Skip to content

Commit b05c18e

Browse files
committed
docs: record ops and runtime batch review limits
1 parent e8ea5a7 commit b05c18e

3 files changed

Lines changed: 78 additions & 5 deletions

File tree

‎BACKLOG.md‎

Lines changed: 11 additions & 5 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -207,9 +207,11 @@ completion/acceptance or semantic-closure counter advanced.
207207
All20 remain open for complete independent verification; resume through a successor
208208
run, retaining sealed evidence. See canonical308 cleanup/partial checkpoint.
209209

210-
- [ ] Review Luna medium independent runtime20 batch evidence from
211-
`CBM-RECON-LUNA-MEDIUM20-20261003`; assignment disjoint from prior pilot20.
212-
Launch/index receipt in canonical308 launch section; no closure credited.
210+
- [ ] Complete Luna medium runtime20 whole-commit source review: documentary
211+
changes requested; manifest31 passes, two bounded source dispositions verified,
212+
18 exact full-hash remainders in parent evidence/medium20-independent-review/review.json.
213+
Group262ab012 telemetry with3507d955 Windows OS hard cap; no runtime/acceptance credit.
214+
Canonical308 finished-batch review owns corrections.
213215
- [ ] Diagnose generic full-index pipeline failure for clean frozen worktree
214216
`/tmp/cbm-recon-luna-medium20-20261003`; logs preserved in medium20 staging.
215217
Worker safely uses verified existing runtime graph; no daemon changes made.
@@ -223,5 +225,9 @@ completion/acceptance or semantic-closure counter advanced.
223225
Correct false absent-alias/YAML/fd-guard/Codex claims, map missing CLI regressions,
224226
and preserve stale worker checksum failure; four source reviews credited, no
225227
runtime/acceptance claims. Canonical308 verification section owns corrections.
226-
- [ ] Independently review NEW ops20 successor
227-
`CBM-RECON-DEEPSEEK-BATCH2-20-20261003`; exact assignment disjoint from prior40.
228+
- [ ] Complete DeepSeek ops20 whole-commit source review: documentary changes
229+
requested; manifest33 passes, two bounded source dispositions verified,18 exact
230+
full-hash remainders in parent evidence/ops20-independent-review/review.json. Correct
231+
56516eff recursive-grep fallback, group26650255 redesign/f339aa62 scope prerequisites,
232+
separate e5c17de6 unchanged cap context and canonical SQL/stale refusal obligations.
233+
Preserve MCP-test versus CLI acceptance distinction. Canonical308 owns corrections.

‎docs/UPSTREAM_308_CANDIDATE_AUDIT_20260912.md‎

Lines changed: 56 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -2143,3 +2143,59 @@ worktree reused; direct shell/CBM/Jev guidance and mandatory durable acknowledge
21432143
retained. Assignment/prompt/launch receipts at
21442144
`/home/nate/.local/state/agent-workflow/handoffs/CBM-DEEPSEEK-BATCH2-20-20261003/`.
21452145
No builds/tests/Jenkins, runtime validation, acceptance or main integration claimed.
2146+
2147+
## Finished ops20 and Luna medium20 independent reviews — 2026-10-03 UTC
2148+
2149+
Runs `CBM-RECON-DEEPSEEK-BATCH2-20-20261003` and
2150+
`CBM-RECON-LUNA-MEDIUM20-20261003` supplied disjoint20-commit batches.
2151+
Parent documentary review requests changes for both; this is not a host
2152+
review/acceptance transaction. Exact assignment/disposition sets and changed-path
2153+
lists pass; worker manifests33 and31 entries have zero failures. Original diffs,
2154+
39 operations and43 runtime paths at all four frozen Git objects, CBM searches,
2155+
coverage receipts and material qualified snippets/both-direction traces are saved
2156+
in parent run evidence `ops20-independent-review/` and
2157+
`medium20-independent-review/`. The frozen production, original QA and later
2158+
QA559214af comparisons remain separate; no new ref or integration is implied.
2159+
2160+
Four bounded whole-commit source dispositions independently verified:
2161+
2162+
| Full upstream hash | Source result |
2163+
| --- | --- |
2164+
| `99c3bb4cbe4c0f9542bf722d29cbb5dd01397455` | Node/edge COUNT failure defaults to CBM_STORE_ERR; renamed target regression caches statements, drops both tables and asserts errors, including scoped counts. Source represented. |
2165+
| `df83d25ace9885e252363cb04be25a17da85c9e8` | Singleton dead parse_cpu_ns assignment removal: target has neither parse_cpu_ns nor cpu_start_ns. Absence of this defect verified in source only. |
2166+
| `0567dc70a097f36a953368978d6728b0a412b229` | POSIX listen reset/recorder guard matches all three targets; shared accessor remains outside guard. Source represented. |
2167+
| `085017ab2172c2f3d4cd3e27251033ecbc5b814b` | Comment-only scanner workaround: obsolete comment/cache absent and overflow UID freshly computed in targets. Source-bounded exclusion. |
2168+
2169+
Corrections and required grouping:
2170+
2171+
| Full upstream hash | Independent finding / continuation requirement |
2172+
| --- | --- |
2173+
| `56516eff2da40e8733217d92420ea7763195ad6c` | Target non-scoped POSIX fallback is recursive grep, not find/sort/xargs. Group with pipeline redesign prerequisite `26650255ef865de00c4a62dbcfdc0743490c5256`; no existing hidden-find-failure defect established in target. |
2174+
| `df8dd1011bd1987d0ca5a45f324775aad2411f54` | Inlining depends on Python scope consolidation `f339aa625ffd71b936fe386250858e281e5b87ff`; targets have separate nearest-binding scans. Dependent optimization, no standalone functional defect inferred. |
2175+
| `e5c17de6217ec5938d18d8c51e2c0d7ead116a19` | EOF clamp and adjacent exact-repeat drop present. Missing acc->dropped++ is unchanged upstream context, not introduced here; separate cap-accounting prerequisite. Two added PowerShell regressions absent; equivalent coverage unresolved. |
2176+
| `a15d99e39fd9ea04722f064ed02dc726b13d2943` | MCP test rewiring is not a standalone CLI feature gap; carry fail-closed scan acceptance through CLI seam. |
2177+
| `c2b68d40b544b352981099c3445401f9d71b33b7` | Separate MCP test from potentially applicable Windows fixtures; runtime_for absence alone does not establish equivalent isolation. |
2178+
| `cc9c2f4c0f51902ad7b9427ed1309bce3f463db4` | Canonical SQL absent; target write_scoped_filelist skips stale/nonregular operands. SQL alone does not establish upstream stale-path refusal. |
2179+
| `3507d9555d73aa746cde23139588081c6c02d2e2` | Windows subprocess Job Object only sets KILL_ON_JOB_CLOSE; JOB_MEMORY, JobMemoryLimit and opts memory_limit_bytes absent. Logical budgets do not establish OS enforcement. Worker correctly rejected Jev equivalence advice against source. |
2180+
| `262ab01217312938728d7176f587e45adca16f01` | Telemetry initialization and uncapped-control regression are dependent followups to3507, not permanent exclusions because target fields are absent. |
2181+
| `469c3dd996f23cdb629f1bbd6a751bc0f29a99f2` | Fresh overflow-UID computation and no pthread_once change stale-cache workaround applicability; full test/nonroot child dispatch review still open. |
2182+
| `3a8b8e82120872a56ca4d0157260569d90abe85c` | Owned-link policy present through follow-owned helpers; initial-openat errno preservation/caller effects still need full review. |
2183+
2184+
Parent Jev advisory: one batched request/two bounded primary-evidence questions,
2185+
model jev-1.13.0, stored request/response and full distributions in ops20 review.
2186+
Scope: dependency_group .98, standalone_defect .01, insufficient_evidence .01,
2187+
exclude_all .00. Scan: separate_policy_gap .98, complete_equivalence .02,
2188+
insufficient_evidence .00, inapplicable .00. Advice supported prerequisite grouping
2189+
and separate stale-scan policy obligations; source retains precedence and advice
2190+
closes no whole-commit remainder. Official helper ran with silently sourced
2191+
TypeSafe environment and checked HTTPS api.typesafe.ai destination.
2192+
2193+
Each batch retains18 exact full-hash whole-commit source-review remainders in its
2194+
review.json and review-crosswalk.jsonl (36 combined). All-hunk, regression and CLI
2195+
adaptation review remains required; worker represented claims are not automatically
2196+
parent-verified. These counts describe these two batches only, not global parity.
2197+
Workers requested completed but finish returned verification_required without native
2198+
acceptance bindings. No builds/tests/Jenkins, runtime validation, acceptance,
2199+
push or main integration occurred. Panes wC:pJ and wC:pK remain idle/open.
2200+
Overall upstream merge/constituent and older canonical disposition audit remains
2201+
incomplete; no exhaustive closure or new five-slice ranking claimed here.

‎docs/UPSTREAM_RECONCILIATION_REPORT_20261002.md‎

Lines changed: 11 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -572,3 +572,14 @@ YAML indicator, fd-capture guard and Codex policy claims; found missing original
572572
regressions and stale checkpoint checksum. Canonical308 verification section owns
573573
source corrections. Full crosswalk/snapshots/CBM/Jev evidence in parent run
574574
`evidence/pilot20-independent-review/`. No runtime validation or acceptance.
575+
576+
### Ops20 and Luna medium20 review consolidation — 2026-10-03 UTC
577+
578+
Both completed worker submissions received documentary changes-requested reviews.
579+
Exact sets and manifests33/31 pass. Four bounded whole-commit source dispositions
580+
verified;36 full-hash remainders retained across parent evidence
581+
ops20-independent-review/ and medium20-independent-review/. Canonical308
582+
“Finished ops20 and Luna medium20 independent reviews” owns detailed source
583+
corrections, prerequisite grouping, Jev distributions and precise limits; BACKLOG
584+
tracks remaining work. No global semantic parity, runtime validation or acceptance
585+
claimed. Workers remain idle/open; full merge/constituent audit is incomplete.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)