raw.json

{"summary":"Strong fail-closed scanner, artifact, verification, and trust-boundary design, but a credential-bearing target URL reaches process arguments before validation, which is a high-severity contract violation. Two bounded consistency gaps also remain in tier execution claims and framework detection.","scores":{"semantic_correctness":88,"false_positive_control":87,"security_trust_boundaries":82,"verification_design":91,"scope_contract_consistency":94,"docs_usability":92},"findings":[{"severity":"H","category":"security_trust_boundaries","file":"skills/playwright-test-generator/scripts/run-preflight-target.sh","line":173,"title":"Unvalidated target URL enters process arguments","evidence":"The launcher appends raw \"$@\" to the Python command line. Therefore --target and --login-url values, including credential-bearing or ambiguous queries, enter a subprocess argument before preflight_target.py validates them, contradicting the included contract that validation occurs before the URL enters process arguments.","recommendation":"Pass raw URLs through a private stdin or descriptor protocol, validate them there, and place only validated canonical URLs in later subprocess arguments."},{"severity":"M","category":"semantic_correctness","file":"skills/e2e-reviewer/scripts/scan.sh","line":2659,"title":"Tier 2 failure prevents promised Tier 3 execution","evidence":"An ast-grep exit greater than 1 terminates the scanner here, before the Tier 3 section begins. This conflicts with the included reviewer contract stating that Tier 3 always runs and that a crashed optional tier cannot suppress its execution, although the overall result still fails closed.","recommendation":"Either continue to Tier 3 while retaining a final infrastructure-error exit, or revise the public contract to state that optional-tier failure aborts before the baseline runs."},{"severity":"M","category":"false_positive_control","file":"skills/e2e-reviewer/SKILL.md","line":32,"title":"Sampled framework exclusion can miss mixed or fixture-based suites","evidence":"The framework-detection procedure permits inspecting only one or two files and treating them as evidence that the candidate specs are out of scope. A mixed directory or Playwright suite importing a project fixture that re-exports test APIs can therefore be excluded before the scanner's stronger transitive-provenance logic runs.","recommendation":"Enumerate every candidate file and trace project-fixture imports before excluding it; use sampling only to classify individual sampled files, never the whole directory."}],"limitations":["This was a static, zero-tool review of only the frozen packet; no implementation was executed.","Omitted CI helpers, fixtures, holdouts, benchmarks, reports, and prior evidence were not assessed or treated as passed.","Runtime compatibility with actual Playwright, Cypress, host, shell, filesystem, and GitHub API versions remains unverified.","This subset review is not full product coverage, skill-accuracy measurement, independent ground truth, human or sealed review, or remote model attestation."],"verdict":"FAIL"}