Visibility of the key:review_requested

[2dreamy]

Would it be possible to make the Key:review_requested more visible, similar to how the "note" feature is presented?
I believe this could be a very helpful feature for beginners who are not yet confident in their mapping and editing skills.

[tordans]

This is a feature request for the website, not the editor iD, right?

[2dreamy]

I'm sorry—I think I may not be fully understanding your point.
The iD editor is a web-based editor, but should I be thinking of the website and the editor as separate things?

In any case, what I meant to say is that I would love to have a feature inside the iD editor that shows requested reviews—just like how we can view "notes" within the editor.

In the case of "notes," they are visible both on the website and within the iD editor interface—so wouldn't it make sense for the review_requested tag to be treated similarly?

[tordans]

So you would like to see objects that belong to changesets that have the review requested flag during editing in iD so you can basically review then while editing?

I like the general idea, however we don't have a good workflow for that and TBH I don't see this change any time soon.

• Where do we get the information from that an object belongs to a changeset which has the review-requested-tag?
• We would have to check that only the last changeset has this flag, not any…
• How would the feedback get back to the user / the changeset? Or do we just change without feedback? That would be a bit weird
• There is no propper way to say "all good" other than posting a comment on the changeset (automatically?)

We could try to set something up with MapRoulette if there where #10758. But that is still super complex.

[danieldegroot2]

Was #4133

See also osmlab/osm-planning#13