Skip to content

Infrastructure: Complete Desktop Driver production release qualification #4345

Open

Description

@JasonVMo

Current status - 2026-11-16

Production release qualification remains open. The landed desktop-foundation work does not complete this release gate.

Landed (PR links): #4463 Windows/Win32 shutdown, readiness and reporting repairs plus bounded descriptor qualification; #4469 Windows ownership and physical input (connected Checkbox and Callout smokes passed on Windows Fabric and Win32 Paper with physical-click receipts); #4490 manifest provenance and credential isolation; #4491 attach-only handoff, including a real physical Ctrl+C of serve --agent on Windows Fabric and Win32 Paper in a remote RDP session; #4492 and #4494 neutral application ownership on macOS and Windows; #4493 macOS permission-enabled evidence; #4498 Windows activation and Win32 secondary content windows (native contracts passed in a remote session; 200% DPI, mixed DPI and negative-origin layouts were not run); #4500 macOS physical-input postconditions and an advisory hosted physical lane (343 passed, 3 declared unsupported).

Remaining: every acceptance criterion below. This issue owns the Apple signing/TCC grant matrix, managed-runner policy, compatibility and packed external-consumer gates, security/performance/resource-bound work, and the sustained reliability thresholds. Live endpoint requalification is tracked in #4441, support and reliability consolidation in #4451, capture fidelity in #4348, and authoritative native CI and the reliability window in #4349.

Per-run evidence is recorded in pull request descriptions and issue comments; each package's references/current-status.md keeps a status overview, stable topic sections, and only the latest result per native endpoint with a link. The driver implementation plan and gates list the release gates. No new OS privacy/input settings or distribution-policy change is implied.

Goal

Complete authoritative native qualification and release hardening for the public Desktop Driver after the delivered implementation/integration milestones #4257 and #4258. Parent: #4275.

Status - 2026-10-01

Open; native providers and repository integration are complete, production release qualification is not. #4257 was explicitly closed as an implementation milestone in its September 3 completion comment. This issue gives the remaining release work a distinct open tracker instead of hiding it in a closed issue or only in a package plan.

The release gates and unfinished work are in the Desktop Driver implementation plan. Versioned packages and successful hosted jobs do not by themselves satisfy its release gate.

Acceptance criteria

  • Complete the required Windows Fabric/Win32 physical click, keyboard, wheel, full lifecycle, process/input recovery, live DPI/capture, and sustained-provider qualification in the plan on authoritative interactive sessions.
  • Complete stable Apple Development signing, grant/revoke/regrant/restart TCC matrix, managed auto-logged-in Aqua CI, PPPC/MDM policy, signing rotation, clean-machine install/upgrade/rollback, and explicit optional Screen Recording behavior.
  • Freeze/test native wire and feature compatibility across Node/macOS/Windows/Win32 and publish verified OS, architecture, toolchain, runtime, and capability support.
  • Complete the plan's focused security review, performance/timeout budgets, long-lived resource bounds, wheel conversion decisions, and remaining cache/multi-consumer/corruption/in-use-artifact qualification.
  • Validate the packed public artifact, native-source completeness, narrow runtime dependencies, platform import policy, external-consumer/read-only package operation, and source builds without install scripts, Appium, or implicit helper downloads.
  • Retain at least 100 representative executions per endpoint over 14 days, at least 99% infrastructure success, zero leaked app/helper processes or unreleased-input incidents, and complete failure/helper metadata.
  • Required capabilities are actually available; missing required authority and all-skipped runs cannot satisfy release proof. Attached apps survive, owned resources clean up, and cancellation/helper failure release owned input.
  • Complete publishing/changeset gates after native qualification; publish the final supported operating model and close every remaining V1 plan item with durable evidence.
  • Decide whether a distributed macOS prebuilt is required. If selected, complete its external trust/signing/notarization/stapling/install/rotation gates; otherwise record a source-build-only decision without adding unnecessary distribution machinery.

Scope and dependencies

Coordinate #4347 (regression parity), #4343/#4346 (accessibility), #4349 (authoritative CI/reliability), #4348 (capture), #4342 (reporting), and #4344 (native catalog). Shared qualification evidence can satisfy multiple gates but must identify the tested revision/cohort.

Explicitly deferred items in the package plan (extra platforms/concurrency, persistent broker, MCP adapter, legacy E2E migration, minimized-window policy) are not silently promoted into V1. Visual comparison delivery remains #4328.

Evidence

Activity

  1. JasonVMo commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @JasonVMo
    ContributorAuthor

    Status update. Since the last update, #4469 (Windows ownership and physical input), #4492/#4494 (neutral application ownership), #4493 (macOS permission-enabled evidence), #4498 (Windows activation and Win32 secondary windows) and #4500 (macOS physical-input postconditions and an advisory hosted physical lane) have landed. None of the acceptance criteria is complete. This issue now also owns the Apple signing/TCC grant matrix. Live endpoint gaps are in #4441, reliability consolidation in #4451, capture in #4348, and CI plus the reliability window in #4349. The issue body links were updated to the driver plan's qualification-gates section.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions