fix: tighten validation workflow observability

Author: rockyshi1993

changelogs/unreleased.md

@@ -13,6 +13,8 @@
 
 - **本地候选修复 — 派生资产新鲜度与默认验证漏检**：刷新 `content/skills/portfolio.json`，并将 `skill-portfolio-current` 纳入 changed/iterative 默认验证不变量，使 clean-tree `npm test` 计划覆盖 portfolio freshness；同步 validation DAG 断言与 Windows 中文文件名负向测试夹具，避免默认验证对派生资产 stale false-green。本项仅为本地源码候选，未 tag、未 publish、未刷新 MCP。
 - **本地候选修复 — 验证入口、产物状态投影与 Profile 当前真相刷新**：收紧 active-root 产物 stale CP 状态检测，避免把“待用户确认是否提交”等非 CP 文案误判为 CP1/CP2 阻断；默认 `test:fast/full/delivery/boundary/profile-deploy/package-release` 改为 `human-cli --plan` 入口并补充 `:ai` 严格变体，避免 Codex/AI 环境缺 `contextEpoch` 时本地 plan 命令误红；新增 `profile-current:refresh` 标准命令，用于更新 active Profile `ProfileCurrentTruthV1` 的当前源码 HEAD 与 source candidate 身份。本项仅为本地源码候选，未 tag、未 publish、未刷新 MCP。
+- **本地候选修复 — 验证入口派生资产与 Profile 边界**：将默认 `test` / `test:changed` / scoped route 入口恢复为执行型验证，新增显式 `test:plan` / `test:*:plan` 作为零执行预览入口，避免 plan-only 被误读为测试已执行；把 `scripts/refresh-profile-current-truth.js` 纳入 profile boundary 与 `profile-governance` 输入闭包，确保修改 Profile current truth refresh 脚本时触发 profile 验证；刷新 `content/skills/portfolio.json`。本项仅为本地源码候选，未 tag、未 publish、未刷新 MCP。
+- **本地候选修复 — 运行态可观测性与历史债务收敛**：`validate.js` 现在对每个 V 探针输出 start/done heartbeat，V7 改为有界 fast-path smoke，避免聚合校验无界卡死；visible reply evidence 绑定当前 promptCount，无 payload 时不再继承旧 precheck；`memory_status` 增加 `summaryCurrentProjection`，显式区分 append-only SUMMARY 历史与当前折叠状态；artifact checker 新增 digest-bound `HistoricalArtifactIssueDispositionV1`，用于精确处置历史 unknown/stale/conflict 产物噪声。本项仅为本地源码候选，未 tag、未 publish、未刷新 MCP。
 
 - **v1.20.0 发布候选 — 任务连续性与工程控制面升级**：汇总 Stage A/B 的任务写入代际、合法 CP 演进续代、taskless 恢复、项目优先 Profile、多语言连续性、分层 SkillRoute、宿主原生多 Agent 编排合同、验证执行提速与修复批次收敛。完整说明见 [`changelogs/releases/v1.20.0.md`](./releases/v1.20.0.md)。正式发布事实仍只由 tag、registry、GitHub Release 与发布后安装回读共同成立。
 - **两阶段精确制品发布防护**：tag 资格阶段只生成一个正式精确 tarball，对同一制品完成隔离 consumer/HOME/prefix/cache/workspace 安装并保存；本机复用该制品完成真实 Codex G1→G2 后，才通过 `publish-qualified` 续发 npm 与 GitHub Release，避免 tag 触发后未经真实宿主验收即发生不可逆发布。

content/skills/portfolio.json

@@ -13,10 +13,10 @@
     "publicTaxonomyDigest": "b673f27fa58c2d7a57b9aa906562faed2aca094a727c8686d941c39a5490f030",
     "portfolioEvidence": "content/skills/portfolio-evidence.json",
     "portfolioEvidenceDigest": "8364a73c66ed2ec9787cdb9300223278d128a45b689a2b8deda0d1f03189f42b",
-    "consumerInventoryFileCount": 718,
-    "consumerInventoryDigest": "90be8bb27ca78eb1fcd8151601ec839c087e6b8727e1f326b7d54897530c0431",
+    "consumerInventoryFileCount": 719,
+    "consumerInventoryDigest": "d16b31fa502b07accabc7e87b05930f22fbbedfa03db8f27d2e932a70ee1421f",
     "consumerProjectionDigest": "2a9023e04a434de68bc88eac365e483307cabfb5f768bbb85151cd24376e34e4",
-    "portfolioInputDigest": "c681c19b07d6611b5e4c2d04d1d27f4961e1834985e05a244048044e9408ec6a"
+    "portfolioInputDigest": "9d5e556f66f0184b7acf174b3c560ece48165e7df247225581d2b3aeb532a3d0"
   },
   "ordering": "skills.id asc; graph edges from/to asc",
   "summary": {

hooks/_runtime/lifecycle-visible-reply.cjs

@@ -284,11 +284,34 @@ function buildLifecycleVisibleReplyUtils(ctx) {
       state.visible.workflowCompletion = projectWorkflowCompletionVisibleState(completionProjection)
     }
     const evidence = getVisibleReplyEvidence(payload)
+    const visibleObservedAt = new Date().toISOString()
+    state.visible.observedPromptCount = Number(state.promptCount || 0)
+    state.visible.observedEventName = eventName
+    state.visible.observedAt = visibleObservedAt
+    state.visible.sampleFreshness = 'current'
+    state.visible.staleReason = ''
     state.visible.replyEvidence = evidence.observed ? 'verified-present' : 'unverified'
     state.visible.replySource = evidence.source || ''
     state.visible.artifactEvidenceSource = evidence.source || ''
     if (!evidence.observed) {
       // PF-163: unobserved payload cannot invent delivery; still surface semantic-artifact gap for completion evidence
+      state.visible.payloadObserved = false
+      state.visible.precheck = false
+      state.visible.precheckStatus = 'unverified'
+      state.visible.precheckMissingItems = []
+      state.visible.entryCheckCompleteness = {
+        claimed: false,
+        complete: false,
+        status: 'not-claimed',
+        missingPcs: [],
+        missingItems: [],
+        foldedRanges: [],
+        presentPcs: [],
+        sourceSchemaVersion: null,
+        migrationStatus: 'not-claimed'
+      }
+      state.visible.sampleFreshness = 'unverified'
+      state.visible.staleReason = 'visible-payload-unobserved'
       state.visible.artifactStatus = 'unverified'
       state.visible.artifactMissingItems = ['visible-payload-unobserved', 'semantic-artifact-items']
       state.visible.finalValidationSummaryStatus = 'unverified'
@@ -436,7 +459,29 @@ function buildLifecycleVisibleReplyUtils(ctx) {
     if (eventName === 'Stop') fs.unlinkSync(statePaths.finalPayloadFlag)
   }
 
+  function getVisibleReplyFreshness(state) {
+    const visible = state?.visible
+    if (!visible || visible.payloadObserved !== true) return { status: 'unverified', reason: 'no-visible-payload' }
+    const currentPromptCount = Number(state.promptCount || 0)
+    const observedPromptCount = Number(visible.observedPromptCount || 0)
+    if (!observedPromptCount || observedPromptCount !== currentPromptCount) {
+      visible.sampleFreshness = 'stale'
+      visible.staleReason = 'prompt-count-mismatch'
+      return {
+        status: 'stale',
+        reason: 'prompt-count-mismatch',
+        observedPromptCount,
+        currentPromptCount
+      }
+    }
+    visible.sampleFreshness = 'current'
+    visible.staleReason = ''
+    return { status: 'current', reason: '' }
+  }
+
   function getPrecheckEvidenceStatus(state) {
+    const freshness = getVisibleReplyFreshness(state)
+    if (freshness.status === 'stale') return 'unverified'
     if (state.visible?.precheck) return 'verified-present'
     if (state.visible?.precheckStatus === 'verified-missing') return 'verified-missing'
     if (state.visible?.payloadObserved) return 'verified-missing'
@@ -488,7 +533,11 @@ function buildLifecycleVisibleReplyUtils(ctx) {
         items.push('entry check block 未输出（S07/C18：首条用户可见回复必须含 PC0~PC10 入口检查块）')
       }
     } else if (eventName === 'Stop' && precheckStatus === 'unverified') {
-      items.push(`无法验证最终用户可见回复是否包含入口检查块（Stop/PreCompact 未提供可解析 assistant 内容；如需取证请创建 ${getStatePaths(state).finalPayloadFlag} 后重试）`)
+      const freshness = getVisibleReplyFreshness(state)
+      const reason = freshness.status === 'stale'
+        ? `可见回复样本已过期（${freshness.reason}，observedPromptCount=${freshness.observedPromptCount || 0}, currentPromptCount=${freshness.currentPromptCount || 0}）`
+        : `Stop/PreCompact 未提供可解析 assistant 内容；如需取证请创建 ${getStatePaths(state).finalPayloadFlag} 后重试`
+      items.push(`无法验证最终用户可见回复是否包含入口检查块（${reason}）`)
     }
     settleS07OrderStatus(state, eventName)
     if (eventName === 'Stop' && state.visible?.s07OrderStatus === 'late') {
@@ -573,6 +622,7 @@ function buildLifecycleVisibleReplyUtils(ctx) {
     analyzeEntryCheckCompleteness,
     updateVisibleReplyState,
     captureFinalPayloadSample,
+    getVisibleReplyFreshness,
     getPrecheckEvidenceStatus,
     settleS07OrderStatus,
     buildClosureReminder,

mcp/memory-server.js

@@ -116,6 +116,7 @@ const {
 const {
   currentActiveSessionIds,
   rowsByCurrentState,
+  summarizeSummaryCurrentProjection,
   summaryStateConflicts
 } = require('../scripts/lib/memory-summary-state.js')
 const {
@@ -3107,6 +3108,7 @@ function handleMemoryStatus(args) {
         latestRows: indexed.latestRows,
         activeSessionIds,
         conflicts,
+        summaryCurrentProjection: indexed.summaryCurrentProjection || null,
         warnings: [...boundWarnings, ...indexed.warnings].slice(0, 20),
         indexReceipt: indexed.envelope.receipt,
         coverage: indexed.envelope.coverage,
@@ -3154,6 +3156,7 @@ function handleMemoryStatus(args) {
       latestRows,
       activeSessionIds,
       conflicts,
+      summaryCurrentProjection: summarizeSummaryCurrentProjection(parsed.rows),
       warnings: [...boundWarnings, ...parsed.warnings].slice(0, 20),
       indexReceipt: memoryIndexFallbackReceipt('summary', indexed),
       coverage: {

package.json

@@ -13,10 +13,13 @@
     "global-adapters:remove": "node index.js global-adapters remove --apply",
     "global-adapters:remove:dry-run": "node index.js global-adapters remove --dry-run",
     "test:global-adapters-cli": "node scripts/test-global-adapters-cli.js",
-    "test": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route changed --actor human-cli --plan",
-    "test:fast": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route fast --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test": "npm run test:changed",
+    "test:plan": "npm run test:changed:plan",
+    "test:fast": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route fast",
+    "test:fast:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route fast --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:fast:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route fast --actor ai-hook",
-    "test:full": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route full --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test:full": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route full",
+    "test:full:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route full --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:full:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route full --actor ai-hook",
     "test:all": "npm run test:full",
     "test:core": "node scripts/validate-versions.js && node scripts/validate.js",
@@ -152,15 +155,20 @@
     "test:ci-validation-plan": "node scripts/test-ci-validation-plan.js",
     "test:validation-authority": "node scripts/test-validation-execution-authority.js && node scripts/test-validation-budget-control.js && node scripts/test-validation-convergence.js",
     "test:artifact-authority": "node scripts/test-artifact-mutation-authority.js && npm run test:artifact-slot-template-coverage",
-    "test:changed": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route changed --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test:changed": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route changed",
+    "test:changed:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route changed --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:changed:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route changed --actor ai-hook",
-    "test:delivery": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route delivery --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test:delivery": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route delivery",
+    "test:delivery:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route delivery --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:delivery:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route delivery --actor ai-hook",
-    "test:boundary": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route boundary --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test:boundary": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route boundary",
+    "test:boundary:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route boundary --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:boundary:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route boundary --actor ai-hook",
-    "test:profile-deploy": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route profile-deploy --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test:profile-deploy": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route profile-deploy",
+    "test:profile-deploy:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route profile-deploy --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:profile-deploy:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route profile-deploy --actor ai-hook",
-    "test:package-release": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route package-release --actor human-cli --plan",
+    "test:package-release": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route package-release",
+    "test:package-release:plan": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route package-release --actor human-cli --plan",
     "test:package-release:ai": "node scripts/run-validation.js --route package-release --actor ai-hook",
     "test:control-plane-module-contracts": "node scripts/test-control-plane-module-contracts.js",
     "test:closure-evidence": "node scripts/test-closure-evidence-controls.js",

scripts/lib/memory-index.js

@@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ const {
   foldSummaryRows,
   isCurrentProjectableRow,
   rowsByCurrentState,
+  summarizeSummaryCurrentProjection,
   summaryStateConflicts
 } = require('./memory-summary-state.js')
 
@@ -168,6 +169,7 @@ function buildSummaryPartitions(document, parsed) {
     nonCanonicalActiveCount: foldSummaryRows(rows).filter(row =>
       row.state === 'active' && !isCurrentProjectableRow(row)
     ).length,
+    summaryCurrentProjection: summarizeSummaryCurrentProjection(rows),
     warnings
   }
   const months = new Map()
@@ -496,6 +498,7 @@ function queryStatusIndex(input = {}) {
       activeSessionIds: payload.activeSessionIds,
       conflicts: payload.conflicts,
       nonCanonicalActiveCount: payload.nonCanonicalActiveCount,
+      summaryCurrentProjection: payload.summaryCurrentProjection,
       warnings: payload.warnings,
       envelope: buildQueryEnvelope({
         status: 'fresh',

scripts/lib/memory-summary-state.js

@@ -71,11 +71,33 @@ function currentActiveSessionIds(rows = []) {
     .map(row => summarySessionKey(row))
 }
 
+function summarizeSummaryCurrentProjection(rows = []) {
+  const sourceRows = Array.isArray(rows) ? rows : []
+  const projectableRows = sourceRows.filter(isCurrentProjectableRow)
+  const currentRows = foldSummaryRows(projectableRows)
+  const projectableActiveRows = projectableRows.filter(row => row.state === 'active')
+  const currentActiveRows = currentRows.filter(row => row.state === 'active')
+  const nonCanonicalActiveRows = sourceRows.filter(row => row.state === 'active' && !isCurrentProjectableRow(row))
+  return {
+    schemaVersion: 'MemorySummaryCurrentProjectionStatsV1',
+    semantics: 'append-only SUMMARY history; current projection is the last canonical row per day/session',
+    sourceRowCount: sourceRows.length,
+    projectableRowCount: projectableRows.length,
+    currentRowCount: currentRows.length,
+    historicalProjectableRowCount: Math.max(0, projectableRows.length - currentRows.length),
+    rawActiveRowCount: sourceRows.filter(row => row.state === 'active').length,
+    currentActiveRowCount: currentActiveRows.length,
+    historicalActiveRowCount: Math.max(0, projectableActiveRows.length - currentActiveRows.length),
+    nonCanonicalActiveRowCount: nonCanonicalActiveRows.length
+  }
+}
+
 module.exports = {
   currentActiveSessionIds,
   foldSummaryRows,
   isCurrentProjectableRow,
   rowsByCurrentState,
+  summarizeSummaryCurrentProjection,
   summarySessionKey,
   summaryStateConflicts
 }

scripts/lib/probe-registry.js

@@ -86,11 +86,15 @@ function createProbeRegistry(groups, { expectedIds = null } = {}) {
   return Object.freeze(ordered)
 }
 
-function runProbeRegistry(registry, { afterRun = null } = {}) {
+function runProbeRegistry(registry, { beforeRun = null, afterRun = null } = {}) {
+  if (beforeRun !== null && typeof beforeRun !== 'function') {
+    throw new TypeError('beforeRun must be a function')
+  }
   if (afterRun !== null && typeof afterRun !== 'function') {
     throw new TypeError('afterRun must be a function')
   }
   for (const descriptor of registry) {
+    if (beforeRun) beforeRun(descriptor)
     descriptor.run()
     if (afterRun) afterRun(descriptor)
   }