Skip to content

Commit 195c7af

Browse files
TMHSDigitalclaude
andcommitted
catalog: re-verify the ten needs-review entries last checked in July (#40)
All ten re-read at the source on 2026-09-26 with dated Evidence lines. fab-megascans-standard and fmod-studio are now active (the Standard License and the FMOD Indie terms read in full: FMOD requires the credit line and splash logo). opengameart commercial -> true (FAQ), freesound commercial -> varies (CC0/BY/BY-NC per sound). lospec, convology-xt, godot-shaders, material-maker-gallery, wwise and charmorph stay needs-review, each with its open question restated in Notes. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 55d8d96 commit 195c7af

12 files changed

Lines changed: 67 additions & 26 deletions

File tree

‎catalog/2d/README.md‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -104,7 +104,7 @@ two carry obligations the rest do not.
104104
| [universal-lpc-generator](universal-lpc-generator.md) | Universal LPC Generator | varies (SA) | varies† | active |
105105
| [lpc-revised-basics](lpc-revised-basics.md) | LPC Revised Basics | varies (OGA-BY for every item) | yes | active |
106106
| [openclipart](openclipart.md) | Openclipart | CC0 | yes | active |
107-
| [opengameart](opengameart.md) | OpenGameArt | varies | unknown | needs-review |
107+
| [opengameart](opengameart.md) | OpenGameArt | varies | yes | needs-review |
108108
| [lospec](lospec.md) | Lospec | varies | unknown | needs-review |
109109
| [dcss-tiles](dcss-tiles.md) | Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup Tiles | varies | unknown | needs-review |
110110

‎catalog/2d/lospec.md‎

Lines changed: 5 additions & 3 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ commercial: unknown
99
attribution_required: unknown
1010
formats: [gpl-palette, PAL, ASE, PNG]
1111
tags: [palettes, pixel-art, retro]
12-
verified: 2026-07-20
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
1313
status: needs-review
1414
---
1515

@@ -19,15 +19,17 @@ Curated pixel palettes and tools. **No site-wide commercial grant** — most pal
1919

2020
## Notes
2121

22-
- `lospec.com/terms` still 404; [privacy-policy](https://lospec.com/privacy-policy) / [about](https://lospec.com/about) have no palette license grant
22+
- `lospec.com/terms` still 404; the footer links [Terms and Conditions](https://lospec.com/terms-and-conditions) instead. Read on 2026-09-26: a generic website/store ToS with no licence for palettes, so there is still no site-wide grant. Open question: each palette's own terms (most pages show none), which keeps `commercial` and `attribution_required` at `unknown`
23+
- [privacy-policy](https://lospec.com/privacy-policy) / [about](https://lospec.com/about) have no palette license grant
2324
- Hardware palettes are often usable as color lists; artist palettes need author terms
2425
- Prefer [paleto-vol01](paleto-vol01.md) when you need a verified commercial-ok starter set
2526

2627
## Evidence
2728

2829
- Live Sweetie 16 / DawnBringer 16 pages (2026-07-20): no license field → catalog-level `commercial: unknown`
2930
- Live [palette-list/tag/cc0](https://lospec.com/palette-list/tag/cc0) (2026-07-20): some uploads self-tag CC0 (e.g. Paleto) — not a site-wide grant → keep `needs-review`
30-
31+
- Live [Terms and Conditions](https://lospec.com/terms-and-conditions) (2026-09-26): covers use of the site and store ("This website is operated by Lospec"); sections on user submissions and prohibited uses, no licence granted for palette content
32+
- Live [Sweetie 16](https://lospec.com/palette-list/sweetie-16) (2026-09-26): "Palette created by GrafxKid", tags and download count only; no licence field
3133
## Related
3234

3335
- [paleto-vol01](paleto-vol01.md)

‎catalog/2d/opengameart.md‎

Lines changed: 7 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -5,11 +5,11 @@ url: https://opengameart.org
55
category: 2d
66
subcategories: [sprites, tileset, aggregator]
77
license: varies
8-
commercial: unknown
8+
commercial: true
99
attribution_required: unknown
1010
formats: [PNG, SVG, OGG]
1111
tags: [community, pixel-art, aggregator]
12-
verified: 2026-07-20
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
1313
status: needs-review
1414
---
1515

@@ -22,11 +22,16 @@ Community hub for game art under many licenses (CC0, CC-BY, CC-BY-SA, GPL, OGA-B
2222
- FAQ: closed-source commercial games OK **if** you follow each file’s license
2323
- Multi-license uploads = pick one compatible set; SA/GPL packs need extra care (see [`docs/high-risk.md`](../../docs/high-risk.md))
2424
- Filter CC0 / CC-BY before packaging
25+
- `commercial: true` follows the FAQ's plain site-wide statement (re-read 2026-09-26). Still open: credit is per upload (CC0 none; CC-BY needs it; the FAQ says to assume GPL uploads need it), and the schema has no per-file value for `attribution_required`, so the entry stays `needs-review`
26+
- Apple App Store: the FAQ says GPL, LGPL, CC-BY-SA and CC-BY terms conflict with Apple's, so ask the artist first
2527

2628
## Evidence
2729

2830
- Live [FAQ](https://opengameart.org/content/faq) (2026-07-20): “I'm a commercial (closed-source) game developer… **Yes, you can use this art. Even in commercial projects.** Be sure to follow the terms of the license…”
2931
- Same FAQ: CC0 “commercial use is ok”; CC-BY needs credit; SA/GPL also hosted → keep catalog-level `needs-review` / `commercial: unknown`
32+
- Live [FAQ](https://opengameart.org/content/faq) (2026-09-26): "Yes, you can use any of the art submitted to this site. Even in commercial projects. Just be sure to adhere to the license terms."
33+
- Same FAQ (2026-09-26): CC0 works may be used "without asking, crediting or notifying the creating artist"; CC-BY: "You must state that you have used the work and credit the original artist"; GPL: "you should assume that all work contained on OpenGameArt requires it [attribution] unless otherwise specified"
34+
- Same FAQ (2026-09-26), Apple App Store: "Not necessarily." Terms "conflict with the terms of the GNU GPL, the GNU LGPL, CC-BY-SA, and CC-BY"
3035

3136
## Related
3237

‎catalog/3d/README.md‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -130,7 +130,7 @@ than pack-wide. Triangle counts are geometry and survive re-hosting; file sizes
130130
| [magicavoxel](magicavoxel.md) | MagicaVoxel | custom | yes | active |
131131
| [smithsonian-open-access](smithsonian-open-access.md) | Smithsonian Open Access | CC0 | yes | active |
132132
| [charge-materials](charge-materials.md) | Charge materials | CC-BY? | unknown | needs-review |
133-
| [fab-megascans-standard](fab-megascans-standard.md) | Fab/Quixel (Standard) | custom | unknown* | needs-review |
133+
| [fab-megascans-standard](fab-megascans-standard.md) | Fab/Quixel (Standard) | custom | yes | active |
134134
| [poly-pizza](poly-pizza.md) | Poly Pizza | varies | unknown | needs-review |
135135
| [sketchfab](sketchfab.md) | Sketchfab | varies | unknown | needs-review |
136136
| [nasa-3d-resources](nasa-3d-resources.md) | NASA 3D Resources | public-domain* | yes* | active |

‎catalog/3d/fab-megascans-standard.md‎

Lines changed: 10 additions & 5 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -5,12 +5,12 @@ url: https://www.fab.com
55
category: 3d
66
subcategories: [photogrammetry, foliage, decals]
77
license: custom
8-
commercial: unknown
9-
attribution_required: unknown
8+
commercial: true
9+
attribution_required: false
1010
formats: [various]
11-
tags: [fab, quixel, engine-check-required, tos-unreachable]
12-
verified: 2026-07-19
13-
status: needs-review
11+
tags: [fab, quixel, engine-check-required]
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
13+
status: active
1414
---
1515

1616
# Fab / Quixel Megascans (Standard License)
@@ -21,10 +21,15 @@ Photogrammetry rocks, foliage, ground materials, etc. **Only** listings under **
2121

2222
- Prefer [poly-haven](../environment/poly-haven.md) / [ambientcg](ambientcg.md) / Kenney nature kits when you need clear CC0
2323
- On 2026-07-19: `fab.com` license URLs **HTTP 403**; Epic Fab docs pages returned Cloudflare challenge shells — cannot re-confirm Standard vs Epic wording live
24+
- On 2026-09-26 the [Fab EULA](https://www.fab.com/eula) loaded in a full browser (plain fetch still 403). The fields above describe **Standard License** listings only; a CC-BY listing needs credit, and a legacy UE Marketplace License listing is noted on its own page
25+
- Personal vs Professional is a price tier by buyer revenue (over $100,000 USD in the last 12 months = Professional); the EULA summary says both tiers "grant you the same scope of rights"
2426

2527
## Evidence
2628

2729
- Live fetch (2026-07-19): `fab.com/licensing`, `/license`, sellers licensing → **403**; `dev.epicgames.com/documentation/.../fab/licenses` → challenge/empty body → keep `needs-review` / `commercial: unknown`
30+
- Live [Fab EULA](https://www.fab.com/eula) Standard License summary (2026-09-26): "Use the assets commercially or privately"; "Use the assets with any compatible tools (usage is not limited to Unreal Engine)"
31+
- Same page (2026-09-26): "You are not required to give credit to the publisher you acquired the Fab asset from"; "You may not: Resell or redistribute the asset for free on a standalone basis"
32+
- Live [Licenses and Pricing in Fab](https://dev.epicgames.com/documentation/en-us/fab/licenses-and-pricing-in-fab) (2026-09-26): "Fab offers the following license types: Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) (Free) Standard (Free or For Sale)"; the UE Marketplace License is being phased out
2833

2934
## Related
3035

‎catalog/audio/convology-xt.md‎

Lines changed: 3 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ commercial: unknown
99
attribution_required: unknown
1010
formats: [VST, AU, AAX, WAV]
1111
tags: [reverb, ir, plugin, free-factory]
12-
verified: 2026-07-19
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
1313
status: needs-review
1414
---
1515

@@ -22,10 +22,12 @@ Free convolution reverb plugin + **74** factory vintage IR samples (Impulse Reco
2222
- Prefer [voxengo-impulses](voxengo-impulses.md) when you need an explicit royalty-free IR file grant for commercial games
2323
- Using the plugin in a DAW to *render* wet audio into a game is a different question from shipping the IR files
2424
- `/license/`, `/eula/`, `/terms/`, `/faq/` all 404 on 2026-07-19; only [privacy](https://impulserecord.com/privacy/) is public — no commercial/redistribution grant there
25+
- Re-checked 2026-09-26: `/license/`, `/eula/`, `/terms/`, `/terms-and-conditions/`, `/licensing/`, `/license-agreement/`, `/faq/` all 404, and the site's page sitemap lists no licence page. Still open: the licence for the 74 factory IRs (commercial use, credit, and whether the WAVs may ship in a game) sits behind the download form, so `commercial` and `attribution_required` stay `unknown`
2526

2627
## Evidence
2728

2829
- Live product page (2026-07-19): “Free Factory Plugin – Includes 74 Vintage Reverb Impulse Response Files… no time limitations, iLok…” — points users to a gated “licensing page” at download; no public commercial/redistribution text found → keep `needs-review`
30+
- Live [product page](https://impulserecord.com/convology-xt/) (2026-09-26): unchanged: "Free Factory Plugin – Includes 74 Vintage Reverb Impulse Response Files"; "Simply fill in the information on the licensing page and that's all there is to it." No licence terms on the page
2931

3032
## Related
3133

‎catalog/audio/freesound.md‎

Lines changed: 5 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -5,11 +5,11 @@ url: https://freesound.org
55
category: audio
66
subcategories: [sfx, field-recordings]
77
license: varies
8-
commercial: unknown
8+
commercial: varies
99
attribution_required: unknown
1010
formats: [WAV, FLAC, OGG]
1111
tags: [community, filter-required, cc0-filter]
12-
verified: 2026-07-19
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
1313
status: needs-review
1414
---
1515

@@ -21,6 +21,8 @@ Huge community audio library. Per-sound licenses are **CC0**, **CC BY**, or **CC
2121

2222
- **Content ID reaches sound effects, through third parties.** Freesound's own FAQ (read 2026-09-23) explains it: musicians put "raw" Freesound sounds into songs and register those songs with YouTube Content ID, so any other video containing the same unedited sound gets matched. It adds that a sound "modified with plugins, stretched or slowed" is less likely to match, and that a claim can be disputed by showing the Freesound upload predates the song. For a game, process sounds before you ship them, which also protects your players' videos
2323

24+
- `commercial: varies` (set 2026-09-26): the FAQ names three per-sound licences, and one of them (BY-NC) forbids commercial use, so this is the per-file case the catalog marks `varies`. Still open: credit is also per sound (CC0 none, BY required), and the schema has no per-file value for `attribution_required`, so the entry stays `needs-review`
25+
2426
- Search filters are not a legal guarantee — open each sound’s license page before packaging
2527
- Attribution list tool: freesound.org/home/attribution/
2628
- Site ToS restricts commercial use of the *website portal*; sound reuse still follows the per-file Creative Commons choice
@@ -30,6 +32,7 @@ Huge community audio library. Per-sound licenses are **CC0**, **CC BY**, or **CC
3032

3133
- Live [FAQ — Licenses](https://freesound.org/help/faq/) (2026-07-19): uploaders choose CC0 / BY / BY-NC; FAQ summary: NC means “you can't earn any money with the piece of work you create!”
3234
- Live [website ToS](https://freesound.org/help/tos_web/) (2026-07-19): sounds/metadata licensed under the CC license the uploader selects — not a site-wide commercial grant → keep `needs-review` / `commercial: unknown`
35+
- Live [FAQ — Licenses](https://freesound.org/help/faq/) (2026-09-26): "freesound lets the user select one of three licenses for their sounds. And, we used to have a 4th license"; zero: "you can do pretty much what you want with the sound"; attribution: "you should always mention the original creators"; noncommercial: "you can't earn any money with the piece of work you create!"
3336

3437
## Related
3538

‎catalog/characters/charmorph.md‎

Lines changed: 6 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ commercial: unknown
99
attribution_required: unknown
1010
formats: [Blend, glTF, FBX]
1111
tags: [blender, humanoid, mb-lab-derived]
12-
verified: 2026-07-19
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
1313
status: needs-review
1414
---
1515

@@ -22,12 +22,17 @@ Blender character tool reimplementing MB-Lab-style morphing (no MB-Lab *code*).
2222
- Open each character’s `license.txt` in [CharMorph-db](https://github.com/Upliner/CharMorph-db) before exporting
2323
- `mb_female` (and likely other `mb_*`) = full AGPL text — treat like MB-Lab export risk
2424
- Antonia = CC-BY-3.0 (attribution required)
25+
- Reom = CC-BY per its `config.yaml` (`license: CC-BY`, no version stated); it has no `license.txt`
2526
- Do not assume “safer than MB-Lab” without checking the active base
27+
- Still open (re-checked 2026-09-26): every stated licence (GPL-3 code, AGPL-3 MB-Lab data, CC-BY Antonia and Reom) permits commercial use in itself; what is unsettled is how far the AGPL on `mb_*` meshes reaches into an exported character shipped in a closed game, and credit differs per base. That keeps `commercial` and `attribution_required` at `unknown`
28+
- Maintenance: GitHub API on 2026-09-26: CharMorph not archived, last push 2025-05-29; CharMorph-db last push 2024-07-23
2629

2730
## Evidence
2831

2932
- Live CharMorph-db (2026-07-19): `characters/mb_female/license.txt` = **GNU AGPL v3**; `characters/antonia/license.txt` = **CC BY 3.0**
3033
- Live `__init__.py`: GPL-3 license block for the addon
34+
- Live [license.txt](https://github.com/Upliner/CharMorph/blob/master/license.txt) (2026-09-26): "All python files released in the CharMorph package, are released under GNU General Public License 3"; "Each character has its own license stated in select list"; MB-Lab character data "released under GNU Affero General Public License 3"
35+
- Live CharMorph-db (2026-09-26): characters are `antonia`, `mb_female`, `mb_male`, `reom`. `antonia/license.txt`: "licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License"; `reom/config.yaml`: "title: Reom (CC-BY)", "license: CC-BY"
3136

3237
## Related
3338

‎catalog/shaders-vfx/godot-shaders.md‎

Lines changed: 3 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ commercial: true
99
attribution_required: unknown
1010
formats: [gdshader]
1111
tags: [godot, canvas-item, spatial, per-item-license]
12-
verified: 2026-07-19
12+
verified: 2026-09-26
1313
status: needs-review
1414
---
1515

@@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ Community Godot shader library. Site policy allows personal **and commercial** u
1919

2020
## Notes
2121

22+
- Still open (re-checked 2026-09-26): credit depends on each post's licence (CC0 none; MIT keeps its notice; GPL v3 carries its own terms), and the schema has no per-file value for `attribution_required`, so the entry stays `needs-review`
2223
- Browse/filter by license on the library; never assume the trending page is GPL-free
2324
- Featured images, screenshots, videos, and embedded assets are **outside** the shader license
2425
- Prefer primary MIT packs in this category ([boujie-water](boujie-water.md), [sky3d](sky3d.md), [waterways](waterways.md)) when you need a known-safe dependency
@@ -27,6 +28,7 @@ Community Godot shader library. Site policy allows personal **and commercial** u
2728

2829
- Live [License](https://godotshaders.com/license/) (2026-07-19): “Anyone will be able to use the shaders posted to the site freely, both in personal and commercial products.” Submitters choose CC0, MIT, or GNU GPL v.3; media exception stated.
2930
- Live [About](https://godotshaders.com/about/) (2026-07-19): “All shaders here are free under CC0, MIT or GNU GPLv.3 license.”
31+
- Live [License](https://godotshaders.com/license/) (2026-09-26): unchanged: "Anyone will be able to use the shaders posted to the site freely, both in personal and commercial products"; licence options CC0, MIT, GNU GPL v.3; "The featured image, screenshots and videos, and assets used in these, do not fall under this license."
3032

3133
## Related
3234

‎catalog/shaders-vfx/material-maker-gallery.md‎

Lines changed: 4 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ commercial: unknown
1010
attribution_required: unknown
1111
formats: [mm, PNG]
1212
tags: [procedural, pbr, per-item-license]
13-
verified: 2026-07-19
13+
verified: 2026-09-26
1414
status: needs-review
1515
---
1616

@@ -21,13 +21,15 @@ Community procedural materials/nodes/brushes/environments with **per-item** lice
2121
## Notes
2222

2323
- CC-BY → credit author; CC-BY-SA → share-alike on asset derivatives (keep graphs/textures extractable)
24-
- Site `/terms` is privacy/cookies, not an IP license for gallery items
24+
- Site `/terms` is privacy/cookies, not an IP license for gallery items (re-read 2026-09-26: still a privacy policy, "effective as of 01/01/2021")
25+
- Still open (2026-09-26): the site makes no commercial or credit statement of its own, and item pages are script-rendered, so a per-item licence could not be read in a plain fetch. All three filter licences are CC licences that allow commercial use, but the catalog records `commercial` only from a source statement, so it and `attribution_required` stay `unknown`
2526
- Bake/export for engines; keep license metadata if you redistribute `.mm`
2627
- Pair with [material-maker](../tools/material-maker.md); for ready CC0 PBR prefer [ambientcg](../3d/ambientcg.md)
2728

2829
## Evidence
2930

3031
- Live gallery license filters (2026-07-19): links labeled **CC-BY**, **CC0**, **CC-BY-SA** (`license_mask` query params), which confirms per-item, not site-wide.
32+
- Live [gallery](https://www.materialmaker.org/materials) (2026-09-26): License filter still lists only "CC-BY", "CC0", "CC-BY-SA"; types material, brush, node, environment
3133

3234
## Related
3335

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)