raw.json

{"summary":"Strong, fail-closed contracts and trust boundaries are largely consistent across the included surfaces. Two bounded issues remain: a mechanical raw-DOM rule can finalize context-dependent findings, and the README misnames the debugger artifact-download mechanism.","scores":{"semantic_correctness":95,"false_positive_control":88,"security_trust_boundaries":96,"verification_design":95,"scope_contract_consistency":94,"docs_usability":91},"findings":[{"severity":"M","category":"false_positive_control","file":"skills/e2e-reviewer/scripts/scan.sh","line":4836,"title":"Raw DOM queries bypass semantic triage","evidence":"The #6 scan is emitted without the triage flag, although pattern-reference.md line 547 recognizes legitimate multi-condition, computed-style, child-count, and cross-element uses. Because SKILL.md line 188 skips mechanically resolved findings in Phase 2, an undocumented but legitimate use can become a final P1 finding without contextual confirmation.","recommendation":"Route #6 matches through LLM triage, or mechanically finalize only shapes whose framework-equivalent semantics are provable."},{"severity":"M","category":"docs_usability","file":"README.md","line":509,"title":"README names the wrong artifact-download command","evidence":"The note says the skill downloads artifacts via `gh run download`, while the included download-playwright-report.py implementation invokes bounded `gh api` requests and deliberately avoids giving gh an extraction destination.","recommendation":"Replace `gh run download` with a description of the bundled bounded `gh api` download helper."}],"limitations":["No commands, tests, benchmarks, holdouts, or runtime probes were executed; scores cover contract and verification design only.","The packet omits benchmark evidence, prior reviews, repository history, and several referenced CI or documentation files, so their behavior and consistency were not assessed.","README sections were transformed or excluded by the packet and were reviewed only in their included form."],"verdict":"PASS"}