.1459,0.2587 +air,table,5,2.0,1_4L,0.6454,0.6017,0.6854,0.942 +air,table,5,2.0,1_2L,1.5416,1.5185,1.7036,1.9883 +air,table,5,2.0,3_4L,1.6932,1.7021,1.9124,2.0844 +air,table,5,2.1,1_8L,0.3284,0.3614,0.3286,0.1946 +air,table,5,2.1,1_4L,0.3095,0.281,0.2764,0.5683 +air,table,5,2.1,1_2L,1.1016,1.0808,1.1466,1.5292 +air,table,5,2.1,3_4L,1.3402,1.3429,1.4338,1.7107 +air,table,5,2.2,1_8L,0.4689,0.498,0.4853,0.3334 +air,table,5,2.2,1_4L,0.1527,0.1538,0.085,0.312 +air,table,5,2.2,1_2L,0.8186,0.7992,0.8247,1.2729 +air,table,5,2.2,3_4L,1.1316,1.1305,1.1727,1.5399 +air,table,5,2.3,1_8L,0.5988,0.6227,0.6071,0.4829 +air,table,5,2.3,1_4L,0.2219,0.2425,0.2329,0.1092 +air,table,5,2.3,1_2L,0.61,0.5915,0.5897,1.006 +air,table,5,2.3,3_4L,0.9982,0.9941,1.0074,1.337 +air,table,5,2.4,1_8L,0.7242,0.7435,0.7202,0.5896 +air,table,5,2.4,1_4L,0.369,0.3892,0.3983,0.1626 +air,table,5,2.4,1_2L,0.4361,0.4181,0.3983,0.7818 +air,table,5,2.4,3_4L,0.9091,0.9023,0.8943,1.1662 +air,table,5,2.5,1_8L,0.8572,0.8724,0.8334,0.675 +air,table,5,2.5,1_4L,0.5363,0.554,0.5636,0.3014 +air,table,5,2.5,1_2L,0.2732,0.2559,0.2155,0.611 +air,table,5,2.5,3_4L,0.8488,0.8394,0.7985,1.0487 +air,table,10,1.0,1_8L,1.0256,1.0314,0.99,1.006 +air,table,10,1.0,1_4L,0.9869,1.0011,0.9465,0.974 +air,table,10,1.0,1_2L,0.8127,0.8462,0.7724,0.8138 +air,table,10,1.0,3_4L,0.5281,0.5768,0.5027,0.5363 +air,table,10,1.1,1_8L,1.0961,1.0927,1.0335,1.0381 +air,table,10,1.1,1_4L,1.0833,1.089,1.0248,1.0274 +air,table,10,1.1,1_2L,0.932,0.9593,0.8682,0.8886 +air,table,10,1.1,3_4L,0.6274,0.6722,0.581,0.611 +air,table,10,1.2,1_8L,1.1887,1.1762,1.0944,1.0808 +air,table,10,1.2,1_4L,1.2128,1.2103,1.1118,1.1021 +air,table,10,1.2,1_2L,1.0961,1.1183,0.99,0.9953 +air,table,10,1.2,3_4L,0.7653,0.8083,0.6941,0.7071 +air,table,10,1.3,1_8L,1.3191,1.2962,1.1727,1.1448 +air,table,10,1.3,1_4L,1.3989,1.3873,1.2424,1.2089 +air,table,10,1.3,1_2L,1.337,1.3548,1.164,1.1448 +air,table,10,1.3,3_4L,0.9705,1.0136,0.8334,0.8459 +air,table,10,1.4,1_8L,1.5208,1.4838,1.312,1.2409 +air,table,10,1.4,1_4L,1.6916,1.6682,1.4599,1.3584 +air,table,10,1.4,1_2L,1.7244,1.7376,1.4686,1.3584 +air,table,10,1.4,3_4L,1.3051,1.3512,1.1031,1.0381 +air,table,10,1.5,1_8L,1.8776,1.8176,1.6252,1.5185 +air,table,10,1.5,1_4L,2.2195,2.1769,1.9472,1.7961 +air,table,10,1.5,1_2L,2.4388,2.4458,2.1213,1.9563 +air,table,10,1.5,3_4L,1.9314,1.9855,1.6775,1.5505 +air,table,10,1.6,1_8L,2.6362,2.5276,2.6521,2.1911 +air,table,10,1.6,1_4L,3.3743,3.2911,3.5484,2.8317 +air,table,10,1.6,1_2L,4.0472,4.0427,4.3316,3.3549 +air,table,10,1.6,3_4L,3.367,3.441,3.6615,2.7677 +air,table,10,1.7,1_8L,3.8509,3.6485,2.539,2.8317 +air,table,10,1.7,1_4L,5.4639,5.2992,4.114,4.508 +air,table,10,1.7,1_2L,7.2337,7.2018,5.8806,6.3978 +air,table,10,1.7,3_4L,6.3329,6.4416,5.4019,5.7892 +air,table,10,1.8,1_8L,1.7371,1.609,1.0596,1.1982 +air,table,10,1.8,1_4L,2.9472,2.8337,2.1039,2.2766 +air,table,10,1.8,1_2L,4.4954,4.4595,3.4614,3.6325 +air,table,10,1.8,3_4L,4.2032,4.2564,3.3744,3.451 +air,table,10,1.9,1_8L,0.5701,0.5128,0.4157,0.8566 +air,table,10,1.9,1_4L,1.2961,1.2312,1.1031,1.7854 +air,table,10,1.9,1_2L,2.3813,2.3541,2.1387,3.0132 +air,table,10,1.9,3_4L,2.3991,2.4201,2.2257,2.9172 +air,table,10,2.0,1_8L,0.2474,0.2566,0.2242,0.2159 +air,table,10,2.0,1_4L,0.65,0.6062,0.7985,0.8672 +air,table,10,2.0,1_2L,1.5475,1.5244,1.7819,1.8495 +air,table,10,2.0,3_4L,1.6981,1.7071,1.9385,1.9135 +water,free,5,1.0,1_2L,1.2052,1.1736,1.212,1.2146 +water,free,5,1.0,3_4L,0.9124,0.8445,0.941,0.9449 +water,free,5,1.0,L,0.4184,0.333,0.4775,0.4763 +water,free,5,1.1,1_2L,1.5667,1.5445,1.6113,1.5519 +water,free,5,1.1,3_4L,1.2422,1.1718,1.3332,1.275 +water,free,5,1.1,L,0.5965,0.5022,0.7306,0.6893 +water,free,5,1.2,1_2L,2.2717,2.2613,2.6596,2.4003 +water,free,5,1.2,3_4L,1.8996,1.8181,2.3994,2.1305 +water,free,5,1.2,L,0.9625,0.8446,1.4616,1.2501 +water,free,5,1.3,1_2L,3.525,3.5365,4.2464,4.3136 +water,free,5,1.3,3_4L,3.1322,3.0321,4.4603,4.2816 +water,free,5,1.3,L,1.6883,1.5286,3.1981,2.7978 +water,free,5,1.4,1_2L,3.6781,3.7158,1.5151,2.6274 +water,free,5,1.4,3_4L,3.5081,3.4274,1.9643,2.9576 +water,free,5,1.4,L,2.0266,1.8798,1.7433,2.2192 +water,free,5,1.5,1_2L,2.3104,2.3501,0.424,1.1082 +water,free,5,1.5,3_4L,2.4016,2.3644,0.9267,1.5554 +water,free,5,1.5,L,1.4984,1.4163,1.1086,1.3886 +water,free,5,1.6,1_2L,1.394,1.4279,0.2814,0.4266 +water,free,5,1.6,3_4L,1.6075,1.5932,0.399,0.9129 +water,free,5,1.6,L,1.0938,1.0496,0.9018,1.023 +water,free,5,1.7,1_2L,0.9237,0.9536,1.3154,0.1284 +water,free,5,1.7,3_4L,1.2112,1.2075,0.4062,0.5686 +water,free,5,1.7,L,0.9086,0.8827,0.8733,0.9307 +water,free,5,1.8,1_2L,0.6414,0.6687,4.4032,2.6949 +water,free,5,1.8,3_4L,0.9936,0.9961,2.8985,1.5057 +water,free,5,1.8,L,0.8323,0.8168,0.5524,0.8845 +water,free,5,1.9,1_2L,0.4419,0.4675,2.6062,2.9931 +water,free,5,1.9,3_4L,0.8635,0.8704,1.9037,2.0595 +water,free,5,1.9,L,0.8201,0.8115,0.2065,0.4408 +water,free,5,2.0,1_2L,0.2792,0.3032,1.8182,2.3612 +water,free,5,2.0,3_4L,0.7829,0.7937,1.4438,1.6761 +water,free,5,2.0,L,0.8592,0.856,0.0853,0.3166 +water,free,5,2.1,1_2L,0.1389,0.1569,1.3618,1.6761 +water,free,5,2.1,3_4L,0.734,0.7489,1.1728,1.2572 +water,free,5,2.1,L,0.9539,0.9559,0.0924,0.1923 +water,free,5,2.2,1_2L,0.1559,0.1375,1.0694,1.3247 +water,free,5,2.2,3_4L,0.7068,0.7268,1.0088,1.0372 +water,free,5,2.2,L,1.1248,1.1325,0.1387,0.1604 +water,free,5,2.3,1_2L,0.4053,0.3766,0.8483,1.0585 +water,free,5,2.3,3_4L,0.689,0.7163,0.8947,0.8952 +water,free,5,2.3,L,1.4091,1.4245,0.1815,0.0965 +water,free,5,2.4,1_2L,0.8033,0.7712,0.7057,0.8419 +water,free,5,2.4,3_4L,0.6398,0.6764,0.834,0.81 +water,free,5,2.4,L,1.8127,1.8386,0.2207,0.061 +water,free,5,2.5,1_2L,1.2191,1.1888,0.5951,0.6822 +water,free,5,2.5,3_4L,0.4631,0.5042,0.8126,0.7638 +water,free,5,2.5,L,2.072,2.1075,0.2742,0.1391 +water,free,5,2.6,1_2L,1.3111,1.2902,0.5167,0.6005 +water,free,5,2.6,3_4L,0.208,0.2339,0.8019,0.7461 +water,free,5,2.6,L,1.8176,1.8531,0.3063,0.2172 +water,free,5,2.7,1_2L,1.1497,1.1381,0.4311,0.5899 +water,free,5,2.7,3_4L,0.161,0.146,0.8198,0.7248 +water,free,5,2.7,L,1.3635,1.393,0.3776,0.1178 +water,free,5,2.8,1_2L,0.9785,0.9727,0.3598,0.5224 +water,free,5,2.8,3_4L,0.2341,0.2145,0.8554,0.7319 +water,free,5,2.8,L,1.0249,1.0488,0.4525,0.1604 +water,free,5,2.9,1_2L,0.8528,0.8504,0.2671,0.4621 +water,free,5,2.9,3_4L,0.2871,0.2706,0.916,0.7603 +water,free,5,2.9,L,0.807,0.8269,0.5773,0.203 +water,free,5,3.0,1_2L,0.7634,0.7631,0.1387,0.3982 +water,free,5,3.0,3_4L,0.3222,0.3086,1.1086,0.8135 +water,free,5,3.0,L,0.6637,0.6809,0.9374,0.274 +water,identified,5,1.0,1_2L,1.4509,1.4308,1.212,1.2146 +water,identified,5,1.0,3_4L,1.2124,1.1468,0.941,0.9449 +water,identified,5,1.0,L,0.7153,0.6259,0.4775,0.4763 +water,identified,5,1.1,1_2L,2.1455,2.1432,1.6113,1.5519 +water,identified,5,1.1,3_4L,1.9164,1.8449,1.3332,1.275 +water,identified,5,1.1,L,1.2109,1.1017,0.7306,0.6893 +water,identified,5,1.2,1_2L,3.7576,3.7983,2.6596,2.4003 +water,identified,5,1.2,3_4L,3.6714,3.588,2.3994,2.1305 +water,identified,5,1.2,L,2.5514,2.3959,1.4616,1.2501 +water,identified,5,1.3,1_2L,3.0491,3.1249,4.2464,4.3136 +water,identified,5,1.3,3_4L,3.4053,3.3749,4.4603,4.2816 +water,identified,5,1.3,L,2.6934,2.5962,3.1981,2.7978 +water,identified,5,1.4,1_2L,1.1129,1.1669,1.5151,2.6274 +water,identified,5,1.4,3_4L,1.5755,1.5858,1.9643,2.9576 +water,identified,5,1.4,L,1.4982,1.4772,1.7433,2.2192 +water,identified,5,1.5,1_2L,0.328,0.3706,0.424,1.1082 +water,identified,5,1.5,3_4L,0.8563,0.8812,0.9267,1.5554 +water,identified,5,1.5,L,1.0856,1.0929,1.1086,1.3886 +water,identified,5,1.6,1_2L,0.2296,0.1913,0.2814,0.4266 +water,identified,5,1.6,3_4L,0.4373,0.4739,0.399,0.9129 +water,identified,5,1.6,L,0.9671,0.994,0.9018,1.023 +water,identified,5,1.7,1_2L,0.924,0.885,1.3154,0.1284 +water,identified,5,1.7,3_4L,0.0673,0.0787,0.4062,0.5686 +water,identified,5,1.7,L,1.0247,1.078,0.8733,0.9307 +water,identified,5,1.8,1_2L,2.2012,2.1632,4.4032,2.6949 +water,identified,5,1.8,3_4L,0.8649,0.7775,2.8985,1.5057 +water,identified,5,1.8,L,1.1767,1.2761,0.5524,0.8845 +water,identified,5,1.9,1_2L,2.4513,2.4377,2.6062,2.9931 +water,identified,5,1.9,3_4L,1.4229,1.3482,1.9037,2.0595 +water,identified,5,1.9,L,0.6664,0.7619,0.2065,0.4408 +water,identified,5,2.0,1_2L,1.6159,1.6191,1.8182,2.3612 +water,identified,5,2.0,3_4L,1.16,1.1204,1.4438,1.6761 +water,identified,5,2.0,L,0.1671,0.2227,0.0853,0.3166 +water,identified,5,2.1,1_2L,1.138,1.1466,1.3618,1.6761 +water,identified,5,2.1,3_4L,0.9559,0.9332,1.1728,1.2572 +water,identified,5,2.1,L,0.0473,0.019,0.0924,0.1923 +water,identified,5,2.2,1_2L,0.8746,0.8852,1.0694,1.3247 +water,identified,5,2.2,3_4L,0.8432,0.8291,1.0088,1.0372 +water,identified,5,2.2,L,0.1475,0.12,0.1387,0.1604 +water,identified,5,2.3,1_2L,0.7065,0.7181,0.8483,1.0585 +water,identified,5,2.3,3_4L,0.7795,0.7705,0.8947,0.8952 +water,identified,5,2.3,L,0.2214,0.2004,0.1815,0.0965 +water,identified,5,2.4,1_2L,0.5854,0.5975,0.7057,0.8419 +water,identified,5,2.4,3_4L,0.745,0.7396,0.834,0.81 +water,identified,5,2.4,L,0.2889,0.2723,0.2207,0.061 +water,identified,5,2.5,1_2L,0.4886,0.5009,0.5951,0.6822 +water,identified,5,2.5,3_4L,0.731,0.7284,0.8126,0.7638 +water,identified,5,2.5,L,0.3625,0.3492,0.2742,0.1391 +water,identified,5,2.6,1_2L,0.4036,0.4158,0.5167,0.6005 +water,identified,5,2.6,3_4L,0.7339,0.7338,0.8019,0.7461 +water,identified,5,2.6,L,0.4531,0.4426,0.3063,0.2172 +water,identified,5,2.7,1_2L,0.3234,0.3347,0.4311,0.5899 +water,identified,5,2.7,3_4L,0.7525,0.7551,0.8198,0.7248 +water,identified,5,2.7,L,0.5744,0.5664,0.3776,0.1178 +water,identified,5,2.8,1_2L,0.2533,0.2607,0.3598,0.5224 +water,identified,5,2.8,3_4L,0.7864,0.7921,0.8554,0.7319 +water,identified,5,2.8,L,0.7467,0.7415,0.4525,0.1604 +water,identified,5,2.9,1_2L,0.2522,0.2472,0.2671,0.4621 +water,identified,5,2.9,3_4L,0.8282,0.8377,0.916,0.7603 +water,identified,5,2.9,L,0.9967,0.9951,0.5773,0.203 +water,identified,5,3.0,1_2L,0.4171,0.4012,0.1387,0.3982 +water,identified,5,3.0,3_4L,0.836,0.8506,1.1086,0.8135 +water,identified,5,3.0,L,1.3195,1.323,0.9374,0.274 +water,table,5,1.0,1_2L,1.3485,1.3229,1.212,1.2146 +water,table,5,1.0,3_4L,1.0808,1.0129,0.941,0.9449 +water,table,5,1.0,L,0.5758,0.4867,0.4775,0.4763 +water,table,5,1.1,1_2L,1.82,1.8054,1.6113,1.5519 +water,table,5,1.1,3_4L,1.5265,1.4539,1.3332,1.275 +water,table,5,1.1,L,0.8402,0.7375,0.7306,0.6893 +water,table,5,1.2,1_2L,2.7882,2.7909,2.6596,2.4003 +water,table,5,1.2,3_4L,2.4683,2.3808,2.3994,2.1305 +water,table,5,1.2,L,1.4195,1.2837,1.4616,1.2501 +water,table,5,1.3,1_2L,3.9431,3.9768,4.2464,4.3136 +water,table,5,1.3,3_4L,3.7187,3.6234,4.4603,4.2816 +water,table,5,1.3,L,2.2581,2.0908,3.1981,2.7978 +water,table,5,1.4,1_2L,3.1182,3.1675,1.5151,2.6274 +water,table,5,1.4,3_4L,3.1775,3.1222,1.9643,2.9576 +water,table,5,1.4,L,2.0569,1.9406,1.7433,2.2192 +water,table,5,1.5,1_2L,1.7925,1.8344,0.424,1.1082 +water,table,5,1.5,3_4L,2.0102,1.9895,0.9267,1.5554 +water,table,5,1.5,L,1.4019,1.3428,1.1086,1.3886 +water,table,5,1.6,1_2L,1.1125,1.1475,0.2814,0.4266 +water,table,5,1.6,3_4L,1.4041,1.3985,0.399,0.9129 +water,table,5,1.6,L,1.0674,1.0352,0.9018,1.023 +water,table,5,1.7,1_2L,0.7455,0.7764,1.3154,0.1284 +water,table,5,1.7,3_4L,1.0951,1.0971,0.4062,0.5686 +water,table,5,1.7,L,0.9192,0.9008,0.8733,0.9307 +water,table,5,1.8,1_2L,0.5081,0.5364,4.4032,2.6949 +water,table,5,1.8,3_4L,0.9182,0.9251,2.8985,1.5057 +water,table,5,1.8,L,0.864,0.854,0.5524,0.8845 +water,table,5,1.9,1_2L,0.3279,0.3544,2.6062,2.9931 +water,table,5,1.9,3_4L,0.8095,0.8203,1.9037,2.0595 +water,table,5,1.9,L,0.8695,0.8655,0.2065,0.4408 +water,table,5,2.0,1_2L,0.1741,0.1972,1.8182,2.3612 +water,table,5,2.0,3_4L,0.7411,0.7558,1.4438,1.6761 +water,table,5,2.0,L,0.9294,0.9307,0.0853,0.3166 +water,table,5,2.1,1_2L,0.107,0.0999,1.3618,1.6761 +water,table,5,2.1,3_4L,0.6988,0.7181,1.1728,1.2572 +water,table,5,2.1,L,1.0544,1.0611,0.0924,0.1923 +water,table,5,2.2,1_2L,0.294,0.2662,1.0694,1.3247 +water,table,5,2.2,3_4L,0.6721,0.6977,1.0088,1.0372 +water,table,5,2.2,L,1.2725,1.286,0.1387,0.1604 +water,table,5,2.3,1_2L,0.627,0.5949,0.8483,1.0585 +water,table,5,2.3,3_4L,0.6397,0.6739,0.8947,0.8952 +water,table,5,2.3,L,1.6176,1.6406,0.1815,0.0965 +water,table,5,2.4,1_2L,1.0731,1.0397,0.7057,0.8419 +water,table,5,2.4,3_4L,0.5348,0.5774,0.834,0.81 +water,table,5,2.4,L,2.0013,2.0357,0.2207,0.061 +water,table,5,2.5,1_2L,1.3585,1.3312,0.5951,0.6822 +water,table,5,2.5,3_4L,0.302,0.3399,0.8126,0.7638 +water,table,5,2.5,L,2.017,2.0567,0.2742,0.1391 +water,table,5,2.6,1_2L,1.2812,1.2646,0.5167,0.6005 +water,table,5,2.6,3_4L,0.1518,0.1509,0.8019,0.7461 +water,table,5,2.6,L,1.6016,1.6366,0.3063,0.2172 +water,table,5,2.7,1_2L,1.088,1.0794,0.4311,0.5899 +water,table,5,2.7,3_4L,0.2125,0.1907,0.8198,0.7248 +water,table,5,2.7,L,1.1878,1.2159,0.3776,0.1178 +water,table,5,2.8,1_2L,0.9311,0.927,0.3598,0.5224 +water,table,5,2.8,3_4L,0.2745,0.2554,0.8554,0.7319 +water,table,5,2.8,L,0.9109,0.9338,0.4525,0.1604 +water,table,5,2.9,1_2L,0.8196,0.8183,0.2671,0.4621 +water,table,5,2.9,3_4L,0.3143,0.2986,0.916,0.7603 +water,table,5,2.9,L,0.7322,0.7515,0.5773,0.203 +water,table,5,3.0,1_2L,0.7397,0.74,0.1387,0.3982 +water,table,5,3.0,3_4L,0.3414,0.3284,1.1086,0.8135 +water,table,5,3.0,L,0.612,0.6288,0.9374,0.274 diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/response_comparison.csv b/validation/experiments/flotant/response_comparison.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..35e617e --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/response_comparison.csv @@ -0,0 +1,121 @@ +set,U_m_per_s,Ur,AD_CF_1_2L_measured,AD_CF_1_2L_cabledyn,AD_CF_1_2L_cabledyn_displacement,direction,AD_CF_3_4L_measured,AD_CF_3_4L_cabledyn,AD_CF_3_4L_cabledyn_displacement,AD_CF_L_measured,AD_CF_L_cabledyn,AD_CF_L_cabledyn_displacement,AD_IL_1_2L_measured,AD_IL_1_2L_cabledyn,AD_IL_1_2L_cabledyn_displacement,AD_IL_3_4L_measured,AD_IL_3_4L_cabledyn,AD_IL_3_4L_cabledyn_displacement,AD_IL_L_measured,AD_IL_L_cabledyn,AD_IL_L_cabledyn_displacement,f_cf_1_2L_hz,fD_U_cf_1_2L,mean_top_tension_N +uls19,0.025,0.294,0.0007,0.0001,0.0001,forwards,0.0002,0.0001,0.0001,0.0006,0.0001,0.0,0.0026,0.0,0.0,0.0023,0.0,0.0,0.0013,0.0,0.0,1.2,2.304,1962.2 +uls19,0.05,0.589,0.0007,0.0009,0.001,forwards,0.0008,0.001,0.001,0.0006,0.0007,0.0007,0.0037,0.0003,0.0003,0.0033,0.0003,0.0003,0.0021,0.0002,0.0002,1.2,1.152,1962.2 +uls19,0.075,0.883,0.0007,0.011,0.0112,forwards,0.0008,0.0109,0.0103,0.0009,0.0073,0.0064,0.0036,0.0025,0.0026,0.0032,0.0025,0.0024,0.0021,0.0017,0.0015,0.825,0.528,1962.2 +uls19,0.1,1.177,0.0011,0.017,0.0171,forwards,0.0012,0.0154,0.0146,0.0012,0.01,0.0091,0.0045,0.0089,0.0091,0.0045,0.0091,0.0083,0.003,0.006,0.0047,1.0,0.48,1962.2 +uls19,0.125,1.471,0.0015,0.1084,0.1101,forwards,0.0013,0.1125,0.111,0.0013,0.0849,0.0812,0.0032,0.0249,0.0254,0.0034,0.0247,0.0232,0.0023,0.0165,0.0143,1.275,0.4896,1962.5 +uls19,0.15,1.766,0.0018,0.0251,0.0254,backwards,0.0013,0.0264,0.0262,0.0016,0.0277,0.0277,0.0025,0.0454,0.0462,0.0023,0.0452,0.0438,0.0015,0.0302,0.0275,1.2,0.384,1962.3 +uls19,0.175,2.06,0.0056,0.0361,0.0369,forwards,0.0054,0.0317,0.0301,0.0036,0.0307,0.0297,0.0039,0.0818,0.0831,0.0039,0.0822,0.0804,0.0026,0.0577,0.0541,1.775,0.4869,1962.4 +uls19,0.2,2.354,0.0034,0.0435,0.0433,backwards,0.0033,0.0294,0.0278,0.0029,0.02,0.019,0.0028,0.1,0.1016,0.0028,0.1029,0.1011,0.002,0.075,0.0713,1.875,0.45,1962.5 +uls19,0.225,2.648,0.0151,0.0473,0.0478,forwards,0.0154,0.0398,0.0379,0.0101,0.0269,0.0245,0.0042,0.0804,0.0818,0.0047,0.0856,0.0848,0.0027,0.0682,0.0661,0.8,0.1707,1962.6 +uls19,0.25,2.943,0.0313,0.1016,0.1036,backwards,0.0299,0.1018,0.0976,0.0183,0.067,0.0596,0.0056,0.0672,0.0666,0.007,0.0365,0.0344,0.0035,0.0294,0.0319,0.975,0.1872,1962.9 +uls19,0.275,3.237,0.112,0.2541,0.2588,forwards,0.1091,0.2542,0.2467,0.0642,0.1716,0.1569,0.0293,0.0773,0.077,0.0314,0.0499,0.0482,0.0147,0.0085,0.01,1.075,0.1876,1964.0 +uls19,0.3,3.531,0.1788,0.4177,0.4245,backwards,0.1731,0.4174,0.4068,0.1034,0.2849,0.2642,0.0335,0.0805,0.0803,0.0424,0.0558,0.0543,0.0203,0.0083,0.0077,1.15,0.184,1966.2 +uls19,0.325,3.825,0.3134,0.543,0.5519,forwards,0.3053,0.5455,0.5329,0.1798,0.3777,0.3527,0.0994,0.0765,0.0764,0.0952,0.0546,0.0534,0.0363,0.0106,0.0093,1.175,0.1735,1968.9 +uls19,0.35,4.12,0.4322,0.6204,0.6304,backwards,0.4169,0.6257,0.6123,0.249,0.4381,0.4112,0.1409,0.0806,0.0805,0.1293,0.0592,0.0581,0.0485,0.0133,0.012,1.2,0.1646,1971.3 +uls19,0.375,4.414,0.5,0.6689,0.6797,forwards,0.4949,0.6761,0.662,0.3048,0.4766,0.448,0.1776,0.0902,0.0901,0.1656,0.0665,0.0653,0.0612,0.016,0.0145,1.2,0.1536,1973.2 +uls19,0.4,4.708,0.673,0.7168,0.7282,backwards,0.6509,0.7278,0.7139,0.4077,0.5195,0.4907,0.1959,0.0962,0.0961,0.2093,0.0722,0.071,0.1027,0.0188,0.0173,1.225,0.147,1975.6 +uls19,0.425,5.002,0.7005,0.7443,0.7562,forwards,0.6955,0.76,0.7465,0.4464,0.5499,0.5215,0.2096,0.1052,0.1052,0.1988,0.0804,0.0791,0.0708,0.0223,0.0207,1.25,0.1412,1977.6 +uls19,0.45,5.297,0.6561,0.7547,0.7669,backwards,0.6469,0.7753,0.7627,0.4428,0.569,0.5415,0.1911,0.1168,0.1167,0.1963,0.0893,0.088,0.0901,0.0252,0.0235,1.25,0.1333,1979.3 +uls19,0.475,5.591,0.7755,0.7431,0.7553,forwards,0.7627,0.7724,0.7617,0.5057,0.5817,0.557,0.2343,0.1291,0.129,0.225,0.0988,0.0974,0.08,0.0287,0.0268,1.3,0.1314,1980.8 +uls19,0.5,5.885,0.3032,0.7364,0.7488,backwards,0.2772,0.7762,0.7673,0.2339,0.6018,0.5796,0.0605,0.1313,0.1312,0.0687,0.101,0.0996,0.0492,0.03,0.0282,1.325,0.1272,1982.5 +uls19,0.525,6.179,0.5204,0.7009,0.713,forwards,0.5191,0.7526,0.746,0.4014,0.6036,0.5849,0.1176,0.1396,0.1395,0.1249,0.1075,0.1061,0.06,0.0339,0.0321,1.35,0.1234,1983.4 +uls19,0.55,6.474,0.3282,0.6452,0.6574,backwards,0.2639,0.7156,0.7121,0.1171,0.6064,0.5921,0.0608,0.1426,0.1424,0.0743,0.1081,0.1067,0.056,0.0373,0.0357,1.375,0.12,1984.4 +uls19,0.575,6.768,0.4236,0.5743,0.5867,forwards,0.3605,0.6709,0.6708,0.2417,0.6091,0.5996,0.0865,0.14,0.1397,0.0909,0.1039,0.1026,0.0479,0.0409,0.0397,1.425,0.119,1985.3 +uls19,0.6,7.062,0.4623,0.482,0.4774,backwards,0.3369,0.2775,0.2666,0.0954,0.3346,0.3516,0.0729,0.0908,0.0903,0.0704,0.0449,0.0447,0.0363,0.0991,0.0999,1.825,0.146,1989.0 +uls19,0.625,7.356,0.5162,0.5234,0.5193,forwards,0.4009,0.3179,0.3062,0.2001,0.3441,0.3605,0.1019,0.1002,0.0998,0.1075,0.0522,0.0517,0.0661,0.0977,0.0986,1.825,0.1402,1993.2 +uls19,0.65,7.651,0.4317,0.5575,0.5536,backwards,0.3155,0.3462,0.3342,0.064,0.3526,0.3696,0.0604,0.1062,0.1057,0.062,0.056,0.0555,0.0221,0.1007,0.1017,1.85,0.1366,1997.9 +uls19,0.675,7.945,0.5637,0.5891,0.5854,forwards,0.4325,0.3694,0.3565,0.1969,0.3453,0.3624,0.1134,0.1121,0.1117,0.1142,0.0618,0.0611,0.0791,0.1032,0.1041,1.875,0.1333,2002.4 +uls19,0.7,8.239,0.3839,0.616,0.6117,backwards,0.3016,0.3734,0.3588,0.0864,0.3274,0.3464,0.059,0.112,0.1116,0.0636,0.0574,0.0567,0.0231,0.107,0.1081,1.9,0.1303,2006.8 +uls19,0.725,8.533,0.5636,0.6531,0.6489,forwards,0.4169,0.3945,0.3777,0.1152,0.2916,0.3116,0.1059,0.1158,0.1153,0.0999,0.0533,0.0525,0.0417,0.1034,0.1047,1.9,0.1258,2011.5 +uls19,0.75,8.828,0.3642,0.6816,0.6777,backwards,0.2686,0.4191,0.4015,0.0774,0.2516,0.2716,0.064,0.1192,0.1186,0.0608,0.0514,0.0502,0.0212,0.0997,0.101,1.925,0.1232,2016.2 +uls19,0.775,9.122,0.4436,0.6993,0.6959,forwards,0.3378,0.4395,0.422,0.1076,0.2085,0.2284,0.0902,0.1213,0.1208,0.0854,0.0512,0.0499,0.0296,0.1008,0.1022,1.95,0.1208,2020.6 +uls19,0.8,9.416,0.3672,0.7105,0.7078,backwards,0.2916,0.4631,0.4463,0.1358,0.1732,0.1909,0.0835,0.1243,0.1239,0.074,0.0565,0.0552,0.0307,0.1001,0.1014,2.0,0.12,2025.3 +uls19,0.825,9.71,0.3473,0.7117,0.7099,forwards,0.2935,0.4849,0.4693,0.1506,0.1337,0.1475,0.0706,0.1272,0.1267,0.0755,0.0604,0.0593,0.037,0.0996,0.101,2.025,0.1178,2029.9 +uls19,0.85,10.005,0.2972,0.7091,0.7079,backwards,0.229,0.5031,0.489,0.1536,0.1048,0.1121,0.0841,0.1295,0.1292,0.069,0.0672,0.0661,0.0331,0.098,0.0992,2.075,0.1172,2035.0 +uls19,0.875,10.299,0.2073,0.7042,0.7036,forwards,0.282,0.5162,0.5032,0.2415,0.0873,0.0876,0.0496,0.1292,0.1288,0.0708,0.0697,0.0688,0.0427,0.0921,0.0934,2.125,0.1166,2040.6 +uls19,0.9,10.593,0.2812,0.6979,0.6979,backwards,0.2494,0.5291,0.5174,0.265,0.0898,0.0827,0.0858,0.1322,0.1318,0.0735,0.0744,0.0727,0.0539,0.0878,0.0886,2.175,0.116,2046.7 +uls19,0.925,10.887,0.1989,0.6872,0.6877,forwards,0.2994,0.5387,0.5282,0.2954,0.1009,0.0895,0.0554,0.1326,0.1323,0.0751,0.0767,0.075,0.0428,0.0826,0.0833,2.225,0.1155,2053.1 +uls19,0.95,11.182,0.1751,0.6711,0.6722,backwards,0.1391,0.545,0.5358,0.2593,0.1203,0.1073,0.0467,0.1324,0.1323,0.0394,0.0797,0.0783,0.0402,0.0786,0.079,2.275,0.1149,2059.9 +uls19,0.975,11.476,0.2142,0.659,0.6605,forwards,0.2965,0.5539,0.5456,0.3181,0.1427,0.1296,0.0601,0.1293,0.1292,0.0824,0.0795,0.0786,0.0483,0.0701,0.0707,2.325,0.1145,2067.9 +uls19,1.0,11.77,0.1993,0.6388,0.6409,backwards,0.1855,0.5595,0.5522,,0.1646,0.1519,0.0622,0.1248,0.1246,0.0615,0.0792,0.0786,0.0607,0.0643,0.0648,2.375,0.114,2075.6 +b1,0.025,0.294,0.0007,0.0,0.0,forwards,0.0002,0.0,0.0,0.0006,0.0,0.0,0.0026,0.0,0.0,0.0023,0.0,0.0,0.0013,0.0,0.0,0.875,1.68,1962.2 +b1,0.05,0.589,0.0007,0.0001,0.0001,forwards,0.0008,0.0001,0.0001,0.0006,0.0001,0.0001,0.0037,0.0014,0.0014,0.0033,0.0015,0.0013,0.0021,0.001,0.0007,1.025,0.984,1962.2 +b1,0.075,0.883,0.0007,0.0011,0.0011,forwards,0.0008,0.0011,0.0011,0.0009,0.0007,0.0007,0.0036,0.0057,0.0058,0.0032,0.0057,0.0053,0.0021,0.0037,0.003,1.075,0.688,1962.2 +b1,0.1,1.177,0.0011,0.0055,0.0057,forwards,0.0012,0.0058,0.0051,0.0012,0.004,0.0027,0.0045,0.0217,0.022,0.0045,0.0217,0.0211,0.003,0.0147,0.0136,0.575,0.276,1962.2 +b1,0.125,1.471,0.0015,0.0099,0.0105,forwards,0.0013,0.0106,0.0096,0.0013,0.0079,0.0059,0.0032,0.0511,0.0519,0.0034,0.0512,0.0501,0.0023,0.0357,0.0334,0.6,0.2304,1962.3 +b1,0.15,1.766,0.0018,0.0323,0.0329,backwards,0.0013,0.0307,0.0268,0.0016,0.0191,0.0135,0.0025,0.084,0.0854,0.0023,0.0863,0.0847,0.0015,0.0624,0.0592,0.625,0.2,1962.4 +b1,0.175,2.06,0.0056,0.0583,0.0595,forwards,0.0054,0.0575,0.0548,0.0036,0.0368,0.0318,0.0039,0.047,0.0465,0.0039,0.0232,0.0215,0.0026,0.021,0.0231,0.925,0.2537,1962.4 +b1,0.2,2.354,0.0034,0.1116,0.1136,backwards,0.0033,0.1111,0.1075,0.0029,0.0737,0.0668,0.0028,0.0473,0.047,0.0028,0.0297,0.0285,0.002,0.0078,0.0092,1.05,0.252,1962.6 +b1,0.225,2.648,0.0151,0.2085,0.2121,forwards,0.0154,0.2099,0.2047,0.0101,0.1441,0.1338,0.0042,0.0366,0.0365,0.0047,0.025,0.0243,0.0027,0.0032,0.003,1.15,0.2453,1963.4 +b1,0.25,2.943,0.0313,0.3618,0.3681,backwards,0.0299,0.369,0.3617,0.0183,0.2623,0.2468,0.0056,0.0133,0.0133,0.007,0.0104,0.0102,0.0035,0.0026,0.0024,1.2,0.2304,1965.8 +b1,0.275,3.237,0.112,0.423,0.4302,forwards,0.1091,0.4341,0.4262,0.0642,0.3132,0.2963,0.0293,0.0105,0.0105,0.0314,0.0092,0.0091,0.0147,0.0028,0.0026,1.225,0.2138,1967.8 +b1,0.3,3.531,0.1788,0.4635,0.4713,backwards,0.1731,0.4778,0.4699,0.1034,0.3487,0.3312,0.0335,0.0101,0.0102,0.0424,0.0102,0.0101,0.0203,0.0035,0.0033,1.25,0.2,1969.9 +b1,0.325,3.825,0.3134,0.483,0.4913,forwards,0.3053,0.4996,0.4916,0.1798,0.3675,0.3496,0.0994,0.0165,0.0166,0.0952,0.0157,0.0155,0.0363,0.0053,0.005,1.25,0.1846,1972.0 +b1,0.35,4.12,0.4322,0.4659,0.4738,backwards,0.4169,0.4839,0.4768,0.249,0.3596,0.3433,0.1409,0.0303,0.0303,0.1293,0.0243,0.024,0.0485,0.01,0.0096,1.275,0.1749,1973.0 +b1,0.375,4.414,0.5,0.466,0.474,forwards,0.4949,0.4877,0.4811,0.3048,0.3678,0.3524,0.1776,0.0389,0.0388,0.1656,0.0288,0.0284,0.0612,0.0109,0.0104,1.3,0.1664,1975.1 +b1,0.4,4.708,0.673,0.463,0.4711,backwards,0.6509,0.489,0.4832,0.4077,0.3759,0.3615,0.1959,0.0437,0.0436,0.2093,0.0319,0.0314,0.1027,0.012,0.0115,1.3,0.156,1977.4 +b1,0.425,5.002,0.7005,0.4579,0.4661,forwards,0.6955,0.4886,0.4835,0.4464,0.3831,0.3698,0.2096,0.05,0.0499,0.1988,0.0362,0.0356,0.0708,0.0137,0.013,1.325,0.1496,1980.0 +b1,0.45,5.297,0.6561,0.4446,0.4528,backwards,0.6469,0.4808,0.4767,0.4428,0.3866,0.3748,0.1911,0.0542,0.0541,0.1963,0.0392,0.0386,0.0901,0.0152,0.0147,1.35,0.144,1982.5 +b1,0.475,5.591,0.7755,0.429,0.4371,forwards,0.7627,0.4716,0.4686,0.5057,0.3909,0.3807,0.2343,0.0583,0.0581,0.225,0.0419,0.0413,0.08,0.0171,0.0166,1.375,0.1389,1985.0 +b1,0.5,5.885,0.3032,0.3232,0.3207,backwards,0.2772,0.1835,0.174,0.2339,0.1466,0.1578,0.0605,0.0442,0.0441,0.0687,0.0256,0.0247,0.0492,0.0457,0.0457,1.85,0.1776,1979.5 +b1,0.525,6.179,0.5204,0.3449,0.3426,forwards,0.5191,0.2023,0.1925,0.4014,0.1401,0.1511,0.1176,0.0459,0.0458,0.1249,0.026,0.0252,0.06,0.0492,0.0494,1.875,0.1714,1983.5 +b1,0.55,6.474,0.3282,0.3591,0.3569,backwards,0.2639,0.2156,0.206,0.1171,0.1397,0.1506,0.0608,0.0494,0.0493,0.0743,0.0309,0.0302,0.056,0.0508,0.051,1.9,0.1658,1987.9 +b1,0.575,6.768,0.4236,0.3752,0.3731,forwards,0.3605,0.2303,0.2207,0.2417,0.1334,0.144,0.0865,0.05,0.0499,0.0909,0.03,0.0299,0.0479,0.0561,0.0566,1.925,0.1607,1993.2 +b1,0.6,7.062,0.4623,0.389,0.3871,backwards,0.3369,0.2443,0.2345,0.0954,0.1234,0.1335,0.0729,0.0524,0.0523,0.0704,0.0304,0.0301,0.0363,0.0608,0.0613,1.95,0.156,1999.3 +b1,0.625,7.356,0.5162,0.4024,0.4007,forwards,0.4009,0.2581,0.2483,0.2001,0.1119,0.1213,0.1019,0.0549,0.0548,0.1075,0.0315,0.031,0.0661,0.0638,0.0643,1.95,0.1498,2006.1 +b1,0.65,7.651,0.4317,0.4132,0.4116,backwards,0.3155,0.2701,0.2605,0.064,0.1033,0.1121,0.0604,0.0565,0.0564,0.062,0.0313,0.0308,0.0221,0.0642,0.0647,1.975,0.1458,2013.7 +b1,0.675,7.945,0.5637,0.4243,0.4229,forwards,0.4325,0.2823,0.2728,0.1969,0.0933,0.1011,0.1134,0.0575,0.0574,0.1142,0.0305,0.03,0.0791,0.0628,0.0634,2.0,0.1422,2022.4 +b1,0.7,8.239,0.3839,0.4351,0.4338,backwards,0.3016,0.2941,0.2849,0.0864,0.0842,0.091,0.059,0.0602,0.06,0.0636,0.0337,0.0328,0.0231,0.0597,0.0601,2.05,0.1406,2032.1 +b1,0.725,8.533,0.5636,0.4414,0.4403,forwards,0.4169,0.3044,0.2955,0.1152,0.0759,0.081,0.1059,0.0606,0.0606,0.0999,0.0357,0.035,0.0417,0.0518,0.0521,2.075,0.1374,2042.5 +b1,0.75,8.828,0.3642,0.4461,0.4452,backwards,0.2686,0.3129,0.3043,0.0774,0.0672,0.0701,0.064,0.0617,0.0616,0.0608,0.0311,0.0303,0.0212,0.0482,0.0485,2.1,0.1344,2053.3 +b1,0.775,9.122,0.4436,0.4494,0.4487,forwards,0.3378,0.3206,0.3124,0.1076,0.0627,0.0629,0.0902,0.0693,0.0699,0.0854,0.0449,0.0419,0.0296,0.0576,0.0558,2.15,0.1332,2065.3 +b1,0.8,9.416,0.3672,0.452,0.4515,backwards,0.2916,0.3276,0.3199,0.1358,0.0631,0.061,0.0835,0.0678,0.0686,0.074,0.0439,0.0414,0.0307,0.0588,0.0572,2.175,0.1305,2077.5 +b1,0.825,9.71,0.3473,0.4533,0.4529,forwards,0.2935,0.3331,0.3257,0.1506,0.0643,0.0601,0.0706,0.073,0.0737,0.0755,0.0505,0.0473,0.037,0.0581,0.056,2.225,0.1295,2090.5 +b1,0.85,10.005,0.2972,0.4538,0.4535,backwards,0.229,0.3374,0.3303,0.1536,0.0672,0.0618,0.0841,0.0742,0.0749,0.069,0.0521,0.0492,0.0331,0.0567,0.0545,2.25,0.1271,2105.1 +b1,0.875,10.299,0.2073,0.4535,0.4533,forwards,0.282,0.3415,0.3349,0.2415,0.0725,0.0663,0.0496,0.0739,0.0745,0.0708,0.0516,0.0488,0.0427,0.0561,0.0542,2.3,0.1262,2119.8 +b1,0.9,10.593,0.2812,0.4516,0.4516,backwards,0.2494,0.3449,0.3387,0.265,0.0787,0.0721,0.0858,0.0747,0.0751,0.0735,0.0519,0.0494,0.0539,0.0542,0.0527,2.35,0.1253,2134.3 +b1,0.925,10.887,0.1989,0.4503,0.4505,forwards,0.2994,0.3483,0.3423,0.2954,0.0852,0.0783,0.0554,0.0798,0.08,0.0751,0.0569,0.0541,0.0428,0.0533,0.0517,2.375,0.1232,2150.0 +b1,0.95,11.182,0.1751,0.4485,0.4487,backwards,0.1391,0.3505,0.3449,0.2593,0.0909,0.0841,0.0467,0.0761,0.0762,0.0394,0.053,0.0509,0.0402,0.0506,0.0499,2.425,0.1225,2167.6 +b1,0.975,11.476,0.2142,0.4462,0.4465,forwards,0.2965,0.353,0.3478,0.3181,0.0979,0.0913,0.0601,0.0768,0.077,0.0824,0.0548,0.0526,0.0483,0.0496,0.0487,2.475,0.1218,2185.0 +b1,1.0,11.77,0.1993,0.1897,0.1868,backwards,0.1855,0.1874,0.1908,,0.3854,0.3875,0.0622,0.0335,0.0308,0.0615,0.044,0.0452,0.0607,0.0279,0.0261,3.25,0.156,2135.3 +wake,0.025,0.294,0.0007,0.0,0.0,forwards,0.0002,0.0,0.0,0.0006,0.0,0.0,0.0026,0.0,0.0,0.0023,0.0,0.0,0.0013,0.0,0.0,0.575,1.104,1962.2 +wake,0.05,0.589,0.0007,0.0001,0.0001,forwards,0.0008,0.0001,0.0001,0.0006,0.0,0.0,0.0037,0.0,0.0,0.0033,0.0,0.0,0.0021,0.0,0.0,0.625,0.6,1962.2 +wake,0.075,0.883,0.0007,0.0001,0.0001,forwards,0.0008,0.0001,0.0001,0.0009,0.0001,0.0001,0.0036,0.0,0.0,0.0032,0.0,0.0,0.0021,0.0,0.0,0.925,0.592,1962.2 +wake,0.1,1.177,0.0011,0.0009,0.0009,forwards,0.0012,0.0009,0.0009,0.0012,0.0007,0.0006,0.0045,0.0,0.0,0.0045,0.0,0.0,0.003,0.0,0.0,1.25,0.6,1962.2 +wake,0.125,1.471,0.0015,0.001,0.001,forwards,0.0013,0.0011,0.0009,0.0013,0.0007,0.0005,0.0032,0.0001,0.0001,0.0034,0.0001,0.0001,0.0023,0.0,0.0,0.575,0.2208,1962.2 +wake,0.15,1.766,0.0018,0.0093,0.0097,backwards,0.0013,0.0098,0.0088,0.0016,0.0065,0.0047,0.0025,0.0002,0.0002,0.0023,0.0002,0.0002,0.0015,0.0002,0.0002,0.65,0.208,1962.2 +wake,0.175,2.06,0.0056,0.0131,0.0135,forwards,0.0054,0.0134,0.0124,0.0036,0.0085,0.0067,0.0039,0.0001,0.0001,0.0039,0.0001,0.0001,0.0026,0.0001,0.0001,0.775,0.2126,1962.3 +wake,0.2,2.354,0.0034,0.0258,0.0264,backwards,0.0033,0.0258,0.0246,0.0029,0.0165,0.0141,0.0028,0.0004,0.0004,0.0028,0.0002,0.0002,0.002,0.0002,0.0002,0.9,0.216,1962.3 +wake,0.225,2.648,0.0151,0.0906,0.0922,forwards,0.0154,0.0911,0.0888,0.0101,0.062,0.0573,0.0042,0.002,0.002,0.0047,0.0014,0.0014,0.0027,0.0002,0.0002,1.125,0.24,1962.5 +wake,0.25,2.943,0.0313,0.1683,0.1713,backwards,0.0299,0.1711,0.1674,0.0183,0.1201,0.1125,0.0056,0.0049,0.0049,0.007,0.0037,0.0036,0.0035,0.0009,0.0008,1.175,0.2256,1963.0 +wake,0.275,3.237,0.112,0.2185,0.2223,forwards,0.1091,0.2235,0.2191,0.0642,0.1594,0.1502,0.0293,0.0074,0.0073,0.0314,0.0056,0.0056,0.0147,0.0015,0.0014,1.2,0.2095,1963.5 +wake,0.3,3.531,0.1788,0.2552,0.2597,backwards,0.1731,0.2628,0.2581,0.1034,0.19,0.1798,0.0335,0.0092,0.0092,0.0424,0.0072,0.0071,0.0203,0.0021,0.002,1.225,0.196,1964.1 +wake,0.325,3.825,0.3134,0.2806,0.2856,forwards,0.3053,0.2909,0.2862,0.1798,0.2132,0.2027,0.0994,0.0104,0.0104,0.0952,0.0084,0.0082,0.0363,0.0027,0.0025,1.25,0.1846,1964.6 +wake,0.35,4.12,0.4322,0.2947,0.3,backwards,0.4169,0.308,0.3035,0.249,0.2293,0.219,0.1409,0.0109,0.0109,0.1293,0.009,0.0089,0.0485,0.0031,0.0029,1.275,0.1749,1965.1 +wake,0.375,4.414,0.5,0.2964,0.3018,forwards,0.4949,0.3129,0.3089,0.3048,0.2375,0.2277,0.1776,0.0107,0.0107,0.1656,0.009,0.0089,0.0612,0.0034,0.0033,1.3,0.1664,1965.6 +wake,0.4,4.708,0.673,0.2833,0.2886,backwards,0.6509,0.3032,0.3,0.4077,0.2359,0.2274,0.1959,0.0097,0.0097,0.2093,0.0085,0.0084,0.1027,0.0035,0.0034,1.325,0.159,1965.9 +wake,0.425,5.002,0.7005,0.2476,0.2525,forwards,0.6955,0.2708,0.2688,0.4464,0.2192,0.2128,0.2096,0.0076,0.0076,0.1988,0.007,0.007,0.0708,0.0034,0.0033,1.35,0.1525,1966.1 +wake,0.45,5.297,0.6561,0.1707,0.1688,backwards,0.6469,0.0825,0.0762,0.4428,0.0787,0.0864,0.1911,0.0037,0.0037,0.1963,0.0017,0.0017,0.0901,0.0016,0.0017,1.825,0.1947,1966.5 +wake,0.475,5.591,0.7755,0.192,0.1903,forwards,0.7627,0.0993,0.0927,0.5057,0.0752,0.0833,0.2343,0.0044,0.0044,0.225,0.0021,0.002,0.08,0.0019,0.0019,1.85,0.1869,1967.5 +wake,0.5,5.885,0.3032,0.2079,0.2063,backwards,0.2772,0.1136,0.107,0.2339,0.0665,0.0746,0.0605,0.0049,0.0049,0.0687,0.0023,0.0023,0.0492,0.002,0.0021,1.875,0.18,1968.5 +wake,0.525,6.179,0.5204,0.218,0.2166,forwards,0.5191,0.125,0.1186,0.4014,0.0559,0.0637,0.1176,0.0051,0.0051,0.1249,0.0025,0.0024,0.06,0.002,0.0021,1.9,0.1737,1969.5 +wake,0.55,6.474,0.3282,0.2232,0.222,backwards,0.2639,0.1336,0.1275,0.1171,0.0436,0.051,0.0608,0.0052,0.0052,0.0743,0.0026,0.0025,0.056,0.0019,0.0019,1.925,0.168,1970.6 +wake,0.575,6.768,0.4236,0.2224,0.2214,forwards,0.3605,0.1385,0.1328,0.2417,0.0305,0.0373,0.0865,0.0051,0.0051,0.0909,0.0026,0.0026,0.0479,0.0016,0.0017,1.95,0.1628,1971.8 +wake,0.6,7.062,0.4623,0.2138,0.2131,backwards,0.3369,0.1386,0.1336,0.0954,0.0176,0.0233,0.0729,0.0047,0.0047,0.0704,0.0025,0.0025,0.0363,0.0013,0.0014,2.0,0.16,1973.0 +wake,0.625,7.356,0.5162,0.1977,0.1972,forwards,0.4009,0.1337,0.1295,0.2001,0.0096,0.0118,0.1019,0.0043,0.0043,0.1075,0.0026,0.0025,0.0661,0.0013,0.0012,2.05,0.1574,1974.3 +wake,0.65,7.651,0.4317,0.1766,0.1764,backwards,0.3155,0.125,0.1217,0.064,0.0181,0.0164,0.0604,0.004,0.0039,0.062,0.0026,0.0025,0.0221,0.0014,0.0011,2.125,0.1569,1975.8 +wake,0.675,7.945,0.5637,0.1493,0.1492,forwards,0.4325,0.1125,0.1103,0.1969,0.0398,0.0386,0.1134,0.0042,0.0037,0.1142,0.0023,0.0021,0.0791,0.0015,0.0014,2.2,0.1564,1977.6 +wake,0.7,8.239,0.3839,0.0379,0.0361,backwards,0.3016,0.0707,0.0722,0.0864,0.1138,0.114,0.059,0.0011,0.0011,0.0636,0.0006,0.0006,0.0231,0.0005,0.0005,2.975,0.204,1980.4 +wake,0.725,8.533,0.5636,0.0476,0.0456,forwards,0.4169,0.0737,0.0754,0.1152,0.1292,0.1297,0.1059,0.0012,0.0012,0.0999,0.0007,0.0007,0.0417,0.0006,0.0006,3.0,0.1986,1983.3 +wake,0.75,8.828,0.3642,0.0559,0.0538,backwards,0.2686,0.0764,0.0782,0.0774,0.1437,0.1443,0.064,0.0013,0.0013,0.0608,0.0008,0.0008,0.0212,0.0007,0.0007,3.05,0.1952,1986.5 +wake,0.775,9.122,0.4436,0.0617,0.0597,forwards,0.3378,0.0794,0.0814,0.1076,0.1591,0.1599,0.0902,0.0015,0.0015,0.0854,0.0009,0.0009,0.0296,0.0008,0.0008,3.075,0.1905,1990.0 +wake,0.8,9.416,0.3672,0.0683,0.0661,backwards,0.2916,0.0797,0.0818,0.1358,0.1708,0.1717,0.0835,0.0015,0.0015,0.074,0.0009,0.0009,0.0307,0.0008,0.0008,3.1,0.186,1993.8 +wake,0.825,9.71,0.3473,0.0741,0.072,forwards,0.2935,0.0782,0.0805,0.1506,0.1801,0.1812,0.0706,0.0016,0.0016,0.0755,0.0009,0.0009,0.037,0.0009,0.0009,3.15,0.1833,1997.7 +wake,0.85,10.005,0.2972,0.0795,0.0775,backwards,0.229,0.0747,0.077,0.1536,0.1862,0.1874,0.0841,0.0016,0.0016,0.069,0.0008,0.0008,0.0331,0.0009,0.0009,3.175,0.1793,2001.8 +wake,0.875,10.299,0.2073,0.0844,0.0824,forwards,0.282,0.0695,0.0718,0.2415,0.1887,0.1901,0.0496,0.0016,0.0016,0.0708,0.0008,0.0008,0.0427,0.0009,0.0009,3.2,0.1755,2006.2 +wake,0.9,10.593,0.2812,0.0882,0.0864,backwards,0.2494,0.0624,0.0647,0.265,0.1876,0.189,0.0858,0.0016,0.0016,0.0735,0.0007,0.0007,0.0539,0.0009,0.0009,3.25,0.1733,2010.7 +wake,0.925,10.887,0.1989,0.091,0.0893,forwards,0.2994,0.0537,0.0559,0.2954,0.1824,0.1839,0.0554,0.0015,0.0015,0.0751,0.0006,0.0006,0.0428,0.0008,0.0008,3.3,0.1712,2015.3 +wake,0.95,11.182,0.1751,0.0927,0.0913,backwards,0.1391,0.0444,0.0464,0.2593,0.1735,0.175,0.0467,0.0015,0.0015,0.0394,0.0006,0.0006,0.0402,0.0007,0.0007,3.325,0.168,2020.2 +wake,0.975,11.476,0.2142,0.0929,0.0917,forwards,0.2965,0.0341,0.0358,0.3181,0.1594,0.1609,0.0601,0.0015,0.0014,0.0824,0.0007,0.0006,0.0483,0.0006,0.0006,3.4,0.1674,2025.3 +wake,1.0,11.77,0.1993,0.0908,0.0898,backwards,0.1855,0.0252,0.0264,,0.1401,0.1416,0.0622,0.0022,0.0019,0.0615,0.0009,0.0008,0.0607,0.0007,0.0008,3.45,0.1656,2030.6 diff --git a/validation/experiments/flotant/summary.json b/validation/experiments/flotant/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..338ec8c --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/flotant/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,505 @@ +{ + "dt_s": 0.002, + "elements_per_table_element": 1, + "tow": { + "end": "identified", + "tmax_s": 60.0, + "statistics_after_s": 20.0, + "highpass_rad_s": 3.5, + "Ur_frequency_hz": 1.77, + "release_fraction_of_peak": 0.7, + "per_set": { + "uls19": { + "label": "Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1, Chh 1.5", + "fitted_to": "the NDP riser in uniform flow; blind here", + "speeds": [ + 0.025, + 0.05, + 0.075, + 0.1, + 0.125, + 0.15, + 0.175, + 0.2, + 0.225, + 0.25, + 0.275, + 0.3, + 0.325, + 0.35, + 0.375, + 0.4, + 0.425, + 0.45, + 0.475, + 0.5, + 0.525, + 0.55, + 0.575, + 0.6, + 0.625, + 0.65, + 0.675, + 0.7, + 0.725, + 0.75, + 0.775, + 0.8, + 0.825, + 0.85, + 0.875, + 0.9, + 0.925, + 0.95, + 0.975, + 1.0 + ], + "compared_tests": "Ur >= 3", + "cf_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.730599035507909, + "cf_ratio_median_all_stations": 1.6045546300304596, + "il_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.7422498473783267, + "il_ratio_median_all_stations": 1.0403634795667123, + "cf_rms_log_error": { + "1_2L": 0.6896505635145447, + "3_4L": 0.6054958725179113, + "L": 0.8757002334921515 + }, + "il_rms_log_error": { + "1_2L": 0.6242433471759753, + "3_4L": 0.5201489867187723, + "L": 0.9962779646872738 + }, + "cf_rms_log_error_1_2L_by_direction": { + "forwards": 0.6473677602467042, + "backwards": 0.7294866568382343 + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak": { + "peak_AD": 0.7547273832653888, + "peak_Ur": 5.296610169491525, + "release_Ur": 7.062146892655367, + "f_hz_at_peak": 1.2499999999984723 + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak_measured": { + "peak_AD": 0.7755, + "peak_Ur": 5.583, + "release_Ur": 5.884 + }, + "mean_top_tension_N_range": [ + 1962, + 2076 + ] + }, + "b1": { + "label": "generic set (Delta Flume case)", + "fitted_to": "no; blind", + "speeds": [ + 0.025, + 0.05, + 0.075, + 0.1, + 0.125, + 0.15, + 0.175, + 0.2, + 0.225, + 0.25, + 0.275, + 0.3, + 0.325, + 0.35, + 0.375, + 0.4, + 0.425, + 0.45, + 0.475, + 0.5, + 0.525, + 0.55, + 0.575, + 0.6, + 0.625, + 0.65, + 0.675, + 0.7, + 0.725, + 0.75, + 0.775, + 0.8, + 0.825, + 0.85, + 0.875, + 0.9, + 0.925, + 0.95, + 0.975, + 1.0 + ], + "compared_tests": "Ur >= 3", + "cf_rms_log_error_all_stations": 0.5941536831759612, + "cf_ratio_median_all_stations": 0.9491137600334464, + "il_rms_log_error_all_stations": 1.0166460852408143, + "il_ratio_median_all_stations": 0.5752475108833648, + "cf_rms_log_error": { + "1_2L": 0.496789066673788, + "3_4L": 0.4791025608890916, + "L": 0.7685296331328462 + }, + "il_rms_log_error": { + "1_2L": 0.8550027299528041, + "3_4L": 1.1234580174708335, + "L": 1.0523878575222048 + }, + "cf_rms_log_error_1_2L_by_direction": { + "forwards": 0.5636506860751169, + "backwards": 0.41940035481658433 + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak": { + "peak_AD": 0.48303768537307423, + "peak_Ur": 3.8253295668549905, + "release_Ur": 5.885122410546138, + "f_hz_at_peak": 1.2499999999984723 + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak_measured": { + "peak_AD": 0.7755, + "peak_Ur": 5.583, + "release_Ur": 5.884 + }, + "mean_top_tension_N_range": [ + 1962, + 2185 + ] + }, + "wake": { + "label": "Facchinetti et al. (2004) wake oscillator", + "fitted_to": "rigid-cylinder data; blind", + "speeds": [ + 0.025, + 0.05, + 0.075, + 0.1, + 0.125, + 0.15, + 0.175, + 0.2, + 0.225, + 0.25, + 0.275, + 0.3, + 0.325, + 0.35, + 0.375, + 0.4, + 0.425, + 0.45, + 0.475, + 0.5, + 0.525, + 0.55, + 0.575, + 0.6, + 0.625, + 0.65, + 0.675, + 0.7, + 0.725, + 0.75, + 0.775, + 0.8, + 0.825, + 0.85, + 0.875, + 0.9, + 0.925, + 0.95, + 0.975, + 1.0 + ], + "compared_tests": "Ur >= 3", + "cf_rms_log_error_all_stations": 1.2083674966459748, + "cf_ratio_median_all_stations": 0.4070965464436991, + "il_rms_log_error_all_stations": 3.605803405022973, + "il_ratio_median_all_stations": 0.02753921577465114, + "cf_rms_log_error": { + "1_2L": 1.1895195653845272, + "3_4L": 1.2909523301731947, + "L": 1.13726967599545 + }, + "il_rms_log_error": { + "1_2L": 3.325377943947132, + "3_4L": 3.92168317276405, + "L": 3.545097630446166 + }, + "cf_rms_log_error_1_2L_by_direction": { + "forwards": 1.214376106938135, + "backwards": 1.1641324081748472 + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak": { + "peak_AD": 0.2964251183985482, + "peak_Ur": 4.413841807909604, + "release_Ur": 5.296610169491525, + "f_hz_at_peak": 1.299999999998411 + }, + "cf_1_2L_peak_measured": { + "peak_AD": 0.7755, + "peak_Ur": 5.583, + "release_Ur": 5.884 + }, + "mean_top_tension_N_range": [ + 1962, + 2031 + ] + } + } + }, + "rao": { + "air_table_5mm": { + "surge": { + "rms_log_error": 0.2271249523692518, + "band_hz": [ + 1.4, + 2.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.7, + 7.386 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.7, + 8.683 + ] + ] + }, + "sway": { + "rms_log_error": 0.2775305840736591, + "band_hz": [ + 1.4, + 2.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.7, + 7.386 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.7, + 9.142 + ] + ] + } + }, + "air_table_10mm": { + "surge": { + "rms_log_error": 0.20858196424547804, + "band_hz": [ + 1.4, + 2.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.7, + 7.234 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.7, + 5.881 + ] + ] + }, + "sway": { + "rms_log_error": 0.22969544591422794, + "band_hz": [ + 1.4, + 2.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.7, + 7.234 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.7, + 6.398 + ] + ] + } + }, + "water_free_5mm": { + "surge": { + "rms_log_error": 1.1742370919761518, + "band_hz": [ + 1.0, + 3.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.4, + 3.678 + ], + [ + 2.6, + 1.311 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.3, + 4.246 + ], + [ + 1.8, + 4.403 + ] + ] + }, + "sway": { + "rms_log_error": 1.2074671000645258, + "band_hz": [ + 1.0, + 3.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.4, + 3.678 + ], + [ + 2.6, + 1.311 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.3, + 4.314 + ], + [ + 1.9, + 2.993 + ] + ] + } + }, + "water_identified_5mm": { + "surge": { + "rms_log_error": 0.45854152035091567, + "band_hz": [ + 1.0, + 3.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.2, + 3.758 + ], + [ + 1.9, + 2.451 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.3, + 4.246 + ], + [ + 1.8, + 4.403 + ] + ] + }, + "sway": { + "rms_log_error": 0.7431022078522367, + "band_hz": [ + 1.0, + 3.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.2, + 3.758 + ], + [ + 1.9, + 2.451 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.3, + 4.314 + ], + [ + 1.9, + 2.993 + ] + ] + } + }, + "water_table_5mm": { + "surge": { + "rms_log_error": 1.1862435338325563, + "band_hz": [ + 1.0, + 3.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.3, + 3.943 + ], + [ + 2.5, + 1.359 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.3, + 4.246 + ], + [ + 1.8, + 4.403 + ] + ] + }, + "sway": { + "rms_log_error": 1.2156538997830377, + "band_hz": [ + 1.0, + 3.0 + ], + "peaks_1_2L_cabledyn": [ + [ + 1.3, + 3.943 + ], + [ + 2.5, + 1.359 + ] + ], + "peaks_1_2L_measured": [ + [ + 1.3, + 4.314 + ], + [ + 1.9, + 2.993 + ] + ] + } + } + }, + "executable_sha256": "3a93a8b9ba3af58d2cf6d158cbcf61299b38de7541ab6ed8caef0a18bb3d2e4b" +} diff --git a/validation/experiments/ndp_riser/ndp_riser_viv.py b/validation/experiments/ndp_riser/ndp_riser_viv.py index 848efba..a817a17 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/ndp_riser/ndp_riser_viv.py +++ b/validation/experiments/ndp_riser/ndp_riser_viv.py @@ -324,6 +324,11 @@ def run_case( if not ( same and out.is_file() and ran.is_file() and ran.read_text().strip() == sha ): + # A run that fails or is interrupted must not leave the previous model's result next + # to the new inputs, where the next attempt would reuse it. + result.unlink(missing_ok=True) + ran.unlink(missing_ok=True) + out.unlink(missing_ok=True) deck.write_text(text, encoding="utf-8") (folder / "current_profile.txt").write_text( f"z ux uy uz\n(m) (m/s) (m/s) (m/s)\n{-WATER_DEPTH:.2f} 0 {u} 0\n0.0 0 {u} 0\n",