raw.json

{"summary":"The packet defines strong fail-closed scanning, artifact validation, reviewer triage, and verification contracts, but the scanner retains a mutable executable symlink after validation and V2 does not require causal attribution of the mutant failure. The executable-binding defect is high severity, so the fixed rubric fails.","scores":{"semantic_correctness":92,"false_positive_control":93,"security_trust_boundaries":80,"verification_design":87,"scope_contract_consistency":94,"docs_usability":92},"findings":[{"severity":"H","category":"security_trust_boundaries","file":"skills/e2e-reviewer/scripts/scan.sh","line":205,"title":"Validated tools remain bound through mutable symlink paths","evidence":"validate_explicit_tool resolves and validates the executable target but returns the original candidate path. Later tool invocations therefore reopen a potentially mutable symlink rather than the validated resolved executable, allowing its target to change after validation; the surrounding project-root check also does not provide execution-time identity binding.","recommendation":"Return and execute the canonical resolved path, reject lexical candidates inside the target project, and recheck executable identity before invocation."},{"severity":"M","category":"verification_design","file":"skills/playwright-test-generator/verification-rules.md","line":44,"title":"V2 accepts an unattributed red mutant run","evidence":"The V2 contract requires only that the mutated run turn red. It does not require evidence that the mutated primary assertion caused the failure, so an unrelated product, setup, infrastructure, or flaky failure could be recorded as successful assertion falsification.","recommendation":"Require the mutant failure to identify the changed primary assertion and expected contradictory mismatch; otherwise return ERROR or CANNOT_VERIFY."}],"limitations":["Packet-only static review; no commands, tests, benchmarks, holdouts, repository history, or external documentation were used.","Omitted helper scripts and CI fixtures were not assessed, and no runtime success or evidence integrity was inferred.","This subset review is not full product coverage, skill-accuracy validation, independent ground truth, human or sealed review, or remote model attestation."],"verdict":"FAIL"}