wip - implement single repo per wheel per hub

remove incorrect code written by AI

Author: aignas

.agents/plans/single_dep_whl_library.md

@@ -0,0 +1,137 @@
+# Single dep for spoke repos per `whl_name`.
+
+The goal is to have `whl_library` instances from wheels (where we pass `url` for a URL or we pass
+a `whl_file` label which points to an actual wheel) to be reused across different python versions
+and across different configurations where different extras are requested. This means that
+if the user is using the same wheel in 2 different configurations, the wheel is reused, because
+the extracted contents should not differ. This could be important for:
+* platform-specific wheels for custom platforms defined by the user. Otherwise the
+  platform-specific wheel behaviour should remain unchanged.
+* cross-platform wheels for are the main affected item here.
+
+The code should be gated by a feature flag, which can be flipped to be enabled using an
+environmental variable via 
+
+The file to modify `python/private/internal_config_repo.bzl`. Use the 
+`RULES_PYTHON_WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED=1` to enable the feature. Add it to the
+`docs/readthedocs_build.sh` file so that we are exercising the code. And document this in
+the `docs/environment-variables.md` file.
+If the flag is off, then it is equivalent to the current
+`main` branch behaviour, if it is on, then it is equivalent to turning all of the behaviour
+implemented here on.
+
+Since this is a refactor for users not using private APIs, the env variable will be switched/removed
+later together with old code.
+
+All of the code should be written in a TDD style where we add a failing test for a feature and then
+we implement the new code.
+
+## Change the naming of the spoke repositories:
+
+> The hub repositories should be named `<hub_name>_<wheel_name_suffix>.
+
+The names should be changed:
+* from `+pip+dev_pip_314_requests_py3_none_any_2a0d60c1_linux_x86_64_linux_x86_64_freethreaded`
+  to `+pip+dev_pip_requests_py3_none_any_2a0d60c1`
+* from `+pip+dev_pip_314_roman_numerals_py3_none_any_647ba99c`
+  to `+pip+dev_pip_roman_numerals_py3_none_any_647ba99c`
+* from `+pip+dev_pip_314_markupsafe_cp314_cp314t_manylinux_2_17_x86_64_fed51ac4`
+  to `+pip+dev_pip_markupsafe_cp314_cp314t_manylinux_2_17_x86_64_fed51ac4`
+
+So the naming convention after the change is:
+`<prefix>_<name>_<py_tag>_<abi_tag>_<platform_tag>_<sha256[:8]>`
+
+Where `<prefix>` is the hub repository name and the rest of the segments come from the wheel name
+itself.
+
+The sdist building `whl_library` instances should change the naming to:
+`<prefix>_<name>_<sha256[:8]>_<rules_python_target_platform>`
+
+The file to modify `python/private/pypi/whl_repo_name.bzl`
+
+## Change the `whl_library_targets`
+
+Using the `METADATA` file that is parsed from `whl_metadata` function where the `Provides-Extra` is
+retrieved from the file. Right now we generate a single target which includes all of the extras that
+are required. Instead do the following target generation:
+* `pkg` (no extras) - target with no extras, this is the main target that includes the python sources,
+  the other targets just include extra dependencies.
+* `pkg__extra` - target for each extra in the provides-extra list. If the target depends on
+  `self[another_extra]`, then explode the nodes so that the target only depends on `pkg` target +
+  extra dependencies. Use `py_library` for this. Also be smart about generating targets:
+    - If the only extra is in the env marker, but the dependency is not in the hub repo, then skip
+      generating the whole `pkg__extra` target.
+    - Propose any extra ideas here.
+
+Related files:
+* `python/private/pypi/whl_library.bzl`
+* `python/private/pypi/whl_metadata.bzl`
+* `python/private/pypi/whl_library_targets.bzl`
+
+## Change `hub_builder` and `hub_repository`
+
+Instead of passing the `requirement[extra1,extra2]` to the `whl_library`, pass it to the
+`hub_repository` via `whl_config_setting` so that the `render_pkg_aliases` is using the information to alias to the right
+extra target based on what is requested. This should retain the behaviour where different target
+platforms are allowed to target `foo[baz]` and `foo[bar]` and we select the
+`@dev_pip_spoke_repo//:pkg__baz` and `@dev_pip_spoke_repo//:pkg__bar` appropriately.
+
+We should also generate extra targets here:
+* `pkg` should point to the target with all specified extras as passed to the `hub_repository`. This is to keep backwards compatibility with how it used to be done
+  previously. This also keeps compatibility with `rules_pycross`. Add this as a comment
+  when doing this. The spoke repos should not be used directly, so this difference in
+  behaviour is OK.
+  This reuses the targets declared in the hub repository described below.
+  It is backed by a `py_library` target if there are multiple extras, or an `alias` if it
+  is only a single extra. It is the same target as described below.
+* `pkg[]` should point to the target in the spoke without extras
+* `pkg[extra]` should point to the target in the spoke with particular extras. Do this for each
+  provided extra. So for `requirements[extra1,extra2]` passed to the hub repo, 2 extra targets will
+  be created. If the extras have not been specified for certain platforms via the
+  `whl_config_setting`, then the `select` statement should raise an `error` for no match.
+  Document the mapping explicitly: hub `pkg[]` → spoke `pkg`, hub `pkg[extra]` → spoke `pkg__extra`.
+  The fact that some of the targets in the spoke repos are unreachable is intentional - this is
+  because the hub repository contents are created before the `whl_library` downloads the whl and
+  inspects the METADATA.
+  The reverse direction is not a concern because the requirements file locking results in
+  consistent file. If something like this happens, then we should provide a message to the
+  user that something went wrong and that they should create a ticket in rules_python bug
+  tracker.
+* If there is `requirement[extra1,extra2]` passed, that means that we should create a special alias
+  that includes both of the targets at once. For this use `py_library` instead of `alias` and pass
+  `:pkg[extra1]` and `:pkg[extra2]` to the `deps` of the `py_library`. This won't cause
+  a failure because for a particular platform that is requested this should work by
+  construction, because the dependency targets will be also defined for the particular platform.
+
+* If the `requirement` is passed without any extras, then hub `pkg` should alias to `pkg[]`.
+* If the target is `py_library`, then we should name it without `[]` to avoid any aspects traversing
+  `py_library` targets changing behaviour. Only alias targets can have `[]`.
+
+Related files:
+* `python/private/pypi/render_pkg_aliases.bzl`
+* `python/private/pypi/hub_builder.bzl`
+* `python/private/pypi/hub_repository.bzl`
+* `python/private/pypi/whl_config_setting.bzl` - consider extending this struct to specify which
+  extras are requested for which platform.
+
+## Modify `pip_repository`
+
+Do similar changes to the `WORKSPACE` code to ensure easier maintenance of `whl_library` so that all
+code paths to `whl_library` remain consistent.
+
+Implement this by using the information that we retrieve by parsing the `requirements.txt` files
+using the `parse_requirements` function. Parse the requirement itself using the existing parser in
+the referenced file `pep508_requirement.bzl`.
+
+Related files:
+* `python/private/pypi/pip_repository.bzl`
+* `python/private/pypi/requirements.bzl.tmpl.workspace`
+* `python/private/pypi/pep508_requirement.bzl`
+
+## Modify `unified_hub_repo`
+
+Pass the extras to the `unified_hub_repo` as well so that the extra targets are created. The target
+topology in the unified hub repo should correspond to the hub_repository.
+
+File:
+* `python/private/pypi/unified_hub_repo.bzl`

.agents/skills/accessing-sandbox/SKILL.md

@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
+# Accessing build failures
+
+When looking at the test results and the build sandbox, do not ask permission to access the paths
+via the absolute path, instead access them via the convenience symlinks in the root of the git
+repository.
+
+Patterns:
+* Use `bazel-bin/tests/pypi/hub_builder` to access the test results for the `//tests/pypi/hub_builder`
+* Use `bazel-rules_python/external/` to access the external repos fetch or materialized by the
+  extensions
+* Use `bazel-testlogs/tests/pypi/hub_builder/test_simple` to access the logs for the `//tests/pypi/hub_builder:test_simple` test.

docs/readthedocs_build.sh

@@ -1,5 +1,8 @@
 #!/usr/bin/env bash
 
+# Exercising the whl_library optimized mode to ensure it is working
+export RULES_PYTHON_WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED=1
+
 set -eou pipefail
 
 declare -a extra_env

python/private/internal_config_repo.bzl

@@ -24,13 +24,17 @@ load(":repo_utils.bzl", "repo_utils")
 _ENABLE_DEPRECATION_WARNINGS_ENVVAR_NAME = "RULES_PYTHON_DEPRECATION_WARNINGS"
 _ENABLE_DEPRECATION_WARNINGS_DEFAULT = "0"
 
+_WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED_ENVVAR_NAME = "RULES_PYTHON_WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED"
+_WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED_DEFAULT = "0"
+
 _CONFIG_TEMPLATE = """
 config = struct(
   build_python_zip_default = {build_python_zip_default},
   supports_whl_extraction = {supports_whl_extraction},
   enable_pystar = True,
   enable_deprecation_warnings = {enable_deprecation_warnings},
   extract_needs_chmod = {extract_needs_chmod},
+  whl_library_optimized = {whl_library_optimized},
   bazel_8_or_later = {bazel_8_or_later},
   bazel_9_or_later = {bazel_9_or_later},
   bazel_10_or_later = {bazel_10_or_later},
@@ -104,6 +108,7 @@ def _internal_config_repo_impl(rctx):
     rctx.file("rules_python_config.bzl", _CONFIG_TEMPLATE.format(
         build_python_zip_default = repo_utils.get_platforms_os_name(rctx) == "windows",
         enable_deprecation_warnings = _bool_from_environ(rctx, _ENABLE_DEPRECATION_WARNINGS_ENVVAR_NAME, _ENABLE_DEPRECATION_WARNINGS_DEFAULT),
+        whl_library_optimized = _bool_from_environ(rctx, _WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED_ENVVAR_NAME, _WHL_LIBRARY_OPTIMIZED_DEFAULT),
         builtin_py_info_symbol = builtin_py_info_symbol,
         builtin_py_runtime_info_symbol = builtin_py_runtime_info_symbol,
         supports_whl_extraction = str(supports_whl_extraction),

python/private/pypi/generate_whl_library_build_bazel.bzl

@@ -27,6 +27,7 @@ _RENDER = {
     "extras": render.list,
     "group_deps": render.list,
     "include": str,
+    "provides_extra": render.list,
     "requires_dist": render.list,
     "srcs_exclude": render.list,
     "tags": render.list,

python/private/pypi/hub_builder.bzl

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ load(":attrs.bzl", "use_isolated")
 load(":parse_requirements.bzl", "parse_requirements")
 load(":pep508_env.bzl", "env")
 load(":pep508_evaluate.bzl", "evaluate")
+load(":pep508_requirement.bzl", "requirement")
 load(":python_tag.bzl", "python_tag")
 load(":requirements_files_by_platform.bzl", "requirements_files_by_platform")
 load(":whl_config_setting.bzl", "whl_config_setting")
@@ -308,13 +309,10 @@ def _add_whl_library(self, *, python_version, whl, repo):
         # disallow building from sdist.
         return
 
-    # TODO @aignas 2025-06-29: we should not need the version in the repo_name if
-    # we are using pipstar and we are downloading the wheel using the downloader
-    #
-    # However, for that we should first have a different way to reference closures with
-    # extras. For example, if some package depends on `foo[extra]` and another depends on
-    # `foo`, we should have 2 py_library targets.
-    repo_name = "{}_{}_{}".format(self.name, version_label(python_version), repo.repo_name)
+    if self._config.whl_library_optimized:
+        repo_name = "{}_{}".format(self.name, repo.repo_name)
+    else:
+        repo_name = "{}_{}_{}".format(self.name, version_label(python_version), repo.repo_name)
 
     if repo_name in self._whl_libraries:
         diff = _diff_dict(self._whl_libraries[repo_name], repo.args)
@@ -538,6 +536,7 @@ def _create_whl_repos(
         )
         for src in whl.srcs:
             repo = _whl_repo(
+                self,
                 src = src,
                 index_url = whl.index_url,
                 whl_library_args = whl_library_args,
@@ -549,6 +548,7 @@ def _create_whl_repos(
                 is_multiple_versions = whl.is_multiple_versions,
                 interpreter = interpreter,
                 enable_pipstar_extract = enable_pipstar_extract,
+                optimized = self._config.whl_library_optimized,
             )
             _add_whl_library(
                 self,
@@ -612,6 +612,7 @@ def _whl_library_args(self, *, whl, whl_modifications):
     return whl_library_args
 
 def _whl_repo(
+        self,
         *,
         src,
         whl_library_args,
@@ -623,9 +624,21 @@ def _whl_repo(
         python_version,
         use_downloader,
         interpreter,
-        enable_pipstar_extract = False):
+        enable_pipstar_extract = False,
+        optimized = False):
     args = dict(whl_library_args)
-    args["requirement"] = src.requirement_line
+    if self._config.whl_library_optimized:
+        line = requirement(src.requirement_line)
+        extras = line.extras
+
+        # Strip extras from the requirement for whls in optimized mode so that
+        # the wheel can be reused across different configurations requesting
+        # different extras.
+        args["requirement"] = line.name
+    else:
+        args["requirement"] = src.requirement_line
+        extras = []
+
     is_whl = src.filename.endswith(".whl")
 
     if src.extra_pip_args and not is_whl:
@@ -658,6 +671,7 @@ def _whl_repo(
                 config_setting = whl_config_setting(
                     version = python_version,
                     target_platforms = target_platforms or None,
+                    extras = extras,
                 ),
             )
 
@@ -678,14 +692,15 @@ def _whl_repo(
     # TODO @aignas 2025-11-02: once we have pipstar enabled we can add extra
     # targets to each hub for each extra combination and solve this more cleanly as opposed to
     # duplicating whl_library repositories.
-    target_platforms = src.target_platforms if is_multiple_versions else []
+    target_platforms = src.target_platforms if (is_multiple_versions and not optimized) else []
 
     return struct(
-        repo_name = whl_repo_name(src.filename, src.sha256, *target_platforms),
+        repo_name = whl_repo_name(src.filename, src.sha256, target_platforms = target_platforms, optimized = optimized),
         args = args,
         config_setting = whl_config_setting(
             version = python_version,
             target_platforms = src.target_platforms,
+            extras = extras,
         ),
     )
 

python/private/pypi/hub_repository.bzl

@@ -146,4 +146,6 @@ def _whl_config_setting_dict(a):
         ret["target_platforms"] = a.target_platforms
     if a.version:
         ret["version"] = a.version
+    if a.extras:
+        ret["extras"] = a.extras
     return ret

python/private/pypi/whl_config_setting.bzl

@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@
 
 "A small function to create an alias for a whl distribution"
 
-def whl_config_setting(*, version = None, target_platforms = None):
+def whl_config_setting(*, version = None, target_platforms = None, extras = None):
     """The bzl_packages value used by by the render_pkg_aliases function.
 
     This contains the minimum amount of information required to generate correct
@@ -27,6 +27,8 @@ def whl_config_setting(*, version = None, target_platforms = None):
             is no match found during a select.
         target_platforms: {type}`list[str] | None` the list of target_platforms for this
             distribution.
+        extras: {type}`list[str] | None` the list of extras for this particular target platform to
+            enable.
 
     Returns:
         a struct with the validated and parsed values.
@@ -55,4 +57,5 @@ def whl_config_setting(*, version = None, target_platforms = None):
         # Make the struct hashable
         target_platforms = tuple(target_platforms) if target_platforms else None,
         version = version,
+        extras = extras or None,
     )