Skip to content

Commit 327dccc

Browse files
committed
docs: integrate upstream reconciliation checkpoint into release-tooling
2 parents ea4335f + c6cc5bf commit 327dccc

4 files changed

Lines changed: 2869 additions & 194 deletions

File tree

‎BACKLOG.md‎

Lines changed: 166 additions & 38 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -2,10 +2,6 @@
22

33
## Resolved
44

5-
- [x] Installer fork defaults and complete AST/watcher/macro/COUNT integration
6-
landed via PR #12; Windows hook/macOS deadline repairs landed via PR #13
7-
(`bbabc073`). Historical Jenkins evidence remains revision-specific.
8-
95
- [x] Release-tooling implements deferred npm/PyPI/public publication,
106
removes Claude automation, enables CodeRabbit, adds Linux-only prerelease
117
selection. Package migration is deferred until exact fork assets and checksums
@@ -27,41 +23,116 @@
2723
`cbm_operation_session_state_free()` before freeing each session. Valgrind
2824
identified the omission through `test_daemon_application_free_releases_live_watch_once`
2925
as 80 direct + 107 indirect lost bytes.
26+
- [x] Validated local `release-tooling` through Jenkins job #34 (full gate
27+
passed at `37dd63ba`). PR #12 merged with installer fix `c9841610`
28+
(install.sh and install.ps1 default to `ngallodev/codebase-memory-cli`).
29+
Resolved thread `PRRT_kwDORjrg5c6n5KE9` 2026-10-01.
30+
- [x] Validated complete AST slice `77ab4bea` / `7707c9d7` in shared
31+
release-tooling Jenkins job #34 (full gate passed at `37dd63ba`); all
32+
definition and auxiliary stacks ported to main.
33+
- [x] Added opt-in, single-run index metrics for performance diagnosis via
34+
`index --metrics-out` flag (`0f5a84bc`). Coverage in src/operations/index.c
35+
and tests/test_index_resilience.c. Merged via PR #12.
36+
- [x] Fixed the PR #12 Windows/macOS CI failures in `bbabc073` (PR #13).
37+
The Windows hook-lifecycle test now uses the fork's installed binary name
38+
(`tests/test_cli.c`), and the macOS connection-cap test gets a 30 s server
39+
hello deadline (`tests/test_daemon_runtime.c`). Jenkins #35 and full GitHub
40+
CI passed. The pre-commit hook also clang-formatted both files.
3041

3142
## Open
3243

33-
- [ ] Reconcile interactive upstream assessment and independent completeness
34-
audit (`CBM-UPSTREAM-ASSESS-20261002`, `CBM-UPSTREAM-VERIFY-20261002`).
35-
Both workers running in pre-indexed isolated trees; frozen MCP `96c3f41c`,
36-
CLI `9cb5cc21`, 19 new / 367 ancestry-differing nonmerge commits. Canonical
37-
applicability/vertical classification and verification remain pending.
38-
39-
- [x] Closed daemon/cache interactive workers after verifying committed clean
40-
candidates `028a4bfb` / `fa5a180b`; sealed partial run receipts, preserved
41-
branches/bundles/evidence and removed only their two worktrees.
42-
- [ ] Review/integrate those candidates and run parent-scheduled Jenkins;
43-
daemon AC-005 additionally needs a direct CLI diagnostic assertion.
44-
45-
- [x] Specified all three selected verticals and prepared external interactive
46-
GPT-6-Luna Agent Runs at frozen base `51aa7a86`, each in an independent
47-
worktree with full permissions/approval never. See the latest 308 dispatch record.
48-
- [x] Launched all three interactive GPT-6-Luna workers in Herdr's right-hand
49-
column (`wC:p5`, `wC:p6`, `wC:p7`), bound to durable external Agent Runs.
50-
Full permissions/approval never verified; all three acknowledged steering
51-
and are observed working. Implementation/Jenkins/review remain pending.
52-
53-
- [ ] Next upstream slice 1: adapt `ed76cf8e` daemon cache-ownership safety
54-
across eager shutdown and quiescence callback; preserve foreign/unknown
55-
sessions and existing exclusive mutation authority. Jenkins only.
56-
- [ ] Next upstream slice 2: adapt `8093d10b` + `ea6fa49f` as a complete
57-
binary `.res` / ReScript admission, traversal, scanner and checksum slice.
58-
- [ ] Next upstream slice 3: adapt `46015320` to preserve `_config.db` and
59-
`_cross_repo.db` across project-index list/count/reset; share exact-name
60-
classification with cross-repo enumeration.
61-
- [ ] Complete full 348-commit semantic disposition and fresh exact-worktree
62-
graph indexes for both repos; this top-three selection is a bounded shortlist.
63-
- [ ] Finish `manage-adr` alias/help and explicit outline parity: existing ADR
64-
candidate failed Jenkins lint before tests and is not integrated.
44+
- [ ] Complete semantic reconciliation of all frozen upstream merges and
45+
constituent commits. Sol R2 inventories all 923 merges / 2,429 non-merges;
46+
311 merges / 367 non-merges differ by ancestry. It reconciles the older 87
47+
canonical rows, but 356 non-merge whole-commit remainders and all 311 merge
48+
dispositions remain unresolved. Census, patch ID and titles are not coverage.
49+
See [the canonical source audit](docs/UPSTREAM_308_CANDIDATE_AUDIT_20260912.md).
50+
- [ ] Finish independent reconciliation of the Luna team evidence. All R3
51+
handoffs were partial; all 40 declared checksums and exact 111/170/86 assignments
52+
were verified and archived. R4 successors continue interactively in Herdr
53+
`wC:pB` / `wC:pC` / `wC:pD`. The 2026-10-02T23:53Z checkpoint contains 54
54+
non-unresolved worker claims and 313 unresolved claims; no whole-commit coverage
55+
or completion is inferred. Parent retains 356 whole non-merge / 311 merge
56+
remainders pending exact source/test review. Full hashes are in the canonical
57+
ledger; the [consolidated report](docs/UPSTREAM_RECONCILIATION_REPORT_20261002.md)
58+
records provenance, source corrections, scope and validation limits.
59+
Parallel split followup: `CBM-RECON-ADAPTER-LOW-20261003` ran Luna low in
60+
Herdr `wC:pE` on 16 explicitly released, previously unreviewed runtime hashes;
61+
all 16 were source-reviewed, 8 closing as adapter-only and 8 retaining
62+
shared-semantic remainders. The consolidation auditor verified the run's
63+
67-file manifest, confirmed every changed path is `src/mcp/**` or
64+
`tests/test_mcp.c` (that subtree exists upstream and is absent from
65+
production and both QA trees), and confirmed the 16 are upstream ancestors
66+
absent from those three CLI trees.
67+
After the Phase1 transfer, original runtime retains 39 hashes; all 367 hashes still have one
68+
effective primary owner. The transfer, acknowledgement, index and launch
69+
receipts are in the new run's evidence. Completed work was not reassigned.
70+
Phase1 successor plan now transfers 115 still-unreviewed runtime hashes to
71+
three prepared DeepSeek Flash assignments (39/26/50 disjoint groups), preserving the
72+
exact releases and completed work. Unstarted low2 was retired; corrected low1
73+
finished partial with detailed handoff and its pane closed. See the canonical
74+
Phase1 plan. Native assignment delivery failed: all three returned predecessor
75+
reports, including after persisted steering and direct follow-ups. Sessions
76+
were stopped; zero assigned comparisons or correlated worker acknowledgements
77+
were established by that failed attempt. Interactive recovery now runs Codex
78+
`--model deepseek-flash` in Herdr `wC:pF` / `wC:pG` / `wC:pH`, with correct
79+
worker-issued run/cwd/count launch acknowledgements and actual process Jev-token
80+
inheritance verified. The same 115 hashes remain the comparison scope; see the
81+
canonical interactive recovery section. No completion/acceptance is inferred.
82+
- [ ] Review additional bounded missing behaviors: malformed confidence parsing
83+
`62b44519c68b403ea44d9a85ba8ee74cddee66e6` (first additional localized candidate),
84+
route handler position `592894a4387a50e1d128ff6a2695ff48f8cc32a5`, late annotation
85+
arguments `c36b4fbc446f9085704a6073b81ec743fd4180fc`, and client-registry selection
86+
`1e25d962d69999438229b0562d44ea60e97f5456`. Group route followups with slice 5;
87+
review full tests/dependencies before broadening implementation scope.
88+
- [ ] Resolve daemon memory policy before selecting active-job division
89+
`21591d51168d26f931f64d62edc36013cd1f6249`. Fork uses fixed worker-capacity
90+
division; upstream active divisor is not represented. Review aggregate
91+
reservation invariants, separate Windows job-memory capability hunks from
92+
MCP adapter policy in merge `2b8bd0c065c1d2728994fddc1683a66f70745748`.
93+
- [x] Daemon/cache/ReScript candidates and ADR alias/outline are integrated
94+
in local QA `559214af28ce2d6f5d6ec86662f6871316d28b45`, per acknowledged
95+
parent steering and source comparison. Candidate implementation is separate
96+
from runtime validation, acceptance and production-main integration.
97+
- [ ] Finish parent review and shared Jenkins validation for that QA revision
98+
and its later repairs. No current Jenkins success or acceptance is established
99+
by Sol R2. The pre-commit candidate retains formatting-only behavior; candidate
100+
ancestry does not establish production Git-child environment isolation.
101+
- [ ] NEW upstream slice 1: Cypher OPTIONAL relationship fallback growth,
102+
`2fabaa2b877986bdededb4f4f78e9a31014c6fdf`; existing append helper avoids
103+
the per-binding overflow. Jenkins `cypher`.
104+
- [ ] NEW upstream slice 2: SQLite zero-cell trailing interior-page packing,
105+
`e7324bb6904c6d0a295b956e83c8585219198358`.
106+
Jenkins `sqlite_writer,graph_buffer,pipeline`.
107+
- [ ] NEW upstream slice 3: Swift scanner shift widths, regression and integrity,
108+
`3f831936b5f3012d13175e7c97326165efecefad` ->
109+
`a2ea711c29560511eb8467bea7ad309ebf500d6e` ->
110+
`e8204092333ee1c38cd681a81abb36f125288894`.
111+
Jenkins `language,extraction,grammar_regression` and vendored integrity;
112+
preserve QA's ReScript manifest/checksum row.
113+
- [ ] NEW upstream slice 4: ancestor ignore chain with correct anchoring,
114+
`c8184ed94887a6b5e130726885b44a07c63a47b7` ->
115+
`282fbfcdabfec79c19c36f5bec5f75c22eb36df5`.
116+
Jenkins `discover,gitignore,git_context,pipeline`.
117+
- [ ] NEW upstream slice 5: deterministic route selection and >64 proto services,
118+
`6b48097471e8d1a3e5cf16447304899a21e12d7a`; adapt route hunks without
119+
importing upstream memory core or unrelated tests. Jenkins `pipeline,parallel`.
120+
Ranking is bounded by inspected source; unresolved work can change priorities.
121+
- [ ] Evaluate GitHub ancestry reconciliation after semantic review. Adapted
122+
commits have different IDs; documentation cannot alter GitHub's behind count.
123+
An upstream ancestry merge requires explicit review of missing/excluded changes
124+
and merge-resolution behavior. Do not use an `ours` merge to conceal unresolved
125+
work, rewrite published history, or declare the fork globally caught up.
126+
- [ ] Clarify CLI coverage array syntax and missing-path results. At dev CLI /
127+
project `tmp-cbm-upstream-sol-20261002`, generation `2026-10-02T17:30:32Z`,
128+
JSON/comma `--paths` values became literal nonexistent paths with
129+
`no_recorded_issue` / `freshness=missing`. Repeated `--paths` / `--scopes`
130+
flags work. Document this spelling and make missing paths prominent.
131+
- [ ] Align trace truncation with documented pagination. `extract_func_def`
132+
both-direction trace at limit 100 returned 127 total callees and truncation
133+
without a next cursor; limit 300 returned all 127 callees / four callers.
134+
Emit a cursor or document the limit restriction. Exact receipts are in Sol R2
135+
evidence; these are observed CLI issues, with no source fix in this audit.
65136
- [ ] Retain validation gaps: live watcher scheduler integration and AST
66137
allocation-failure injection are not established by completed helper tests.
67138
- [ ] PR #14 at `1ce4e164` has failing GitHub diagnostic, macOS LSan,
@@ -83,8 +154,17 @@
83154
CLI-only process model before porting.
84155
- `e5c17de6` and `b04f5450` coverage correctness/performance; manually
85156
reconcile against the fork's changed coverage implementation.
86-
- MCP-only output/search/pagination/compact-output commits are intentionally
87-
excluded from this backlog item.
157+
- Exclude direct MCP-only adapter imports at the source seam; shared neutral
158+
capability parity still requires source verification. Historical exclusions
159+
are superseded by the canonical audit where mixed hunks were found.
160+
161+
- [ ] Assess a lightweight path for store-only test execution. Run just the
162+
store test binaries after shared prerequisites are built, while keeping the
163+
existing incremental suite selection and full-suite gates intact. First
164+
inspect the runner's configuration and targets to determine whether this is
165+
already supported. The `cbm-upstream-count-20260929` focused run passed 96
166+
store tests, but a cold worktree spent several minutes compiling shared
167+
prerequisites including `lsp_all.c`.
88168

89169
- [ ] Classify residual Heaptrack allocations in the neutral daemon test path.
90170
- Baseline evidence: Heaptrack reported 91 leaked allocations across the
@@ -111,3 +191,51 @@
111191
- [ ] Reconcile the GPT-6.1-Sol full upstream merge/constituent audit
112192
`CBM-UPSTREAM-SOL-20261002-R2`, including ungrouped verticals and the next
113193
five recommended slices. Do not count running audit work as coverage.
194+
195+
- [ ] Complete DeepSeek Phase1 independent source review. All115 assignments and
196+
342 evidence-manifest entries pass integrity checks; six bounded semantic
197+
questions were reviewed in three batched Jev requests. Documentary result is
198+
changes requested: narrow runtime `9724d903046626df0640ced218259cb58070e4e8`
199+
committed-counter/budget claim, preserve operations
200+
`b04f54506ab42eddcbd89232a0d47d8355edd596` mechanism remainder and
201+
`f6afd6138e605365a76d065d04521ec2037bed3d` title-policy question, and classify
202+
integration `00411ce7bc41995783bfb16aada673515585446d` changed Linux alias
203+
behavior as missing. Other109 hashes remain independently unreviewed; integration
204+
29 partial rows plus1 unresolved row require function-level work. Exact hashes,
205+
requests, full distributions and source corrections are in the canonical308 review
206+
section and consolidated report; machine crosswalk stays handoff evidence. No
207+
completion/acceptance or semantic-closure counter advanced.
208+
209+
- [x] Gather Luna low pilot and successor source evidence; independent review is
210+
recorded in canonical308. Remaining16 full-hash whole-commit reviews are tracked
211+
below; former launch-only20-unverified snapshot is superseded.
212+
213+
- [ ] Complete Luna medium runtime20 whole-commit source review: documentary
214+
changes requested; manifest31 passes, two bounded source dispositions verified,
215+
18 exact full-hash remainders in parent evidence/medium20-independent-review/review.json.
216+
Group262ab012 telemetry with3507d955 Windows OS hard cap; no runtime/acceptance credit.
217+
Canonical308 finished-batch review owns corrections.
218+
- [ ] Diagnose generic full-index pipeline failure for clean frozen worktree
219+
`/tmp/cbm-recon-luna-medium20-20261003`; logs preserved in medium20 staging.
220+
Worker safely uses verified existing runtime graph; no daemon changes made.
221+
222+
- [x] Review resumed DeepSeek pilot20 submission; four bounded source dispositions
223+
verified and16 retained unresolved (see following task). Worker completion is not acceptance.
224+
225+
- [ ] Resolve prior DeepSeek pilot20 independent review changes:16 exact full-hash
226+
whole-commit remainders in parent evidence/pilot20-independent-review/review.json.
227+
Correct false absent-alias/YAML/fd-guard/Codex claims, map missing CLI regressions,
228+
and preserve stale worker checksum failure; four source reviews credited, no
229+
runtime/acceptance claims. Canonical308 verification section owns corrections.
230+
- [ ] Complete remaining17 DeepSeek ops20 whole-commit source reviews, exact hashes
231+
in parent evidence/ops20-followup-v4-review/review.json. Three source dispositions
232+
verified, including missing Scala route composition d4931241. Preserve56516eff
233+
recursive-grep fallback correction,26650255/f339aa62 dependencies, separate
234+
e5c17de6 unchanged cap context and canonical SQL/stale refusal policy obligations.
235+
- [x] Review followup-v2/v3 evidence and record their semantic limits; v3 hunk
236+
inventory is discovery only. Followup-v4 corrects wrong-function/test exclusion
237+
for d4931241; other17 full-hash semantic mappings remain pending above.
238+
- [x] Independently verify d4931241adaef732066afb5ebf1cb225e2474403 source comparison:
239+
all3 hunks missing across production and both frozen QA refs. Applicable shared
240+
Scala regression/harness verified; prerequisite041eb99c11692b93d43ea72c884cc50c51285db5
241+
present. Future implementation/Jenkins/acceptance remain unperformed.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)