Skip to content

Commit 645880e

Browse files
committed
Mark all review experiment pairs prepared
1 parent a028706 commit 645880e

2 files changed

Lines changed: 3 additions & 3 deletions

File tree

‎docs/experiments/review-protocol.md‎

Lines changed: 2 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
11
# Plan-indexed review: go/no-go protocol
22

3-
Status: **pair selection frozen; pair 1 prepared; reviews not started**. Max Hwang (`mchwang`) is the blinded reviewer and Codex is the experiment operator. This document does not claim a passed gate. Complete each row's PR and SHA fields and commit that exact revision before the first timed review. No issue, assignment, order, or threshold may change once the first review begins.
3+
Status: **pair selection frozen; all four pairs prepared; reviews not started**. Max Hwang (`mchwang`) is the blinded reviewer and Codex is the experiment operator. This document does not claim a passed gate. Every row's PR and exact base/head SHAs are committed below. No issue, assignment, order, or threshold may change once the first review begins.
44

55
## Pair selection and order
66

@@ -43,4 +43,4 @@ Report declared-file catch rate for both methods without a pass threshold. Stop
4343

4444
## Current evidence
4545

46-
Engineering tests prove browser interactions, persistence, attribution, and planting mechanics. The separate manual assignment proves that one real merged issue can be completely classified through stored review choices. Neither establishes human review speed or catch rates. Pair 1 is prepared at the exact PR revisions above and passed the repository preflight; the other three pairs remain in preparation. No timed decision or catch-rate result exists yet.
46+
Engineering tests prove browser interactions, persistence, attribution, and planting mechanics. The separate manual assignment proves that one real merged issue can be completely classified through stored review choices. Neither establishes human review speed or catch rates. All four pairs are prepared at the eight exact PR revisions above, and every revision passed the repository preflight. No timed decision or catch-rate result exists yet.

‎docs/implementation/read-only-review.md‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ Store schema v2 adds the review counter and per-item notes through a transaction
2222

2323
- No agent answers, test execution, AI findings ingestion, send-to-agent action, or merge control is included. These belong after the go/no-go gate. Four checks distinguish unavailable evidence from success.
2424
- File cards show mode/path/object IDs and blob byte sizes. PNG/JPEG/GIF/WebP previews are bounded to 1 MiB each and 4 MiB across a history; unsupported/oversized images say unavailable. Gitlink byte sizes are not applicable. SVG/HTML is never embedded.
25-
- The real issue pairs are frozen in `docs/experiments/review-protocol.md`, and the completed manual assignment is recorded in `docs/experiments/manual-assignment.md`. Pair 1 is prepared at its exact PR revisions; pairs 2–4, human timing, and the final result remain pending. Do not mark issue #3 closed or claim the gate passed.
25+
- The real issue pairs are frozen in `docs/experiments/review-protocol.md`, and the completed manual assignment is recorded in `docs/experiments/manual-assignment.md`. All four pairs are prepared at their exact PR revisions; human timing and the final result remain pending. Do not mark issue #3 closed or claim the gate passed.
2626
- The planting helper is intentionally limited to disposable clones and supported regular top-level paths; it never publishes PRs.
2727

2828
## Validation

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)