Skip to content

u2: profile view refresh (unit 2 of the 1921 split) - 505 priced lines against unit 1 - #73

Open
easonLiangWorldedtech wants to merge 3 commits into
vps2/1921-u1-view-state-corefrom
vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh
Open

easonLiangWorldedtech wants to merge 3 commits into
vps2/1921-u1-view-state-corefrom
vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh

Conversation

@easonLiangWorldedtech

@easonLiangWorldedtech easonLiangWorldedtech commented Nov 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

1921 unit 2/8 - refresh the profile view after an external settings write

Stacked on unit 1 (vps2/1921-u1-view-state-core), so this is one reviewable
increment on top of it, not a slice of Zoo-Code-Org#1921 cut against main.

What this unit carries

Unit 2's assigned hunks of Zoo-Code-Org#1921 in src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts: the
external-write refresh path and its helper methods, plus the view-state helpers
this unit's code reads.

Two carrier notes, both stated for the lead's review rather than asserted as
settled:

  • The ProfileDeletionActivationError re-export that this unit used to carry is
    gone from this head. The module, its import and its re-export now live in unit
    3, which is the unit whose code throws it, so unit 2 no longer re-exports a
    module that is absent from its own tree. That was the shape knip reported when
    the file sat one unit earlier with no reader.
  • Unit 2's own cut had left the file ending in a blank line, and prettier --check reports that blank line at a unit 2 head. It is not a test(webview): ClineProvider parallelMode suite with viewStates pruning edges Zoo-Code-Org/Zoo-Code#1921 content
    line: test(webview): ClineProvider parallelMode suite with viewStates pruning edges Zoo-Code-Org/Zoo-Code#1921's own blob for this path, unit 1's blob here, and main's blob all
    end the file at the closing brace with one newline. The blank line was an
    artifact of where the cut landed, so it was removed; no content line moved.
    This means unit 2's formatting verdict did not clear merely through unit 1 -
    unit 1's dangling signature is repaired in unit 1, and this line was repaired
    here. Both are stated so the verdict is reproducible rather than inherited.

Verification at this head (f3e81f6)

Taken against this head, not inherited from unit 1:

  • pnpm exec prettier --check . - exit 0
  • pnpm --dir src exec eslint --max-warnings=0 on the touched path - exit 0, no problem rows
  • pnpm --dir packages/types run check-types - exit 0; pnpm --dir src run check-types - exit 0
  • src/eslint-suppressions.json is byte-identical to the blob at the parent
    (ae3d504003d7), so no suppression count moved
    All legs ran under node v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1, this box's interpreter; the src
    check-types leg prints Unsupported engine: wanted {"node":"22.23.4"} beside
    the direct legs, so that leg is a node-25 reading and not the CI interpreter's.
  • The fork runs no checks, so this unit has no CI mutation run; the mutation
    measurement for this delta is owed to unit 2's own org PR when the chain lands.

Size, against parent 71cfcf3 (unit 1)

Measured with the shipped instrument (scripts/stryker-diff.mjs: parseChangedLines
per file over git diff -U0 -M <base>...<head> -- <path>, then executableChangedLines
on the head blob, grouped by packageForPath):

package file executable changed lines selectors
extension src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts 507 127
extension total 507 127

The size ask rides with this delta: 507 executable changed lines against a 500-line
cap is over by 7, exactly as it was
before this round's carrier work, which is the expected result - removing one
re-export line and one blank line from the delta does not change the
executable-line count, because neither line was counted as executable.

Superseded figures for this unit, all retired by the measurement above: 507 with
margin -7 taken on the previous head (509 with margin -9, and the 505/-5 chain
before it) and 556 with 11 ranges for the unit below it. The 507 published here
was re-taken against the new parent named above, which is a different base from
the earlier 507's, and it came out the same.

A content push after a review row exists costs a re-approval - the dated rulesets
REST read of 2026-11-10 reports dismiss_stale_reviews_on_push true with
required_approving_review_count 1 and current_user_can_bypass never - so this
unit's content is finished before any review is invited, and review-state reads here
are keyed to the head they were read against. The landing mechanism is the merge
queue in the same dated read: SQUASH, ALLGREEN grouping, at most 5 entries, a 60-minute
check timeout, over a ruleset that has not moved since before unit pricing
(created 2026-04-24, updated 2026-05-24). That is the measured reason merge order is
declared rather than assumed.

Merge order: unit 1, then this unit, then unit 3. A unit cannot precede unit 1 in
a chain whose whole purpose is one reviewable increment at a time.

Repriced at head cc15812 (supersedes the 507/127 figure at 71cfcf3)

Two whole donor statements left this unit for unit 3 so the delta clears the 500
changed-executable-line cap: the late-commit re-post in enqueueProviderProfileMutation's
queue-advance callback (Zoo-Code-Org#1921 lines 489-502) and the shared-provider-settings restore
try/catch inside _restoreProfileActivationState (Zoo-Code-Org#1921 lines 3125-3131). Both spans are
complete statements, each appears once in Zoo-Code-Org#1921 and once in unit 3, and neither strands a
declaration - callerTimedOut is still read by the timeout callback that stays, and the
snapshot the moved restore read is still read by the three restores that stay.

Measurement Base named Instrument Result
changed executable lines / selector ranges, this head unit 1 6e3cfda3f75b shipped scripts/stryker-diff.mjs (parseChangedLines per file over git diff -U0 -M, executableChangedLines, packageForPath, toRanges) extension 500 lines / 136 ranges
same, superseded head 71cfcf331411 unit 1 71cfcf331411 same extension 507 lines / 127 ranges

The two figures do not differ by the 23 lines that left the file: deleting lines mid-file
shifts git's hunk alignment and re-admits identical comment lines elsewhere into the
changed-line set, so the instrument moved 507 to 500 rather than to 484. The cap in the
script is > 500, so exactly 500 passes and the margin here is zero: the figure is a
statement about this commit against this base, not about the file in general.

Both legs ran under node v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1; pnpm --dir src run check-types prints
Unsupported engine: wanted {"node":"22.23.4"} beside it, so those legs are node-25
readings and not the CI interpreter's.

One thing this round measured that the earlier rounds did not: main's own webview specs are
red at this head for reasons that predate the move and are unchanged by it. Running
vitest run over ClineProvider.spec.ts, ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts and
ClineProvider.sticky-profile.spec.ts gives 4 failed / 377 passed at f3e81f6c01a2 (the
pre-move head) and the same 4 at this head, with no new failure. Zoo-Code-Org#1921 rewrites those three
spec files (+7,564/-80, +740/-71 and +356 against main) and this unit carries main's
versions, so four assertions that Zoo-Code-Org#1921 had already updated are still asserting the old
behaviour against production that this unit changed. The fix is to carry Zoo-Code-Org#1921's versions of
those spec blocks in the unit that changes the behaviour, which costs nothing against the
cap because EXCLUDED_PATH_SEGMENTS (scripts/stryker-diff.mjs:76) prices no __tests__
path at all; that is a content decision for the lead and is recorded here rather than taken
unilaterally.

Round U61: spec carrier, head eb30971 (supersedes cc15812)

This unit now carries Zoo-Code-Org#1921's versions of the four webview spec assertions its production change
invalidates: three tests in src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.spec.ts ("saves mode config
when updating API configuration", "handles successful upsertApiConfiguration", "handles
buildApiHandler error in updateApiConfiguration") and the Mode switch failure scenarios describe
block in src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts. At cc15812 the three
inherited spec files reported 4 failed / 377 passed (381 total). At this head the same three files
report 3 passed (3) files and 380 passed / 380 tests
(verify23_u2v9_vitest_webview.log, 2,264 B, sha256 prefix 0e2cc32a02). The total drops by one
test because Zoo-Code-Org#1921 states the mode-switch failure scenarios in 74 lines where main used 140; every
one of the four previously failing names runs and passes here.

src/eslint-suppressions.json moved with the carrier, downward only:
core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts @typescript-eslint/no-explicit-any
27 -> 26 (blob ae3d504003d7 -> 9582b5032e69,
committed prettier-formatted (eslint's own writer emits it unformatted);
prettier --check . is 0 at this head, and eslint without --prune-suppressions also exits 0
against those counts).

Re-measured at this head against parent 6e3cfda3f75b6d4fdeeb4d534f6c35dab6926308 with the shipped
instrument scripts/stryker-diff.mjs (MAX_CHANGED_LINES = 500 at line 11; the cap fires on >, so
500 passes and 501 does not):

package file executable changed lines selectors
extension src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts 500 136
extension total 500 136

Margin 0 against the 500-line cap, taken against this parent. The carrier touched only two
__tests__ paths and a .json, none of which the instrument prices - SOURCE_EXTENSIONS (line 75)
lists .js/.jsx/.mjs/.cjs/.ts/.tsx and EXCLUDED_PATH_SEGMENTS (line 76) returns no package for any
__tests__ path - which is why the figure did not move; it is printed because it was re-measured,
not because it was predicted.

Mutants: none published for this head. Local related-test discovery cannot start (see unit 3's
section for the spawn failure and the install that did not change it), so this branch claims
nothing for or against the 400-mutant cap (MAX_MUTANTS, line 12).

Gates at this head, all taken against it: prettier --check . 0; eslint --max-warnings=0 on
ClineProvider.ts and both carried specs 0, and 0 again with --prune-suppressions
(verify23_u2v9_eslint.log, verify23_u2v9_eslint_prune.log); check-types in src 0 and in
packages/types 0; knip --treat-config-hints-as-errors 0. Every leg in this set ran under node
v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1, and the check-types legs print Unsupported engine: wanted {"node":"22.23.4"} beside them, so they are node-25 readings rather than node-22 readings.

Round U65: the pairing repair, head 36498f1 (supersedes eb30971)

Read moments are UTC. Each one is either the modification time of the log file named beside
the reading or the moment a program printed, and each figure comes from the program that
produced the artifact named beside it.

What this round adds

One commit: 36498f188369cfb5137a4b393b410ad37aa74b4f (tree
4ed1650fc54f66ca8f2d7a0482a10f73ea94ef07, parent eb30971aa119eef689f78979f6991d5692db936b,
committer date 2026-11-11T08:56:49+08:00), titled
test(webview): carry the spec revision that describes the moved write.

git diff --name-only HEAD^..HEAD names exactly one path, and its numstat is 77 added /
12 deleted: src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.apiHandlerRebuild.spec.ts
(_scratch/u65/delta_totals.log, 627 B, sha256 prefix 556d56f6f3eb888c, read
2026-11-11T01:27:18Z, row unit2_added_commit). The blob at the head is
809e0b9de94c21591af1666d37cd0f6c4eb8dd4c (43,727 B, 34 it( blocks, 39 vitest tests);
the blob it replaces is the one main carries, c2aec90dcd85e02260b0427d15b1bad6ad97cd98
(40,685 B, 33 it( blocks, 38 tests).

Spec-path-only was proved with the gate's own counter rather than by reading the
instrument's exclusion list. A byte-identical copy of the shipped instrument (28,202 B,
831 content lines, sha256 prefix 96f48df9cd0fb9b5, git diff HEAD empty against the
revision it was copied from) was run over exactly this commit and printed, at
2026-11-11T00:57:41Z, exit 0 in 0.3 s:

No changed executable lines in mutation-tested packages; mutation testing is not applicable.

(gate29_u2spec_only_counter.log, 94 B.)

Why the revision had to be carried here, and what was red

The suite is green where its blob lives on main's line: Tests 38 passed (38), 1 file, at
org main (spec28_main_apihandler.log, 1,917 B, 2026-11-11T00:19:03Z) and at unit 1
(spec28_u1_apihandler.log, 1,919 B, 2026-11-11T00:35:06Z). At this unit's previous head
eb30971aa119 the same file reported 5 failed | 33 passed (38)
(spec28_u2_apihandler.log, 8,083 B, 2026-11-11T00:34:59Z). Nothing in this unit's
production change was wrong: the suite was asserting the shape of the write before this
unit moved it. That is a pairing defect in this unit - production moved ahead of the spec
revision that describes it - and this PR did not say so. It is disclosed here because the
fork runs no checks on this PR, so no reviewer could see it from a status.

Provenance of the carried revision: it is held by the merge commit 49a030915cbf
(2026-11-01T07:20:27Z) and by no other reachable commit in this checkout. Neither of that
merge's parents holds it: 6390402ee6a1 holds 01701e662a96 and 70eba96cab53 holds
main's c2aec90dcd85. The 16-commit lineage of this path on main returns main's own tip
blob, so the revision is not reachable from main for this path. It comes from the donor
lineage the plan routes Zoo-Code-Org#1921 through, and it is green where the donor carries it:
Tests 39 passed (39) at 1921's own tip (spec28_donortip_apihandler.log, 1,920 B,
2026-11-11T00:29:33Z; spec28_u3_donorspec.log, 1,919 B, 2026-11-11T00:35:13Z).

Gate set and readings at head 36498f1

All legs ran in the unit 2 worktree at this head under node v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1, which
is this box's only interpreter: node 22 does not exist here, so every figure below is a
node-25 reading and not the CI interpreter's. The verification set now includes every suite
the mutation stage discovers for the packages a unit changes; at this head that discovery
report ran 246 suites and 1,211 tests with 0 failing suites
(_scratch/u65-mut-reports/u2/extension/vitest-related.json, 444,866 B, sha256 prefix
37e668ae1c26dd23, read 2026-11-11T01:23:51Z). An earlier revision of this body said "44 suites",
which was that report's top-level testResults entry count rather than its
numTotalTestSuites; comment 6784647927 on this PR records the correction with both
fields side by side, and it also carries the priced classification of the 12 changed-line gaps
below (8,477 B, sha256 prefix 687e9a6ff9deb3d2, posted 2026-11-11T01:52:08Z).

  • ClineProvider.apiHandlerRebuild.spec.ts at the carried revision: Test Files 1 passed (1), Tests 39 passed (39), exit 0, 4.85 s (gate29_u2_apihandler.log, 1,845 B,
    2026-11-11T00:57:47Z). The five failures at the previous head are gone.
  • The three webview specs that read 380 of 380 at unit 1 (ClineProvider.spec.ts,
    ClineProvider.sticky-profile.spec.ts, ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts): unchanged
    here, Test Files 3 passed (3), Tests 380 passed (380), exit 0, 8.88 s
    (gate29_u2_webview_three.log, 2,190 B, 2026-11-11T00:57:57Z).
  • eslint --max-warnings=0 --prune-suppressions over the paths this unit touches: exit 0,
    no problem rows (gate29_u2_eslint_prune.log, 477 B, 2026-11-11T00:57:58Z). The carried
    file's @typescript-eslint/no-explicit-any suppression count stays 34 and prune proposed
    no reduction for it. Prune also rewrote entries for files outside the narrow list it was
    launched with; that rewrite was discarded with git checkout -- so the commit stays
    spec-path-only. No suppression count rose.
  • prettier --check on the changed file: All matched files use Prettier code style!,
    exit 0 (gate29_u2_prettier_file.log, 545 B, 2026-11-11T00:58:06Z).
  • pnpm --dir src run check-types: exit 0 with 0 error TS lines
    (gate29_u2_checktypes_src.log, 699 B, 2026-11-11T00:58:07Z), printed beside the
    Unsupported engine: wanted {"node":"22.23.4"} (current: {"node":"v25.9.0","pnpm":"10.8.1"})
    warning.
  • knip --treat-config-hints-as-errors: exit 0 (gate29_u2_knip.log, 477 B,
    2026-11-11T00:58:16Z).

Size against unit 1, unchanged, and mutation now measured on this delta

Re-priced at this head against unit 1 6e3cfda3f75b6d4fdeeb4d534f6c35dab6926308, the
instrument printed at 2026-11-11T01:23:51Z:

Mutation-testing 1 package(s) from merge base 6e3cfda3f75b: extension (500 lines)

(_scratch/u65/mut_u2.log, 2,590 B, sha256 prefix e5f5f5bdd3c6baf7). 500 executable changed
lines against a 500-line cap is margin 0, exactly the figure at eb30971aa119: the file
added this round is a test path, and the counter adds nothing for it - the same fact the
not-applicable line states for that commit taken alone. Added-row measure for the whole
delta against unit 1 at this head: 1,054 added / 285 deleted over 5 files
(_scratch/u65/delta_totals.log, row unit2_vs_unit1).

The mutation stage now completes on this delta, where at the previous head it stopped
before executing a mutant. It instrumented 1 file with 378 mutants and ran them: 99 killed,
154 survived, 125 no-coverage, 0 timeouts, tallied over the whole report
(_scratch/u65-mut-reports/u2/extension/mutation.json, 1,287,351 B, sha256 prefix
3239187a03295b03, read 2026-11-11T01:23:51Z). The report is a whole-report tally, not the
changed-line subset the CI annotation prints; on changed lines the run printed 7 advisories that together name 12 gaps, all on
src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts at lines 262 (2 gaps), 274, 279 (2), 280 (4), 281, 282
and 284. An advisory that covers several gaps prints only one example mutant; the examples
printed by this run are 6 survived mutants and 1 no-coverage mutant
(_scratch/u65/mut_u2.log, 2,590 B, sha256 prefix e5f5f5bdd3c6baf7). A survivor here means a mutant on a changed line that no test
in the discovered set distinguished from the original; a no-coverage entry means the mutant
was never reached, which says nothing about whether a test exists elsewhere.

The run used a copy of the shipped instrument with two measurement-only deviations, both
needed only because this box has no node 22 and no POSIX binaries: shell: true at the two
spawn sites (the extension-less .bin shims are ENOENT for a shell-less spawn here) and
tolerance of a non-zero related-test discovery exit when the report it wrote lists usable
suites. The copy is 29,271 B, 849 lines, sha256 prefix e50d61cb1c5b8ead, and it is the
instrument plus exactly those two patches, proved by reverse reconstruction: deleting the
two shell: true lines and restoring the five-line discovery block yields a file
byte-identical to the instrument (28,202 B, sha256 prefix 96f48df9cd0fb9b5). Neither
deviation changes which mutants are instrumented or counted, and both are inert on ubuntu
with node 22, where the gate actually runs.

Push

Pushed from the unit 2 worktree with hooks enabled and no --no-verify, under
--force-with-lease=refs/heads/vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh:eb30971aa119... where the
expected value was taken from git ls-remote inside the same run as the push. Proof is by
read-back, not by exit code: git ls-remote origin returns
36498f188369cfb5137a4b393b410ad37aa74b4f refs/heads/vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh,
equal to the local head, and the same read at 2026-11-11T01:27:29Z confirms it again
(_scratch/u65/main_read.log, 491 B, sha256 prefix f882f58f3849670e). The pre-push hook ran
the repository check-types legs and printed the node-25 engine warning beside them
(_scratch/u65/push_u2.log). The worktree was left attached to u59-u2 with an empty
porcelain.

Update 2026-11-11T02:40Z: this unit's new head, the gap tests, and the mutation re-run

New head, and what changed in it

4d0bb6feea5ebd9fc3de6e854684bc8eaede4181 (tree ff6d86c628f2f9bf88e3adc0d5af267b0455f77c),
parent c2ed51f8484cbd8781e924fc73a7c69e65247354 - unit 1's new head, which carries the
profile-reader tests the reviewer asked for on Zoo-Code-Org#2416. The production commit this unit carries
is unchanged in content; the only thing this unit added is a test file.

diff added deleted files
unit 2's test commit alone 82 0 1
unit 2 over unit 1 1054 285 5

The claim-helper mutation gaps are closed, measured mutant by mutant

The mutation stage was re-run over this unit's own delta - base c2ed51f8484c, head
4d0bb6feea - by a lane copy of the in-tree instrument blob
7dfe0006d2d5c7e4d2282f65f68b8ed5f16866bc, the revision sitting at org main 53cb5b5e7c80 and
at every unit head, i.e. the revision CI runs. The copy was verified by reverse reconstruction:
removing its Windows-only deviation hunks reproduces the source blob byte for byte (31,176 B
copy against 30,108 B source, 3 hunks archived). It printed

Mutation-testing 1 package(s) from merge base c2ed51f: extension (500 lines)

identical to the figure printed before the tests existed, because the test commit adds 0 counted
executable lines - the gate's own counter sees no change.

Inventory: 378 valid mutants (same 378 locations as the earlier run, matched by position and
mutation text), 128 killed, 0 timeout, 145 survived, 105 no coverage. The advisory summary
lists 250 surviving or uncovered mutants on 145 lines, earliest 323, latest 3862. None of them
sits in the claim-helper block this unit adds.

Every one of the thirteen mutants on lines 259-286 is now killed. The report's own killedBy
field names one test per mutant, so a mutant covered by several tests is credited to the first
one that killed it:

line mutator -> replacement before now named killer
262 ArithmeticOperator -> (profileCreateClaims.get(name) ?? 0) - 1 Survived Killed T1
262 LogicalOperator -> profileCreateClaims.get(name) && 0 Survived Killed T1
274 CallExpression -> ; (the succeeded-mark) Survived Killed T4
279 ArithmeticOperator -> (profileCreateClaims.get(name) ?? 1) + 1 Survived Killed T1
279 LogicalOperator -> profileCreateClaims.get(name) && 1 Survived Killed T1
280 ConditionalExpression -> true Survived Killed T1
280 ConditionalExpression -> false Survived Killed T1
280 EqualityOperator -> remaining < 0 Survived Killed T1
280 EqualityOperator -> remaining > 0 Survived Killed T1
281 CallExpression -> ; (the claim-map delete) Survived Killed T5
282 BooleanLiteral -> false (last-claimant answer) Survived Killed T1
284 CallExpression -> ; (writing the count back) NoCoverage Killed T1
285 BooleanLiteral -> true (not-last-claimant answer) NoCoverage Killed T1

The four tests, named as they appear in the spec file:

  • T1 keeps a created record when another view is still creating the same name - three
    concurrent claims, three restores, the create fails: nothing is deleted while a claimant is
    still in flight, and exactly one delete runs when the last one leaves.
  • T2 deletes the record a lone failed create made - one claim, one failed create, one restore:
    one delete.
  • T4 keeps the record a concurrent successful save of the same name wrote - a claim that
    survives a sibling create that succeeds: the record is saved, and the compensating delete does
    not run.
  • T5 deletes again when the next create of the same name fails - two failed create cycles in
    a row: two deletes, which is what proves the claim map is cleared between cycles.

T2 never appears as a named killer: its assertions overlap T1's on the delete branch, so it
covers those mutants without being the first to kill them. That is stated rather than counted
as a kill. The test the plan listed as T3 (a claim left behind by a thrown create does not pin the name) was not authored: its two predicted deaths, line 274 and line 282, were taken by
T4 and T1, and its claim-leak sentence is expressed more cheaply by T5's second cycle.

The earlier run's note on line 281 - that the mutant there might be equivalent, because a
leftover zero count is indistinguishable from an absent one - is falsified by this run: T5's
second cycle kills it. It was a prediction, and it was wrong.

Where the other mutant moves came from

Package tallies moved from 99 killed / 154 survived / 125 uncovered to 128 / 145 / 105 between
the two instrument revisions. All 42 status changes are attributed by the report's own fields:

  • 29 mutants moved to Killed and every one names core/webview/__tests__/ ClineProvider.apiHandlerRebuild.spec.ts as its killer: 13 in the claim-helper block, and 16
    on the snapshot, restore and persist paths this unit also adds (lines 3081, 3083, 3090, 3091,
    3106, 3150, 3155, 3159, 3490). That spec file was selected by both instrument revisions, so
    these are the new tests, not the new revision.
  • 9 mutants moved from uncovered to covered-but-surviving and are covered by the same spec file
    (lines 3463, 3469, 3480): coverage without a kill, recorded as such.
  • 4 mutants moved from uncovered to covered-but-surviving via
    __tests__/removeClineFromStack-delegation.spec.ts, which the CI-revision instrument selects
    and the older revision did not. That is the revision's doing, not this unit's.
  • No mutant that was killed before lost its kill: 99 stayed killed.

The CI-revision instrument selects 44 related spec files for this delta where the older
9742879106-lineage copy selected 12, a strict superset. Package-level kill rates therefore are
not comparable across revisions, and the figures above are labelled with the revision that
printed them. The earlier tallies published on this PR came from the older revision.

Gate legs on the new head

  • vitest run core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.apiHandlerRebuild.spec.ts - Test Files 1 passed (1), Tests 43 passed (43); it was 39 before the four tests were added.
  • eslint --max-warnings=0 on the touched spec paths exits 0. The commit touches only spec
    paths, and src/eslint-suppressions.json is untouched by it; a --prune-suppressions probe
    proposed no count reduction, and the two probe runs that reformatted the file were reverted,
    leaving 2867 suppressed findings across 265 keys before and after.
  • pnpm --dir src run check-types reports Tasks: 12 successful, 12 total.
  • The counter figure quoted above, re-printed by the CI-revision instrument, is unchanged at
    500 of 500 counted executable lines: zero margin, and no line of it comes from the tests.

The review-budget and gate figures for this unit's test commit are 82 added rows and 0 deleted
against a 400-row review budget, and 0 counted executable lines against the gate's 500.

@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh branch 3 times, most recently from 3c9a408 to f3e81f6 Compare November 10, 2026 20:48
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u1-view-state-core branch from 71cfcf3 to 6e3cfda Compare November 10, 2026 22:06
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh branch 2 times, most recently from cc15812 to eb30971 Compare November 10, 2026 23:06
@easonLiangWorldedtech

easonLiangWorldedtech commented Nov 11, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Unit 2's 12 changed-line mutation gaps: added or inherited, what would kill each, and what each costs

Unit 2 at 36498f188369cfb5137a4b393b410ad37aa74b4f against merge base
6e3cfda3f75b6d4fdeeb4d534f6c35dab6926308. Run read 2026-11-11T01:23:51Z
(_scratch/u65/mut_u2.log, 2,590 B, sha256 prefix e5f5f5bdd3c6baf7), whole report
_scratch/u65-mut-reports/u2/extension/mutation.json (1,287,351 B, prefix 3239187a03295b03),
interpreter node v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1 (no node 22 on this box). The CI annotation aggregates
7 advisories covering 12 changed-line gaps; the 12 are enumerated below from the report itself,
so this list is the annotation's subset and not the whole-run tally (that is 99 killed, 154
survived, 125 no-coverage over 378 mutants).

Which side of the delta each mutated line sits on

git diff -U0 6e3cfda3f75b..36498f188369 -- src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts (captured in
_scratch/u66/u2_delta_u0.diff, 63,920 B) yields 89 hunks and 943 head-side added lines. All
seven advisory lines - 262, 274, 279, 280, 281, 282, 284 - fall inside those added ranges. So on
this delta every gap is on a line the unit adds; none is inherited. The whole block is unit 2's
create-claim bookkeeping: claimProfileCreate (line 261), profileCreatesSucceeded (270),
markProfileCreateSucceeded (273), releaseProfileCreate (278), consumed at lines 3090,
3154-3158 and 3490-3492, where only the last claimant may act and a create that already succeeded
spares the record.

The 12 gaps

mutant line mutator -> replacement status coverage
1 262 ArithmeticOperator -> (profileCreateClaims.get(name) ?? 0) - 1 Survived 4 tests
2 262 LogicalOperator -> profileCreateClaims.get(name) && 0 Survived 4 tests
3 274 CallExpression -> no call (statement removed) Survived 4 tests
4 279 ArithmeticOperator -> (profileCreateClaims.get(name) ?? 1) + 1 Survived 4 tests
5 279 LogicalOperator -> profileCreateClaims.get(name) && 1 Survived 4 tests
6 280 ConditionalExpression -> true Survived 4 tests
7 280 ConditionalExpression -> false Survived 4 tests
8 280 EqualityOperator -> remaining < 0 Survived 4 tests
9 280 EqualityOperator -> remaining > 0 Survived 4 tests
10 281 CallExpression -> no call (profileCreateClaims.delete(name) removed) Survived 4 tests
11 282 BooleanLiteral -> false (return true in the last-claimant branch) Survived 4 tests
12 284 CallExpression -> no call (profileCreateClaims.set(name, remaining) removed) NoCoverage none

The four covering tests are, by name: "ClineProvider prompt cache TTL round trip a saved 1h
survives a fresh ..." and its two siblings in src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.spec.ts,
plus "ClineProvider - Sticky Mode Error handling should restore API configur..." in
src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts. They reach these helpers on the
way through the message path and assert nothing about claim counts. No test in the repository
mentions claimProfileCreate, releaseProfileCreate, markProfileCreateSucceeded or
profileCreatesSucceeded: a content search over src/**/*.ts returned no matches. That is
also why mutant 12 has no coverage at all - no test drives two creates of the same name
concurrently, so the remaining > 0 write-back at line 284 is never executed.

Five tests that would close all twelve, and their price

Counted lines are what the gate measures, and every one of these files is excluded by the shipped
instrument: the segment list ["/__mocks__/", "/__tests__/", "/fixtures/", "/test-utils/"] is
line 76 and is applied at line 197, and the name-shape rules at lines 198-203 (a
*.test|spec|visual.*.ts pattern, .d.ts, vitest.config., vite.config.,
vitest.setup., test-utils.) catch the same files a second time. Per-package exact-name
exclusions are lines 53 and 64-69, applied at line 209. So each test below costs 0 counted lines
and unit 2's margin of 0 on its 500 counted lines is untouched. Added rows are a separate price
against the 400 added+deleted review budget, which unit 2 already exceeds at 1,054; those numbers
are my estimates of the tests I would write, priced against the file's own distribution (37 it(
blocks in 5,943 lines, median 21, mean 23, max 55), and they are estimates, not measurements.

test asserts kills added rows
T1 concurrent creates, same name start two creates for one name, fail the second while the first is still in flight, assert the record delete is not invoked 1, 2, 6, 9, 12 ~26
T2 lone failed create one create that fails must delete the record it staged 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11 ~16
T3 succeeded marker cleared after a create succeeds, a later failed create for the same name must delete rather than spare 3, 11 ~24
T4 successful sibling spares the record a failed create must not delete a record a successful sibling saved 3 ~22
T5 no claim leak across cycles after a failed create the next create cycle for the same name behaves as if unclaimed 10 ~20

Which test kills which mutant is a prediction from the mutated expression and the call sites, not
a measurement: measuring it means adding the tests and re-running the stage, and that re-run has
not been spent. Two gaps are killed by more than one test (9 and 11), and mutant 3 is listed under
both T3 and T4 because its removal makes the spare-the-record rule unenforceable from either
side. Killing 11 of 12 needs T1, T2 and T4 at least; 12 of 12 needs all five. The cheapest set
that empties this advisory list is therefore T1, T2, T4 for 64 added rows and 0 counted lines,
with T3 and T5 adding 44 more for the mutants they duplicate.

What this list does not say

It does not say the unit is wrong: all twelve gaps sit on lines unit 2 adds, which is what a
changed-line advisory is for. It does not count mutants outside these seven lines - 154 survived
and 125 no-coverage across the whole extension report, and a no-coverage entry says nothing about
tests elsewhere in the repository. And it prices only added rows and counted lines; it does not
price the reviewer's time. If a production change were preferred over tests here it would cost
counted lines against a margin of zero, so it would need either a compensating reduction inside
the same delta or a decision that the margin moves - that is an authorisation, not something I can
assume.

One figure from these runs that I had labelled wrong, corrected here

The related-test discovery report is vitest's JSON output and it carries two different numbers at
once. For unit 2's delta
(_scratch/u65-mut-reports/u2/extension/vitest-related.json, 444,866 B, prefix 37e668ae1c26dd23)
numTotalTestSuites is 246, numTotalTests is 1,211, numFailedTestSuites is 0, and the
top-level testResults array holds 44 entries. I quoted that last number as a suite count when
I wrote "44 suites and 1,211 assertions", so the published body on this PR carries a mislabel: the
discovery step ran 246 suites and 1,211 tests with no failures, and 44 is the number of
top-level result files in that report. For unit 3's delta the same fields read 246 suites,
1,211 tests, 0 failed
(_scratch/u65-mut-reports/u3/extension/vitest-related.json, 444,840 B, prefix c610cee56dc9d9a3).
For the delta re-run this round at unit 1 (6e3cfda3f75b over merge base 18861b2e3572, which
is also the merge base against today's main 53cb5b5e7c80) the fields read 646 suites, 3,129
tests, 0 failed, 120 top-level entries
(_scratch/u66-mut-reports/u1vsmain/extension/vitest-related.json, 1,121,564 B, prefix
02d0803fc92db3e6).

That also settles the oddity I recorded last round as owed work. I had written that discovery
"listed 246 suite entries before the repair and 44 after". It never changed: the pre-repair report
for the same delta (_scratch/u64-mut-reports/real2/extension/vitest-related.json, 453,021 B)
reads 246 suites, 1,210 tests, 5 failed suites and 44 top-level entries. Both numbers were in the
same file the whole time; I counted different fields on the two rounds. The difference between
deltas - 246 entries here against 646 at unit 1 - tracks how many suites are related to the files
each delta touches, which is what related-test scoping is for. No follow-up is owed on this.

Erratum, 2026-11-11T02:40Z: the cheapest gap-closing set costs 84 added rows, not 64

The section above states that the cheapest set that empties this unit's advisory list costs 64
added rows. That arithmetic was wrong. The kill sets published above are T1 -> {1, 2, 6, 9, 12}
(26 rows), T2 -> {4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11} (16), T3 -> {3, 11} (24), T4 -> {3} (22), T5 -> {10} (20).
T1 union T2 union T4 covers mutants {1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12} - eleven of the twelve.
Line 281 carries only mutant 10, and nothing in that union reaches line 281 with a state that
makes the deletion decision differ. Adding T5 empties the list, so the cheapest set that
empties it is T1 + T2 + T4 + T5 = 26 + 16 + 22 + 20 = 84 added rows.

T3 stays out of that figure honestly: its two predicted deaths are already covered by T4 and
T2's sets, so its 24 rows buy assertion text rather than mutant deaths, and it is judged on its
assertion text, not on a mutant count.

What the re-run actually measured

The four tests that landed (T1, T2, T4, T5) cost 82 added rows, measured as the numstat of
spec-path-only commit 4d0bb6feea5ebd9fc3de6e854684bc8eaede4181 against its parent - two rows
below the 84 estimate, in the same file.

Re-running the mutation stage over this unit's delta (base c2ed51f8484c, head 4d0bb6feea,
instrument blob 7dfe0006d2d5c7e4d2282f65f68b8ed5f16866bc, the revision CI runs) killed every
mutant in the block:

  • all twelve gaps listed above died, plus the line 285 mutant that the no-coverage column left
    unmentioned in this comment;
  • mutants 1-2, 4-9, 11-13 died to T1, mutant 3 to T4, mutant 10 to T5;
  • T2 co-covers its predicted set but is never the named killer, so its 16 rows are credited
    with coverage rather than kills;
  • the line 281 mutant, flagged above as possibly equivalent, was killed by T5: the equivalence
    guess was wrong, and the 84-row set is what empties the list by measurement, not only by
    arithmetic.

After the change no advisory row falls anywhere in lines 259-286. The delta's remaining 250
advisory mutants (145 survived, 105 uncovered, on 145 lines from 323 to 3862) sit on lines this
unit carried rather than authored, and are priced by the added-versus-inherited split above.

Erratum 2, 2026-11-11T02:56Z: "12 gaps" was the annotation view, not the advisory total

The gate's own summary lists every surviving or uncovered mutant on the delta's changed lines.
For unit 2 at its new head that is 250 mutants - 145 survived, 105 uncovered - spread over
145 lines, earliest 323 and latest 3862. At the previous head it was 279 (154 + 125). The GitHub
annotations CI emits are capped at 7 rows per file, and those 7 annotations named 12 mutants on
lines 262 to 284. That capped view is the number this comment and the round's plan quoted as
"unit 2's changed-line mutation gaps", and it understates the advisory total by 238 mutants.

Measured against the delta's own added-line ranges (git diff -U0 of unit 2 against unit 1's
head, intersected with the advisory table): all 250 advisory mutants sit on lines unit 2
adds - 250 introduced, 0 inherited.
The same measurement for unit 3 gives 319 introduced, 0
inherited
(301 uncovered and 16 surviving on ClineProvider.ts, plus two uncovered string
mutants at src/core/webview/profileDeletionError.ts:16 and :17), against 8 killed of 327.
A unit whose delta is almost entirely new lines has no inherited lines to attribute gaps to:
the added-versus-inherited split this comment opens with resolves to "added" for both units.

Two consequences, stated plainly:

  • the four tests and the 84-row set close the twelve gaps the annotations named. They do not
    empty the advisory list, and nothing in this round claimed otherwise: the gate blocks on
    counted executable lines, not on advisory findings, and CI's leg on unit 1's new head completed
    success with advisories present.
  • the remaining 250 advisory mutants on unit 2's delta are test debt this unit carries, on 145
    distinct lines, in a unit already priced at 500 of 500 counted executable lines. Paying it in
    this unit or deferring it to a later one is a split-plan decision for the maintainers; a spec
    commit cannot absorb it, because more tests in this unit's own spec files would not change the
    line price and more production lines would breach the cap.

@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh branch from 36498f1 to 4d0bb6f Compare November 11, 2026 02:19
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u1-view-state-core branch from c2ed51f to ebdbb5a Compare November 11, 2026 04:14
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh branch from 4d0bb6f to 41180cf Compare November 11, 2026 04:15
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u1-view-state-core branch from ebdbb5a to 5b542a4 Compare November 11, 2026 04:22
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh branch 3 times, most recently from d4c3f49 to 0293ef1 Compare November 11, 2026 08:23
…ndings that only unit 3 reads

The lead's eleventh ruling applied the carrier rule a third time on this unit's tree: the
import at 1921 head src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts:89 and the two local bindings at head
:4267 and :4277 travel to the unit that carries their only reads, which is unit 3. The uses
stay where they are and no reading statement moves.

Coordinates of the reads that motivated the move, all 1921 head line numbers inside unit 3's
hunks plus 3721,378 plus 4280,45 and plus 4330,27: the throw that consumes
ProfileDeletionActivationError at :4095; the reads of managerSelectionSnapshot at :4309,
:4321 and :4348; the reads of activationSnapshot at :4283, :4310, :4322, :4349 and :4353.
This unit keeps its comment lines and its remaining statements; it stops holding three
declarations that nothing in this tree reads.

The re-export at head :92 stays here. It re-exports from ./profileDeletionError rather than
from the moved import binding, so it compiles without it, and it is the row knip's unused-file
report is about upstream; moving it is not part of this ruling and is left for one.

Verification at this head before the push, with pnpm 10.8.1 on PATH:
- eslint --max-warnings=0 core/webview/ClineProvider.ts: exit 0, no problem rows. This
  supersedes the 3 no-unused-vars rows measured at 155a1d7.
- pnpm --dir src run check-types: exit 0.
- prettier --check src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts: exit 1. The file is format-dirty for one
  reason, and it is not this unit's: the tree carries a dangling method header
  `async broadcastResetToAllInstances(): Promise<void> {` immediately followed by a closing
  brace, because unit 1's assigned range ends at that signature line while the method's body
  belongs to a later unit. 1921's own head is prettier-clean (prettier 3.9.10, same version CI
  resolves), so this is an artifact of where the split cut, not inherited from Zoo-Code-Org#1921. It is
  reported for a ruling on unit 1 rather than fixed here, because fixing it moves a line across
  a unit boundary.

Hooks: committed with husky's pre-commit enabled (pnpm on PATH), exit 0, no --no-verify. The
commit log carries the summary and no hook output, which is recorded as an absence in a log and
not attributed to toolchain absence.
Two whole donor statements move down into unit 3 so this unit lands at the 500 changed
executable-line cap measured against unit 1 6e3cfda: the late-commit re-post inside
enqueueProviderProfileMutation's queue-advance callback (Zoo-Code-Org#1921 lines 489-502) and the
shared-provider-settings restore try/catch inside _restoreProfileActivationState (Zoo-Code-Org#1921
lines 3125-3131). Each moved span is a complete statement at a syntactic boundary, each
appears exactly once in Zoo-Code-Org#1921 and once in unit 3's file, and neither strands a declaration:
callerTimedOut is still read by the timeout callback that stays here, and the snapshot the
moved restore read is still read by the three restores that stay.

Priced with the shipped instrument against unit 1 6e3cfda (parseChangedLines per file
over git diff -U0 -M, executableChangedLines on the head blob, packageForPath, toRanges
lengths): extension 500 changed executable lines over 136 selector ranges, against 507 over
127 at 71cfcf3, which this supersedes rather than restarts. The figures do not differ
by the size of the moved spans: deleting lines mid-file shifts git's hunk alignment and
re-admits identical comment lines elsewhere into the changed-line set, so the instrument
moves 507 to 500 while 23 donor lines leave the unit. The cap is `> 500` in the script, so
exactly 500 passes, with no margin: this figure holds for this commit against this base and
is not a general statement about the file.

No spec row travels with either span: this unit carries no test file, and the specs that
kill them sit in units below this one in the chain, not in this delta.

Legs ran under node v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1; src check-types prints Unsupported engine:
wanted {"node":"22.23.4"} beside the direct legs, so those legs are node-25 readings and
not the CI interpreter's.
Spec carrier: three assertions in src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.spec.ts
("saves mode config when updating API configuration", "handles successful
upsertApiConfiguration", "handles buildApiHandler error in updateApiConfiguration") and the
`Mode switch failure scenarios` describe block in
src/core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts now carry Zoo-Code-Org#1921's versions rather
than main's, because this unit changes the behaviour they check while main's copies still assert
the old behaviour: at the previous head these three spec files gave 4 failed / 377 passed (381)
and with the carried blocks they give 380 passed / 380. The count drops by one because Zoo-Code-Org#1921
consolidated the mode-switch failure scenarios into a shorter block (main 140 lines -> Zoo-Code-Org#1921 74
lines), which is a difference in how the scenarios are expressed, not a dropped assertion: every
one of the four previously failing names now runs and passes.

The priced file set is unchanged by this commit: only two `__tests__` paths and
`src/eslint-suppressions.json` move, and neither is priced - SOURCE_EXTENSIONS
(scripts/stryker-diff.mjs:75) lists only .js/.jsx/.mjs/.cjs/.ts/.tsx, and EXCLUDED_PATH_SEGMENTS
(:76) returns no package for any `__tests__` path. The instrument is nevertheless re-run at this
head and its reading is published beside the superseded one with the base named.

`src/eslint-suppressions.json` is committed pruned: the carried blocks contain fewer of the
suppressed patterns than main's copies, so eslint without --prune-suppressions exited 2 on
main's counts with 'There are suppressions left that do not occur anymore' and exits 0 on the
pruned counts. One entry moved, downward: core/webview/__tests__/ClineProvider.sticky-mode.spec.ts
@typescript-eslint/no-explicit-any 27 -> 26. No count increased.

All legs ran under node v25.9.0 with pnpm 10.8.1; `pnpm --dir src run check-types` prints
`Unsupported engine: wanted {"node":"22.23.4"}` beside it, so those legs are node-25 readings.

Formatting note: eslint's own suppression writer emits src/eslint-suppressions.json unformatted, so the
prettier --write pass runs after the prune leg and before the commit; prettier --check . is green at
this head, and eslint without --prune-suppressions also exits 0 against the committed counts.
The apiHandlerRebuild suite is green at unit 1 and at main and red from this unit's head
onward: 5 of main's 38 assertions fail against this tree, because this unit moved the
profile-write production ahead of the spec revision that describes it.

The revision that describes the moved write is blob
809e0b9 (43727 bytes, 39 tests). Its provenance is
measured rather than invented: it is held by exactly one commit of the 1921 lineage that
touches the path, the merge 49a0309 at 2026-11-01T07:20:27Z (Merge upstream/main
into vps2/f1b-getstate-merge), and by neither of that merge's parents; main's 16-commit
lineage for the path holds it nowhere and holds the 40685-byte revision c2aec90
instead. At the 1921 tip the file runs 39 of 39.

Carried as a spec-path-only commit: the unit that moves production ahead of the spec
revision that describes it owns the pairing, and this is where the red starts.
…es on

Spec-path-only change on unit 2. Four focused tests drive the provider-manager snapshot
and restore pair directly: three concurrent creates of one name keep the record until the
last claimant fails, a lone failed create deletes the record it made, a create whose
concurrent sibling saved successfully leaves that save in place, and a second failed
create of the same name deletes again. No production line changes, so no executable line
inside a mutation-tested package moves.
@easonLiangWorldedtech
easonLiangWorldedtech force-pushed the vps2/1921-u2-profile-view-refresh branch from 0293ef1 to c9e8355 Compare November 11, 2026 08:59

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant