Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
43 lines (37 loc) · 3.12 KB

gpu-comparison.md

File metadata and controls

43 lines (37 loc) · 3.12 KB

B70 vs current AMD / NVIDIA / Intel GPUs (for bandwidth-bound CFD)

Researched 2026-06-18, cited. Prices are June-2026 street estimates (volatile — GDDR shortage + AI demand). Standard (non-tensor) throughput unless noted.

GPU Mem BW (GB/s) VRAM FP64 std (TF) FP32 (TF) ~Price $ GB/s per $ VRAM-GB per $
Intel Arc Pro B70 608 (spec; 530 meas. sustained) 32 GB ~1.3 (meas.) 22.9 ~950–1083 ~0.59 ~0.031 ★
NVIDIA RTX 4090 1008 24 GB 1.29 (1:64) 82.6 ~2400 ~0.42 ~0.010
NVIDIA RTX 5090 1792 32 GB 1.64 (1:64) 104.8 ~4000 ~0.45 ~0.008
NVIDIA L40S 864 48 GB ~1.4 (1:64) 91.6 ~8000+ ~0.10 ~0.006
NVIDIA A100 80GB 1935–2039 80 GB 9.7 19.5 ~15k (used less) ~0.12 ~0.005
NVIDIA H100 SXM 3350 80 GB 34 67 ~30–40k ~0.10 ~0.002
AMD RX 7900 XTX 960 24 GB 1.92 (1:32) ~46 ~800–1300 ~0.85 ~0.022
AMD Radeon Pro W7900 864 48 GB ~1.9 ~46 ~3400 ~0.24 ~0.013
AMD Instinct MI210 1638 64 GB 22.6 22.6 ~6–10k ~0.20 ~0.008
AMD Instinct MI300X 5300 192 GB 81.7 163.4 ~15–18k ~0.32 ~0.012
Intel Max 1100 1229 48 GB 22.2 21.8 ~3–4k ~0.35 ~0.013
Intel Max 1550 3277 128 GB 52.4 51.4 ~8–10k ~0.39 ~0.014

Verdict for our use case (32 GB, bandwidth-bound, mixed precision)

  • B70 is the clear winner on VRAM-per-dollar among 32GB+ cards (~2.5–4× better than RTX 5090 / W7900 / MI300X / Max 1550). The cheapest way to get 32 GB at decent bandwidth, with native oneAPI/SYCL fit. Sweet spot for large-memory, bandwidth-efficient FP32/FP16 explicit CFD (LBM/FluidX3D) on a budget.
  • Bandwidth (608 GB/s spec) is mid-pack consumer-class (≈L40S, below 7900XTX/ 4090); 3.3× behind MI300X, 5.5× behind H100 SXM. GB/s-per-$ competitive (~0.59).
  • FP64 is weak (~1.3 TF, like all consumer cards) — strong FP64 is data-center only (MI300X 82, Max 1550 52, H100 34, A100 9.7). But our diagnostics show FP64 is NOT the bottleneck (bandwidth + the SYCL preconditioner software are).
  • LBM efficiency: B70 hits 85% of its bandwidth (FluidX3D) — ties RTX 4090, beats Intel's own Max 1100 (47%). For FP32/FP16 LBM the B70 is genuinely good.
  • No-compromise upgrade = AMD MI300X (3.3× bandwidth, 192 GB, full FP64) at ~16–19× the price; A100 80GB = meaningful bandwidth+FP64 step-up at sometimes-comparable used price but 2.5× less VRAM/$ and no SYCL-native fit.

Sources: TechPowerUp, Intel ARK (B70), FluidX3D README, Lehmann et al. PRE 2022 (arXiv:2112.08926), NVIDIA/AMD datasheets, NVIDIA HPCG blog.

Note: B70 bandwidth spec is 608 GB/s (256-bit × 19 Gbps); our 530 GB/s is measured sustained (87%). FP64 is vendor-unpublished; ~1.3 TF = our clpeak.