diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 264bf09..827be46 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -132,6 +132,17 @@ All notable changes to CableDyn are recorded in this file. The format follows (cross-flow r.m.s. log error 0.731); the generic set is 38 % low at the peak and releases at the measured speed (0.594); the wake oscillator of Facchinetti et al. (2004) is 62 % low (1.208). +- Validation case L3-Wh (`validation/experiments/wang_scr`): heave-induced cross-flow VIV of + the L3-W riser in still water, its upper end moved along the measured top trajectory of + Thorsen et al. (2017, period 5.96 s), with their coefficient set, the strain band-passed as + Wang et al. (2014) process it. Without a `VIV FRAME` row the dominant frequency is 1.019 Hz + (measured close to 1 Hz), the largest r.m.s. strain 20.8 % above the measured largest and the + lower half of the span 1.71 times the measured on average (Thorsen et al.'s model 5.6 % and + 1.44). The heave period is about 6 VIV periods, below the `VIV FRAME` scale separation, and the + result depends on `Tf` (0.35–1 s): the response falls on a 1.01–1.02 Hz or a 0.88–0.89 Hz + branch, reported as a sensitivity. The case's script is now `wang_scr_viv.py` for both parts + (it replaces `wang_scr_uniform_current.py`; the L3-W numbers are unchanged), and its data, + including Thorsen et al.'s simulated lines, are read by `extract_thorsen2017.py`. - Theory manual, Published coefficient sets: the VIV coefficient sets of Thorsen et al. (2016, 2017), Ulveseter et al. (2018), Andersen et al. (2024a, b) and Facchinetti et al. (2004), each with its source, its test data and the line-type columns it maps to, and Thorsen et al.'s diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 1f6aa90..21109df 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -172,8 +172,8 @@ layout is described in the architecture notes in the repository. CableDyn is verified against analytical solutions and compared with MoorDyn, OrcaFlex, seven published physical experiments (Holcombe lazy-wave, Bergdahl dynamic -chain, Chaplin riser natural frequencies and stepped-current VIV, Wang catenary-riser VIV, -NDP high-mode riser VIV, FLOTANT power-cable VIV), the IEA 15 MW VolturnUS-S reference systems, and coupled OpenFAST runs. Results, +chain, Chaplin riser natural frequencies and stepped-current VIV, Wang catenary-riser VIV in +current and heave, NDP high-mode riser VIV, FLOTANT power-cable VIV), the IEA 15 MW VolturnUS-S reference systems, and coupled OpenFAST runs. Results, acceptance criteria, and reproduction commands are in the [validation record](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/validation.html); data and scripts are in [`validation/`](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/validation.html). diff --git a/VALIDATION.md b/VALIDATION.md index c2e73f4..b68648d 100644 --- a/VALIDATION.md +++ b/VALIDATION.md @@ -84,7 +84,8 @@ article's methods, are compared in | **L3-B** | Bergdahl chain experiment, 30 orbit conditions | measured upper-end force | RMSE 1.58 N; MAPE 3.11%; Pearson 0.993; Lin concordance 0.989 | full published matrix | Pass | | **L3-C** | Chaplin Delta Flume riser, still-water natural frequencies | measured modes 1–7 at five tensions | mean error +1.87%, mean absolute 2.28%, largest 4.88% (34 of 35; one outlier reported) | full published table, no fitted parameter | Pass | | **L3-D** | Chaplin Delta Flume riser in a stepped current, blind-trial cases 1–9, cross-flow and in-line VIV | measured dominant mode, peak cross-flow amplitude, mean in-line displacement, curvature standard deviations | mode right in 5/9, within one in 9/9; mean in-line within ±17% in 7/9 (−25% to +34%); cross-flow amplitude −45% to +4%; cross-flow curvature −39% to +26% | generic coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass measured | -| **L3-W** | SJTU steel catenary riser in 0.2 m/s current, cross-flow VIV | measured r.m.s. strain (25 stations) and dominant frequency | frequency 0.992 vs 1.00 Hz; max r.m.s. strain +7.3%, station mean +3.6% | published coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass | +| **L3-W** | SJTU steel catenary riser in 0.2 m/s current, cross-flow VIV | measured r.m.s. strain (25 stations) and dominant frequency | frequency 0.992 vs 1.00 Hz; max r.m.s. strain +7.3%, station mean +3.6% (Thorsen et al. 2017: 1.02 Hz, −0.4%, −3.0%) | published coefficient set, no fitted parameter | Pass | +| **L3-Wh** | SJTU steel catenary riser, heave-induced cross-flow VIV in still water (measured top motion, 5.96 s) | measured r.m.s. strain (25 stations, band-passed 0.67–50 Hz) and dominant frequency | no `VIV FRAME`: frequency 1.019 Hz vs close to 1 Hz; max r.m.s. strain +20.8%, station mean +33%, lower/upper half 1.71/0.93 (Thorsen et al. 2017: +5.6%, +8.7%, 1.44/0.71); `VIV FRAME` `Tf` 0.35–1 s: two branches, 1.01–1.02 Hz (max +7 to +13%) or 0.88–0.89 Hz (max −2.8 to −4.2%), `Tf` 0.5 s changes branch at dt/2 | published coefficient set, no fitted parameter; heave period about 6 VIV periods, below the `VIV FRAME` scale separation | Pass measured | | **L3-N** | NDP 38 m high-mode riser in uniform flow, 0.3–2.4 m/s (22 tests), cross-flow VIV | measured maximum r.m.s. cross-flow strain, dominant frequency, spatial-mean σ/D | strain r.m.s. log error: Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.178, Andersen et al. (2024b) 0.186, generic set 0.277, Thorsen et al. (2016) 0.363 (their own simulation 0.187); f D/U 0.145 / 0.134 / 0.192 / 0.193 vs 0.143 measured | generic set blind; the other sets fitted by their authors to NDP tests (implementation check) | Pass measured | | **L3-F** | FLOTANT OD 48 mm power-cable specimen with a 200 kg clump, tow tests at 0.025–1.0 m/s (40 tests), cross-flow and in-line VIV | measured A/D_rms (σ/OD) at 1/2L, 3/4L and L (de Wilde et al. 2021, App. 3) | CF r.m.s. log error (Ur ≥ 3): Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.731, generic set 0.594, wake oscillator 1.208; first peak at 1/2L 0.755 / 0.483 / 0.296 vs 0.776 measured; release Ur 7.06 / 5.89 / 5.30 vs 5.88 | published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests; structure identified from the specimen's in-air and in-water RAOs | Pass measured | | **L-fig** | Along-arc curvature overlay (CableDyn / OrcaFlex / MoorDyn-F ±4×) | 3-code committed record | CableDyn peak 0.11% from OrcaFlex | <0.5% | Pass | @@ -373,9 +374,29 @@ the tow tests it predicts). Inputs, reduction scripts, results, and source prove frequency 8.25 m from the lower end is 0.992 Hz against the measured 1.00 Hz (their model 1.02 Hz; [Davies et al., 2026](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-davies2026), 1.04 Hz). The largest r.m.s. strain is 7.3% above the measured largest (theirs 0.4% below) and the - mean over the 25 stations 3.6% above. The response has one r.m.s. peak more along the span than - the test, as theirs, so the station-by-station ratio scatters. 400 elements and half the time step - change the largest r.m.s. strain by 0.2% and 0.1%. + mean over the 25 stations 3.6% above (theirs 3.0% below). The response has one r.m.s. peak more + along the span than the test, as theirs, so the station-by-station ratio scatters (r.m.s. log + error 0.338, theirs 0.360). 400 elements and half the time step change the largest r.m.s. + strain by 0.2% and 0.1%. + +- **L3-Wh SJTU steel catenary riser, heave-induced cross-flow VIV** + ([Wang et al., 2014](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-wang2014); + [Thorsen et al., 2017](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-thorsen2017)): + the L3-W riser in still water, its upper end moved along the measured top trajectory (two + sinusoids of 5.96 s fitted to their Fig. 19: x 0.049 m, z 0.130 m), with Thorsen et al.'s set + for this case (C_v 0.8), the strain band-passed from 4 times the motion frequency to 50 Hz as + Wang et al. process the measurement. Without a `VIV FRAME` row, the published model's phase + input, the dominant frequency 8.25 m from the lower end is 1.019 Hz (measured close to 1 Hz), + the largest r.m.s. strain 20.8% above the measured largest (theirs 5.6% above) and the + station mean 33% above (theirs 8.7%). The lower half of the span reads 1.71 times the measured + on average and the upper half 0.93 times; their model has the same pattern, 1.44 and 0.71. + Half the time step and 400 elements change the largest strain by −1.0% and −0.7% and the + station mean by −2.9% and −2.3%, at the same frequency. The heave period is about 6 VIV + periods, below the scale separation a `VIV FRAME` filter needs (about 30), and the result + depends on `Tf`: at 0.35–0.5 s the response stays at 1.01–1.02 Hz with the largest strain + 7–13% high, at 0.75–1 s it moves to 0.88 Hz with the largest strain 3–4% low and the upper half + 0.60–0.63 times the measured, and at 0.5 s half the time step moves it from the first branch + to the second. The default run reproduces the committed record byte for byte. - **L3-N NDP high-mode riser, cross-flow VIV in uniform flow** ([Trim et al., 2005](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-trim2005); diff --git a/doc/theory.rst b/doc/theory.rst index 8ce9d1b..c483be9 100644 --- a/doc/theory.rst +++ b/doc/theory.rst @@ -1705,10 +1705,12 @@ and model form. The table gives each set with its source and the line-type colum damping :math:`C_{d,y} = 0.31 + 0.89\,y_0/D` (their Eq. 1) - a ``VIV AMPLITUDE`` table (below); ``VIV DAMPING`` ``0.31 0.89 0`` * - :ref:`Thorsen et al. (2017) `: the truncated catenary riser of - :ref:`Wang et al. (2014) ` in uniform current (Re about 3 000) - - :math:`C_v` 0.7, :math:`\hat f_0` 0.18, :math:`\Delta\hat f` 0.08, :math:`C_D` 1.2, - :math:`C_M` 2 - - ``Cl dF cF`` = ``0.7 0.08 0.18``, ``Cd_n`` 1.2, ``Ca_n`` 1.0 (validation case L3-W) + :ref:`Wang et al. (2014) ` in uniform current (Re about 3 000) and under + heave motion of its upper end (Re about 4 000) + - :math:`C_v` 0.7 in the current, 0.8 in heave; :math:`\hat f_0` 0.18, + :math:`\Delta\hat f` 0.08, :math:`C_D` 1.2, :math:`C_M` 2 + - ``Cl dF cF`` = ``0.7 0.08 0.18`` (current) or ``0.8 0.08 0.18`` (heave), ``Cd_n`` 1.2, + ``Ca_n`` 1.0 (validation cases L3-W and L3-Wh) * - :ref:`Ulveseter et al. (2018) `: in-line force at twice the cross-flow frequency - :math:`C_x` 0.85, :math:`\alpha` 0.15, with a cross-flow :math:`C_L` of 0.65 diff --git a/validation/README.md b/validation/README.md index ccda055..36a4213 100644 --- a/validation/README.md +++ b/validation/README.md @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ redistributed. | [`RELEASE_0_1_1.md`](RELEASE_0_1_1.md) | The same for v0.1.1 | | [`RELEASE_0_1_0.md`](RELEASE_0_1_0.md) | The same for v0.1.0 | | [`bodies/`](bodies/README.md) | Rigid-body, rod and shared-anchor cases with MoorDyn-C twins, stored references and pass limits | -| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV, Trim et al. (2005) NDP high-mode riser VIV and de Wilde et al. (2021) FLOTANT power-cable VIV comparisons | +| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV in current and heave, Trim et al. (2005) NDP high-mode riser VIV and de Wilde et al. (2021) FLOTANT power-cable VIV comparisons | | [`PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md`](PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md) | Wall time of CableDyn 0.1.0, MoorDyn-C and MoorDyn-F at equal accuracy on five mooring, cable, buoy and coupled cases | | [`performance/`](performance/README.md) | Same-host wall-clock records of the L5 cases: the resolved lazy-wave spans, the one-hour VolturnUS-S mooring and the tension-only chain | | [`PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md`](PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md) | Every CableDyn result in the journal article, re-run with the release defaults and in paper mode | diff --git a/validation/experiments/README.md b/validation/experiments/README.md index c9b32e2..aac5049 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/README.md +++ b/validation/experiments/README.md @@ -13,8 +13,8 @@ committed results. | [`bergdahl/`](bergdahl/README.md) | Bergdahl et al. (2016), 33 m dynamically scaled chain | Tension-only mooring chain | | [`chaplin/`](chaplin/README.md) | Chaplin et al. (2005), 13.12 m vertical tension riser, still-water natural frequencies | Finite-EI riser, modal analysis | | [`delta_flume/`](delta_flume/README.md) | Chaplin et al. (2005), 13.12 m vertical tension riser, stepped current, blind-trial cases 1–9 | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV, cross-flow and in-line | -| [`wang_scr/`](wang_scr/README.md) | Wang et al. (2014), truncated steel catenary riser in uniform current, cross-flow VIV | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | +| [`wang_scr/`](wang_scr/README.md) | Wang et al. (2014), truncated steel catenary riser in uniform current and under heave motion of its upper end, cross-flow VIV | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | | [`ndp_riser/`](ndp_riser/README.md) | Trim et al. (2005), NDP 38 m high-mode riser in uniform flow, cross-flow VIV with a generic and three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | | [`flotant/`](flotant/README.md) | de Wilde et al. (2021), FLOTANT OD 48 mm power-cable specimen with a clump weight, tow tests and forced-oscillation RAOs, cross-flow and in-line VIV with three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI cable, synchronisation and wake-oscillator VIV | -The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D, L3-W, L3-N and L3-F in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). +The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D, L3-W, L3-Wh, L3-N and L3-F in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/README.md b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/README.md index c420ee2..76894c8 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/README.md +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/README.md @@ -1,61 +1,228 @@ -# Steel catenary riser in uniform current: cross-flow VIV +# Steel catenary riser: cross-flow VIV in uniform current and under heave -This directory compares CableDyn's cross-flow VIV with the SJTU model test of a truncated steel -catenary riser in a 0.2 m/s uniform current: Wang et al. (2014), -, as Thorsen et al. (2017), -, use it to verify the time-domain synchronisation -model that CableDyn's cross-flow VIV implements. The model runs with their coefficient set for this -case; nothing is fitted to the measurements. +This directory compares CableDyn's cross-flow VIV with the SJTU model tests of a truncated steel +catenary riser: Wang et al. (2014), , as Thorsen +et al. (2017), , use them to verify the +time-domain synchronisation model that CableDyn's cross-flow VIV implements. Both of their cases +are run, each with their published coefficient set for it; nothing is fitted to the measurements. + +- **Uniform current, 0.2 m/s (case L3-W):** the dominant strain frequency 8.25 m from the lower + end is 0.992 Hz against the measured 1.00 Hz (Thorsen et al.'s model 1.02 Hz). The largest r.m.s. + cross-flow strain is 7.3 % above the measured largest (theirs 0.4 % below), the mean over the 25 + stations 3.6 % above (theirs 3.0 % below), and the r.m.s. log error over the stations 0.338 + (theirs 0.360). +- **Heave-induced VIV in still water (case L3-Wh):** with the phase input of the published model + (no `VIV FRAME`), the largest r.m.s. strain is 20.8 % above the measured largest (theirs + 5.6 % above) and the station mean 33 % above (theirs 8.7 % above); the dominant frequency is + 1.019 Hz (measured close to 1 Hz). Over the lower half of the span the strain is 1.71 times + the measured on average, over the upper half 0.93 times; Thorsen et al.'s model has the same + pattern, 1.44 and 0.71. +- **The heave result depends on the `VIV FRAME` filter time `Tf`.** The heave period, 5.96 s, is + about 6 VIV periods, below the scale separation the filter needs (a motion period of at least + about 30 VIV periods; [`VIV FRAME`](../../../doc/driver_format.md)). With `Tf` from 0.35 to 1 s + the response falls on one of two branches, about 1.02 Hz or 0.88 Hz, and at `Tf` 0.5 s halving + the time step moves it from the first to the second. The `Tf` runs are a sensitivity, not the + result. ## Model and data -- **Riser (Thorsen et al. 2017, Table 1):** - - length 23.71 m, between universal joints (pinned); - - the top 21.0425 m horizontally and 9 m vertically from the lower end, with a 2.626 m flowline on - the seabed; - - D 0.024 m, 0.69 kg/m (a solid section: no internal water is added), EI 10.5 N m², EA 6.66e5 N. -- **Seabed:** 1 (kN/m)/m in compression (`kBot` = 1000/D), friction 0.2. -- **Current:** 0.2 m/s along the riser plane, from the lower end towards the top. -- **VIV (their set for this case):** C_v 0.7 (their choice for Re ≈ 3000), f̂0 0.18, Δf̂ 0.08, - cross-flow only; C_D 1.2, C_M 2. -- **Measurements:** `measured_rms_strain.csv` holds the 25 measured r.m.s. dynamic cross-flow strains - at the outer surface (Thorsen et al. 2017, Fig. 17), read from the vector figure. The axes are - calibrated on its tick marks; as a check, the simulated maximum of the same figure reads 99.6 % of - the measured one, as their text states. The measured dominant strain frequency 8.25 m from the - lower end is 1.00 Hz (their Fig. 18). -- **Assumed:** the top joint 0.5 m below the surface (not given; the current is uniform). -- **CableDyn:** 200 elements, dt 0.005 s, 150 s, statistics over t > 30 s. The cross-flow curvature - is the section component with no static mean (the in-plane one carries the catenary curvature); - strain = κ D/2. +- **Riser (Thorsen et al. 2017, Table 1; Wang et al. 2014, Table 2):** + - length 23.71 m, between universal joints (moment free); + - the top 21.0425 m horizontally and 9 m vertically from the lower end, with a 2.626 m flowline + on the fake seabed; + - D 0.024 m, 0.69 kg/m (a solid section of coating, PPR pipe and copper core: no internal water + is added), EI 10.5 N m², EA 6.66e5 N (Thorsen et al.; Wang et al. give 6.67e5 N). +- **Seabed (Thorsen et al. 2017, Sec. 5.1):** 1 (kN/m)/m in compression (`kBot` = 1000/D), + friction 0.2. +- **Coefficients (Thorsen et al.'s sets):** C_v 0.7 in the current (their choice for Re ≈ 3000) + and 0.8 in heave (Re ≈ 4000, from the largest r.m.s. in-plane velocity of their model, + 0.16 m/s); f̂0 0.18, Δf̂ 0.08, cross-flow only; C_D 1.2, C_M 2. +- **Assumed:** the top joint 0.5 m below the surface, in 9.5 m of water (not given). +- **CableDyn:** one finite-EI line, 200 elements, dt 0.005 s (Thorsen et al.'s step; they use 500 + elements). + +### Uniform current (Thorsen et al. 2017, Sec. 5.1) + +- **Current:** 0.2 m/s along the riser plane, from the lower end towards the top. In the test the + top and the seabed moved together on tracks through still water. +- **Run:** 150 s, statistics over t > 30 s (frequency resolution 0.0083 Hz). +- **Measured:** the r.m.s. dynamic cross-flow strain at the outer surface at the 25 stations + (Fig. 17), and the dominant strain frequency 8.25 m from the lower end, 1.00 Hz (Fig. 18). + Thorsen et al.'s model: 99.6 % of the measured largest r.m.s. strain (their text), 1.02 Hz. + +### Heave-induced VIV (Thorsen et al. 2017, Sec. 5.2) + +- **Top motion:** the measured x and z motion of the upper end (Fig. 19, top panel), fitted with + sinusoids of the period the text gives, 5.96 s: x amplitude 0.0485 m, z amplitude 0.1305 m, x + lagging z by 83°; the residuals of the fits are 3 and 7 mm, about the width of the plotted + lines. The motion is prescribed about the static position, ramped in over two periods, in still + water. Thorsen et al. prescribe the measured motion itself; Wang et al. drove the top along + trajectories they computed for pure heave of the full-length riser. +- **Run:** 200 s, statistics over t > 40 s (frequency resolution 0.0063 Hz). +- **Processing, as Wang et al. (2014, Sec. 3.1) process the measurement:** the cross-flow strain + band-passed from 4 times the motion frequency (0.67 Hz) to 50 Hz. +- **Measured:** the r.m.s. cross-flow strain at the 25 stations (Fig. 22; the largest, 5.96e-5, + at s 2.84 m); the dominant frequency 8.25 m from the lower end "close to 1 Hz" (Fig. 23 and + text). Thorsen et al.'s model: 6 % above the measured largest (their text), also close to 1 Hz. +- **`VIV FRAME`:** without the row the synchronisation phase reads the node's velocity across the + relative flow, as the published model does. A row with `Tf` > 0 takes the node's velocity less + its low-pass filtered value, so that the slow motion counts as flow; the runs at `Tf` 0.35, + 0.5, 0.75 and 1 s, and at 0.5 s with half the time step, measure how the result depends on it. + +### Analysis (`wang_scr_viv.py`) + +- The section axis x of a line not restrained in torsion starts at End A as global +z projected + normal to the line and is carried along it, so `CurvX` is the in-plane (catenary) curvature + and `CurvY` the cross-flow one; the script checks this on their static means. Strain = κ D/2, + the outer-surface strain of Figs. 17 and 22; arc length s from the lower end. +- The r.m.s. strain is compared with the measured values at the stations (linear interpolation + between nodes); the ratio is CableDyn over measured, and the r.m.s. log error + √(mean (ln ratio)²). The lower half of the span is stations 1–13 (s < 11.855 m), the upper half + stations 14–25. Thorsen et al.'s simulated line is scored the same way. +- The dominant frequency is the peak of the Hann-windowed spectrum of the strain at the node + nearest 8.25 m. In heave, the shares of that spectrum in 0.80–0.95 Hz and 0.95–1.10 Hz tell the + two response branches apart. + +### Data + +`extract_thorsen2017.py` reads Thorsen et al.'s PDF (not distributed; PyMuPDF, NumPy and Pillow): + +- `thorsen2017_fig17.csv`, `thorsen2017_fig22.csv`: the measured points and Thorsen et al.'s + simulated line of Figs. 17 and 22, read from the vector graphics. The tick labels are glyph + outlines, so the axes are calibrated on the tick marks. As a check, the simulated line peaks at + 99.6 % (Fig. 17) and 105.6 % (Fig. 22) of the measured largest value, where the text gives + 99.6 % and 6 % too high. +- `thorsen2017_fig19_top.csv`, `thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json`: the top motion of Fig. 19, a raster + image, traced by colour (742 and 738 pixel columns over t 30–50 s), with the axis calibrated on + the dotted grid lines, and the fitted sinusoids. + +The data are digitised from the article; its figures are not reproduced. ## Reproduce From the repository root, with `path/to/cabledyn.exe` the release executable or a local build: ```powershell -python validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_uniform_current.py ` - path/to/cabledyn.exe validation/experiments/wang_scr/work ` +python validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_viv.py ` + path/to/cabledyn.exe validation/experiments/wang_scr/work --jobs 11 ` --summary validation/experiments/wang_scr ``` -`--segments` and `--dt` change the mesh and the time step. +The default is the committed record: the 11 runs of the tables below, about 5 minutes with 11 +parallel runs on a 24-core workstation. Run into a new work directory with the executable of +`summary.json`, it reproduces `response_comparison.csv` and `summary.json` byte for byte. +`--runs` selects runs by name (a comma list: `current`, `current_dt2`, `current_n400`, `heave`, +`heave_dt2`, `heave_n400`, `heave_tf0.35`, `heave_tf0.5`, `heave_tf0.75`, `heave_tf1`, +`heave_tf0.5_dt2`). A run whose folder holds the same input files and executable is not +repeated; `--keep` keeps the output tables (100–400 MB a run). ## Results -| | CableDyn | Measured | Thorsen et al. (2017) | Davies et al. (2026) | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Dominant cross-flow strain frequency, 8.25 m from the lower end | **0.992 Hz** (±0.008) | 1.00 Hz | 1.02 Hz | 1.04 Hz | -| Maximum r.m.s. strain / measured maximum | **1.073** | 1 | 0.996 | - | -| Mean ratio at the 25 stations | 1.036 | 1 | - | - | -| r.m.s. peaks along the span | 7 | 6 | 7 | - | - -- **Frequency:** within the 0.008 Hz resolution of the measured value. -- **Strain magnitude:** the largest r.m.s. strain is 7 % above the measured largest, and the mean - over the stations 4 % above. -- **Spatial pattern:** the predicted response has one r.m.s. peak more along the span than the test - (7 against 6), as in Thorsen et al. (2017). So the peaks and troughs fall at different stations, - and the station-by-station ratio scatters (`rms_strain_comparison.csv`, r.m.s. log error 0.34). -- **Convergence:** 400 elements and half the time step change the maximum ratio by 0.2 % and 0.1 % - and leave the frequency unchanged (`provenance.json`). +`response_comparison.csv` holds the r.m.s. strain of every run, and of Thorsen et al.'s line, at +the 25 stations; `summary.json` the statistics, the top motion and the SHA-256 of the +executable; `provenance.json` the sources and the build. + +### Uniform current (L3-W) + +| | Largest r.m.s. strain / measured largest | Station mean ratio | r.m.s. log error | Lower / upper half mean ratio | f at 8.25 m | r.m.s. peaks along the span | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Measured | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 / 1 | 1.00 Hz | 6 | +| CableDyn | **1.073** (s 14.0 m) | 1.036 | 0.338 | 0.947 / 1.133 | **0.992 Hz** (±0.008) | 7 | +| Thorsen et al. (2017) | 0.996 (s 14.1 m) | 0.970 | 0.360 | 0.879 / 1.068 | 1.02 Hz | 7 | + +- **Frequency:** within the 0.008 Hz resolution of the measured value; Thorsen et al.'s model is + 0.02 Hz above it. +- **Strain magnitude:** the largest r.m.s. strain is 7.3 % above the measured largest, and the + station mean 3.6 % above; Thorsen et al.'s are 0.4 % and 3.0 % below. +- **Spatial pattern:** CableDyn and Thorsen et al.'s model have one r.m.s. peak more along the + span than the test (7 against 6), so the peaks and troughs fall at different stations and the + station ratios scatter (0.41–1.71; Thorsen et al.'s 0.34–1.61). Station by station CableDyn's + r.m.s. strain is 1.07 times Thorsen et al.'s on average (0.87–1.20). + +### Heave-induced VIV (L3-Wh) + +The primary result is the run without `VIV FRAME`, the published model's phase input: + +| | Largest r.m.s. strain / measured largest | Station mean ratio | r.m.s. log error | Lower / upper half mean ratio | f at 8.25 m | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Measured | 1 (s 2.84 m) | 1 | 0 | 1 / 1 | close to 1 Hz | +| CableDyn, no `VIV FRAME` | **1.208** (s 7.2 m) | 1.334 | 0.460 | 1.710 / 0.927 | **1.019 Hz** | +| Thorsen et al. (2017) | 1.056 (s 8.2 m) | 1.087 | 0.406 | 1.438 / 0.708 | close to 1 Hz | + +- **Frequency:** 1.019 Hz; 61 % of the band-passed spectrum at 8.25 m lies in 0.95–1.10 Hz and + 1 % in 0.80–0.95 Hz. +- **Strain magnitude:** the largest r.m.s. strain is 20.8 % above the measured largest, at s + 7.2 m instead of 2.84 m; Thorsen et al.'s is 5.6 % above, at s 8.2 m. +- **The lower half reads high:** over stations 1–13 the strain is 1.71 times the measured on + average, over stations 14–25 0.93 times. Thorsen et al. report the same pattern, "over-predicted + for the lower part and under-predicted for the upper half"; their line gives 1.44 and 0.71. + Station 1 (s 1.04 m, next to the lower joint, measured 0.57e-5) contributes most: 5.08 times + the measured value (Thorsen et al. 3.10); without it the lower-half means are 1.43 and 1.30. + Over the upper half CableDyn is closer to the measurement than Thorsen et al.'s model (0.93 + against 0.71). + +#### Sensitivity to the `VIV FRAME` filter time + +| `Tf` (s) | dt (s) | Largest r.m.s. strain / measured largest | Station mean ratio | Lower / upper half mean ratio | f at 8.25 m (Hz) | Spectral share 0.80–0.95 / 0.95–1.10 Hz | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| none | 0.005 | 1.208 | 1.334 | 1.710 / 0.927 | 1.019 | 0.01 / 0.61 | +| 0.35 | 0.005 | 1.128 | 1.279 | 1.667 / 0.860 | 1.012 | 0.17 / 0.52 | +| 0.5 | 0.005 | 1.069 | 1.219 | 1.584 / 0.824 | 1.019 | 0.17 / 0.52 | +| 0.5 | 0.0025 | 0.972 | 1.107 | 1.454 / 0.731 | 0.894 | 0.59 / 0.22 | +| 0.75 | 0.005 | 0.967 | 1.029 | 1.400 / 0.628 | 0.881 | 0.69 / 0.14 | +| 1.0 | 0.005 | 0.958 | 1.009 | 1.390 / 0.596 | 0.881 | 0.71 / 0.12 | + +- **Two branches:** `Tf` ≤ 0.5 s at dt 0.005 s keeps the response at 1.01–1.02 Hz with the largest + strain 1.07–1.21 times the measured; `Tf` ≥ 0.75 s moves it to 0.88 Hz, the largest strain + 0.96–0.97 times the measured, at s 4.4 m, and the station mean to 1.01–1.03. At `Tf` 0.5 s, + halving the time step moves the response from the first branch to the second (largest strain + 1.069 to 0.972, f 1.019 to 0.894 Hz). +- **On the lower branch the strain distribution departs further from the measured one:** the + r.m.s. log error rises from 0.460 to 0.49–0.52 and the upper-half mean falls to 0.60–0.63, so + the station mean near 1 comes from a high lower half and a low upper half. +- **Why no `Tf` separates the scales:** the first-order filter keeps the fraction + ωTf/√(1 + (ωTf)²) of the VIV velocity in the phase input and leaves the same fraction of the + motion's velocity, at the motion frequency, in it. At the VIV frequency (1.02 Hz) and the heave + frequency (0.168 Hz): + + | `Tf` (s) | VIV velocity kept | Heave velocity left in the phase input | + | --- | --- | --- | + | 0.35 | 0.913 | 0.346 | + | 0.5 | 0.955 | 0.466 | + | 0.75 | 0.979 | 0.620 | + | 1.0 | 0.988 | 0.726 | + + Keeping 95 % of the VIV velocity while leaving at most 10 % of the motion's needs a motion + period of at least about 30 VIV periods; here it is about 6. Every `Tf` that keeps the VIV + velocity leaves 35–73 % of the heave velocity in the phase input, against 100 % without the row. + +### Convergence + +Re-run on this build (`summary.json`, runs `*_dt2` and `*_n400`): + +- **Uniform current:** half the time step and 400 elements change the largest r.m.s. strain by + +0.13 % and +0.24 %, the station mean by at most 0.05 %, and leave the frequency and the number + of peaks unchanged. +- **Heave, no `VIV FRAME`:** half the time step and 400 elements change the largest r.m.s. + strain by −1.0 % and −0.7 %, the station mean by −2.9 % and −2.3 %, the upper-half mean by + −5.8 % and −4.2 %, and leave the frequency (1.019 Hz) and the branch unchanged. +- **Heave with `VIV FRAME` `Tf` 0.5 s:** not converged in the time step; it changes branch (above). + +## Limitations + +- The heave case tests the model in a regime where its phase input is not defined uniquely: the + published model reads the node's velocity in the earth frame, and a filtered frame cannot + separate a motion only about 6 VIV periods long. Over the runs here the largest strain moves + by up to 21 % and the frequency by up to 14 % with that choice. +- The cause of the lower-half excess in heave is not identified. It is larger than in Thorsen et + al.'s model; the depth of the top joint, the seabed contact and the static procedure (Thorsen + et al. reach the static shape by a prescribed top displacement) differ from theirs or are + assumed. +- The top motion is a two-sinusoid fit to a raster figure; the measured motion's higher + harmonics (residual r.m.s. 3–7 mm, about the plotted line width) are not reproduced. +- Thorsen et al. do not state which case of the Wang et al. (2014) test matrix their heave case + is; the comparison uses the top motion and strains they plot. +- The measured strains were taken at a diameter of 19.5 mm and scaled to the outer surface by + Thorsen et al.; the uncertainties of the measurements are not published. diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/extract_thorsen2017.py b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/extract_thorsen2017.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4c36d5b --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/extract_thorsen2017.py @@ -0,0 +1,219 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""Read the Wang et al. (2014) riser data of Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2017) from the article's PDF. + +The PDF is not distributed; this script documents how the committed CSV and JSON files were read +from it (PyMuPDF, NumPy and Pillow): + +- Fig. 17 (uniform current, PDF page 14) and Fig. 22 (heave-induced VIV, PDF page 16), vector + graphics: the measured r.m.s. dynamic cross-flow strains (4 x 4 pt stroked squares, the legend + square removed) and the simulated line of Thorsen et al. (two polylines of 200-300 straight + segments each, joined at s 9.5 m; their vertices). + The tick labels are glyph outlines, not text, so the axes are calibrated on the tick marks: + x 0, 5, ..., 25 m; y 0, 1, ..., 6 x 1e-5 (Fig. 17) and 0, 2, ..., 8 x 1e-5 (Fig. 22). + -> thorsen2017_fig17.csv, thorsen2017_fig22.csv (series measured or thorsen2017) +- Fig. 19 top panel (PDF page 15), a raster image: the measured x (red) and z (blue) + displacement of the riser's upper end, t 30-50 s. The panel's frame is found from its dark + pixels, the time axis spans the frame, the displacement axis is calibrated on the dotted grid + lines at -0.1, 0 and 0.1 m, and each colour gives one median row per pixel column. A sinusoid + of the period the text gives (5.96 s) is fitted to each component by least squares. + -> thorsen2017_fig19_top.csv, thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json + + python extract_thorsen2017.py THORSEN2017.pdf [--check fig19_check.png] + +Source: M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2017), Non-linear time domain analysis of +cross-flow vortex-induced vibrations, Marine Structures 51, 134-151, +https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2016.10.007 +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import csv +import io +import json +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np +import pymupdf +from PIL import Image + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +PERIOD = 5.96 # s, the top motion period of Sec. 5.2 + + +def strain_figure(page, y_top: float, name: str) -> None: + """Measured squares and the simulated line of an r.m.s. strain figure in the lower part of + a page; y_top is the strain at the highest tick mark.""" + h = page.rect.height + dr = [g for g in page.get_drawings() if g["rect"].y0 > 0.6 * h] + strokes = [g for g in dr if g["type"] == "s"] + frame = max( + (g for g in strokes if len(g["items"]) == 2), key=lambda g: g["rect"].width + )["rect"] + xt = sorted( + { + round(g["rect"].x0, 2) + for g in strokes + if g["rect"].width < 0.1 + and 1.5 < g["rect"].height < 2.5 + and abs(g["rect"].y1 - frame.y1) < 3 + } + ) + yt = sorted( + { + round(g["rect"].y0, 2) + for g in strokes + if g["rect"].height < 0.1 + and 1.5 < g["rect"].width < 2.5 + and abs(g["rect"].x0 - frame.x0) < 3 + }, + reverse=True, + ) + assert len(xt) == 6, xt + assert len(yt) >= 5, yt + + def fx(x: float) -> float: + return (x - xt[0]) / (xt[-1] - xt[0]) * 25.0 + + def fy(y: float) -> float: + return (yt[0] - y) / (yt[0] - yt[-1]) * y_top + + squares = [ + g["rect"] + for g in strokes + if abs(g["rect"].width - 4.0) < 0.4 and abs(g["rect"].height - 4.0) < 0.4 + ] + # the legend square, in the upper right corner of the frame + squares = [ + r + for r in squares + if not ( + r.x0 > frame.x0 + 0.7 * frame.width and r.y1 < frame.y0 + 0.3 * frame.height + ) + ] + measured = sorted((fx((r.x0 + r.x1) / 2), fy((r.y0 + r.y1) / 2)) for r in squares) + # the simulated line is drawn as two polylines of straight segments, joined at x 254.7 pt + pts = set() + for line in strokes: + if len(line["items"]) >= 20 and all(it[0] == "l" for it in line["items"]): + for it in line["items"]: + pts.update(((it[1].x, it[1].y), (it[2].x, it[2].y))) + sim = sorted((fx(x), fy(y)) for x, y in pts) + with open(HERE / name, "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + w = csv.writer(fh, lineterminator="\n") + w.writerow(["series", "s_m", "rms_strain"]) + for series, data in (("measured", measured), ("thorsen2017", sim)): + w.writerows((series, round(a, 4), f"{b:.4e}") for a, b in data) + peak = max(measured, key=lambda p: p[1]) + print( + f"{name}: {len(measured)} measured points, max {peak[1]:.3e} at s {peak[0]:.2f} m; " + f"simulated line {len(sim)} points, max {max(v for _, v in sim):.3e} " + f"({100 * max(v for _, v in sim) / peak[1]:.1f} % of the measured max)" + ) + + +def top_motion(doc, check: Path | None) -> None: + page = doc[14] + big = max(page.get_image_info(xrefs=True), key=lambda i: i["width"] * i["height"]) + img = Image.open(io.BytesIO(doc.extract_image(big["xref"])["image"])).convert("RGB") + a = np.asarray(img).astype(int) + r, g, b = a[..., 0], a[..., 1], a[..., 2] + red = (r > 180) & (g < 110) & (b < 110) + blue = (b > 180) & (r < 110) & (g < 140) + dark = (r < 90) & (g < 90) & (b < 90) + # the top panel lies above the strain contour plot: the first row where coloured pixels + # fill more than 30 % of the width + colour = (np.abs(r - g) > 60) | (np.abs(g - b) > 60) | (np.abs(r - b) > 60) + top_end = int(np.flatnonzero(colour.mean(axis=1) > 0.3)[0]) - 8 + red[top_end:] = False + blue[top_end:] = False + rows = np.flatnonzero(red.any(axis=1)) + r0, r1 = rows.min(), rows.max() + # the panel frame: dark columns with long vertical runs over the red rows + band = dark[max(0, r0 - 40) : r1 + 40] + cand = np.flatnonzero(band.sum(axis=0) > 0.6 * band.shape[0]) + x0, x1 = cand.min(), cand.max() + hor = np.flatnonzero(dark[:, x0:x1].sum(axis=1) > 0.6 * (x1 - x0)) + hor = hor[(hor > r0 - 60) & (hor < r1 + 60)] + y_top, y_bot = hor.min(), hor.max() + # dotted grid lines: rows inside the frame with many dark pixels + darkish = (r < 140) & (g < 140) & (b < 140) & ~red & ~blue + inner = darkish[y_top + 4 : y_bot - 3, x0 + 4 : x1 - 3].sum(axis=1) + grid = np.flatnonzero(inner > 0.04 * (x1 - x0)) + y_top + 4 + groups = np.split(grid, np.flatnonzero(np.diff(grid) > 2) + 1) + gy = sorted(float(gr.mean()) for gr in groups if gr.size) + assert len(gy) == 3, gy # 0.1, 0 and -0.1 m from the top + + def disp(row: float) -> float: + return 0.1 - (row - gy[0]) / (gy[2] - gy[0]) * 0.2 + + def time(col: int) -> float: + return 30.0 + (col - x0) / (x1 - x0) * 20.0 + + w = 2 * np.pi / PERIOD + fit, traces = {}, {} + for name, mask in (("x", red), ("z", blue)): + cols, vals = [], [] + for c in range(x0 + 2, x1 - 1): + rr = np.flatnonzero(mask[y_top:y_bot, c]) + if rr.size: + cols.append(time(c)) + vals.append(disp(y_top + float(np.median(rr)))) + t, y = np.array(cols), np.array(vals) + basis = np.column_stack([np.sin(w * t), np.cos(w * t), np.ones_like(t)]) + coef, *_ = np.linalg.lstsq(basis, y, rcond=None) + resid = y - basis @ coef + fit[name] = { + "amp_m": float(np.hypot(coef[0], coef[1])), + "phase_rad": float(np.arctan2(coef[1], coef[0])), + "mean_m": float(coef[2]), + "rms_resid_m": float(resid.std()), + "n": int(t.size), + } + traces[name] = (t, y) + print( + f"{name}: amplitude {fit[name]['amp_m']:.4f} m, phase " + f"{np.degrees(fit[name]['phase_rad']):.2f} deg (A sin(w t + phase) + mean), " + f"residual r.m.s. {resid.std():.4f} m over {t.size} columns" + ) + (HERE / "thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json").write_text( + json.dumps({**fit, "period_s": PERIOD}, indent=1) + "\n", + encoding="utf-8", + newline="\n", + ) + with open( + HERE / "thorsen2017_fig19_top.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8" + ) as fh: + fh.write("component,t_s,disp_m\n") + for name, (t, y) in traces.items(): + fh.writelines( + f"{name},{tt:.4f},{yy:.5f}\n" for tt, yy in zip(t, y, strict=True) + ) + if check is not None: # the fitted sinusoids drawn over the image + chk = img.copy() + px = chk.load() + for v in fit.values(): + for c in range(x0, x1): + yy = v["amp_m"] * np.sin(w * time(c) + v["phase_rad"]) + v["mean_m"] + row = round(gy[0] + (0.1 - yy) / 0.2 * (gy[2] - gy[0])) + if 0 <= row < chk.height: + px[c, row] = (0, 0, 0) + box = (max(0, x0 - 60), max(0, y_top - 20), min(chk.width, x1 + 20), y_bot + 40) + chk.crop(box).save(check) + + +def main() -> None: + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) + ap.add_argument("pdf") + ap.add_argument("--check", type=Path, default=None, help="PNG of the Fig. 19 fit") + a = ap.parse_args() + doc = pymupdf.open(a.pdf) + strain_figure(doc[13], 6.0e-5, "thorsen2017_fig17.csv") + strain_figure(doc[15], 8.0e-5, "thorsen2017_fig22.csv") + top_motion(doc, a.check) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/measured_rms_strain.csv b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/measured_rms_strain.csv deleted file mode 100644 index 6e123aa..0000000 --- a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/measured_rms_strain.csv +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -s_m,rms_strain -1.044,4.5870e-05 -1.9427,3.5715e-05 -2.8415,3.9650e-05 -3.7493,5.3852e-05 -4.6479,4.5683e-05 -5.5467,2.5858e-05 -6.4454,2.9980e-05 -7.3441,4.7144e-05 -8.2428,5.1266e-05 -9.1416,3.9199e-05 -10.0493,2.9081e-05 -10.9479,4.0136e-05 -11.8468,4.8156e-05 -12.7454,4.5607e-05 -13.6441,3.3653e-05 -14.5428,3.3615e-05 -15.4416,4.0436e-05 -16.3494,4.2572e-05 -17.2481,3.9012e-05 -18.1467,2.5709e-05 -19.0456,2.8369e-05 -19.9442,3.7176e-05 -20.8429,3.3653e-05 -21.7416,2.8107e-05 -22.6495,2.2223e-05 diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/provenance.json b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/provenance.json index e2f3ebd..a32d20a 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/provenance.json +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/provenance.json @@ -1,10 +1,18 @@ { - "source": "Wang, Fu, Baarholm, Wu & Larsen (2014), Marine Structures 39, 131-156 (the model riser, Table 2); Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2017), Marine Structures 51, 134-151 (Table 1, Sec. 5.1, Figs. 17-18)", + "source": "Wang, Fu, Baarholm, Wu & Larsen (2014), Fatigue damage of a steel catenary riser from vortex-induced vibration caused by vessel motions, Marine Structures 39, 131-156 (Table 2, the model riser; Sec. 3.1, the band-pass of the measured strain); Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2017), Non-linear time domain analysis of cross-flow vortex-induced vibrations, Marine Structures 51, 134-151 (Table 1; Secs. 5.1 and 5.2; Figs. 17, 18, 19, 22 and 23)", "doi": ["10.1016/j.marstruc.2014.07.002", "10.1016/j.marstruc.2016.10.007"], - "data_used": "the model riser properties; the 25 measured r.m.s. dynamic cross-flow strains of Fig. 17 (read from the vector figure, axes calibrated on its tick marks; the simulated maximum of the same figure reads 99.6 % of the measured one, as the text states); the measured dominant frequency 1.00 Hz 8.25 m from the lower end", - "coefficients": "Thorsen et al. (2017) for this case, not tuned: Cv 0.7, f0 0.18, df 0.08 (cross-flow only), CD 1.2, CM 2", - "CableDyn_commit": "4b94321 (dev) with the mid-point VIV phase update", - "validation_date": "2026-11-16", + "bibliographic_data": "authors, titles, journal, volume, year, pages and DOI from the first page of each article's PDF (Wang et al. 2014, PDF page 1, printed page 131; Thorsen et al. 2017, PDF page 1, printed page 134)", + "pdf_sha256": { + "thorsen2017": "b0c565301a775ed157bbbb5dc89853bbc02d534e2c162555b102b12fe3471b57", + "wang2014": "87883edf10c87b004fa6af7774665683cd252d391925ab4658dd408034fe7644" + }, + "data_used": "riser properties (Thorsen et al. 2017, Table 1; Wang et al. 2014, Table 2, which gives EA 6.67e5 N against Thorsen et al.'s 6.66e5 N); seabed stiffness and friction, time step and coefficient sets (Thorsen et al. 2017, Secs. 5.1 and 5.2); the 25 measured r.m.s. dynamic cross-flow strains and Thorsen et al.'s simulated line in uniform current (Fig. 17, PDF page 14) and in heave (Fig. 22, PDF page 16); the measured dominant frequency 8.25 m from the lower end, 1.00 Hz in current (Fig. 18) and close to 1 Hz in heave (Fig. 23 and text); the measured top motion in heave (Fig. 19 top panel, PDF page 15) and its period 5.96 s (text); the band-pass from 4 times the motion frequency to 50 Hz (Wang et al. 2014, Sec. 3.1)", + "extraction": "extract_thorsen2017.py: Figs. 17 and 22 are vector graphics; the axes are calibrated on the tick marks (the tick labels are glyph outlines), the measured points are the 4 x 4 pt stroked squares (legend square removed), Thorsen et al.'s line the vertices of its two polylines; as a check the line peaks at 99.6 % (Fig. 17) and 105.6 % (Fig. 22) of the measured largest value, where the text gives 99.6 % and 6 % too high. Fig. 19 is a raster image: the top panel's frame from its dark pixels, the time axis 30-50 s across it, the displacement axis on the dotted grid lines at -0.1, 0 and 0.1 m; the red (x) and blue (z) traces as one median row per pixel column (742 and 738 columns); sinusoids of period 5.96 s fitted by least squares: x 0.0485 m, z 0.1305 m, x lagging z by 83.3 deg, residual r.m.s. 3.3 and 7.1 mm", + "assumptions": "the top joint 0.5 m below the surface in 9.5 m of water (not given); the heave top motion as the two fitted sinusoids about the static position (the fitted means, 4.8 and 1.6 mm, dropped), ramped in over two periods with a half-cosine; the static shape from CableDyn's static solve between the two joints (Thorsen et al. reach it by a prescribed top displacement)", + "coefficients": "Thorsen et al. (2017), not tuned: uniform current Cv 0.7 (Re about 3000), heave Cv 0.8 (Re about 4000); f0 0.18, df 0.08, cross-flow only; CD 1.2, CM 2 (Ca 1)", + "processing": "cross-flow curvature CurvY at every node (the script checks that CurvX carries the static catenary curvature); strain = kappa D/2; current: r.m.s. of the strain less its mean over t > 30 s of 150 s; heave: the strain band-passed (FFT) from 4/5.96 Hz to 50 Hz over t > 40 s of 200 s; station values by linear interpolation along the arc length from the lower end; dominant frequency from the Hann-windowed spectrum at the node nearest 8.25 m; lower half stations 1-13 (s < 11.855 m)", + "CableDyn_commit": "dca9e29 (dev)", + "validation_date": "2026-11-17", "executable_name": "cabledyn.exe", "executable_sha256": "see summary.json", "compiler": "GNU Fortran 16.2.0", @@ -12,8 +20,5 @@ "platform": "Windows 11 x86-64", "segments": 200, "dt_s": 0.005, - "sensitivity": { - "segments_400": {"max_ratio": 1.0759, "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.0365, "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.9917}, - "dt_0p0025": {"max_ratio": 1.0747, "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.0365, "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.9917} - } + "reproduction": "the default command, run into a new work directory with the executable of summary.json, reproduces response_comparison.csv and summary.json byte for byte; the convergence runs (*_dt2, *_n400) and the VIV FRAME sensitivity runs (heave_tf*) are part of the default and of summary.json" } diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/response_comparison.csv b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/response_comparison.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cd95da4 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/response_comparison.csv @@ -0,0 +1,276 @@ +run,part,segments,dt_s,viv_frame_Tf_s,station,s_m,measured_rms_strain,cabledyn_rms_strain,cabledyn_ratio,thorsen2017_rms_strain,thorsen2017_ratio +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,1,1.0440,4.5870e-05,1.8728e-05,0.4083,1.5790e-05,0.3442 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,2,1.9427,3.5715e-05,4.0661e-05,1.1385,4.6801e-05,1.3104 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,3,2.8415,3.9650e-05,3.2307e-05,0.8148,2.6955e-05,0.6798 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,4,3.7493,5.3852e-05,4.7825e-05,0.8881,4.3682e-05,0.8111 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,5,4.6479,4.5683e-05,3.3000e-05,0.7224,3.3051e-05,0.7235 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,6,5.5467,2.5858e-05,1.8539e-05,0.7170,1.6756e-05,0.6480 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,7,6.4454,2.9980e-05,4.1568e-05,1.3865,3.5759e-05,1.1928 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,8,7.3441,4.7144e-05,4.9799e-05,1.0563,4.5382e-05,0.9626 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,9,8.2428,5.1266e-05,3.4437e-05,0.6717,3.3722e-05,0.6578 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,10,9.1416,3.9199e-05,2.6991e-05,0.6886,2.4669e-05,0.6293 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,11,10.0493,2.9081e-05,4.7442e-05,1.6314,4.1827e-05,1.4383 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,12,10.9479,4.0136e-05,5.3466e-05,1.3321,4.8831e-05,1.2166 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,13,11.8468,4.8156e-05,4.1015e-05,0.8517,3.9045e-05,0.8108 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,14,12.7454,4.5607e-05,4.0325e-05,0.8842,3.6560e-05,0.8016 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,15,13.6441,3.3653e-05,5.5747e-05,1.6565,5.0901e-05,1.5125 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,16,14.5428,3.3615e-05,5.4845e-05,1.6316,5.1790e-05,1.5407 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,17,15.4416,4.0436e-05,4.0492e-05,1.0014,3.9772e-05,0.9836 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,18,16.3494,4.2572e-05,3.8411e-05,0.9023,3.6785e-05,0.8641 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,19,17.2481,3.9012e-05,4.6689e-05,1.1968,4.3691e-05,1.1199 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,20,18.1467,2.5709e-05,4.3858e-05,1.7059,4.1379e-05,1.6095 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,21,19.0456,2.8369e-05,3.0204e-05,1.0647,2.9541e-05,1.0413 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,22,19.9442,3.7176e-05,2.4982e-05,0.6720,2.3998e-05,0.6455 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,23,20.8429,3.3653e-05,2.9929e-05,0.8893,2.7996e-05,0.8319 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,24,21.7416,2.8107e-05,2.9243e-05,1.0404,2.7258e-05,0.9698 +current,current,200,0.005,0.0,25,22.6495,2.2223e-05,2.1115e-05,0.9501,1.9841e-05,0.8928 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,1,1.0440,4.5870e-05,1.8801e-05,0.4099,1.5790e-05,0.3442 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,2,1.9427,3.5715e-05,4.0685e-05,1.1392,4.6801e-05,1.3104 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,3,2.8415,3.9650e-05,3.2406e-05,0.8173,2.6955e-05,0.6798 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,4,3.7493,5.3852e-05,4.7890e-05,0.8893,4.3682e-05,0.8111 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,5,4.6479,4.5683e-05,3.2991e-05,0.7222,3.3051e-05,0.7235 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,6,5.5467,2.5858e-05,1.8621e-05,0.7201,1.6756e-05,0.6480 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,7,6.4454,2.9980e-05,4.1711e-05,1.3913,3.5759e-05,1.1928 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,8,7.3441,4.7144e-05,4.9864e-05,1.0577,4.5382e-05,0.9626 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,9,8.2428,5.1266e-05,3.4385e-05,0.6707,3.3722e-05,0.6578 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,10,9.1416,3.9199e-05,2.7107e-05,0.6915,2.4669e-05,0.6293 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,11,10.0493,2.9081e-05,4.7605e-05,1.6370,4.1827e-05,1.4383 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,12,10.9479,4.0136e-05,5.3489e-05,1.3327,4.8831e-05,1.2166 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,13,11.8468,4.8156e-05,4.0924e-05,0.8498,3.9045e-05,0.8108 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,14,12.7454,4.5607e-05,4.0433e-05,0.8865,3.6560e-05,0.8016 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,15,13.6441,3.3653e-05,5.5877e-05,1.6604,5.0901e-05,1.5125 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,16,14.5428,3.3615e-05,5.4804e-05,1.6304,5.1790e-05,1.5407 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,17,15.4416,4.0436e-05,4.0372e-05,0.9984,3.9772e-05,0.9836 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,18,16.3494,4.2572e-05,3.8461e-05,0.9034,3.6785e-05,0.8641 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,19,17.2481,3.9012e-05,4.6728e-05,1.1978,4.3691e-05,1.1199 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,20,18.1467,2.5709e-05,4.3777e-05,1.7028,4.1379e-05,1.6095 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,21,19.0456,2.8369e-05,3.0061e-05,1.0596,2.9541e-05,1.0413 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,22,19.9442,3.7176e-05,2.4976e-05,0.6718,2.3998e-05,0.6455 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,23,20.8429,3.3653e-05,2.9908e-05,0.8887,2.7996e-05,0.8319 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,24,21.7416,2.8107e-05,2.9163e-05,1.0376,2.7258e-05,0.9698 +current_dt2,current,200,0.0025,0.0,25,22.6495,2.2223e-05,2.1029e-05,0.9463,1.9841e-05,0.8928 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,1,1.0440,4.5870e-05,1.8567e-05,0.4048,1.5790e-05,0.3442 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,2,1.9427,3.5715e-05,4.0523e-05,1.1346,4.6801e-05,1.3104 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,3,2.8415,3.9650e-05,3.2343e-05,0.8157,2.6955e-05,0.6798 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,4,3.7493,5.3852e-05,4.7953e-05,0.8905,4.3682e-05,0.8111 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,5,4.6479,4.5683e-05,3.3026e-05,0.7229,3.3051e-05,0.7235 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,6,5.5467,2.5858e-05,1.8413e-05,0.7121,1.6756e-05,0.6480 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,7,6.4454,2.9980e-05,4.1658e-05,1.3895,3.5759e-05,1.1928 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,8,7.3441,4.7144e-05,4.9888e-05,1.0582,4.5382e-05,0.9626 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,9,8.2428,5.1266e-05,3.4408e-05,0.6712,3.3722e-05,0.6578 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,10,9.1416,3.9199e-05,2.6883e-05,0.6858,2.4669e-05,0.6293 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,11,10.0493,2.9081e-05,4.7502e-05,1.6335,4.1827e-05,1.4383 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,12,10.9479,4.0136e-05,5.3541e-05,1.3340,4.8831e-05,1.2166 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,13,11.8468,4.8156e-05,4.0951e-05,0.8504,3.9045e-05,0.8108 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,14,12.7454,4.5607e-05,4.0330e-05,0.8843,3.6560e-05,0.8016 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,15,13.6441,3.3653e-05,5.5852e-05,1.6597,5.0901e-05,1.5125 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,16,14.5428,3.3615e-05,5.4949e-05,1.6347,5.1790e-05,1.5407 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,17,15.4416,4.0436e-05,4.0482e-05,1.0011,3.9772e-05,0.9836 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,18,16.3494,4.2572e-05,3.8419e-05,0.9024,3.6785e-05,0.8641 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,19,17.2481,3.9012e-05,4.6786e-05,1.1993,4.3691e-05,1.1199 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,20,18.1467,2.5709e-05,4.3934e-05,1.7089,4.1379e-05,1.6095 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,21,19.0456,2.8369e-05,3.0203e-05,1.0647,2.9541e-05,1.0413 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,22,19.9442,3.7176e-05,2.4984e-05,0.6720,2.3998e-05,0.6455 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,23,20.8429,3.3653e-05,2.9967e-05,0.8905,2.7996e-05,0.8319 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,24,21.7416,2.8107e-05,2.9293e-05,1.0422,2.7258e-05,0.9698 +current_n400,current,400,0.005,0.0,25,22.6495,2.2223e-05,2.1130e-05,0.9508,1.9841e-05,0.8928 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.8889e-05,5.0826,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,4.1125e-05,1.1262,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,5.2727e-05,0.8842,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.7556e-05,1.9350,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.8642e-05,1.1604,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.9077e-05,1.0249,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,6.3530e-05,1.8707,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,7.1699e-05,2.1321,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.8324e-05,1.4319,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,5.5233e-05,1.3833,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,5.8864e-05,1.5772,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,4.9345e-05,1.6356,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.3262e-05,0.9808,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,3.0015e-05,0.7700,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,3.1940e-05,0.9088,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,3.1133e-05,0.7336,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,2.8514e-05,0.7911,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.3451e-05,0.6867,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,3.2391e-05,0.8570,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,4.5077e-05,1.2425,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,4.7681e-05,1.2444,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,3.0239e-05,0.9108,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,3.2493e-05,0.9372,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,5.1923e-05,1.0470,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave,heave,200,0.005,0.0,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,4.3785e-05,0.9983,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.8324e-05,4.9831,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,4.0434e-05,1.1072,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,5.1981e-05,0.8717,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.6694e-05,1.9060,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.8294e-05,1.1535,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.8606e-05,1.0151,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,6.2041e-05,1.8269,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,7.1221e-05,2.1179,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.8037e-05,1.4248,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,5.3913e-05,1.3503,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,5.7935e-05,1.5523,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,4.8694e-05,1.6140,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.3095e-05,0.9759,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,3.0183e-05,0.7743,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,3.1497e-05,0.8962,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,3.0126e-05,0.7099,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,2.7697e-05,0.7684,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.2488e-05,0.6585,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,3.0308e-05,0.8019,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,4.1406e-05,1.1413,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,4.3337e-05,1.1310,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,2.7835e-05,0.8384,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,3.0350e-05,0.8754,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,4.7993e-05,0.9678,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.0,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,4.0325e-05,0.9194,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.7978e-05,4.9222,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,4.0261e-05,1.1025,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,5.1910e-05,0.8705,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.6931e-05,1.9140,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.8525e-05,1.1581,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.8770e-05,1.0185,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,6.2491e-05,1.8401,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,7.1382e-05,2.1227,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.8452e-05,1.4350,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,5.4435e-05,1.3634,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,5.8654e-05,1.5716,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,4.9443e-05,1.6388,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.3282e-05,0.9814,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,3.0599e-05,0.7850,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,3.2243e-05,0.9175,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,3.0632e-05,0.7218,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,2.7773e-05,0.7705,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.2853e-05,0.6692,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,3.0796e-05,0.8148,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,4.1963e-05,1.1566,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,4.3942e-05,1.1468,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,2.8749e-05,0.8659,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,3.0872e-05,0.8905,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,4.8772e-05,0.9835,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_n400,heave,400,0.005,0.0,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,4.1234e-05,0.9401,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,3.0135e-05,5.3017,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,4.1384e-05,1.1332,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,5.2827e-05,0.8859,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.8871e-05,1.9792,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.9374e-05,1.1749,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.7928e-05,1.0009,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,6.1267e-05,1.8041,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,6.5973e-05,1.9618,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.1891e-05,1.2739,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,4.7940e-05,1.2007,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,5.0917e-05,1.3643,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,4.4692e-05,1.4813,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.7529e-05,1.1067,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,3.5035e-05,0.8988,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,3.4491e-05,0.9814,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,3.3896e-05,0.7987,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,3.2582e-05,0.9039,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.8024e-05,0.8206,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,3.0609e-05,0.8098,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,3.7521e-05,1.0342,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,3.5144e-05,0.9172,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,2.1634e-05,0.6516,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,2.9349e-05,0.8465,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,4.2590e-05,0.8588,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_tf0.35,heave,200,0.005,0.35,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,3.4807e-05,0.7936,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.8314e-05,4.9814,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,3.9382e-05,1.0784,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,5.0388e-05,0.8450,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.6056e-05,1.8845,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.8135e-05,1.1503,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.6075e-05,0.9622,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,5.5818e-05,1.6436,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,6.3489e-05,1.8880,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.2463e-05,1.2880,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,4.4718e-05,1.1200,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,4.6059e-05,1.2341,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,4.2612e-05,1.4124,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.7296e-05,1.0998,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,3.4149e-05,0.8761,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,3.2373e-05,0.9211,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,3.1212e-05,0.7355,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,3.1392e-05,0.8709,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.8104e-05,0.8230,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,2.9760e-05,0.7874,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,3.5537e-05,0.9795,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,3.3631e-05,0.8777,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,2.1147e-05,0.6369,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,2.8045e-05,0.8089,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,4.0545e-05,0.8176,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_tf0.5,heave,200,0.005,0.5,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,3.3274e-05,0.7587,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.6208e-05,4.6108,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,3.6896e-05,1.0103,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,4.7654e-05,0.7992,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.1961e-05,1.7469,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.6474e-05,1.1175,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.3433e-05,0.9070,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,4.5309e-05,1.3342,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,5.5610e-05,1.6537,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.1002e-05,1.2521,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,3.6181e-05,0.9062,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,2.9588e-05,0.7928,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,3.2550e-05,1.0789,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.3666e-05,0.9927,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,2.8412e-05,0.7289,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,2.2875e-05,0.6509,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,2.2083e-05,0.5204,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,2.2390e-05,0.6212,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.2992e-05,0.6733,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,2.5027e-05,0.6622,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,2.5990e-05,0.7164,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,2.2860e-05,0.5966,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,1.5301e-05,0.4609,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,2.3340e-05,0.6732,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,3.2119e-05,0.6477,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_tf0.75,heave,200,0.005,0.75,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,2.5533e-05,0.5822,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.6051e-05,4.5832,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,3.6716e-05,1.0054,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,4.7545e-05,0.7973,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.1417e-05,1.7286,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.6022e-05,1.1085,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.3427e-05,0.9069,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,4.6076e-05,1.3568,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,5.5635e-05,1.6544,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.0118e-05,1.2304,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,3.6443e-05,0.9128,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,3.0689e-05,0.8223,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,3.1236e-05,1.0353,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.1528e-05,0.9297,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,2.7338e-05,0.7013,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,2.1857e-05,0.6219,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,2.0210e-05,0.4762,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,2.0127e-05,0.5584,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.0989e-05,0.6146,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,2.3243e-05,0.6149,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,2.4001e-05,0.6615,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,2.1390e-05,0.5582,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,1.4975e-05,0.4510,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,2.3424e-05,0.6756,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,3.1818e-05,0.6416,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_tf1,heave,200,0.005,1.0,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,2.5180e-05,0.5741,3.0640e-05,0.6986 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,1,1.0440,5.6840e-06,2.6309e-05,4.6287,1.7639e-05,3.1032 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,2,1.9427,3.6518e-05,3.7033e-05,1.0141,3.6617e-05,1.0027 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,3,2.8415,5.9631e-05,4.8007e-05,0.8051,5.2956e-05,0.8881 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,4,3.7493,2.9745e-05,5.2828e-05,1.7760,5.2173e-05,1.7540 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,5,4.6479,5.0537e-05,5.6476e-05,1.1175,5.6649e-05,1.1209 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,6,5.5467,4.7884e-05,4.3849e-05,0.9157,5.6216e-05,1.1740 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,7,6.4454,3.3960e-05,4.8711e-05,1.4344,4.5610e-05,1.3431 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,8,7.3441,3.3628e-05,5.7886e-05,1.7214,5.4710e-05,1.6269 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,9,8.2428,4.0733e-05,5.1281e-05,1.2590,6.2947e-05,1.5454 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,10,9.1416,3.9927e-05,4.0614e-05,1.0172,5.3588e-05,1.3422 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,11,10.0493,3.7322e-05,3.5822e-05,0.9598,4.5091e-05,1.2082 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,12,10.9479,3.0170e-05,3.5925e-05,1.1908,4.3576e-05,1.4443 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,13,11.8468,3.3912e-05,3.6204e-05,1.0676,3.8696e-05,1.1411 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,14,12.7454,3.8980e-05,3.1080e-05,0.7973,3.4095e-05,0.8747 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,15,13.6441,3.5144e-05,2.6253e-05,0.7470,2.8714e-05,0.8170 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,16,14.5428,4.2438e-05,2.6805e-05,0.6316,2.4184e-05,0.5699 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,17,15.4416,3.6044e-05,2.7222e-05,0.7552,2.3170e-05,0.6428 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,18,16.3494,3.4149e-05,2.5587e-05,0.7493,2.2830e-05,0.6685 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,19,17.2481,3.7796e-05,2.7385e-05,0.7246,2.2792e-05,0.6030 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,20,18.1467,3.6281e-05,3.1441e-05,0.8666,2.7431e-05,0.7561 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,21,19.0456,3.8317e-05,2.8717e-05,0.7495,2.7945e-05,0.7293 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,22,19.9442,3.3202e-05,1.8691e-05,0.5630,2.0257e-05,0.6101 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,23,20.8429,3.4670e-05,2.6209e-05,0.7560,2.6075e-05,0.7521 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,24,21.7416,4.9590e-05,3.7068e-05,0.7475,3.8080e-05,0.7679 +heave_tf0.5_dt2,heave,200,0.0025,0.5,25,22.6495,4.3859e-05,2.9991e-05,0.6838,3.0640e-05,0.6986 diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/rms_strain_comparison.csv b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/rms_strain_comparison.csv deleted file mode 100644 index 8ed6894..0000000 --- a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/rms_strain_comparison.csv +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -s_m,measured_rms_strain,cabledyn_rms_strain,ratio -1.0440,4.5870e-05,1.8728e-05,0.4083 -1.9427,3.5715e-05,4.0661e-05,1.1385 -2.8415,3.9650e-05,3.2307e-05,0.8148 -3.7493,5.3852e-05,4.7825e-05,0.8881 -4.6479,4.5683e-05,3.3000e-05,0.7224 -5.5467,2.5858e-05,1.8539e-05,0.7170 -6.4454,2.9980e-05,4.1568e-05,1.3865 -7.3441,4.7144e-05,4.9799e-05,1.0563 -8.2428,5.1266e-05,3.4437e-05,0.6717 -9.1416,3.9199e-05,2.6991e-05,0.6886 -10.0493,2.9081e-05,4.7442e-05,1.6314 -10.9479,4.0136e-05,5.3466e-05,1.3321 -11.8468,4.8156e-05,4.1015e-05,0.8517 -12.7454,4.5607e-05,4.0325e-05,0.8842 -13.6441,3.3653e-05,5.5747e-05,1.6565 -14.5428,3.3615e-05,5.4845e-05,1.6316 -15.4416,4.0436e-05,4.0492e-05,1.0014 -16.3494,4.2572e-05,3.8411e-05,0.9023 -17.2481,3.9012e-05,4.6689e-05,1.1968 -18.1467,2.5709e-05,4.3858e-05,1.7059 -19.0456,2.8369e-05,3.0204e-05,1.0647 -19.9442,3.7176e-05,2.4982e-05,0.6720 -20.8429,3.3653e-05,2.9929e-05,0.8893 -21.7416,2.8107e-05,2.9243e-05,1.0404 -22.6495,2.2223e-05,2.1115e-05,0.9501 diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/summary.json b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/summary.json index 7436d15..8b57b68 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/summary.json +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/summary.json @@ -1,17 +1,313 @@ { - "segments": 200, - "dt_s": 0.005, - "analysis_window_s": [ - 30.0, - 150.0 - ], - "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00833333333332907, - "max_rms_strain": 5.7799927402857905e-05, - "measured_max_rms_strain": 5.3852e-05, - "max_ratio": 1.0733106923207663, - "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.0360992762509706, - "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.3384790204846645, - "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.9916666666661592, - "measured_dominant_frequency_hz": 1.0, - "executable_sha256": "7810cc2efd3449cceb8825d543beacadfdf6cd86253f6bad1b1a8207ad7beca9" + "current": { + "coefficients": { + "Cv": 0.7, + "f0": 0.18, + "df": 0.08, + "CD": 1.2, + "CM": 2.0 + }, + "tmax_s": 150.0, + "statistics_after_s": 30.0, + "measured_max_rms_strain": 5.3852e-05, + "measured_dominant_frequency_hz": 1.0, + "thorsen2017": { + "max_rms_strain": 5.3628e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 14.0796, + "max_ratio": 0.99584, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 0.969544, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.360103, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 0.878869, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 1.06778 + }, + "runs": { + "current": { + "role": "primary", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.0, + "max_rms_strain": 5.77999e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 13.9889, + "max_ratio": 1.07331, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.0361, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.338479, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 0.946716, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 1.13293, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.991667, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00833333, + "rms_peaks": 7, + "mean_top_tension_N": 67.7937 + }, + "current_dt2": { + "role": "convergence: half the time step", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.0, + "max_rms_strain": 5.78745e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 13.9889, + "max_ratio": 1.0747, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.0365, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.338048, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 0.948357, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 1.13198, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.991667, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00833333, + "rms_peaks": 7, + "mean_top_tension_N": 67.7942, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": 0.00129009 + }, + "current_n400": { + "role": "convergence: twice the elements", + "segments": 400, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.0, + "max_rms_strain": 5.79404e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 14.0482, + "max_ratio": 1.07592, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.03655, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.340338, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 0.946395, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 1.13421, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.23922, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.991667, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00833333, + "rms_peaks": 7, + "mean_top_tension_N": 67.7939, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": 0.00242973 + } + } + }, + "heave": { + "coefficients": { + "Cv": 0.8, + "f0": 0.18, + "df": 0.08, + "CD": 1.2, + "CM": 2.0 + }, + "tmax_s": 200.0, + "statistics_after_s": 40.0, + "measured_max_rms_strain": 5.9631e-05, + "measured_dominant_frequency_hz": 1.0, + "thorsen2017": { + "max_rms_strain": 6.2947e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 8.1971, + "max_ratio": 1.05561, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.08737, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.406399, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.438, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.707507 + }, + "runs": { + "heave": { + "role": "primary (no VIV FRAME)", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.0, + "max_rms_strain": 7.20238e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 7.23155, + "max_ratio": 1.20783, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.33409, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.459744, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.70961, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.927286, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 1.01875, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 6, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1909, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.00933546, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.611495 + }, + "heave_dt2": { + "role": "convergence: half the time step", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.0, + "max_rms_strain": 7.12927e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 7.23155, + "max_ratio": 1.19557, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.29525, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.45551, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.68451, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.873542, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 1.01875, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 6, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1788, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.0168386, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.59526, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.0101505 + }, + "heave_n400": { + "role": "convergence: twice the elements", + "segments": 400, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.0, + "max_rms_strain": 7.14995e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 7.29083, + "max_ratio": 1.19903, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.30404, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.453764, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.6876, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.888513, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.23922, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 1.01875, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 6, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1786, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.00847915, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.612012, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.0072802 + }, + "heave_tf0.35": { + "role": "VIV FRAME sensitivity", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.35, + "max_rms_strain": 6.72598e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 7.113, + "max_ratio": 1.12793, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.27936, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.443287, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.66681, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.859609, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 1.0125, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 6, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1743, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.170412, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.518878, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.0661451 + }, + "heave_tf0.5": { + "role": "VIV FRAME sensitivity", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.5, + "max_rms_strain": 6.37249e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 7.23155, + "max_ratio": 1.06865, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.21924, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.426653, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.58367, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.824439, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 1.01875, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 6, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1602, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.166241, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.523756, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.115225 + }, + "heave_tf0.75": { + "role": "VIV FRAME sensitivity", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.75, + "max_rms_strain": 5.76812e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 4.38635, + "max_ratio": 0.967302, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.02944, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.492177, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.40018, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.627803, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.88125, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 5, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1596, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.694759, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.138379, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.199138 + }, + "heave_tf1": { + "role": "VIV FRAME sensitivity", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.005, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 1.0, + "max_rms_strain": 5.71462e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 4.38635, + "max_ratio": 0.95833, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.00885, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.515722, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.39013, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.595803, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.88125, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 5, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.156, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.709745, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.116697, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.206566 + }, + "heave_tf0.5_dt2": { + "role": "VIV FRAME sensitivity, half the time step", + "segments": 200, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": 0.5, + "max_rms_strain": 5.79878e-05, + "s_of_max_m": 4.38635, + "max_ratio": 0.972444, + "mean_ratio_at_stations": 1.10714, + "rms_log_error_at_stations": 0.42963, + "mean_ratio_lower_half": 1.4544, + "mean_ratio_upper_half": 0.730944, + "frequency_station_s_m": 8.2985, + "dominant_frequency_hz": 0.89375, + "frequency_resolution_hz": 0.00625, + "rms_peaks": 6, + "mean_top_tension_N": 64.1618, + "band_hz": [ + 0.671141, + 50.0 + ], + "share_0.80-0.95_hz": 0.59208, + "share_0.95-1.10_hz": 0.217544, + "max_ratio_change_from_primary": -0.19488 + } + }, + "top_motion": { + "period_s": 5.96, + "x_amplitude_m": 0.0485065, + "z_amplitude_m": 0.130469, + "x_lag_behind_z_deg": 83.3184, + "ramp_periods": 2.0 + } + }, + "executable_sha256": "7b1bd9a903f6cbc473bbac1fddfe9370cd18e65771334faf048d255fbcc2faeb" } diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig17.csv b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig17.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1ee1c22 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig17.csv @@ -0,0 +1,522 @@ +series,s_m,rms_strain +measured,1.044,4.5870e-05 +measured,1.9427,3.5715e-05 +measured,2.8415,3.9650e-05 +measured,3.7493,5.3852e-05 +measured,4.6479,4.5683e-05 +measured,5.5467,2.5858e-05 +measured,6.4454,2.9980e-05 +measured,7.3441,4.7144e-05 +measured,8.2428,5.1266e-05 +measured,9.1416,3.9199e-05 +measured,10.0493,2.9081e-05 +measured,10.9479,4.0136e-05 +measured,11.8468,4.8156e-05 +measured,12.7454,4.5607e-05 +measured,13.6441,3.3653e-05 +measured,14.5428,3.3615e-05 +measured,15.4416,4.0436e-05 +measured,16.3494,4.2572e-05 +measured,17.2481,3.9012e-05 +measured,18.1467,2.5709e-05 +measured,19.0456,2.8369e-05 +measured,19.9442,3.7176e-05 +measured,20.8429,3.3653e-05 +measured,21.7416,2.8107e-05 +measured,22.6495,2.2223e-05 +thorsen2017,-0.0001,7.5765e-08 +thorsen2017,0.0451,3.8711e-08 +thorsen2017,0.0907,1.1335e-07 +thorsen2017,0.136,1.5097e-07 +thorsen2017,0.1814,2.2617e-07 +thorsen2017,0.2359,2.6323e-07 +thorsen2017,0.2813,3.3790e-07 +thorsen2017,0.3267,4.1310e-07 +thorsen2017,0.372,5.2589e-07 +thorsen2017,0.4265,7.1283e-07 +thorsen2017,0.4719,1.0507e-06 +thorsen2017,0.5173,1.4997e-06 +thorsen2017,0.5626,2.1374e-06 +thorsen2017,0.608,2.8867e-06 +thorsen2017,0.6626,3.7858e-06 +thorsen2017,0.708,4.7602e-06 +thorsen2017,0.7532,5.8093e-06 +thorsen2017,0.7988,6.8589e-06 +thorsen2017,0.8532,7.9085e-06 +thorsen2017,0.8986,9.1074e-06 +thorsen2017,0.944,1.0644e-05 +thorsen2017,0.9893,1.2668e-05 +thorsen2017,1.0347,1.5253e-05 +thorsen2017,1.0892,1.8401e-05 +thorsen2017,1.1346,2.1998e-05 +thorsen2017,1.1799,2.5784e-05 +thorsen2017,1.2254,2.9456e-05 +thorsen2017,1.2798,3.2904e-05 +thorsen2017,1.3252,3.6051e-05 +thorsen2017,1.3707,3.8862e-05 +thorsen2017,1.4161,4.1299e-05 +thorsen2017,1.4613,4.3434e-05 +thorsen2017,1.5159,4.5233e-05 +thorsen2017,1.5613,4.6694e-05 +thorsen2017,1.6067,4.7819e-05 +thorsen2017,1.6521,4.8643e-05 +thorsen2017,1.7065,4.9130e-05 +thorsen2017,1.7518,4.9318e-05 +thorsen2017,1.7973,4.9168e-05 +thorsen2017,1.8426,4.8681e-05 +thorsen2017,1.888,4.7894e-05 +thorsen2017,1.9425,4.6807e-05 +thorsen2017,1.9879,4.5421e-05 +thorsen2017,2.0332,4.3809e-05 +thorsen2017,2.0788,4.1935e-05 +thorsen2017,2.1331,3.9874e-05 +thorsen2017,2.1784,3.7589e-05 +thorsen2017,2.224,3.5115e-05 +thorsen2017,2.2692,3.2529e-05 +thorsen2017,2.3148,2.9906e-05 +thorsen2017,2.3692,2.7395e-05 +thorsen2017,2.4146,2.5109e-05 +thorsen2017,2.4599,2.3310e-05 +thorsen2017,2.5053,2.2149e-05 +thorsen2017,2.5599,2.1624e-05 +thorsen2017,2.6052,2.1699e-05 +thorsen2017,2.6505,2.2261e-05 +thorsen2017,2.6959,2.3161e-05 +thorsen2017,2.7413,2.4284e-05 +thorsen2017,2.7958,2.5559e-05 +thorsen2017,2.8412,2.6946e-05 +thorsen2017,2.8867,2.8370e-05 +thorsen2017,2.9319,2.9756e-05 +thorsen2017,2.9865,3.1142e-05 +thorsen2017,3.0319,3.2492e-05 +thorsen2017,3.0771,3.3766e-05 +thorsen2017,3.1227,3.5002e-05 +thorsen2017,3.168,3.6126e-05 +thorsen2017,3.2225,3.7214e-05 +thorsen2017,3.2679,3.8225e-05 +thorsen2017,3.3133,3.9125e-05 +thorsen2017,3.3587,3.9949e-05 +thorsen2017,3.4131,4.0736e-05 +thorsen2017,3.4585,4.1373e-05 +thorsen2017,3.5038,4.1973e-05 +thorsen2017,3.5493,4.2459e-05 +thorsen2017,3.6039,4.2910e-05 +thorsen2017,3.6491,4.3246e-05 +thorsen2017,3.6946,4.3510e-05 +thorsen2017,3.74,4.3659e-05 +thorsen2017,3.7854,4.3771e-05 +thorsen2017,3.8398,4.3771e-05 +thorsen2017,3.8852,4.3696e-05 +thorsen2017,3.9306,4.3547e-05 +thorsen2017,3.976,4.3359e-05 +thorsen2017,4.0305,4.3059e-05 +thorsen2017,4.0758,4.2684e-05 +thorsen2017,4.1212,4.2235e-05 +thorsen2017,4.1666,4.1710e-05 +thorsen2017,4.212,4.1149e-05 +thorsen2017,4.2664,4.0474e-05 +thorsen2017,4.3118,3.9761e-05 +thorsen2017,4.3572,3.9013e-05 +thorsen2017,4.4025,3.8150e-05 +thorsen2017,4.4572,3.7288e-05 +thorsen2017,4.5025,3.6352e-05 +thorsen2017,4.5479,3.5340e-05 +thorsen2017,4.5933,3.4328e-05 +thorsen2017,4.6387,3.3241e-05 +thorsen2017,4.6931,3.2117e-05 +thorsen2017,4.7385,3.0993e-05 +thorsen2017,4.7839,2.9831e-05 +thorsen2017,4.8293,2.8632e-05 +thorsen2017,4.8837,2.7432e-05 +thorsen2017,4.9291,2.6233e-05 +thorsen2017,4.9744,2.5034e-05 +thorsen2017,5.0199,2.3872e-05 +thorsen2017,5.0652,2.2711e-05 +thorsen2017,5.1199,2.1624e-05 +thorsen2017,5.1651,2.0574e-05 +thorsen2017,5.2104,1.9638e-05 +thorsen2017,5.256,1.8776e-05 +thorsen2017,5.3104,1.8026e-05 +thorsen2017,5.3558,1.7427e-05 +thorsen2017,5.4012,1.6977e-05 +thorsen2017,5.4466,1.6715e-05 +thorsen2017,5.4919,1.6640e-05 +thorsen2017,5.5463,1.6753e-05 +thorsen2017,5.5918,1.7052e-05 +thorsen2017,5.6371,1.7539e-05 +thorsen2017,5.6826,1.8176e-05 +thorsen2017,5.737,1.8926e-05 +thorsen2017,5.7824,1.9825e-05 +thorsen2017,5.8278,2.0799e-05 +thorsen2017,5.8731,2.1849e-05 +thorsen2017,5.9185,2.2973e-05 +thorsen2017,5.973,2.4097e-05 +thorsen2017,6.0186,2.5296e-05 +thorsen2017,6.0637,2.6495e-05 +thorsen2017,6.1093,2.7695e-05 +thorsen2017,6.1637,2.8931e-05 +thorsen2017,6.2091,3.0130e-05 +thorsen2017,6.2544,3.1292e-05 +thorsen2017,6.2999,3.2454e-05 +thorsen2017,6.3453,3.3578e-05 +thorsen2017,6.3997,3.4702e-05 +thorsen2017,6.4451,3.5752e-05 +thorsen2017,6.4905,3.6764e-05 +thorsen2017,6.5358,3.7737e-05 +thorsen2017,6.5905,3.8675e-05 +thorsen2017,6.6357,3.9537e-05 +thorsen2017,6.6811,4.0361e-05 +thorsen2017,6.7266,4.1149e-05 +thorsen2017,6.7809,4.1823e-05 +thorsen2017,6.8264,4.2498e-05 +thorsen2017,6.8718,4.3059e-05 +thorsen2017,6.9172,4.3584e-05 +thorsen2017,6.9625,4.4071e-05 +thorsen2017,7.017,4.4446e-05 +thorsen2017,7.0624,4.4783e-05 +thorsen2017,7.1078,4.5046e-05 +thorsen2017,7.1531,4.5270e-05 +thorsen2017,7.2076,4.5383e-05 +thorsen2017,7.253,4.5458e-05 +thorsen2017,7.2984,4.5458e-05 +thorsen2017,7.3438,4.5383e-05 +thorsen2017,7.3891,4.5270e-05 +thorsen2017,7.4436,4.5083e-05 +thorsen2017,7.4892,4.4820e-05 +thorsen2017,7.5345,4.4521e-05 +thorsen2017,7.5799,4.4146e-05 +thorsen2017,7.6343,4.3696e-05 +thorsen2017,7.6797,4.3209e-05 +thorsen2017,7.7249,4.2647e-05 +thorsen2017,7.7705,4.2047e-05 +thorsen2017,7.8159,4.1373e-05 +thorsen2017,7.8703,4.0699e-05 +thorsen2017,7.9157,3.9949e-05 +thorsen2017,7.9611,3.9125e-05 +thorsen2017,8.0065,3.8300e-05 +thorsen2017,8.061,3.7439e-05 +thorsen2017,8.1063,3.6539e-05 +thorsen2017,8.1517,3.5640e-05 +thorsen2017,8.1971,3.4702e-05 +thorsen2017,8.2424,3.3729e-05 +thorsen2017,8.2969,3.2791e-05 +thorsen2017,8.3424,3.1817e-05 +thorsen2017,8.3878,3.0880e-05 +thorsen2017,8.433,2.9943e-05 +thorsen2017,8.4876,2.9044e-05 +thorsen2017,8.533,2.8182e-05 +thorsen2017,8.5784,2.7358e-05 +thorsen2017,8.6238,2.6608e-05 +thorsen2017,8.6692,2.5933e-05 +thorsen2017,8.7236,2.5296e-05 +thorsen2017,8.769,2.4772e-05 +thorsen2017,8.8144,2.4359e-05 +thorsen2017,8.8597,2.4059e-05 +thorsen2017,8.9142,2.3872e-05 +thorsen2017,8.9598,2.3797e-05 +thorsen2017,9.0049,2.3835e-05 +thorsen2017,9.0505,2.4022e-05 +thorsen2017,9.0957,2.4322e-05 +thorsen2017,9.1504,2.4735e-05 +thorsen2017,9.1957,2.5296e-05 +thorsen2017,9.2411,2.5896e-05 +thorsen2017,9.2865,2.6608e-05 +thorsen2017,9.3409,2.7395e-05 +thorsen2017,9.3863,2.8257e-05 +thorsen2017,9.4316,2.9156e-05 +thorsen2017,9.4772,3.0093e-05 +thorsen2017,9.5224,3.1068e-05 +thorsen2017,9.5225,3.1068e-05 +thorsen2017,9.577,3.2080e-05 +thorsen2017,9.6223,3.3091e-05 +thorsen2017,9.6679,3.4140e-05 +thorsen2017,9.7131,3.5152e-05 +thorsen2017,9.7677,3.6164e-05 +thorsen2017,9.8131,3.7175e-05 +thorsen2017,9.8585,3.8150e-05 +thorsen2017,9.9038,3.9125e-05 +thorsen2017,9.9492,4.0024e-05 +thorsen2017,10.0037,4.0924e-05 +thorsen2017,10.0491,4.1823e-05 +thorsen2017,10.0944,4.2647e-05 +thorsen2017,10.1398,4.3434e-05 +thorsen2017,10.1943,4.4146e-05 +thorsen2017,10.2397,4.4858e-05 +thorsen2017,10.2851,4.5533e-05 +thorsen2017,10.3306,4.6132e-05 +thorsen2017,10.3849,4.6695e-05 +thorsen2017,10.4304,4.7181e-05 +thorsen2017,10.4756,4.7631e-05 +thorsen2017,10.5212,4.8007e-05 +thorsen2017,10.5666,4.8343e-05 +thorsen2017,10.621,4.8605e-05 +thorsen2017,10.6663,4.8793e-05 +thorsen2017,10.7118,4.8943e-05 +thorsen2017,10.7572,4.9056e-05 +thorsen2017,10.8117,4.9093e-05 +thorsen2017,10.857,4.9056e-05 +thorsen2017,10.9024,4.8980e-05 +thorsen2017,10.9478,4.8831e-05 +thorsen2017,10.9931,4.8643e-05 +thorsen2017,11.0476,4.8381e-05 +thorsen2017,11.093,4.8081e-05 +thorsen2017,11.1385,4.7744e-05 +thorsen2017,11.1837,4.7369e-05 +thorsen2017,11.2383,4.6919e-05 +thorsen2017,11.2837,4.6470e-05 +thorsen2017,11.3291,4.5983e-05 +thorsen2017,11.3744,4.5420e-05 +thorsen2017,11.4199,4.4858e-05 +thorsen2017,11.4743,4.4296e-05 +thorsen2017,11.5197,4.3659e-05 +thorsen2017,11.5651,4.3022e-05 +thorsen2017,11.6104,4.2385e-05 +thorsen2017,11.6649,4.1711e-05 +thorsen2017,11.7557,4.0361e-05 +thorsen2017,11.8011,3.9724e-05 +thorsen2017,11.8464,3.9050e-05 +thorsen2017,11.9011,3.8413e-05 +thorsen2017,11.9462,3.7813e-05 +thorsen2017,11.9918,3.7214e-05 +thorsen2017,12.0372,3.6689e-05 +thorsen2017,12.0917,3.6202e-05 +thorsen2017,12.137,3.5752e-05 +thorsen2017,12.1823,3.5377e-05 +thorsen2017,12.2277,3.5077e-05 +thorsen2017,12.2731,3.4853e-05 +thorsen2017,12.3276,3.4665e-05 +thorsen2017,12.373,3.4553e-05 +thorsen2017,12.4184,3.4516e-05 +thorsen2017,12.4637,3.4590e-05 +thorsen2017,12.5181,3.4702e-05 +thorsen2017,12.5636,3.4928e-05 +thorsen2017,12.6092,3.5227e-05 +thorsen2017,12.6545,3.5640e-05 +thorsen2017,12.6997,3.6089e-05 +thorsen2017,12.7542,3.6651e-05 +thorsen2017,12.7997,3.7288e-05 +thorsen2017,12.8449,3.7963e-05 +thorsen2017,12.8905,3.8712e-05 +thorsen2017,12.945,3.9500e-05 +thorsen2017,12.9904,4.0361e-05 +thorsen2017,13.0356,4.1223e-05 +thorsen2017,13.081,4.2123e-05 +thorsen2017,13.1265,4.3022e-05 +thorsen2017,13.181,4.3884e-05 +thorsen2017,13.2263,4.4746e-05 +thorsen2017,13.2717,4.5608e-05 +thorsen2017,13.3171,4.6395e-05 +thorsen2017,13.3715,4.7181e-05 +thorsen2017,13.4169,4.7931e-05 +thorsen2017,13.4625,4.8605e-05 +thorsen2017,13.5078,4.9280e-05 +thorsen2017,13.5623,4.9918e-05 +thorsen2017,13.6076,5.0480e-05 +thorsen2017,13.653,5.1004e-05 +thorsen2017,13.6984,5.1492e-05 +thorsen2017,13.7437,5.1941e-05 +thorsen2017,13.7983,5.2353e-05 +thorsen2017,13.8436,5.2690e-05 +thorsen2017,13.889,5.2953e-05 +thorsen2017,13.9344,5.3215e-05 +thorsen2017,13.9888,5.3403e-05 +thorsen2017,14.0343,5.3515e-05 +thorsen2017,14.0796,5.3628e-05 +thorsen2017,14.1705,5.3628e-05 +thorsen2017,14.2248,5.3552e-05 +thorsen2017,14.2704,5.3440e-05 +thorsen2017,14.3157,5.3253e-05 +thorsen2017,14.3611,5.3028e-05 +thorsen2017,14.4155,5.2766e-05 +thorsen2017,14.4609,5.2465e-05 +thorsen2017,14.5517,5.1717e-05 +thorsen2017,14.597,5.1266e-05 +thorsen2017,14.6515,5.0779e-05 +thorsen2017,14.6969,5.0255e-05 +thorsen2017,14.7423,4.9730e-05 +thorsen2017,14.7879,4.9130e-05 +thorsen2017,14.8421,4.8531e-05 +thorsen2017,14.8875,4.7894e-05 +thorsen2017,15.0238,4.5870e-05 +thorsen2017,15.0781,4.5158e-05 +thorsen2017,15.1236,4.4446e-05 +thorsen2017,15.169,4.3734e-05 +thorsen2017,15.2144,4.3022e-05 +thorsen2017,15.2688,4.2310e-05 +thorsen2017,15.3142,4.1635e-05 +thorsen2017,15.3596,4.0924e-05 +thorsen2017,15.405,4.0287e-05 +thorsen2017,15.4503,3.9649e-05 +thorsen2017,15.5048,3.9050e-05 +thorsen2017,15.5502,3.8450e-05 +thorsen2017,15.5956,3.7925e-05 +thorsen2017,15.641,3.7439e-05 +thorsen2017,15.6954,3.7026e-05 +thorsen2017,15.7407,3.6651e-05 +thorsen2017,15.7863,3.6314e-05 +thorsen2017,15.8317,3.6052e-05 +thorsen2017,15.8771,3.5827e-05 +thorsen2017,15.9316,3.5677e-05 +thorsen2017,15.9769,3.5602e-05 +thorsen2017,16.0221,3.5565e-05 +thorsen2017,16.0677,3.5602e-05 +thorsen2017,16.1222,3.5677e-05 +thorsen2017,16.1675,3.5827e-05 +thorsen2017,16.2129,3.6014e-05 +thorsen2017,16.2582,3.6239e-05 +thorsen2017,16.3037,3.6501e-05 +thorsen2017,16.3581,3.6839e-05 +thorsen2017,16.4035,3.7175e-05 +thorsen2017,16.4491,3.7551e-05 +thorsen2017,16.4942,3.7925e-05 +thorsen2017,16.5487,3.8338e-05 +thorsen2017,16.594,3.8750e-05 +thorsen2017,16.6397,3.9162e-05 +thorsen2017,16.685,3.9612e-05 +thorsen2017,16.7304,4.0024e-05 +thorsen2017,16.7849,4.0437e-05 +thorsen2017,16.8302,4.0849e-05 +thorsen2017,16.8755,4.1261e-05 +thorsen2017,16.921,4.1635e-05 +thorsen2017,16.9755,4.2010e-05 +thorsen2017,17.0209,4.2385e-05 +thorsen2017,17.0662,4.2684e-05 +thorsen2017,17.1115,4.2985e-05 +thorsen2017,17.166,4.3284e-05 +thorsen2017,17.2116,4.3509e-05 +thorsen2017,17.2568,4.3734e-05 +thorsen2017,17.3024,4.3921e-05 +thorsen2017,17.3477,4.4071e-05 +thorsen2017,17.402,4.4184e-05 +thorsen2017,17.4473,4.4296e-05 +thorsen2017,17.4929,4.4334e-05 +thorsen2017,17.5384,4.4371e-05 +thorsen2017,17.5928,4.4334e-05 +thorsen2017,17.6382,4.4258e-05 +thorsen2017,17.6835,4.4184e-05 +thorsen2017,17.7289,4.4071e-05 +thorsen2017,17.7742,4.3884e-05 +thorsen2017,17.8288,4.3696e-05 +thorsen2017,17.9195,4.3172e-05 +thorsen2017,17.9648,4.2872e-05 +thorsen2017,18.0193,4.2498e-05 +thorsen2017,18.0647,4.2123e-05 +thorsen2017,18.1103,4.1711e-05 +thorsen2017,18.1556,4.1298e-05 +thorsen2017,18.201,4.0811e-05 +thorsen2017,18.2554,4.0324e-05 +thorsen2017,18.3009,3.9799e-05 +thorsen2017,18.3462,3.9238e-05 +thorsen2017,18.3916,3.8675e-05 +thorsen2017,18.4462,3.8075e-05 +thorsen2017,18.4915,3.7439e-05 +thorsen2017,18.5368,3.6801e-05 +thorsen2017,18.5822,3.6164e-05 +thorsen2017,18.6276,3.5489e-05 +thorsen2017,18.6823,3.4815e-05 +thorsen2017,18.7274,3.4140e-05 +thorsen2017,18.7728,3.3466e-05 +thorsen2017,18.8184,3.2754e-05 +thorsen2017,18.8728,3.2080e-05 +thorsen2017,18.918,3.1405e-05 +thorsen2017,18.9635,3.0730e-05 +thorsen2017,19.009,3.0056e-05 +thorsen2017,19.0543,2.9419e-05 +thorsen2017,19.1087,2.8781e-05 +thorsen2017,19.1542,2.8182e-05 +thorsen2017,19.1996,2.7620e-05 +thorsen2017,19.2448,2.7058e-05 +thorsen2017,19.2994,2.6534e-05 +thorsen2017,19.3448,2.6083e-05 +thorsen2017,19.3902,2.5634e-05 +thorsen2017,19.4355,2.5259e-05 +thorsen2017,19.4808,2.4922e-05 +thorsen2017,19.5355,2.4622e-05 +thorsen2017,19.5809,2.4359e-05 +thorsen2017,19.6262,2.4172e-05 +thorsen2017,19.6717,2.4022e-05 +thorsen2017,19.7261,2.3910e-05 +thorsen2017,19.7715,2.3835e-05 +thorsen2017,19.8166,2.3835e-05 +thorsen2017,19.8622,2.3872e-05 +thorsen2017,19.9077,2.3948e-05 +thorsen2017,19.9621,2.4022e-05 +thorsen2017,20.0075,2.4172e-05 +thorsen2017,20.0529,2.4322e-05 +thorsen2017,20.0982,2.4510e-05 +thorsen2017,20.1527,2.4734e-05 +thorsen2017,20.1981,2.4960e-05 +thorsen2017,20.2436,2.5184e-05 +thorsen2017,20.289,2.5409e-05 +thorsen2017,20.3434,2.5671e-05 +thorsen2017,20.3886,2.5934e-05 +thorsen2017,20.434,2.6159e-05 +thorsen2017,20.4796,2.6421e-05 +thorsen2017,20.525,2.6646e-05 +thorsen2017,20.5794,2.6908e-05 +thorsen2017,20.6248,2.7133e-05 +thorsen2017,20.6702,2.7320e-05 +thorsen2017,20.7155,2.7545e-05 +thorsen2017,20.7699,2.7732e-05 +thorsen2017,20.8154,2.7882e-05 +thorsen2017,20.8608,2.8070e-05 +thorsen2017,20.9061,2.8182e-05 +thorsen2017,20.9515,2.8295e-05 +thorsen2017,21.006,2.8407e-05 +thorsen2017,21.0515,2.8482e-05 +thorsen2017,21.0969,2.8557e-05 +thorsen2017,21.1421,2.8594e-05 +thorsen2017,21.1967,2.8632e-05 +thorsen2017,21.2419,2.8632e-05 +thorsen2017,21.2874,2.8594e-05 +thorsen2017,21.3329,2.8557e-05 +thorsen2017,21.3783,2.8482e-05 +thorsen2017,21.4327,2.8407e-05 +thorsen2017,21.478,2.8295e-05 +thorsen2017,21.5233,2.8145e-05 +thorsen2017,21.5689,2.7995e-05 +thorsen2017,21.6233,2.7808e-05 +thorsen2017,21.6687,2.7620e-05 +thorsen2017,21.714,2.7395e-05 +thorsen2017,21.7594,2.7170e-05 +thorsen2017,21.8048,2.6908e-05 +thorsen2017,21.8591,2.6608e-05 +thorsen2017,21.9048,2.6308e-05 +thorsen2017,21.95,2.6009e-05 +thorsen2017,21.9955,2.5671e-05 +thorsen2017,22.0497,2.5334e-05 +thorsen2017,22.0951,2.4960e-05 +thorsen2017,22.1405,2.4585e-05 +thorsen2017,22.1861,2.4172e-05 +thorsen2017,22.2315,2.3797e-05 +thorsen2017,22.2859,2.3385e-05 +thorsen2017,22.3312,2.2936e-05 +thorsen2017,22.3766,2.2523e-05 +thorsen2017,22.422,2.2074e-05 +thorsen2017,22.4766,2.1624e-05 +thorsen2017,22.522,2.1174e-05 +thorsen2017,22.5672,2.0687e-05 +thorsen2017,22.6126,2.0238e-05 +thorsen2017,22.658,1.9750e-05 +thorsen2017,22.7125,1.9300e-05 +thorsen2017,22.7578,1.8813e-05 +thorsen2017,22.8032,1.8326e-05 +thorsen2017,22.8488,1.7839e-05 +thorsen2017,22.9032,1.7314e-05 +thorsen2017,22.9484,1.6790e-05 +thorsen2017,22.9938,1.6265e-05 +thorsen2017,23.0394,1.5703e-05 +thorsen2017,23.0847,1.5141e-05 +thorsen2017,23.1391,1.4504e-05 +thorsen2017,23.1846,1.3867e-05 +thorsen2017,23.23,1.3154e-05 +thorsen2017,23.2753,1.2405e-05 +thorsen2017,23.3297,1.1543e-05 +thorsen2017,23.3752,1.0644e-05 +thorsen2017,23.4206,9.5946e-06 +thorsen2017,23.4659,8.4703e-06 +thorsen2017,23.5113,7.1586e-06 +thorsen2017,23.5658,5.6970e-06 +thorsen2017,23.6113,4.0480e-06 +thorsen2017,23.6564,2.1744e-06 +thorsen2017,23.7021,3.8711e-08 diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2d2505a --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +{ + "x": { + "amp_m": 0.04850646676197546, + "phase_rad": -2.861742946927835, + "mean_m": 0.004840880575071412, + "rms_resid_m": 0.0032526093331303563, + "n": 742 + }, + "z": { + "amp_m": 0.1304688402025639, + "phase_rad": -1.4075616831041384, + "mean_m": 0.0015992444874741148, + "rms_resid_m": 0.0071182722737839176, + "n": 738 + }, + "period_s": 5.96 +} diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig19_top.csv b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig19_top.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e5f109d --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig19_top.csv @@ -0,0 +1,1481 @@ +component,t_s,disp_m +x,30.0537,-0.01515 +x,30.0805,-0.01667 +x,30.1074,-0.01818 +x,30.1342,-0.01970 +x,30.1611,-0.02121 +x,30.1879,-0.02121 +x,30.2148,-0.02424 +x,30.2416,-0.02576 +x,30.2685,-0.02576 +x,30.2953,-0.02727 +x,30.3221,-0.02879 +x,30.3490,-0.03030 +x,30.3758,-0.03030 +x,30.4027,-0.03182 +x,30.4295,-0.03333 +x,30.4564,-0.03485 +x,30.4832,-0.03485 +x,30.5101,-0.03636 +x,30.5369,-0.03636 +x,30.5638,-0.03939 +x,30.5906,-0.03939 +x,30.6174,-0.03939 +x,30.6443,-0.03939 +x,30.6711,-0.04242 +x,30.6980,-0.04242 +x,30.7248,-0.04242 +x,30.7517,-0.04394 +x,30.7785,-0.04394 +x,30.8054,-0.04394 +x,30.8322,-0.04394 +x,30.8591,-0.04545 +x,30.8859,-0.04545 +x,30.9128,-0.04545 +x,30.9396,-0.04394 +x,30.9664,-0.04545 +x,30.9933,-0.04394 +x,31.0201,-0.04545 +x,31.0470,-0.04545 +x,31.0738,-0.04394 +x,31.1007,-0.04394 +x,31.1275,-0.04545 +x,31.1544,-0.04394 +x,31.1812,-0.04394 +x,31.2081,-0.04394 +x,31.2349,-0.04394 +x,31.2617,-0.04242 +x,31.2886,-0.04242 +x,31.3154,-0.04242 +x,31.3423,-0.03939 +x,31.3691,-0.03939 +x,31.3960,-0.03939 +x,31.4228,-0.03939 +x,31.4497,-0.03939 +x,31.4765,-0.03939 +x,31.5034,-0.03636 +x,31.5302,-0.03636 +x,31.5570,-0.03636 +x,31.5839,-0.03485 +x,31.6107,-0.03485 +x,31.6376,-0.03333 +x,31.6644,-0.03333 +x,31.6913,-0.03030 +x,31.7181,-0.03030 +x,31.7450,-0.03030 +x,31.7718,-0.03030 +x,31.7987,-0.02879 +x,31.8255,-0.02727 +x,31.8523,-0.02576 +x,31.8792,-0.02576 +x,31.9060,-0.02576 +x,31.9329,-0.02424 +x,31.9597,-0.02424 +x,31.9866,-0.02121 +x,32.0134,-0.02121 +x,32.0403,-0.02121 +x,32.0671,-0.01970 +x,32.0940,-0.01818 +x,32.1208,-0.01667 +x,32.1477,-0.01667 +x,32.1745,-0.01515 +x,32.2013,-0.01364 +x,32.2282,-0.01212 +x,32.2550,-0.01212 +x,32.2819,-0.01061 +x,32.3087,-0.00909 +x,32.3356,-0.00758 +x,32.3624,-0.00758 +x,32.3893,-0.00606 +x,32.4161,-0.00455 +x,32.4430,-0.00303 +x,32.4698,-0.00303 +x,32.4966,-0.00152 +x,32.5235,0.00000 +x,32.5503,0.00152 +x,32.5772,0.00152 +x,32.6040,0.00303 +x,32.6309,0.00606 +x,32.6577,0.00606 +x,32.6846,0.00758 +x,32.7114,0.00909 +x,32.7383,0.01061 +x,32.7651,0.01212 +x,32.7919,0.01364 +x,32.8188,0.01515 +x,32.8456,0.01515 +x,32.8725,0.01818 +x,32.8993,0.01970 +x,32.9262,0.01970 +x,32.9530,0.02121 +x,32.9799,0.02424 +x,33.0067,0.02424 +x,33.0336,0.02576 +x,33.0604,0.02879 +x,33.0872,0.02879 +x,33.1141,0.03030 +x,33.1409,0.03182 +x,33.1678,0.03333 +x,33.1946,0.03333 +x,33.2215,0.03636 +x,33.2483,0.03788 +x,33.2752,0.03788 +x,33.3020,0.03939 +x,33.3289,0.04242 +x,33.3557,0.04242 +x,33.3826,0.04394 +x,33.4094,0.04545 +x,33.4362,0.04697 +x,33.4631,0.04697 +x,33.4899,0.04848 +x,33.5168,0.05000 +x,33.5436,0.05152 +x,33.5705,0.05152 +x,33.5973,0.05152 +x,33.6242,0.05152 +x,33.6510,0.05152 +x,33.6779,0.05455 +x,33.7047,0.05455 +x,33.7315,0.05455 +x,33.7584,0.05455 +x,33.7852,0.05606 +x,33.8121,0.05606 +x,33.8389,0.05606 +x,33.8658,0.05606 +x,33.8926,0.05606 +x,33.9195,0.05606 +x,33.9463,0.05606 +x,33.9732,0.05606 +x,34.0000,0.05606 +x,34.0268,0.05606 +x,34.0537,0.05606 +x,34.0805,0.05606 +x,34.1074,0.05455 +x,34.1342,0.05455 +x,34.1611,0.05455 +x,34.1879,0.05152 +x,34.2148,0.05152 +x,34.2416,0.05152 +x,34.2685,0.05152 +x,34.2953,0.05152 +x,34.3221,0.05152 +x,34.3490,0.05000 +x,34.3758,0.04848 +x,34.4027,0.04848 +x,34.4295,0.04697 +x,34.4564,0.04697 +x,34.4832,0.04697 +x,34.5101,0.04545 +x,34.5369,0.04545 +x,34.5638,0.04242 +x,34.5906,0.04242 +x,34.6174,0.04242 +x,34.6443,0.04242 +x,34.6711,0.04091 +x,34.6980,0.03939 +x,34.7248,0.03939 +x,34.7517,0.03788 +x,34.7785,0.03788 +x,34.8054,0.03636 +x,34.8322,0.03485 +x,34.8591,0.03333 +x,34.8859,0.03333 +x,34.9128,0.03333 +x,34.9396,0.03182 +x,34.9664,0.03030 +x,34.9933,0.02879 +x,35.0201,0.02879 +x,35.0470,0.02727 +x,35.0738,0.02576 +x,35.1007,0.02424 +x,35.1275,0.02424 +x,35.1544,0.02424 +x,35.1812,0.02121 +x,35.2081,0.02121 +x,35.2349,0.01970 +x,35.2617,0.01970 +x,35.2886,0.01818 +x,35.3154,0.01515 +x,35.3423,0.01515 +x,35.3691,0.01515 +x,35.3960,0.01364 +x,35.4228,0.01212 +x,35.4497,0.01061 +x,35.4765,0.01061 +x,35.5034,0.00909 +x,35.5302,0.00606 +x,35.5570,0.00606 +x,35.5839,0.00606 +x,35.6107,0.00303 +x,35.6376,0.00303 +x,35.6644,0.00152 +x,35.6913,0.00000 +x,35.7181,-0.00152 +x,35.7450,-0.00303 +x,35.7718,-0.00303 +x,35.7987,-0.00455 +x,35.8255,-0.00606 +x,35.8523,-0.00758 +x,35.8792,-0.00909 +x,35.9060,-0.01061 +x,35.9329,-0.01212 +x,35.9597,-0.01212 +x,35.9866,-0.01515 +x,36.0134,-0.01667 +x,36.0403,-0.01667 +x,36.0671,-0.01818 +x,36.0940,-0.01970 +x,36.1208,-0.02121 +x,36.1477,-0.02121 +x,36.1745,-0.02424 +x,36.2013,-0.02576 +x,36.2282,-0.02576 +x,36.2550,-0.02727 +x,36.2819,-0.02879 +x,36.3087,-0.03030 +x,36.3356,-0.03030 +x,36.3624,-0.03182 +x,36.3893,-0.03333 +x,36.4161,-0.03485 +x,36.4430,-0.03485 +x,36.4698,-0.03636 +x,36.4966,-0.03788 +x,36.5235,-0.03939 +x,36.5503,-0.03939 +x,36.5772,-0.03939 +x,36.6040,-0.03939 +x,36.6309,-0.04242 +x,36.6577,-0.04242 +x,36.6846,-0.04242 +x,36.7114,-0.04394 +x,36.7383,-0.04394 +x,36.7651,-0.04394 +x,36.7919,-0.04394 +x,36.8188,-0.04545 +x,36.8456,-0.04394 +x,36.8725,-0.04394 +x,36.8993,-0.04394 +x,36.9262,-0.04394 +x,36.9530,-0.04545 +x,36.9799,-0.04394 +x,37.0067,-0.04394 +x,37.0336,-0.04394 +x,37.0604,-0.04394 +x,37.0872,-0.04545 +x,37.1141,-0.04394 +x,37.1409,-0.04394 +x,37.1678,-0.04394 +x,37.1946,-0.04394 +x,37.2215,-0.04242 +x,37.2483,-0.04242 +x,37.2752,-0.04242 +x,37.3020,-0.03939 +x,37.3289,-0.03939 +x,37.3557,-0.03939 +x,37.3826,-0.03939 +x,37.4094,-0.03939 +x,37.4362,-0.03788 +x,37.4631,-0.03636 +x,37.4899,-0.03636 +x,37.5168,-0.03636 +x,37.5436,-0.03485 +x,37.5705,-0.03485 +x,37.5973,-0.03333 +x,37.6242,-0.03333 +x,37.6510,-0.03030 +x,37.6779,-0.03030 +x,37.7047,-0.03030 +x,37.7315,-0.03030 +x,37.7584,-0.03030 +x,37.7852,-0.02727 +x,37.8121,-0.02727 +x,37.8389,-0.02576 +x,37.8658,-0.02576 +x,37.8926,-0.02424 +x,37.9195,-0.02273 +x,37.9463,-0.02121 +x,37.9732,-0.02121 +x,38.0000,-0.02121 +x,38.0268,-0.01818 +x,38.0537,-0.01818 +x,38.0805,-0.01667 +x,38.1074,-0.01667 +x,38.1342,-0.01515 +x,38.1611,-0.01515 +x,38.1879,-0.01212 +x,38.2148,-0.01212 +x,38.2416,-0.01212 +x,38.2685,-0.00909 +x,38.2953,-0.00758 +x,38.3221,-0.00758 +x,38.3490,-0.00606 +x,38.3758,-0.00455 +x,38.4027,-0.00303 +x,38.4295,-0.00303 +x,38.4564,-0.00303 +x,38.4832,0.00000 +x,38.5101,0.00152 +x,38.5369,0.00152 +x,38.5638,0.00455 +x,38.5906,0.00606 +x,38.6174,0.00606 +x,38.6443,0.00758 +x,38.6711,0.01061 +x,38.6980,0.01061 +x,38.7248,0.01061 +x,38.7517,0.01212 +x,38.7785,0.01515 +x,38.8054,0.01515 +x,38.8322,0.01818 +x,38.8591,0.01970 +x,38.8859,0.01970 +x,38.9128,0.02121 +x,38.9396,0.02424 +x,38.9664,0.02424 +x,38.9933,0.02576 +x,39.0201,0.02727 +x,39.0470,0.02879 +x,39.0738,0.03030 +x,39.1007,0.03182 +x,39.1275,0.03333 +x,39.1544,0.03485 +x,39.1812,0.03636 +x,39.2081,0.03788 +x,39.2349,0.03788 +x,39.2617,0.03939 +x,39.2886,0.04242 +x,39.3154,0.04242 +x,39.3423,0.04394 +x,39.3691,0.04545 +x,39.3960,0.04697 +x,39.4228,0.04697 +x,39.4497,0.04848 +x,39.4765,0.05000 +x,39.5034,0.05152 +x,39.5302,0.05152 +x,39.5570,0.05152 +x,39.5839,0.05152 +x,39.6107,0.05152 +x,39.6376,0.05455 +x,39.6644,0.05455 +x,39.6913,0.05455 +x,39.7181,0.05455 +x,39.7450,0.05606 +x,39.7718,0.05606 +x,39.7987,0.05606 +x,39.8255,0.05606 +x,39.8523,0.05606 +x,39.8792,0.05606 +x,39.9060,0.05606 +x,39.9329,0.05606 +x,39.9597,0.05606 +x,39.9866,0.05606 +x,40.0134,0.05606 +x,40.0403,0.05455 +x,40.0671,0.05455 +x,40.0940,0.05455 +x,40.1208,0.05455 +x,40.1477,0.05152 +x,40.1745,0.05152 +x,40.2013,0.05152 +x,40.2282,0.05152 +x,40.2550,0.05152 +x,40.2819,0.05152 +x,40.3087,0.05152 +x,40.3356,0.04848 +x,40.3624,0.04848 +x,40.3893,0.04697 +x,40.4161,0.04697 +x,40.4430,0.04697 +x,40.4698,0.04545 +x,40.4966,0.04545 +x,40.5235,0.04242 +x,40.5503,0.04242 +x,40.5772,0.04242 +x,40.6040,0.04242 +x,40.6309,0.03939 +x,40.6577,0.03939 +x,40.6846,0.03788 +x,40.7114,0.03788 +x,40.7383,0.03788 +x,40.7651,0.03636 +x,40.7919,0.03485 +x,40.8188,0.03333 +x,40.8456,0.03333 +x,40.8725,0.03333 +x,40.8993,0.03030 +x,40.9262,0.02879 +x,40.9530,0.02879 +x,40.9799,0.02727 +x,41.0067,0.02727 +x,41.0336,0.02424 +x,41.0604,0.02424 +x,41.0872,0.02424 +x,41.1141,0.02273 +x,41.1409,0.02121 +x,41.1678,0.01970 +x,41.1946,0.01970 +x,41.2215,0.01818 +x,41.2483,0.01667 +x,41.2752,0.01515 +x,41.3020,0.01515 +x,41.3289,0.01364 +x,41.3557,0.01212 +x,41.3826,0.01061 +x,41.4094,0.01061 +x,41.4362,0.00909 +x,41.4631,0.00758 +x,41.4899,0.00606 +x,41.5168,0.00606 +x,41.5436,0.00455 +x,41.5705,0.00303 +x,41.5973,0.00152 +x,41.6242,0.00000 +x,41.6510,-0.00152 +x,41.6779,-0.00303 +x,41.7047,-0.00303 +x,41.7315,-0.00455 +x,41.7584,-0.00606 +x,41.7852,-0.00758 +x,41.8121,-0.00909 +x,41.8389,-0.01061 +x,41.8658,-0.01212 +x,41.8926,-0.01364 +x,41.9195,-0.01667 +x,41.9463,-0.01667 +x,41.9732,-0.01818 +x,42.0000,-0.02121 +x,42.0268,-0.02121 +x,42.0537,-0.02273 +x,42.0805,-0.02424 +x,42.1074,-0.02576 +x,42.1342,-0.02576 +x,42.1611,-0.02727 +x,42.1879,-0.03030 +x,42.2148,-0.03030 +x,42.2416,-0.03030 +x,42.2685,-0.03333 +x,42.2953,-0.03485 +x,42.3221,-0.03485 +x,42.3490,-0.03636 +x,42.3758,-0.03636 +x,42.4027,-0.03939 +x,42.4295,-0.03939 +x,42.4564,-0.03939 +x,42.4832,-0.03939 +x,42.5101,-0.04091 +x,42.5369,-0.04242 +x,42.5638,-0.04242 +x,42.5906,-0.04394 +x,42.6174,-0.04394 +x,42.6443,-0.04394 +x,42.6711,-0.04394 +x,42.6980,-0.04545 +x,42.7248,-0.04545 +x,42.7517,-0.04394 +x,42.7785,-0.04394 +x,42.8054,-0.04545 +x,42.8322,-0.04394 +x,42.8591,-0.04545 +x,42.8859,-0.04394 +x,42.9128,-0.04394 +x,42.9396,-0.04394 +x,42.9664,-0.04394 +x,42.9933,-0.04394 +x,43.0201,-0.04394 +x,43.0470,-0.04394 +x,43.0738,-0.04394 +x,43.1007,-0.04394 +x,43.1275,-0.04242 +x,43.1544,-0.04242 +x,43.1812,-0.04091 +x,43.2081,-0.03939 +x,43.2349,-0.03939 +x,43.2617,-0.03939 +x,43.2886,-0.03939 +x,43.3154,-0.03939 +x,43.3423,-0.03636 +x,43.3691,-0.03636 +x,43.3960,-0.03636 +x,43.4228,-0.03485 +x,43.4497,-0.03485 +x,43.4765,-0.03333 +x,43.5034,-0.03333 +x,43.5302,-0.03182 +x,43.5570,-0.03030 +x,43.5839,-0.03030 +x,43.6107,-0.03030 +x,43.6376,-0.03030 +x,43.6644,-0.02727 +x,43.6913,-0.02576 +x,43.7181,-0.02576 +x,43.7450,-0.02424 +x,43.7718,-0.02424 +x,43.7987,-0.02121 +x,43.8255,-0.02121 +x,43.8523,-0.02121 +x,43.8792,-0.01970 +x,43.9060,-0.01818 +x,43.9329,-0.01667 +x,43.9597,-0.01515 +x,43.9866,-0.01515 +x,44.0134,-0.01212 +x,44.0403,-0.01212 +x,44.0671,-0.01061 +x,44.0940,-0.00909 +x,44.1208,-0.00758 +x,44.1477,-0.00758 +x,44.1745,-0.00606 +x,44.2013,-0.00455 +x,44.2282,-0.00303 +x,44.2550,-0.00303 +x,44.2819,-0.00152 +x,44.3087,0.00000 +x,44.3356,0.00152 +x,44.3624,0.00152 +x,44.3893,0.00455 +x,44.4161,0.00606 +x,44.4430,0.00606 +x,44.4698,0.00758 +x,44.4966,0.00909 +x,44.5235,0.01061 +x,44.5503,0.01061 +x,44.5772,0.01212 +x,44.6040,0.01515 +x,44.6309,0.01515 +x,44.6577,0.01667 +x,44.6846,0.01970 +x,44.7114,0.01970 +x,44.7383,0.02121 +x,44.7651,0.02424 +x,44.7919,0.02424 +x,44.8188,0.02424 +x,44.8456,0.02727 +x,44.8725,0.02879 +x,44.8993,0.03030 +x,44.9262,0.03182 +x,44.9530,0.03333 +x,44.9799,0.03333 +x,45.0067,0.03636 +x,45.0336,0.03788 +x,45.0604,0.03788 +x,45.0872,0.03939 +x,45.1141,0.04242 +x,45.1409,0.04242 +x,45.1678,0.04394 +x,45.1946,0.04545 +x,45.2215,0.04697 +x,45.2483,0.04697 +x,45.2752,0.04848 +x,45.3020,0.05000 +x,45.3289,0.05152 +x,45.3557,0.05152 +x,45.3826,0.05152 +x,45.4094,0.05152 +x,45.4362,0.05152 +x,45.4631,0.05455 +x,45.4899,0.05455 +x,45.5168,0.05455 +x,45.5436,0.05455 +x,45.5705,0.05606 +x,45.5973,0.05606 +x,45.6242,0.05606 +x,45.6510,0.05606 +x,45.6779,0.05606 +x,45.7047,0.05606 +x,45.7315,0.05606 +x,45.7584,0.05606 +x,45.7852,0.05606 +x,45.8121,0.05606 +x,45.8389,0.05606 +x,45.8658,0.05606 +x,45.8926,0.05455 +x,45.9195,0.05455 +x,45.9463,0.05455 +x,45.9732,0.05152 +x,46.0000,0.05152 +x,46.0268,0.05152 +x,46.0537,0.05152 +x,46.0805,0.05152 +x,46.1074,0.05152 +x,46.1342,0.05000 +x,46.1611,0.04848 +x,46.1879,0.04848 +x,46.2148,0.04697 +x,46.2416,0.04697 +x,46.2685,0.04697 +x,46.2953,0.04545 +x,46.3221,0.04545 +x,46.3490,0.04394 +x,46.3758,0.04242 +x,46.4027,0.04242 +x,46.4295,0.04242 +x,46.4564,0.04091 +x,46.4832,0.03939 +x,46.5101,0.03788 +x,46.5369,0.03788 +x,46.5638,0.03788 +x,46.5906,0.03636 +x,46.6174,0.03485 +x,46.6443,0.03333 +x,46.6711,0.03333 +x,46.6980,0.03333 +x,46.7248,0.03030 +x,46.7517,0.03030 +x,46.7785,0.02879 +x,46.8054,0.02879 +x,46.8322,0.02727 +x,46.8591,0.02576 +x,46.8859,0.02424 +x,46.9128,0.02424 +x,46.9396,0.02424 +x,46.9664,0.02121 +x,46.9933,0.01970 +x,47.0201,0.01970 +x,47.0470,0.01818 +x,47.0738,0.01818 +x,47.1007,0.01515 +x,47.1275,0.01515 +x,47.1544,0.01515 +x,47.1812,0.01212 +x,47.2081,0.01061 +x,47.2349,0.01061 +x,47.2617,0.01061 +x,47.2886,0.00758 +x,47.3154,0.00606 +x,47.3423,0.00606 +x,47.3691,0.00455 +x,47.3960,0.00303 +x,47.4228,0.00152 +x,47.4497,0.00000 +x,47.4765,0.00000 +x,47.5034,-0.00303 +x,47.5302,-0.00303 +x,47.5570,-0.00455 +x,47.5839,-0.00606 +x,47.6107,-0.00758 +x,47.6376,-0.00909 +x,47.6644,-0.00909 +x,47.6913,-0.01212 +x,47.7181,-0.01212 +x,47.7450,-0.01364 +x,47.7718,-0.01515 +x,47.7987,-0.01667 +x,47.8255,-0.01818 +x,47.8523,-0.01970 +x,47.8792,-0.02121 +x,47.9060,-0.02273 +x,47.9329,-0.02424 +x,47.9597,-0.02576 +x,47.9866,-0.02576 +x,48.0134,-0.02727 +x,48.0403,-0.03030 +x,48.0671,-0.03030 +x,48.0940,-0.03030 +x,48.1208,-0.03333 +x,48.1477,-0.03333 +x,48.1745,-0.03485 +x,48.2013,-0.03485 +x,48.2282,-0.03636 +x,48.2550,-0.03939 +x,48.2819,-0.03939 +x,48.3087,-0.03939 +x,48.3356,-0.03939 +x,48.3624,-0.04091 +x,48.3893,-0.04242 +x,48.4161,-0.04242 +x,48.4430,-0.04394 +x,48.4698,-0.04394 +x,48.4966,-0.04394 +x,48.5235,-0.04394 +x,48.5503,-0.04545 +x,48.5772,-0.04545 +x,48.6040,-0.04545 +x,48.6309,-0.04394 +x,48.6577,-0.04394 +x,48.6846,-0.04394 +x,48.7114,-0.04394 +x,48.7383,-0.04394 +x,48.7651,-0.04394 +x,48.7919,-0.04394 +x,48.8188,-0.04545 +x,48.8456,-0.04394 +x,48.8725,-0.04394 +x,48.8993,-0.04394 +x,48.9262,-0.04394 +x,48.9530,-0.04394 +x,48.9799,-0.04242 +x,49.0067,-0.04242 +x,49.0336,-0.04091 +x,49.0604,-0.03939 +x,49.0872,-0.03939 +x,49.1141,-0.03939 +x,49.1409,-0.03939 +x,49.1678,-0.03939 +x,49.1946,-0.03788 +x,49.2215,-0.03636 +x,49.2483,-0.03636 +x,49.2752,-0.03485 +x,49.3020,-0.03485 +x,49.3289,-0.03485 +x,49.3557,-0.03333 +x,49.3826,-0.03333 +x,49.4094,-0.03030 +x,49.4362,-0.03030 +x,49.4631,-0.03030 +x,49.4899,-0.03030 +x,49.5168,-0.02727 +x,49.5436,-0.02727 +x,49.5705,-0.02576 +x,49.5973,-0.02576 +x,49.6242,-0.02424 +x,49.6510,-0.02424 +x,49.6779,-0.02273 +x,49.7047,-0.02121 +x,49.7315,-0.02121 +x,49.7584,-0.02121 +x,49.7852,-0.01818 +x,49.8121,-0.01667 +x,49.8389,-0.01667 +x,49.8658,-0.01667 +x,49.8926,-0.01515 +x,49.9195,-0.01212 +x,49.9463,-0.01212 +z,30.0537,-0.12121 +z,30.0805,-0.12121 +z,30.1074,-0.12121 +z,30.1342,-0.11818 +z,30.1611,-0.11667 +z,30.1879,-0.11667 +z,30.2148,-0.11364 +z,30.2416,-0.11212 +z,30.2685,-0.10909 +z,30.2953,-0.10758 +z,30.3221,-0.10455 +z,30.3490,-0.10303 +z,30.3758,-0.10000 +z,30.4027,-0.09848 +z,30.4295,-0.09545 +z,30.4564,-0.09242 +z,30.4832,-0.08939 +z,30.5101,-0.08636 +z,30.5369,-0.08333 +z,30.5638,-0.08030 +z,30.5906,-0.07727 +z,30.6174,-0.07424 +z,30.6443,-0.07121 +z,30.6711,-0.06667 +z,30.6980,-0.06364 +z,30.7248,-0.06061 +z,30.7517,-0.05758 +z,30.7785,-0.05303 +z,30.8054,-0.05000 +z,30.8322,-0.04848 +z,30.8591,-0.03939 +z,30.8859,-0.03788 +z,30.9128,-0.03485 +z,30.9396,-0.03182 +z,30.9664,-0.02879 +z,30.9933,-0.02424 +z,31.0201,-0.01970 +z,31.0470,-0.01667 +z,31.0738,-0.01364 +z,31.1007,-0.00909 +z,31.1275,-0.00606 +z,31.1544,-0.00152 +z,31.1812,0.00152 +z,31.2081,0.00455 +z,31.2349,0.00909 +z,31.2617,0.01212 +z,31.2886,0.01667 +z,31.3154,0.01970 +z,31.3423,0.02273 +z,31.3691,0.02727 +z,31.3960,0.03030 +z,31.4228,0.03333 +z,31.4497,0.03788 +z,31.4765,0.04091 +z,31.5034,0.04394 +z,31.5302,0.04697 +z,31.5570,0.05152 +z,31.5839,0.05606 +z,31.6107,0.05606 +z,31.6376,0.06061 +z,31.6644,0.06515 +z,31.6913,0.06515 +z,31.7181,0.06970 +z,31.7450,0.07273 +z,31.7718,0.07424 +z,31.7987,0.07879 +z,31.8255,0.08030 +z,31.8523,0.08333 +z,31.8792,0.08636 +z,31.9060,0.08788 +z,31.9329,0.09242 +z,31.9597,0.09394 +z,31.9866,0.09697 +z,32.0134,0.09848 +z,32.0403,0.10152 +z,32.0671,0.10303 +z,32.0940,0.10606 +z,32.1208,0.10606 +z,32.1477,0.10909 +z,32.1745,0.11061 +z,32.2013,0.11212 +z,32.2282,0.11515 +z,32.2550,0.11515 +z,32.2819,0.11818 +z,32.3087,0.11970 +z,32.3356,0.11970 +z,32.3624,0.12273 +z,32.3893,0.12424 +z,32.4161,0.12424 +z,32.4430,0.12424 +z,32.4698,0.12727 +z,32.4966,0.12727 +z,32.5235,0.12879 +z,32.5503,0.12879 +z,32.5772,0.12879 +z,32.6040,0.13030 +z,32.6309,0.13030 +z,32.6577,0.13030 +z,32.6846,0.13030 +z,32.7114,0.13030 +z,32.7383,0.13030 +z,32.7651,0.13030 +z,32.7919,0.13030 +z,32.8188,0.13030 +z,32.8456,0.13030 +z,32.8725,0.13030 +z,32.8993,0.13030 +z,32.9262,0.13030 +z,32.9530,0.12879 +z,32.9799,0.12879 +z,33.0067,0.12879 +z,33.0336,0.12727 +z,33.0604,0.12424 +z,33.0872,0.12424 +z,33.1141,0.12273 +z,33.1409,0.11970 +z,33.1678,0.11970 +z,33.1946,0.11667 +z,33.2215,0.11515 +z,33.2483,0.11364 +z,33.2752,0.11061 +z,33.3020,0.10758 +z,33.3289,0.10606 +z,33.3557,0.10455 +z,33.3826,0.10152 +z,33.4094,0.09848 +z,33.4362,0.09545 +z,33.4631,0.09242 +z,33.4899,0.08939 +z,33.5168,0.08636 +z,33.5436,0.08333 +z,33.5705,0.08030 +z,33.5973,0.07576 +z,33.6242,0.07273 +z,33.6510,0.06970 +z,33.6779,0.06515 +z,33.7047,0.06212 +z,33.7315,0.05909 +z,33.7852,0.05152 +z,33.8121,0.04697 +z,33.8389,0.04394 +z,33.8658,0.04091 +z,33.8926,0.03788 +z,33.9195,0.03333 +z,33.9463,0.02879 +z,33.9732,0.02576 +z,34.0000,0.02121 +z,34.0268,0.01818 +z,34.0537,0.01364 +z,34.0805,0.01061 +z,34.1074,0.00606 +z,34.1342,0.00303 +z,34.1611,-0.00152 +z,34.1879,-0.00455 +z,34.2148,-0.00758 +z,34.2416,-0.01061 +z,34.2685,-0.01667 +z,34.2953,-0.01970 +z,34.3221,-0.02273 +z,34.3490,-0.02576 +z,34.3758,-0.03030 +z,34.4027,-0.03333 +z,34.4295,-0.03636 +z,34.4564,-0.04091 +z,34.4832,-0.04394 +z,34.5101,-0.04697 +z,34.5369,-0.05000 +z,34.5638,-0.05303 +z,34.5906,-0.05606 +z,34.6174,-0.05909 +z,34.6443,-0.06212 +z,34.6711,-0.06515 +z,34.6980,-0.06818 +z,34.7248,-0.07121 +z,34.7517,-0.07424 +z,34.7785,-0.07727 +z,34.8054,-0.08030 +z,34.8322,-0.08333 +z,34.8591,-0.08636 +z,34.8859,-0.08939 +z,34.9128,-0.08939 +z,34.9396,-0.09394 +z,34.9664,-0.09394 +z,34.9933,-0.09848 +z,35.0201,-0.09848 +z,35.0470,-0.10303 +z,35.0738,-0.10303 +z,35.1007,-0.10606 +z,35.1275,-0.10758 +z,35.1544,-0.10909 +z,35.1812,-0.11212 +z,35.2081,-0.11212 +z,35.2349,-0.11364 +z,35.2617,-0.11667 +z,35.2886,-0.11667 +z,35.3154,-0.11818 +z,35.3423,-0.12121 +z,35.3691,-0.12121 +z,35.3960,-0.12121 +z,35.4228,-0.12273 +z,35.4497,-0.12424 +z,35.4765,-0.12576 +z,35.5034,-0.12576 +z,35.5302,-0.12576 +z,35.5570,-0.12727 +z,35.5839,-0.12727 +z,35.6107,-0.12727 +z,35.6376,-0.12727 +z,35.6644,-0.12727 +z,35.6913,-0.12879 +z,35.7181,-0.13030 +z,35.7450,-0.13030 +z,35.7718,-0.12727 +z,35.7987,-0.12727 +z,35.8255,-0.12727 +z,35.8523,-0.12727 +z,35.8792,-0.12727 +z,35.9060,-0.12576 +z,35.9329,-0.12576 +z,35.9597,-0.12576 +z,35.9866,-0.12424 +z,36.0134,-0.12121 +z,36.0403,-0.12121 +z,36.0671,-0.12121 +z,36.0940,-0.11818 +z,36.1208,-0.11667 +z,36.1477,-0.11515 +z,36.1745,-0.11212 +z,36.2013,-0.11212 +z,36.2282,-0.10909 +z,36.2550,-0.10758 +z,36.2819,-0.10455 +z,36.3087,-0.10303 +z,36.3356,-0.10000 +z,36.3624,-0.09848 +z,36.3893,-0.09394 +z,36.4161,-0.09242 +z,36.4430,-0.08939 +z,36.4698,-0.08636 +z,36.4966,-0.08333 +z,36.5235,-0.08030 +z,36.5503,-0.07727 +z,36.5772,-0.07424 +z,36.6040,-0.07121 +z,36.6309,-0.06667 +z,36.6577,-0.06364 +z,36.6846,-0.05909 +z,36.7114,-0.05606 +z,36.7383,-0.05303 +z,36.7651,-0.05000 +z,36.7919,-0.04848 +z,36.8188,-0.03939 +z,36.8456,-0.03788 +z,36.8725,-0.03485 +z,36.8993,-0.03182 +z,36.9262,-0.02879 +z,36.9530,-0.02424 +z,36.9799,-0.01970 +z,37.0067,-0.01667 +z,37.0336,-0.01364 +z,37.0604,-0.00909 +z,37.0872,-0.00606 +z,37.1141,-0.00152 +z,37.1409,0.00152 +z,37.1678,0.00606 +z,37.1946,0.01061 +z,37.2215,0.01364 +z,37.2483,0.01667 +z,37.2752,0.01970 +z,37.3020,0.02273 +z,37.3289,0.02727 +z,37.3557,0.03182 +z,37.3826,0.03485 +z,37.4094,0.03788 +z,37.4362,0.04091 +z,37.4631,0.04394 +z,37.4899,0.04697 +z,37.5168,0.05152 +z,37.5436,0.05606 +z,37.5705,0.05606 +z,37.5973,0.06061 +z,37.6242,0.06515 +z,37.6510,0.06515 +z,37.6779,0.06970 +z,37.7047,0.07424 +z,37.7315,0.07424 +z,37.7584,0.07879 +z,37.7852,0.08182 +z,37.8121,0.08333 +z,37.8389,0.08636 +z,37.8658,0.08939 +z,37.8926,0.09242 +z,37.9195,0.09394 +z,37.9463,0.09697 +z,37.9732,0.09848 +z,38.0000,0.10152 +z,38.0268,0.10303 +z,38.0537,0.10606 +z,38.0805,0.10606 +z,38.1074,0.10909 +z,38.1342,0.11061 +z,38.1611,0.11212 +z,38.1879,0.11515 +z,38.2148,0.11515 +z,38.2416,0.11818 +z,38.2685,0.11970 +z,38.2953,0.11970 +z,38.3221,0.12121 +z,38.3490,0.12424 +z,38.3758,0.12424 +z,38.4027,0.12424 +z,38.4295,0.12727 +z,38.4564,0.12879 +z,38.4832,0.12879 +z,38.5101,0.12879 +z,38.5369,0.12879 +z,38.5638,0.12879 +z,38.5906,0.13030 +z,38.6174,0.13030 +z,38.6443,0.13030 +z,38.6711,0.13030 +z,38.6980,0.13030 +z,38.7248,0.13030 +z,38.7517,0.13030 +z,38.7785,0.13030 +z,38.8054,0.13030 +z,38.8322,0.13030 +z,38.8591,0.13030 +z,38.8859,0.13030 +z,38.9128,0.12879 +z,38.9396,0.12879 +z,38.9664,0.12879 +z,38.9933,0.12727 +z,39.0201,0.12424 +z,39.0470,0.12424 +z,39.0738,0.12273 +z,39.1007,0.11970 +z,39.1275,0.11970 +z,39.1544,0.11667 +z,39.1812,0.11515 +z,39.2081,0.11364 +z,39.2349,0.11061 +z,39.2617,0.10758 +z,39.2886,0.10606 +z,39.3154,0.10303 +z,39.3423,0.10152 +z,39.3691,0.09697 +z,39.3960,0.09545 +z,39.4228,0.09242 +z,39.4497,0.08939 +z,39.4765,0.08636 +z,39.5034,0.08333 +z,39.5302,0.08030 +z,39.5570,0.07576 +z,39.5839,0.07121 +z,39.6107,0.06818 +z,39.6376,0.06515 +z,39.6644,0.06212 +z,39.6913,0.05909 +z,39.7450,0.05152 +z,39.7718,0.04697 +z,39.7987,0.04394 +z,39.8255,0.03939 +z,39.8523,0.03636 +z,39.8792,0.03182 +z,39.9060,0.02879 +z,39.9329,0.02576 +z,39.9597,0.02121 +z,39.9866,0.01818 +z,40.0134,0.01364 +z,40.0403,0.01061 +z,40.0671,0.00606 +z,40.0940,0.00303 +z,40.1208,-0.00152 +z,40.1477,-0.00455 +z,40.1745,-0.00758 +z,40.2013,-0.01212 +z,40.2282,-0.01667 +z,40.2550,-0.01970 +z,40.2819,-0.02273 +z,40.3087,-0.02576 +z,40.3356,-0.02879 +z,40.3624,-0.03485 +z,40.3893,-0.03788 +z,40.4161,-0.04091 +z,40.4430,-0.04394 +z,40.4698,-0.04697 +z,40.4966,-0.05000 +z,40.5235,-0.05303 +z,40.5503,-0.05758 +z,40.5772,-0.05909 +z,40.6040,-0.06212 +z,40.6309,-0.06515 +z,40.6577,-0.06818 +z,40.6846,-0.07121 +z,40.7114,-0.07576 +z,40.7383,-0.07727 +z,40.7651,-0.08030 +z,40.7919,-0.08333 +z,40.8188,-0.08636 +z,40.8456,-0.08939 +z,40.8725,-0.09242 +z,40.8993,-0.09394 +z,40.9262,-0.09697 +z,40.9530,-0.09848 +z,40.9799,-0.10152 +z,41.0067,-0.10303 +z,41.0336,-0.10606 +z,41.0604,-0.10758 +z,41.0872,-0.10909 +z,41.1141,-0.11212 +z,41.1409,-0.11212 +z,41.1678,-0.11364 +z,41.1946,-0.11667 +z,41.2215,-0.11667 +z,41.2483,-0.11818 +z,41.2752,-0.11970 +z,41.3020,-0.12121 +z,41.3289,-0.12121 +z,41.3557,-0.12273 +z,41.3826,-0.12424 +z,41.4094,-0.12576 +z,41.4362,-0.12576 +z,41.4631,-0.12576 +z,41.4899,-0.12576 +z,41.5168,-0.12727 +z,41.5436,-0.12727 +z,41.5705,-0.12727 +z,41.5973,-0.12727 +z,41.6242,-0.12727 +z,41.6510,-0.13030 +z,41.6779,-0.13030 +z,41.7047,-0.12727 +z,41.7315,-0.12727 +z,41.7584,-0.12727 +z,41.7852,-0.12727 +z,41.8121,-0.12727 +z,41.8389,-0.12576 +z,41.8658,-0.12576 +z,41.8926,-0.12424 +z,41.9195,-0.12121 +z,41.9463,-0.12121 +z,41.9732,-0.11970 +z,42.0000,-0.11667 +z,42.0268,-0.11667 +z,42.0537,-0.11364 +z,42.0805,-0.11212 +z,42.1074,-0.11061 +z,42.1342,-0.10758 +z,42.1611,-0.10606 +z,42.1879,-0.10303 +z,42.2148,-0.10152 +z,42.2416,-0.09848 +z,42.2685,-0.09545 +z,42.2953,-0.09242 +z,42.3221,-0.08939 +z,42.3490,-0.08788 +z,42.3758,-0.08485 +z,42.4027,-0.08030 +z,42.4295,-0.07727 +z,42.4564,-0.07424 +z,42.4832,-0.07121 +z,42.5101,-0.06818 +z,42.5369,-0.06515 +z,42.5638,-0.06212 +z,42.5906,-0.05909 +z,42.6174,-0.05455 +z,42.6443,-0.05000 +z,42.6711,-0.04848 +z,42.7248,-0.03939 +z,42.7517,-0.03636 +z,42.7785,-0.03333 +z,42.8054,-0.02879 +z,42.8322,-0.02576 +z,42.8591,-0.02121 +z,42.8859,-0.01818 +z,42.9128,-0.01364 +z,42.9396,-0.01061 +z,42.9664,-0.00758 +z,42.9933,-0.00455 +z,43.0201,0.00152 +z,43.0470,0.00303 +z,43.0738,0.00758 +z,43.1007,0.01061 +z,43.1275,0.01515 +z,43.1544,0.01970 +z,43.1812,0.02273 +z,43.2081,0.02576 +z,43.2349,0.02879 +z,43.2617,0.03182 +z,43.2886,0.03636 +z,43.3154,0.03939 +z,43.3423,0.04394 +z,43.3691,0.04697 +z,43.3960,0.05000 +z,43.4228,0.05455 +z,43.4497,0.05606 +z,43.4765,0.06061 +z,43.5034,0.06515 +z,43.5302,0.06515 +z,43.5570,0.06970 +z,43.5839,0.07424 +z,43.6107,0.07424 +z,43.6376,0.07879 +z,43.6644,0.08333 +z,43.6913,0.08333 +z,43.7181,0.08788 +z,43.7450,0.08939 +z,43.7718,0.09242 +z,43.7987,0.09545 +z,43.8255,0.09848 +z,43.8523,0.10152 +z,43.8792,0.10303 +z,43.9060,0.10606 +z,43.9329,0.10758 +z,43.9597,0.11061 +z,43.9866,0.11212 +z,44.0134,0.11515 +z,44.0403,0.11515 +z,44.0671,0.11818 +z,44.0940,0.11970 +z,44.1208,0.11970 +z,44.1477,0.12121 +z,44.1745,0.12424 +z,44.2013,0.12424 +z,44.2282,0.12424 +z,44.2550,0.12727 +z,44.2819,0.12879 +z,44.3087,0.12879 +z,44.3356,0.12879 +z,44.3624,0.12879 +z,44.3893,0.12879 +z,44.4161,0.13030 +z,44.4430,0.13030 +z,44.4698,0.13030 +z,44.4966,0.13030 +z,44.5235,0.13030 +z,44.5503,0.13030 +z,44.5772,0.13030 +z,44.6040,0.13030 +z,44.6309,0.13030 +z,44.6577,0.13030 +z,44.6846,0.13030 +z,44.7114,0.13030 +z,44.7383,0.12879 +z,44.7651,0.12879 +z,44.7919,0.12727 +z,44.8188,0.12727 +z,44.8456,0.12424 +z,44.8725,0.12424 +z,44.8993,0.12273 +z,44.9262,0.11970 +z,44.9530,0.11970 +z,44.9799,0.11667 +z,45.0067,0.11515 +z,45.0336,0.11364 +z,45.0604,0.11061 +z,45.0872,0.10758 +z,45.1141,0.10606 +z,45.1409,0.10303 +z,45.1678,0.10152 +z,45.1946,0.09848 +z,45.2215,0.09545 +z,45.2483,0.09242 +z,45.2752,0.08788 +z,45.3020,0.08636 +z,45.3289,0.08333 +z,45.3557,0.07879 +z,45.3826,0.07576 +z,45.4094,0.07273 +z,45.4362,0.06970 +z,45.4631,0.06515 +z,45.4899,0.06212 +z,45.5168,0.05909 +z,45.5705,0.05000 +z,45.5973,0.04697 +z,45.6242,0.04394 +z,45.6510,0.04091 +z,45.6779,0.03788 +z,45.7047,0.03182 +z,45.7315,0.02879 +z,45.7584,0.02576 +z,45.7852,0.02121 +z,45.8121,0.01818 +z,45.8389,0.01364 +z,45.8658,0.01061 +z,45.8926,0.00758 +z,45.9195,0.00152 +z,45.9463,-0.00152 +z,45.9732,-0.00455 +z,46.0000,-0.00758 +z,46.0268,-0.01212 +z,46.0537,-0.01667 +z,46.0805,-0.01970 +z,46.1074,-0.02273 +z,46.1342,-0.02576 +z,46.1611,-0.03030 +z,46.1879,-0.03485 +z,46.2148,-0.03788 +z,46.2416,-0.04091 +z,46.2685,-0.04394 +z,46.2953,-0.04697 +z,46.3221,-0.05000 +z,46.3490,-0.05303 +z,46.3758,-0.05758 +z,46.4027,-0.05909 +z,46.4295,-0.06212 +z,46.4564,-0.06667 +z,46.4832,-0.06818 +z,46.5101,-0.07121 +z,46.5369,-0.07576 +z,46.5638,-0.07727 +z,46.5906,-0.08030 +z,46.6174,-0.08333 +z,46.6443,-0.08636 +z,46.6711,-0.08939 +z,46.6980,-0.08939 +z,46.7248,-0.09394 +z,46.7517,-0.09545 +z,46.7785,-0.09848 +z,46.8054,-0.10152 +z,46.8322,-0.10303 +z,46.8591,-0.10455 +z,46.8859,-0.10758 +z,46.9128,-0.10758 +z,46.9396,-0.11061 +z,46.9664,-0.11212 +z,46.9933,-0.11364 +z,47.0201,-0.11515 +z,47.0470,-0.11667 +z,47.0738,-0.11818 +z,47.1007,-0.11970 +z,47.1275,-0.12121 +z,47.1544,-0.12121 +z,47.1812,-0.12121 +z,47.2081,-0.12273 +z,47.2349,-0.12576 +z,47.2617,-0.12576 +z,47.2886,-0.12576 +z,47.3154,-0.12576 +z,47.3423,-0.12727 +z,47.3691,-0.12727 +z,47.3960,-0.12727 +z,47.4228,-0.12727 +z,47.4497,-0.12727 +z,47.4765,-0.13030 +z,47.5034,-0.13030 +z,47.5302,-0.12879 +z,47.5570,-0.12727 +z,47.5839,-0.12727 +z,47.6107,-0.12727 +z,47.6376,-0.12727 +z,47.6644,-0.12576 +z,47.6913,-0.12576 +z,47.7181,-0.12576 +z,47.7450,-0.12424 +z,47.7718,-0.12121 +z,47.7987,-0.12121 +z,47.8255,-0.12121 +z,47.8523,-0.11818 +z,47.8792,-0.11667 +z,47.9060,-0.11364 +z,47.9329,-0.11212 +z,47.9597,-0.11061 +z,47.9866,-0.10758 +z,48.0134,-0.10758 +z,48.0403,-0.10455 +z,48.0671,-0.10152 +z,48.0940,-0.09848 +z,48.1208,-0.09545 +z,48.1477,-0.09394 +z,48.1745,-0.08939 +z,48.2013,-0.08788 +z,48.2282,-0.08485 +z,48.2550,-0.08030 +z,48.2819,-0.07727 +z,48.3087,-0.07576 +z,48.3356,-0.07121 +z,48.3624,-0.06970 +z,48.3893,-0.06515 +z,48.4161,-0.06212 +z,48.4430,-0.05909 +z,48.4698,-0.05606 +z,48.4966,-0.05303 +z,48.5235,-0.04848 +z,48.5503,-0.04848 +z,48.5772,-0.03939 +z,48.6040,-0.03788 +z,48.6309,-0.03485 +z,48.6577,-0.03030 +z,48.6846,-0.02576 +z,48.7114,-0.02273 +z,48.7383,-0.01818 +z,48.7651,-0.01515 +z,48.7919,-0.01061 +z,48.8188,-0.00758 +z,48.8456,-0.00455 +z,48.8725,0.00000 +z,48.8993,0.00303 +z,48.9262,0.00758 +z,48.9530,0.01061 +z,48.9799,0.01364 +z,49.0067,0.01818 +z,49.0336,0.02121 +z,49.0604,0.02576 +z,49.0872,0.02879 +z,49.1141,0.03182 +z,49.1409,0.03636 +z,49.1678,0.03788 +z,49.1946,0.04242 +z,49.2215,0.04697 +z,49.2483,0.05000 +z,49.2752,0.05303 +z,49.3020,0.05606 +z,49.3289,0.05909 +z,49.3557,0.06212 +z,49.3826,0.06515 +z,49.4094,0.06818 +z,49.4362,0.07121 +z,49.4631,0.07424 +z,49.4899,0.07727 +z,49.5168,0.07879 +z,49.5436,0.08333 +z,49.5705,0.08485 +z,49.5973,0.08788 +z,49.6242,0.08939 +z,49.6510,0.09242 +z,49.6779,0.09545 +z,49.7047,0.09697 +z,49.7315,0.10000 +z,49.7584,0.10152 +z,49.7852,0.10455 +z,49.8121,0.10606 +z,49.8389,0.10758 +z,49.8658,0.11061 +z,49.8926,0.11061 +z,49.9195,0.11364 +z,49.9463,0.11515 diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig22.csv b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig22.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..589a9b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/thorsen2017_fig22.csv @@ -0,0 +1,506 @@ +series,s_m,rms_strain +measured,1.044,5.6840e-06 +measured,1.9427,3.6518e-05 +measured,2.8415,5.9631e-05 +measured,3.7493,2.9745e-05 +measured,4.6479,5.0537e-05 +measured,5.5467,4.7884e-05 +measured,6.4454,3.3960e-05 +measured,7.3441,3.3628e-05 +measured,8.2428,4.0733e-05 +measured,9.1416,3.9927e-05 +measured,10.0493,3.7322e-05 +measured,10.9479,3.0170e-05 +measured,11.8468,3.3912e-05 +measured,12.7454,3.8980e-05 +measured,13.6441,3.5144e-05 +measured,14.5428,4.2438e-05 +measured,15.4416,3.6044e-05 +measured,16.3494,3.4149e-05 +measured,17.2481,3.7796e-05 +measured,18.1467,3.6281e-05 +measured,19.0456,3.8317e-05 +measured,19.9442,3.3202e-05 +measured,20.8429,3.4670e-05 +measured,21.7416,4.9590e-05 +measured,22.6495,4.3859e-05 +thorsen2017,-0.0001,4.7509e-08 +thorsen2017,0.0451,8.5268e-07 +thorsen2017,0.0907,1.7997e-06 +thorsen2017,0.136,2.7000e-06 +thorsen2017,0.1814,3.6477e-06 +thorsen2017,0.2359,4.5947e-06 +thorsen2017,0.2813,5.5893e-06 +thorsen2017,0.3267,6.5364e-06 +thorsen2017,0.372,7.5316e-06 +thorsen2017,0.4265,8.4787e-06 +thorsen2017,0.4719,9.4732e-06 +thorsen2017,0.5173,1.0515e-05 +thorsen2017,0.5626,1.1557e-05 +thorsen2017,0.608,1.2694e-05 +thorsen2017,0.6626,1.3831e-05 +thorsen2017,0.708,1.4777e-05 +thorsen2017,0.7532,1.5441e-05 +thorsen2017,0.7988,1.5773e-05 +thorsen2017,0.8532,1.5963e-05 +thorsen2017,0.8986,1.6104e-05 +thorsen2017,0.944,1.6388e-05 +thorsen2017,0.9893,1.6815e-05 +thorsen2017,1.0347,1.7477e-05 +thorsen2017,1.0892,1.8425e-05 +thorsen2017,1.1346,1.9610e-05 +thorsen2017,1.1799,2.1172e-05 +thorsen2017,1.2254,2.2829e-05 +thorsen2017,1.2798,2.4488e-05 +thorsen2017,1.3252,2.6004e-05 +thorsen2017,1.3707,2.7329e-05 +thorsen2017,1.4161,2.8419e-05 +thorsen2017,1.4613,2.9365e-05 +thorsen2017,1.5159,3.0171e-05 +thorsen2017,1.5613,3.0787e-05 +thorsen2017,1.6067,3.1355e-05 +thorsen2017,1.6521,3.1877e-05 +thorsen2017,1.7065,3.2444e-05 +thorsen2017,1.7518,3.3060e-05 +thorsen2017,1.7973,3.3866e-05 +thorsen2017,1.8426,3.4718e-05 +thorsen2017,1.888,3.5666e-05 +thorsen2017,1.9425,3.6613e-05 +thorsen2017,1.9879,3.7560e-05 +thorsen2017,2.0332,3.8460e-05 +thorsen2017,2.0788,3.9313e-05 +thorsen2017,2.1331,4.0165e-05 +thorsen2017,2.1784,4.1065e-05 +thorsen2017,2.224,4.2059e-05 +thorsen2017,2.2692,4.3055e-05 +thorsen2017,2.3148,4.4143e-05 +thorsen2017,2.3692,4.5186e-05 +thorsen2017,2.4146,4.6227e-05 +thorsen2017,2.4599,4.7222e-05 +thorsen2017,2.5053,4.8217e-05 +thorsen2017,2.5599,4.9069e-05 +thorsen2017,2.6052,4.9875e-05 +thorsen2017,2.6505,5.0632e-05 +thorsen2017,2.6959,5.1296e-05 +thorsen2017,2.7413,5.1911e-05 +thorsen2017,2.7958,5.2433e-05 +thorsen2017,2.8412,5.2953e-05 +thorsen2017,2.8867,5.3474e-05 +thorsen2017,2.9319,5.3947e-05 +thorsen2017,2.9865,5.4327e-05 +thorsen2017,3.0319,5.4705e-05 +thorsen2017,3.0771,5.4990e-05 +thorsen2017,3.1227,5.5226e-05 +thorsen2017,3.168,5.5417e-05 +thorsen2017,3.2225,5.5510e-05 +thorsen2017,3.2679,5.5559e-05 +thorsen2017,3.3133,5.5510e-05 +thorsen2017,3.3587,5.5417e-05 +thorsen2017,3.4131,5.5274e-05 +thorsen2017,3.4585,5.5084e-05 +thorsen2017,3.5038,5.4753e-05 +thorsen2017,3.5493,5.4374e-05 +thorsen2017,3.6039,5.3947e-05 +thorsen2017,3.6491,5.3427e-05 +thorsen2017,3.6946,5.2905e-05 +thorsen2017,3.74,5.2290e-05 +thorsen2017,3.7854,5.1721e-05 +thorsen2017,3.8398,5.1153e-05 +thorsen2017,3.8852,5.0585e-05 +thorsen2017,3.9306,5.0111e-05 +thorsen2017,3.976,4.9780e-05 +thorsen2017,4.0305,4.9542e-05 +thorsen2017,4.0758,4.9495e-05 +thorsen2017,4.1212,4.9542e-05 +thorsen2017,4.1666,4.9827e-05 +thorsen2017,4.212,5.0254e-05 +thorsen2017,4.2664,5.0774e-05 +thorsen2017,4.3118,5.1437e-05 +thorsen2017,4.3572,5.2148e-05 +thorsen2017,4.4025,5.2905e-05 +thorsen2017,4.4572,5.3664e-05 +thorsen2017,4.5025,5.4421e-05 +thorsen2017,4.5479,5.5179e-05 +thorsen2017,4.5933,5.5889e-05 +thorsen2017,4.6387,5.6553e-05 +thorsen2017,4.6931,5.7121e-05 +thorsen2017,4.7385,5.7642e-05 +thorsen2017,4.7839,5.8116e-05 +thorsen2017,4.8293,5.8542e-05 +thorsen2017,4.8837,5.8827e-05 +thorsen2017,4.9291,5.9110e-05 +thorsen2017,4.9744,5.9252e-05 +thorsen2017,5.0199,5.9395e-05 +thorsen2017,5.1199,5.9395e-05 +thorsen2017,5.1651,5.9252e-05 +thorsen2017,5.2104,5.9110e-05 +thorsen2017,5.256,5.8827e-05 +thorsen2017,5.3104,5.8542e-05 +thorsen2017,5.3558,5.8163e-05 +thorsen2017,5.4012,5.7784e-05 +thorsen2017,5.4466,5.7311e-05 +thorsen2017,5.4919,5.6789e-05 +thorsen2017,5.5463,5.6221e-05 +thorsen2017,5.5918,5.5652e-05 +thorsen2017,5.6371,5.5037e-05 +thorsen2017,5.6826,5.4374e-05 +thorsen2017,5.737,5.3711e-05 +thorsen2017,5.7824,5.3048e-05 +thorsen2017,5.8278,5.2384e-05 +thorsen2017,5.9185,5.0964e-05 +thorsen2017,5.973,5.0300e-05 +thorsen2017,6.0186,4.9591e-05 +thorsen2017,6.0637,4.8927e-05 +thorsen2017,6.1093,4.8311e-05 +thorsen2017,6.2091,4.7270e-05 +thorsen2017,6.2544,4.6796e-05 +thorsen2017,6.2999,4.6370e-05 +thorsen2017,6.3453,4.6038e-05 +thorsen2017,6.3997,4.5801e-05 +thorsen2017,6.4451,4.5611e-05 +thorsen2017,6.4905,4.5469e-05 +thorsen2017,6.5358,4.5469e-05 +thorsen2017,6.5905,4.5518e-05 +thorsen2017,6.6357,4.5659e-05 +thorsen2017,6.6811,4.5896e-05 +thorsen2017,6.7266,4.6227e-05 +thorsen2017,6.7809,4.6654e-05 +thorsen2017,6.8264,4.7080e-05 +thorsen2017,6.8718,4.7601e-05 +thorsen2017,6.9172,4.8122e-05 +thorsen2017,6.9625,4.8738e-05 +thorsen2017,7.017,4.9400e-05 +thorsen2017,7.0624,5.0064e-05 +thorsen2017,7.1078,5.0774e-05 +thorsen2017,7.1531,5.1532e-05 +thorsen2017,7.2076,5.2290e-05 +thorsen2017,7.253,5.3048e-05 +thorsen2017,7.2984,5.3853e-05 +thorsen2017,7.3438,5.4705e-05 +thorsen2017,7.3891,5.5510e-05 +thorsen2017,7.4436,5.6269e-05 +thorsen2017,7.4892,5.7027e-05 +thorsen2017,7.5345,5.7784e-05 +thorsen2017,7.5799,5.8447e-05 +thorsen2017,7.6343,5.9110e-05 +thorsen2017,7.6797,5.9679e-05 +thorsen2017,7.7249,6.0247e-05 +thorsen2017,7.7705,6.0768e-05 +thorsen2017,7.8159,6.1242e-05 +thorsen2017,7.8703,6.1669e-05 +thorsen2017,7.9157,6.1999e-05 +thorsen2017,7.9611,6.2284e-05 +thorsen2017,8.0065,6.2521e-05 +thorsen2017,8.061,6.2662e-05 +thorsen2017,8.1063,6.2805e-05 +thorsen2017,8.1517,6.2899e-05 +thorsen2017,8.1971,6.2947e-05 +thorsen2017,8.2969,6.2947e-05 +thorsen2017,8.3424,6.2805e-05 +thorsen2017,8.3878,6.2615e-05 +thorsen2017,8.433,6.2379e-05 +thorsen2017,8.4876,6.2047e-05 +thorsen2017,8.533,6.1669e-05 +thorsen2017,8.5784,6.1242e-05 +thorsen2017,8.6238,6.0768e-05 +thorsen2017,8.6692,6.0200e-05 +thorsen2017,8.7236,5.9631e-05 +thorsen2017,8.769,5.9015e-05 +thorsen2017,8.8144,5.8400e-05 +thorsen2017,8.8597,5.7737e-05 +thorsen2017,8.9142,5.7027e-05 +thorsen2017,8.9598,5.6315e-05 +thorsen2017,9.0049,5.5605e-05 +thorsen2017,9.0505,5.4895e-05 +thorsen2017,9.0957,5.4185e-05 +thorsen2017,9.1504,5.3474e-05 +thorsen2017,9.1957,5.2763e-05 +thorsen2017,9.2411,5.2100e-05 +thorsen2017,9.2865,5.1437e-05 +thorsen2017,9.3409,5.0774e-05 +thorsen2017,9.3863,5.0159e-05 +thorsen2017,9.4316,4.9591e-05 +thorsen2017,9.4772,4.9021e-05 +thorsen2017,9.5224,4.8501e-05 +thorsen2017,9.5229,4.8501e-05 +thorsen2017,9.5775,4.8028e-05 +thorsen2017,9.6227,4.7553e-05 +thorsen2017,9.6683,4.7174e-05 +thorsen2017,9.7136,4.6795e-05 +thorsen2017,9.7681,4.6416e-05 +thorsen2017,9.8135,4.6133e-05 +thorsen2017,9.8589,4.5848e-05 +thorsen2017,9.9042,4.5611e-05 +thorsen2017,9.9496,4.5374e-05 +thorsen2017,10.0041,4.5233e-05 +thorsen2017,10.0495,4.5090e-05 +thorsen2017,10.0948,4.4948e-05 +thorsen2017,10.1402,4.4853e-05 +thorsen2017,10.1947,4.4758e-05 +thorsen2017,10.2401,4.4664e-05 +thorsen2017,10.2856,4.4617e-05 +thorsen2017,10.331,4.4569e-05 +thorsen2017,10.3853,4.4474e-05 +thorsen2017,10.4308,4.4427e-05 +thorsen2017,10.476,4.4381e-05 +thorsen2017,10.5216,4.4332e-05 +thorsen2017,10.567,4.4285e-05 +thorsen2017,10.6214,4.4190e-05 +thorsen2017,10.6667,4.4142e-05 +thorsen2017,10.7122,4.4049e-05 +thorsen2017,10.7576,4.4001e-05 +thorsen2017,10.8121,4.3906e-05 +thorsen2017,10.8574,4.3812e-05 +thorsen2017,10.9028,4.3669e-05 +thorsen2017,10.9482,4.3575e-05 +thorsen2017,10.9935,4.3433e-05 +thorsen2017,11.048,4.3290e-05 +thorsen2017,11.1389,4.2912e-05 +thorsen2017,11.1841,4.2722e-05 +thorsen2017,11.2387,4.2486e-05 +thorsen2017,11.2841,4.2248e-05 +thorsen2017,11.3295,4.2011e-05 +thorsen2017,11.3748,4.1727e-05 +thorsen2017,11.4203,4.1443e-05 +thorsen2017,11.4747,4.1112e-05 +thorsen2017,11.5201,4.0780e-05 +thorsen2017,11.5655,4.0496e-05 +thorsen2017,11.6108,4.0164e-05 +thorsen2017,11.6653,3.9880e-05 +thorsen2017,11.7107,3.9549e-05 +thorsen2017,11.7561,3.9265e-05 +thorsen2017,11.8015,3.8981e-05 +thorsen2017,11.8468,3.8696e-05 +thorsen2017,11.9015,3.8412e-05 +thorsen2017,11.9466,3.8175e-05 +thorsen2017,11.9922,3.7891e-05 +thorsen2017,12.0376,3.7655e-05 +thorsen2017,12.0921,3.7417e-05 +thorsen2017,12.1374,3.7180e-05 +thorsen2017,12.1827,3.6896e-05 +thorsen2017,12.2281,3.6660e-05 +thorsen2017,12.2735,3.6423e-05 +thorsen2017,12.328,3.6233e-05 +thorsen2017,12.4641,3.5523e-05 +thorsen2017,12.5185,3.5286e-05 +thorsen2017,12.564,3.5049e-05 +thorsen2017,12.6096,3.4813e-05 +thorsen2017,12.6549,3.4528e-05 +thorsen2017,12.7001,3.4291e-05 +thorsen2017,12.7547,3.4055e-05 +thorsen2017,12.8001,3.3770e-05 +thorsen2017,12.8454,3.3486e-05 +thorsen2017,12.8909,3.3249e-05 +thorsen2017,12.9454,3.2965e-05 +thorsen2017,12.9908,3.2681e-05 +thorsen2017,13.036,3.2397e-05 +thorsen2017,13.1269,3.1828e-05 +thorsen2017,13.1814,3.1544e-05 +thorsen2017,13.2267,3.1260e-05 +thorsen2017,13.2721,3.0976e-05 +thorsen2017,13.3175,3.0692e-05 +thorsen2017,13.3719,3.0408e-05 +thorsen2017,13.4174,3.0123e-05 +thorsen2017,13.4629,2.9839e-05 +thorsen2017,13.5082,2.9555e-05 +thorsen2017,13.5627,2.9224e-05 +thorsen2017,13.608,2.8939e-05 +thorsen2017,13.6988,2.8372e-05 +thorsen2017,13.7441,2.8086e-05 +thorsen2017,13.7987,2.7803e-05 +thorsen2017,13.844,2.7518e-05 +thorsen2017,13.8894,2.7234e-05 +thorsen2017,13.9348,2.6950e-05 +thorsen2017,13.9892,2.6666e-05 +thorsen2017,14.0348,2.6429e-05 +thorsen2017,14.08,2.6145e-05 +thorsen2017,14.1254,2.5908e-05 +thorsen2017,14.1709,2.5623e-05 +thorsen2017,14.2252,2.5387e-05 +thorsen2017,14.2708,2.5198e-05 +thorsen2017,14.3161,2.4961e-05 +thorsen2017,14.3615,2.4771e-05 +thorsen2017,14.4159,2.4582e-05 +thorsen2017,14.5067,2.4297e-05 +thorsen2017,14.5521,2.4155e-05 +thorsen2017,14.5974,2.4013e-05 +thorsen2017,14.6519,2.3919e-05 +thorsen2017,14.6973,2.3871e-05 +thorsen2017,14.7427,2.3777e-05 +thorsen2017,14.7883,2.3729e-05 +thorsen2017,14.8425,2.3682e-05 +thorsen2017,14.9334,2.3587e-05 +thorsen2017,14.9788,2.3540e-05 +thorsen2017,15.0242,2.3493e-05 +thorsen2017,15.0786,2.3493e-05 +thorsen2017,15.1694,2.3397e-05 +thorsen2017,15.2148,2.3350e-05 +thorsen2017,15.2692,2.3302e-05 +thorsen2017,15.3146,2.3256e-05 +thorsen2017,15.36,2.3256e-05 +thorsen2017,15.4054,2.3208e-05 +thorsen2017,15.4507,2.3161e-05 +thorsen2017,15.5052,2.3114e-05 +thorsen2017,15.5506,2.3114e-05 +thorsen2017,15.596,2.3066e-05 +thorsen2017,15.6414,2.3018e-05 +thorsen2017,15.6958,2.2972e-05 +thorsen2017,15.7411,2.2972e-05 +thorsen2017,15.7867,2.2923e-05 +thorsen2017,15.8321,2.2923e-05 +thorsen2017,15.8775,2.2877e-05 +thorsen2017,16.0681,2.2877e-05 +thorsen2017,16.1226,2.2830e-05 +thorsen2017,16.4039,2.2830e-05 +thorsen2017,16.4495,2.2782e-05 +thorsen2017,16.4946,2.2735e-05 +thorsen2017,16.5491,2.2687e-05 +thorsen2017,16.5944,2.2593e-05 +thorsen2017,16.6401,2.2498e-05 +thorsen2017,16.6854,2.2403e-05 +thorsen2017,16.7308,2.2308e-05 +thorsen2017,16.7853,2.2214e-05 +thorsen2017,16.8306,2.2118e-05 +thorsen2017,16.8759,2.2025e-05 +thorsen2017,16.9214,2.2025e-05 +thorsen2017,16.9759,2.2071e-05 +thorsen2017,17.0213,2.2118e-05 +thorsen2017,17.0666,2.2214e-05 +thorsen2017,17.1119,2.2355e-05 +thorsen2017,17.1664,2.2498e-05 +thorsen2017,17.212,2.2640e-05 +thorsen2017,17.2572,2.2830e-05 +thorsen2017,17.3028,2.3066e-05 +thorsen2017,17.3481,2.3256e-05 +thorsen2017,17.4025,2.3493e-05 +thorsen2017,17.4477,2.3729e-05 +thorsen2017,17.4933,2.4013e-05 +thorsen2017,17.5388,2.4250e-05 +thorsen2017,17.5932,2.4534e-05 +thorsen2017,17.6386,2.4771e-05 +thorsen2017,17.6839,2.5055e-05 +thorsen2017,17.7293,2.5340e-05 +thorsen2017,17.7746,2.5577e-05 +thorsen2017,17.8292,2.5860e-05 +thorsen2017,17.8747,2.6097e-05 +thorsen2017,17.9199,2.6334e-05 +thorsen2017,17.9652,2.6619e-05 +thorsen2017,18.0197,2.6807e-05 +thorsen2017,18.0651,2.7045e-05 +thorsen2017,18.1107,2.7281e-05 +thorsen2017,18.2014,2.7660e-05 +thorsen2017,18.2558,2.7850e-05 +thorsen2017,18.3013,2.8040e-05 +thorsen2017,18.3466,2.8181e-05 +thorsen2017,18.392,2.8323e-05 +thorsen2017,18.4467,2.8418e-05 +thorsen2017,18.4919,2.8560e-05 +thorsen2017,18.5372,2.8608e-05 +thorsen2017,18.5826,2.8702e-05 +thorsen2017,18.628,2.8702e-05 +thorsen2017,18.6827,2.8750e-05 +thorsen2017,18.7278,2.8750e-05 +thorsen2017,18.7732,2.8702e-05 +thorsen2017,18.8188,2.8655e-05 +thorsen2017,18.8732,2.8560e-05 +thorsen2017,18.9185,2.8418e-05 +thorsen2017,18.9639,2.8277e-05 +thorsen2017,19.0094,2.8134e-05 +thorsen2017,19.0547,2.7897e-05 +thorsen2017,19.1091,2.7660e-05 +thorsen2017,19.1546,2.7376e-05 +thorsen2017,19.2,2.7092e-05 +thorsen2017,19.2452,2.6761e-05 +thorsen2017,19.2998,2.6429e-05 +thorsen2017,19.3452,2.6050e-05 +thorsen2017,19.3907,2.5672e-05 +thorsen2017,19.4812,2.4818e-05 +thorsen2017,19.5359,2.4346e-05 +thorsen2017,19.5813,2.3919e-05 +thorsen2017,19.6266,2.3445e-05 +thorsen2017,19.6721,2.2972e-05 +thorsen2017,19.7265,2.2498e-05 +thorsen2017,19.7719,2.1976e-05 +thorsen2017,19.8171,2.1503e-05 +thorsen2017,19.8626,2.0982e-05 +thorsen2017,19.9081,2.0509e-05 +thorsen2017,19.9625,2.0130e-05 +thorsen2017,20.0079,1.9751e-05 +thorsen2017,20.0533,1.9467e-05 +thorsen2017,20.0986,1.9276e-05 +thorsen2017,20.1531,1.9183e-05 +thorsen2017,20.1986,1.9183e-05 +thorsen2017,20.244,1.9276e-05 +thorsen2017,20.2894,1.9467e-05 +thorsen2017,20.3438,1.9703e-05 +thorsen2017,20.389,2.0035e-05 +thorsen2017,20.4345,2.0414e-05 +thorsen2017,20.48,2.0887e-05 +thorsen2017,20.5254,2.1456e-05 +thorsen2017,20.5798,2.2071e-05 +thorsen2017,20.6252,2.2687e-05 +thorsen2017,20.6706,2.3397e-05 +thorsen2017,20.7159,2.4108e-05 +thorsen2017,20.7703,2.4866e-05 +thorsen2017,20.8158,2.5623e-05 +thorsen2017,20.8612,2.6381e-05 +thorsen2017,20.9065,2.7139e-05 +thorsen2017,20.9519,2.7897e-05 +thorsen2017,21.0065,2.8655e-05 +thorsen2017,21.0519,2.9413e-05 +thorsen2017,21.0973,3.0217e-05 +thorsen2017,21.1426,3.0976e-05 +thorsen2017,21.1971,3.1781e-05 +thorsen2017,21.2424,3.2492e-05 +thorsen2017,21.2878,3.3249e-05 +thorsen2017,21.3333,3.3912e-05 +thorsen2017,21.3787,3.4576e-05 +thorsen2017,21.4331,3.5192e-05 +thorsen2017,21.4784,3.5807e-05 +thorsen2017,21.5237,3.6327e-05 +thorsen2017,21.5693,3.6802e-05 +thorsen2017,21.6237,3.7228e-05 +thorsen2017,21.6691,3.7606e-05 +thorsen2017,21.7144,3.7938e-05 +thorsen2017,21.7598,3.8175e-05 +thorsen2017,21.8052,3.8364e-05 +thorsen2017,21.8595,3.8507e-05 +thorsen2017,21.9052,3.8554e-05 +thorsen2017,21.9505,3.8554e-05 +thorsen2017,21.9959,3.8459e-05 +thorsen2017,22.0501,3.8317e-05 +thorsen2017,22.0955,3.8080e-05 +thorsen2017,22.1409,3.7797e-05 +thorsen2017,22.1865,3.7417e-05 +thorsen2017,22.2319,3.6991e-05 +thorsen2017,22.2863,3.6470e-05 +thorsen2017,22.3316,3.5949e-05 +thorsen2017,22.377,3.5334e-05 +thorsen2017,22.4224,3.4670e-05 +thorsen2017,22.477,3.3960e-05 +thorsen2017,22.5225,3.3154e-05 +thorsen2017,22.5676,3.2302e-05 +thorsen2017,22.613,3.1402e-05 +thorsen2017,22.6584,3.0454e-05 +thorsen2017,22.7129,2.9460e-05 +thorsen2017,22.7582,2.8418e-05 +thorsen2017,22.8036,2.7281e-05 +thorsen2017,22.8492,2.6145e-05 +thorsen2017,22.9036,2.4961e-05 +thorsen2017,22.9488,2.3729e-05 +thorsen2017,22.9943,2.2450e-05 +thorsen2017,23.0398,2.1171e-05 +thorsen2017,23.0851,1.9798e-05 +thorsen2017,23.1395,1.8424e-05 +thorsen2017,23.185,1.7003e-05 +thorsen2017,23.2304,1.5535e-05 +thorsen2017,23.2757,1.4067e-05 +thorsen2017,23.3301,1.2551e-05 +thorsen2017,23.3756,1.1035e-05 +thorsen2017,23.421,9.4725e-06 +thorsen2017,23.4663,7.9572e-06 +thorsen2017,23.5117,6.3469e-06 +thorsen2017,23.5663,4.7834e-06 +thorsen2017,23.6117,3.2199e-06 +thorsen2017,23.6568,1.6103e-06 +thorsen2017,23.7025,4.6794e-08 diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_uniform_current.py b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_uniform_current.py deleted file mode 100644 index 69b982b..0000000 --- a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_uniform_current.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,207 +0,0 @@ -#!/usr/bin/env python3 -# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 -# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University -"""Cross-flow VIV of the SJTU truncated steel catenary riser in a 0.2 m/s uniform current. - -The model test of Wang et al. (2014), as used by Thorsen et al. (2017, Sec. 5.1) to verify the -time-domain synchronisation model that CableDyn's cross-flow VIV implements: writes the deck, runs -it, and compares the r.m.s. of the dynamic cross-flow strain along the riser with the 25 measured -values (Thorsen et al. 2017, Fig. 17) and the dominant strain frequency 8.25 m from the lower end -with the measured 1.00 Hz. - - python wang_scr_uniform_current.py path/to/cabledyn.exe WORKDIR [--segments 200] - [--dt 0.005] [--tmax 150] [--t0 30] [--summary DIR] - -Sources: - J. Wang, S. Fu, R. Baarholm, J. Wu, C.M. Larsen (2014), Fatigue damage of a steel catenary - riser from vortex-induced vibration caused by vessel motions, Marine Structures 39, 131-156, - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2014.07.002 (Table 2: the model riser) - M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2017), Non-linear time domain analysis of cross-flow - vortex-induced vibrations, Marine Structures 51, 134-151, - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2016.10.007 (Table 1, Sec. 5.1, Fig. 17: the measured - r.m.s. strains, read from the vector figure) -""" - -from __future__ import annotations - -import argparse -import csv -import hashlib -import json -import os -import shutil -import subprocess -from pathlib import Path - -import numpy as np - -HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent - -# Thorsen et al. (2017) Table 1 / Wang et al. (2014) Table 2: the truncated model riser. The -# outer coating, PPR pipe and copper core are solid: no internal water is added to the 0.69 kg/m. -LENGTH = 23.71 # m -X_TOP = 21.0425 # m, horizontal distance of the top joint from the lower end -H_TOP = 9.0 # m, height of the top joint above the fake seabed -DIAMETER = 0.024 # m -MASS = 0.69 # kg/m -EI = 10.5 # N m^2 -EA = 6.66e5 # N -# Thorsen et al. (2017) Sec. 5.1: seabed springs of 1 (kN/m)/m in compression, friction 0.2; -# their coefficient set for this case: Cv 0.7 (Re about 3000), f0 0.18, df 0.08, CD 1.2, CM 2 -SEABED_K_PER_LENGTH = 1000.0 # N/m per m of riser -FRICTION = 0.2 -CV, F0, DF, CD, CA = 0.7, 0.18, 0.08, 1.2, 1.0 -CURRENT = 0.2 # m/s, uniform, in the riser plane from the lower end towards the top -WATER_DEPTH = ( - 9.5 # m: the top joint 0.5 m below the surface (not given; the current is uniform) -) -MEASURED_FREQUENCY = ( - 1.00 # Hz, 8.25 m from the lower end (Thorsen et al. 2017, Fig. 18) -) -FREQUENCY_STATION = 8.25 # m from the lower end - - -def write_deck(case: Path, segments: int, dt: float, tmax: float) -> Path: - case.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) - (case / "current_profile.txt").write_text( - f"z ux uy uz\n(m) (m/s) (m/s) (m/s)\n{-WATER_DEPTH:.2f} {CURRENT} 0 0\n0.0 {CURRENT} 0 0\n", - encoding="utf-8", - ) - outs = "".join(f"CurvX1N{j}\nCurvY1N{j}\n" for j in range(1, segments + 2)) - text = f"""--------------------- CableDyn Input File --------------------------------- -Wang et al. (2014) truncated SCR, 0.2 m/s uniform current (Thorsen et al. 2017, case 1) ------------------------ LINE TYPES ------------------------------------------ -TypeName Diam Mass EA BA EI Cd_n Cd_t Ca_n Ca_t Cl dF cF -(-) (m) (kg/m) (N) (N-s) (N-m^2) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) -scr {DIAMETER} {MASS} {EA:.6e} 0.0 {EI} {CD} 0.0 {CA} 0.0 {CV} {DF} {F0} ------------------------ POINTS ---------------------------------------------- -ID Attachment X Y Z M V CdA CA -(-) (-) (m) (m) (m) (kg) (m^3) (m^2) (-) -1 Coupled {X_TOP} 0.0 {-(WATER_DEPTH - H_TOP):.4f} 0 0 0 0 -2 Fixed 0.0 0.0 {-WATER_DEPTH:.4f} 0 0 0 0 ------------------------ LINES ----------------------------------------------- -ID LineType AttachA AttachB UnstrLen NumSegs Outputs -(-) (-) (-) (-) (m) (-) (-) -1 scr 1 2 {LENGTH} {segments} - ----------------------- OPTIONS ---------------------------------------------- -1025.0 rhoW -9.80665 g -{WATER_DEPTH} WtrDpth -{SEABED_K_PER_LENGTH / DIAMETER:.6e} kBot -{FRICTION} frictionMu -{dt:.6f} dtM -{round(tmax / dt) * dt:.6f} TMax -1 Currents ----------------------- OUTPUTS ----------------------------------------------- -{outs}END -------------------------- need this line -------------------------------------- -""" - deck = case / "wang_scr.dat" - deck.write_text(text, encoding="utf-8") - return deck - - -def cross_flow_strain(out: Path, t0: float): - """Arc length from the lower end, r.m.s. dynamic cross-flow strain, the strain histories. - - The cross-flow (out-of-plane) curvature is the section component with no static mean (the - in-plane one carries the catenary curvature); the strain is kappa D/2 at the outer surface, - as Fig. 17 reports it. - """ - lines = out.read_text(encoding="utf-8").splitlines() - head = lines[1].split() - a = np.loadtxt(lines[3:]) - t = a[:, 0] - keep = t > t0 - nodes = sorted({int(c[7:]) for c in head if c.startswith("CurvX1N")}) - cx = np.array([a[keep, head.index(f"CurvX1N{j}")] for j in nodes]) - cy = np.array([a[keep, head.index(f"CurvY1N{j}")] for j in nodes]) - cf = cx if np.abs(cx.mean(axis=1)).mean() < np.abs(cy.mean(axis=1)).mean() else cy - strain = (cf - cf.mean(axis=1, keepdims=True)) * DIAMETER / 2.0 - s = LENGTH - (np.array(nodes) - 1) * LENGTH / (len(nodes) - 1) - order = np.argsort(s) - return ( - s[order], - np.sqrt((strain[order] ** 2).mean(axis=1)), - strain[order], - t[keep][1] - t[keep][0], - ) - - -def main() -> None: - ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) - ap.add_argument("exe") - ap.add_argument("workdir") - ap.add_argument("--segments", type=int, default=200) - ap.add_argument("--dt", type=float, default=0.005) - ap.add_argument("--tmax", type=float, default=150.0) - ap.add_argument("--t0", type=float, default=30.0) - ap.add_argument( - "--summary", - default=None, - help="directory for the comparison CSV and summary JSON", - ) - a = ap.parse_args() - # the run starts in the case folder: resolve the executable against the invocation directory - # (or PATH, for a bare name) first - found = a.exe if Path(a.exe).is_file() else shutil.which(a.exe) - if found is None: - raise SystemExit(f"CableDyn executable not found: {a.exe}") - exe = Path(found).resolve() - case = Path(a.workdir) / f"wang_scr_n{a.segments}_dt{a.dt:g}" - deck = write_deck(case, a.segments, a.dt, a.tmax) - env = dict(os.environ, OMP_NUM_THREADS="1") - proc = subprocess.run( - [str(exe), deck.name, "out"], - cwd=case, - capture_output=True, - text=True, - env=env, - check=False, - ) - if proc.returncode != 0: - raise SystemExit(f"CableDyn failed ({proc.returncode}):\n{proc.stderr[-2000:]}") - s, rms, strain, dt = cross_flow_strain(case / "out.out", a.t0) - with open(HERE / "measured_rms_strain.csv", encoding="utf-8") as fh: - measured = [ - (float(r["s_m"]), float(r["rms_strain"])) for r in csv.DictReader(fh) - ] - sm = np.array([m[0] for m in measured]) - em = np.array([m[1] for m in measured]) - at = np.interp(sm, s, rms) - j = int(np.argmin(np.abs(s - FREQUENCY_STATION))) - spec = np.abs(np.fft.rfft(strain[j] * np.hanning(strain.shape[1]))) - freq = np.fft.rfftfreq(strain.shape[1], dt) - f_dom = float(freq[1 + int(np.argmax(spec[1:]))]) - summary = { - "segments": a.segments, - "dt_s": a.dt, - "analysis_window_s": [a.t0, a.tmax], - "frequency_resolution_hz": float(freq[1]), - "max_rms_strain": float(rms.max()), - "measured_max_rms_strain": float(em.max()), - "max_ratio": float(rms.max() / em.max()), - "mean_ratio_at_stations": float(np.mean(at / em)), - "rms_log_error_at_stations": float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.log(at / em) ** 2))), - "dominant_frequency_hz": f_dom, - "measured_dominant_frequency_hz": MEASURED_FREQUENCY, - "executable_sha256": hashlib.sha256(exe.read_bytes()).hexdigest(), - } - print(json.dumps(summary, indent=2)) - if a.summary: - out = Path(a.summary) - out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) - with open( - out / "rms_strain_comparison.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8" - ) as fh: - w = csv.writer(fh, lineterminator="\n") - w.writerow(["s_m", "measured_rms_strain", "cabledyn_rms_strain", "ratio"]) - for x, m, c in zip(sm, em, at, strict=True): - w.writerow([f"{x:.4f}", f"{m:.4e}", f"{c:.4e}", f"{c / m:.4f}"]) - (out / "summary.json").write_text( - json.dumps(summary, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n" - ) - - -if __name__ == "__main__": - main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_viv.py b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_viv.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9451561 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/wang_scr/wang_scr_viv.py @@ -0,0 +1,545 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""Cross-flow VIV of the SJTU truncated steel catenary riser: uniform current and heave. + +The model test of Wang et al. (2014) as Thorsen et al. (2017) use it to verify the time-domain +synchronisation model that CableDyn's cross-flow VIV implements, in its two parts: + +- current: a 0.2 m/s uniform in-plane current (Thorsen et al. 2017, Sec. 5.1): the r.m.s. of + the dynamic cross-flow strain along the riser against the 25 measured values (their Fig. 17) + and the dominant strain frequency 8.25 m from the lower end against the measured 1.00 Hz; +- heave: still water, the upper end moved along the measured top trajectory (Sec. 5.2, period + 5.96 s, their Fig. 19): the r.m.s. cross-flow strain band-passed from 4 times the motion + frequency to 50 Hz, as Wang et al. (2014) process the measurement, against the 25 measured + values of their Fig. 22, with and without a VIV FRAME filter. + +Writes a deck per run, runs them in parallel (a run whose folder holds the same input files and +executable is reused) and compares. The default runs are the committed record: the two primary +runs, their convergence runs (half the time step, twice the elements) and the frame-filter +sensitivity of the heave case. + + python wang_scr_viv.py path/to/cabledyn.exe WORKDIR [--runs NAME,...] [--jobs N] + [--keep] [--summary DIR] + +Sources: + J. Wang, S. Fu, R. Baarholm, J. Wu, C.M. Larsen (2014), Fatigue damage of a steel catenary + riser from vortex-induced vibration caused by vessel motions, Marine Structures 39, 131-156, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2014.07.002 (Table 2: the model riser; Sec. 3.1: the + band-pass of the measured strain) + M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2017), Non-linear time domain analysis of cross-flow + vortex-induced vibrations, Marine Structures 51, 134-151, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2016.10.007 (Table 1; Secs. 5.1 and 5.2; Figs. 17, 19 + and 22, read by extract_thorsen2017.py) +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import csv +import hashlib +import json +import math +import os +import shutil +import subprocess +from concurrent.futures import ThreadPoolExecutor +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent + +# Thorsen et al. (2017) Table 1 / Wang et al. (2014) Table 2: the truncated model riser. The +# outer coating, PPR pipe and copper core are solid: no internal water is added to the 0.69 kg/m. +# Wang et al. give EA 6.67e5 N; Thorsen et al.'s 6.66e5 N is used. +LENGTH = 23.71 # m +X_TOP = 21.0425 # m, horizontal distance of the top joint from the lower end +H_TOP = 9.0 # m, height of the top joint above the fake seabed +DIAMETER = 0.024 # m +MASS = 0.69 # kg/m +EI = 10.5 # N m^2 +EA = 6.66e5 # N +# Thorsen et al. (2017) Sec. 5.1: seabed springs of 1 (kN/m)/m in compression, friction 0.2 +SEABED_K_PER_LENGTH = 1000.0 # N/m per m of riser +FRICTION = 0.2 +# Their coefficient sets: C_v 0.7 in the current (Re about 3000), 0.8 in heave (Re about 4000); +# f0 0.18, df 0.08, cross-flow only; C_D 1.2, C_M 2 (C_a 1) +CV = {"current": 0.7, "heave": 0.8} +F0, DF, CD, CA = 0.18, 0.08, 1.2, 1.0 +CURRENT = 0.2 # m/s, uniform, in the riser plane from the lower end towards the top +WATER_DEPTH = 9.5 # m: the top joint 0.5 m below the surface (not given) +FREQUENCY_STATION = 8.25 # m from the lower end +MEASURED_FREQUENCY = { + "current": 1.00, + "heave": 1.0, +} # Hz: Fig. 18; "close to 1 Hz" (Fig. 23) +RAMP_PERIODS = 2.0 # the top motion is ramped in over two periods +BAND_HIGH = 50.0 # Hz, the upper end of Wang et al.'s band-pass +# The two response branches of the heave case: spectral shares of the band-passed strain 8.25 m +# from the lower end +BRANCHES = {"0.80-0.95": (0.80, 0.95), "0.95-1.10": (0.95, 1.10)} +PART = { + "current": {"tmax": 150.0, "t0": 30.0, "fig": "thorsen2017_fig17.csv"}, + "heave": {"tmax": 200.0, "t0": 40.0, "fig": "thorsen2017_fig22.csv"}, +} +ANALYSIS = "1" # part of the reuse key: bump when analyse() changes + +# name: (part, role, segments, dt, Tf); the first of each part is its primary run +RUNS: dict[str, tuple[str, str, int, float, float]] = { + "current": ("current", "primary", 200, 0.005, 0.0), + "current_dt2": ("current", "convergence: half the time step", 200, 0.0025, 0.0), + "current_n400": ("current", "convergence: twice the elements", 400, 0.005, 0.0), + "heave": ("heave", "primary (no VIV FRAME)", 200, 0.005, 0.0), + "heave_dt2": ("heave", "convergence: half the time step", 200, 0.0025, 0.0), + "heave_n400": ("heave", "convergence: twice the elements", 400, 0.005, 0.0), + "heave_tf0.35": ("heave", "VIV FRAME sensitivity", 200, 0.005, 0.35), + "heave_tf0.5": ("heave", "VIV FRAME sensitivity", 200, 0.005, 0.5), + "heave_tf0.75": ("heave", "VIV FRAME sensitivity", 200, 0.005, 0.75), + "heave_tf1": ("heave", "VIV FRAME sensitivity", 200, 0.005, 1.0), + "heave_tf0.5_dt2": ( + "heave", + "VIV FRAME sensitivity, half the time step", + 200, + 0.0025, + 0.5, + ), +} + + +def top_motion() -> dict: + """The sinusoids fitted to the measured top motion (extract_thorsen2017.py).""" + return json.loads((HERE / "thorsen2017_fig19_fit.json").read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + + +def deck_files(part: str, segments: int, dt: float, tf: float) -> dict[str, str]: + tmax = round(PART[part]["tmax"] / dt) * dt + z_top = -(WATER_DEPTH - H_TOP) + frame = ( + "--------------------- VIV FRAME ----------------------------------------\n" + f"TypeName Tf\n(-) (s)\nscr {tf:g}\n" + if tf > 0 + else "" + ) + drive = "1 Currents" if part == "current" else "motion.txt motionFile" + nodes = segments + 1 + # The cross-flow curvature at every node; the in-plane one at every tenth, to check which + # component is which (analyse()) + outs = "FairTen1\n" + "".join(f"CurvY1N{j}\n" for j in range(1, nodes + 1)) + outs += "".join(f"CurvX1N{j}\n" for j in range(1, nodes + 1, 10)) + title = ( + f"{CURRENT} m/s uniform current (Thorsen et al. 2017, case 1)" + if part == "current" + else "heave-induced VIV in still water (Thorsen et al. 2017, case 2)" + ) + files = { + "wang.dat": f"""--------------------- CableDyn Input File --------------------------------- +Wang et al. (2014) truncated SCR, {title} +----------------------- LINE TYPES ------------------------------------------ +TypeName Diam Mass EA BA EI Cd_n Cd_t Ca_n Ca_t Cl dF cF +(-) (m) (kg/m) (N) (N-s) (N-m^2) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) +scr {DIAMETER} {MASS} {EA:.6e} 0.0 {EI} {CD} 0.0 {CA} 0.0 {CV[part]} {DF} {F0} +----------------------- POINTS ---------------------------------------------- +ID Attachment X Y Z M V CdA CA +(-) (-) (m) (m) (m) (kg) (m^3) (m^2) (-) +1 Coupled {X_TOP} 0.0 {z_top:.4f} 0 0 0 0 +2 Fixed 0.0 0.0 {-WATER_DEPTH:.4f} 0 0 0 0 +----------------------- LINES ----------------------------------------------- +ID LineType AttachA AttachB UnstrLen NumSegs Outputs +(-) (-) (-) (-) (m) (-) (-) +1 scr 1 2 {LENGTH} {segments} - +{frame}---------------------- OPTIONS ---------------------------------------------- +1025.0 rhoW +9.80665 g +{WATER_DEPTH} WtrDpth +{SEABED_K_PER_LENGTH / DIAMETER:.6e} kBot +{FRICTION} frictionMu +{dt:.6f} dtM +{tmax:.6f} TMax +{drive} +---------------------- OUTPUTS ----------------------------------------------- +{outs}END +------------------------- need this line -------------------------------------- +""" + } + if part == "current": + files["current_profile.txt"] = ( + f"z ux uy uz\n(m) (m/s) (m/s) (m/s)\n{-WATER_DEPTH:.2f} {CURRENT} 0 0\n" + f"0.0 {CURRENT} 0 0\n" + ) + else: + files["motion.txt"] = motion_text(dt, tmax, z_top) + return files + + +def motion_text(dt: float, tmax: float, z_top: float) -> str: + """The top joint's x and z: the fitted sinusoids about the static position, ramped in over + RAMP_PERIODS periods with a half-cosine, with their exact velocities and accelerations.""" + fit = top_motion() + w = 2.0 * math.pi / fit["period_s"] + ramp = RAMP_PERIODS * fit["period_s"] + rows = ["# time point x y z vx vy vz ax ay az\n"] + for k in range(round(tmax / dt) + 1): + t = k * dt + if t < ramp: + q = math.pi / ramp + r, dr, ddr = ( + 0.5 * (1.0 - math.cos(q * t)), + 0.5 * q * math.sin(q * t), + 0.5 * q * q * math.cos(q * t), + ) + else: + r, dr, ddr = 1.0, 0.0, 0.0 + vals = [] + for comp, base in (("x", X_TOP), ("z", z_top)): + amp, ph = fit[comp]["amp_m"], fit[comp]["phase_rad"] + s, c = math.sin(w * t + ph), math.cos(w * t + ph) + vals.append( + ( + base + amp * r * s, + amp * (dr * s + r * w * c), + amp * (ddr * s + 2.0 * dr * w * c - r * w * w * s), + ) + ) + (x, vx, ax), (z, vz, az) = vals + rows.append( + f"{t:.6f} 1 {x:.9e} 0 {z:.9e} {vx:.9e} 0 {vz:.9e} {ax:.9e} 0 {az:.9e}\n" + ) + return "".join(rows) + + +def share(spec: np.ndarray, f: np.ndarray, lo: float, hi: float) -> float | None: + total = spec.sum() + return float(spec[(f >= lo) & (f < hi)].sum() / total) if total > 0 else None + + +def analyse(out: Path, part: str, t0: float) -> dict: + """r.m.s. cross-flow strain along the riser (arc length s from the lower end) and the + spectrum of the strain 8.25 m from the lower end, over t > t0. + + The section axes of a line not restrained in torsion start at End A with x the projection + of global +z normal to the line, so CurvX is the in-plane curvature (the catenary's) and + CurvY the cross-flow one; this is checked on the static means. The strain is kappa D/2 at + the outer surface, as Figs. 17 and 22 report it. Current: the dynamic part (mean removed). + Heave: band-passed from 4 times the motion frequency to 50 Hz, as Wang et al. (2014, Sec. + 3.1) process the measurement. + """ + with open(out, encoding="utf-8") as fh: + fh.readline() + head = fh.readline().split() + fh.readline() + a = np.loadtxt(fh) + t = a[:, 0] + keep = t > t0 + dt = float(t[1] - t[0]) + nodes = sorted(int(c[7:]) for c in head if c.startswith("CurvY1N")) + cy = np.array([a[keep, head.index(f"CurvY1N{j}")] for j in nodes]) + sampled = sorted(int(c[7:]) for c in head if c.startswith("CurvX1N")) + cx_mean = np.abs( + [a[keep, head.index(f"CurvX1N{j}")].mean() for j in sampled] + ).mean() + cy_mean = np.abs(cy[[nodes.index(j) for j in sampled]].mean(axis=1)).mean() + if not cx_mean > 10.0 * cy_mean: + raise SystemExit( + f"{out}: CurvX is not the in-plane curvature ({cx_mean}, {cy_mean})" + ) + strain = (cy - cy.mean(axis=1, keepdims=True)) * DIAMETER / 2.0 + f = np.fft.rfftfreq(strain.shape[1], dt) + band = None + if part == "heave": + band = (4.0 / top_motion()["period_s"], BAND_HIGH) + sp = np.fft.rfft(strain, axis=1) + sp[:, (f < band[0]) | (f > band[1])] = 0.0 + strain = np.fft.irfft(sp, strain.shape[1], axis=1) + s = LENGTH - (np.array(nodes) - 1) * LENGTH / (len(nodes) - 1) + order = np.argsort(s) + s, strain = s[order], strain[order] + rms = np.sqrt((strain**2).mean(axis=1)) + j = int(np.argmin(np.abs(s - FREQUENCY_STATION))) + spec = np.abs(np.fft.rfft(strain[j] * np.hanning(strain.shape[1]))) ** 2 + inner = ( + (rms[1:-1] > rms[:-2]) & (rms[1:-1] > rms[2:]) & (rms[1:-1] > 0.5 * rms.max()) + ) + res = { + "s_m": s.tolist(), + "rms_strain": rms.tolist(), + "frequency_station_s_m": float(s[j]), + "dominant_frequency_hz": float(f[1 + int(np.argmax(spec[1:]))]), + "frequency_resolution_hz": float(f[1]), + "rms_peaks": int(inner.sum()), + "mean_top_tension_N": float(a[keep, head.index("FairTen1")].mean()), + } + if band is not None: + res["band_hz"] = list(band) + for name, (lo, hi) in BRANCHES.items(): + res[f"share_{name}_hz"] = share(spec, f, lo, hi) + return res + + +def run_case( + exe: Path, folder: Path, files: dict, analyse_out, key: str, keep: bool, sha: str +): + """Write the input files, run the deck and analyse it. A folder that holds the same input + files run by the same executable is not run again: its result is reused when the analysis + key is also the same, and its output is analysed again if it was kept.""" + folder.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + result, out, ran = ( + folder / "result.json", + folder / "wang.out", + folder / "executable_sha256.txt", + ) + same = all( + (folder / n).is_file() and (folder / n).read_text(encoding="utf-8") == v + for n, v in files.items() + ) + if same and result.is_file(): + old = json.loads(result.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + if old.pop("reuse_key", None) == f"{sha}:{key}": + return old + if not ( + same and out.is_file() and ran.is_file() and ran.read_text().strip() == sha + ): + # A run that fails or is interrupted must not leave the previous model's result next + # to the new inputs, where the next attempt would reuse it. + result.unlink(missing_ok=True) + ran.unlink(missing_ok=True) + out.unlink(missing_ok=True) + for n, v in files.items(): + (folder / n).write_text(v, encoding="utf-8", newline="\n") + proc = subprocess.run( + [str(exe), "wang.dat", "wang"], + cwd=folder, + capture_output=True, + text=True, + encoding="utf-8", + errors="replace", + env=dict(os.environ, OMP_NUM_THREADS="1"), + check=False, + ) + (folder / "console.txt").write_text(proc.stdout + proc.stderr, encoding="utf-8") + if proc.returncode != 0: + raise SystemExit(f"{folder}: CableDyn exited with {proc.returncode}") + ran.write_text(sha + "\n", encoding="utf-8") + res = analyse_out(out) + result.write_text( + json.dumps({**res, "reuse_key": f"{sha}:{key}"}, indent=1) + "\n", + encoding="utf-8", + ) + if not keep: + out.unlink() + return res + + +def figure(name: str) -> dict[str, np.ndarray]: + """The measured points and Thorsen et al.'s simulated line of Fig. 17 or 22.""" + data: dict[str, list] = {"measured": [], "thorsen2017": []} + with open(HERE / name, encoding="utf-8") as fh: + for r in csv.DictReader(fh): + data[r["series"]].append((float(r["s_m"]), float(r["rms_strain"]))) + return {k: np.array(sorted(v)) for k, v in data.items()} + + +def mean_or_none(values) -> float | None: + values = list(values) + return float(np.mean(values)) if values else None + + +def scores(s: np.ndarray, rms: np.ndarray, measured: np.ndarray) -> dict: + """r.m.s. strain against the measured stations: the largest over the span, the station + ratios, and their means over the lower and upper halves of the span.""" + at = np.interp(measured[:, 0], s, rms) + ratio = at / measured[:, 1] + lower = measured[:, 0] < LENGTH / 2.0 + return { + "max_rms_strain": float(rms.max()), + "s_of_max_m": float(s[int(np.argmax(rms))]), + "max_ratio": float(rms.max() / measured[:, 1].max()), + "mean_ratio_at_stations": float(ratio.mean()), + "rms_log_error_at_stations": float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.log(ratio) ** 2))), + "mean_ratio_lower_half": mean_or_none(ratio[lower]), + "mean_ratio_upper_half": mean_or_none(ratio[~lower]), + "station_ratios": ratio.tolist(), + "station_values": at.tolist(), + } + + +def rounded(x): + """Six significant digits, so the record does not carry the last bits of the arithmetic.""" + if isinstance(x, float): + return float(f"{x:.6g}") + if isinstance(x, dict): + return {k: rounded(v) for k, v in x.items()} + if isinstance(x, list): + return [rounded(v) for v in x] + return x + + +def fmt(value: float | None, spec: str = ".3f") -> str: + """A score for the console; n/a when the selection holds nothing for it.""" + return "n/a" if value is None else format(value, spec) + + +def main() -> None: + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) + ap.add_argument("exe") + ap.add_argument("workdir") + ap.add_argument( + "--runs", default="all", help="comma list of " + ", ".join(RUNS) + ", or all" + ) + ap.add_argument("--jobs", type=int, default=os.cpu_count() or 1) + ap.add_argument("--keep", action="store_true", help="keep the output tables") + ap.add_argument( + "--summary", + default=None, + help="directory for the comparison CSV and summary JSON", + ) + a = ap.parse_args() + found = a.exe if Path(a.exe).is_file() else shutil.which(a.exe) + if found is None: + raise SystemExit(f"CableDyn executable not found: {a.exe}") + exe = Path(found).resolve() + sha = hashlib.sha256(exe.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + names = ( + list(RUNS) + if a.runs == "all" + else [n.strip() for n in a.runs.split(",") if n.strip()] + ) + if not names or any(n not in RUNS for n in names): + raise SystemExit(f"--runs: choose from {', '.join(RUNS)}, got {a.runs!r}") + work = Path(a.workdir).resolve() + + def one(name: str) -> dict: + part, _, segments, dt, tf = RUNS[name] + t0 = PART[part]["t0"] + folder = work / f"{part}_n{segments}_dt{dt:g}_tf{tf:g}" + files = deck_files(part, segments, dt, tf) + return run_case( + exe, + folder, + files, + lambda out: analyse(out, part, t0), + f"{part}:{t0:g}:{ANALYSIS}", + a.keep, + sha, + ) + + with ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=max(1, min(a.jobs, len(names)))) as pool: + results = dict(zip(names, pool.map(one, names), strict=True)) + + rows, summary = [], {} + for part in PART: + fig = figure(PART[part]["fig"]) + measured, th = fig["measured"], fig["thorsen2017"] + th_scores = scores(th[:, 0], th[:, 1], measured) + block = { + "coefficients": { + "Cv": CV[part], + "f0": F0, + "df": DF, + "CD": CD, + "CM": 1.0 + CA, + }, + "tmax_s": PART[part]["tmax"], + "statistics_after_s": PART[part]["t0"], + "measured_max_rms_strain": float(measured[:, 1].max()), + "measured_dominant_frequency_hz": MEASURED_FREQUENCY[part], + "thorsen2017": { + k: v + for k, v in th_scores.items() + if k not in ("station_ratios", "station_values") + }, + "runs": {}, + } + if part == "heave": + fit = top_motion() + block["top_motion"] = { + "period_s": fit["period_s"], + "x_amplitude_m": fit["x"]["amp_m"], + "z_amplitude_m": fit["z"]["amp_m"], + "x_lag_behind_z_deg": math.degrees( + fit["z"]["phase_rad"] - fit["x"]["phase_rad"] + ), + "ramp_periods": RAMP_PERIODS, + } + for name in (n for n in RUNS if n in results and RUNS[n][0] == part): + _, role, segments, dt, tf = RUNS[name] + r = results[name] + sc = scores(np.array(r["s_m"]), np.array(r["rms_strain"]), measured) + run = { + "role": role, + "segments": segments, + "dt_s": dt, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": tf, + **{ + k: v + for k, v in sc.items() + if k not in ("station_ratios", "station_values") + }, + **{k: v for k, v in r.items() if k not in ("s_m", "rms_strain")}, + } + block["runs"][name] = run + th_at = np.interp(measured[:, 0], th[:, 0], th[:, 1]) + for k, (sm, em) in enumerate(measured): + rows.append( + { + "run": name, + "part": part, + "segments": segments, + "dt_s": dt, + "viv_frame_Tf_s": tf, + "station": k + 1, + "s_m": f"{sm:.4f}", + "measured_rms_strain": f"{em:.4e}", + "cabledyn_rms_strain": f"{sc['station_values'][k]:.4e}", + "cabledyn_ratio": f"{sc['station_ratios'][k]:.4f}", + "thorsen2017_rms_strain": f"{th_at[k]:.4e}", + "thorsen2017_ratio": f"{th_at[k] / em:.4f}", + } + ) + print( + f"{name:16s} max r.m.s. / measured {fmt(run['max_ratio'])} at s " + f"{run['s_of_max_m']:.2f} m; station mean {fmt(run['mean_ratio_at_stations'])} " + f"(lower half {fmt(run['mean_ratio_lower_half'])}, upper " + f"{fmt(run['mean_ratio_upper_half'])}), log error " + f"{fmt(run['rms_log_error_at_stations'])}; f({FREQUENCY_STATION} m) " + f"{run['dominant_frequency_hz']:.3f} Hz" + + "".join( + f"; share {b} Hz {fmt(run.get(f'share_{b}_hz'), '.2f')}" + for b in BRANCHES + if part == "heave" + ) + ) + if block["runs"]: + primary = next(n for n in RUNS if RUNS[n][0] == part) + base = block["runs"].get(primary) + for name, run in block["runs"].items(): + if name != primary and base is not None: + run["max_ratio_change_from_primary"] = ( + run["max_ratio"] / base["max_ratio"] - 1.0 + ) + ths = block["thorsen2017"] + print( + f"{part}: Thorsen et al. (2017) max {fmt(ths['max_ratio'])}, station mean " + f"{fmt(ths['mean_ratio_at_stations'])} (lower {fmt(ths['mean_ratio_lower_half'])}, " + f"upper {fmt(ths['mean_ratio_upper_half'])}), log error " + f"{fmt(ths['rms_log_error_at_stations'])}" + ) + summary[part] = block + summary["executable_sha256"] = sha + summary = rounded(summary) + if a.summary: + out = Path(a.summary) + out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + with open( + out / "response_comparison.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8" + ) as fh: + w = csv.DictWriter(fh, fieldnames=list(rows[0]), lineterminator="\n") + w.writeheader() + w.writerows(rows) + (out / "summary.json").write_text( + json.dumps(summary, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n" + ) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main()