Repository navigation
Description
Current reconciliation - 2026-11-09
Audited against main 666e32983.
Open, with a newer delivered baseline. #4386 adds transparent/content-drawn macOS surfaces, Windows rounded/shadowed popups, first/last entry focus, anchor-press handling, nested dismissal, and constrained Win32 adapters. Its body records native Callout/popup runs and explicit visual/AT limits. The October 15 baseline below is historical, not the current implementation ceiling.
Remaining: the full DPI/RTL/multi-monitor/scroll/transform and attachment-replacement geometry matrix, work-area edge margins, non-focused deactivation, 100-cycle resource/lifetime checks, and VoiceOver/field-editor/visual evidence. Reproduce the historical scroll-offset concern against the current native path before prescribing a repair; this audit did not execute geometry. Win32 host transparency/gap/command limitations remain #4384.
Source: packages/agentic/native-core/references/modern-components.md, packages/agentic/native-core/src/components/callout/SPEC.md, and packages/agentic/components/src/components/popover/SPEC.md.
Evidence limits: Source and committed-test inspection only; package/build/native tests were not run in this reconciliation. Earlier native results remain revision-specific; skips, unsupported outcomes, and input-lane exclusions are not passes.
Historical issue scope and acceptance (retained; current reconciliation above supersedes stale status and dependencies)
Goal
Close the remaining desktop Callout qualification gaps from native-core modernization. Part of #4274; coordinate #4343 and #4346 for accessibility coverage/state projection.
Observed baseline — 2026-10-15
On native-lib2 at b55d6c9a3, Windows 11 x64 / RNW 0.81.35 at 100% scale passes view/local-rect/local-point geometry within one logical unit, readiness/focus/reposition/close/rearm, outside-input and Escape dismissal, owner focus return, teardown without visible leaked popups, and flat Menu composition. macOS Fabric and Paper pass the updated authored native cases; local rect/point stories render but do not establish the full geometry matrix. Win32 REX 0.81.1 / react-native-win32 0.81.9 passes legacy outside-click/recreate and Escape, not modern operations.
Remaining work and acceptance
- Qualify Windows geometry at non-100% DPI, RTL, negative monitor origins, collision/flip, alignment/gap, and scrolled/transformed anchors. The current frame-summing positioning path ignores ancestor scroll offsets; fix the owning native geometry path rather than blessing it with render-only tests.
- Qualify Windows app deactivation for presentations that do not hold keyboard focus; preserve outside-input and nested-popup ownership.
- Execute the full macOS Fabric/Paper one-logical-unit view/rect/point geometry matrix, including RTL, backing scale, collision/flip, and attachment replacement.
- Run at least 100 open/close/rearm/reattach cycles per qualified host and check popup/window, observer/subscription, native view, and input resource lifetime; stale cleanup must not detach a newer generation.
- Qualify VoiceOver, field-editor content, and accessibility behavior beyond the authored happy paths.
- Record exact commands/versions, native evidence, pass/fail/skip counts, and unsupported scenarios. Passive inspection must not activate a popup; compile checks and skipped tests are not native qualification.
Evidence and reproduction
Historical handoff: b55d6c9a3:packages/agentic/native-core/plans/modernization.md. Contract: packages/agentic/native-core/src/components/callout/SPEC.md. Run native-core package checks and, from apps/storybook, the native-* owned storybook smoke --<platform> --mode stories-and-tests lanes; add --paper on macOS. Preserve existing qualified readiness, explicit-operation, dismissal, focus-return, and rearm behavior.
Activity