diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md index 16c78a3..71acb34 100644 --- a/CHANGELOG.md +++ b/CHANGELOG.md @@ -151,6 +151,17 @@ All notable changes to CableDyn are recorded in this file. The format follows U_R,max 4 the wake oscillator gives the measured largest A/D (0.280 against 0.286); at 6.5 and 7.9 every set holds the lock-in while the flow slows, the gap between the paths 2-5 times the measured one and the largest A/D 1.3-2.3 times the measured. +- Validation case L3-K (`validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary`): cross-flow VIV of the + untensioned catenary model riser of Chaplin & King (2018), 5.36 m long with EI 1.3 N m² and + floor touchdown, at both mass ratios in current of 0.2–1.4 m/s in both directions, with three + published coefficient sets none of which is fitted to these tests, against the measured mean + top tension, cross-flow frequencies and straight-part inclination (read from the article's + figures by `extract_chaplin2018.py`). Every set gives the measured single frequency along the + span in positive current, at f d/U 0.121 (Ulveseter et al. 2019), 0.138 (generic set) and + 0.17 (wake oscillator) against 0.111; the generic set's drag amplification gives the light + riser's tension rise (9.8 % r.m.s.) and the heavy riser's inclination in negative current + (5.0° r.m.s.). The heavy riser's still-water tension is 37 % above the measured with the + article's geometry, reported as a caveat of the data. - Theory manual, Published coefficient sets: the VIV coefficient sets of Thorsen et al. (2016, 2017), Ulveseter et al. (2018), Andersen et al. (2024a, b) and Facchinetti et al. (2004), each with its source, its test data and the line-type columns it maps to, and Thorsen et al.'s diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 00fb2ca..39e876a 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -171,9 +171,10 @@ layout is described in the architecture notes in the repository. ## Validation CableDyn is verified against analytical solutions and compared with MoorDyn, -OrcaFlex, eight published physical experiments (Holcombe lazy-wave, Bergdahl dynamic +OrcaFlex, nine published physical experiments (Holcombe lazy-wave, Bergdahl dynamic chain, Chaplin riser natural frequencies and stepped-current VIV, Wang catenary-riser VIV in -current and heave, NDP high-mode riser VIV, FLOTANT power-cable VIV, oscillatory-flow cylinder VIV), the IEA 15 MW VolturnUS-S reference systems, and coupled OpenFAST runs. Results, +current and heave, NDP high-mode riser VIV, FLOTANT power-cable VIV, oscillatory-flow cylinder VIV, Chaplin & King +untensioned catenary-riser VIV), the IEA 15 MW VolturnUS-S reference systems, and coupled OpenFAST runs. Results, acceptance criteria, and reproduction commands are in the [validation record](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/validation.html); data and scripts are in [`validation/`](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/validation.html). diff --git a/VALIDATION.md b/VALIDATION.md index 2702dc1..3b68fed 100644 --- a/VALIDATION.md +++ b/VALIDATION.md @@ -89,6 +89,7 @@ article's methods, are compared in | **L3-N** | NDP 38 m high-mode riser in uniform flow, 0.3–2.4 m/s (22 tests), cross-flow VIV | measured maximum r.m.s. cross-flow strain, dominant frequency, spatial-mean σ/D | strain r.m.s. log error: Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.178, Andersen et al. (2024b) 0.186, generic set 0.277, Thorsen et al. (2016) 0.363 (their own simulation 0.187); f D/U 0.145 / 0.134 / 0.192 / 0.193 vs 0.143 measured | generic set blind; the other sets fitted by their authors to NDP tests (implementation check) | Pass measured | | **L3-F** | FLOTANT OD 48 mm power-cable specimen with a 200 kg clump, tow tests at 0.025–1.0 m/s (40 tests), cross-flow and in-line VIV | measured A/D_rms (σ/OD) at 1/2L, 3/4L and L (de Wilde et al. 2021, App. 3) | CF r.m.s. log error (Ur ≥ 3): Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.731, generic set 0.594, wake oscillator 1.208; first peak at 1/2L 0.755 / 0.483 / 0.296 vs 0.776 measured; release Ur 7.06 / 5.89 / 5.30 vs 5.88 | published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests; structure identified from the specimen's in-air and in-water RAOs | Pass measured | | **L3-O** | SJTU 4 m flexible cylinder moved harmonically through still water, KC 178 at U_R,max 4, 6.5 and 7.9, cross-flow VIV | measured A/D on the acceleration and deceleration paths at mid-span (Fu et al. 2014, Figs. 15–17); lock-in shares 17/34/50 % | A/D r.m.s. error: wake oscillator 0.088 / 0.177 / 0.132, generic set 0.138 / 0.339 / 0.345, Ulveseter et al. (2019) set 0.079 / 0.340 / 0.338; largest A/D at U_R,max 4: 0.280 / 0.472 / 0.124 vs 0.286; at 6.5 and 7.9 every set holds the lock-in while the flow slows: mean deceleration-acceleration gap 0.25–0.50 vs 0.09–0.12 measured | published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests; `VIV FRAME` Tf 0.2 s (sensitivity none, 0.1, 0.3 s) | Pass measured | +| **L3-K** | Southampton untensioned catenary riser with high curvature and floor touchdown, two mass ratios, current of 0.2–1.4 m/s in both directions (13 speeds each), cross-flow VIV | measured mean top tension and its standard deviation, cross-flow spectral peak frequencies, inclination of the straight part (Chaplin & King 2018, Figs. 9, 10, 12, 13, 15) | frequency uniform along the span in positive current (26/26 runs generic set, 22 wake oscillator, 20 Ulveseter et al. 2019) at f d/U 0.138 / 0.17 / 0.121 vs 0.111 measured; light-riser tension in positive current r.m.s. 9.8% with drag amplification (generic set), 17.8–24.5% without; heavy-riser straight-part inclination 5.0° r.m.s. (implied C_d 2.55 vs 2.47); still-water top tension 81.2 vs 59.1 N (m* 1.84) | published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests; floor friction and damping assumed, with sensitivity runs | Pass measured | | **L-fig** | Along-arc curvature overlay (CableDyn / OrcaFlex / MoorDyn-F ±4×) | 3-code committed record | CableDyn peak 0.11% from OrcaFlex | <0.5% | Pass | | **L4-1** | Coupled platform + mooring | synthetic reference | bit-for-bit | — | Pass | | **L4-1b** | VolturnUS-S coupled platform + power cable | OpenFAST v5.0.0 (CompMooring 5 vs 3) | platform DOFs <0.6% (3-seed DLC-1.1); fairlead and anchor <0.001% static | <3% platform | Pass | @@ -471,6 +472,37 @@ the tow tests it predicts). Inputs, reduction scripts, results, and source prove 21%, the wake oscillator's by up to 11%. Half the time step and 80 elements change the largest A/D by at most 0.1% (generic set, wake oscillator) and 4.1% (Ulveseter et al. set); the default run reproduces the committed record byte for byte. +- **L3-K Southampton untensioned catenary riser, cross-flow VIV with high curvature and + touchdown** + ([Chaplin & King, 2018](https://cabledyn.readthedocs.io/en/latest/references.html#ref-chaplin2018)): + the 5.36 m, 56 mm riser of very low bending stiffness (EI 1.3 N m²) pinned on the floor of a + 2 m flume and 0.2 m above the surface 4.30 m away, at both mass ratios (2.9 and 20.9 N/m + submerged) in current of 0.2–1.4 m/s in both directions, with floor contact (friction 0.5, + assumed) and 3% Rayleigh damping. The article measures one cross-flow frequency along the + whole riser in positive current, close to f d/U = 0.11 on the speed at the near-vertical top, + so that the local Strouhal number on the normal velocity runs from 0.11 to above 0.3. Three + published VIV sets, none fitted to these tests, and a run without VIV: + - all three give one frequency along the suspended span, the curved lower part included + (within 10% in 26 of 26 positive runs with the generic set, 22 with the wake oscillator of + Facchinetti et al. (2004), 20 with Ulveseter et al.'s (2019) set), at their own level: + f d/U 0.121 for Ulveseter et al.'s set (9% above the measured 0.111), 0.138 for the generic + set and 0.17 for the wake oscillator; + - in negative current the heavy riser's measured frequency stays at 1.05–1.16 Hz from 1.1 m/s; + Ulveseter et al.'s set levels off at 1.45–1.5 Hz (f d/(U sin ψ) 0.130 against 0.119), the + generic set gives 1.45–1.85 Hz and the wake oscillator 2.1–2.45 Hz; + - the mean top tension needs the drag amplification of the generic set (Chaplin et al. 2005, + Eq. 4): the light riser's tension in positive current within 9.8% r.m.s. and a rise to + 1.4 m/s of 88.8 N against 88.6 N measured (49.8 N without VIV, 60.1 and 51.4 N with the two + sets that keep C_d 1.2); the heavy riser's straight-line inclination in negative current + within 5.0° r.m.s., implying C_d 2.55 through the article's Eq. 9 against 2.47 measured. + + With the article's length, span and weights the heavy riser's still-water top tension is + 81.2 N against 59.1 and 61.8 N measured (light 15.1 against 13.4 and 11.5 N), a geometry the + article's numbers do not close, so the tension is also compared as its increment from still + water. Half the time step and twice the elements change the mean tension by at most 5.3% and + 2.9%; without structural damping or floor friction the mean tension moves by up to 15% and + 40% and its standard deviation by up to +296% and +412%. The default run reproduces the + committed record byte for byte. ## L4 coupled OpenFAST diff --git a/doc/references.rst b/doc/references.rst index 715b4c4..8b7d6b5 100644 --- a/doc/references.rst +++ b/doc/references.rst @@ -300,6 +300,12 @@ Verification and validation references laboratory measurements of vortex-induced vibrations of a tension riser. *Journal of Fluids and Structures* **21**\ (1), 25–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.05.016 +.. _ref-chaplin2018: + +- **Chaplin, J. R. & King, R. (2018).** Laboratory measurements of the vortex-induced vibrations + of an untensioned catenary riser with high curvature. *Journal of Fluids and Structures* + **79**, 26–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2018.01.008 + .. _ref-trim2005: - **Trim, A. D., Braaten, H., Lie, H. & Tognarelli, M. A. (2005).** Experimental investigation diff --git a/validation/README.md b/validation/README.md index a22b439..410d55c 100644 --- a/validation/README.md +++ b/validation/README.md @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ redistributed. | [`RELEASE_0_1_1.md`](RELEASE_0_1_1.md) | The same for v0.1.1 | | [`RELEASE_0_1_0.md`](RELEASE_0_1_0.md) | The same for v0.1.0 | | [`bodies/`](bodies/README.md) | Rigid-body, rod and shared-anchor cases with MoorDyn-C twins, stored references and pass limits | -| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV in current and heave, Trim et al. (2005) NDP high-mode riser VIV, de Wilde et al. (2021) FLOTANT power-cable VIV and Fu et al. (2014) oscillatory-flow cylinder VIV comparisons | +| [`experiments/`](experiments/README.md) | Holcombe et al. (2025) static lazy-wave, Bergdahl et al. (2016) dynamic-chain, Chaplin et al. (2005) riser natural-frequency and stepped-current VIV, Wang et al. (2014) catenary-riser VIV in current and heave, Trim et al. (2005) NDP high-mode riser VIV, de Wilde et al. (2021) FLOTANT power-cable VIV, Fu et al. (2014) oscillatory-flow cylinder VIV and Chaplin & King (2018) untensioned catenary-riser VIV comparisons | | [`PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md`](PERFORMANCE_0_1_0.md) | Wall time of CableDyn 0.1.0, MoorDyn-C and MoorDyn-F at equal accuracy on five mooring, cable, buoy and coupled cases | | [`performance/`](performance/README.md) | Same-host wall-clock records of the L5 cases: the resolved lazy-wave spans, the one-hour VolturnUS-S mooring and the tension-only chain | | [`PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md`](PAPER_REPRODUCTION.md) | Every CableDyn result in the journal article, re-run with the release defaults and in paper mode | diff --git a/validation/experiments/README.md b/validation/experiments/README.md index cc4668d..8d71865 100644 --- a/validation/experiments/README.md +++ b/validation/experiments/README.md @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ # Experimental comparisons -This directory lets reviewers reproduce CableDyn's comparisons with seven published physical +This directory lets reviewers reproduce CableDyn's comparisons with eight published physical experiments. Each subdirectory gives the data source, the translation of the published parameters into a CableDyn model, the assessed quantity, the reproduction commands and the committed results. @@ -17,5 +17,6 @@ committed results. | [`ndp_riser/`](ndp_riser/README.md) | Trim et al. (2005), NDP 38 m high-mode riser in uniform flow, cross-flow VIV with a generic and three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI riser, synchronisation VIV | | [`flotant/`](flotant/README.md) | de Wilde et al. (2021), FLOTANT OD 48 mm power-cable specimen with a clump weight, tow tests and forced-oscillation RAOs, cross-flow and in-line VIV with three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI cable, synchronisation and wake-oscillator VIV | | [`fu_oscillatory/`](fu_oscillatory/README.md) | Fu et al. (2014), SJTU 4 m flexible cylinder moved harmonically through still water, cross-flow VIV on the acceleration and deceleration paths with three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI cylinder, synchronisation and wake-oscillator VIV, `VIV FRAME` | +| [`chaplin_catenary/`](chaplin_catenary/README.md) | Chaplin & King (2018), 5.36 m untensioned catenary riser with high curvature and floor touchdown in current of both directions, two mass ratios: mean top tension, cross-flow frequency, inclination, with three published coefficient sets | Finite-EI riser with floor contact, synchronisation and wake-oscillator VIV | -The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D, L3-W, L3-Wh, L3-N and L3-F in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). +The results are summarised as cases L3-H, L3-B, L3-C, L3-D, L3-W, L3-Wh, L3-N, L3-F and L3-K in [`VALIDATION.md`](../../VALIDATION.md). diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/README.md b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..66e269c --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,331 @@ + + +# Southampton untensioned catenary riser: VIV with high curvature and touchdown + +This directory compares CableDyn with the tests of Chaplin & King (2018), +: a 5.36 m, 56 mm model riser of very low +bending stiffness, pinned on the floor of a 2 m deep flume and 0.2 m above the surface 4.30 m +away, tensioned only by its weight and the drag, at two mass ratios in currents of 0.2-1.4 m/s in +both directions. Much of it lies on the floor, and the touchdown moves with the flow: a highly +curved, untensioned catenary with touchdown in VIV, the configuration of a free-hanging dynamic +cable near the seabed. Its frequencies test what a local time-domain VIV model does where the +normal velocity varies threefold along the span: the article measures one cross-flow frequency +along the whole riser, close to f = 0.11 U/d with U the flow speed, well below the Strouhal number +of about 0.2 of a stationary cylinder. No model parameter is fitted to these tests. + +In short: + +- **All three VIV models reproduce the uniform frequency along the span** in positive current + (within 10 % over the suspended stations in 26 of 26 runs with the generic set, 22 with the + wake oscillator, 20 with Ulveseter et al.'s set), **but at their own Strouhal number, not at + the measured 0.11:** f d/U 0.121 (Ulveseter et al. 2019, 9 % high), 0.138 (generic set, 24 % + high) and 0.17 (wake oscillator, St 0.2, 53 % high). The frequency follows the flow at the + near-vertical top, as measured, and the lower part follows it. +- **In negative current** the heavy riser's measured frequency stays at 1.05-1.16 Hz from + 1.1 m/s, where the straight part's normal velocity is constant; Ulveseter et al.'s set also + levels off, about 35 % higher at 1.45-1.5 Hz (f d/(U sin ψ) 0.130 against 0.119 measured), the + generic set gives 1.45-1.85 Hz and the wake oscillator 2.1-2.45 Hz. +- **The mean top tension needs the drag amplification:** with it (the generic set) the light + riser's tension in positive current is within 9.8 % r.m.s. and rises by 88.8 N to 1.4 m/s + against 88.6 N measured; with C_d 1.2 it rises by 49.8 N without VIV and by 60.1 and 51.4 N + with the two sets that keep C_d. The same set gives the heavy riser's straight-line inclination + in negative current to 5.0° r.m.s. (the drag coefficient it implies by the article's Eq. 9, + 2.55, against 2.47 measured), and overshoots its tension rise above 1.2 m/s. +- **The still-water tension of the heavy riser is 37 % above the measured one** (81.2 against + 59.1 N; light riser 15.1 against 13.4 N) with the article's length, span and weights, a + geometry the article's numbers do not close; the tension is therefore also compared as the + increment from still water. + +## The tests (Chaplin & King 2018) + +- **Riser (Table 1, Sec. 2):** a 4 mm wire rope through nylon bobbins (30 mm long, 10 mm apart) in + a silicone sheath, d 56 mm, 5.36 m between pinned ends; EI 1.3 N m² and EA 790 kN estimated from + the parts; structural damping about 3 % of critical in air (free decays, hanging vertically); + submerged weight 2.9 N/m (m* 1.12) and 20.9 N/m (m* 1.84, lead plugs; the twelve instrumented + bobbins have none), m* the mass with the internal water over the displaced mass. +- **Set-up:** a recirculating flume, 2.0 m deep; the lower pin on the floor, the upper pin 0.2 m + above the surface and 4.30 m away horizontally. Positive current: the upstream pin on the floor + (the profile concave to the flow); negative: the upstream pin at the surface, obtained in the + laboratory by swapping the pin elevations (Sec. 3). U from 0.2 to 1.4 m/s in 0.05 m/s steps, + Re up to 70 000. +- **Measured:** tension load cells at both ends; twelve 3-axis accelerometers 0.4 m apart; video + of up to three bobbins. The article reports the mean top tension with ±1 standard deviation + (Figs. 10 and 13), spectral peak frequencies of the cross-flow accelerations (Figs. 7-9, 15, 16), + the mean profile and the inclination of the straight part in negative current (Figs. 5, 11, 12), + and no amplitude statistics. +- **Findings the case tests:** in positive current the cross-flow frequency is uniform along the + riser and close to f = 0.11 U/d, U within 3 % of the normal velocity at the near-vertical top + (Fig. 9), so that the local Strouhal number on the normal velocity runs from 0.11 at the top + to above 0.3 lower down (Fig. 8); in negative current the riser takes a straight inclined + profile on which the normal drag balances the normal weight (their Eq. 9; C_d 2.0-2.8 bracket + the measured inclinations), U sin ψ tends to a constant, and the frequency follows + f = 0.13 U sin ψ/d (Fig. 15(b)) except where the response locks in. + +### Caveats of the data + +- **Still-water tension.** With the stated length, span, depth and weights the riser hangs as a + catenary whose top tension is 81.2 N (m* 1.84) and 15.1 N (m* 1.12), with the 0.2 m above the + surface in air. The article's still-water points are 59.1 and 61.8 N (Figs. 10 and 13, the + two rigs) and 13.4 and 11.5 N. A catenary of 5.36 m between the stated pins cannot hang that + slack; the touchdown in Fig. 5 is also further from the floor pin than the model's. A laid part + that is not straight (slack held by the floor friction) or a geometry other than Table 1's would + explain both; the article does not say. The comparison is made on the absolute tension and on + its increment from still water, each figure against its own still-water point. +- **The reference lines W h of Fig. 13** (41.8 and 5.8 N, Table 1's weight times the water + depth) leave out the in-air weight of the part above the surface, m g × 0.2 m, 9.0 and 5.4 N + in the model; the measured tensions in negative current sit on these lines. +- **Frequencies** are spectral peaks of accelerometer signals, which gravity contaminates at the + vibration frequency (Sec. 3); the article shows that the peaks agree with those of video + displacements (Fig. 4). Several peaks are given at some speeds (Fig. 15). +- **Not given:** the accelerometer positions (only the 0.4 m spacing; the profiles of Fig. 5 put + the first 0.5 m from the floor pin), the floor friction, the flume's water density, the spectral + method, and the scatter of the frequencies. + +## Model + +- **Line:** one finite-EI line of 54 elements (0.099 m), End A the upper pin at (4.30, 0, 0.2) m, + End B the lower pin on the floor at (0, 0, -2.0) m, both pinned. d 56 mm, EI 1.3 N m², EA + 790 kN, mass ρA + W/g (2.759 and 4.594 kg/m; Table 1's m* 1.84 gives 4.532 kg/m, 1.4 % less), + the same mass above the surface. Fresh water, 1000 kg/m³ (not stated; m* 1.12 and 2.9 N/m agree + at it). C_d 1.2, C_a 1. +- **Structural damping:** Rayleigh damping (`EI|-zeta|f1|f2`), 3 % at 0.3 and 3.0 Hz, the range of + the measured cross-flow frequencies; run without it as a sensitivity. +- **Floor:** the default penalty contact and a friction coefficient 0.5 (a silicone sheath on the + flume floor; not given). Without friction the laid part slides sideways under the suspended + part's motion; frictionless runs are a sensitivity. +- **Current:** uniform over the depth along the riser's plane, +x positive, -x negative, ramped + linearly from still water over 10 s (a static solve in the full current finds no equilibrium + for some light-riser cases in negative current, where the riser lifts off the floor; every run + starts from the same still-water state). The part above the surface is dry. +- **Runs:** dt 2.5 ms, 110 s, statistics over 30-110 s (80 s); without VIV 40 s, statistics over + 30-40 s. U = 0.2-1.4 m/s in 0.1 m/s steps for both mass ratios and directions (52 runs per set). + +### Coefficient sets + +The sets of the FLOTANT and NDP cases, none fitted to these tests, and a run +without VIV: + +| Set | Source | Values | Fitted to | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| `uls19` | Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1 | C_l 0.85, f̂0 0.144 ± 0.064; in-line C_x 0.75, α 0.15, C_hh 1.5 | the NDP riser in uniform flow: blind here | +| `b1` | The generic set of the Delta Flume case | C_l 0.8, f̂0 0.18 ± 0.08; in-line C_x 0.85, α 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018, Table 3); `VIV AMPLITUDE` C_v 0.8 with the drag amplification of Chaplin et al. (2005, Eq. 4); `VIV DAMPING` `0 0 1` | nothing from these tests: blind | +| `wake` | Facchinetti et al. (2004) | `WAKE OSCILLATOR` C_L0 0.3, St 0.2, ε 0.3, A 12; cross-flow only | rigid-cylinder data: blind | +| `none` | | no VIV force, C_d 1.2 | | + +Only `b1` amplifies the drag with the response; `uls19` and `wake` keep C_d 1.2, so their mean +tension differs from `none` only by the dynamics. + +### Processing + +- **Tension:** mean and standard deviation of the tension at the upper pin (`FairTen1`); the + measured value of each figure at the same speed; the increment from still water, each against + its own still-water value. +- **Frequency:** the peak of the averaged spectrum (20 s Hann segments, half overlapping, + 0.05 Hz resolution) of the cross-flow (y) displacement within 0.3-6 Hz (the lowest measured + frequency is 0.34 Hz; below it some runs wander slowly sideways), the dominant frequency the + article shows to agree in its acceleration and video-displacement spectra (Fig. 4); the peak + of the same spectrum weighted by ω⁴, the acceleration spectrum, within 0.15-6 Hz, is in + `response_comparison.csv` (`model_f_acc_…`). Compared points, by their mean elevation: the two + dots of the inset of Fig. 9(a) (0.65 and 0.37 of the height between the pins; the mean of the + two) and the dot of Fig. 9(b) (0.19) in positive current, mid-depth (Fig. 15, "around + mid-depth") in negative current. The model's frequency is set against the nearest measured + peak at the same speed and mass ratio (`nearest_measured_…`) and against the median measured + f d/U. The spread along the span is (max - min)/median over the twelve accelerometer stations, + taken 0.48 m from each pin and 0.4 m apart, that are off the floor and under water. +- **Inclination:** of the mean profile to the horizontal at mid-depth; the drag coefficient it + implies by the article's Eq. 9, C_d = 2 W cos ψ / (ρ d U² sin² ψ), for the model and the + measurement, as a comparison only: nothing is fitted to it. + +### Measurements + +`extract_chaplin2018.py` reads the article's PDF (not distributed; PyMuPDF, NumPy, SciPy, Pillow) +into `measured_chaplin2018.csv`. The figures are greyscale raster images: + +- each panel is calibrated on its frame and the tick marks on both opposite sides of it (largest + residual 0.0010 m/s, 0.0036 Hz, 0.07°, 0.14 N); +- the markers are found by a circle Hough transform, classed solid or open by their fill and + snapped to the 0.05 m/s test grid (largest snap 0.012 m/s); peaks off the grid or between the + classes are dropped and listed by the script; the error bars are read from their caps; +- **checks:** the line f d/U = 0.11 drawn in Fig. 9 reads 0.105 and 0.108; the lines W h in + Fig. 13 read 41.9 and 5.65 N against Table 1's 41.8 and 5.8 N; +- **points read:** Fig. 10, 26 open and 24 solid (every marker; 46 standard deviations); Fig. 13, + 25 and 26 (one open marker lost where the series cross; 44 standard deviations); Fig. 12(a), + 20 and 25; Fig. 15(a), 26 and 47; Fig. 9(a), 12 and 40, Fig. 9(b), 22 and 34. Markers hidden + under others are lost, which in Fig. 9(a), where both series and both accelerometers fall on + one line, is most of the open ones; `--check DIR` draws what was read over each figure. + +The data are digitised from the article; its figures are not reproduced. + +## Reproduce + +From the repository root, with `path/to/cabledyn.exe` the release executable or a local build: + +```powershell +python validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/extract_chaplin2018.py CHAPLIN2018.pdf +python validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/chaplin_catenary_viv.py ` + path/to/cabledyn.exe validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/work --jobs 4 ` + --summary validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary +``` + +The default is the committed record: 2 still-water runs, 208 primary runs, 12 convergence runs and +72 sensitivity runs, about an hour with 4 parallel runs. `--runs` selects runs by name; a run +whose folder holds the same input files and executable is not repeated; `--keep` keeps the output +tables (about 110 MB a run). `response_comparison.csv` holds every run, `summary.json` the scores +and the SHA-256 of the executable, `provenance.json` the sources and assumptions. + +## Results + +`response_comparison.csv` holds every run against the measured values at its speed; +`summary.json` the scores below. + +### Still water + +| m* | CableDyn (N) | Measured, Fig. 10 (N) | Measured, Fig. 13 (N) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1.12 | 15.1 | 13.4 | 11.5 | +| 1.84 | 81.2 | 59.1 | 61.8 | + +The model's touchdown is 2.18 m (m* 1.84) and 1.99 m (m* 1.12) from the floor pin; Fig. 5 puts +the heavy riser's touchdown at the lowest speeds near 2.6 m (by eye). See the caveats above. + +### Mean top tension + +r.m.s. relative error of the mean tension over the 13 speeds (12 where Fig. 10 has no marker), +r.m.s. error of its increment from still water (N), and the median ratio of the standard +deviations (CableDyn over measured, where the error bar was read): + +| Set | Positive, m* 1.12 | Positive, m* 1.84 | Negative, m* 1.12 | Negative, m* 1.84 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| `none` (C_d 1.2) | 0.245; 19.6 N | 0.135; 18.4 N | 0.365; 11.5 N | 0.385; 22.8 N | +| `uls19` | 0.178; 14.5 N; sd 0.81 | 0.150; 12.2 N; sd 1.14 | 0.322; 6.9 N; sd 1.43 | 0.296; 14.3 N; sd 1.61 | +| `b1` | **0.098; 1.8 N**; sd 0.59 | 0.238; **4.9 N**; sd 0.69 | 0.301; **3.9 N**; sd 1.22 | 0.248; 13.7 N; sd 1.21 | +| `wake` | 0.234; 18.8 N; sd 0.19 | 0.139; 17.7 N; sd 0.42 | 0.351; 10.5 N; sd 0.42 | 0.316; 16.4 N; sd 0.76 | + +Tension at 1.4 m/s (N; the increment from still water in brackets): + +| | Positive, m* 1.12 | Positive, m* 1.84 | Negative, m* 1.12 | Negative, m* 1.84 | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Measured | 102.0 (+88.6) | 154.9 (+95.8) | 58.3 (+46.8) | 49.5 (−12.3) | +| `none` | 64.9 (+49.8) | 145.6 (+64.4) | 39.7 (+24.6) | 41.9 (−39.3) | +| `uls19` | 75.2 (+60.1) | 158.5 (+77.3) | 48.2 (+33.1) | 50.8 (−30.4) | +| `b1` | 103.8 (+88.8) | 188.8 (+107.6) | 70.7 (+55.7) | 68.4 (−12.8) | +| `wake` | 66.5 (+51.4) | 146.4 (+65.2) | 41.5 (+26.4) | 49.7 (−31.5) | + +- **Positive current:** the tension rises with the drag on the suspended part. Only the generic + set, whose drag grows with the response (Chaplin et al. 2005, Eq. 4), follows the light + riser's rise: within 5.6 N at every speed and within 1.8 N from 1.0 m/s (80.2 against + 80.2 N at 1.2 m/s). The sets that keep C_d 1.2 fall 13-36 N short at 1.0-1.4 m/s, close to + the run without VIV: Ulveseter et al.'s response adds 5-10 N to it, the wake oscillator's + 1-2 N. For the heavy riser the still-water offset dominates the absolute error; the generic + set's increment is 12 % above the measured at 1.4 m/s, the others 19-33 % below. +- **Negative current:** the heavy riser's tension falls from the still-water value as the drag + lifts it into a straight line whose top tension the article puts at W h (41.8 N): measured + 59 → 40 N at 0.2-0.65 m/s, then 41-49 N to 1.4 m/s. Every set reproduces the fall, at higher + speeds: the generic set reaches 40 N at 0.7 m/s, Ulveseter et al.'s and the wake oscillator + near 0.9 m/s. Above 1.2 m/s the generic set rises to 68 N where the measured stays below + 50 N. The light riser lifts off the floor entirely from 0.5-0.6 m/s in the model, as measured + (lifted at 0.6 m/s, Sec. 4.2); its tension rise to 1.4 m/s is 55.7 N with the generic set + against 46.8 N measured, 33.1 N with Ulveseter et al.'s. +- **Fluctuation:** the generic set's standard deviation is 0.59-0.69 of the measured in positive + current; Ulveseter et al.'s is 0.81-1.14; the wake oscillator's 0.19-0.42. + +### Cross-flow frequency + +Median f d/U of CableDyn at the points compared and of the measured points read (all speeds), +and the median ratio of CableDyn's frequency to the nearest measured point at the same speed: + +| Set | Positive, upper (Fig. 9(a)) | Positive, lower (Fig. 9(b)) | Negative, mid-depth (Fig. 15(a)) | Uniform along the span (positive / negative runs) | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | +| Measured, m* 1.12 / 1.84 | 0.111 / 0.113 | 0.090 / 0.102 | 0.064 / 0.061 | uniform (Fig. 7) | +| `uls19` | 0.121; ratio 1.11 / 1.07 | 0.121; 1.37 / 1.08 | 0.090 / 0.103; 1.47 / 1.32 | 20 of 26 / 12 of 26 | +| `b1` | 0.138; 1.24 / 1.25 | 0.138; 1.52 / 1.28 | 0.128 / 0.098; 1.84 / 1.45 | 26 of 26 / 15 of 26 | +| `wake` | 0.173 / 0.168; 1.31 / 1.40 | 0.168; 1.83 / 1.47 | 0.074 / 0.128; 0.98 / 2.03 | 22 of 26 / 22 of 26 | + +Uniform: the spread of the frequency over the suspended stations under water within 10 % of its +median. + +- **Positive current: one frequency along the span.** In every set the cross-flow response of + the whole suspended span, the curved and nearly horizontal lower part included, is at one + frequency set by the flow at the near-vertical top; the local normal velocity there is within + 3 % of U, and further down the same frequency means a local f d/(U sin ψ) rising towards the + touchdown, as Fig. 8 measures. The lower part does not respond at the frequency of its own + normal velocity: its synchronisation or wake follows the motion the span imposes on it. The + level is each model's own: Ulveseter et al.'s set, whose band is centred at 0.144, settles at + 0.121, 9 % above the measured 0.11 (7 of 12 heavy-riser speeds within 10 % of a measured + peak); the generic set (centre 0.18) at 0.138; the wake oscillator at its Strouhal number, + 0.17. +- **Not reproduced in positive current:** the heavy riser's second branch at the lower + accelerometer, 0.67-0.83 Hz at 0.6-1.0 m/s (about half the dominant frequency, Fig. 9(b)), + and the light riser's frequency at the same point levelling at 1.57-1.81 Hz from 0.9 m/s; + CableDyn keeps the dominant frequency there. +- **Negative current, heavy riser:** the measured frequency at mid-depth rises to about 1.05 Hz + at 0.5-0.6 m/s, dips (the article attributes it to lock-in while the touchdown moves) and + stays at 1.05-1.16 Hz from 1.1 m/s, where U sin ψ is constant. Ulveseter et al.'s set has the + same plateau at 1.45-1.5 Hz from 1.0 m/s, f d/(U sin ψ) 0.130 on the model's own inclination + (measured 0.119 on the measured one, the article's line 0.13); the generic set 1.45-1.85 Hz; + the wake oscillator 2.1-2.45 Hz. +- **Negative current, light riser:** the measured spectra have a low branch at 0.34-0.45 Hz to + 0.85 m/s and a branch rising from 0.5 Hz at 0.6 m/s to 1.75 Hz at 1.3 m/s, which the article + attributes to lock-in under the rising tension; Ulveseter et al.'s and the generic set have + 0.5-0.85 Hz to 0.8 m/s and then mostly 2.2-3.6 Hz at mid-depth, above the measured branch; the + wake oscillator stays at 0.9-1.15 Hz. +- **Slow sideways wandering:** with Ulveseter et al.'s set the light riser at 0.4-0.5 m/s, where + it lifts off the floor, and the heavy riser at 1.0-1.3 m/s in negative current drift sideways + at under 0.3 Hz (A/D_rms 2-7.3 with the drift, 0.5-0.7 without); the article does not report + it. +- **The acceleration spectrum** (`model_f_acc_…`), the article's measured quantity, peaks at a + higher harmonic of the displacement's peak in 2-5 of the 13 runs of a point with Ulveseter et + al.'s set (its higher-harmonic force, C_hh 1.5) and in 8 of 13 with the wake oscillator in + light negative current, at most 2 with the generic set; the measured acceleration spectra + peak where the displacement's do (Fig. 4). + +### Inclination of the straight part in negative current + +r.m.s. difference of the inclination at mid-depth from Fig. 12(a), and the median drag +coefficient the inclination implies by Eq. 9 (measured: 1.84 for m* 1.12 and 2.47 for m* 1.84): + +| Set | m* 1.12 | m* 1.84 | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `none` (C_d 1.2) | 18.6°; C_d 0.80 | 10.1°; C_d 1.33 | +| `uls19` | 15.0°; 0.90 | 10.1°; 1.36 | +| `b1` | 14.7°; 0.94 | **5.0°; 2.55** | +| `wake` | 15.7°; 0.92 | 10.3°; 1.36 | + +- For the heavy riser the generic set's drag amplification gives the measured inclination and + drag: the article's C_d 2.0-2.8 follows from the response, not from an input. The sets with + C_d 1.2 differ by 10° r.m.s., steeper at the higher speeds (34° against 25° at 1.2 m/s). +- The light riser's model inclination at mid-depth is not a tension-free straight line: the run + without VIV, C_d 1.2 by input, reads 0.80 through Eq. 9. Its comparison is a profile check, + not a drag check; every set differs by 15-19° r.m.s., steeper on average. + +### Sensitivity and convergence + +- **Convergence** (`uls19`, `b1`, `wake` at m* 1.84, +0.8 m/s and m* 1.12, −1.2 m/s): half the + time step changes the mean tension by at most 0.6 % except one run (+5.3 %, `b1`, light, + −1.2 m/s, whose frequency moves by −11 %); the standard deviation by at most 5.5 % and the + largest A/D_rms by at most 7.9 %. Twice the elements change the mean + tension by at most 2.9 %, its standard deviation by at most 17 % (`uls19`, light, −1.2 m/s) + and the frequency by at most one bin. +- **Without structural damping** (36 runs at 0.4, 0.8 and 1.2 m/s): the mean tension changes by + −1.3 to +15.5 % (above 5 % in five runs, all in negative current); the standard deviation of + the tension by up to +296 % (the wake oscillator, light, +0.8 m/s), so the 3 % damping + matters for the fluctuation and not for the mean; 12 of the 54 compared frequencies change. +- **Frictionless floor** (36 runs): the mean tension changes by −3 to +40 % (above 5 % in five + runs, the largest the wake oscillator, light, −0.4 m/s, where the riser lifts off); the + standard deviation by up to +412 %, the laid part sliding sideways; 34 of the 54 frequencies + change, by −15 % to +150 %. The friction coefficient, not given, is the largest modelling + uncertainty of the case after the still-water geometry. +- The default command, run into a new work directory, reproduces `response_comparison.csv` and + `summary.json` byte for byte. + +## Limitations + +- The still-water top tension of the heavy riser is not reproduced (+37 %), so the absolute + tension carries that offset; the article's numbers do not close the geometry. +- The frequencies are read from raster figures in which many markers overlap: in Fig. 9(a) most + of the light riser's points are hidden (12 read), and the accelerometer positions are assumed. +- The floor friction and the representation of the 3 % structural damping are assumptions, and + the tension fluctuation depends on both. +- The current is uniform to the floor; the flume's boundary layer is not modelled, and the laid + part sees the full current. +- One 80 s record per speed; the article does not give the scatter of its frequencies. diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/chaplin_catenary_viv.py b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/chaplin_catenary_viv.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8088e88 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/chaplin_catenary_viv.py @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""VIV of the Southampton untensioned catenary model riser with high curvature in steady current. + +The tests of Chaplin & King (2018): a 5.36 m, 56 mm riser of very low bending stiffness, pinned +on the floor of a 2 m deep flume and 0.2 m above the surface 4.30 m away, tensioned only by its +weight and the drag, at two mass ratios (submerged weight 2.9 and 20.9 N/m) in currents up to +1.4 m/s in both directions: positive with the upstream end on the floor, negative with it at +the surface. Writes a deck per run, runs them in parallel (a run whose folder holds the same +input files and executable is reused) and compares with the measurements of the article (read +by extract_chaplin2018.py): + the mean top tension and its standard deviation against U (Figs. 10 and 13); + the dominant cross-flow frequency against U (Fig. 9, positive; Fig. 15(a), negative) and its + spread along the suspended span (uniform in the tests); + the inclination of the straight part in negative current (Fig. 12(a)) and the drag + coefficient it implies by the article's Eq. 9, as a comparison only; +for three published VIV coefficient sets and without VIV (C_d 1.2). + +The default runs are the committed record: every set at U = 0.2-1.4 m/s in steps of 0.1 m/s for +both mass ratios and directions, the still-water runs, and the convergence runs and the runs +without structural damping and without floor friction (README). + + python chaplin_catenary_viv.py path/to/cabledyn.exe WORKDIR [--runs NAME,...] [--jobs N] + [--keep] [--summary DIR] + +Sources: + J.R. Chaplin, R. King (2018), Laboratory measurements of the vortex-induced vibrations of an + untensioned catenary riser with high curvature, Journal of Fluids and Structures 79, 26-38, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2018.01.008 (Table 1; Secs. 2-4; Eqs. 9-10; + Figs. 9, 10, 12, 13 and 15) + J.V. Ulveseter, M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2019), Simulating fundamental and higher + harmonic VIV of slender structures, Applied Ocean Research 90, 101856, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apor.2019.101856 (Table 1) + J.V. Ulveseter, M.J. Thorsen, S. Saevik, C.M. Larsen (2018), Time domain simulation of riser + VIV in current and irregular waves, Marine Structures 60, 241-260, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marstruc.2018.04.001 (Table 3) + J.R. Chaplin, P.W. Bearman, F.J. Huera Huarte, R.J. Pattenden (2005), Laboratory measurements + of vortex-induced vibrations of a vertical tension riser in a stepped current, Journal of + Fluids and Structures 21(1), 3-24, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010 (Eq. 4) + M.L. Facchinetti, E. de Langre, F. Biolley (2004), Coupling of structure and wake oscillators + in vortex-induced vibrations, Journal of Fluids and Structures 19(2), 123-140, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2003.12.004 +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import csv +import hashlib +import json +import math +import os +import shutil +import subprocess +from concurrent.futures import ThreadPoolExecutor +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +GRAVITY = 9.80665 # m/s^2 +RHO = 1000.0 # kg/m^3: fresh water (not stated; Table 1's W and m* agree at 1000 for m* 1.12) +# Chaplin & King (2018), Table 1 +LENGTH = 5.36 # m, between the pin ends +DIAMETER = 0.056 # m +EI = 1.3 # N m^2, estimated +EA = 7.9e5 # N, estimated +ZETA = 0.03 # structural damping in air, "about 3 % of critical" +WEIGHT = {"1.12": 2.9, "1.84": 20.9} # N/m submerged, by mass ratio m* +DEPTH = 2.0 # m, the lower pin on the floor +TOP = 0.2 # m, the upper pin above the surface +SPAN = 4.30 # m, horizontal distance between the pins +CD, CA = 1.2, 1.0 +FRICTION = ( + 0.5 # floor friction coefficient (not given: a silicone sheath on the flume floor) +) +SEGMENTS, DT = 54, 0.0025 # about 0.1 m elements +# The current is ramped up linearly from still water over RAMP s: a static solve in the full +# current finds no equilibrium for some light-riser cases in negative current, where the riser +# lifts off the floor, so every run starts from the same still-water state. +RAMP = 10.0 # s +TMAX, T0 = 110.0, 30.0 # s: run length, statistics from T0 +TMAX_NONE, T0_NONE = 40.0, 30.0 # s: the runs without VIV settle to a steady state +WELCH = 20.0 # s, the segment of the averaged spectra (0.05 Hz resolution) +# Hz, where the dominant cross-flow frequency is sought: in the displacement spectrum from 0.3 Hz +# (below the lowest measured frequency, 0.35 Hz; a light riser lifted in negative current also +# wanders slowly sideways), in the acceleration spectrum from 0.15 Hz +BAND = {0: (0.3, 6.0), 4: (0.15, 6.0)} +SPEEDS = [round(0.1 * k, 1) for k in range(2, 15)] # m/s +DIRECTIONS = {"pos": 1.0, "neg": -1.0} +# Rayleigh damping 3 % at the ends of the band of the measured cross-flow frequencies +RAYLEIGH = (0.3, 3.0) # Hz +# The points compared with the measured frequencies, by their mean elevation [m]: the dots of +# the insets of Fig. 9 (two near the top, (a); one low down, (b)), at their share of the height +# between the pins (0.65 and 0.37; 0.19), and mid-depth for Fig. 15 ("around mid-depth"). +PROBES = { + "upper_a": -DEPTH + 0.65 * (DEPTH + TOP), + "upper_b": -DEPTH + 0.37 * (DEPTH + TOP), + "lower": -DEPTH + 0.19 * (DEPTH + TOP), + "mid_depth": -0.5 * DEPTH, +} +ANALYSIS = "2" # part of the reuse key: bump when an analysis changes + + +def chaplin_amplification(ad: float) -> float: + """Chaplin et al. (2005, Eq. 4): Cd/Cd0 = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s^2, s = (A/D)/sqrt(2).""" + s = ad / math.sqrt(2.0) + return 1.0 + 2.3 * s + 1.7 * s * s + + +# The coefficient sets of the FLOTANT, NDP and V701 cases: LINE TYPES Cl dF cF; VIV row (ClX, +# alpha, Chh); VIV AMPLITUDE with Chaplin's drag amplification; VIV DAMPING (a, b, c); WAKE +# OSCILLATOR (CL0, St, eps, A). none: no VIV, C_d 1.2. +SETS: dict[str, dict] = { + "uls19": { + "label": "Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1, Chh 1.5", + "cl": (0.85, 0.064, 0.144), + "viv": (0.75, 0.15, 1.5), + "amp": False, + "damping": None, + "wake": None, + }, + "b1": { + "label": "generic set (Delta Flume case)", + "cl": (0.8, 0.08, 0.18), + "viv": (0.85, 0.15, None), + "amp": True, + "damping": (0, 0, 1), + "wake": None, + }, + "wake": { + "label": "Facchinetti et al. (2004) wake oscillator", + "cl": (0, 0.08, 0.18), + "viv": None, + "amp": False, + "damping": None, + "wake": (0.3, 0.2, 0.3, 12), + }, + "none": { + "label": "no VIV, C_d 1.2", + "cl": (0, 0.08, 0.18), + "viv": None, + "amp": False, + "damping": None, + "wake": None, + }, +} + + +def viv_sections(hset: str) -> str: + s = SETS[hset] + text = "" + if s["viv"]: + clx, alpha, chh = s["viv"] + cols, vals = "ClX alpha", f"{clx} {alpha}" + if chh is not None: + cols, vals = cols + " Chh", vals + f" {chh}" + text += ( + "--------------------- VIV ----------------------------------------------\n" + f"TypeName {cols}\n(-){' (-)' * len(cols.split())}\nriser {vals}\n" + ) + if s["amp"]: + text += ( + "--------------------- VIV AMPLITUDE ------------------------------------\n" + "TypeName AD Cv CdAmp\n(-) (-) (-) (-)\n" + + "".join( + f"riser {0.1 * k:.2f} {s['cl'][0]} {chaplin_amplification(0.1 * k):.5f}\n" + for k in range(16) + ) + ) + if s["damping"]: + a, b, c = s["damping"] + text += ( + "--------------------- VIV DAMPING ------------------------------------\n" + f"TypeName a b c\n(-) (-) (-) (-)\nriser {a} {b} {c}\n" + ) + if s["wake"]: + text += ( + "--------------------- WAKE OSCILLATOR ----------------------------------\n" + "TypeName CL0 St eps A\n(-) (-) (-) (-) (-)\n" + f"riser {' '.join(f'{v:g}' for v in s['wake'])}\n" + ) + return text + + +def mass(mstar: str) -> float: + """Mass per metre with the internal water, from the submerged weight of Table 1.""" + return RHO * math.pi * DIAMETER**2 / 4.0 + WEIGHT[mstar] / GRAVITY + + +def deck_files( + hset: str, + mstar: str, + direction: str, + u: float, + segments: int, + dt: float, + damping: bool, + friction: float = FRICTION, +) -> dict[str, str]: + """The deck: End A the upper pin, End B the lower pin on the floor at x = 0; the current + along +x (positive: the upstream end on the floor) or -x (negative).""" + ux = DIRECTIONS[direction] * u + cl = " ".join(f"{v:g}" for v in SETS[hset]["cl"]) + ei = f"{EI}|-{ZETA}|{RAYLEIGH[0]}|{RAYLEIGH[1]}" if damping else f"{EI}" + outs = ["FairTen1"] + [f"L1N{j}p{c}" for j in range(1, segments + 2) for c in "xyz"] + tmax = TMAX_NONE if hset == "none" else TMAX + deck = f"""--------------------- CableDyn Input File --------------------------------- +Chaplin & King (2018) catenary riser, m* {mstar}, U {ux:+.2f} m/s, set {hset} +----------------------- LINE TYPES ------------------------------------------ +TypeName Diam Mass EA BA EI Cd_n Cd_t Ca_n Ca_t Cl dF cF +(-) (m) (kg/m) (N) (N-s) (N-m^2) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) (-) +riser {DIAMETER} {mass(mstar):.6f} {EA:.6e} 0.0 {ei} {CD} 0.0 {CA} 0.0 {cl} +----------------------- POINTS ---------------------------------------------- +ID Attachment X Y Z M V CdA CA +(-) (-) (m) (m) (m) (kg) (m^3) (m^2) (-) +1 Coupled {SPAN} 0.0 {TOP} 0 0 0 0 +2 Fixed 0.0 0.0 {-DEPTH} 0 0 0 0 +----------------------- LINES ----------------------------------------------- +ID LineType AttachA AttachB UnstrLen NumSegs Outputs +(-) (-) (-) (-) (m) (-) (-) +1 riser 1 2 {LENGTH} {segments} - +{viv_sections(hset)}---------------------- OPTIONS ---------------------------------------------- +{RHO} rhoW +{GRAVITY} g +{DEPTH} WtrDpth +{friction:g} frictionMu +{dt:.6f} dtM +{tmax:.6f} TMax +2 Currents +---------------------- OUTPUTS ----------------------------------------------- +{chr(10).join(outs)} +END +------------------------- need this line -------------------------------------- +""" + # a depth profile in time (Currents 2): uniform over the depth, zero at t = 0, U from RAMP + # on; the last row past the end of the run (the table repeats past its last sample) + profile = ( + "Chaplin & King (2018) flume current\n" + "uniform over the depth, ramped from still water\n\n" + "depths (m)\n" + f"{-DEPTH - 0.5:.2f} 0.00\n" + "t (s), ux at each depth (m/s)\n" + + "".join( + f"{t:g} {v:.4f} {v:.4f}\n" + for t, v in ( + (0.0, 0.0), + (RAMP, ux), + (RAMP * math.ceil(tmax / RAMP + 1.0), ux), + ) + ) + ) + return {"ck.dat": deck, "current_profile_dynamic.txt": profile} + + +def read_output(out: Path) -> tuple[list[str], np.ndarray]: + with open(out, encoding="utf-8") as fh: + fh.readline() + head = fh.readline().split() + fh.readline() + a = np.loadtxt(fh) + return head, a + + +def stations() -> list[float]: + """Arc lengths from the upper pin of the twelve accelerometers: 0.4 m apart (Sec. 2), taken + as centred on the line (0.48 m from each pin; the article gives no positions).""" + first = 0.5 * (LENGTH - 11 * 0.4) + return [first + 0.4 * k for k in range(12)] + + +def peak_frequency(y: np.ndarray, dt: float, power: int) -> float: + """The peak of the averaged spectrum (Hann segments of WELCH s, half overlapping) of y, + weighted by omega^power (4: the acceleration spectrum of a displacement), within its BAND.""" + n = int(round(WELCH / dt)) + win = np.hanning(n) + f = np.fft.rfftfreq(n, dt) + sp = np.zeros(len(f)) + for k in range(0, len(y) - n + 1, n // 2): + seg = y[k : k + n] - y[k : k + n].mean() + sp += np.abs(np.fft.rfft(seg * win)) ** 2 + sp *= (2.0 * np.pi * f) ** power + lo, hi = BAND[power] + m = (f >= lo) & (f <= hi) + return float(f[m][np.argmax(sp[m])]) + + +def highpassed_rms(y: np.ndarray, dt: float) -> float: + """r.m.s. of y above the lower edge of the displacement BAND (the vibration without the + slow sideways wandering).""" + f = np.fft.rfftfreq(len(y), dt) + sp = np.fft.rfft(y - y.mean()) + sp[f < BAND[0][0]] = 0.0 + return float(np.fft.irfft(sp, len(y)).std()) + + +def analyse(out: Path, hset: str, direction: str, u: float, segments: int) -> dict: + """Mean and standard deviation of the top tension; the mean profile; at each accelerometer + station and probe the cross-flow A/D_rms (all of it and above 0.3 Hz) and the peak + frequencies of its displacement and acceleration spectra; the inclination of the mean + profile at mid-depth.""" + head, a = read_output(out) + t = a[:, 0] + dt = float(t[1] - t[0]) + t0 = T0 if hset != "none" else T0_NONE + k = t > t0 + 1e-9 + nodes = range(1, segments + 2) + col = {h: i for i, h in enumerate(head)} + ten = a[k, col["FairTen1"]] + xm = np.array([a[k, col[f"L1N{j}px"]].mean() for j in nodes]) + zm = np.array([a[k, col[f"L1N{j}pz"]].mean() for j in nodes]) + s0 = np.linspace(0.0, LENGTH, segments + 1) # unstretched arc length of each node + grounded = zm < -DEPTH + 0.01 + res: dict = { + "mean_top_tension_N": float(ten.mean()), + "sd_top_tension_N": float(ten.std()), + "suspended_length_m": float(s0[~grounded].max()) if (~grounded).any() else 0.0, + "touchdown_x_m": float(xm[~grounded][-1]) if grounded.any() else None, + } + # inclination of the mean profile to the horizontal at mid-depth (z = -DEPTH/2) + j = int(np.argmin(np.abs(zm + 0.5 * DEPTH))) + dz = zm[j - 1] - zm[j + 1] + dx = abs(xm[j - 1] - xm[j + 1]) + res["psi_mid_depth_deg"] = float(math.degrees(math.atan2(abs(dz), dx))) + res["x_mid_depth_m"] = float(xm[j]) + st = [] + for s in stations(): + n = int(round(s / LENGTH * segments)) + 1 + y = a[k, col[f"L1N{n}py"]] + row = { + "s_m": round(s, 3), + "node": n, + "x_m": float(xm[n - 1]), + "z_m": float(zm[n - 1]), + "suspended": bool(not grounded[n - 1]), + "AD_rms": float(y.std() / DIAMETER), + "AD_rms_above_0p3hz": highpassed_rms(y, dt) / DIAMETER, + } + if hset != "none": + row["f_acc_hz"] = peak_frequency(y, dt, 4) + row["f_disp_hz"] = peak_frequency(y, dt, 0) + st.append(row) + res["stations"] = st + for name, zp in PROBES.items(): + free = np.where(~grounded)[0] + n = int(free[np.argmin(np.abs(zm[free] - zp))]) + 1 + y = a[k, col[f"L1N{n}py"]] + p = {"node": n, "x_m": float(xm[n - 1]), "z_m": float(zm[n - 1])} + p["AD_rms"] = float(y.std() / DIAMETER) + p["AD_rms_above_0p3hz"] = highpassed_rms(y, dt) / DIAMETER + if hset != "none": + p["f_acc_hz"] = peak_frequency(y, dt, 4) + p["f_disp_hz"] = peak_frequency(y, dt, 0) + res[name] = p + res["frequency_resolution_hz"] = 1.0 / WELCH + res["steps"] = int(len(t)) + return res + + +def run_case( + exe: Path, folder: Path, files: dict, analyse_fn, key: str, keep: bool, sha: str +) -> dict: + """Write the deck, run it and analyse it. A folder that holds the same input files run by + the same executable is not run again: its result is reused when the analysis key is also + the same, and its output is analysed again if it was kept.""" + folder.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + result, out, ran = ( + folder / "result.json", + folder / "ck.out", + folder / "executable_sha256.txt", + ) + same = all( + (folder / n).is_file() and (folder / n).read_text(encoding="utf-8") == v + for n, v in files.items() + ) + if same and result.is_file(): + old = json.loads(result.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + if old.pop("reuse_key", None) == f"{sha}:{key}": + return old + if not ( + same and out.is_file() and ran.is_file() and ran.read_text().strip() == sha + ): + # A run that fails or is interrupted must not leave the previous model's result next + # to the new inputs, where the next attempt would reuse it. + result.unlink(missing_ok=True) + ran.unlink(missing_ok=True) + out.unlink(missing_ok=True) + for n, v in files.items(): + (folder / n).write_text(v, encoding="utf-8", newline="\n") + proc = subprocess.run( + [str(exe), "ck.dat", "ck"], + cwd=folder, + capture_output=True, + text=True, + encoding="utf-8", + errors="replace", + env=dict(os.environ, OMP_NUM_THREADS="1"), + check=False, + ) + (folder / "console.txt").write_text(proc.stdout + proc.stderr, encoding="utf-8") + if proc.returncode != 0: + raise SystemExit(f"{folder}: CableDyn exited with {proc.returncode}") + ran.write_text(sha + "\n", encoding="utf-8") + res = analyse_fn(out) + result.write_text( + json.dumps({**res, "reuse_key": f"{sha}:{key}"}, indent=1) + "\n", + encoding="utf-8", + ) + if not keep: + out.unlink() + return res + + +# name -> (set, m*, direction, U, role, segments, dt, structural damping, floor friction) +RUNS: dict[str, tuple] = {} +for _m in WEIGHT: + RUNS[f"none_m{_m}_still"] = ( + "none", + _m, + "pos", + 0.0, + "still water", + SEGMENTS, + DT, + True, + FRICTION, + ) +for _s in SETS: + for _m in WEIGHT: + for _d in DIRECTIONS: + for _u in SPEEDS: + RUNS[f"{_s}_m{_m}_{_d}{_u:g}"] = ( + _s, + _m, + _d, + _u, + "primary", + SEGMENTS, + DT, + True, + FRICTION, + ) +CONVERGENCE = (("1.84", "pos", 0.8), ("1.12", "neg", 1.2)) +for _s in ("uls19", "b1", "wake"): + for _m, _d, _u in CONVERGENCE: + _base = f"{_s}_m{_m}_{_d}{_u:g}" + RUNS[_base + "_dt"] = ( + _s, + _m, + _d, + _u, + "half the time step", + SEGMENTS, + DT / 2, + True, + FRICTION, + ) + RUNS[_base + "_n108"] = ( + _s, + _m, + _d, + _u, + "twice the elements", + 2 * SEGMENTS, + DT, + True, + FRICTION, + ) +for _s in ("uls19", "b1", "wake"): + for _m in WEIGHT: + for _d in DIRECTIONS: + for _u in (0.4, 0.8, 1.2): + _base = f"{_s}_m{_m}_{_d}{_u:g}" + RUNS[_base + "_undamped"] = ( + _s, + _m, + _d, + _u, + "no structural damping", + SEGMENTS, + DT, + False, + FRICTION, + ) + RUNS[_base + "_frictionless"] = ( + _s, + _m, + _d, + _u, + "frictionless floor", + SEGMENTS, + DT, + True, + 0.0, + ) + + +def measured() -> dict: + """{(figure, m*): {U: [(value, sd), ...]}} of the extracted points (extract_chaplin2018.py).""" + data: dict = {} + with open(HERE / "measured_chaplin2018.csv", encoding="utf-8") as fh: + for r in csv.DictReader(fh): + key = (r["figure"], r["m_star"]) + sd = float(r["sd"]) if r["sd"] else None + data.setdefault(key, {}).setdefault(round(float(r["U_mps"]), 2), []).append( + (float(r["value"]), sd) + ) + return data + + +def implied_cd(psi_deg: float, u: float, w: float) -> float | None: + """The drag coefficient of a straight line at the inclination psi by the article's Eq. 9, + 0.5 rho Cd d (U sin psi)^2 = W cos psi.""" + p = math.radians(psi_deg) + if u <= 0.0 or p <= 0.0: + return None + return 2.0 * w * math.cos(p) / (RHO * DIAMETER * (u * math.sin(p)) ** 2) + + +def rounded(x): + """Six significant digits, so the record does not carry the last bits of the arithmetic.""" + if isinstance(x, float): + return float(f"{x:.6g}") + if isinstance(x, dict): + return {k: rounded(v) for k, v in x.items()} + if isinstance(x, list): + return [rounded(v) for v in x] + return x + + +def fmt(value: float | None, spec: str = ".3f") -> str: + """A score for the console; n/a when the selection holds nothing for it.""" + return "n/a" if value is None else format(value, spec) + + +def nearest(values: list[float], v: float) -> float | None: + return min(values, key=lambda q: abs(q - v)) if values else None + + +def compare_run(name: str, res: dict, meas: dict, still: dict) -> dict: + """One run against the measured points at its speed.""" + hset, mstar, direction, u, role, segments, dt, damp, mu = RUNS[name] + fig_t = "10" if direction == "pos" else "13" + row: dict = { + "run": name, + "set": hset, + "role": role, + "m_star": mstar, + "direction": direction, + "U_mps": u, + "segments": segments, + "dt_s": dt, + "structural_damping": int(damp), + "floor_friction": mu, + "model_mean_T_N": res["mean_top_tension_N"], + "model_sd_T_N": res["sd_top_tension_N"], + "model_still_T_N": still[mstar], + } + t = meas.get((fig_t, mstar), {}).get(round(u, 2), []) + row["measured_mean_T_N"] = t[0][0] if t else None + row["measured_sd_T_N"] = t[0][1] if t else None + t0 = meas.get((fig_t, mstar), {}).get(0.0, []) + row["measured_still_T_N"] = t0[0][0] if t0 else None + row["model_psi_mid_depth_deg"] = res["psi_mid_depth_deg"] + row["model_cd_eq9"] = implied_cd(res["psi_mid_depth_deg"], u, WEIGHT[mstar]) + p = meas.get(("12a", mstar), {}).get(round(u, 2), []) if direction == "neg" else [] + row["measured_psi_deg"] = p[0][0] if p else None + row["measured_cd_eq9"] = implied_cd(p[0][0], u, WEIGHT[mstar]) if p else None + if hset != "none": + if direction == "pos": + probes = {"upper": ("upper_a", "upper_b"), "lower": ("lower",)} + figs = {"upper": "9a", "lower": "9b"} + else: + probes, figs = {"mid": ("mid_depth",)}, {"mid": "15a"} + for where, names in probes.items(): + # the dominant frequency: the peak of the displacement spectrum (the article's + # acceleration and video-displacement peaks agree, its Fig. 4); the acceleration + # spectrum's peak as a second value + row[f"model_f_{where}_hz"] = float( + np.mean([res[q]["f_disp_hz"] for q in names]) + ) + row[f"model_f_acc_{where}_hz"] = float( + np.mean([res[q]["f_acc_hz"] for q in names]) + ) + pts = [ + v for v, _ in meas.get((figs[where], mstar), {}).get(round(u, 2), []) + ] + row[f"measured_f_{where}_hz"] = ";".join(f"{v:.3f}" for v in sorted(pts)) + row[f"nearest_measured_f_{where}_hz"] = nearest( + pts, row[f"model_f_{where}_hz"] + ) + fs = [ + s["f_disp_hz"] for s in res["stations"] if s["suspended"] and s["z_m"] < 0.0 + ] + row["model_f_span_min_hz"] = min(fs) if fs else None + row["model_f_span_median_hz"] = float(np.median(fs)) if fs else None + row["model_f_span_max_hz"] = max(fs) if fs else None + row["model_AD_rms_max"] = max(s["AD_rms"] for s in res["stations"]) + row["model_AD_rms_above_0p3hz_max"] = max( + s["AD_rms_above_0p3hz"] for s in res["stations"] + ) + return row + + +def scores(rows: list[dict]) -> dict: + """Scores of a set at one mass ratio and direction over the primary speeds.""" + out: dict = {} + t = [ + (r["model_mean_T_N"], r["measured_mean_T_N"]) + for r in rows + if r["measured_mean_T_N"] + ] + if t: + e = np.array([m / x - 1.0 for m, x in t]) + out["T_rms_rel_error"] = float(np.sqrt(np.mean(e**2))) + out["T_mean_rel_error"] = float(np.mean(e)) + out["T_points"] = len(t) + inc = [ + ( + r["model_mean_T_N"] - r["model_still_T_N"], + r["measured_mean_T_N"] - r["measured_still_T_N"], + ) + for r in rows + if r["measured_mean_T_N"] and r["measured_still_T_N"] + ] + if inc: + out["dT_rms_error_N"] = float(np.sqrt(np.mean([(m - x) ** 2 for m, x in inc]))) + out["dT_mean_error_N"] = float(np.mean([m - x for m, x in inc])) + sd = [ + r["model_sd_T_N"] / r["measured_sd_T_N"] for r in rows if r["measured_sd_T_N"] + ] + if sd: + out["sd_T_ratio_median"] = float(np.median(sd)) + out["sd_T_points"] = len(sd) + psi = [ + r["model_psi_mid_depth_deg"] - r["measured_psi_deg"] + for r in rows + if r["measured_psi_deg"] is not None + ] + if psi: + out["psi_rms_error_deg"] = float(np.sqrt(np.mean(np.square(psi)))) + out["psi_mean_error_deg"] = float(np.mean(psi)) + out["cd_eq9_model_median"] = float( + np.median([r["model_cd_eq9"] for r in rows if r["model_cd_eq9"]]) + ) + out["cd_eq9_measured_median"] = float( + np.median([r["measured_cd_eq9"] for r in rows if r["measured_cd_eq9"]]) + ) + for where in ("upper", "lower", "mid"): + k = f"model_f_{where}_hz" + if not rows or k not in rows[0]: + continue + # runs whose acceleration spectrum peaks at a higher harmonic of the displacement's + out[f"f_{where}_acc_peak_at_harmonic"] = int( + sum(r[f"model_f_acc_{where}_hz"] >= 1.5 * r[k] for r in rows) + ) + out[f"f_{where}_model_fd_over_U_median"] = float( + np.median([r[k] * DIAMETER / r["U_mps"] for r in rows]) + ) + meas_fd = [ + float(v) * DIAMETER / r["U_mps"] + for r in rows + for v in r[f"measured_f_{where}_hz"].split(";") + if v + ] + if meas_fd: + out[f"f_{where}_measured_fd_over_U_median"] = float(np.median(meas_fd)) + out[f"f_{where}_measured_points"] = len(meas_fd) + if where == "mid": + # on the normal velocity U sin(psi) of the straight part (Fig. 15(b)): the model's + # inclination at mid-depth, the measured one of Fig. 12(a) + out["f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median"] = float( + np.median( + [ + r[k] + * DIAMETER + / ( + r["U_mps"] + * math.sin(math.radians(r["model_psi_mid_depth_deg"])) + ) + for r in rows + ] + ) + ) + mn = [ + float(v) + * DIAMETER + / (r["U_mps"] * math.sin(math.radians(r["measured_psi_deg"]))) + for r in rows + if r["measured_psi_deg"] + for v in r["measured_f_mid_hz"].split(";") + if v + ] + if mn: + out["f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median"] = float(np.median(mn)) + sel = [r for r in rows if r[f"nearest_measured_f_{where}_hz"]] + if sel: + ratio = [r[k] / r[f"nearest_measured_f_{where}_hz"] for r in sel] + out[f"f_{where}_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median"] = float(np.median(ratio)) + out[f"f_{where}_within_10pct"] = int( + sum(abs(q - 1.0) <= 0.1 for q in ratio) + ) + out[f"f_{where}_points"] = len(sel) + sp = [ + (r["model_f_span_max_hz"] - r["model_f_span_min_hz"]) + / r["model_f_span_median_hz"] + for r in rows + if r.get("model_f_span_median_hz") + ] + if sp: + out["f_span_spread_median"] = float(np.median(sp)) + return out + + +def change(r: dict, base: dict) -> dict: + """Relative change of a sensitivity or convergence run from its primary run.""" + + def rel(k): + if r.get(k) is None or not base.get(k): + return None + return r[k] / base[k] - 1.0 + + ch = { + "role": r["role"], + "mean_T": rel("model_mean_T_N"), + "sd_T": rel("model_sd_T_N"), + } + ch["AD_rms_max"] = rel("model_AD_rms_max") + for w in ("upper", "lower", "mid"): + if f"model_f_{w}_hz" in r: + ch[f"f_{w}"] = rel(f"model_f_{w}_hz") + return ch + + +def main() -> None: + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__.split("\n\n")[0]) + ap.add_argument("exe") + ap.add_argument("workdir") + ap.add_argument( + "--runs", default="all", help="comma list of run names (see RUNS), or all" + ) + ap.add_argument("--jobs", type=int, default=os.cpu_count() or 1) + ap.add_argument("--keep", action="store_true", help="keep the output tables") + ap.add_argument( + "--summary", + default=None, + help="directory for the comparison CSV and summary JSON", + ) + a = ap.parse_args() + found = a.exe if Path(a.exe).is_file() else shutil.which(a.exe) + if found is None: + raise SystemExit(f"CableDyn executable not found: {a.exe}") + exe = Path(found).resolve() + sha = hashlib.sha256(exe.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + names = ( + list(RUNS) + if a.runs == "all" + else [n.strip() for n in a.runs.split(",") if n.strip()] + ) + if not names or any(n not in RUNS for n in names): + raise SystemExit(f"--runs: choose from {', '.join(RUNS)}, got {a.runs!r}") + # the still-water runs are the reference of the tension increments: always run + names = [n for n in RUNS if n.endswith("_still") and n not in names] + names + work = Path(a.workdir).resolve() + + def one(name: str) -> dict: + hset, mstar, direction, u, _, segments, dt, damp, mu = RUNS[name] + folder = work / ( + f"{hset}_m{mstar}_{direction}{u:g}_n{segments}_dt{dt:g}_mu{mu:g}" + + ("" if damp else "_undamped") + ) + return run_case( + exe, + folder, + deck_files(hset, mstar, direction, u, segments, dt, damp, mu), + lambda out: analyse(out, hset, direction, u, segments), + f"{segments}:{ANALYSIS}", + a.keep, + sha, + ) + + with ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=max(1, min(a.jobs, len(names)))) as pool: + results = dict(zip(names, pool.map(one, names), strict=True)) + + meas = measured() + still = { + RUNS[n][1]: results[n]["mean_top_tension_N"] + for n in results + if n.endswith("_still") + } + rows = [compare_run(n, results[n], meas, still) for n in RUNS if n in results] + by = {r["run"]: r for r in rows} + groups: dict = {} + for r in rows: + if r["role"] == "primary": + groups.setdefault(f"{r['set']}_m{r['m_star']}_{r['direction']}", []).append( + r + ) + summary_scores = {k: scores(v) for k, v in groups.items()} + for k, sc in summary_scores.items(): + freq = "; ".join( + f"f_{w} fd/U {fmt(sc.get(f'f_{w}_model_fd_over_U_median'))} [nearest measured " + f"ratio {fmt(sc.get(f'f_{w}_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median'), '.2f')}]" + for w in ("upper", "lower", "mid") + if f"f_{w}_model_fd_over_U_median" in sc + ) + print( + f"{k:18s} T r.m.s. rel. error {fmt(sc.get('T_rms_rel_error'))} " + f"(mean {fmt(sc.get('T_mean_rel_error'), '+.3f')}); increment r.m.s. " + f"{fmt(sc.get('dT_rms_error_N'), '.2f')} N; sd ratio " + f"{fmt(sc.get('sd_T_ratio_median'), '.2f')}; {freq}" + ) + changes = { + r["run"]: change(r, by[r["run"].rsplit("_", 1)[0]]) + for r in rows + if r["role"] not in ("primary", "still water") + and r["run"].rsplit("_", 1)[0] in by + } + summary = rounded( + { + "sets": {k: v["label"] for k, v in SETS.items()}, + "model": { + "length_m": LENGTH, + "diameter_m": DIAMETER, + "EI_Nm2": EI, + "EA_N": EA, + "mass_kg_per_m": {m: mass(m) for m in WEIGHT}, + "submerged_weight_N_per_m": WEIGHT, + "rayleigh_damping": { + "zeta": ZETA, + "f1_hz": RAYLEIGH[0], + "f2_hz": RAYLEIGH[1], + }, + "floor_friction": FRICTION, + "segments": SEGMENTS, + "dt_s": DT, + "tmax_s": TMAX, + "statistics_from_s": T0, + "current_ramp_s": RAMP, + "welch_segment_s": WELCH, + "probe_elevations_m": PROBES, + }, + "still_water_top_tension_N": { + m: { + "model": still[m], + "measured_fig10": meas.get(("10", m), {}).get(0.0, [(None,)])[0][0], + "measured_fig13": meas.get(("13", m), {}).get(0.0, [(None,)])[0][0], + } + for m in still + }, + "scores": summary_scores, + "sensitivity_and_convergence": changes, + "executable_sha256": sha, + } + ) + if a.summary: + out = Path(a.summary) + out.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + fields = list(dict.fromkeys(k for r in rows for k in r)) + + def cell(v): + if v is None: + return "" + if isinstance(v, float): + return f"{v:.6g}" + return v + + with open( + out / "response_comparison.csv", "w", newline="", encoding="utf-8" + ) as fh: + w = csv.DictWriter(fh, fieldnames=fields, lineterminator="\n") + w.writeheader() + for r in rows: + w.writerow({k: cell(r.get(k)) for k in fields}) + (out / "summary.json").write_text( + json.dumps(summary, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n" + ) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/extract_chaplin2018.py b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/extract_chaplin2018.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..201d534 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/extract_chaplin2018.py @@ -0,0 +1,493 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +# SPDX-License-Identifier: Apache-2.0 +# Copyright (c) 2026 Jae Hoon Seo, SMI Lab, Inha University +"""Read the measured points of Chaplin & King (2018), Figs. 9, 10, 12(a), 13 and 15(a), from the PDF. + +The figures are embedded greyscale raster images. Each panel is calibrated on its plot frame and +its tick marks: the frame's left and bottom lines are the zero of each axis (printed there), the +marks found on both opposite sides of the frame give the tick spacing (a mark on one side only, +or a reference line drawn across the frame, is not a tick), and the axis is the least-squares +line through the origin and the ticks; its largest residual is reported. + +The markers are circles of one radius per kind (open, m* 1.12; solid, m* 1.84). Each is a peak of +the share of dark pixels among the dark and white ones on a circle about the point (a circle +Hough transform: grey pixels, an error bar drawn over the outline, count neither way), classed +by the share of dark pixels inside it (less its centre column, where a frame line can pass) as +solid or open; one between the classes is reported and dropped, and so is a peak off the +0.05 m/s grid of the tested speeds by more than a quarter step (two overlapping markers make +such a peak). A marker hidden under another is lost. The speeds are snapped to the grid. + +The error bars of Figs. 10 and 13 (one standard deviation of the top tension each way) end in +caps, grey rows at least a marker radius wide through the marker's column: the bar is the +nearest pair of caps about equally far above and below the marker, its half-length the +standard deviation and its centre the mean (the bar is drawn about it). A bar hidden by its +marker (shorter than the radius), or among the overlapping bars of the two series, is not read +(`sd` blank). Two lines drawn in the figures check the reading: f d/U = 0.11 in Fig. 9 (read +where no marker or tick is near it) and the total submerged weight times the water depth, W h, +in Fig. 13 (Table 1: 41.8 and 5.8 N). + + python extract_chaplin2018.py CHAPLIN2018.pdf [--out measured_chaplin2018.csv] [--check DIR] + +Source: + J.R. Chaplin, R. King (2018), Laboratory measurements of the vortex-induced vibrations of an + untensioned catenary riser with high curvature, Journal of Fluids and Structures 79, 26-38, + https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2018.01.008 (Figs. 9, 10, 12, 13 and 15) +""" + +from __future__ import annotations + +import argparse +import csv +import io +import json +from pathlib import Path + +import numpy as np +import pymupdf +from PIL import Image, ImageDraw +from scipy import ndimage + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +U_GRID = 0.05 # m/s, the speed step of the tests +DIAMETER = 0.056 # m (Table 1), for the slope of the line f d/U = 0.11 in Fig. 9 +DEPTH = 2.0 # m (Table 1), for the lines W h in Fig. 13 + +# Panel: figure label, page index (from 0), image index on the page, panel (0 the left frame, 1 +# the right), quantity, current direction, the point on the riser, x and y tick steps, the grey +# level below which a pixel is dark, marker radii (open, solid) in pixels, masked boxes +# (x0, y0, x1, y1) in pixels (insets, legends, panel labels, notes), and the grey levels of the +# error bars or None. +PANELS = ( + { + "figure": "9a", + "page": 8, + "image": 1, + "panel": 0, + "quantity": "f_cf_hz", + "current": "positive", + "where": "upper (two points of the inset)", + "x_step": 0.25, + "y_step": 0.5, + "black": 128, + "radius": (7.5, 7.5), + "masks": ((150, 18, 340, 125), (265, 312, 470, 378), (455, 325, 516, 380)), + "bars": None, + }, + { + "figure": "9b", + "page": 8, + "image": 1, + "panel": 1, + "quantity": "f_cf_hz", + "current": "positive", + "where": "lower (the point of the inset)", + "x_step": 0.25, + "y_step": 0.5, + "black": 128, + "radius": (7.5, 7.5), + "masks": ((585, 18, 790, 125), (655, 318, 880, 378), (890, 325, 951, 380)), + "bars": None, + }, + { + "figure": "10", + "page": 8, + "image": 2, + "panel": 0, + "quantity": "mean_top_tension_N", + "current": "positive", + "where": "top", + "x_step": 0.25, + "y_step": 50.0, + "black": 70, + "radius": (9.5, 9.5), + "masks": (), + "bars": (75, 140), + }, + { + "figure": "12a", + "page": 9, + "image": 3, + "panel": 0, + "quantity": "psi_deg", + "current": "negative", + "where": "straight part", + "x_step": 0.25, + "y_step": 15.0, + "black": 128, + "radius": (7.0, 7.0), + "masks": ((330, 8, 556, 120), (142, 270, 200, 328)), + "bars": None, + }, + { + "figure": "13", + "page": 10, + "image": 0, + "panel": 0, + "quantity": "mean_top_tension_N", + "current": "negative", + "where": "top", + "x_step": 0.25, + "y_step": 25.0, + "black": 110, + "radius": (10.0, 10.0), + "masks": ((390, 40, 720, 160),), + "bars": (140, 225), + }, + { + "figure": "15a", + "page": 11, + "image": 0, + "panel": 0, + "quantity": "f_cf_hz", + "current": "negative", + "where": "around mid-depth", + "x_step": 0.4, + "y_step": 0.5, + "black": 128, + "radius": (7.5, 4.5), + "masks": ((165, 17, 225, 70),), + "bars": None, + }, +) + + +def image(doc, page: int, index: int) -> np.ndarray: + xref = doc[page].get_images(full=True)[index][0] + return np.asarray( + Image.open(io.BytesIO(doc.extract_image(xref)["image"])).convert("L") + ).astype(int) + + +def groups(idx: np.ndarray) -> list[float]: + if not len(idx): + return [] + return [float(g.mean()) for g in np.split(idx, np.where(np.diff(idx) > 1)[0] + 1)] + + +def frames(dark: np.ndarray) -> list[tuple[float, float, float, float]]: + """The plot frames of the image, left to right: (left, right, top, bottom) centre lines.""" + h, w = dark.shape + rows = groups(np.where(dark.sum(axis=1) > 0.35 * w)[0]) + top, bottom = rows[0], rows[-1] + t, b = int(top) + 3, int(bottom) - 2 + cols = groups(np.where(dark[t:b].sum(axis=0) > 0.9 * (b - t))[0]) + return [(cols[i], cols[i + 1], top, bottom) for i in range(0, len(cols) - 1, 2)] + + +def axis( + dark: np.ndarray, frame: tuple, horizontal: bool, step: float +) -> tuple[float, float, float, int]: + """Origin pixel and pixels per unit of one axis from the frame and its tick marks, the + largest residual of the ticks (in axis units) and their number.""" + left, right, top, bottom = (int(round(v)) for v in frame) + if horizontal: + near = groups( + np.where(dark[bottom - 13 : bottom - 3, left + 4 : right - 3].sum(0) >= 7)[ + 0 + ] + + left + + 4 + ) + far = groups( + np.where(dark[top + 3 : top + 13, left + 4 : right - 3].sum(0) >= 7)[0] + + left + + 4 + ) + origin = frame[0] + else: + near = groups( + np.where(dark[top + 4 : bottom - 3, left + 3 : left + 13].sum(1) >= 7)[0] + + top + + 4 + ) + far = groups( + np.where(dark[top + 4 : bottom - 3, right - 13 : right - 3].sum(1) >= 7)[0] + + top + + 4 + ) + origin = frame[3] + ticks = [p for p in near if any(abs(p - q) <= 1.5 for q in far)] + # the spacing that puts marks on the most whole steps from the origin, less the steps + # without a mark (a reference line drawn across the frame is not on a step) + cands = [abs(p - origin) / k for p in ticks for k in range(1, 11)] + + def score(s: float) -> int: + steps = [abs(p - origin) / s for p in ticks] + on = {round(k) for k in steps if abs(k - round(k)) < 0.1 and round(k) > 0} + return 2 * len(on) - max(on, default=0) + + spacing = max(cands, key=lambda s: (score(s), s)) + pix, val = [origin], [0.0] + for p in ticks: + k = (p - origin) / spacing * (1 if horizontal else -1) + if abs(k - round(k)) < 0.15 and round(k) > 0: + pix.append(p) + val.append(round(k) * step) + slope, icept = np.polyfit(val, pix, 1) + resid = max(abs((p - icept) / slope - v) for p, v in zip(pix, val, strict=True)) + return icept, slope, float(resid), len(pix) - 1 + + +def ring_votes(black: np.ndarray, white: np.ndarray, radius: float) -> np.ndarray: + """The share of dark pixels among the dark and white ones on the circle of the radius about + each pixel (a grey pixel, an error bar drawn over the outline, is no evidence either way); + zero where under half the circle is dark or white.""" + h, w = black.shape + pad = int(radius) + 3 + pb, pw = np.pad(black.astype(float), pad), np.pad(white.astype(float), pad) + ang = np.linspace(0.0, 2.0 * np.pi, 96, endpoint=False) + offs = {(round(radius * np.sin(a)), round(radius * np.cos(a))) for a in ang} + nb, nw = np.zeros((h, w)), np.zeros((h, w)) + for dy, dx in offs: + nb += pb[pad + dy : pad + dy + h, pad + dx : pad + dx + w] + nw += pw[pad + dy : pad + dy + h, pad + dx : pad + dx + w] + seen = nb + nw + return np.where(seen >= 0.5 * len(offs), nb / np.maximum(seen, 1.0), 0.0) + + +def disc_fill(black: np.ndarray, white: np.ndarray, radius: float) -> np.ndarray: + """The share of dark pixels among the dark and white ones in the disc of the radius, less + its centre column on a large disc (where a frame line passes through a marker).""" + r = int(np.ceil(radius)) + yy, xx = np.mgrid[-r : r + 1, -r : r + 1] + k = ( + (xx * xx + yy * yy <= radius * radius) + & (np.abs(xx) > (2 if radius > 4.0 else -1)) + ).astype(float) + nb = ndimage.convolve(black.astype(float), k, mode="constant") + nw = ndimage.convolve(white.astype(float), k, mode="constant") + return nb / np.maximum(nb + nw, 1.0) + + +def markers( + black: np.ndarray, white: np.ndarray, r_open: float, r_solid: float, vote: float +) -> list[tuple]: + """(x, y, kind, ring share, fill share) of the circles found: a peak of the share of dark + pixels on the circle (the largest of four radii, the outline being anti-aliased), classed + by the share of dark pixels inside it.""" + found = [] + for kind, r in (("open", r_open), ("solid", r_solid)): + v = np.max( + [ring_votes(black, white, r - d) for d in (0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5)], axis=0 + ) + fill = disc_fill(black, white, max(r - 4.0, 1.5) if kind == "open" else r - 2.0) + size = int(2 * round(0.7 * r) + 1) + peak = (v == ndimage.maximum_filter(v, size=size)) & (v >= vote) + for y, x in zip(*np.where(peak), strict=True): + f = float(fill[y, x]) + if kind == "open" and r_open == r_solid: + k = "solid" if f > 0.7 else ("open" if f < 0.3 else "unclassified") + elif kind == "open": + k = "open" if f < 0.3 else None + else: + k = "solid" if f > 0.7 else None + if k: + found.append((float(x), float(y), k, float(v[y, x]), f)) + if r_open == r_solid: + break + # one marker per cluster of peaks (a plateau or an anti-aliased edge gives several) + found.sort(key=lambda m: -m[3]) + out: list[tuple] = [] + for m in found: + r = r_open if m[2] == "open" else r_solid + if all((m[0] - o[0]) ** 2 + (m[1] - o[1]) ** 2 > (0.9 * r) ** 2 for o in out): + out.append(m) + return out + + +def error_bar( + grey: np.ndarray, x: float, y: float, r: float +) -> tuple[float, float] | None: + """The centre row and half-length in pixels of the error bar of the marker at (x, y), or + None when the bar is hidden by the marker. + + The bar ends in caps, grey rows at least a marker radius wide through the marker's column; + the bar is the nearest pair of caps about equally far (within half a radius) above and below + the marker's centre. The bar is drawn about the mean, so its centre refines the marker's.""" + c = int(round(x)) + caps = [] + for row in range(grey.shape[0]): + if not grey[row, c - 1 : c + 2].any(): + continue + a = b = c + while a > 0 and grey[row, a - 1]: + a -= 1 + while b < grey.shape[1] - 1 and grey[row, b + 1]: + b += 1 + if b - a + 1 >= r: + caps.append(row) + centres = groups(np.array(caps, dtype=int)) + pairs = [ + (0.5 * (d - u), 0.5 * (u + d)) + for u in centres + if u < y + for d in centres + if d > y and abs((y - u) - (d - y)) <= 0.5 * r + ] + return min(pairs, key=lambda q: q[0])[::-1] if pairs else None + + +def extract(pdf: Path, check: Path | None) -> tuple[list[dict], dict]: + doc = pymupdf.open(pdf) + rows, report = [], {} + for p in PANELS: + g = image(doc, p["page"], p["image"]) + dark = g < 110 + fr = frames(dark)[p["panel"]] + x0, sx, rx, nx = axis(dark, fr, True, p["x_step"]) + y0, sy, ry, ny = axis(dark, fr, False, p["y_step"]) + black = g < p["black"] + left, right, top, bottom = (int(round(v)) for v in fr) + inner = np.zeros_like(black) + inner[top + 3 : bottom - 2, left - 12 : right + 12] = True + if p["figure"] not in ("10", "13"): # no marker on the side lines + inner[:, : left + 3] = False + inner[:, right - 2 :] = False + for a, b, c, d in p["masks"]: + inner[b:d, a:c] = False + black &= inner + white = (g > 215) & inner + # reference lines drawn across the frame are no evidence for or against a marker + h, w = g.shape + for q in groups(np.where(dark.sum(axis=1) > 0.35 * w)[0])[1:-1]: + black[int(q) - 2 : int(q) + 3] = False + white[int(q) - 2 : int(q) + 3] = False + found = markers(black, white, *p["radius"], p.get("vote", 0.8)) + grey = None + if p["bars"]: + lo, hi = p["bars"] + grey = (g >= lo) & (g <= hi) & inner + snaps, dropped, off_grid, shifts, panel_rows = [], [], [], [], [] + for x, y, kind, vote, fill in sorted(found): + u = (x - x0) / sx + val = (y - y0) / sy + ug = round(u / U_GRID) * U_GRID + if kind == "unclassified": + dropped.append( + {"U": round(u, 3), "value": round(val, 3), "fill": round(fill, 2)} + ) + continue + if abs(u - ug) > 0.25 * U_GRID: # between two tested speeds: not a marker + off_grid.append( + {"U": round(u, 3), "value": round(val, 3), "kind": kind} + ) + continue + snaps.append(abs(u - ug)) + row = { + "figure": p["figure"], + "quantity": p["quantity"], + "current": p["current"], + "where": p["where"], + "m_star": "1.84" if kind == "solid" else "1.12", + "U_mps": f"{ug:.2f}", + "value": round(float(val), 4), + "sd": "", + } + bar = None if grey is None else error_bar(grey, x, y, p["radius"][0]) + if bar is not None: + shifts.append(abs(bar[0] - y)) + row["value"] = round(float((bar[0] - y0) / sy), 4) + row["sd"] = round(abs(bar[1] / sy), 3) + panel_rows.append(row) + panel_rows.sort(key=lambda q: (q["m_star"], float(q["U_mps"]), q["value"])) + rows += panel_rows + anchor = {} + if p["figure"] in ("9a", "9b"): + # the line f = 0.11 U/d drawn in the panel, read where no marker or tick mark is + # near it (below the markers, and in (b) above them at the higher speeds), as the + # slope through the origin + us, fs = [], [] + for c in range(left + 4, right - 3): + u = (c - x0) / sx + if not ( + 0.07 <= u <= 0.15 or (p["figure"] == "9b" and 1.1 <= u <= 1.45) + ): + continue + rr = np.where(dark[top + 14 : bottom - 14, c])[0] + top + 14 + if len(rr) and np.ptp(rr) < 6: + us.append(u) + fs.append((float(np.mean(rr)) - y0) / sy) + us_a, fs_a = np.array(us), np.array(fs) + anchor = { + "line_fd_over_U": round( + float(us_a @ fs_a / (us_a @ us_a)) * DIAMETER, 4 + ), + "line_columns": len(us), + "stated": 0.11, + } + if p["figure"] == "13": + # the lines of the total submerged weight times the water depth, W h + h, w = g.shape + lines = groups(np.where(dark.sum(axis=1) > 0.35 * w)[0])[1:-1] + anchor = { + "W_h_lines_N": [round(float((q - y0) / sy), 3) for q in lines], + "table_1_W_h_N": [round(wt * DEPTH, 3) for wt in (20.9, 2.9)], + } + report[p["figure"]] = { + **({"anchor": anchor} if anchor else {}), + "x_ticks": nx, + "x_residual": round(rx, 4), + "y_ticks": ny, + "y_residual": round(ry, 4), + "points": { + m: int(sum(q["m_star"] == m for q in panel_rows)) + for m in ("1.12", "1.84") + }, + "sd_read": { + m: int(sum(q["m_star"] == m and q["sd"] != "" for q in panel_rows)) + for m in ("1.12", "1.84") + } + if grey is not None + else None, + "unclassified": dropped, + "off_grid": off_grid, + "largest_U_snap": round(max(snaps), 4) if snaps else None, + "largest_bar_centre_shift": round(max(shifts) / abs(sy), 4) + if shifts + else None, + } + if check is not None: + check.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + vis = Image.fromarray(g.astype(np.uint8)).convert("RGB") + dr = ImageDraw.Draw(vis) + for x, y, kind, _v, _f in found: + r = p["radius"][0] if kind == "open" else p["radius"][1] + col = {"open": (0, 90, 255), "solid": (230, 0, 0)}.get( + kind, (255, 160, 0) + ) + dr.ellipse((x - r, y - r, x + r, y + r), outline=col, width=2) + bar = None if grey is None else error_bar(grey, x, y, p["radius"][0]) + if bar is not None: + yc, half = bar + dr.line( + (x + 3, yc - half, x + 3, yc + half), fill=(0, 180, 0), width=1 + ) + for k in range(0, 40): + xx = x0 + k * p["x_step"] * sx + if left - 1 <= xx <= right + 1: + dr.line((xx, bottom - 20, xx, bottom), fill=(255, 0, 255)) + yy = y0 + k * p["y_step"] * sy + if top - 1 <= yy <= bottom + 1: + dr.line((left, yy, left + 20, yy), fill=(255, 0, 255)) + vis.save(check / f"fig{p['figure']}_check.png") + return rows, report + + +def main() -> None: + ap = argparse.ArgumentParser() + ap.add_argument("pdf", type=Path) + ap.add_argument("--out", type=Path, default=HERE / "measured_chaplin2018.csv") + ap.add_argument( + "--check", type=Path, help="write the markers found over each figure into DIR" + ) + a = ap.parse_args() + rows, report = extract(a.pdf, a.check) + with open(a.out, "w", encoding="utf-8", newline="\n") as fh: + w = csv.DictWriter(fh, fieldnames=list(rows[0]), lineterminator="\n") + w.writeheader() + w.writerows(rows) + print(json.dumps(report, indent=1)) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/measured_chaplin2018.csv b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/measured_chaplin2018.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..490d2c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/measured_chaplin2018.csv @@ -0,0 +1,328 @@ +figure,quantity,current,where,m_star,U_mps,value,sd +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,0.25,0.6065, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,0.30,0.8144, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,0.35,0.8944, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,0.40,0.8064, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,0.50,1.1104, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,0.55,1.1424, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,1.20,2.1183, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,1.20,2.3503, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,1.25,2.4383, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,1.35,2.2703, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,1.35,2.5503, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.12,1.40,2.3023, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.25,0.5425, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.30,0.6625, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.30,0.7184, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.35,0.7504, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.35,0.9984, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.40,0.9504, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.40,1.0064, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.45,0.9024, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.45,0.9584, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.45,1.0944, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.50,0.9824, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.55,1.0464, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.60,1.2784, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.60,1.3344, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.65,1.3504, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.70,1.3904, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.70,1.4464, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.75,1.4544, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.75,1.5424, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.80,1.5824, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.80,1.6384, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.80,1.6944, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.85,1.7743, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.90,1.7344, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.90,1.8223, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,0.95,1.9423, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.00,1.9583, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.00,2.0143, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.05,2.0463, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.10,2.0463, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.15,2.1503, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.15,2.2063, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.20,2.2783, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.25,2.2943, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.30,2.3103, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.30,2.4223, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.30,2.4863, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.35,2.4943, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.40,2.4543, +9a,f_cf_hz,positive,upper (two points of the inset),1.84,1.40,2.5743, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.20,0.5268, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.45,0.9097, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.50,0.8698, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.60,0.9894, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.65,0.9575, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.65,1.3883, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.70,1.125, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.75,1.2527, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.75,1.5637, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.80,1.2766, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.85,1.2925, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.90,1.5717, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,0.95,1.6515, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.00,1.6435, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.05,1.6993, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.10,1.7472, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.15,1.6515, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.20,1.7392, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.25,1.6674, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.30,1.6993, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.35,1.7791, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.12,1.40,1.811, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.25,0.5826, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.30,0.6784, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.35,0.798, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.40,0.8219, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.45,0.7661, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.50,0.9815, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.55,1.0453, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.60,0.6704, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.60,1.2846, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.65,0.7182, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.65,1.3165, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.70,0.7023, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.70,1.4042, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.70,1.46, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.75,0.6624, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.75,1.5079, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.80,0.8219, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.80,1.6116, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.85,0.7661, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.85,1.7312, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.90,0.7661, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.90,1.827, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.95,0.9416, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,0.95,1.8429, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.00,0.8299, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.00,1.9466, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.05,1.9147, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.10,1.9945, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.15,2.0104, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.20,2.0503, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.25,2.146, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.30,2.2337, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.35,2.2816, +9b,f_cf_hz,positive,lower (the point of the inset),1.84,1.40,2.3454, +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.00,13.3836, +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.20,15.2686, +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.25,16.2111,1.178 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.30,17.6249,1.414 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.35,19.5099,1.885 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.40,21.3949,2.356 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.45,23.5156,2.592 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.50,25.8718,3.534 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.55,28.5815,3.417 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.60,31.5269,4.477 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.65,34.59,5.184 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.70,36.9463,6.126 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.75,40.9519,7.304 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.80,45.311,7.893 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.85,49.0811,8.6 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.90,53.2045,10.132 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,0.95,56.3855,11.192 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.00,60.7446,12.017 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.05,65.9284,13.431 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.10,69.2271,14.373 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.15,75.1178,16.023 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.20,80.1838,16.612 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.25,85.4854,17.908 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.30,90.9048,18.615 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.35,96.7955,20.264 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.12,1.40,101.9793,21.678 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.00,59.0952, +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.20,67.1065, +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.25,66.9887,1.06 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.30,68.2846,1.178 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.35,69.934,1.414 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.40,71.1122,1.885 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.45,73.5862,2.945 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.60,82.6579,5.655 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.65,85.9566,6.598 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.70,89.0198,6.833 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.75,93.968,8.483 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.80,95.7352,9.072 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.85,100.8011,10.132 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.90,104.8068,11.781 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,0.95,109.0481,12.253 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.00,111.8756,13.195 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.05,119.8869,14.609 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.10,123.8926,16.258 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.15,126.7201,16.258 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.20,133.082,18.379 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.25,138.9727,20.971 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.30,144.0386,19.675 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.35,150.8718,23.68 +10,mean_top_tension_N,positive,top,1.84,1.40,154.8775,23.68 +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.25,56.599, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.30,44.7277, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.35,38.1864, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.40,33.0988, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.45,28.4956, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.50,25.3461, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.55,21.9543, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.60,19.5316, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.65,16.8666, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.75,13.9594, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.80,13.4749, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.85,12.748, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,0.95,12.5058, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.00,12.0212, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.10,12.2635, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.20,12.2635, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.25,11.779, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.30,11.5367, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.35,11.2944, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.12,1.40,11.5367, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.20,66.2898, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.25,65.3207, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.30,64.8362, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.35,62.1712, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.40,58.2949, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.45,58.2949, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.50,59.0217, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.55,57.5681, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.60,54.1763, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.65,49.3309, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.70,46.4236, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.75,42.305, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.80,38.671, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.85,37.2174, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.90,35.2792, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,0.95,33.5833, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.00,30.4338, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.05,30.1915, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.10,28.0111, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.15,27.042, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.20,25.1038, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.25,25.1038, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.30,23.1657, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.35,22.4389, +12a,psi_deg,negative,straight part,1.84,1.40,22.1966, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.00,11.4975, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.20,7.7903,0.992 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.25,7.6337,0.835 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.30,6.3283,0.783 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.35,6.2761, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.40,6.6938, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.45,6.9549,0.992 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.50,7.216,0.835 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.55,7.6337,0.835 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.60,8.3124,0.783 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.65,11.132,1.41 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.70,13.2728,1.253 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.75,15.3613,1.462 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.80,16.249,2.036 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.85,18.0764,2.924 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.90,22.9845,4.073 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,0.95,25.282,4.177 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.00,28.0493,4.229 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.05,31.7565,5.013 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.10,34.4716,5.326 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.15,37.8133, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.20,41.5205,6.736 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.30,49.8747,8.72 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.35,52.7464,8.354 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.12,1.40,58.2811, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.00,61.7794,1.514 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.20,58.8555,1.827 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.25,58.0723,1.88 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.30,55.6182,2.036 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.35,55.1483, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.40,51.2322,3.185 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.45,49.1959,3.133 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.50,47.8383, +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.55,44.0267,4.334 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.60,41.6771,4.177 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.65,40.3195,3.551 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.70,40.685,3.812 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.75,40.8939,4.334 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.80,40.9461,4.908 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.85,41.7293,5.9 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.90,42.6692,6.422 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,0.95,42.3559,6.109 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.00,42.1992,6.161 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.05,43.6612,6.892 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.10,44.1312,6.109 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.15,44.2356,6.213 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.20,46.1153,6.109 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.25,46.4808,7.519 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.30,47.0551,5.9 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.35,47.7339,6.37 +13,mean_top_tension_N,negative,top,1.84,1.40,49.457,6.944 +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.40,0.344, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.45,0.3865, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.50,0.3759, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.55,0.3546, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.60,0.344, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.60,0.5354, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.65,0.3971, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.65,0.7002, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.70,0.445, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.70,0.8756, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.75,0.4609, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.75,0.8969, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.80,0.3918, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.80,0.9075, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.85,0.3918, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.85,0.9872, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.90,1.1308, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,0.95,1.1733, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.00,1.2956, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.05,1.3806, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.10,1.4498, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.15,1.5455, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.20,1.5986, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.25,1.673, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.30,1.7528, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.12,1.35,1.7847, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.20,0.3759, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.20,0.445, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.25,0.5832, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.25,0.6045, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.30,0.5991, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.30,0.647, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.30,0.6523, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.35,0.647, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.35,0.6683, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.35,0.8278, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.40,0.8596, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.45,0.8437, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.45,0.865, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.50,0.8596, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.50,1.067, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.55,0.95, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.55,0.9713, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.60,1.0564, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.60,1.0776, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.65,0.4769, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.65,1.0298, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.70,0.7321, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.70,0.9872, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.75,0.95, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.75,1.051, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.80,0.8703, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.85,0.8331, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.85,0.8543, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.90,0.8384, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,0.95,0.7959, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.00,0.7693, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.00,0.7905, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.05,0.7852, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.05,1.1361, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.10,1.0989, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.10,1.1201, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.10,1.1574, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.15,0.9872, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.15,1.1414, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.20,1.0829, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.25,1.0989, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.30,1.0457, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.30,1.067, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.35,1.0776, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.40,1.0989, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.40,1.1148, +15a,f_cf_hz,negative,around mid-depth,1.84,1.40,1.1361, diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/provenance.json b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/provenance.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..79a46a6 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/provenance.json @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +{ + "source": "Chaplin & King (2018), Laboratory measurements of the vortex-induced vibrations of an untensioned catenary riser with high curvature, Journal of Fluids and Structures 79, 26-38 (Table 1; Secs. 2, 3, 4.1, 4.2; Eqs. 9-10; Figs. 3, 5, 9, 10, 12, 13, 15 and their captions); Ulveseter, Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2019), Applied Ocean Research 90, 101856 (Table 1); Ulveseter, Thorsen, Saevik & Larsen (2018), Marine Structures 60, 241-260 (Table 3); Chaplin, Bearman, Huera Huarte & Pattenden (2005), Journal of Fluids and Structures 21(1), 3-24 (Eq. 4); Facchinetti, de Langre & Biolley (2004), Journal of Fluids and Structures 19(2), 123-140 (Secs. 2-3)", + "doi": [ + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2018.01.008", + "10.1016/j.apor.2019.101856", + "10.1016/j.marstruc.2018.04.001", + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2005.04.010", + "10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2003.12.004" + ], + "article_pdf_sha256": "0903b21f16eacc374135408e5473d5c48cc20a041fd0f63621187a7032a42984", + "bibliographic_data": "Chaplin & King (2018): authors, title, journal, volume, year, pages and DOI from the article's first page; the other articles as in the FLOTANT case", + "data_used": "the riser (Table 1: d 56 mm, 5.36 m between the pin ends, EI 1.3 N m^2 and EA 790 kN estimated, structural damping in air about 3 % of critical, submerged weight 2.9 and 20.9 N/m at m* 1.12 and 1.84, water depth 2.0 m, lower pin on the floor, upper pin 200 mm above the surface, 4.30 m between the pins horizontally, U 0 to +-1.4 m/s); the current directions (Sec. 3: positive with the upstream pin on the floor); twelve accelerometers 400 mm apart (Sec. 2); mean top tension and its standard deviation against U (Fig. 10, positive; Fig. 13, negative); cross-flow spectral peak frequencies against U (Fig. 9(a), two accelerometers near the top, and 9(b), one lower down, positive; Fig. 15(a), around mid-depth, negative); the inclination of the straight part in negative current (Fig. 12(a)); Eq. 9 (the straight-line balance of normal drag and weight) for the implied drag coefficient; the statements f d/U about 0.11 (positive, Sec. 4.1) and f d/(U sin psi) about 0.13 (negative, Sec. 4.2); the mean profiles (Fig. 5) for the touchdown, by eye", + "extraction": "extract_chaplin2018.py: Figs. 9, 10, 12, 13 and 15 are embedded greyscale raster images; each panel calibrated on its frame and the tick marks found on both opposite sides of it (largest tick residual 0.0010 m/s, 0.0036 Hz, 0.07 deg, 0.14 N); markers found by a circle Hough transform and classed solid (m* 1.84) or open (m* 1.12) by their fill; speeds snapped to the 0.05 m/s test grid (largest snap 0.012 m/s); peaks off the grid by more than 0.0125 m/s or with a fill between the classes dropped and reported; error bars read from their caps (the bar centre moves the marker's by at most 0.59 N); points read (open/solid): Fig. 9(a) 12/40, 9(b) 22/34, 10 26/24 (46 standard deviations), 12(a) 20/25, 13 25/26 (44 standard deviations), 15(a) 26/47; checks: the line f d/U = 0.11 drawn in Fig. 9 reads 0.105 and 0.108, the lines W h drawn in Fig. 13 read 41.9 and 5.65 N against Table 1's 41.8 and 5.8 N", + "assumptions": "fresh water 1000 kg/m^3 (not stated; m* 1.12 and W 2.9 N/m agree at it); mass per metre with the internal water from the submerged weight, rho A + W/g (for m* 1.84 Table 1's m* gives 1.4 % less mass); the 0.2 m above the surface in air with the same mass; pinned ends at (0, 0, -2.0) and (4.30, 0, 0.2); uniform current over the depth, in the riser's plane, ramped linearly from still water over 10 s (a static solve in the full current finds no equilibrium for some light-riser cases in negative current); Cd 1.2 and Ca 1; floor contact with the default penalty stiffness and damping and friction coefficient 0.5 (not given; a silicone sheath on the flume floor; frictionless as sensitivity); structural damping as Rayleigh damping, 3 % at 0.3 and 3.0 Hz (the range of the measured cross-flow frequencies; none as sensitivity); the accelerometers 0.48 m from each pin, 0.4 m apart (positions not given); the compared points by their mean elevation, at the share of the height between the pins of the dots of the insets of Fig. 9 (0.65 and 0.37 for (a), 0.19 for (b)) and mid-depth for Fig. 15", + "coefficients": { + "uls19": "Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1, fitted by them to the NDP riser in uniform flow (Sec. 4.1, Chh 1.5): Cd 1.2, CM 2, Cl 0.85, cF 0.144, dF 0.064; VIV ClX 0.75, alpha 0.15, Chh 1.5; blind here", + "b1": "the generic set of the Delta Flume case, nothing fitted to these tests: Cl 0.8, cF 0.18, dF 0.08, Cd 1.2; VIV ClX 0.85, alpha 0.15 (Ulveseter et al. 2018, Table 3); VIV AMPLITUDE Cv 0.8 with CdAmp = 1 + 2.3 s + 1.7 s^2, s = (A/D)/sqrt(2), at A/D 0-1.5 (Chaplin et al. 2005, Eq. 4); VIV DAMPING 0 0 1", + "wake": "Facchinetti et al. (2004): WAKE OSCILLATOR CL0 0.3, St 0.2, eps 0.3, A 12, LINE TYPES Cl 0, Cd 1.2; cross-flow only", + "none": "no VIV force, Cd 1.2: the drag of the static solution" + }, + "processing": "statistics over 30-110 s (30-40 s of 40 s runs without VIV); mean and standard deviation of the tension at the upper pin (FairTen1); the mean profile from the mean node positions; the inclination to the horizontal at mid-depth from the neighbouring nodes; the dominant cross-flow frequency as the peak of the averaged spectrum (20 s Hann segments, half overlapping, 0.05 Hz resolution) of the horizontal cross-flow displacement within 0.3-6 Hz, and the peak of the same spectrum times omega^4 (the acceleration spectrum) within 0.15-6 Hz as a second value; A/D_rms of the cross-flow displacement, all of it and above 0.3 Hz; the spread along the span over the assumed accelerometer stations that are suspended and below the surface; the model's frequency compared with the nearest measured point at the same speed and mass ratio (the figures give several spectral peaks at some speeds) and as median f d/U; the tension also as the increment from the still-water value of each figure and of the model; the drag coefficient implied by an inclination through Eq. 9, Cd = 2 W cos psi / (rho d U^2 sin^2 psi)", + "CableDyn_commit": "15b5ebc (dev)", + "validation_date": "2026-11-17", + "executable_name": "cabledyn.exe", + "executable_sha256": "see summary.json", + "compiler": "GNU Fortran 16.2.0", + "build_type": "Release", + "platform": "Windows 11 x86-64", + "segments": 54, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "tmax_s": 110.0, + "statistics_after_s": 30.0, + "reproduction": "the default command, run into a new work directory with the executable of summary.json, reproduces response_comparison.csv and summary.json byte for byte", + "current_ramp_s": 10.0, + "runs": "2 still water, 208 primary (4 sets x 2 mass ratios x 2 directions x 13 speeds), 12 convergence, 72 sensitivity" +} diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/response_comparison.csv b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/response_comparison.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b236f23 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/response_comparison.csv @@ -0,0 +1,295 @@ +run,set,role,m_star,direction,U_mps,segments,dt_s,structural_damping,floor_friction,model_mean_T_N,model_sd_T_N,model_still_T_N,measured_mean_T_N,measured_sd_T_N,measured_still_T_N,model_psi_mid_depth_deg,model_cd_eq9,measured_psi_deg,measured_cd_eq9,model_f_upper_hz,model_f_acc_upper_hz,measured_f_upper_hz,nearest_measured_f_upper_hz,model_f_lower_hz,model_f_acc_lower_hz,measured_f_lower_hz,nearest_measured_f_lower_hz,model_f_span_min_hz,model_f_span_median_hz,model_f_span_max_hz,model_AD_rms_max,model_AD_rms_above_0p3hz_max,model_f_mid_hz,model_f_acc_mid_hz,measured_f_mid_hz,nearest_measured_f_mid_hz +none_m1.12_still,none,still water,1.12,pos,0,54,0.0025,1,0.5,15.0821,7.40696e-07,15.0821,13.3836,,13.3836,52.9723,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_still,none,still water,1.84,pos,0,54,0.0025,1,0.5,81.1893,4.70667e-06,81.1893,59.0952,,59.0952,53.2598,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.2,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,16.7982,0.505064,15.0821,15.2686,,13.3836,51.6608,2.61078,,,0.4,0.8,,,0.4,1.1,0.527,0.5268,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.290581,0.279148,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.3,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,19.0259,0.987133,15.0821,17.6249,1.414,13.3836,50.1694,1.24989,,,0.65,1.85,0.814,0.8144,0.65,0.65,,,0.65,0.65,0.65,0.297955,0.295891,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.4,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,21.291,1.72297,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,48.9137,0.748849,,,0.9,0.9,0.806,0.8064,0.9,0.9,,,0.9,0.9,0.9,0.244977,0.235142,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.5,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,24.7421,3.2214,15.0821,25.8718,3.534,13.3836,49.4818,0.465748,,,1.125,2.2,1.110,1.1104,1.15,1.15,0.870,0.8698,1.1,1.15,1.15,0.285731,0.280606,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.6,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,28.5592,4.74229,15.0821,31.5269,4.477,13.3836,48.245,0.34427,,,1.3,2.525,,,1.3,1.3,0.989,0.9894,1.15,1.3,1.3,0.298055,0.292083,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.7,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,32.45,5.92764,15.0821,36.9463,6.126,13.3836,46.9257,0.270537,,,1.425,1.65,,,1.45,1.65,1.125,1.125,1.4,1.65,1.65,0.281958,0.273706,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.8,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,36.3536,6.68757,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,46.3414,0.213451,,,1.75,3.45,,,1.75,1.75,1.277,1.2766,1.75,1.75,1.75,0.293301,0.287427,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.9,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,42.4833,9.49256,15.0821,53.2045,10.132,13.3836,41.5234,0.217833,,,1.9,1.9,,,1.9,1.9,1.572,1.5717,1.9,1.9,1.9,0.326064,0.316025,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,47.7699,10.0317,15.0821,60.7446,12.017,13.3836,40.3932,0.187839,,,2.3,2.3,,,2.3,2.3,1.643,1.6435,2.3,2.3,2.3,0.316676,0.312013,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1.1,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,53.7868,10.1786,15.0821,69.2271,14.373,13.3836,39.5243,0.16302,,,2.45,2.45,,,2.45,2.45,1.747,1.7472,2.45,2.45,2.45,0.338084,0.332129,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1.2,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,60.3426,11.2162,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,38.883,0.142085,,,2.6,2.6,2.118;2.350,2.3503,2.6,2.6,1.739,1.7392,2.6,2.6,2.6,0.336076,0.332256,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1.3,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,67.5869,12.428,15.0821,90.9048,18.615,13.3836,38.1945,0.125975,,,2.75,2.75,,,2.75,2.75,1.699,1.6993,0.6,2.75,2.75,0.335948,0.331869,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1.4,uls19,primary,1.12,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,75.2104,16.9342,15.0821,101.979,21.678,13.3836,37.4696,0.113327,,,3.075,3.075,2.302,2.3023,2.85,2.85,1.811,1.811,0.65,2.95,3.2,0.334496,0.329498,,,, +uls19_m1.12_neg0.2,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,13.207,0.48489,15.0821,7.7903,0.992,11.4975,54.5352,2.26468,,,,,,,,,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.401757,0.39923,0.4,1.15,, +uls19_m1.12_neg0.3,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,10.64,1.46672,15.0821,6.3283,0.783,11.4975,56.5974,0.909037,44.7277,1.65088,,,,,,,,,0.6,0.6,0.6,0.358314,0.355103,0.6,0.6,, +uls19_m1.12_neg0.4,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,8.91868,1.48389,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,45.3003,0.901194,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.55,0.6,0.7,4.84122,0.587544,0.6,0.6,0.344,0.344 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.5,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,9.18885,1.64364,15.0821,7.216,0.835,11.4975,29.1746,1.52223,25.3461,2.04307,,,,,,,,,0.3,0.65,0.8,7.29032,0.659966,0.8,0.8,0.376,0.3759 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.6,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,10.7976,1.70681,15.0821,8.3124,0.783,11.4975,24.9233,1.46921,19.5316,2.42581,,,,,,,,,0.7,0.7,0.7,0.657846,0.383439,0.7,0.7,0.344;0.535,0.5354 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.7,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,12.8915,2.66935,15.0821,13.2728,1.253,11.4975,7.81918,11.3138,,,,,,,,,,,0.7,0.75,0.75,0.481963,0.336565,0.75,4.25,0.445;0.876,0.8756 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.8,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,15.9706,3.90666,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,13.771,2.77387,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,0.65,0.65,1.8,0.352379,0.331739,0.65,1.8,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.9,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,20.0349,5.14278,15.0821,22.9845,4.073,11.4975,21.4405,0.890744,,,,,,,,,,,0.7,0.725,1.95,0.42938,0.394161,0.7,1.95,1.131,1.1308 +uls19_m1.12_neg1,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,24.7594,6.02741,15.0821,28.0493,4.229,11.4975,27.8851,0.418507,12.0212,2.33529,,,,,,,,,0.7,0.7,2.15,0.3942,0.37677,2.15,2.15,1.296,1.2956 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.1,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,29.5512,6.50701,15.0821,34.4716,5.326,11.4975,30.2918,0.290497,12.2635,1.85391,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,2.4,0.431732,0.419519,0.75,2.4,1.450,1.4498 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.2,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,35.5558,8.34394,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.7633,0.220681,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,2.7,0.402902,0.395627,2.7,2.7,1.599,1.5986 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.3,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,41.9534,8.93749,15.0821,49.8747,8.72,11.4975,33.2026,0.171007,11.5367,1.50123,,,,,,,,,0.85,0.9,2.85,0.377392,0.371633,2.85,2.85,1.753,1.7528 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.4,uls19,primary,1.12,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,48.1665,10.0241,15.0821,58.2811,,11.4975,33.5734,0.143967,11.5367,1.29443,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,3,0.334655,0.3307,3,3,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.2,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,83.5018,0.562486,81.1893,67.1065,,59.0952,53.0688,17.5476,,,0.4,0.4,,,0.4,0.4,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.576817,0.575521,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.3,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,85.3707,1.77032,81.1893,68.2846,1.178,59.0952,52.6434,7.96481,,,0.7,1.375,0.662;0.718,0.7184,0.7,0.7,0.678,0.6784,0.7,0.7,0.7,0.29515,0.294309,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.4,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,88.0966,2.08189,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.4136,4.53148,,,0.8,0.8,0.950;1.006,0.9504,0.8,2.55,0.822,0.8219,0.8,0.8,0.8,0.2599,0.258093,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.5,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,92.1167,5.58529,81.1893,,,59.0952,51.8191,2.98693,,,1.15,3.4,0.982,0.9824,1.15,3.4,0.982,0.9815,1.15,1.15,1.15,0.257071,0.255393,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.6,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,97.2255,6.35024,81.1893,82.6579,5.655,59.0952,51.2613,2.13256,,,1.25,2.375,1.278;1.334,1.2784,1.15,1.25,0.670;1.285,1.2846,1.15,1.25,1.25,0.308735,0.305862,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.7,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,102.06,9.24732,81.1893,89.0198,6.833,59.0952,50.6741,1.61331,,,1.55,1.55,1.390;1.446,1.4464,1.55,1.55,0.702;1.404;1.460,1.46,1.55,1.55,1.55,0.271429,0.267213,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.8,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,108.387,11.8418,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.9678,1.27959,,,1.65,1.65,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6384,1.65,4.8,0.822;1.612,1.6116,1.65,1.65,1.65,0.274848,0.26973,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.9,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,114.847,12.9385,81.1893,104.807,11.781,59.0952,49.4142,1.03951,,,2,2,1.734;1.822,1.8223,2,2,0.766;1.827,1.827,2,2,2,0.281236,0.277281,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,121.545,15.0978,81.1893,111.876,13.195,59.0952,48.8015,0.868404,,,2.05,2.05,1.958;2.014,2.0143,2.05,2.05,0.830;1.947,1.9466,2.05,2.05,2.05,0.266045,0.263599,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1.1,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,130.096,18.0775,81.1893,123.893,16.258,59.0952,47.7316,0.7577,,,2.45,2.45,2.046,2.0463,2.45,2.45,1.994,1.9945,2.45,2.45,2.45,0.284093,0.27958,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1.2,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,138.99,20.5616,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,47.0828,0.658131,,,2.6,2.6,2.278,2.2783,2.6,2.6,2.050,2.0503,2.5,2.6,2.6,0.297519,0.29508,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1.3,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,148.038,23.082,81.1893,144.039,19.675,59.0952,46.4481,0.579362,,,2.65,2.9,2.310;2.422;2.486,2.4863,2.6,2.9,2.234,2.2337,2.5,2.6,2.9,0.304974,0.302497,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1.4,uls19,primary,1.84,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,158.499,28.4721,81.1893,154.877,23.68,59.0952,45.6708,0.520058,,,3.1,3.1,2.454;2.574,2.5743,3.1,3.1,2.345,2.3454,2.7,3.1,3.1,0.31863,0.316677,,,, +uls19_m1.84_neg0.2,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,78.9164,0.688175,81.1893,58.8555,1.827,61.7794,53.4022,17.2606,66.2898,8.95099,,,,,,,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.630941,0.629787,0.4,0.4,0.376;0.445,0.3759 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.3,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,76.9682,1.85657,81.1893,55.6182,2.036,61.7794,53.8297,7.51106,64.8362,4.30484,,,,,,,,,0.7,0.7,0.7,0.380995,0.380378,0.7,0.7,0.599;0.647;0.652,0.6523 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.4,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,73.618,2.70573,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.133,4.16217,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.429528,0.427898,0.75,0.75,0.860,0.8596 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.5,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,69.2553,7.26376,81.1893,47.8383,,61.7794,54.6664,2.59456,59.0217,2.09067,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.359293,0.356198,1.05,3.25,0.860;1.067,1.067 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.6,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,64.4232,7.776,81.1893,41.6771,4.177,61.7794,55.0391,1.76893,54.1763,1.8459,,,,,,,,,1.1,1.1,1.1,0.38279,0.380068,1.1,3.3,1.056;1.078,1.0776 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.7,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,57.104,11.6844,81.1893,40.685,3.812,61.7794,55.2549,1.28584,46.4236,2.00074,,,,,,,,,1.35,1.35,1.35,0.42465,0.422203,1.35,1.35,0.732;0.987,0.9872 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.8,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,46.6838,11.7027,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,54.9516,0.999326,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.35,1.35,1.35,0.51698,0.513608,1.35,1.35,0.870,0.8703 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.9,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,41.5531,10.1871,81.1893,42.6692,6.422,61.7794,51.8108,0.922272,35.2792,2.25518,,,,,,,,,1.7,1.7,1.7,0.620772,0.387479,1.7,1.7,0.838,0.8384 +uls19_m1.84_neg1,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,40.9581,9.43808,81.1893,42.1992,6.161,61.7794,40.0715,1.37836,30.4338,2.50826,,,,,,,,,1.35,1.475,1.5,2.05317,0.510681,1.5,1.5,0.769;0.790,0.7905 +uls19_m1.84_neg1.1,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,43.7696,10.2278,81.1893,44.1312,6.109,61.7794,37.1388,1.3491,28.0111,2.46921,,,,,,,,,0.3,1.45,1.7,4.22466,0.517487,1.45,1.45,1.099;1.120;1.157,1.1574 +uls19_m1.84_neg1.2,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,44.481,10.067,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,34.1723,1.35935,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,1.35,1.5,1.6,4.92323,0.535254,1.5,1.6,1.083,1.0829 +uls19_m1.84_neg1.3,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,45.6169,8.97161,81.1893,47.0551,5.9,61.7794,32.0176,1.33227,23.1657,2.62387,,,,,,,,,0.3,1.45,1.45,2.32614,0.594189,1.45,1.45,1.046;1.067,1.067 +uls19_m1.84_neg1.4,uls19,primary,1.84,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,50.8233,11.3919,81.1893,49.457,6.944,61.7794,30.0477,1.31481,22.1966,2.4706,,,,,,,,,1.25,1.5,1.5,0.720432,0.685319,1.5,1.5,1.099;1.115;1.136,1.1361 +b1_m1.12_pos0.2,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,17.8442,0.462354,15.0821,15.2686,,13.3836,51.0541,2.69076,,,0.45,0.45,,,0.45,0.45,0.527,0.5268,0.45,0.45,0.45,0.335692,0.335062,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.3,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,20.617,0.894396,15.0821,17.6249,1.414,13.3836,49.5317,1.2905,,,0.7,0.7,0.814,0.8144,0.7,0.7,,,0.7,0.7,0.7,0.256612,0.255881,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.4,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,23.8264,1.08904,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,50.587,0.688543,,,1,1,0.806,0.8064,1,1,,,1,1,1,0.205427,0.202575,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.5,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,28.1924,1.98308,15.0821,25.8718,3.534,13.3836,49.1511,0.473562,,,1.3,1.3,1.110,1.1104,1.3,1.3,0.870,0.8698,1.3,1.3,1.3,0.221766,0.2184,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.6,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,34.9741,4.49274,15.0821,31.5269,4.477,13.3836,46.8139,0.370351,,,1.5,1.5,,,1.5,1.5,0.989,0.9894,1.5,1.5,1.5,0.272664,0.272337,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.7,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,42.4771,6.1477,15.0821,36.9463,6.126,13.3836,42.0844,0.34922,,,1.6,1.6,,,1.6,1.6,1.125,1.125,1.6,1.6,1.6,0.344173,0.343541,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.8,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,49.0168,7.01484,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,40.4558,0.292474,,,1.75,1.75,,,1.75,1.75,1.277,1.2766,1.75,1.75,1.75,0.341887,0.341488,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.9,b1,primary,1.12,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,57.239,7.69997,15.0821,53.2045,10.132,13.3836,38.6426,0.25611,,,1.9,1.9,,,1.9,1.9,1.572,1.5717,1.9,1.9,1.9,0.377248,0.376985,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1,b1,primary,1.12,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,60.2975,7.40786,15.0821,60.7446,12.017,13.3836,38.338,0.211133,,,2.65,2.65,,,2.65,2.65,1.643,1.6435,2.65,2.65,2.65,0.235408,0.231654,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1.1,b1,primary,1.12,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,69.6399,8.0892,15.0821,69.2271,14.373,13.3836,37.3617,0.184743,,,2.85,2.85,,,2.85,2.85,1.747,1.7472,2.85,2.85,2.85,0.246849,0.245344,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1.2,b1,primary,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,80.1743,8.78522,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,36.5842,0.162587,,,3.05,3.05,2.118;2.350,2.3503,3.05,3.05,1.739,1.7392,3.05,3.05,3.05,0.257829,0.255474,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1.3,b1,primary,1.12,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,91.9598,9.62496,15.0821,90.9048,18.615,13.3836,36.0306,0.143241,,,3.2,3.2,,,3.2,3.2,1.699,1.6993,3.2,3.2,3.2,0.271682,0.269195,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1.4,b1,primary,1.12,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,103.84,10.6626,15.0821,101.979,21.678,13.3836,35.4957,0.127608,,,3.4,3.4,2.302,2.3023,3.4,3.4,1.811,1.811,3.4,3.4,3.4,0.278058,0.275187,,,, +b1_m1.12_neg0.2,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,11.8077,0.331512,15.0821,7.7903,0.992,11.4975,55.8476,2.12258,,,,,,,,,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.361508,0.360993,0.4,0.4,, +b1_m1.12_neg0.3,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,6.97933,0.896034,15.0821,6.3283,0.783,11.4975,55.9692,0.937718,44.7277,1.65088,,,,,,,,,0.6,0.6,0.65,2.88907,0.443817,0.6,0.65,, +b1_m1.12_neg0.4,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,8.64443,1.17382,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,29.2802,2.36044,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.65,0.65,0.65,6.33725,0.392525,0.5,0.65,0.344,0.344 +b1_m1.12_neg0.5,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,9.62771,1.21886,15.0821,7.216,0.835,11.4975,27.2191,1.76096,25.3461,2.04307,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,0.8,1.59474,0.306817,0.8,0.85,0.376,0.3759 +b1_m1.12_neg0.6,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,12.7133,1.62156,15.0821,8.3124,0.783,11.4975,12.3059,6.18799,19.5316,2.42581,,,,,,,,,0.85,1.4,1.4,0.301397,0.275481,0.85,1.4,0.344;0.535,0.5354 +b1_m1.12_neg0.7,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,16.4408,2.35539,15.0821,13.2728,1.253,11.4975,9.57303,7.53607,,,,,,,,,,,0.85,1.6,1.6,0.295568,0.287685,1.6,1.6,0.445;0.876,0.8756 +b1_m1.12_neg0.8,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,20.9937,3.72381,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,20.6909,1.2127,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,2,0.317085,0.303612,0.8,2,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +b1_m1.12_neg0.9,b1,primary,1.12,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,27.6884,4.66769,15.0821,22.9845,4.073,11.4975,27.4542,0.533813,,,,,,,,,,,0.9,2.2,2.2,0.309022,0.302846,2.2,2.2,1.131,1.1308 +b1_m1.12_neg1,b1,primary,1.12,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,34.5055,5.42344,15.0821,28.0493,4.229,11.4975,29.372,0.375184,12.0212,2.33529,,,,,,,,,0.85,2.4,2.4,0.299756,0.292745,2.4,2.4,1.296,1.2956 +b1_m1.12_neg1.1,b1,primary,1.12,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,42.7488,6.50108,15.0821,34.4716,5.326,11.4975,30.6859,0.282643,12.2635,1.85391,,,,,,,,,0.95,2.6,2.6,0.293857,0.291643,2.6,2.6,1.450,1.4498 +b1_m1.12_neg1.2,b1,primary,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,49.6299,8.06837,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.5836,0.223367,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,3.15,3.15,0.288318,0.282889,3.15,3.15,1.599,1.5986 +b1_m1.12_neg1.3,b1,primary,1.12,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,60.5516,10.4315,15.0821,49.8747,8.72,11.4975,32.6386,0.177415,11.5367,1.50123,,,,,,,,,1.1,3.35,3.35,0.30644,0.302574,3.35,3.35,1.753,1.7528 +b1_m1.12_neg1.4,b1,primary,1.12,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,70.7403,11.0166,15.0821,58.2811,,11.4975,32.826,0.151108,11.5367,1.29443,,,,,,,,,1.05,3.55,3.55,0.286056,0.28236,3.55,3.55,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.2,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,84.5959,0.315659,81.1893,67.1065,,59.0952,53.0472,17.5663,,,0.4,0.4,,,0.4,0.4,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.414209,0.413506,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.3,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,87.2795,1.30437,81.1893,68.2846,1.178,59.0952,52.4095,8.05763,,,0.8,0.8,0.662;0.718,0.7184,0.8,0.8,0.678,0.6784,0.8,0.8,0.8,0.299691,0.299448,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.4,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,91.8078,1.65316,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,51.9078,4.64658,,,0.85,0.875,0.950;1.006,0.9504,0.85,2.65,0.822,0.8219,0.85,0.85,0.85,0.294024,0.293808,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.5,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,97.206,3.99897,81.1893,,,59.0952,51.4993,3.03475,,,1.25,1.25,0.982,0.9824,1.25,1.25,0.982,0.9815,1.25,1.25,1.25,0.278779,0.278422,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.6,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,102.611,6.28011,81.1893,82.6579,5.655,59.0952,51.1333,2.14619,,,1.65,1.65,1.278;1.334,1.3344,1.65,1.65,0.670;1.285,1.2846,1.65,1.65,1.65,0.232829,0.232134,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.7,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,111.354,6.58642,81.1893,89.0198,6.833,59.0952,50.4149,1.63432,,,1.7,1.7,1.390;1.446,1.4464,1.7,1.7,0.702;1.404;1.460,1.46,1.7,1.7,1.7,0.254988,0.254675,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.8,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,117.248,5.44981,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.7613,1.2929,,,2.15,2.15,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.15,2.15,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.15,2.15,2.15,0.202551,0.200234,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.9,b1,primary,1.84,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,128.23,5.4304,81.1893,104.807,11.781,59.0952,51.3579,0.943261,,,2.2,2.25,1.734;1.822,1.8223,2.2,2.25,0.766;1.827,1.827,2.2,2.2,2.2,0.223181,0.221544,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1,b1,primary,1.84,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,138.562,7.35885,81.1893,111.876,13.195,59.0952,50.6823,0.790197,,,2.4,2.4,1.958;2.014,2.0143,2.4,2.4,0.830;1.947,1.9466,2.4,2.4,2.4,0.230163,0.228669,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1.1,b1,primary,1.84,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,148.977,11.1622,81.1893,123.893,16.258,59.0952,49.9679,0.676799,,,2.7,2.7,2.046,2.0463,2.7,2.7,1.994,1.9945,2.7,2.7,2.7,0.228494,0.227725,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1.2,b1,primary,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,161.442,12.2877,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,49.2552,0.589421,,,2.9,2.9,2.278,2.2783,2.9,2.9,2.050,2.0503,2.9,2.9,2.9,0.236213,0.234689,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1.3,b1,primary,1.84,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,172.672,13.2286,81.1893,144.039,19.675,59.0952,48.5104,0.521466,,,3.35,3.35,2.310;2.422;2.486,2.4863,3.35,3.35,2.234,2.2337,3.35,3.35,3.35,0.233991,0.231738,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1.4,b1,primary,1.84,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,188.787,16.9118,81.1893,154.877,23.68,59.0952,47.7798,0.466616,,,3.55,3.55,2.454;2.574,2.5743,3.55,3.55,2.345,2.3454,3.55,3.55,3.55,0.248269,0.245969,,,, +b1_m1.84_neg0.2,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,77.5835,0.380754,81.1893,58.8555,1.827,61.7794,53.4401,17.2283,66.2898,8.95099,,,,,,,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.452471,0.451603,0.4,0.4,0.376;0.445,0.3759 +b1_m1.84_neg0.3,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,74.351,1.25332,81.1893,55.6182,2.036,61.7794,54.1917,7.378,64.8362,4.30484,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.364583,0.364234,0.75,0.75,0.599;0.647;0.652,0.6523 +b1_m1.84_neg0.4,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,66.3728,1.82298,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,55.1275,3.96276,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.51534,0.515239,0.75,0.8,0.860,0.8596 +b1_m1.84_neg0.5,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,61.3014,3.739,81.1893,47.8383,,61.7794,54.4635,2.62067,59.0217,2.09067,,,,,,,,,1.1,1.1,1.1,0.361778,0.361137,1.1,1.1,0.860;1.067,1.067 +b1_m1.84_neg0.6,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,45.2312,3.60092,81.1893,41.6771,4.177,61.7794,52.1771,2.03774,54.1763,1.8459,,,,,,,,,1.1,1.1,1.1,0.412343,0.41208,1.1,1.1,1.056;1.078,1.0776 +b1_m1.84_neg0.7,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,39.7423,6.25808,81.1893,40.685,3.812,61.7794,47.9008,1.85501,46.4236,2.00074,,,,,,,,,1.2,1.2,1.7,1.50073,0.353537,1.2,1.75,0.732;0.987,0.9872 +b1_m1.84_neg0.8,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,36.3453,5.99557,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,36.4359,2.66003,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.4,1.4,1.4,0.625166,0.458806,1.4,1.4,0.870,0.8703 +b1_m1.84_neg0.9,b1,primary,1.84,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,39.4287,8.51141,81.1893,42.6692,6.422,61.7794,35.0859,2.2823,35.2792,2.25518,,,,,,,,,1.75,1.75,1.75,0.487621,0.401164,1.75,1.75,0.838,0.8384 +b1_m1.84_neg1,b1,primary,1.84,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,46.0085,8.90145,81.1893,42.1992,6.161,61.7794,30.2035,2.54896,30.4338,2.50826,,,,,,,,,1.45,1.45,1.45,0.640768,0.633602,1.45,1.45,0.769;0.790,0.7905 +b1_m1.84_neg1.1,b1,primary,1.84,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,47.0611,8.11609,81.1893,44.1312,6.109,61.7794,28.2051,2.43371,28.0111,2.46921,,,,,,,,,1.7,1.7,1.7,0.460818,0.457059,1.7,1.7,1.099;1.120;1.157,1.1574 +b1_m1.84_neg1.2,b1,primary,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,54.2003,7.26079,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,25.3593,2.55351,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,1.7,1.7,1.7,0.478409,0.475229,1.7,1.7,1.083,1.0829 +b1_m1.84_neg1.3,b1,primary,1.84,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,68.1528,7.23587,81.1893,47.0551,5.9,61.7794,22.4299,2.80432,23.1657,2.62387,,,,,,,,,1.55,1.55,1.55,0.712186,0.708497,1.55,1.55,1.046;1.067,1.067 +b1_m1.84_neg1.4,b1,primary,1.84,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,68.3621,7.80477,81.1893,49.457,6.944,61.7794,22.0258,2.51016,22.1966,2.4706,,,,,,,,,1.45,1.85,1.85,0.60034,0.596298,1.85,1.85,1.099;1.115;1.136,1.1361 +wake_m1.12_pos0.2,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,16.661,0.170801,15.0821,15.2686,,13.3836,51.822,2.58997,,,0.65,0.65,,,0.65,0.65,0.527,0.5268,0.65,0.65,0.65,0.115981,0.115959,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.3,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,18.4945,0.246897,15.0821,17.6249,1.414,13.3836,50.6199,1.22207,,,0.75,0.75,0.814,0.8144,0.75,0.75,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.141841,0.141796,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.4,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,20.849,0.409665,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,51.506,0.657736,,,1.05,1.05,0.806,0.8064,1.05,1.05,,,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.100873,0.100827,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.5,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,23.6381,0.42611,15.0821,25.8718,3.534,13.3836,50.2137,0.448967,,,1.45,1.45,1.110,1.1104,1.45,1.45,0.870,0.8698,1.45,1.45,1.45,0.0723722,0.0723298,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.6,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,26.8303,0.45461,15.0821,31.5269,4.477,13.3836,48.8897,0.333224,,,1.8,1.8,,,1.8,1.8,0.989,0.9894,1.8,1.8,1.8,0.0665012,0.0664786,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.7,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,30.406,0.461556,15.0821,36.9463,6.126,13.3836,47.5924,0.261468,,,2.2,2.2,,,2.2,2.2,1.125,1.125,2.2,2.2,2.2,0.061609,0.0615921,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.8,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,34.2969,0.752786,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,46.4124,0.212671,,,2.7,2.7,,,2.7,2.7,1.277,1.2766,2.7,2.7,2.7,0.0551598,0.0551403,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.9,wake,primary,1.12,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,38.9532,3.94744,15.0821,53.2045,10.132,13.3836,45.1656,0.17927,,,2.8,2.8,,,2.8,2.8,1.572,1.5717,2.8,2.8,2.8,0.0924481,0.0924292,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1,wake,primary,1.12,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,43.5717,4.18102,15.0821,60.7446,12.017,13.3836,41.1332,0.180275,,,3,3,,,3,3,1.643,1.6435,3,3,3,0.0904283,0.0904264,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1.1,wake,primary,1.12,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,48.5331,4.22874,15.0821,69.2271,14.373,13.3836,40.1994,0.156932,,,3.5,3.5,,,3.5,3.5,1.747,1.7472,1.2,3.5,3.5,0.0908766,0.0908747,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1.2,wake,primary,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,54.1453,4.47332,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,39.3656,0.138222,,,3.7,3.7,2.118;2.350,2.3503,3.7,3.7,1.739,1.7392,1.3,3.7,3.7,0.0955076,0.0955059,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1.3,wake,primary,1.12,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,59.9828,4.30422,15.0821,90.9048,18.615,13.3836,38.6897,0.122419,,,3.9,3.9,,,3.9,3.9,1.699,1.6993,1.35,3.9,3.9,0.08576,0.0857565,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1.4,wake,primary,1.12,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,66.5193,4.3679,15.0821,101.979,21.678,13.3836,38.1281,0.109042,,,4.45,4.45,2.302,2.3023,1.5,4.45,1.811,1.811,1.5,4.45,4.45,0.0895442,0.0895351,,,, +wake_m1.12_neg0.2,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,13.382,0.159206,15.0821,7.7903,0.992,11.4975,54.2897,2.29229,,,,,,,,,,,0.65,0.65,0.65,0.145324,0.145322,0.65,0.65,, +wake_m1.12_neg0.3,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,10.908,0.381385,15.0821,6.3283,0.783,11.4975,56.311,0.922007,44.7277,1.65088,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.19522,0.195196,0.75,0.75,, +wake_m1.12_neg0.4,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,6.60157,0.618627,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,60.0522,0.430415,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,1.1,1.1,1.1,2.17459,0.330561,1.05,1.1,0.344,0.344 +wake_m1.12_neg0.5,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,8.96422,1.04159,15.0821,7.216,0.835,11.4975,33.3284,1.14665,25.3461,2.04307,,,,,,,,,0.3,1,1,5.84594,0.477238,1,1.05,0.376,0.3759 +wake_m1.12_neg0.6,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,9.46979,0.337079,15.0821,8.3124,0.783,11.4975,28.5169,1.1091,19.5316,2.42581,,,,,,,,,0.95,0.95,0.95,0.503508,0.171016,0.95,0.95,0.344;0.535,0.5354 +wake_m1.12_neg0.7,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,11.7779,0.494708,15.0821,13.2728,1.253,11.4975,15.8764,2.71667,,,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.375011,0.128873,1.05,2.25,0.445;0.876,0.8756 +wake_m1.12_neg0.8,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,13.9601,1.06802,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,6.55674,12.3303,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,2.35,0.132718,0.129969,1.05,2.35,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +wake_m1.12_neg0.9,wake,primary,1.12,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,16.9286,1.22128,15.0821,22.9845,4.073,11.4975,14.8527,1.88097,,,,,,,,,,,0.9,0.9,0.9,0.181414,0.181246,0.9,2.85,1.131,1.1308 +wake_m1.12_neg1,wake,primary,1.12,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,20.804,1.93042,15.0821,28.0493,4.229,11.4975,21.4908,0.71804,12.0212,2.33529,,,,,,,,,1,1,1,0.229624,0.229614,1,3.05,1.296,1.2956 +wake_m1.12_neg1.1,wake,primary,1.12,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,25.1048,2.2469,15.0821,34.4716,5.326,11.4975,27.4711,0.356885,12.2635,1.85391,,,,,,,,,1.1,1.1,1.1,0.215837,0.215836,1.1,3.25,1.450,1.4498 +wake_m1.12_neg1.2,wake,primary,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,29.935,2.70359,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,29.4392,0.259292,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,0.95,0.95,0.272134,0.271988,0.95,3.8,1.599,1.5986 +wake_m1.12_neg1.3,wake,primary,1.12,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,35.507,3.48301,15.0821,49.8747,8.72,11.4975,30.9032,0.199355,11.5367,1.50123,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.260566,0.26054,1.05,4,1.753,1.7528 +wake_m1.12_neg1.4,wake,primary,1.12,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,41.5115,4.09762,15.0821,58.2811,,11.4975,31.9795,0.159801,11.5367,1.29443,,,,,,,,,1.15,1.15,4.2,0.241753,0.24172,1.15,4.25,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.2,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,82.8629,0.0687709,81.1893,67.1065,,59.0952,53.0689,17.5475,,,0.4,0.45,,,0.4,0.45,,,0.4,0.4,0.4,0.16757,0.167172,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.3,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,85.0724,0.672893,81.1893,68.2846,1.178,59.0952,52.7721,7.91423,,,0.8,0.8,0.662;0.718,0.7184,0.8,0.8,0.678,0.6784,0.8,0.8,0.8,0.22153,0.2215,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.4,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,87.844,1.44613,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.4521,4.52285,,,1.2,1.2,0.950;1.006,1.0064,1.2,1.2,0.822,0.8219,1.2,1.2,1.2,0.157132,0.157128,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.5,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,91.4428,2.03103,81.1893,,,59.0952,52.0287,2.95603,,,1.25,1.25,0.982,0.9824,1.25,1.25,0.982,0.9815,1.25,1.25,1.25,0.182603,0.182547,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.6,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,95.5815,3.47034,81.1893,82.6579,5.655,59.0952,51.5628,2.10083,,,1.7,1.7,1.278;1.334,1.3344,1.7,1.7,0.670;1.285,1.2846,1.7,1.7,1.7,0.143667,0.143664,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.7,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,100.171,3.55503,81.1893,89.0198,6.833,59.0952,51.0453,1.58372,,,1.8,1.8,1.390;1.446,1.4464,1.8,1.8,0.702;1.404;1.460,1.46,1.8,1.8,1.8,0.13306,0.13306,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.8,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,105.591,4.94124,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.4405,1.24968,,,2.25,2.25,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.25,2.25,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.25,2.25,2.25,0.116867,0.116857,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.9,wake,primary,1.84,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,111.216,5.00462,81.1893,104.807,11.781,59.0952,49.8015,1.01949,,,2.7,2.75,1.734;1.822,1.8223,2.7,2.75,0.766;1.827,1.827,2.7,2.7,2.7,0.0901874,0.0901867,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1,wake,primary,1.84,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,117.097,4.40724,81.1893,111.876,13.195,59.0952,49.1796,0.852003,,,3.25,3.25,1.958;2.014,2.0143,3.25,3.25,0.830;1.947,1.9466,3.25,3.25,3.25,0.0654489,0.0654455,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1.1,wake,primary,1.84,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,124.076,3.9978,81.1893,123.893,16.258,59.0952,48.5429,0.727131,,,3.35,3.35,2.046,2.0463,3.35,3.35,1.994,1.9945,3.35,3.35,3.35,0.0775094,0.0775043,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1.2,wake,primary,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,130.962,2.65824,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,50.2617,0.560397,,,3.85,3.85,2.278,2.2783,3.85,3.85,2.050,2.0503,3.85,3.85,3.85,0.0603488,0.060347,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1.3,wake,primary,1.84,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,138.232,1.64084,81.1893,144.039,19.675,59.0952,49.751,0.48987,,,4.35,4.35,2.310;2.422;2.486,2.4863,4.35,4.35,2.234,2.2337,4.35,4.35,4.35,0.0469925,0.0469611,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1.4,wake,primary,1.84,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,146.368,1.67264,81.1893,154.877,23.68,59.0952,49.1593,0.435141,,,4.6,4.6,2.454;2.574,2.5743,4.6,4.6,2.345,2.3454,4.6,4.6,4.6,0.0555173,0.055509,,,, +wake_m1.84_neg0.2,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,79.5154,0.030973,81.1893,58.8555,1.827,61.7794,53.4513,17.2188,66.2898,8.95099,,,,,,,,,0.45,0.45,0.45,0.139498,0.138974,0.45,0.45,0.376;0.445,0.445 +wake_m1.84_neg0.3,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,77.2669,0.240443,81.1893,55.6182,2.036,61.7794,53.732,7.54741,64.8362,4.30484,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.222992,0.222692,0.75,0.75,0.599;0.647;0.652,0.6523 +wake_m1.84_neg0.4,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,74.2509,1.44239,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.0402,4.18129,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,1.15,1.15,1.15,0.208451,0.208451,1.15,1.15,0.860,0.8596 +wake_m1.84_neg0.5,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,70.2035,1.43578,81.1893,47.8383,,61.7794,54.4837,2.61807,59.0217,2.09067,,,,,,,,,1.2,1.2,1.2,0.196587,0.196575,1.2,1.2,0.860;1.067,1.067 +wake_m1.84_neg0.6,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,64.8811,3.65972,81.1893,41.6771,4.177,61.7794,54.8751,1.78331,54.1763,1.8459,,,,,,,,,1.6,1.6,1.6,0.191176,0.191176,1.6,1.6,1.056;1.078,1.0776 +wake_m1.84_neg0.7,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,58.317,4.84428,81.1893,40.685,3.812,61.7794,54.8843,1.30959,46.4236,2.00074,,,,,,,,,2,2,2,0.155515,0.155451,2,2,0.732;0.987,0.9872 +wake_m1.84_neg0.8,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,49.3009,4.47424,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,54.7239,1.01063,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,2.05,2.05,2.05,0.202368,0.20236,2.05,2.05,0.870,0.8703 +wake_m1.84_neg0.9,wake,primary,1.84,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,37.3182,4.25987,81.1893,42.6692,6.422,61.7794,52.5411,0.889474,35.2792,2.25518,,,,,,,,,2.05,2.05,2.05,0.193915,0.193915,2.05,2.05,0.838,0.8384 +wake_m1.84_neg1,wake,primary,1.84,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,37.4836,4.76732,81.1893,42.1992,6.161,61.7794,40.8471,1.31996,30.4338,2.50826,,,,,,,,,2.2,2.2,2.35,3.2332,0.211639,2.2,2.2,0.769;0.790,0.7905 +wake_m1.84_neg1.1,wake,primary,1.84,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,39.0213,5.38894,81.1893,44.1312,6.109,61.7794,37.0466,1.3565,28.0111,2.46921,,,,,,,,,2.1,2.1,2.1,0.368666,0.245915,2.1,2.1,1.099;1.120;1.157,1.1574 +wake_m1.84_neg1.2,wake,primary,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,39.1552,8.37672,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,34.1276,1.3632,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,0.3,2.25,2.35,2.30002,0.381694,2.35,2.35,1.083,1.0829 +wake_m1.84_neg1.3,wake,primary,1.84,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,44.7781,4.40543,81.1893,47.0551,5.9,61.7794,32.5513,1.28597,23.1657,2.62387,,,,,,,,,2.35,2.35,2.35,0.79893,0.241826,2.35,2.35,1.046;1.067,1.067 +wake_m1.84_neg1.4,wake,primary,1.84,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,49.7178,4.63371,81.1893,49.457,6.944,61.7794,30.6402,1.2615,22.1966,2.4706,,,,,,,,,2.45,2.45,2.45,0.239212,0.237978,2.45,2.45,1.099;1.115;1.136,1.1361 +none_m1.12_pos0.2,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,16.6043,3.23758e-06,15.0821,15.2686,,13.3836,51.8709,2.58369,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.3,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,18.3818,3.17243e-06,15.0821,17.6249,1.414,13.3836,50.6819,1.21829,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.4,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,20.6968,2.86669e-06,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,51.5577,0.656047,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.5,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,23.469,2.72735e-06,15.0821,25.8718,3.534,13.3836,50.2748,0.447596,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.6,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,26.6401,2.51769e-06,15.0821,31.5269,4.477,13.3836,48.9658,0.331948,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.7,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,30.1751,2.20194e-06,15.0821,36.9463,6.126,13.3836,47.6875,0.260204,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.8,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,34.0521,2.77975e-06,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,46.4745,0.211992,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos0.9,none,primary,1.12,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,38.2471,2.29357e-06,15.0821,53.2045,10.132,13.3836,45.3418,0.177628,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos1,none,primary,1.12,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,42.6878,2.03627e-06,15.0821,60.7446,12.017,13.3836,41.2962,0.178663,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos1.1,none,primary,1.12,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,47.5589,1.85755e-06,15.0821,69.2271,14.373,13.3836,40.3255,0.155827,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos1.2,none,primary,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,52.8881,7.71361e-07,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,39.4965,0.137199,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos1.3,none,primary,1.12,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,58.6774,7.68674e-07,15.0821,90.9048,18.615,13.3836,38.7926,0.121696,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_pos1.4,none,primary,1.12,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,64.9281,1.52201e-06,15.0821,101.979,21.678,13.3836,38.1962,0.108611,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.2,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,13.4376,7.40944e-07,15.0821,7.7903,0.992,11.4975,54.2478,2.29705,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.3,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,11.1065,4.48659e-06,15.0821,6.3283,0.783,11.4975,56.1727,0.928331,44.7277,1.65088,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.4,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,6.81533,0.00863582,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,61.5378,0.399159,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.5,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,6.23557,0.573704,15.0821,7.216,0.835,11.4975,61.1706,0.260294,25.3461,2.04307,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.6,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,7.28736,1.79831,15.0821,8.3124,0.783,11.4975,21.7193,1.9517,19.5316,2.42581,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.7,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,11.4101,8.93115e-05,15.0821,13.2728,1.253,11.4975,17.1159,2.33225,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.8,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,13.6453,4.28707e-05,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,6.55053,12.3538,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg0.9,none,primary,1.12,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,16.4367,1.2183e-05,15.0821,22.9845,4.073,11.4975,13.9295,2.1416,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg1,none,primary,1.12,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,19.8921,1.57349e-06,15.0821,28.0493,4.229,11.4975,20.3341,0.80427,12.0212,2.33529,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg1.1,none,primary,1.12,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,23.9958,7.10543e-15,15.0821,34.4716,5.326,11.4975,23.2415,0.505089,12.2635,1.85391,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg1.2,none,primary,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,28.6936,0,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,28.5876,0.275833,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg1.3,none,primary,1.12,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,33.9438,0,15.0821,49.8747,8.72,11.4975,30.177,0.20967,11.5367,1.50123,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.12_neg1.4,none,primary,1.12,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,39.7142,7.10543e-15,15.0821,58.2811,,11.4975,31.401,0.166147,11.5367,1.29443,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.2,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,82.7919,4.68702e-06,81.1893,67.1065,,59.0952,53.0657,17.5503,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.3,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,84.7097,4.61432e-06,81.1893,68.2846,1.178,59.0952,52.83,7.89158,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.4,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,87.3875,4.32533e-06,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.5027,4.51154,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.5,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,90.7894,4.47444e-06,81.1893,,,59.0952,52.0927,2.94665,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.6,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,94.7686,4.32785e-06,81.1893,82.6579,5.655,59.0952,51.6158,2.09531,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.7,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,99.4023,4.4944e-06,81.1893,89.0198,6.833,59.0952,51.08,1.58098,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.8,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,104.564,4.99424e-06,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.5018,1.24585,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos0.9,none,primary,1.84,pos,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,110.246,4.97856e-06,81.1893,104.807,11.781,59.0952,49.8938,1.01478,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos1,none,primary,1.84,pos,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,116.446,4.62493e-06,81.1893,111.876,13.195,59.0952,49.2686,0.848194,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos1.1,none,primary,1.84,pos,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,123.102,4.82939e-06,81.1893,123.893,16.258,59.0952,48.6363,0.723703,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos1.2,none,primary,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,130.17,4.93996e-06,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,50.3481,0.557981,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos1.3,none,primary,1.84,pos,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,137.673,4.58367e-06,81.1893,144.039,19.675,59.0952,49.7942,0.48881,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_pos1.4,none,primary,1.84,pos,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,145.589,4.9991e-06,81.1893,154.877,23.68,59.0952,49.2458,0.433248,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.2,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,79.5571,4.94942e-06,81.1893,58.8555,1.827,61.7794,53.4565,17.2144,66.2898,8.95099,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.3,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,77.5119,4.69369e-06,81.1893,55.6182,2.036,61.7794,53.7009,7.55902,64.8362,4.30484,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.4,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,74.6379,4.15719e-06,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.0336,4.18265,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.5,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.5,54,0.0025,1,0.5,70.6578,4.34354e-06,81.1893,47.8383,,61.7794,54.4668,2.62024,59.0217,2.09067,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.6,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.6,54,0.0025,1,0.5,65.6525,4.30444e-06,81.1893,41.6771,4.177,61.7794,54.9187,1.77947,54.1763,1.8459,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.7,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.7,54,0.0025,1,0.5,59.2085,4.2832e-06,81.1893,40.685,3.812,61.7794,54.9252,1.30695,46.4236,2.00074,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.8,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0.5,50.6914,4.0385e-06,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,55.0849,0.992776,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg0.9,none,primary,1.84,neg,0.9,54,0.0025,1,0.5,38.7879,0.000180165,81.1893,42.6692,6.422,61.7794,51.9741,0.914828,35.2792,2.25518,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg1,none,primary,1.84,neg,1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,24.3491,0.0250707,81.1893,42.1992,6.161,61.7794,26.3547,3.39395,30.4338,2.50826,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg1.1,none,primary,1.84,neg,1.1,54,0.0025,1,0.5,29.1183,6.4681,81.1893,44.1312,6.109,61.7794,39.3439,1.18697,28.0111,2.46921,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg1.2,none,primary,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0.5,28.2123,5.17866,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,34.8255,1.30473,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg1.3,none,primary,1.84,neg,1.3,54,0.0025,1,0.5,29.2292,5.51833,81.1893,47.0551,5.9,61.7794,32.0851,1.32629,23.1657,2.62387,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +none_m1.84_neg1.4,none,primary,1.84,neg,1.4,54,0.0025,1,0.5,41.8815,3.14293e-05,81.1893,49.457,6.944,61.7794,30.1839,1.30228,22.1966,2.4706,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_dt,uls19,half the time step,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.00125,1,0.5,108.364,12.49,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.9582,1.2802,,,1.65,1.675,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6384,1.65,4.85,0.822;1.612,1.6116,1.65,1.65,1.65,0.29644,0.291208,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_n108,uls19,twice the elements,1.84,pos,0.8,108,0.0025,1,0.5,108.237,12.439,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.9688,1.21717,,,1.65,1.65,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6384,1.65,1.65,0.822;1.612,1.6116,1.65,1.65,1.65,0.304494,0.302059,,,, +uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_dt,uls19,half the time step,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.00125,1,0.5,35.7748,8.03099,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.9474,0.217974,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,2.65,0.413355,0.407282,2.65,2.65,1.599,1.5986 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_n108,uls19,twice the elements,1.12,neg,1.2,108,0.0025,1,0.5,34.5143,6.895,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.6511,0.222353,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,2.65,0.367172,0.363668,2.65,2.65,1.599,1.5986 +b1_m1.84_pos0.8_dt,b1,half the time step,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.00125,1,0.5,117.209,5.58544,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.7453,1.29394,,,2.15,2.15,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.15,2.15,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.15,2.15,2.15,0.201511,0.200155,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.8_n108,b1,twice the elements,1.84,pos,0.8,108,0.0025,1,0.5,117.213,5.46316,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.8827,1.2224,,,2.15,2.15,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.15,2.15,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.15,2.15,2.15,0.200439,0.199432,,,, +b1_m1.12_neg1.2_dt,b1,half the time step,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.00125,1,0.5,52.2549,8.25416,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.6051,0.223043,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,2.8,2.8,0.304001,0.301326,2.8,2.8,1.599,1.5986 +b1_m1.12_neg1.2_n108,b1,twice the elements,1.12,neg,1.2,108,0.0025,1,0.5,50.1123,8.11487,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.5557,0.223789,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,1.05,3.15,3.15,0.286081,0.283416,3.15,3.15,1.599,1.5986 +wake_m1.84_pos0.8_dt,wake,half the time step,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.00125,1,0.5,105.59,4.93216,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.4404,1.24968,,,2.25,2.25,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.25,2.25,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.25,2.25,2.25,0.116859,0.11685,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.8_n108,wake,twice the elements,1.84,pos,0.8,108,0.0025,1,0.5,105.61,4.94639,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,51.4551,1.18806,,,2.25,2.25,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.25,2.25,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.25,2.25,2.25,0.118043,0.118035,,,, +wake_m1.12_neg1.2_dt,wake,half the time step,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.00125,1,0.5,29.9379,2.69443,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,29.4387,0.2593,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,0.95,0.95,0.272119,0.271972,0.95,3.8,1.599,1.5986 +wake_m1.12_neg1.2_n108,wake,twice the elements,1.12,neg,1.2,108,0.0025,1,0.5,29.9925,2.88835,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,29.3614,0.260743,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,0.95,0.95,0.271317,0.27114,0.95,3.8,1.599,1.5986 +uls19_m1.12_pos0.4_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,21.3928,1.88607,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,48.8433,0.751513,,,0.9,0.9,0.806,0.8064,0.9,2.45,,,0.9,0.9,0.9,0.247629,0.240026,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.4_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,21.8555,3.45141,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,48.5353,0.763303,,,0.9,0.9,0.806,0.8064,0.9,2.6,,,0.9,0.9,0.9,0.313907,0.311185,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.8_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,37.3481,10.3058,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,43.0174,0.254224,,,1.75,1.75,,,1.75,1.75,1.277,1.2766,1.75,1.75,1.75,0.322832,0.311009,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos0.8_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,36.4663,6.64358,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,43.55,0.247081,,,1.75,3.45,,,1.75,1.75,1.277,1.2766,1.75,1.75,1.75,0.319515,0.316068,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1.2_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,61.0498,18.9067,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,39.1846,0.139654,,,2.6,2.6,2.118;2.350,2.3503,2.6,2.6,1.739,1.7392,2.6,2.6,2.6,0.331161,0.324869,,,, +uls19_m1.12_pos1.2_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,60.5594,10.8583,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,38.8029,0.14274,,,2.6,2.6,2.118;2.350,2.3503,2.6,2.6,1.739,1.7392,0.55,2.6,2.6,0.341742,0.33617,,,, +uls19_m1.12_neg0.4_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,8.8567,1.656,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,46.3584,0.853058,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.6,0.75,0.75,4.64363,0.503556,0.6,2.15,0.344,0.344 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.4_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,9.26392,1.459,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,44.8655,0.921923,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.6,0.6,0.6,6.60654,0.467369,0.6,0.6,0.344,0.344 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.8_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,16.7678,6.73279,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,14.9658,2.34433,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,0.75,1.275,1.8,0.402196,0.338631,1.8,1.8,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +uls19_m1.12_neg0.8_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,15.8226,4.00728,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,11.4976,3.99136,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,1.8,0.362042,0.324763,0.75,1.8,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,37.9354,22.0635,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,32.2106,0.214185,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.85,2.75,0.327546,0.317727,2.7,2.75,1.599,1.5986 +uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,35.6849,8.18804,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.8084,0.220013,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,2.7,0.392115,0.385611,2.7,2.7,1.599,1.5986 +uls19_m1.84_pos0.4_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,88.3884,2.78453,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.3557,4.54451,,,0.8,0.8,0.950;1.006,0.9504,0.8,2.5,0.822,0.8219,0.8,0.8,0.8,0.3143,0.312724,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.4_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,88.3486,3.35209,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.2918,4.55893,,,0.95,2.75,0.950;1.006,0.9504,0.95,0.95,0.822,0.8219,0.8,0.95,0.95,0.269728,0.267262,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,108.521,15.074,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.065,1.27337,,,1.65,1.65,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6384,1.65,4.85,0.822;1.612,1.6116,1.65,1.65,1.65,0.307563,0.303991,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,110.13,18.1144,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.9047,1.28363,,,1.7,1.7,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,1.7,1.7,0.822;1.612,1.6116,1.7,1.7,1.7,0.35277,0.351192,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1.2_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,140.248,28.3793,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,47.2078,0.65393,,,2.5,2.5,2.278,2.2783,2.35,2.5,2.050,2.0503,2.35,2.5,2.5,0.312138,0.308185,,,, +uls19_m1.84_pos1.2_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,138.66,21.53,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,47.5795,0.641633,,,2.4,2.4,2.278,2.2783,2.4,2.4,2.050,2.0503,2.4,2.4,2.4,0.390628,0.388757,,,, +uls19_m1.84_neg0.4_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,73.5966,2.86567,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.1093,4.16705,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.420917,0.41867,0.75,0.75,0.860,0.8596 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.4_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,73.6683,5.37917,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.1395,4.16084,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,0.8,0.8,0.8,0.424085,0.423612,0.8,2.45,0.860,0.8596 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.8_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,46.0778,14.5493,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,54.8792,1.00291,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.35,1.35,1.35,0.529936,0.522378,1.35,1.35,0.870,0.8703 +uls19_m1.84_neg0.8_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,48.6101,13.6689,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,53.0172,1.09952,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.4,1.4,1.45,0.634717,0.633678,1.4,4.25,0.870,0.8703 +uls19_m1.84_neg1.2_undamped,uls19,no structural damping,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,44.1958,11.9873,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,34.0096,1.37345,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,1.35,1.6,1.7,4.6224,0.603239,1.55,1.7,1.083,1.0829 +uls19_m1.84_neg1.2_frictionless,uls19,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,46.4164,11.9361,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,34.3262,1.34621,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,1.45,1.5,1.5,5.51625,1.01513,1.5,1.5,1.083,1.0829 +b1_m1.12_pos0.4_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,23.9067,1.21375,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,50.6311,0.687031,,,1,1,0.806,0.8064,1,1,,,1,1,1,0.217719,0.214648,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.4_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,25.0863,3.2076,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,50.1993,0.702017,,,1,1,0.806,0.8064,1,1,,,1,1,1,0.330186,0.327051,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.8_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,48.4038,7.64849,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,40.4445,0.292659,,,2.05,2.05,,,2.05,2.05,1.277,1.2766,2.05,2.05,2.05,0.312905,0.311972,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos0.8_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,47.5073,6.78456,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,40.383,0.293666,,,2.05,2.05,,,2.05,2.05,1.277,1.2766,2.05,2.05,2.05,0.29501,0.292828,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1.2_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,81.9444,11.0669,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,36.6912,0.161548,,,3.05,3.05,2.118;2.350,2.3503,3.05,3.05,1.739,1.7392,3.05,3.05,3.05,0.268219,0.264878,,,, +b1_m1.12_pos1.2_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,80.3038,8.90782,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,36.5813,0.162615,,,3.05,3.05,2.118;2.350,2.3503,3.05,3.05,1.739,1.7392,3.05,3.05,3.05,0.25997,0.2572,,,, +b1_m1.12_neg0.4_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,8.84126,1.15085,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,29.0706,2.39648,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.3,0.55,0.65,6.88438,0.348482,0.5,0.55,0.344,0.344 +b1_m1.12_neg0.4_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,8.94046,1.40754,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,25.9909,3.02979,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.3,0.3,0.6,8.18006,0.515789,0.6,0.65,0.344,0.344 +b1_m1.12_neg0.8_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,22.1587,5.44904,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,21.9267,1.0766,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,0.8,1.425,2.05,0.323273,0.313989,0.8,2.05,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +b1_m1.12_neg0.8_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,20.7895,3.57533,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,20.3292,1.2573,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,0.8,2,2,0.293837,0.284045,2,2,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +b1_m1.12_neg1.2_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,52.5927,14.3716,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,32.2527,0.213587,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,1.05,3.2,3.2,0.314244,0.310337,3.2,3.2,1.599,1.5986 +b1_m1.12_neg1.2_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,49.7568,8.06323,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,31.6245,0.222752,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,3.15,3.15,0.284886,0.279459,3.15,3.15,1.599,1.5986 +b1_m1.84_pos0.4_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,92.5261,1.81579,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,51.789,4.67407,,,0.85,0.85,0.950;1.006,0.9504,0.85,2.6,0.822,0.8219,0.85,0.85,0.85,0.338679,0.33842,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.4_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,92.1989,4.21346,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,51.9429,4.63848,,,1.05,1.05,0.950;1.006,1.0064,1.05,1.05,0.822,0.8219,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.294694,0.294391,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.8_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,117.263,7.23403,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.7841,1.29142,,,2.15,2.15,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.15,2.15,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.15,2.15,2.15,0.20473,0.202495,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos0.8_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,120.568,16.5165,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,49.1584,1.33268,,,2.25,2.25,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.25,2.25,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.25,2.25,2.25,0.264153,0.263435,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1.2_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,161.575,19.2895,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,49.295,0.588242,,,2.9,2.9,2.278,2.2783,2.9,2.9,2.050,2.0503,2.9,2.9,2.9,0.236138,0.233984,,,, +b1_m1.84_pos1.2_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,163.109,21.6435,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,48.8547,0.601439,,,2.85,3.55,2.278,2.2783,2.85,2.85,2.050,2.0503,2.8,2.85,3.55,0.247303,0.245265,,,, +b1_m1.84_neg0.4_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,65.9575,1.87311,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,55.2026,3.94809,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,0.75,0.75,0.75,0.538117,0.537645,0.75,0.75,0.860,0.8596 +b1_m1.84_neg0.4_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,70.2627,5.46864,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.2595,4.13625,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.314109,0.313703,1.05,1.05,0.860,0.8596 +b1_m1.84_neg0.8_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,41.9767,7.40718,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,37.762,2.45865,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.5,1.5,1.5,0.500742,0.401845,1.5,1.5,0.870,0.8703 +b1_m1.84_neg0.8_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,46.5736,6.10507,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,39.6981,2.19949,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.55,1.55,1.55,0.40078,0.397824,1.55,1.55,0.870,0.8703 +b1_m1.84_neg1.2_undamped,b1,no structural damping,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,53.789,12.298,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,25.9709,2.43005,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,1.95,1.95,1.95,0.454551,0.434966,1.95,1.95,1.083,1.0829 +b1_m1.84_neg1.2_frictionless,b1,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,54.0654,7.73406,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,25.4029,2.54441,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,1.65,1.65,1.65,0.476203,0.468212,1.65,1.7,1.083,1.0829 +wake_m1.12_pos0.4_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,20.8637,0.462776,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,51.5039,0.657804,,,1.05,1.05,0.806,0.8064,1.05,1.05,,,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.107187,0.10718,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.4_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,21.0146,2.00897,15.0821,21.3949,2.356,13.3836,49.1265,0.740858,,,1.2,1.2,0.806,0.8064,1.2,1.2,,,1.2,1.2,1.2,0.143736,0.143724,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.8_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,34.5019,2.98042,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,46.3506,0.21335,,,2.7,2.7,,,2.7,2.7,1.277,1.2766,2.7,2.7,2.7,0.0820627,0.0820357,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos0.8_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,34.7256,3.83871,15.0821,45.311,7.893,13.3836,46.3244,0.213638,,,2.3,2.35,,,2.3,2.35,1.277,1.2766,2.3,2.3,2.3,0.109985,0.109959,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1.2_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,54.8616,7.51264,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,39.3467,0.138371,,,3.6,3.6,2.118;2.350,2.3503,3.6,3.6,1.739,1.7392,3.6,3.6,3.6,0.122887,0.122884,,,, +wake_m1.12_pos1.2_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.12,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,54.1415,4.4719,15.0821,80.1838,16.612,13.3836,39.3645,0.138231,,,3.7,3.7,2.118;2.350,2.3503,3.7,3.7,1.739,1.7392,1.3,3.7,3.7,0.0953627,0.0953615,,,, +wake_m1.12_neg0.4_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,6.81629,0.792442,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,60.3128,0.424791,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,1,1.05,1.05,2.76999,0.343145,1.05,1.05,0.344,0.344 +wake_m1.12_neg0.4_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,9.24269,1.14357,15.0821,6.6938,,11.4975,49.1094,0.741494,33.0988,1.81846,,,,,,,,,0.95,0.95,0.95,5.96691,0.208535,0.95,0.95,0.344,0.344 +wake_m1.12_neg0.8_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,14.1123,2.20211,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,6.79152,11.4907,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,2.35,0.141191,0.140656,1.05,2.35,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +wake_m1.12_neg0.8_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,13.96,1.06779,15.0821,16.249,2.036,11.4975,6.55685,12.33,13.4749,2.89837,,,,,,,,,1.05,1.05,2.35,0.130275,0.130031,1.05,2.35,0.392;0.907,0.9075 +wake_m1.12_neg1.2_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,30.6227,8.07547,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,29.7946,0.252801,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,1,1,3.8,0.257774,0.257767,1,3.8,1.599,1.5986 +wake_m1.12_neg1.2_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.12,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,29.9349,2.70363,15.0821,41.5205,6.736,11.4975,29.4392,0.259291,12.2635,1.5578,,,,,,,,,0.95,0.95,0.95,0.272183,0.272003,0.95,3.8,1.599,1.5986 +wake_m1.84_pos0.4_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,87.8978,1.62124,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.4475,4.52388,,,1.2,1.2,0.950;1.006,1.0064,1.2,1.2,0.822,0.8219,1.2,1.2,1.2,0.168256,0.168239,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.4_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,87.9091,1.86603,81.1893,71.1122,1.885,59.0952,52.4265,4.52859,,,1.05,1.05,0.950;1.006,1.0064,1.05,1.05,0.822,0.8219,1.05,1.05,1.05,0.18901,0.188996,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.8_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,105.654,5.16498,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.4433,1.2495,,,2.25,2.25,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.25,2.25,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.25,2.25,2.25,0.120572,0.120567,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos0.8_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,106.025,10.8638,81.1893,95.7352,9.072,59.0952,50.4143,1.25132,,,2.2,2.2,1.582;1.638;1.694,1.6944,2.2,2.2,0.822;1.612,1.6116,2.2,2.2,2.2,0.145151,0.145134,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1.2_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,130.912,1.7041,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,50.272,0.56011,,,3.85,3.85,2.278,2.2783,3.85,3.85,2.050,2.0503,3.85,3.85,3.85,0.0574786,0.0574738,,,, +wake_m1.84_pos1.2_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.84,pos,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,132.078,13.6087,81.1893,133.082,18.379,59.0952,50.2041,0.562014,,,3.8,3.8,2.278,2.2783,3.8,3.8,2.050,2.0503,3.8,3.8,3.8,0.102251,0.102249,,,, +wake_m1.84_neg0.4_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,0,0.5,74.2177,1.60284,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.0396,4.1814,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,1.15,1.15,1.15,0.219606,0.219573,1.15,3.4,0.860,0.8596 +wake_m1.84_neg0.4_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,0.4,54,0.0025,1,0,74.3323,2.27551,81.1893,51.2322,3.185,61.7794,54.0191,4.18563,58.2949,3.38736,,,,,,,,,1.15,1.15,1.15,0.189865,0.189849,1.15,1.15,0.860,0.8596 +wake_m1.84_neg0.8_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,0,0.5,49.2291,4.34995,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,54.6958,1.01203,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,2.05,2.05,2.05,0.212875,0.212869,2.05,2.05,0.870,0.8703 +wake_m1.84_neg0.8_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,0.8,54,0.0025,1,0,48.9572,8.74131,81.1893,40.9461,4.908,61.7794,54.5013,1.02179,38.671,2.33222,,,,,,,,,1.95,1.95,1.95,0.211699,0.211698,1.95,1.95,0.870,0.8703 +wake_m1.84_neg1.2_undamped,wake,no structural damping,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,0,0.5,44.6578,7.46844,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,34.9048,1.29831,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,2.35,2.35,2.4,4.40156,0.335287,2.35,2.35,1.083,1.0829 +wake_m1.84_neg1.2_frictionless,wake,frictionless floor,1.84,neg,1.2,54,0.0025,1,0,46.064,7.63729,81.1893,46.1153,6.109,61.7794,35.0392,1.28752,25.1038,2.60778,,,,,,,,,0.4,2.35,2.35,5.62834,0.953313,2.35,2.35,1.083,1.0829 diff --git a/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/summary.json b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1e01644 --- /dev/null +++ b/validation/experiments/chaplin_catenary/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,1013 @@ +{ + "sets": { + "uls19": "Ulveseter et al. (2019), Table 1, Chh 1.5", + "b1": "generic set (Delta Flume case)", + "wake": "Facchinetti et al. (2004) wake oscillator", + "none": "no VIV, C_d 1.2" + }, + "model": { + "length_m": 5.36, + "diameter_m": 0.056, + "EI_Nm2": 1.3, + "EA_N": 790000.0, + "mass_kg_per_m": { + "1.12": 2.75873, + "1.84": 4.59422 + }, + "submerged_weight_N_per_m": { + "1.12": 2.9, + "1.84": 20.9 + }, + "rayleigh_damping": { + "zeta": 0.03, + "f1_hz": 0.3, + "f2_hz": 3.0 + }, + "floor_friction": 0.5, + "segments": 54, + "dt_s": 0.0025, + "tmax_s": 110.0, + "statistics_from_s": 30.0, + "current_ramp_s": 10.0, + "welch_segment_s": 20.0, + "probe_elevations_m": { + "upper_a": -0.57, + "upper_b": -1.186, + "lower": -1.582, + "mid_depth": -1.0 + } + }, + "still_water_top_tension_N": { + "1.12": { + "model": 15.0821, + "measured_fig10": 13.3836, + "measured_fig13": 11.4975 + }, + "1.84": { + "model": 81.1893, + "measured_fig10": 59.0952, + "measured_fig13": 61.7794 + } + }, + "scores": { + "uls19_m1.12_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.178227, + "T_mean_rel_error": -0.129766, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 14.5405, + "dT_mean_error_N": -11.2207, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.80798, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "f_upper_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 5, + "f_upper_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.121333, + "f_upper_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.111253, + "f_upper_measured_points": 6, + "f_upper_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.10624, + "f_upper_within_10pct": 1, + "f_upper_points": 5, + "f_lower_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 1, + "f_lower_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.121333, + "f_lower_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.09, + "f_lower_measured_points": 11, + "f_lower_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.37083, + "f_lower_within_10pct": 0, + "f_lower_points": 11, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.322249, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.105473, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 6.87095, + "dT_mean_error_N": -5.07762, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 1.42526, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 14.9851, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 13.0682, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 0.901194, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 1.83619, + "f_mid_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 5, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.0896, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.06349, + "f_mid_measured_points": 13, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median": 0.183805, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median": 0.210911, + "f_mid_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.4667, + "f_mid_within_10pct": 0, + "f_mid_points": 10, + "f_span_spread_median": 1.72414 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.150491, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.126341, + "T_points": 12, + "dT_rms_error_N": 12.2279, + "dT_mean_error_N": -11.2468, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 1.14421, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "f_upper_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 3, + "f_upper_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.121333, + "f_upper_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.1112, + "f_upper_measured_points": 23, + "f_upper_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.06873, + "f_upper_within_10pct": 7, + "f_upper_points": 12, + "f_lower_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 3, + "f_lower_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.121333, + "f_lower_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.105272, + "f_lower_measured_points": 18, + "f_lower_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.07817, + "f_lower_within_10pct": 6, + "f_lower_points": 12, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.296105, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.199745, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 14.3201, + "dT_mean_error_N": -9.74128, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 1.61341, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 10.1491, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 4.20246, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 1.35935, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 2.4706, + "f_mid_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 2, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.102667, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.0589018, + "f_mid_measured_points": 25, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median": 0.129569, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median": 0.119125, + "f_mid_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.32031, + "f_mid_within_10pct": 4, + "f_mid_points": 13, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.0982925, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.0759066, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 1.75874, + "dT_mean_error_N": 0.602227, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.589627, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "f_upper_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_upper_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.137846, + "f_upper_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.111253, + "f_upper_measured_points": 6, + "f_upper_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.24008, + "f_upper_within_10pct": 0, + "f_upper_points": 5, + "f_lower_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_lower_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.137846, + "f_lower_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.09, + "f_lower_measured_points": 11, + "f_lower_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.51607, + "f_lower_within_10pct": 0, + "f_lower_points": 11, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.301008, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.277109, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 3.88365, + "dT_mean_error_N": 1.95593, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 1.22063, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 14.7002, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 10.6771, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 0.937718, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 1.83619, + "f_mid_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 2, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.128, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.06349, + "f_mid_measured_points": 13, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median": 0.261949, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median": 0.210911, + "f_mid_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.83987, + "f_mid_within_10pct": 0, + "f_mid_points": 10, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.590909 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.23847, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.236845, + "T_points": 12, + "dT_rms_error_N": 4.92599, + "dT_mean_error_N": 1.829, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.686568, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "f_upper_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_upper_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.137455, + "f_upper_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.1112, + "f_upper_measured_points": 23, + "f_upper_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.2527, + "f_upper_within_10pct": 0, + "f_upper_points": 12, + "f_lower_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 1, + "f_lower_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.137455, + "f_lower_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.105272, + "f_lower_measured_points": 18, + "f_lower_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.279, + "f_lower_within_10pct": 1, + "f_lower_points": 12, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.24774, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.17449, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 13.745, + "dT_mean_error_N": -10.5128, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 1.20507, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 4.97044, + "psi_mean_error_deg": -2.68136, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 2.55351, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 2.4706, + "f_mid_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.098, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.0589018, + "f_mid_measured_points": 25, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median": 0.165005, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median": 0.119125, + "f_mid_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.45267, + "f_mid_within_10pct": 3, + "f_mid_points": 13, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.23445, + "T_mean_rel_error": -0.184807, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 18.8472, + "dT_mean_error_N": -14.5683, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.188049, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "f_upper_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_upper_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.172667, + "f_upper_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.111253, + "f_upper_measured_points": 6, + "f_upper_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.30584, + "f_upper_within_10pct": 1, + "f_upper_points": 5, + "f_lower_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 1, + "f_lower_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.168, + "f_lower_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.09, + "f_lower_measured_points": 11, + "f_lower_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.82537, + "f_lower_within_10pct": 0, + "f_lower_points": 11, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.351188, + "T_mean_rel_error": -0.00712777, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 10.4983, + "dT_mean_error_N": -7.90692, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.421873, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 15.6904, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 13.0248, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 0.922007, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 1.83619, + "f_mid_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 8, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.0735, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.06349, + "f_mid_measured_points": 13, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median": 0.169652, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median": 0.210911, + "f_mid_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 0.976461, + "f_mid_within_10pct": 0, + "f_mid_points": 10, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.13919, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.0915524, + "T_points": 12, + "dT_rms_error_N": 17.7077, + "dT_mean_error_N": -15.5452, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.424804, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "f_upper_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_upper_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.168, + "f_upper_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.1112, + "f_upper_measured_points": 23, + "f_upper_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.40477, + "f_upper_within_10pct": 0, + "f_upper_points": 12, + "f_lower_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_lower_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.168, + "f_lower_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.105272, + "f_lower_measured_points": 18, + "f_lower_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 1.46893, + "f_lower_within_10pct": 0, + "f_lower_points": 12, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.316394, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.177252, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 16.4008, + "dT_mean_error_N": -10.7383, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 0.760237, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 10.3235, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 4.31082, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 1.3565, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 2.4706, + "f_mid_acc_peak_at_harmonic": 0, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_U_median": 0.127556, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_U_median": 0.0589018, + "f_mid_measured_points": 25, + "f_mid_model_fd_over_Un_median": 0.182582, + "f_mid_measured_fd_over_Un_median": 0.119125, + "f_mid_ratio_to_nearest_measured_median": 2.02593, + "f_mid_within_10pct": 1, + "f_mid_points": 13, + "f_span_spread_median": 0.0 + }, + "none_m1.12_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.244553, + "T_mean_rel_error": -0.194729, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 19.638, + "dT_mean_error_N": -15.1741, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 2.89274e-07, + "sd_T_points": 12 + }, + "none_m1.12_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.365008, + "T_mean_rel_error": -0.0683198, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 11.4584, + "dT_mean_error_N": -8.8485, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 2.99115e-06, + "sd_T_points": 11, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 18.6388, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 14.5091, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 0.80427, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 1.83619 + }, + "none_m1.84_pos": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.135055, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.0849025, + "T_points": 12, + "dT_rms_error_N": 18.367, + "dT_mean_error_N": -16.2307, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 4.22593e-07, + "sd_T_points": 11 + }, + "none_m1.84_neg": { + "T_rms_rel_error": 0.385349, + "T_mean_rel_error": 0.0902642, + "T_points": 13, + "dT_rms_error_N": 22.8256, + "dT_mean_error_N": -14.7163, + "sd_T_ratio_median": 3.61758e-06, + "sd_T_points": 12, + "psi_rms_error_deg": 10.1204, + "psi_mean_error_deg": 3.34231, + "cd_eq9_model_median": 1.32629, + "cd_eq9_measured_median": 2.4706 + } + }, + "sensitivity_and_convergence": { + "uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_dt": { + "role": "half the time step", + "mean_T": -0.000213727, + "sd_T": 0.0547442, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0785622, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_n108": { + "role": "twice the elements", + "mean_T": -0.00138539, + "sd_T": 0.0504323, + "AD_rms_max": 0.107866, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_dt": { + "role": "half the time step", + "mean_T": 0.00615787, + "sd_T": -0.0375066, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0259441, + "f_mid": -0.0185185 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_n108": { + "role": "twice the elements", + "mean_T": -0.0292937, + "sd_T": -0.173652, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0886828, + "f_mid": -0.0185185 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos0.8_dt": { + "role": "half the time step", + "mean_T": -0.000333733, + "sd_T": 0.0248872, + "AD_rms_max": -0.00513647, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos0.8_n108": { + "role": "twice the elements", + "mean_T": -0.000293523, + "sd_T": 0.00244924, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0104285, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg1.2_dt": { + "role": "half the time step", + "mean_T": 0.0528912, + "sd_T": 0.0230265, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0543951, + "f_mid": -0.111111 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg1.2_n108": { + "role": "twice the elements", + "mean_T": 0.00971889, + "sd_T": 0.00576302, + "AD_rms_max": -0.00775592, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos0.8_dt": { + "role": "half the time step", + "mean_T": -1.14851e-05, + "sd_T": -0.00183678, + "AD_rms_max": -7.15033e-05, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos0.8_n108": { + "role": "twice the elements", + "mean_T": 0.000176472, + "sd_T": 0.00104338, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0100616, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg1.2_dt": { + "role": "half the time step", + "mean_T": 9.78408e-05, + "sd_T": -0.00338539, + "AD_rms_max": -5.35361e-05, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg1.2_n108": { + "role": "twice the elements", + "mean_T": 0.00192069, + "sd_T": 0.0683398, + "AD_rms_max": -0.00300082, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_pos0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00478151, + "sd_T": 0.0946651, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0108269, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_pos0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0265117, + "sd_T": 1.00318, + "AD_rms_max": 0.281374, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_pos0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0273574, + "sd_T": 0.541039, + "AD_rms_max": 0.100682, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_pos0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00310262, + "sd_T": -0.0065773, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0893733, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_pos1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.011719, + "sd_T": 0.685669, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0146251, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_pos1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00359373, + "sd_T": -0.0319049, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0168571, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.00695026, + "sd_T": 0.115984, + "AD_rms_max": -0.040814, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0387092, + "sd_T": -0.0167714, + "AD_rms_max": 0.364643, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0499191, + "sd_T": 0.723415, + "AD_rms_max": 0.141373, + "f_mid": 1.76923 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -0.00926855, + "sd_T": 0.0257577, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0274219, + "f_mid": 0.153846 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0669251, + "sd_T": 1.64425, + "AD_rms_max": -0.187033, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.12_neg1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00363012, + "sd_T": -0.0186852, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0267742, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00331159, + "sd_T": 0.337498, + "AD_rms_max": 0.209312, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00286032, + "sd_T": 0.610118, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0378133, + "f_upper": 0.1875, + "f_lower": 0.1875 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00124073, + "sd_T": 0.272957, + "AD_rms_max": 0.119029, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0160846, + "sd_T": 0.529706, + "AD_rms_max": 0.283511, + "f_upper": 0.030303, + "f_lower": 0.030303 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00905076, + "sd_T": 0.380209, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0491352, + "f_upper": -0.0384615, + "f_lower": -0.0961538 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_pos1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -0.00237351, + "sd_T": 0.0470997, + "AD_rms_max": 0.312951, + "f_upper": -0.0769231, + "f_lower": -0.0769231 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.000291763, + "sd_T": 0.0591125, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0200486, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.000682553, + "sd_T": 0.988066, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0126726, + "f_mid": 0.0666667 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.0129811, + "sd_T": 0.24324, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0250626, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0412617, + "sd_T": 0.168008, + "AD_rms_max": 0.22774, + "f_mid": 0.037037 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.00641234, + "sd_T": 0.190758, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0611028, + "f_mid": 0.0333333 + }, + "uls19_m1.84_neg1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0435104, + "sd_T": 0.18567, + "AD_rms_max": 0.120453, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00337188, + "sd_T": 0.11451, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0598356, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0528784, + "sd_T": 1.94534, + "AD_rms_max": 0.607314, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.0125056, + "sd_T": 0.0903299, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0847705, + "f_upper": 0.171429, + "f_lower": 0.171429 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -0.0307946, + "sd_T": -0.0328283, + "AD_rms_max": -0.137113, + "f_upper": 0.171429, + "f_lower": 0.171429 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0220779, + "sd_T": 0.259716, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0402986, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_pos1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00161545, + "sd_T": 0.0139552, + "AD_rms_max": 0.00830583, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0227695, + "sd_T": -0.0195736, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0863363, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0342446, + "sd_T": 0.19911, + "AD_rms_max": 0.29079, + "f_mid": 0.2 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0554924, + "sd_T": 0.463296, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0195141, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -0.00972576, + "sd_T": -0.0398738, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0733204, + "f_mid": 1.5 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0596978, + "sd_T": 0.781224, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0899233, + "f_mid": 0.015873 + }, + "b1_m1.12_neg1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00255669, + "sd_T": -0.000636848, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0119029, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00782454, + "sd_T": 0.0983797, + "AD_rms_max": 0.151877, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0042603, + "sd_T": 1.54874, + "AD_rms_max": 0.00227848, + "f_upper": 0.235294, + "f_lower": 0.235294 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.000127782, + "sd_T": 0.32739, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0107553, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0283157, + "sd_T": 2.03065, + "AD_rms_max": 0.304132, + "f_upper": 0.0465116, + "f_lower": 0.0465116 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.000824041, + "sd_T": 0.569817, + "AD_rms_max": -0.00031999, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_pos1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0103245, + "sd_T": 0.761389, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0469476, + "f_upper": -0.0172414, + "f_lower": -0.0172414 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.00625667, + "sd_T": 0.0274971, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0441987, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.058606, + "sd_T": 1.99983, + "AD_rms_max": -0.390481, + "f_mid": 0.4 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.154942, + "sd_T": 0.235442, + "AD_rms_max": -0.199025, + "f_mid": 0.0714286 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.281418, + "sd_T": 0.018263, + "AD_rms_max": -0.358921, + "f_mid": 0.107143 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.0075888, + "sd_T": 0.693758, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0498695, + "f_mid": 0.147059 + }, + "b1_m1.84_neg1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -0.00248897, + "sd_T": 0.0651826, + "AD_rms_max": -0.00460963, + "f_mid": -0.0294118 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00070455, + "sd_T": 0.129646, + "AD_rms_max": 0.062596, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00794549, + "sd_T": 3.90394, + "AD_rms_max": 0.424917, + "f_upper": 0.142857, + "f_lower": 0.142857 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.00597687, + "sd_T": 2.95918, + "AD_rms_max": 0.487728, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.0124979, + "sd_T": 4.09934, + "AD_rms_max": 0.993938, + "f_upper": -0.148148, + "f_lower": -0.148148 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0132288, + "sd_T": 0.679432, + "AD_rms_max": 0.286669, + "f_upper": -0.027027, + "f_lower": -0.027027 + }, + "wake_m1.12_pos1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -6.98416e-05, + "sd_T": -0.000317822, + "AD_rms_max": -0.00151722, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.032525, + "sd_T": 0.280969, + "AD_rms_max": 0.273797, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.400073, + "sd_T": 0.848568, + "AD_rms_max": 1.74392, + "f_mid": -0.0952381 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0109013, + "sd_T": 1.06185, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0638437, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -7.78067e-06, + "sd_T": -0.00021671, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0184043, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.0229739, + "sd_T": 1.98694, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0527667, + "f_mid": 0.0526316 + }, + "wake_m1.12_neg1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -4.41773e-06, + "sd_T": 1.74642e-05, + "AD_rms_max": 0.000181606, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.000612241, + "sd_T": 0.12109, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0707901, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.000741443, + "sd_T": 0.290359, + "AD_rms_max": 0.202874, + "f_upper": -0.125, + "f_lower": -0.125 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.000594474, + "sd_T": 0.0452808, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0317005, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00410578, + "sd_T": 1.1986, + "AD_rms_max": 0.242015, + "f_upper": -0.0222222, + "f_lower": -0.0222222 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.000385042, + "sd_T": -0.358935, + "AD_rms_max": -0.047561, + "f_upper": 0.0, + "f_lower": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_pos1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00851441, + "sd_T": 4.11944, + "AD_rms_max": 0.69433, + "f_upper": -0.012987, + "f_lower": -0.012987 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg0.4_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.000446763, + "sd_T": 0.111242, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0535107, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg0.4_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.00109584, + "sd_T": 0.5776, + "AD_rms_max": -0.0891654, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg0.8_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": -0.00145667, + "sd_T": -0.0277809, + "AD_rms_max": 0.051921, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg0.8_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": -0.00697171, + "sd_T": 0.953695, + "AD_rms_max": 0.0461086, + "f_mid": -0.0487805 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg1.2_undamped": { + "role": "no structural damping", + "mean_T": 0.140531, + "sd_T": -0.108429, + "AD_rms_max": 0.913708, + "f_mid": 0.0 + }, + "wake_m1.84_neg1.2_frictionless": { + "role": "frictionless floor", + "mean_T": 0.176446, + "sd_T": -0.0882717, + "AD_rms_max": 1.44709, + "f_mid": 0.0 + } + }, + "executable_sha256": "2cb307b11eab738867274a994d1364f75b9d79fd4562c00de82df59d946b7426" +}