Skip to content

Commit 740e70a

Browse files
authored
Merge pull request #78 from samiabobaker/paper-got-known-list-violations
Mark GOT list-specification violations as known
2 parents 9eecfa3 + 37b7e92 commit 740e70a

1 file changed

Lines changed: 2 additions & 2 deletions

File tree

‎paper/paper.tex‎

Lines changed: 2 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -422,7 +422,7 @@ \subsection{Checking properties of transformation functions}
422422
& AdOPTed \cite{Ressel1996} + TM1.1 \cite{Sun2017} & \noviol & \newviol & \newviol & \newviol & \newviol & \Circle \\
423423
& AdOPTed \cite{Ressel1996} + TTF \cite{Oster2006TTF} & \noviol & \noviol & \noviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \Circle \\
424424
& dOPT + Ellis \cite{Ellis1989} & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \Circle \\
425-
& GOT \cite{Sun1998TOCHI} & \newviol & \newviol & \newviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \Circle \\
425+
& GOT \cite{Sun1998TOCHI} & \newviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \Circle \\
426426
& GOTO \cite{Sun1998CSCW} + TTF \cite{Oster2006TTF} & \noviol & \noviol & \noviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \Circle \\
427427
& LBT \cite{Li2005} & \newviol & \newviol & \newviol & \newviol & \newviol & \Circle \\
428428
& SDT \cite{Li2008} & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \knownviol & \Circle \\
@@ -665,7 +665,7 @@ \section{Conclusion}
665665

666666
We presented Darner, a model checker specialised for testing properties of collaborative text editing algorithms. Apart from convergence and the weak list specification, the other properties we checked for (Attiya et al.'s strong list specification \cite{Attiya2016}, forward non-interleaving, and maximal non-interleaving \cite{Weidner2025Fugue}) did not previously have executable checkers, and this is the first time these properties have been checked against most collaborative text-editing algorithms.
667667
We provide a corpus of implementations covering most of the research literature and open-source libraries on collaborative text editing, and test these with Darner to produce a set of results documenting which algorithms satisfy which properties.
668-
Our implementations resolve multiple ambiguities in previous research, and for many algorithms, ours is the first publicly available implementation. We find previously unreported convergence violations in four algorithms, violations of the weak list specification in seven, and many violations of the other properties.
668+
Our implementations resolve multiple ambiguities in previous research, and for many algorithms, ours is the first publicly available implementation. We find previously unreported convergence violations in four algorithms, violations of the weak list specification in six, and many violations of the other properties.
669669
Darner supports both randomised and exhaustive checking, and we evaluate the behaviour of these two strategies, justifying our use of random over exhaustive checking. We hope Darner will help to quickly rule out broken algorithms, so future research in this area may avoid the correctness issues that have plagued this field in the past.
670670

671671
Future work may apply more rigorous proof techniques to verify the algorithms for which Darner is unable to find a violation.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)