raw.json

{"summary":"The subset defines strong fail-closed scanning, artifact parsing, verification, and false-positive controls, but three execution and artifact-origin trust gaps materially contradict its secure-default boundaries.","scores":{"semantic_correctness":91,"false_positive_control":92,"security_trust_boundaries":68,"verification_design":89,"scope_contract_consistency":91,"docs_usability":87},"findings":[{"severity":"H","category":"security_trust_boundaries","file":"skills/e2e-reviewer/scripts/scan.sh","line":318,"title":"Scanner utilities remain vulnerable to imported Bash functions","evidence":"The scanner invokes `mktemp` by bare command name. Although it replaces PATH, it never removes functions imported by Bash before startup; an exported function named `mktemp`, `awk`, `head`, or another bare utility can therefore execute arbitrary code despite the default claim that no target-controlled executable is evaluated.","recommendation":"Before any command dispatch, unset `ENV` and `BASH_ENV`, remove all imported functions using Bash builtins, disable aliases, and bind security-sensitive utilities to validated absolute paths."},{"severity":"H","category":"security_trust_boundaries","file":"skills/playwright-test-generator/SKILL.md","line":159,"title":"Trusted preflight is launched through ambient python3","evidence":"The prescribed safety preflight starts with bare `python3`, so PATH resolution occurs before `preflight_target.py` can bind its trusted curl executable. A project-controlled PATH entry can replace the validator itself, and Python startup customization can run before its code.","recommendation":"Provide a launcher that resolves a non-project absolute Python executable, clears Python startup and loader variables, uses a minimal environment, and invokes the helper with isolated mode (`-I -B`)."},{"severity":"H","category":"security_trust_boundaries","file":"skills/playwright-debugger/scripts/download-playwright-report.py","line":399,"title":"Artifact run is not bound to an independently approved repository","evidence":"The helper only checks that `head_repository` equals the run's own `repository`. Its API endpoints use `repos/{owner}/{repo}`, resolved from ambient checkout context, but no supplied or independently derived expected repository ID is compared with the run repository; this does not establish the documented repository-origin validation.","recommendation":"Require an explicit expected owner/repository or repository ID, resolve it through the fixed GitHub host, and compare that identity with both run repository fields before listing or downloading artifacts."}],"limitations":["This was a packet-only static review with no tools or execution; runtime success was not inferred.","Referenced tests, helper modules, workflows, manifests, and CI results omitted from the packet could not be assessed.","The review does not assess benchmark accuracy, holdouts, full product coverage, skill effectiveness, repository history, or remote attestation."],"verdict":"FAIL"}