Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
768 lines (653 loc) · 73.2 KB

UPSTREAM_RECONCILIATION_REPORT_20261002.md

File metadata and controls

768 lines (653 loc) · 73.2 KB

Upstream reconciliation evidence report — 2026-10-02

Five-slice upstream ancestry trial — 2026-10-03

The user authorized a trial of five upstream verticals, followed by release-tooling integration, a main merge and an origin push only after successful validation. The trial starts at release-tooling 327dccc04d749892dddf19ca4dc62bf28a5131c8 and merges upstream milestone 4d8ac9e1cea0d645a02f876f47536c54a5bfa406. It includes exactly five first-parent PR merges, five non-merge constituents and three branch-sync merges: 13 upstream ancestry commits, not thirteen new features. The full-hash constituent receipt and source/graph/Jev evidence are under the existing run evidence directory five-slice-merge-trial/.

Vertical Upstream PR merge Non-merge constituent Trial disposition and acceptance
Trace evidence ordering 5fbab7bb7332bd06aaa880653ddfb2696e648f90 0106ff5d9933b9bd65eba393a998586e219da7bd MCP transport remains deleted. Native CLI src/operations/trace.c:leg_json already emits strategy/confidence before args in both header and rows and forwards include_evidence in both directions. This source representation does not claim MCP transport equivalence.
Numeric auto-index limit logging b44e58490f11e4ee895dd91c02067b6de59cdf96 dc24d5813081ba7f4f1cb282cd9e10b8ac963eb7 Adapt warning to native src/daemon/application.c: log numeric configured limit with tracked-file count. Extended daemon_application_auto_index_honors_tracked_file_limit requires actual skipped admission and files=1/limit=0 log.
Interrupted spawn backoff 1424934980d353f97c3664f07b2c1721792b7efa c537bf0f8b3b6a77e39df49fec78560b5e8e87b7 Merge cbm_nanosleep_full into compat, use it from subprocess backoff. Retain thread CPU API. Upstream registered POSIX signal regression requires delivered signals, full delay and clean subprocess outcome; Windows remains platform-specific.
Client selector help c895513f2d6821a3479ea4cbdcf8a39cee2f33ba 1e0aac527b016d519eb7f8fc7dd610dbeb66e988 Add install --clients discovery to native CLI help while preserving native commands/product identity.
Registry client selection 4d8ac9e1cea0d645a02f876f47536c54a5bfa406 1e25d962d69999438229b0562d44ea60e97f5456 Filter registry display/install paths, expose stable registry vocabulary, reject unknown selectors. Adapt regression from removed MCP settings to actual Qoder CLI skill: cursor excludes Qoder artifact, qoder installs it. Retain scoped config-follow behavior.

Branch-sync constituents: 3a500bc8450ab78969d1d8cb4b12e55a479b68d7, 359f7360ddd39dc155637076e76a4e855c27611f, 98e386e58b753bcf63f67aeeacbfcb94961d035c. Their changes are included in the milestone tree comparison; they are not separately credited as functionality.

The isolated trial resolves five conflict paths. MCP source/tests stay deleted; shared fixes and native adaptations remain. Exact-worktree CBM full indexing completed with ready root; flagged parse-partial paths use exact source fallback. Only formatting and git diff checks ran locally. The full Jenkins gate #54 completed SUCCESS at d3e2ac401ec8dccff0bf9d1c33150fe5c67ee8de: 7,528 ordinary tests passed, zero failed and three platform skips; ThreadSanitizer reported 671 passed and two platform skips. The named backoff, selector and numeric-limit regressions passed. Both archived source-revision files match that exact SHA. CodeRabbit reviewed all seven changed source files with zero findings; its one minor test-timer cleanup finding was fixed, and a fresh review of all three changed test files completed with zero findings. Main was fast-forwarded to the validated source after this gate. Origin publication is separately recorded in run evidence five-slice-merge-trial/final-promotion.json. This is Linux validation, not native Windows qualification or acceptance of the whole upstream audit. Jev-1.13.0 source advice: consistent 0.65 / defect 0.30 / insufficient 0.05; Qoder skill regression applicable 0.77 / inapplicable 0.22 / insufficient 0.01. Source inspection and Jenkins retain authority. The preceding ten-task source confirmation is separate.

The integrated milestone reduces the upstream ancestry difference from 678 to 665. Read-only remote checks confirmed upstream still points at the frozen 96c3f41cf334d87670cb085f1fcf16f637293222. Final local/remote branch receipts are in run evidence. This trial does not resolve the global semantic audit remainder or credit thirteen commits as thirteen newly implemented features.

The history inventory is complete; the semantic audit is partial. This report collects the Sol source audit, Luna handoffs, corrections, QA delta and remaining limits. It is a dated synthesis, subordinate to BACKLOG.md and the canonical 308 ledger. It creates no second implementation queue and establishes no review, acceptance or publication.

Comparison boundaries

Tree Frozen full revision Meaning
Integrated upstream 96c3f41cf334d87670cb085f1fcf16f637293222 Reachable merged history under audit
Production origin/main bbabc07386f347ac416a60fe530b1007ced5c27b Frozen shipped-source comparison
Original QA 5fe820df8bfeec059fa646e0050c1652f38a4165 Audit worktree source baseline
Later captured QA 559214af28ce2d6f5d6ec86662f6871316d28b45 Candidate integration, runtime-unaccepted
Common ancestor 17786374dfc39b8c751933d34d269501f2b4d6b7 Shared history boundary

Original QA is 13 commits ahead of production; src/, internal/ and Makefile.cbm are identical. Its release/CI/package/documentation delta cannot be attributed to production. The isolated audit branch adds documentation only; a fresh base-to-HEAD source comparison is empty. The later QA boundary is a captured snapshot, not a claim about today's live refs or GitHub state. No ref was fetched or moved for this consolidation.

Canonical primary dirty snapshots were preserved and reconciled in the isolated branch: 123/610 backlog/ledger lines versus 104/438 at original QA. Existing dirty files, deletions, notebook untracked files and other worktrees were not overwritten. The comprehensive report is a proposal committed locally for parent review.

Complete ancestry and constituent inventory

Exact inventory Count
All upstream reachable commits 3,352
Actual merges / non-merges 923 / 2,429
Differing merges / non-merges against frozen production/original QA 311 / 367
First-parent commits / actual merges 1,412 / 724
Differing first-parent merges 202
Differing non-merges with equal patch ID 3
Differing merges with nonempty combined diff 24
Cached upstream-only branch refs outside integrated scope 69

Actual merges are identified by multiple parents, not subjects. Every merge has full parents, first-parent membership, first-parent result paths, constituent non-merges and nested merges in the crosswalk. Introduced ancestry for M is rev-list M --not M^1, excluding M; nested merges are retained separately. Later captured QA also retains the same 311/367 ancestry-differing hash sets; its source adaptations do not import those upstream originals into history. All 923/2,429 hash sets and the 311/367 differing sets were checked against the frozen Git objects again during consolidation. Each differing non-merge has exactly one auditor assignment. Constituents can occur in nested containers; those memberships are not unique implementation tasks.

The 612 inherited merges and 2,062 inherited non-merges are ancestors. They were not freshly semantically or operationally revalidated. Equal stable patch IDs for 25a7aacc87250bff752ff61cd33e9236be5d1310, 349aecba9528427fa635975e246f5b8959b14f30, and 557cb0102863e66cbd5cc622509a29a4964d1831 establish a mechanical relationship; they do not close test, followup or acceptance requirements. An empty --cc diff likewise does not establish safe merge resolution or whole-result parity.

The 69 cached upstream-only branch refs have commits outside the frozen integrated upstream tip. Full tips and hashes are in upstream-branches-outside-scope.json. Remote freshness and open-PR status were not checked, so these are separately excluded from integrated scope rather than silently counted as missing merged work.

What the evidence can establish

Claim Required evidence Result here
Ancestry Exact Git reachability Complete frozen census
Patch equivalence Stable patch ID Three matches; discovery only
Semantic representation Target source behavior, dependencies and regression hunks Bounded checks; unresolved remainder explicit
Grouping Common behavior plus prerequisites/fixes/checksums/tests Source-checked verticals and provisional containers
Implementation Scoped source commit/tree Historical main work and later QA candidates separated
Review Independent findings/disposition R4 full-hunk review pending
Jenkins validation Existing venue artifacts at exact revision No new result collected or triggered
Acceptance Host decision against evidence Not asserted
Integration Exact target ancestry/tree Frozen production versus later QA distinguished

Fourteen Sol R2 source-only rows cover bounded behavior: failed COUNT reads, linear LSP array decode, TS awaited generic calls, optional COUNT, .NET XML admission, properties payload state, macro scanning, specified growable AST stacks, Cypher parser/variable-capacity guards and empty-function sorting. Those are not whole commit certificates. Watcher scheduler execution and AST allocation-failure injection remain unestablished. The scratch lifetime change is separate from previously ported growable stacks.

Historical Jenkins #34 at 37dd63ba5b4dfc45790cad6722e7e5c097216607 and #35/GitHub evidence tied to bbabc07386f347ac416a60fe530b1007ced5c27b remain historical claims at those revisions. They do not validate the later QA ports, this audit's candidates, or current PR #14. Its remote 1ce4e164033d6407c902b6d3b462558df2f30ee6 red checks are a prior snapshot; they were neither refreshed nor repaired here.

Auditor results and recovery

Original headless workers lost their live processes near 18:16Z despite running projections. Their evidence remains preserved; process-loss cause was not proved. Unstarted R2 headless retries were superseded at the user's request. R3 interactive Luna high workers ran in real managed managed terminals with independent full exact-root indexes and clean frozen QA trees. All R3 handoffs were partial:

R3 auditor Assignment Touched rows Untouched rows
Extraction 111 non-merges 10 101
Runtime 170 non-merges 20 150
History 86 non-merges plus 311 merges 4 non-merges 82 non-merges; all whole merges open

All assignment sets and all 40 declared artifact checksums (6/25/9) were verified. Thirty-four touched rows were not 34 proven whole commits: some regression hunks were missing or unverified, and some verdicts confused presence upstream with representation in the target. Raw claims remain available separately from parent judgment. None was automatically accepted from a finished terminal state.

R4 successors preserve official retry lineage and continue interactively in managed terminal, managed terminal, managed terminal. They retain all remaining assignments and incrementally save full diffs/source/coverage. The capture time is 2026-10-02T23:53:00.456924+00:00. It is not a sealed result:

R4 auditor Rows accounted for Non-unresolved raw claims Unresolved raw claims
CBM-RECON-EXTRACT-20261002-R4 111 30 81
CBM-RECON-RUNTIME-20261002-R4 170 5 165
CBM-RECON-HISTORY-20261002-R4 86 19 67

These 54 claims are pending independent whole-hunk/target/test review. The remaining 313 worker claims are explicitly unresolved. The conservative parent inventory retains 364 non-merge whole-commit remainders and all 311 merge remainders; three exact empty-tree changes require no source port. Full hashes, bounded parent dispositions, groups and provisional R4 claims are in the canonical appendix. Do not subtract touched rows from the parent remainder or infer semantic coverage from assignment completeness.

Source corrections and additional gaps

The strongest new correction concerns 21591d51168d26f931f64d62edc36013cd1f6249. In src/daemon/application.c:1709–1717, production and both QA trees count active jobs but divide aggregate memory by physical_job_limit. Upstream lines1760–1770 divide by active. Function/log names and the default four-worker test do not prove equivalence. Fork comments/test expect fixed quarter-budget slices. Upstream adds a spawn-time active-slice test; an already-running worker retains its old cap as concurrency grows. Whether direct porting preserves the aggregate global budget is unresolved. Record a behavior difference and reservation-policy review; copying the divisor alone is not a ready adaptation.

Merge 2b8bd0c065c1d2728994fddc1683a66f70745748 separately contains Windows Job Object memory-cap/peak evidence in src/foundation/subprocess.[ch], plus MCP-only supervisor floor/1.5x headroom diagnostics. The neutral subprocess capability is missing in the fork and potentially usable by src/operations/index_supervisor.c; its policy and regression adaptation need review. Exclude direct MCP adapter imports, not the entire shared capability. The merge's broad first-parent result is still unresolved after inspecting these hunks; constituent review or one function snippet cannot close it.

Parent frozen-source checks also establish these bounded gaps:

Upstream constituent Target evidence and missing behavior Adaptation / remaining review
62b44519c68b403ea44d9a85ba8ee74cddee66e6 src/graph_buffer/graph_buffer.c, edge_props_confidence, uses strtod(..., NULL); upstream checks the end pointer Localized strict numeric parse; review malformed/empty/trailing cases and tests; first additional candidate
592894a4387a50e1d128ff6a2695ff48f8cc32a5 internal/cbm/extract_calls.c, extract_handler_arg, chooses first eligible handler and caps scan Terminal eligible handler after middleware; route followup; full regression/dependency review open
c36b4fbc446f9085704a6073b81ec743fd4180fc internal/cbm/extract_defs.c limits outer annotation argument scan to three positions Scan all outer positions while retaining bounded inner traversal; route followup
1e25d962d69999438229b0562d44ea60e97f5456 src/cli/cli.c install/uninstall registry dispatch lacks upstream client-selection guards Apply supported CLI selection policy, preserve unrelated registrations; full interface/tests open

R3/R4 also identify source-backed candidates requiring parent whole-hunk review: Python parameter shadowing 95689b5c20101db7d92b69767bbea75e5bf0d4fc with superseded bounded lookup 0b0d143c2d733e3313eef5b9d9745b0fb08cc2c0 and final walk-carried lookup 97517a4652f376cb6bf096255e235edf456f86b1; scratch stack lifetime 40f2722d6166c1f97fa1667c1e63e8c97e6f05f0; dotted JS/TS import basenames 48cb94f65ce221e1494119d850d35019c86a59e2; Swift argument unwrapping c4e902849f8062e37a0f0ddaed1c6cc042780cb3; Elixir positional arguments dc0f8ae642bf39b4b11bec2a88a8cdc7a1e4ab5b; Ruby base collection 4b1cdf57804afffbcb61e69fd484b42858fcc02f; strict numeric environment parsing 6b801eec68d6465aad2020de438e629cead99f5c; FreeBSD package/UI resolution 2bff501a62a3bba1aeb39f49f7c785d541ca209e; EOF VT/FF/CR whitespace 572725e61a00b9deda7407971dc9290477170515; and EINTR-safe spawn backoff c537bf0f8b3b6a77e39df49fec78560b5e8e87b7. These are findings to reconcile, not an independently accepted additional queue.

Mixed saturation/error-reporting commit 3909e5a0e1d55236fccac9ab680a1c6103ce5daf has shared Cypher/BFS behavior and MCP/UI response hunks; adapter exclusion must be at the hunk seam. Followup 619c6834807532b69c419454fd53074d6d10050a requires the truncation carrier. Parse-unusable/range-drop marker a953509275a4fa42a907f88852d62a613f27bc56 also mixes shared extraction with MCP rendering. Result-field, neutral CLI formatting and test dependencies require review together. A path/title exclusion cannot discharge the shared portions.

Older canonical rows, exclusions and grouping

All 87 old selected/deferred/excluded rows (16/24/47) and 190 distinct revision tokens have full-object crosswalks. This resolves references, not historical semantics. The canonical appendix preserves each old label next to the current bounded disposition. Every differing non-merge has one primary group; the 199 Sol groups include checked verticals and provisional native first-parent containers. A broad container remains to be split by behavior, not imported as a single slice.

Important prerequisite and followup corrections:

  • ReScript checksum ea6fa49f follows 8093d10b; JSX checksum c5c13a87 follows grammar 1b795589. Full objects are in the canonical token crosswalk.
  • Swift manifest/checksum e8204092333ee1c38cd681a81abb36f125288894 stays with both width fixes. No runtime delta does not mean no integrity work.
  • SQL regression 259dbb67 follows c0a06b3d; watcher regressions 07eb426c and 5a9c72d8 remain grouped. Source backoff presence does not supply 4fc5999a85f50bbb131dd87c5f41949c08617c1a's absent accessor/test seam.
  • fa229211 touches shared pipeline artifact-export failure state; its MCP title does not justify whole-commit exclusion. 4c466fc4 has partial build-stamp coherence: ordinary C objects are covered, grammar/LSP/preprocessor/vendor recipes and complexity-test cleanup remain to inspect/adapt.
  • Test reliability/harness claims such as 7e47043acce9bdfd87e7becc7fe7a348b02753ec and 132e8fc32309e843ccd97138c8f032e317333673 are not missing runtime features, but applicable validation followups cannot be discarded on that basis.

Only exact empty tree changes can be excluded without a runtime behavior question. Pure MCP response/session adapters require exact hunk reasons; their exclusion never proves neutral CLI parity. Historical artifact-sharing draft 9baa0a8dc5cbe7a9fa687e0a8811dfcbdcd0551e is superseded by 957b27fca50d2c3b1ac86d771733f39612bae841; source review must compare the final practical documentation, not label the draft's title missing forever.

Captured QA integration and production boundary

Daemon ownership 028a4bfb4233a0cda91ad57c6859f214fcb112a8, cache stores fa5a180b7afee333109b3a1041f102fc74562bb8, and ReScript hang work 0eaa19f84544151068111a262772d32d5c5e9a64 plus 9766a378a73905cc7ad1101c0358bf64e40e8fc9 were candidates when launched. Parent subsequently reported integration repairs including 42b0248e9571d5e72bf51944e44d38e0e45e14ec, fixture followups, ADR alias/ outline and hook-environment ancestry in captured QA 559214af. Source comparison confirms daemon/cache/ReScript and ADR changes. Parent found child assertion placement and maintenance intent-before-ownership defects, then compile signature and ADR pagination/allocation fixes. These are parent-reported repairs, not a Jenkins success or independent acceptance established by this audit.

The pre-commit file has no original-to-later QA tree delta and remains formatting only. Candidate ancestry does not establish production Git-child environment isolation or restore test hooks. The three ports and ADR are QA-integrated, runtime-unaccepted and outside frozen production; they are excluded from the next five new slices. Preserve later QA's ReScript manifest/checksum row when adapting Swift. No candidate was pushed or merged to main by this auditor.

Next five new verticals

The authoritative source/dependency/acceptance detail is in the canonical recommendation section. This condensed comparison records why the five remain recommended among inspected work; unresolved commits may change the order. Every slice is absent in the relevant frozen production/original/later QA source. Parent selects existing shared codebase-memory-cli-release-tooling Jenkins suites and records the actual revision/result. No suite below was run or scheduled here.

Rank / impact Constituents in adaptation sequence Actual upstream first-parent merge Smallest adaptation and meaningful acceptance Existing Jenkins suites
1. Memory safety; very small 2fabaa2b877986bdededb4f4f78e9a31014c6fdf ea7e01e91e64da62a74c1abbfe7a138710d1c88a src/cypher/cypher.c, cross_join_with_rels: reuse binding_out_append; four missing-label OPTIONAL inputs retain four distinct rows with unbound optional variables and no overflow, retain nonempty/COUNT behavior cypher
2. Persisted index correctness; small e7324bb6904c6d0a295b956e83c8585219198358 6bce86383ea192a2f0fbf795e161d3ddca4a78cc internal/cbm/sqlite_writer.c, fill_interior_page / pb_build_interior: give back final cell and rewind when only a right child would remain; long-key row sweep, rightmost miss/delete and SQLite integrity sqlite_writer,graph_buffer,pipeline
3. Scanner UB and integrity; very small 3f831936b5f3012d13175e7c97326165efecefad → a2ea711c29560511eb8467bea7ad309ebf500d6e → e8204092333ee1c38cd681a81abb36f125288894 620613ede6a983f04b7c1539a2ea4c65b34d42f6 Swift eat_operators / OP_SYMBOL_SUPPRESSOR: use 1ULL at both sites, retain regression and fork-byte manifest/checksum provenance; preserve ReScript row; force-unwrap/try! extraction and failing UBSan trap policy language,extraction,grammar_regression plus integrity gate
4. Discovery completeness; medium c8184ed94887a6b5e130726885b44a07c63a47b7 → 282fbfcdabfec79c19c36f5bec5f75c22eb36df5 92910147aba1e56a1cb8fff7da5e74dbf8011b35 discover_impl: reuse ignore chains/walk helpers with per-ancestor base offsets; rooted patterns, intermediate ignores, deeper negation, linked worktree/common-dir exclusions and OOM cleanup agree with Git discover,gitignore,git_context,pipeline
5. Deterministic graph and complete routes; small/medium 6b48097471e8d1a3e5cf16447304899a21e12d7a f1e51133e9ec0708756e0ca9311b6b0f3a8cca34 pass_route_nodes.c, match_one_infra_route / create_grpc_routes: total QN ordering and exact-size service pointer array, free on all exits; >64 services and permuted insertion orders yield identical HANDLES sets pipeline,parallel

Existing parser/capacity groundwork is not a substitute for OPTIONAL buffer growth. SQLite atomic-publish diagnostics are independent. Ancestor ignore fix must include its anchoring followup. Route change can be adapted without the omnibus memory core or unrelated spill/staging tests; those hunks remain unresolved separately. If route scope adds handler-position/late-annotation fixes, add their full hashes and meaningful middleware/late-position regressions plus existing edge_types_probe,extraction selections before implementation. They are related followups, not prerequisites for the narrow route admission slice.

Jev jev-1.13.0 advised on six bounded prioritization alternatives from 52,640 bytes of verbatim primary requirements/source. Full request/answer distributions are in consolidation evidence; no prior verdicts or Jev answers were supplied. Scores (out of three) and P(defer/useful/high/urgent):

Candidate Score Distribution
Cypher 2.89 0.01 / 0.01 / 0.08 / 0.90
SQLite 2.71 0.02 / 0.05 / 0.14 / 0.79
Swift 1.69 0.03 / 0.29 / 0.65 / 0.03
Ignore 1.93 0.08 / 0.26 / 0.31 / 0.35
Routes 1.97 0.04 / 0.11 / 0.69 / 0.16
Confidence parse 2.03 0.01 / 0.08 / 0.78 / 0.13

Exact safety evidence and tiny Swift effort retain its third place; small advisory score gaps do not establish queue order. Confidence parsing is first additional. Jev provided decision support, not semantic proof, code, permissions or validation. The history worker separately advised reservation accounting before active-job division; that provisional reasoning does not replace fork policy/source review.

GitHub's behind count and honest integration

GitHub compares commit ancestry. Adapting/cherry-picking upstream behavior generally creates different hashes; equal source or patch ID does not make the originals ancestors. Editing commit hashes rewrites the objects and descendants. This report cannot alter GitHub's count, and no rewrite or remote action was performed.

A normal upstream-history merge would record ancestry and change the count, but only an independently reviewed integration that handles missing/excluded behavior and all resolution hunks would honestly establish incorporation. An ours merge would mark unresolved history incorporated while retaining missing source. Keep the frozen census plus canonical semantic ledger until an authorized integration has reviewed resolutions and exact-revision Jenkins evidence. Do not claim the fork caught up globally from counts, selected ports or a paperwork update.

Evidence custody, reproducibility and precise limits

Durable authority for this consolidation is CBM-UPSTREAM-CONSOLIDATE-20261002; original Sol R2 and partial R3 evidence remain unchanged. Machine-readable crosswalks/grouping stay in run evidence rather than another repository ledger:

Artifact Purpose
consolidation-summary.json Exact capture time, sets, raw checkpoint counts and conservative limits
nonmerge-crosswalk.jsonl / merge-crosswalk.jsonl All 2,429/923 commits, exact memberships, parent notes and raw claims
first-parent-history.tsv Complete upstream first-parent history
canonical-reconciliation.jsonl 190 revision tokens / all 87 older rows resolved to objects
slice-grouping.json / next-five-slices.json One primary group per differing non-merge; source-grounded shortlist
unresolved-dispositions.tsv Full-hash 364 non-merge and 311 merge remainders
auditor-checkpoints/ / artifact-integrity.json Preserved partial R3 artifacts and hashed live R4 checkpoint copies
frozen-source/, source/combined diff receipts and graph/ Exact material source, traces, coverage and fallback
jev-prioritization-{request,response}.json, jev-decision-use.md Question/model/distributions and actual effect on ranking
source-drift-check.json, doc-consistency-review.json Doc-only provenance and final permitted checks

The initial exact-worktree nonpersistent index receipt recorded 26,723 nodes / 128,682 edges at generation17:30:32Z. The later live status is ready at the same root with 26,736/128,694 and still 91 partial files; it exposes no generation field. Source-to-original-QA diff remains empty. Do not infer unchanged generation from source identity or call the counts exhaustive. Earlier saved material coverage receipts carry generation, qualified complete searches and both-direction traces; all cited partial/ignored ranges use exact source fallback. vendored scopes and MCP adapter paths require direct frozen Git reads. No reindex/cache-root/daemon change was necessary for the doc-only consolidation.

Acknowledgement correction on the later parallel split: both runtime and history correction steering have correlated worker-issued durable acknowledgement intents. The earlier parent check missed the history receipt while inspecting only message/ event projections. Its acknowledgement existed before the report checkpoint; the alleged ordering gap is withdrawn. The original receipt is retained in the new split run's evidence. A terminal submission alone remains insufficient. Launch, delivery, application and completion are separate evidence claims.

The remaining limits are explicit: 364 differing non-merges and all 311 differing merges need whole-commit semantic closure; 24 combined merge diffs and additional first-parent result changes require review; older exclusions/shared MCP seams, provisional groups and regression followups need source verification. No local build/test/binary/sanitizer/install/benchmark/hang harness or Jenkins trigger ran. No push, PR, main merge, tag, fetch or publication occurred. Only doc consistency, exact Git/source reads, evidence hashing and git diff --check are permitted here. The report and ledger can be committed while the full audit honestly remains open.

Later parallel split of unfinished work

After the snapshot above, the user authorized splitting only unfinished work and Luna low for straightforward comparisons. Runtime R4 released exactly 16 still unreviewed adapter/test followup hashes, outside both its reviewed rows and active batch, and issued a correlated durable acknowledgement. New interactive external run CBM-RECON-ADAPTER-LOW-20261003, worker luna-adapter-low, is observed working in managed terminal with Luna low. It has a separately indexed clean exact-QA worktree and TypeSafe credentials sourced silently in the actual launch shell. No finished comparison was reassigned. Runtime retains 154 hashes; the effective ownership crosswalk still accounts for all 367 differing non-merges once. Exact source and hash comparisons use Git/CBM; bounded semantic comparison may use proper Jev requests, with complete primary payloads/distributions and decision-use notes. This launch changes ownership, not verification/acceptance or the frozen inventory. The original checkpoint tables remain dated snapshots rather than live counts.

Phase1 handoff to three DeepSeek Flash workers

The user selected runtime Luna's remaining unreviewed scope for three parallel DeepSeek Flash workers. Runtime released106 unfinished hashes with a correlated acknowledgement; the superseded unstarted low2 batch contributes9 more. Phase1's 115 hashes are assigned without overlap to runtime39, operations26, integration50, keeping original followup groups intact. Completed comparisons are excluded. The first low batch's corrected source review is finalized partial: all16 inspected, 8 shared-semantic mappings unresolved, original Jev payload unrecoverable. Its full handoff/hash checks are preserved and pane closed; this is not acceptance.

The canonical Phase1 plan owns current plan/status. Exact machine assignments/effective ownership and launch/ index receipts remain in the three run evidence roots. Native workspace subagents use isolated frozen worktrees; they are not managed terminal agents. Each must retain full source comparisons, bounded primary-evidence Jev calls and resumable batch checkpoints. Subsequent delivery checks found that all three returned predecessor tasks instead of their assignments, even after persisted steering and direct follow-ups. The affected sessions were stopped. No correlated Phase1 acknowledgement, assigned comparison or Jev call is established; all 115 hashes remain pending. Per-run parent recovery checkpoints/handoffs retain exact hashes and next actions; the canonical plan records the failed-delivery boundary and unexpected predecessor activity. No result is represented as complete or accepted. The original capture tables remain dated evidence, not silently refreshed progress counters.

Interactive recovery now uses three Codex --model deepseek-flash sessions in managed terminal / managed terminal / managed terminal under the corresponding CBM-RECON-DEEPSEEK-{RUNTIME,OPS,INTEGRATION}-managed terminal-PHASE1-20261003 runs. All three are observed working and have correct run/cwd/count launch acknowledgements. Actual Codex processes inherited the silently sourced Jev token; destination, official footer and matching ready CBM index generations are verified. The exact 39/26/50 assignments remain disjoint. The canonical interactive recovery section owns current status; this is launch evidence, not completed comparison or acceptance.

Appendix: non-unresolved auditor checkpoint claims

This is a source-finding snapshot, not another task ledger. It makes the collected work readable without relying on private run paths. Verdicts are the workers' CLI target claims at the capture above; they remain provisional. Parent corrections in the source section and canonical disposition column take precedence. Reasons below are worker findings, not independent acceptance. Full source/diff/test evidence and unresolved hunks are retained with each raw record in run evidence.

Full upstream hash R4 raw target claim Recorded source reason / remaining scope
c537bf0f8b3b6a77e39df49fec78560b5e8e87b7 missing cbm_spawn_backoff in src/foundation/subprocess.c calls cbm_nanosleep(&delay,NULL) in production/original/current QA; upstream uses cbm_nanosleep_full, which loops on EINTR via nanosleep remaining in src/foundation/compat.c:20-31. Full production/QA defect and tests are in the exact diff.
1e0aac527b016d519eb7f8fc7dd610dbeb66e988 missing The changed two help lines advertise install --clients; absent from production src/main.c install usage. Existing install-hooks --clients help is a distinct command. Frozen upstream src/main.c:1108-1109 has the added install help.
3f831936b5f3012d13175e7c97326165efecefad missing The source operation shifts an int by token indices that can exceed int width; upstream widens the left operand to unsigned long long. production/QA have not picked up the fix.
a2ea711c29560511eb8467bea7ad309ebf500d6e missing The BANG suppressor shifts an unsigned long whose width is 32 bits on LLP64; upstream uses a 64-bit literal.
e8204092333ee1c38cd681a81abb36f125288894 excluded This commit adds only vendored-source manifest/checksum provenance; it does not change CLI runtime behavior. Keep it as a dependency/follow-up when carrying the adjacent Swift scanner fixes, but exclude it from semantic-behavior missing counts.
25a7aacc87250bff752ff61cd33e9236be5d1310 represented Parser failure now returns an error instead of silently executing a parsed prefix and returning misleading rows.
44caa4c386c578e59c5919735e1e4d6094ac1af7 represented .razor files are admitted to discovery and C# extraction.
fd73c347fbcfd7f66c210577b4d713fc6ce7780b partially represented Source behavior is present, but this commit’s route-specific positive/negative regression hunks are not in production/QA.
592894a4387a50e1d128ff6a2695ff48f8cc32a5 missing Upstream selects the terminal route handler when middleware precedes it; production/QA can bind middleware or stop before the handler.
349aecba9528427fa635975e246f5b8959b14f30 partially represented The source guard is shape-based rather than testing dot presence in reference text. Full test-hunk parity remains unverified, so whole-commit disposition is partial.
e0785b353af1af3812d5d14cad55c839efc5749d missing The commit adds GET /api/ui-config version response (src/ui/http_server.c) and App fetch/display. Production/original/current QA handler returns lang and upstream_issues_url only; corresponding App version fetch/title are absent. Frozen upstream has response at src/ui/http_server.c:155 and display graph-ui/src/App.tsx:95.
40f2722d6166c1f97fa1667c1e63e8c97e6f05f0 missing Growable traversal avoids fixed-cap truncation; this commit specifically moves temporary stacks into per-file scratch so they do not live as long as cached extraction results.
95689b5c20101db7d92b69767bbea75e5bf0d4fc missing Avoids fabricating a project CALLS edge from a module function when the bare callee is shadowed by an enclosing Python parameter.
8bcfa2915fa02721c5b6d2a6c7082a26fef79d88 excluded No semantic behavior: the exact commit only clang-formats existing test rows. The CLI test formatting has no functional parity impact; target feature tests are absent with their parent feature.
0b0d143c2d733e3313eef5b9d9745b0fb08cc2c0 superseded The intermediate bounded cursor walk was replaced upstream by O(1) walk-carried binding lookup in commit 97517a4652f376cb6bf096255e235edf456f86b1. Target lacks the final suppression behavior and test.
97517a4652f376cb6bf096255e235edf456f86b1 missing The final O(1) walk-carried Python parameter binding helper is upstream at internal/cbm/extract_calls.c:3234-3238 and used by the invocation path; production and both QA refs lack the helper, call site and regression.
c4e902849f8062e37a0f0ddaed1c6cc042780cb3 missing Swift call arguments are reached through call_suffix/value_arguments and labeled values are unwrapped; upstream helper/call site at internal/cbm/extract_calls.c:3317,3940 feeds URL/service route extraction. Target source and added extraction/pipeline regressions are absent.
9baa0a8dc5cbe7a9fa687e0a8811dfcbdcd0551e missing README change instructs team repos to use LFS and replace generated merge=ours attributes; target README at production/original/current QA has no corresponding LFS guidance. Upstream follow-up 957b27fca50d2c3b1ac86d771733f39612bae841 materially refines the advice.
957b27fca50d2c3b1ac86d771733f39612bae841 superseded The commit corrects the prior LFS guidance: retain nested .codebase-memory/.gitattributes; track only .zst from root attributes; explain cadence, rewrite requirement, LFS costs/install. This full current guidance is in upstream README.md:253-259 and absent from all CLI target snapshots.
57ef0a6d8662e9854dc5711922f801c3da381071 missing trace fix adds end-to-end integer parsing, CBM_DURATION_UNKNOWN and checked-duration propagation into HTTP span records. Production/original/current QA have only cbm_parse_duration and assign its 0 on unreadable start; frozen upstream contains checked parser and unknown sentinel. Full diff includes API header, code, regression tests.
2c76563a137876b110cec15b9b6fa08d35069f73 represented The type-root receiver-chain guard gates both unique-name and suffix-match resolution; receiver-chain rejection regression is present in all target snapshots.
1770d68a2c934501b889e625dc94ef933e3a1815 represented .cshtml is admitted as C# and @page route extraction handles .cshtml; all target refs contain positive route and no-page/layout coverage under adapted test names.
48cb94f65ce221e1494119d850d35019c86a59e2 missing Upstream strips only recognized JS/TS module extensions and preserves dotted extensionless basenames; production and both QA refs still call strip_ext, truncating at the last dot, and lack import regression.
73f4a432e4ac1d575635a490d96e0f5ea588344d missing Windows guard changes add per-section CBM_RUNTIME_DIR isolation, SetupFailure classification, complete stdout/stderr, timeout preservation, and independent failures. Target tests/windows/test_daemon_stability.py has none of these revised paths; its cache-only isolation and head-slice diagnostics remain. Adjacent Windows tests likewise lack the diff additions. This is test/CI coverage, not a production daemon implementation change.
be66a2d2c6f1538a4a831eb2c91622997be5b5ec missing Pi smoke probe now provides TypeBox stub and rejects extension imports other than Node builtins plus Pi host package typebox. Target scripts/smoke-test.sh has no PI_HOST_PACKAGES/typebox import allowlist or stub; the exact smoke-test hunk is absent.
63b99976a21463697d6e980e32aa42f5913319da represented RETURN * deduplicates repeated pattern variables and reads live WITH aliases; both source branches and regressions are present in all target refs.
426e415f5427f2fb2e9c6f918cc7cc9abd9c109b represented WITH rejects a projection wider than CYP_MAX_VARS before silent binding truncation; the guard and boundary regression are present in all target refs.
f404dfbc7ae47f9912b18a0554a5e5d91f65be1a missing MSan image hunk installs bounded retry shell wrapper and uses it for apt/network steps and clean-retry clones. Production/original/current QA Dockerfile still directly runs apt-get and git clone, pins LLVM 21.1.8; frozen upstream has retry and LLVM 22. This commit changes image build resilience, not indexed product runtime.
9104feb67f78959e64ddff78d236e0dea475a434 represented Full diff adds the shared daemon cohort conflict retry, preserving immediate failure for an unbounded deadline, emitting the conflict kind once, plus atomic test seam and two regressions. Production and both QA targets contain this exact behavioral contract and corresponding test cases; upstream also contains it. Representation is source-level only; no tests or runtime acceptance were run.
4b1cdf57804afffbcb61e69fd484b42858fcc02f missing Ruby base collection now handles constant and scope_resolution children; upstream includes Ruby inheritance regressions. Production and both QA refs lack both.
7c34adf8bb60f873bd525e3d45ab78a395874582 excluded The commit has one parent and an empty tree diff (zero paths/hunks). It is an event to rerun CI, with no source/config/test artifact change to port.
cd3ea5b35bfad379f3d76b5cc83f78826b57555c excluded The commit has one parent and an empty tree diff (zero paths/hunks). It is an event to rerun CI, with no source/config/test artifact change to port.
dc0f8ae642bf39b4b11bec2a88a8cdc7a1e4ab5b missing Elixir call nodes expose arguments positionally, not via the generic arguments field. Upstream fallback at internal/cbm/extract_calls.c:545,3929-3931 passes their string literals to route/HTTP/config extraction. Production and both QA refs have no fallback/call site; existing elixir_call_arguments is used only for definition-role analysis.
7e47043acce9bdfd87e7becc7fe7a348b02753ec excluded The change adds a monotonic waiter-enqueue counter and uses it to make the absolute-deadline fixture deterministic; it does not change lock acquisition decisions or public lock behavior. Production/original/current QA lack this internal test seam and updated fixture. Treat as test reliability follow-up, not a missing CLI runtime feature. The atomic counter does add instrumentation to the lock path.
ffc29f73bb27dfbad778acbc48e1a3a54f17d1b5 missing For positive committed_nodes with persisted_nodes==0 and ratio>0, the change reports degraded even below min_floor. Production/original/current QA return false at the min_floor short-circuit and miss total persistence loss in sparse projects. Frozen upstream adds that explicit zero-persisted check and regression test.
6b0c44afcfeae65eed82e2dbbd58f00b043f21f6 missing The exact package-lock hunk updates graph-ui fflate 0.8.2 to 0.8.3 and nested three-stdlib fflate 0.6.10 to 0.6.11 with new registry URLs and integrity hashes. Production/original/current QA lockfile retains 0.8.2 and 0.6.10; frozen upstream carries both updated lock entries. No package manifest source change is in this commit.
132e8fc32309e843ccd97138c8f032e317333673 excluded The hunk changes only the Windows test-wave harness: descendant probe gets an independent 15-second budget/two attempts, preserves fail-closed outcomes, and reports blockers distinctly; contract tests pin those properties. No shipped CLI/product source changes. The target harness/test contract lacks the change, so retain as test-infrastructure reliability evidence outside runtime parity.
7d20ff9398cb494a61f6cd259a51b309dbe5bd54 missing Full diff replaces shell-script command registration with direct exec-form registration for Claude PreToolUse/PostToolUse/session/subagent hooks; exact command+args identity is used for owned-hook update/removal, and installed binary path is passed across install/uninstall. Production and both QA targets retain shell command resolution through cbm_resolve_hook_command(CMM_HOOK_GATE_SCRIPT); they lack the new binary/args path and exact args ownership. Upstream contains it. Windows integration test also changes to invoke the binary with forward-slash argv and direct stdin payload. The existing shell-form hook feature is related but does not provide this shell-free contract.
39c74bdd5c8b5dc3bcd43f962195add0ba794150 missing Complete diff changes tests/test_cli.c and scripts/smoke-test.sh only. It updates Windows lifecycle assertions to count five exec-form hooks, verify prior owned shell hooks are removed while foreign hooks remain, checks uninstallation removes exec-form entries, and makes smoke assert installed binary plus hook-augment args. These are applicable CLI regression checks for 7d20, not new shipped behavior. They are absent in production and both QA target test sources; upstream contains them. No production behavior is inferred from test text.
fece72b049db1954eb38f2fce139cec5eb499b00 missing ELF hardening now explicitly links -Wl,-z,relro -Wl,-z,now, and binary-composition CI asserts PT_GNU_RELRO coverage of every GOT section and eager binding where dynamic. Production/original/current QA lack those flags and A1c/A1d artifact checks. The commit gives a measured static Linux GOT gap and targets the shipped ELF artifact; this is security/build behavior, not a generic linker preference.
7b92d2a6218936767b112081b9aa4e79d5b81dd9 partially represented Mixed commit: the shared scripts/ci/check-binary-composition.sh guard and tests/test_release_candidate_derivation_contract.sh fixture declaration are CLI release-qualification relevant and missing in production/QA; old script fails A1d for lazily linked fixture because it applies the release-link property to all ELF inputs. The tests/test_mcpb_bundle_contract.sh fixture change is MCPB-only and the file is absent from CLI targets; exclude only that exact hunk. Upstream retains every change. This is not a runtime behavior claim.
1a6f80c37baed2d4e670304f5b95e766289aeaa4 represented Production/original/current QA already treat refused UI config as nonfatal for bare daemon start (warning with daemon left running), while --port/--open still fail; the refused-config test seam and Windows lifecycle assertions are present. Exact behavior in frozen upstream is present too. This source behavior arrived via another path even though this exact commit hash is not target ancestry.
3909e5a0e1d55236fccac9ab680a1c6103ce5daf partially represented Mixed commit. Missing shared CLI/core hunks: Cypher result truncation and generic plain-BFS saturation/edge-error behavior; CLI process logging/verbose behavior is also absent from target. cbm_store_bfs_with_edge_limit is only called from MCP. MCP compact response, MCP pagination/format and graph-UI/hook adapter hunks are excluded from CLI semantic missing counts.
17d61ea9be09b004a3e64f330c82c2f716a10a4e excluded The full diff changes only tests/test_incremental.c calls to MCP detect_changes and their response assertions (empty changed_files omission, changed_total/changed_returned scalars); no operation or CLI source changed. The test uses call_tool_timed against the MCP adapter. Direct adapter response-shape assertions do not establish neutral CLI behavior and cannot be ported unchanged.
4cbc0536ac8d672482068375340382cc78a033e1 represented Pagination generation validation and generation advance at the staged-publish tail are present in production and both QA refs, including canonical UID/counter validation.
f4c7d2010d8f77bc4dd1e5ae62e2e5aa84e44c42 excluded The two call sites switch to main_daemon_endpoint_new so the opt-in test runtime-parent seam isolates one-shot daemon coordination. Production/original/current QA already contain that helper and test seam, but those two callers still pass NULL directly. Without CBM_ENABLE_TEST_SEAMS the calls resolve to the same bootstrap endpoint, so shipped product behavior is unchanged. This is a Windows/CLI test-isolation follow-up, not a runtime parity gap.
619c6834807532b69c419454fd53074d6d10050a missing The variable-length traversal probes beyond the engine depth cap and marks the result truncated if a candidate exists beyond it. Upstream has the probe in src/cypher/cypher.c; target lacks it and the truncated carrier.
c25c16206be0d2abf9faf8a7069ef72dc554116d superseded The commit changes format-migration logging from INFO to WARN, but assigned commit b795203025596562fcfcce08c052ce782b411464 changes it back to INFO. Frozen upstream and target all show INFO at pipeline.route/format_change_reindex.
b795203025596562fcfcce08c052ce782b411464 partially represented Library default INFO is present in production and both QA refs. The final upstream also installs role-aware process policy via cbm_log_init_for_process; that startup behavior is absent from production and both QA.
0365ef94173f22677e31de98ea62dc0d00415669 missing Upstream distinguishes symlink/reparse-point skips and records ignored-file reason symlink; production and both QA silently return from safe_stat failures. Added regression exists upstream only.
24f54c0eb64c516941abee2ad0d7de758b34ac86 represented Markup embedded-script attribute selection and full definitions/imports/calls extraction are present in production and both QA, including Svelte/HTML/Astro host behavior and Astro TypeScript defaults. Regression coverage is present.
6db22aadb6e5a92b9b193608e2ac3f420e461ec3 represented VB6 marker detection, .frm/.cls disambiguation to unsupported, and regressions are present in production and both QA.
a953509275a4fa42a907f88852d62a613f27bc56 partially represented Core error-range cap/dropped-marker and parse_unusable behavior (including ObjectScript range aggregation and parallel/serial phase storage) are absent from production and both QA. MCP-only coverage wording/serialization is excluded from CLI semantic counts.
21591d51168d26f931f64d62edc36013cd1f6249 partially represented The decisive arithmetic differs: production and both QA targets return aggregate_memory_budget_bytes / physical_job_limit despite computing and logging active job count. Frozen upstream returns aggregate_memory_budget_bytes / active, where active comes from nonterminal jobs and has a floor of one. Thus symbol presence, active_jobs logging, and the shared helper do not establish parity. The upstream merge plan explicitly lists this hash as divide by active jobs rather than configured capacity and assigns daemon_application,daemon suites. The commit also adds a sequenced two-job regression for aggregate then half-aggregate slices and a test that a clean worker over-budget error passes through without a recovery retry; neither test name is in production/QA. Do not infer the separately assigned Windows job-memory-resolution change from this hash.

DeepSeek Phase1 review with batched Jev advice — 2026-10-03 UTC

Review disposition: changes requested. This is documentary parent review evidence; no host acceptance/rejection or Agent-Workflow review gate is invoked.

All 115 assignments match their disposition sets exactly, with no duplicate rows or missing evidence links. All 342 worker-manifest entries verify (runtime113, operations86, integration143). Independent Git diffs were captured for all115; capturing a diff is not semantic review.

Three official-helper API calls batch two questions each. Requests contain verbatim governing requirements, exact commit diffs, frozen source excerpts, and deterministic integrity output. Worker verdicts, worker summaries, previous Jev answers and credential values were excluded. Token sourced silently; destination verified https://api.typesafe.ai. SDK used in an isolated offline-cached uv runtime; no project install, build/test or Jenkins execution.

Six full-hash commits received bounded source review; other109 remain explicitly independently unreviewed in review-crosswalk.jsonl. No worker rows are silently changed or counted as accepted.

Findings

  • Runtime: 9724d903046626df0640ced218259cb58070e4e8 lacks committed/peak-counter guards in target diagnostics, but its claim that the normal Linux budget path reads the committed counter is too broad. Frozen target src/foundation/mem.c cbm_mem_over_budget:511-515 calls cbm_mem_rss, whose Linux branch reads OS /proc RSS first. Keep missing diagnostics adaptation and upstream-only heap-switch applicability distinct. No runtime failure reproduced.
  • Runtime: d70b79417978a9f3ab0d1aa849879dbf049793cf changes internal/cbm/result_spill.c, absent in all frozen CLI targets. Bounded seam exclusion is supportable for this exact MSan guard; surrounding shared memory work remains separate.
  • Operations: b04f54506ab42eddcbd89232a0d47d8355edd596 is not closed by table-lookup property similarity. Target internal/cbm/cbm.c:1129-1300 builds offsets for cbm_subtract_macro_invocation_regions; upstream diff optimizes cbm_refine_regions_with_pp_lines and supplies allocation fallback. Exact changed caller/refinement mechanism remains unresolved.
  • Operations: f6afd6138e605365a76d065d04521ec2037bed3d removes MCP title accessor and changes the upstream generated Pi label. Target src/operations/tool_catalog.c retains cbm_tool_catalog_title. No governing CLI title-removal policy supplied: exclude direct MCP edits, keep the neutral policy question unresolved.
  • Integration: 00411ce7bc41995783bfb16aada673515585446d should be recorded as missing changed Linux alias behavior, not merely partly represented because surrounding security functions exist. Target activation_posix_walk_path is Apple-only and returns NULL for non-symlink aliases; upstream admits Linux and /home and continues for ordinary directories. All three frozen CLI targets have the same relevant pre-change behavior.
  • Integration: 8f3c15044b8200a15ee1895c5127f4bf117da493 can be excluded at the direct generated-OpenCode-plugin seam: target install branch emits instructions/skills, generator file/call is absent. This does not approve all16 excluded integration rows or establish broader OpenCode parity.

Jev results and decision effects

Batch / question Model Choice Full probability distribution Advice effect
runtime / counter_guard_scope jev-1.13.0 diagnostics_only (confidence 0.43) diagnostics_only=0.58, represented=0.34, budget_and_diagnostics=0.07, insufficient=0.01 Narrow 9724d903 to missing diagnostics/allocator wrap guard adaptation; normal Linux budget pressure is OS-RSS based. No reproduced runtime defect. Do not import upstream heap switch by default.
runtime / spill_exclusion jev-1.13.0 excluded (confidence 0.75) insufficient=0.05, shared_missing=0.12, excluded=0.83 Bounded exclusion for this exact internal/cbm/result_spill.c MSan guard; not a verdict on adjoining neutral memory commits.
ops / table_optimization_equivalence jev-1.13.0 partial_property (confidence 0.53) whole_represented=0.34, insufficient=0.00, partial_property=0.66, missing=0.00 Do not promote property-level representation to whole-commit closure. Target region subtraction and upstream per-line preprocessor refinement are different callers/mechanisms; preserve unresolved exact delta.
ops / title_policy_scope jev-1.13.0 exclude_mcp_preserve_policy (confidence 0.75) exclude_mcp_preserve_policy=0.81, represented=0.09, insufficient=0.08, remove_cli_title=0.02 Preserve MCP/adapter seam exclusion and explicit neutral CLI title policy question. No title removal implemented or authorized by upstream diff alone.
integration / linux_alias_behavior jev-1.13.0 missing_changed_behavior (confidence 0.55) missing_changed_behavior=0.66, represented=0.20, partial_changed_behavior=0.13, insufficient=0.01 Correct 00411ce7 changed-behavior disposition to missing at all frozen CLI targets: Apple-only alias branch excludes Linux, and ordinary directory continuation is absent. Shared surrounding security code is distinct.
integration / opencode_adapter_exclusion jev-1.13.0 bounded_exclusion (confidence 0.69) shared_missing=0.17, represented=0.03, insufficient=0.04, bounded_exclusion=0.76 Retain bounded direct generator-seam exclusion for 8f3c1504: target installs instruction/skill assets and has no generator call; do not generalize to all 16 upstream-only-path rows.

The counter and table-optimization answers retain substantial represented probability (0.34). They are split advice, not a correctness measure. The review findings rest on exact functions and changed callers; no confidence threshold grants acceptance.

Required continuation

  • Correct runtime committed-memory/budget claim.
  • Keep ops b04f5450 partial at exact mechanism level, f6afd613 policy unresolved; resolve other explicit ops remainders.
  • Correct integration 00411ce7 to missing changed Linux alias behavior; function-level review for at least29 partial rows and1 unresolved row remains required.
  • Do not count integration16 seam exclusions as independently approved based on single worker Jev call or this one sampled exclusion.
  • Independently review other109 full hashes before whole phase semantic closure.
  • Host collection/verification binding is separate from source review, runtime Jenkins and acceptance.

All worker scopes were processed, but integration explicitly did not complete function-level reading beyond its activation cluster. Its29 partial rows and1 unresolved row require deeper reads. Operations retains four explicit remainders. Runtime finish returned verification_required due missing host acceptance-command binding. Worker idle, saved rows and Jev execution do not establish semantic closure, runtime validation, review approval, acceptance or integration.

Evidence

Exact requests: runtime-request-payload.json, ops-request-payload.json, integration-request-payload.json. Full results: corresponding *-response.json. Deterministic receipt: deterministic-integrity.json. Graph source/snippets/traces/coverage: graph/. Exact Git source excerpts are embedded in requests; target-scope-receipt.json records additional full-blob symbol checks. All115 independent primary diffs: *-diffs/. Full-hash independent-review crosswalk: review-crosswalk.jsonl. Machine-readable finding/distribution/advice-use record: review.json.

Graph generations match recorded exact-worktree indexes. Partial internal/cbm/cbm.c and CLI/activation paths were verified from Git source; no negative claim rests on graph absence. Broad coverage search was discovery-only, not an exhaustive pagination claim. Initial multi-path coverage invocation failed syntax; per-path retries succeeded, both outputs retained.

Luna low pilot20 launch — 2026-10-03 UTC

Independent verification continues with a bounded20-commit Luna low pilot in managed terminal, run CBM-RECON-LUNA-LOW-PILOT20-20261003. Its exact assignment excludes six already-reviewed hashes and is grouped by shared behavior;89 other unreviewed commits remain outside scope. The canonical308 pilot section owns current plan. Actual Codex low-model argv/Jev-token inheritance and ready exact full-index generation were verified. Existing comparisons remain discovery only, and detailed batched Jev/source/checkpoint evidence is required. Completed DeepSeek panes managed terminal/managed terminal closed; runtime pane was already absent. All worktrees and saved handoffs retained. Launch is not semantic closure.

Cleanup and pilot outcome — 2026-10-03 UTC

Original idle Luna high panes managed terminal/managed terminal/managed terminal closed; evidence/worktrees retained. History still has an unfinished checkpoint. The pilot finalized partial: 6 incompletely examined,14 untouched,0 credited as fully verified. All20 plus89 outside scope remain open. Canonical308 cleanup section records exact resumption boundaries and evidence locations. Pilot pane managed terminal remains idle/open.

Luna medium independent batch20 launch — 2026-10-03 UTC

User authorized a different20-commit comparison with Luna medium. Run CBM-RECON-LUNA-MEDIUM20-20261003 owns20 independently unreviewed runtime hashes, disjoint from the previous pilot20 and six parent-reviewed rows. Exact assignment, prepared prompt and launch receipts: local run evidence. Worker uses interactive managed terminal, codex - luna-review-medium20, with GPT-6-Luna medium, sourced Jev environment and batched primary-evidence guidance.

New isolated worktree full index failed with only a generic pipeline error; clean failed worktree retained for diagnosis. Reused idle former runtime worker worktree local run evidence, frozen QA559214af, ready full index generation2026-10-03T01:07:59Z,26764nodes/129401edges,91 partial files. Fresh status/root/coverage generation and unchanged clean Git baseline verified. No shared daemon/cache changes. Launch does not establish source closure, runtime validation, review or acceptance; detailed checkpoints are required.

DeepSeek pilot continuation recovery — 2026-10-03 UTC

User switched old pilot pane managed terminal to DeepSeek Flash and requested execution help. Transcript showed unsupported call: exec: JSON function calls replayed Luna's old executor format. Direct exec_command with pwd succeeded after corrective guidance; no permission change was needed. Prepared external successor CBM-RECON-DEEPSEEK-PILOT20-CONTINUE-20261003 preserves finalized partial predecessor and owns the same20 still-unverified pilot hashes, disjoint from Luna medium20. Exact clean frozen source and full ready graph generation reverified; live worker Jev credential inheritance confirmed without values. New evidence must remain in successor run; prior evidence is immutable. Renamed pane/worker codex - deepseek-pilot20-continue, durably steered and resumed with mandatory acknowledgement. Recovery receipts/prompt at local run evidence. No source closure, Jenkins, review or acceptance credited from recovery.

Pilot20 verification and ops20 successor — 2026-10-03 UTC

New DeepSeek ops20 run CBM-RECON-DEEPSEEK-BATCH2-20-20261003 assigned in managed terminal; disjoint from prior pilot20 and Luna medium runtime20. Prior pilot20 independent review requests changes: all20 rows assessed,4 bounded whole-commit source reviews completed,16 full-hash remainders retained. Corrected absent-alias, YAML indicator, fd-capture guard and Codex policy claims; found missing original CLI regressions and stale checkpoint checksum. Canonical308 verification section owns source corrections. Full crosswalk/snapshots/CBM/Jev evidence in parent run evidence/pilot20-independent-review/. No runtime validation or acceptance.

Ops20 and Luna medium20 review consolidation — 2026-10-03 UTC

Both completed worker submissions received documentary changes-requested reviews. Exact sets and manifests33/31 pass. Four bounded whole-commit source dispositions verified;36 full-hash remainders retained across parent evidence ops20-independent-review/ and medium20-independent-review/. Canonical308 “Finished ops20 and Luna medium20 independent reviews” owns detailed source corrections, prerequisite grouping, Jev distributions and precise limits; BACKLOG tracks remaining work. No global semantic parity, runtime validation or acceptance claimed. Workers remain idle/open; full merge/constituent audit is incomplete.

Ops20 followup-v2 review — 2026-10-03 UTC

DeepSeek applied bounded corrections in new followup-v2 evidence; exact18 rows and 40 manifest entries pass integrity. Documentary changes requested: checkpoint claims18 done/no remaining while detailed rows explicitly retain full-hunk, caller, regression and CLI adaptation mappings. No additional whole-commit source closure credited;18 operations and18 runtime remainders still open. Parent review and exact full-hash row gaps saved in run evidence/ops20-followup-v2-review/review.json. Durable steer79d95426-9418-4e7a-879e-7c78c0b2a40d asks DeepSeek to continue actual per-hunk/frozen-target verification in followup-v3, preserving originals. No implementation, runtime validation or acceptance credited.

Ops20 followup-v3 review — 2026-10-03 UTC

Manifest129 entries passes. Worker now preserves18 partial obligations honestly; 315-hunk mechanical inventory is discovery, not semantic closure. Zero new whole-commit dispositions verified. Concrete d4931241adaef732066afb5ebf1cb225e2474403 mapping defect: function disposition cites extract_class_def while changed source hunk is in push_method_def; shared extraction test hunks require regression review, not generic MCP-only exclusion. Parent evidence/ops20-followup-v3-review/review.json retains exact18 remainders. Durable steer41c60a51-08a1-4efb-bbc5-7bce885b1856 narrows continuation to that one commit’s three hunks, actual caller/dependency chain, frozen-target behavior and Scala fixture/registration. Other17 operations and18 runtime reviews remain pending. No runtime/acceptance credit.

Current checkpoint: Scala source comparison verified — 2026-10-03 UTC

DeepSeek is idle after followup-v4. Parent independently verified all three original hunks of d4931241adaef732066afb5ebf1cb225e2474403: missing in frozen production bbabc073, original QA5fe820df and later QA559214af. This is a completed source comparison, not an implemented or runtime-validated port. Worker manifest137 entries passes without failures; original/v2/v3 evidence remains preserved.

internal/cbm/extract_defs.c:push_method_def still limits class-prefix composition to JAVA/KOTLIN in all three targets; upstream adds SCALA. Exact shared dependencies extract_route_from_decorators, spring_class_route_prefix and join_route_paths are present. Prefix and join helper bodies match; the omitted language guard prevents composition for Scala JAX-RS methods. Parent qualified snippets, both-direction traces, coverage receipts and frozen source are in run evidence ops20-followup-v4-review/. This corrects v3's unrelated extract_class_def mapping.

Both TEST(handles_jaxrs_scala) and its suite registration are absent from target tests/test_edge_types_probe.c. This is shared extraction coverage, not MCP-only; existing Java/Kotlin route and Scala extraction fixtures do not assert the original three composed Scala routes. Prerequisite 041eb99c11692b93d43ea72c884cc50c51285db5 is an ancestor of all three targets. Smallest future adaptation: extend the existing guard with CBM_LANG_SCALA and add original fixture/registration using the existing harness. Acceptance must assert HANDLES edges and exact /billingAccount, /billingAccount/{id} and /billingAccount/{id}/attachment/{attachmentId}/content, covering empty and nonempty method paths. Existing Jenkinsfile suites: edge_types_probe, extraction, route_canon; not run or scheduled here.

Worker Jev model jev-1.13.0 full distributions: source_gap_reality: real_functional_gap .68, insufficient_evidence .24, language_support_difference .08; test_applicability: inapplicable .66, directly_adaptable .32, insufficient_evidence .02. Parent rejects the test-inapplicability advice against actual shared harness and source evidence. Payload/response/effect remain in worker followup-v4; advisory results do not establish review, acceptance or runtime correctness.

Current two-batch checkpoint supersedes their earlier18+18 remainder count: operations3 whole-commit source dispositions verified (two represented/absence-of- defect plus this missing comparison),17 exact full-hash remainders in parent ops20-followup-v4-review/review.json; runtime2 verified,18 remainders in medium20-independent-review/review.json. Thus5 reviewed dispositions and35 pending whole-commit source reviews across these40 assignments. These are batch-local counts, not global parity or feature completion. Earlier pilot16 and other Phase1, merge-history and old canonical-row obligations remain separate and open.

Canonical BACKLOG tracks continuation; this308 document owns disposition context; UPSTREAM_RECONCILIATION_REPORT_20261002.md consolidates the checkpoint. Full-hash machine crosswalks remain run evidence, not a second repository ledger. DeepSeek pane managed terminal remains idle/open; no new assignment sent in this checkpoint. No builds, tests, Jenkins triggers, implementation, push, main integration or acceptance.

Ten recorded merged/adapted tasks independently confirmed — 2026-10-03 UTC

User selected ten historical completed/represented tasks for bounded verification, not ten outstanding-gap candidates. 10 selected,10 source-confirmed,0 remaining in this selected batch. Current release-tooling target: 327dccc04d749892dddf19ca4dc62bf28a5131c8; current local main also inspected at ef623b598d1f355043595024b114bd90074e1d31. Current refs are separate from frozen production/original/later QA comparisons. Five original local commits are ancestors of release-tooling; five adapted task implementations/tests survive via bed05b9947bb10959cbf112b8051b80450145304 with different commit identities.

Recorded task Full original local evidence commit Confirmation
Go selector/struct-field binding e497dd0c5fed0d95a9ea1a7e49b43e78ffc68a91 Member-shape fields propagate to both resolver paths; genuine selectors bind fields while bare Go names are vetoed. Changed handle_usages policy call gains state argument without removing member bit.
Daemon activation, UI refusal and Unicode roots 6e289d5a31da737cf5aa542561c5a525ac727131 Directory checks use cbm_path_info_utf8 instead of narrow stat; bare start tolerates refused UI with warning, explicit UI requests fail and do not open browser. Later JSON/status handling adds behavior without removing this branch.
Cypher WITH/star scope and capacity a7721244856d114d2c42e49b07667c2f14acc67b WITH uses CYP_MAX_VARS bound while RETURN uses CBM_SZ_32; duplicate pattern variables projected once; RETURN * after WITH uses projected aliases. Relevant bodies match local post-image.
Registry receiver-chain guard e52b31cdd2808204672de378ce7353b87bb4a504 Uppercase type roots normalize :: and must match candidate parent segments; lowercase and bare roots retain lookup, all-caps underscore constants excepted. Both return paths call guard.
Daemon cohort conflict handoff retry 3036e1954ddbe08d749bc416b28aaaadfc4e53ad Conflicts retried until caller deadline with no guard retained between attempts; retry counter proves waiter actually met holder. Later ownership-aware mutation reservation changes another path, not the preserved acquire retry. Scope only this vertical, not entire24-file3036 commit.
Windows YAML removal filesystem guards 523d398d7c5ef570639de8e35624b1a1e613189c Original helper and both Windows guard test bodies preserved; both registered. Separate POSIX test evolved to refuse foreign-owned rather than every symlink, without removing these Windows cases.
Version-cohort distinct-cache-root handoff 01af5cb255608801158dfd29b5222e5c7afc8782 Fixture helpers and both added test bodies preserved with suite registration; cross-cache quiescence and Windows canonical separator contract asserted. Native Windows qualification pending.
Complexity traversal determinism 43d3a2103f343a68e03674005aa3aa055127bc7d Entire production file identical to original adapted post-image. Canonical order includes QN,path,start/end,name,label; test signature retains duplicate-QN identity fields.
Razor .razor/.cshtml discovery and routes 5b1bc08538e132d9c9a43abfa37bb4be21c57caf Both suffixes mapped to C#; explicit @page absolute route stored on implicit Module as GET; route pass includes Module in label list. Modified functions and route pass file preserve post-image.
Embedded Svelte/HTML/Astro script structure f8971e7a6ac81576c6b8823c35e10830723e6be0 Entire production import/spec files identical to adapted post-image. Emits defs/imports/calls for active sibling hosts; rejects src/inert types; Astro TS grammar. Existing host-control assertions corrected0→1; string-literal split in added HTML fixture preserves contents.

Verification used original local changed hunks/post-images, exact current source, full relevant changed functions/callers and test bodies/registrations. Material CBM qualified snippets and both-direction traces completed pagination;27-path coverage and exact frozen/current source fallback retained. Go member bits reach both serial/parallel consumers; Cypher alias/dedup/capacity fixtures exist; all five receiver-chain controls registered; cohort retry counter prevents vacuous handoff proof. Windows YAML/cohort fixtures remain source-confirmed with native Windows qualification pending. Complexity comparison includes duplicate-QN identity fields. Razor includes discovery→Module route→HANDLES chain. Embedded active/inert fixtures match shared structure behavior; old sibling-host control changed0→1 consistently.

Source confirmation is attached to the named vertical, not a whole combined local commit or all upstream constituent commits. In particular3036e195 is reviewed here only for daemon cohort handoff retry. Explicit original upstream mappings consulted: Go 349aecba9528427fa635975e246f5b8959b14f30 and cohort retry 9104feb67f78959e64ddff78d236e0dea475a434. Do not invent one-upstream-commit-per- task cardinality or subtract ten from the678 ancestry gap. This batch confirms prior absorption; it adds no source implementation and does not change the separate 35 pending ops/runtime whole-commit source reviews or close the global367/311 audit.

Evidence: Sol R2 evidence/recorded-absorbed-ten-review/ owns exact10 rows, local/current source snapshots, function comparisons/evolved diffs, graph receipts, coverage, ancestry/provenance and hash manifest. The earlier outstanding-gap ten selection is superseded and uncredited; its work remains discovery evidence only. One primary-evidence batched Jev request, jev-1.13.0: fixture_consistency supports_port .97, contradicts_port .03, insufficient_evidence .00; evidence_boundary source_representation_only1.00, runtime_complete/not_represented/insufficient_evidence .00. Advice corroborated fixture consistency and source-only boundary.

Jenkins51 still running at observation with exact327dccc0 checkout. No fresh passing runtime result or host acceptance claimed. No new build/test execution locally, source ports, rebase, upstream history merge, push or main integration. GitHub behind count remains ancestry-based; this selected confirmation queue is now complete.